Kalupur
Kalupur
Kalupur
CUSTOMER SATISFACTION
At
KALUPUR COMMERCIAL CO-OPERATIVE BANK LTD.
KALUPUR CHOKHA BAZAR BRANCH.
Submitted To:
Declaration
I the undersigned hereby declare that the work incorporated in the Summer internship
report and titled CUSTOMER SATISFACTION REGARDING KALUPUR
COMMERCIAL CO.OP BANK. Is original and has not been submitted to any
university as part fulfilment of award of any degree or deploma.
The material obtained and used from other sources has been duly acknowledged in the
report.
Date:
Chandraprakash Vishwakarma.
Place:
PREFACE
Summer training is an integral part of our academic curriculum. During the training a
student gets an opportunity to set the practical aspects of theory. Theory makes the
concept clear.
I feel great pleasure in submitting this piece of work as a summer training project, taken
from Kalupur Bank, Ahmedabad.
I hope that this work will provide fruitful result in the eyes of the reader. It is hence
expected that creating of this shall benefit the reader in all aspects.
The project deals with nearly all the aspects of Banking Industry and the essence of
Know Your Customer Norms. I have tried my best to cover nearly all the aspects related
to Customer satisfaction of Kalupur Bank.
The working title of the project is Customer satisfaction. It is done in a very cordial
manner. This research is an attempt to present a report on account of little practical
knowledge. In my opinion, the readers will be satisfied with the project in all ways. I
guarantee the original work and authenticity of this.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
I am immensely thankful to entire staff of Kalupur commercial cooperative Bank limited
(Kalupur Chokha Bazar) help and support and for excellent hospitality they extended to
me during the project.
I extended my heartfelt gratitude to all those who have extended their tremendous
support and co-operation.
I would also like to thank Mr. Praful Patel, Mr. Bharat Parmar, and Mr. Rajnikant
Patel & Mr. Hardik Trivedi of Kalupur Bank for guiding and supporting as and when I
needed.
Last but not least, I would like to thank the director sir Mr. Jay Desai who gave me the
opportunity and full support to do this project and also would like to thank all those who
are associated directly or indirectly with this project.
Lastly, the greatest credit goes to the blessings bestowed by Almighty God without whose
yearning; I could not have even moved a step forward and to my parents who are always
a constant source of inspiration in all my endeavors.
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
The report contains the organizational study done at KALUPUR COMMERCIAL CO.OP BANK
LTD. The report title is CUSTOMER SATISFACTION REGARDIND KALUPUR
COMMERCIAL CO.OP BANK.
The report gives an overview of the banking Sector and company profile. And awareness of
customers about different types of products and services offered by KALUPUR COMMERCIAL
CO.OP BANK.
This study was conducted to find out the customer satisfaction regarding KALUPUR
COMMERCIAL CO.OP BANK.
The methodology adopted for the study was through a structured questionnaire, which is targeted
to the different persons in Kalupur Chokha Bazar for this purpose sample size of 100 was taken.
The data collected from the different persons was analyzed thoroughly and presented in the form
of charts and tables.
KALUPUR COMMERCIAL CO.OP BANK must advertise regularly and create brand value for
its products and services. Most of its competitors like ADC, Axis, kotak Mahindra and
nationalized banks use television advertisements to promote their products. The Indian consumer
has a false perception about Co-operative banks they feel that it would not safe.
Safety and returns are the two main reasons people invest in banks. On the whole KALUPUR
COMMERCIAL CO.OP BANK is a good place to work at. Every new recruit is provided with
extensive training on the products of KALUPUR COMMERCIAL CO.OP BANK. This training
enables an advisor/sales manager to market the policies better. The company should try to create
awareness about itself in India. With an improvement in the sales techniques used, a fair bit of
advertising and modifications to the existing product portfolio, KALUPUR COMMERCIAL
CO.OP BANK would be all set to capture the banking market in India as it has around the globe.
TABLE OF CONTENT
CHAPTE
R
Particulars
Pag
e
No.
5
Preface
Acknowledgement
Executive Summary
Introduction to sector
1.1
1.2
Importance of A Bank
1.3
Banking in India
1.4
10
1.5
11
1.6
12
1.7
14
1.8
15
1.9
16
2.1
Background
17
2.2
History
17
2.3
Mission
18
2.4
Vision
18
2.5
Achievements
19
2.6
19
2.7
20
2.8
Financial Data
20
2.9
Future plans
20
2.10
21
ltd
2.11
3
26
30
Research Methodology
4.1
Research Objective
38
4.2
38
6
Findings
5.1
39
5.2
40
5.3
42
5.4
44
Case Study 1
48
6.2
Case Study 2
54
Conclusion
57
Bibliography
58
Chapter 1:
Introduction
OF MONEY:
The money with the bank remains in safe custody there is always risk in keeping cash with
ones own self. It may be lost or stolen. Businessman likes to keep money with a bank to avoid
risks of money the customer need not keep large some of money.
IT
CULTIVATES HABIT OF SAVING:
Banks cultivates the habit of saving in the Bank on the one hand are safe and on the other earned
interest for the depositor who prompted to safe and deposit money in their banks accounts.
FINANCIAL
HELP TO CUSTOMER:
Banks allows overdraft facilities to their customer so whenever a customer needs money he can
even withdraw more money then the balance in his account. Bank also grants loans and credit
facilities to their customers.
SAFE
INFORMATION:
By opening an account with a bank, the customers may also take advantages of various other
services providing by the banks, such a purchase and sale of securities, travelers cheque etc.
10
SCHEDULED BANKS IN
COMMERCIAL BANKS
COOPERATIVE BANKS
REGIONAL RURAL
PRIVATE
BANKS
SECTOR
(86) BANKS
FOREIGN
(23)
BANKS
PUBLIC(45)
SECTOR BANKS (26)
NATONALIZED BANKS
SBI (19)
AND ASSOCIATE BANK
OLD (15)
NEW (7)
A. Scheduled Banks
Scheduled commercial banks are those that come under the purview of the Second Schedule of
Reserve Bank of India (RBI) Act, 1934. The banks that are included under this schedule are
those that satisfy the criteria laid down vide section 42 (6 of the Act).
1. The bank is dealing in banking business in India only.
2. The paid up capital and total funds of the bank should not be less than five lakh rupees.
3. It should convince RBI that its activities would not be against the interest of investors.
4. The bank must be:
(a) State cooperative bank, or
(b) A company according to the definition of the companies Act1956, or
(c) An institution notified by the central government, or
(d) A corporation or a company incorporated by or under any law in force in any
place outside India.
Thus,
(I) Indian Commercial Banks
(II) Foreign Commercial Banks, and
(iii) State Cooperative Banks fulfilling the above condition are considered
as scheduled banks.
Moreover under the RBI Act section 42, the Central Government has declared the following
banks as scheduled banks.
(i) State Bank of India and its seven subsidiary banks,
(ii) Twenty nationalized banks, and
(iii) Urban Banks.
In June 1980 there were 149 scheduled banks which included
1. Public Sector Banks
2. Private sector Banks,
3. Foreign Exchange Banks and
13
A bank which wants to register its name as scheduled bank has to apply to the Central
Government. On receiving such application, the central government orders RBI to investigate the
banks accounts. If RBI gives favorable reports, the central government sanctions its proposal,
and the bank is listed under schedule annexure II and is considered as a scheduled bank.
Some co-operative banks come under the category of scheduled commercial banks though not all
co-operative banks.
PUBLIC
SECTOR BANKS
Public sector banks are those in which the Government of India or the RBI is a majority
shareholder. These banks include the State Bank of India (SBI) and its subsidiaries,
other nationalized banks, and Regional Rural Banks (RRBs). Over 70% of the
aggregate branches in India are those of the public sector banks. Some of the leading
banks in this segment include Allahabad Bank, Canara Bank, Bank of Maharashtra,
Central Bank of India, Indian Overseas Bank, State Bank of India, State Bank of
Patiala, State Bank of Bikaner and Jaipur, State Bank of Travancore, Bank of Baroda,
Bank of India, Oriental Bank of Commerce, UCO Bank, Union Bank of India, Dena
Bank and Corporation Bank.
PRIVATE
SECTOR BANKS
14
Co-operative
Banks
Co-operative banks act as substitutes for moneylenders, and offer timely and adequate
short-term and long-term institutional credit at reasonable rates of interest. Co-operative
banks are relatively similar in terms of functions to the other banks except for the
following:
a) They are organized and managed on the principal of co-operation, self-help,
and mutual help.
b) They operate under the rule of "one member, one vote".
c) Operate on "no profit, no loss" basis.
d) Co-operative bank conducts all the main banking functions of deposit mobilization,
supply of credit and provision of remittance facilities. Co-operative banks offer
limited banking products and are functionally specialists in agriculture-related
products, and even in providing housing loans. Urban Co-operative Banks offer
working capital loans and term loans as well.
e) Co-operative banks primarily operate in the agriculture and rural sector. However,
UCBs, SCBs, and CCBs function in semi urban, urban, and metropolitan areas too.
Co-operative banks are probably the first government sponsored, governmentf) Supported and government-subsidized financial agency in India. They get financial
and other aid from the Reserve Bank of India NABARD, central government and
state governments. They are the "most favored" banking sector with risk of
nationalization.
g) Co-operative banks normally concentrate on "high revenue" niche retail segments.
Development Banks
Development banks are primarily intended to encourage industrial development by
providing adequate flow of funds to industrial projects. In other words, these
institutions undertake the responsibility of aiding all-round development in the
countrys economy by promoting new industrial projects, and providing financial
assistance for the expansion, diversification, and up gradation of the existing units.
Development Banks may be classified as All India development banks and Regional
development banks. While All India development banks include Industrial
Development Bank of India and Industrial Finance Corporation of India, examples of
Regional development banks include State Financial Corporation and State Industrial
Development Corporation
2. Non-scheduled Banks:
The banks, which are not included in the second schedule of RBI Act, 1934, are known
15
as non-scheduled banks. Such banks total share capital is less than five lakhs. These
banks are not governed according to the RBI Act and they receive no benefits from the
RBI. These banks have no place in the list of recognized banks of the RBI. These banks
are not much trusted by the people and they do not get handsome deposits. Since 1951
the numbers of such banks have been gradually decreasing. In 1979 there were only
five non-scheduled banks.
Generally now days we found many cooperative banks which are belongs to the nonschedule co-operative banks. Following are the types of non-schedule banks they are
work like the schedule banks but here difference in its status and it not having the status
of the schedule banks.
a. Deposits Banks
b. Cooperative Banks
c. Central Banks
d. Exchange Banks
e. Investment or Industrial Banks
f. Land Development Banks
g. Savings Banks
the country and making profits is unknown to it, it is entrusted the right it issue currency
notes. No other bank is allowed this right. It operates in close cooperation with the
government of implementing economic policies, thereby promoting economic development.
17
The origins of the cooperative banking movement in India can be traced to the close of
nineteenth century when, inspired by the success of the experiments related to the cooperative
movement in Britain and the cooperative credit movement in Germany, such societies were set
up in India. They are the primary financiers of agricultural activities, some small-scale industries
and self-employed workers. The Anyonya Cooperative Bank in India is considered to have been
the first cooperative bank in Asia.
Cooperative movement is quite well established in India. The first legislation on cooperation
was passed in 1904. In 1914 the McLaren committee envisaged a three tier structure for
cooperative banking viz. Primary Agricultural Credit Societies (PACs) at the grass root level,
Central Cooperative Banks (CCBs) at the district level and State Cooperative Banks (SCBs) at
state level or Apex Level. The first urban cooperative bank in India was formed nearly 100 years
back in Baroda.
In the beginning of 20th century, availability of credit in India, more particularly in rural
areas, was almost absent. Agricultural and related activities were starved of organized,
institutional credit. The rural folk had to depend entirely on the money lenders, who lent often at
usurious rates of interest.
The cooperative banks arrived in India in the beginning of 20th Century as an official effort
to create a new type of institution based on the principles of cooperative organization and
management, suitable for problems peculiar to Indian conditions. These banks were conceived as
substitutes for money lenders, to provide timely and adequate short-term and long-term
institutional credit at reasonable rates of interest. In the formative stage Cooperative Banks were
Urban Cooperative Societies run on community basis and their lending activities were restricted
to meeting the credit requirements of their members. The concept of Urban Co-operative Bank
was first spelt out by Mehta Bhansali Committee in 1939 which defined on Urban Cooperative
Bank. Provisions of Section 5 (CCB) of Banking Regulation Act, 1949 (as applicable to Cooperative Societies) defined an Urban Cooperative Bank as a Primary Co-operative Bank other
than a Primary Cooperative Society was made applicable in 1966.
sectoral competition is absent and intra-sectoral integration is high for cooperative bank.
RBI
NABARD
SCBs
SLDBs
CCBs
CLDBs
UCBs
PACS
PLDBs
SCBs:
BRANCHES OF SLDBs
CCBs:
(a) Values:
Co-operatives are based on the self-responsibility, democracy, equality and solidarity.
In the tradition of their founders, co-operative members believe in the ethical values of
honest, openness, social responsibility and carrying for others.
(b) Principles
The co-operative principles are guidelines by which co-operative banks put their
values into practice.
1. Voluntary and open membership:
The co-operative banks are voluntary organizations open to all persons able to use
their services and willing to accept the responsibilities of membership without gender,
social, racial, political and religious discriminations.
2. Democratic member control
Co-operative bank do their member who actively participate in setting their policies
and making decisions, men and women serving control democratic organizations as
elected representatives are accountable to the membership in primary co-operative
members have equal voting rights and co-operative at the other level are also
organized in a democratic manner.
3. Members economic participation
Members contribute equality and democratically control the capital of their cooperative. At least part of the capital is usually the common property of the cooperative. Members usually receive limited compensation if any on capital subscribed
as the condition of membership. Members allocate surplus for any of the following
purpose: developing their co-operative, possibly by setting up their reserves, part of
which at least would be invisible, benefiting members in proportions to their
22
23
24
Chapter 2:
The Kalupur
Commercial CoOperative Bank Ltd.
26
2.1BACKGROUND:
Kalupur Commerical Coop. Bank Ltd., was founded in 1970 to cater to the needs like timely and
adequate credit facilities of small traders and industrial units in big cities. With this objective in
mind Ahmedabad Grain Merchants Association promoted this bank under the leadership of late
Shri Baldevbhai Dosabhai Patel.
The bank was registered in 1970-71 under Gujarat State Coop. Societies Act and later widens its
scope by registering under multi-state cooperative societies Act in 1995. It has a network of 43
branches of which 4 are functioning in neighboring urban towns viz. Barla, Bareja, Sanand and
Gandhinagar in Ahmedabad District. The Bank has also opened branches outside Ahmedabad at
Anand, Badodra, Khmbaht, Surat and Kalbadevi (Mumbai).
The Bank is founded by Late Shri Baldevbhai Dosabhai Patel, Late Shri Gopaldas Shivlal Patel
and Shri Arvindbhai Jivanlal Saheba. The Bank has nurtured its traditional values in business
practices and in serving the small businessmen. These were the people with deep and abiding
ideas, faith, vision, optimism and entrepreneurial skills with commendable sense of service and
duty.
The dynamism infused by the Board of Directors, affectionate loyalties of clients and devotion of
staff members has created the sound foundation of The Kalupur Commercial Co-operative Bank
Ltd and has emerged as one of the leading Multi Sate Scheduled Co-operative Bank in the
country.
27
The Bank has adopted new technologies and advanced Banking tools to add value to its services.
The Kalupur Bank has earned a name in co-operative Banking sector due to its rich heritage,
integrity and adherence to prudent banking practices, technology advancement customized
products and services.
The Kalupur Bank believes that Customer Delight is the ultimate goal and has a strong belief
that customers and all shareholders, wholehearted support, absolute faith and their patronage
coupled with hard work of the staff members has been largely responsible for its noteworthy and
appreciable growth. The Kalupur Bank is committed to provide banking services with speed,
comfort and convenience. The Kalupur Bank has a visionary growth plan focusing all business
strategies.
The Bank has 44 branches of which 33 are situated in Banks own premises. These branches are
spread over Ahmedabad, Sanand, Bareja, Bavla, Anand, Khambhat, Vadodara, Surat,
Gandhinagar and Mumbai.
2.3 MISSION
Kalupur Bank will provide to its customers, premier banking services through technology
upgradation.
2.4 VISION
Kalupur Bank will strive to emerge as the most preferred co-operative Bank by 2020.
In the year 1993-94. The Bank achieved top position amongst all co-operative Banks in
Gujarat
in
terms
of
Business
The Bank has maintained its number ONE rank till now.
In 1995, the Bank was permitted to work as Banker to the issue. This was a
noteworthy achievement. The Bank successfully handled three issues in one month.
In the year 1995, the Bank got the status of Multi State Scheduled Bank.
It was a unique honour. The Bank opened a branch in Mumbai.
In the year 1999, the Bank started Demat Department. At that time, the Bank was the
first co-operative Bank in the city of Ahmedabad to start Demat Dept and function as
Depository Participant (D.P.) of National Securities Depositories Ltd. (NSDL)
In the year 2003-04, the Kalupur Bank was authorized by the Ahmedabad Municipal
Corporation to collect property tax and Vehicle Tax.
The Bank has been permitted to work as Authorized Stamp Vendor by the
Government of Gujarat. 33 branches of the Bank are providing this services.
The Bank has entered into the business of General Insurance as Referred Agency with
Bajaj Allianz Co.
In the year 2005 the RBI permitted the Bank to start Real Time Gross Settlement
(RTGS) services, Now the Bank is linked to 78000 bank branches of the country for fund
transfer. The Bank gives RTGS / NEFT / NECS and speed clearing services.
The Bank was the first co-operative Bank in the state of Gujarat to be on RTGS
platform.
The Bank is a member of CCIL (Clearing Corporation of India Ltd ) which gives the
Bank an access to various dealing platforms for dealing in Government Securities, Call
Money and conducting collateralized Borrowing and Lending Obligation (CBLO)
The Bank is the first and only co-operative Bank amongst scheduled, District and State
Co-operative Banks in Gujarat to get license as an Authorized Dealer category 1, to
deal in Forex, from RBI in 2007.
The Kalupur Bank is the only Bank in Ahmedabad City with a Dealing Room for
Forex operations.
The Bank has installed 38 on site and 2 off-site ATMs.
The Bank provides SMS Banking facilities.
UTKARSHA Award
(2003)
Excellency Award
29
Knowledge Revolution
"SHERDIL" Gujarat
Award
Share Capital
: 85.18 cr.
: Rs.772.61 cr.
Net NPO
: 0%
Cash on hand, GOVT security investment and RBI deposit: 2762.89 cr.
30
The bank wants to open new 51 branches in all over Gujarat by 2015.
The banks will decrease the Non Performing Assets as soon as possible.
The future plan of the bank is that it wants to increase the investment by them through
investment.
The bank will improve their in house facilities like franking, ATM centers etc.
QUALITY CONTROL:
The bank wants to keep the positive attitude towards the customers from management side.
The management wants to solve the query of the customers on the spot.
33
Partnership
Deed
duly
attested
3. Lockers A/c
Lockers of four different sizes viz. small, medium, large and extra large are available in the
bank which can be hired by any prospective customer for safe custody of their articles. A
prospective customers who wants to hire a locker, has to fill in embossing form and specimen
signature card. For getting a locker, the locker hire must open a SB A/c with the bank so that
annual lock rent can be charged by debiting that A/c. He has to keep a lien or minimum balance
in that account depending upon the size of the locker hired. The annual rates of Locker rent and
the lien are as follows.
Term Deposit for Locker
A minimum of Rs.10000/- has to be placed in Term Deposit by a locker hirer as per RBI
guidelines.
Nomination must for Individual Locker Holders
A Single locker holder must nominate someone in his locker A/c to receive the articles lying
in his locker after his deat
35
2. RTGS Service:
RBA has implemented RTGS system for the banks in India, where banks can remit funds
to other banks through this mechanism. The RTGS system is managed by IDBRT,
Hyderabad, which connects all banks to a central server maintained at RBI.
Each bank maintains a pool accounts with RBI for inflow and outflow of funds
received/paid through RTGS. The bank has to monitor the balance in the account
throughout the day, so a so keep it sufficiently funded, to take care of outward
remittances. For customer remittances, the minimum amount for RTGS transfers Rs. 2
lac.
3. NEFT Service:
This is another fund transfer facility for banks in India, which runs on the batch
process method. This is used for small remittances by customers from an account
with one bank to another account in another bank. The funds adjustment for NEFT
is also done through the pool accounts maintained by individual banks.
4. Locker Facility
36
5. Stamp Franking:
Kalupur Bank has been permitted for stamp franking by Govt. of Gujarat. You can get
the facility of stamp franking at your nearest branch.
6. Bank assurance:
Kalupur Bank have NON LIFE INSURANCE PRODUCTS
referral agreement with BAJAJ ALLIANZ GENERAL INSURANCE CO. LTD
7. SMS Banking.
8. AMC Property Tax
9. Pan Card Service
10. Any Branch Banking (ABB)
Any Branch Banking (ABB) is a facilit y for customers to operate their account from any
of networked branches. The branch where the customer maintains his account is the base
branch and the branch from where he carries out his transactions is referred as the remote
branches. Any Branch Banking facility is available in ALL branches of our Bank.
Cash Withdrawal: Can withdraw cash from your account from any of our
branches by presenting a self drawn cheque. This facilit y is not extended for withdrawals
by any third party. Maximum amount of cash that can be withdrawn across the Bank on a
particular day is Rs 50,000/ - only
Cash Deposit: Deposit cash for credit of your account through any of our
branches. Maximum amount of cash that can be deposited across the Bank on a
37
38
CHAPTER 3:
LITERATURE
REVIEW
39
Anderson 1994Over the last four decades, the literature has defined and measured customer
satisfaction in many different ways. Satisfaction as pleasurable fulfillment; as such, the consumer
views consumption as satisfying some need, desire, goal, etc. in which its fulfillment is
pleasurable.
In spite of many definitions of customer satisfaction in the literature, a common way to define
customer satisfaction is to follow the approach of the expectancy confirmation/disconfirmation
paradigm.
Boulding et al. 1993 Customer satisfaction has generally been suggested to contain two such
different dimensions as a transaction-specific evaluation approach and an overall, cumulative
evaluation approach. That is, there exist two general conceptualizations of customer satisfaction
in the literature. Prior research has portrayed customer satisfaction as transaction-specific.
Customers satisfaction is seen as a post-consumption evaluative judgment of a particular
purchase experience or activity Another formulation to measure customer satisfaction, widely
used in recent studies, including studies utilizing the satisfaction metric in the ACSI data, is
overall or cumulative satisfaction, which is, in other words, relationship-specific. With this
formulation, overall satisfaction can be viewed as a customers overall satisfaction experiences
of these two formulations of customer satisfaction, overall or cumulative satisfaction has been
widely used with regard to customer satisfaction. On one hand, transaction-specific satisfaction
conceptualizes customer satisfaction as the outcome of a single transaction. Thus, this
transaction-specific satisfaction formulation may be too restrictive i.e., the transaction specific
satisfaction approach has a very limited predictive power maintains that overall satisfaction is
more appropriate for an analysis of the satisfaction relationship, inasmuch as the cumulative
40
Yi, 1991 One of the most important recent aspects of this customer satisfaction metric is that
academics identify differences in customer satisfaction across individual customers and
competitive settings (product or service categories and firms).
For example, the effects of such customer characteristics as age, gender, income, and education
on levels of customer satisfaction. Customer satisfaction is one of the most important metrics in
marketing, since Bank regard customer satisfaction as one of the key business goals for
evaluating the effectiveness of their business operations. In addition, customer satisfaction is a
starting metric of the value chain between customer satisfaction, customer loyalty, banking
facility, customer satisfaction has been shown to positively impact operating margins, accounting
returns, returns on investment, and cash flow and shareholder value.
Anderson and Fornell 1993 Banks have invested a great amount of money on this metric, as
customer satisfaction investments represent the number one marketing research expenditure item
for most firms. Customer satisfaction can be seen as an essential measure used to oversee
business outcomes, decide on limited resource allocation, and provide rewards to management.
For the majority of firms, the pursuit of customer satisfaction is illustrated in their
communications, including advertisements, public relations releases, and mission statements.
With regard to this importance, a variety of marketing academics and practitioners have studied
customer satisfaction for the past forty years.
Oliver and DeSarbo 1988 The main consequence of customer satisfaction, has been defined and
measured in many various ways over the past decades. Early academic and practitioner research
focused on the customer satisfaction metric for several reasons, as discussed earlier.
41
Heskett et al (1994) The service profit chain, first proposed by heskett et al Within the service
The overall chain sees service quality driving customer satisfaction, which creates customer
loyalty leading to growth and profit. The specific relationship between employee satisfaction,
service quality and customer satisfaction has been the subject of a number of empirical studies.
The relationship is often described as the satisfaction mirror reinforcing the idea that business
success results from employee satisfaction being reflected in terms of customer satisfaction The
balance of evidence suggests that employee satisfaction is a key driver of service quality for
example, find that employee satisfaction directly affects both service quality and customer
satisfaction
42
- Services are heterogeneous; delivery can vary from provider to provider and customer to
customer
- Production and consumption of Services are inseparable. Services are not manufactured
remotely and then delivered intact to the customer.
Banking customers, find a much stronger relationship between technical quality and satisfaction
than functional quality and satisfaction. Critically, it is the performance of the overall basket of
processes, rather than performance of one or two individual processes, which determines
satisfaction levels. There is a direct causal relationship between staff satisfaction, service quality
and customer satisfaction. Within the service profit chain literature, the satisfaction mirror
simplifies this relationship suggesting that staff satisfaction is a direct driver of customer
satisfaction.
43
The management took various steps to win over the confidence of the customers.
But customers wanted to be on the safe side and withdrew their deposits. The Management put
massive shamianas (tents for shadow), arranged water and food for the depositors, continued,
and allowed the customers beyond banking hours to withdraw their deposits. After few days
when the depositors realized that the Bank has not been discouraging withdrawals and even
making all arrangements for the convenience of the depositors, they started depositing back their
withdrawals and reposing their faith with Bank.
Even today the customers have full confidence on the credibility of the customers and the Bank.
The damage was done to cooperative sector by Madhavpura Bank. It had a chain reaction. At
many places in the country, people lost faith in cooperative banking system. Consequently, large
number of Urban Banks collapsed and Kalupur Bank too suffered a dent. Their deposit base got
depleted from Rs.1298 cr. in 1999- 2000 to Rs.731 cr. post Madhavpura incident. The
Management recovered to show upward trends in the deposits, thereafter once again the
members/customers realized about the credibility of the Bank.
members. One can discernibly notice plans and their implementation by the management of the
Bank.
The other deposits like recurring deposits etc., have attracted less than 1%. It shows confidence
of the members and the customers on the bank that is why almost 69 percent of their deposit base
is in form of term deposits which gives lot of leverage to the Bank to advance the funds for
longer duration. The Kalupur Bank is the first Ahmadabad based bank to works depository
participant of National Securities Depository Limited (NSDL). It offers to its customers a whole
range of depository services. NSDL carries out its depository functions through a network of
'Depository Participants' who conduct business with the investors. The depository system
functions very much like the banking system where one can open an account and deposit/with
draw/transfer the money. Similarly one can open a security account on the participants' to
deliver/ receive securities. The Bank also offers d-mat services at 9 branches viz. Kalupura, SM
Road, Patrakar Colony, Sola Road, Panchvati, Drive-in, Vasna, Mani Nagar and Bapu Nagar
branches. Through these services bank facilitates opening d-mat accounts, accept d-mat requisite
forms, issue delivery slips and also accept delivery slips for market and off-market trades. Bank
has tied up with Max New York Insurance Co. for life insurance and with Bajaj Allianz for nonlife insurance.
Governance Structure
45
The Bank is collectively owned by its members, which are more than twenty seven thousand in
number. Majority of them are small traders from Kalupur Mandi, but traders from other areas in
Ahmedabad have also been admitted. The members play pivotal role in governance of the bank
in annual general meetings, branch level committees & during get together with the customers.
Though six hundred to seven hundred members out of 27,000 members attend the AGM but their
participation in the decision making of the Bank has been of great importance. Even during
Madhopura crisis a questionnaire was distributed to all branches to contact the members and get
their views about the stability & credibility of the Bank. The Bank has 15 members in the Board
including the Chairman, Managing Director, two co-opted professional board members and the
General Manager as ex-officio board member. The Chairman and Vice Chairman are elected
amongst the Directors. The Chairman, Vice-Chairman and Managing Director have made rich
contributions to take the Bank to greater heights. There are two professional Directors co- opted
for advice. The term of the board is for five years, but each year few members retire and on
rotation basis, election is held for filling up the vacancies. The Directors meet during the last
week of every month. The agenda is prepared in advance and distributed to the board members
well in advance. Each item is discussed at length and Chairman seeks views of all members
including the professionals. Besides Director's meetings, sub committees have been formed to
facilitate Director's work. Sub committees like Committees of Directors, Special Committee of
Directors, Investment committee, Audit Committee, Assets Liability Management Committee,
Information and Technology Committee, Recovery Committee, Building Committee etc., Have
been formed. This committees meet at least once in a month and if need be they can meet as
many times, if required. The meetings are held in a harmonious atmosphere and all decisions are
taken unanimously after an in depth, transparent deliberation on a democratic note.
The Bank does not have system of enclosing a copy of Annual Report along with the notice to
the members for attending the Annual General Meeting. The members can obtain the copy of the
report from Share Department at Head Office of the Bank and in certain cases annual report can
be obtained from nearest branch of the Bank. This practice, though not desirable, must have been
followed as only twenty to twenty five percent of the members attend the AGM. Definitely, this
practice saves cost, but there could be a likelihood of members attending the AGM without
having sufficient information about the happening in the Bank during the previous year. The
Bank needs to be more compassionate towards members' needs, services and communications.
46
Except AGM and customer meets there appears to be no other interactions between the members
and management. The frequency of meeting and participation needs to be strengthened and
increased.
Lot of transparency has been noticed in the dealing of management with customer, members and
reporting. The schedules of disclosure in the Annual Report has included information on
movement of CRAR, investments, advances against real estate, advances against housing, cost of
deposits, advances to Director, their relatives and companies in which they are interested,
movement of NPAs, profitability, profit per employee and investments in public sector securities.
The Directors are also involved in training programmers in-house or organized outside the
Bank. They have attended training programmers on Leadership, Financial Management, Branch
Management, Micro- financing, Assets Liability Management, Legal aspect of banking etc.
Measures of Success
The financial growth of the Bank has been quite astonishing. It has touched a deposit base of
nearly Rs.1300 cr. in the year 1999-2000. But for Madhopura incident, the Bank could have
easily crossed two thousand cr. by now. Still by the end of 2005-06, it has deposit base of 1083
cr. advances to the tune of 579 cr. and profit of more than eighteen cr. Besides financial strengths
the bank has an excellent infrastructure. All branches, including head office are owned by the
Bank and some of the branches have been recently constructed and confidently could be matched
with any multi-national Organization. The customers are quite satisfied with the services of the
Bank. To review any lapse on the part of the Bank, it seeks suggestions from the customers
during get together at branch level. The members get credit facility without much delay from the
Bank and continued to get dividend @ 12% p.a. from the Bank. The Bank has more than 440
customers, who are quite committed towards the development of the Bank. The Bank nearly
spends ten cr. towards salaries, allowances, provident fund and bonus to customers, which is
almost 10% of their total expenditure. The working environment of customers are not less than
any standard bank and their training needs are met through in-house or through training at other
institutions. The bank has started a separate division for marketing its services. This division has
shown excellent results.
47
IT interventions:
The Bank has seventeen customers headed by a Manager for providing computerized solutions to
the bank. It is only first of its kind Bank, which has developed its own software in banking. For
all its services, the Bank is served by these customers who have provided software for all the
services provided by the Bank, including D-mat at 8 branches. All the branches are linked with
each other and concept of any branch banking apply. The customers can withdraw the money
from any of the branch of the Bank. The ATM services are available at Ashram Road, St.
Xavier's, Vastrapur and Sola Extension counter, Swastik, SM Road, Bhopal, Bapu Nagar & 4
other branches. The Bank is planning to further this facility to seven more branches. Besides
technology the IT centre also organizes training programmers for the customers at the computer
lab where simultaneously 20 persons can be given hands on practice training.
Chapter 4:
48
Research
Methodology
49
It is overall operational pattern framework of the project that stipulates what information is to be
collected from which sources by what procedures
Sample Design
Kalupur Bank customers
Kalupur Bank customers
100
Kalupur Bank customers
Convenience Sampling
Structured Questionnaire and formal Interview
Frequency Distribution & percentages
SPSS Software15.0 has been used.
51
Required data has to be carried out in order to study the facts and figures. There are two types of
data
1. Primary data
2. Secondary data
A combination of both is utilize
1. Primary data
Primary data is the first hand information collected from five the Kalupur Bank in the industry
for benchmarking of customers satisfaction & banking facility by using unstructured
questionnaire. To find out perspective of the customers towards the satisfying process the data is
collected through structural questionnaire
2. Secondary data
The secondary data was collected from company records, various books and internet.
1. Gender:
Response
Male
Female
No. of Respondent
76
24
%age of Respondents
76.0
24.0
52
24%
Male
Female
76%
Interpretation:
From the above graph it is clear that majority of the respondents are male i.e. 76% and 24%
respondents are female.
2. Age:
Response
18 28
29 - 39
40 50
Above 50
No. of Respondent
%age of Respondents
14
31
45
10
14.0
31.0
45.0
10.0
53
18 28
10% 14%
29 - 39
40 50
45%
Above 50
31%
Interpretation:
From the above graph it is clear that majority of the respondents. I.e. 45% are between 40-50 ,
31% are between 29-39, 14% are between 18-28 and 10% are above 50.
3. Occupation:
Response
Businessman
Student
Doctor
Other
No. of Respondent
%age of Respondents
49
10
5
36
49.0
10.0
5.0
36.0
54
Businessman
36%
49%
Student
Doctor
Other
5%
10%
Interpretation:
From the above graph it is clear that majority of the respondents. I.e. 49% are Businessman,
36% are other, 10% are Student and 5% are Doctor.
55
4. Annual income:
Response
< 3,00,000
3,00,000 5,00,000
5,00,000 10,00,000
Above 10,00,000
No. of Respondent
%age of Respondents
25
21
39
15
15%
25.0
21.0
39.0
15.0
25%
< 3,00,000
3,00,000 5,00,000
5,00,000 10,00,000
39%
21%
Above 10,00,000
Interpretation:
From the above graph it is clear that majority of the respondents annual income. I.e. 39% are
between 500000-1000000, 25% are between <300000, 21% are between 300000-500000 and
15% are between Above 1000000.
5. Do you think that your bank caters all your banking needs?
Response
Yes
No
No. of Respondent
%age of Respondents
63
37
63.0
37.0
56
37%
Yes
No
63%
Interpretation:
From the above graph it is clear that 63% of the respondents are think that your bank caters all
your banking needs and the rest is not think about it.
57
6. For the past how many years you have account with this bank?
Response
1-5
6-10
11-20
Above 20
No. of Respondent
%age of Respondents
19
36
34
11
11%
19.0
36.0
34.0
11.0
19%
1-5
6-10
11-20
34%
Above 20
36%
Interpretation:
From the above graph it is clear that majority of the respondents account with this bank. I.e.
36% are between 6-10, 34% are between 11-20, 19% are between 1-5 and 11% are Above 20.
Response
Current
Savings
Loan a/c
Demat
No. of Respondent
%age of Respondents
48
21
25
6
48.0
21.0
25.0
6.0
6%
Current
25%
Savings
48%
Loan a/c
Demat
21%
Interpretation:
From the above graph it is clear that majority of the respondents are maintain Current a/c i.e.
48%.25% are maintain Loan a/c, 21% Savings a/c and 6% demat a/c.
No. of Respondent
%age of Respondents
18
13
40
29
18.0
13.0
40.0
29.0
59
18%
29%
Loan facilities
O/D facilities
13%
ATM facilities
Locker facilities
40%
Interpretation:
From the above graph it is clear that 40% of the respondents is given more importance in ATM
facilities, 29% in Locker facilities, 18% in Loan facilities and 13% in O/D facilities.
No. of Respondent
%age of Respondents
78
22
78.0
22.0
60
22%
Yes
No
78%
Interpretation:
From the above graph it is clear that 78% of the respondents said bank offer competitive service
charge and the rest said bank had not offer competitive service charge.
Response
Yes
No
No. of Respondent
%age of Respondents
58
42
58.0
42.0
61
42%
Yes
58%
No
Interpretation:
From the above graph it is clear that 58% of the respondents said bank offer competitive intrest
rate and the rest said bank had not offer competitive intrest rate.
62
No. of Respondent
%age of Respondents
61
39
39%
61.0
39.0
Yes
61%
No
Interpretation:
From the above graph it is clear that 61% of the respondents use the service of alternates
banking and the rest not use the service of alternates banking.
63
Response
Very Poor
Poor
Average
Good
Very Good
No. of Respondent
%age of Respondents
20
3
26
39
12
20.0
3.0
26.0
39.0
12.0
12. What do you feel about over all service quality of your bank?
12%
20%
Very Poor
3%
Poor
Average
Good
39%
26%
Very Good
Interpretation:
64
No. of Respondent
%age of Respondents
86
14
86.0
14.0
14%
Yes
No
86%
Interpretation:
65
66
Conclusion:
67
Bibliography:
NEWSPAPERS:
Business standard
Economics times
Case Study prepared by Prof. Paramjit Sharma, VAMNICOM, Pune
The Indian Banker
BOOKS:
68
Bibliography:
www.kalupurbank.com
kalyan-city.blogspot.in
www.goodreturns.in
www.nos.org
QUESTIONNAIRE
1. Name : ___________________________________________
2. Gender :
( )Male
( )Female
3. Age :
(A) 18 28
(C) 40 50
4. Occupation :
(A) Businessman
(B) Doctor
5. Annual income :
(B) 29 - 39
(D) Above 50
(B) Student
(D) Other
69
70