Distribution of Soil Moisture and Groundwater Levels at Patch and Catchment Scales
Distribution of Soil Moisture and Groundwater Levels at Patch and Catchment Scales
Distribution of Soil Moisture and Groundwater Levels at Patch and Catchment Scales
Abstract
This study is a contribution to the northern hemisphere climate processes land surface experiment (NOPEX). Its purpose is
to investigate the spatial variability of groundwater levels and soil moisture content at different scales in a landscape
dominated by boreal forest and till soils, which is characteristic of the Nordic countries. The analysis of data from the NOPEX
area are based on a review of previous studies on the spatial distribution of these state variables and their signicance for
runoff formation. Soil moisture content in the unsaturated zone and depth to the groundwater table show characteristic patterns
which are related to the landscape elements (patches) of the drainage basins. Similar behaviour is observed in different parts of
the NOPEX region. The variability of average values between areas decreases to a minimum for catchments with size larger
than 1 km2. It can therefore be concluded that the main part of the spatial variability of soil moisture content and depth to the
groundwater level in the till soils of the NOPEX area is found within small drainage basins. Based on a physical description of
the soil, distribution functions of soil moisture content conditioned on the depth to the groundwater table have been developed,
both for the patch scale and the catchment scale. # 1999 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.
Keywords: Till; Groundwater; Unsaturated zone; Spatial distribution
1. Introduction
This work is a contribution to the northern hemisphere climate processes land surface experiment
(NOPEX). The purpose of NOPEX is to study
landsurfaceatmosphere interactions at local and
regional scales in a Northern European landscape
dominated by boreal forest and crystalline rocks
and affected by a number of glaciations. Since the
*
Corresponding author. Fax: 47-22-95-92-01.
E-mail address: stein.beldring@nve.no (S. Beldring).
0168-1923/99/$ see front matter # 1999 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.
PII: S 0 1 6 8 - 1 9 2 3 ( 9 9 ) 0 0 1 0 3 - 3
306
307
308
Area
(km2)
Buddby
0.5
Dansarhallarna 0.9
stfora
O
0.45
Elevation
(m asl)
Nose (%)
Slope (%)
Hollow (%)
Buddby
Dansarhallarna
31.7
38.5
18.8
11.5
49.5
50.0
309
No. of piezometers
Buddby No. 1
Buddby No. 2
Dansarhallarna No. 1
Dansarhallarna No. 2
stfora
O
130
80
110
90
40
13
4
13
6
5
nose
nose
nose
0
nose
310
Fig. 2. Mean volumetric water content from the transect lines in the experimental catchments and from two other experimental sites in the
stfora are located in areas with till, Tarnsjo on an esker (sand and gravel) and Marsta in an
NOPEX region. Buddby, Dansarhallarna and O
agricultural area (clay).
311
Fig. 3. Mean values of depth to the groundwater table in topographic units along the transect lines Buddby No. 1 and Dansarhallarna No. 1.
> a
(1)
nr
where is the volumetric water content, r the residual
water content, the tension head of soil water, n the
porosity of the soil, a the air entry tension head and
a parameter that depends on the pore size distribution
of the soil.
312
Fig. 4. Groundwater table depths from squares with three piezometers along transect lines Buddby No. 1 and Dansarhallarna No. 1 in May and
June 1996.
hz >
hz
hz
(2)
h
Strictly, the measured water content could be considered to apply to a soil depth of 7.5 cm, however it is
assumed to be valid at the ground surface.
The equilibrium state assumes that the soil moisture
tension at a given depth depends on the distance to the
groundwater table. In the root zone the water content
is generally below the equilibrium value due to evapotranspiration. Since sufcient data on root geometry
or root pressures are not known, this soil moisture
decit must be evaluated by treating the root system as
a lumped system which penetrates the upper layer of
the soil uniformly (Guymon, 1994). The moisture
content at the surface is then given by:
a
h> a
(4)
0 n0
r0 h
0 n0
h
313
The lack of knowledge regarding the factors controlling the soil moisture content can be expressed by
treating them as random variables (Romanowicz et al.,
1995). In principle, it would be correct to consider a
joint distribution function of all relevant factors which
determine the volumetric water content at the soil
surface. However, in order to make the problem
mathematically tractable, some simplications must
be made and the variability of porosity at the patch
scale is assumed to account for the variability in the
other soil parameters as well as the variability in root
concentration, microscale topography and the factor
r0. The reason for selecting porosity as the stochastic
variable which is explaining the variability in soil
characteristics is that it is the parameter in Brooks
and Corey's equation which resembles most what we
want to model; the volumetric water content. In
addition, the study by Tallaksen and Erichsen
(1995) shows a variability in saturated water content
at small scale which cannot be neglected. This
approach implies that air entry tension head and pore
size distribution index are considered as effective
parameters, while r0 is considered constant at the
patch scale.
At the catchment scale, we assume that the depth to
the groundwater table is the main factor determining
variations in soil moisture at the surface. The frequency distribution of volumetric soil moisture near
the ground surface at this scale can now be determined. However, we must take into account the following result from the experimental catchments: at a
given instant of time, r0 increases with increasing
depth to the groundwater table (Table 4). This means
that the soil moisture decit relative to the equilibrium
value is largest in the upper parts of slopes where the
groundwater table is deep, a result which is supported
by Lundin (1982). This is the recharge area where a
vertically downward movement of groundwater leaves
less water available for lling the decit than in the
discharge areas at the bottom of slopes where an
upward directed groundwater ow supplies water.
Since only limited information about this relationship
is available, we assume that r0 at a given instant of
time has a linear variation over a range of values
determined by the observed depths to the groundwater
table:
r0 Ah B
(5)
314
Table 4
Mean depth to the groundwater table within squares along transect line No. 1 in the Buddby catchment, vs. r0, the ratio between the actual soil
moisture tension at the soil surface and the soil moisture tension at equilibrium, as given by Eq. (11)
Date
Groundwater
table depth (m)
r0
Groundwater.
table depth (m)
r0
Groundwater.
table depth (m)
r0
25/04/95
03/05/95
05/05/95
17/05/95
24/05/95
31/05/95
07/06/95
06/07/95
0.055
0.025
0.030
0.300
0.045
0.080
0.080
0.240
1.000
1.000
1.000
1.000
1.000
1.000
1.000
0.610
0.055
0.020
0.040
0.040
0.090
0.195
0.240
0.390
1.000
1.000
1.000
1.000
1.000
1.933
1.977
1.191
0.340
0.140
0.250
0.200
0.375
0.580
0.725
1.215
5.691
4.098
3.849
6.253
4.859
7.376
7.633
4.458
where
A
rmax rmin
;
hmax hmin
B rmin hmin
rmax rmin
hmax hmin
1
np1 1n0 q1
Bp; q 0
p > 0;
q>0
0 n0 1;
(6)
315
0 < n0
(10)
316
Fig. 6. Cumulative probability distributions of soil moisture within squares of size 8 m 8 m along transect line No. 1 in the Buddby
catchment on 6 July 1995 based on observed data (points) and the theoretical expression in Eq. (10) (lines).
1 h
h e
h 0;
> 0;
>0
(15)
(16)
2
VarH 2H
We select the two parameter g-distribution distribution to describe the stochastic variable H, depth to the
(17)
mH
s2H
(18)
m2H
s2H
(19)
f0 0
11= C
2A
2A
0
h>
a;
0 < n0
(20)
where
"
1= #1=2
n0
;
C B 4A a
0
2
317
318
saturated conditions near the soil surface where saturation excess overland flow will occur during precipitation or snowmelt (Anderson and Burt, 1990). This
catchment proportion varies with time as a result of
varying precipitation, evapotranspiration and downslope flow through the soil. The total area which can
be expected to contribute actively to runoff during
storms is larger, since the high proportion of groundwater must be caused by water which has infiltrated in
parts of the recharge area (Rodhe, 1987).
7. Regional scale variability
Soil moisture and groundwater data from catchments in till soils in different parts of the NOPEX
region show more or less identical uctuations (Figs. 2
and 3), indicating similar hydrological behaviour. This
similarity suggests that above a certain threshold scale
a catchment might contain a sufcient sample of the
geology, topography, vegetation and other landscape
characteristics of a region to decrease the variability of
catchment average uxes to a minimum. This is a
prerequisite of the representative elementary area
concept, which assumes that the distribution of characteristics within a catchment may be important in
determining these uxes, but the pattern of those
characteristics is no longer important (Wood et al.,
1988, 1990). The REA can be interpreted as a scale at
319
Fig. 10. Mean volumetric water content in the upper 15 cm of the soil versus size of the averaging area. Data from experimental sites in areas
with till on 8 May and 19 June 1996.
from the patch scale (100 m2) to the size of the small
experimental catchments (1 km2). By comparison,
averaging data from experimental sites in different
landscape and soil types does not yield the same
decrease in variability, as shown for soil moisture
data in Fig. 12. Groundwater data from different
landscape and soil types vary even more, as the depth
320
Fig. 11. Mean depth to the groundwater table versus size of the averaging area. Data from experimental sites in areas with till on 8 May and 19
June 1996.
321
Fig. 12. Mean volumetric water content in the upper 15 cm of the soil versus size of the averaging area. Data from experimental sites in areas
with till, on an esker (sand and gravel) and in an agricultural area (clay) on 8 May and 19 June 1996.
322
Acknowledgements
The data used in this study were collected by
students and staff at Uppsala University, Department
of Earth Sciences and University of Oslo, Department
of Geophysics. We are particularly indebted to Dr.
Allan Rodhe, Uppsala University for organization of
eld work and stimulating discussions. The eld work
has been made possible through grants from the
Nordic Council of Ministers. This work has been
carried out within the framework of NOPEX a
NOrthern hemisphere climate Processes land-surface
EXperiment. The data used in this investigation comes
from SINOP the System for Information in NOPEX
(Lundin et al., 1998; Rodhe et al., 1999; Tallaksen
et al., 1999).
References
Aanderson, M.G., Burt, T.P., 1990. Subsurface runoff. In:
Anderson, M.G., Burt, T.P. (Eds.), Process Studies in Hillslope
Hydrology, Wiley, Chichester, pp. 365400.
Beven, K., 1995. Linking parameters across scales: subgrid
parameterizations and scale dependent hydrological models.
In: Kalma, J.D., Sivapalan, M. (Eds.), Scale Issues in
Hydrological Modelling, Wiley, Chichester, pp. 263281.
Beven, K., Kirkby, M.J., 1979. A physically based, variable
contributing area model of basin hydrology. Hydrological
Sciences Bulletin 24, 4369.
Beven, K., Wood, E.F., 1983. Catchment geomorphology and the
dynamics of runoff contributing areas. J. Hydrology 65, 139
158.
Bloschl, G., Grayson, R.B., Sivapalan M., 1995. On the
Representative Elementary Area (REA) concept and its utility
for distributed rainfall-runoff modelling. In: Kalma, J.D.,
Sivapalan, M. (Eds.), Scale Issues in Hydrological Modelling,
Wiley, Chichester, pp. 7188.
Bonell, M., 1993. Progress in the understanding of runoff
generation dynamics in forests. J. Hydrology 150, 217275.
Brooks, R.H., Corey, A.T., 1966. Properties of porous media
affecting fluid flow. Proc. Am. Soc. Civ. Eng. J. Irrigation and
Drainage Division 92 (IR-2) 6188.
Dingman, S.L., 1994. Physical Hydrology, Prentice-Hall, New
Jersey, 576 pp.
Espeby, B., 1990. Tracing the origin of natural waters in a glacial
till slope during snowmelt. J. Hydrology 118, 107127.
Flugel, W.-A., 1995. Delineating hydrological response units by
geographical information system analysis for regional hydrological modelling using PRMS/MMS in the drainage basin of
river Brol, Germany. In: Kalma, J.D., Sivapalan, M. (Eds.),
Scale Issues in Hydrological Modelling, Wiley, Chichester, pp.
181194.
323
324