1401 BCG Winning in Africa PDF
1401 BCG Winning in Africa PDF
1401 BCG Winning in Africa PDF
The Boston Consulting Group (BCG) is a global management consulting firm and the worlds
leading advisor on business strategy. We partner with clients from the private, public, and not-forprofit sectors in all regions to identify their highest-value opportunities, address their most critical
challenges, and transform their enterprises. Our customized approach combines deep insight into
the dynamics of companies and markets with close collaboration at all levels of the client
organization. This ensures that our clients achieve sustainable competitive advantage, build more
capable organizations, and secure lasting results. Founded in 1963, BCG is a private company with
78 offices in 43 countries. For more information, please visit bcg.com.
Winning in Africa
From Trading Posts to Ecosystems
Patrick Dupoux
Tenbite Ermias
Stphane Heuz
Stefano Niavas
Mia von Koschitzky Kimani
Contents
Executive Summary
Embracing Africa
Economic Africa
A Trading-Post Economy
A New Dawn
Surging Domestic Demand
It Takes an Ecosystem
1 2
1 4
1 6
2 0
2 3
2 7
Commit to Africa
Pursue Made in Africa
Engage with Your Local Stakeholders
Align with Africas Development Agenda
2 9
3 1
3 2
2 | Winning in Africa
Executive Summary
They will need to create an explicit and sizable ambition for their
Africa business.
There is not just one Africa. The continent is a collection of different markets. To address Africas diversity, companies will need
to do the following.
Control distribution.
Africa has an ambitious development agenda. Consequently, companies should determine how they can assist African countries in
achieving their development goals. This means that they must
commit to Africa, which will require that they do the following.
4 | Winning in Africa
Embracing Africa
Economic Africa
Those years represented Africas lost decades. Fortunately, they are unrepresentative
of the continents past and future. Africa has
always been rich in natural resources and
produced bountiful supplies of food. In fact,
Africa entered the postcolonial era with a
running start over many other emerging markets and held onto that lead for at least 20
years. By 1980, Africas annual per capita
GDP of $708 was nearly three times the size
of Indias $230 and almost four times the size
of Chinas $186 (in constant 2000 dollars).
By the end of the lost decades, Africas postcolonial hope and promise had vanished.
Small groups of elites controlled both political and economic power in many nations,
and nearly all of them struggled to meet the
basic health, educational, infrastructure, and
environmental needs of their people. Africa
was a marginal player in the global economy.
A Trading-Post Economy
During the lost decades, many multinationals
retreated entirely from Africa or scaled back
continent by, say, cutting and finishing diamonds, they shipped raw resources abroad.
Even prior to the lost decades, Africa was a
distant outpost that often did not receive adequate management attention, investment, or
organizational support. While production capabilities and a consumer class began to
emerge in other emerging markets, Africa remained a trading post. Finished goods arrived to satisfy a happy few in selected ports
and urban centers. Raw materialsand most
of the value generated from doing business in
Africaleft the continent. This was the state
of play at the turn of the century.
A New Dawn
Fast forward to this decade. Since 2000, Africas GDP has been growing 2 to 3 percentage
points faster than global GDP, helping the
continent regain lost ground. Annual GDP
growth is now starting to approach postcolonial levels. (See Exhibit 1.)
Foreign companies are returning and moving
in. In 2013, Barclays Bank increased its stake
Lost decades
Africas rise
3,000
2.0%
800
0.0%
2.0%
400
1960
China
1965
1970
Africa
1975
1980
India
1985
1990
1995
2000
2005
2010
2015
CAGR
Commodity boom
Commodity price index (1992 = 100)
400
300
184
200
104
100
0
257
1992 1994 1996 1998 2000 2002 2004 2006 2008 2010
2001
1993 1995 1997 1999 2001 2003 2005 2007 2009 2011
Capital flows
20
60
11
8
40
3
1
4
2
1990
1999
2000
2005
2006
2011
1
1975
1982
1983
1989
50
12
10
2020
10
2011
30
20
10
0
1960
1970
1965
1980
1975
1990
1985
2000
1995
2010
2005
2015
Connectivity
Telecommunication and Internet penetration rates (%)
70
60
50
40
30
20
10
0
70
65
60
55
1990
1994
1992
1998
1996
2002
2000
2006
2004
2010
2008
Internet users
50
1990
1970
1980
Africa
2010
2000
Asia
2030
2020
2050
2040
2060
Europe
enrolled in school as more and more people enter the workforce. This transition will also lessen the social-spending burden.
Africas workforce is not just young and growing but also better educated than ever before.
In Angola, for example, the number of students enrolled in primary school has tripled
since 2001, and the enrollment rate has hit 80
percent. The share of young people of secondary-school age who are in school rose to 40
percent in 2010 from just 25 percent in 2000.
Across the continent, adult literacy rose from
57 to 63 percent during the same period.
Connectivity. The rapid rise in mobile and
Internet connectivity in Africa is helping the
continents economies modernize. Unshackled by legacy infrastructure or embedded
commercial interests, they are leapfrogging
their developed-market counterparts by
taking advantage of the latest waves of
innovation, leveraging technology to address
their most urgent development needs.
Africa is the fastest-growing mobile phone
market in the world. Penetration jumped
from less than 2 percent in 2000 to more than
60 percent in 2011. Between 2012 and 2016,
mobile connections in Africa are projected to
grow at an annual rate of 21 percent. Mobile
phones are increasingly helping Africans run
businesses; find jobs; pay bills; learn, share,
and connect; and deposit, withdraw, and
transfer money. East African farmers share
best practices in order to increase crop yields,
and a not-for-profit organization in Ghana is
using an SMS platform to fight the spread of
counterfeit medication. Internet usage is
growing, too, albeit less quickly. Google is
working to make the Internet local by providing translation for many of the continents
more than 2,000 languages.
Mobile and Internet access has had a greater
effect on productivity and economic growth
than elsewhere because the continent started
from such a small base of fixed-line usage.
For example, one-third of Kenyas GDP now
flows through the M-Pesa mobile-payments
systems created by Safaricom, a telecom operator. Internet access has also been instrumental in the spread of democracy and greater
government openness.
10 | Winning in Africa
Between 2001 and 2011, the number of Africans with more than $2,700 in annual incomethe threshold for discretionary spending
in emerging marketsexpanded from 104 million to 184 million. By 2017, that number will
likely have risen to 257 million. These consumers tend to be forward looking, fascinated by
technology, and enamored of brands.
In fact, 88 percent of Africans are optimistic
about the future, compared with 72 percent
in China, India, and Brazil and 48 percent in
mature economies, according to BCGs survey
of 10,000 consumers in eight African countries. (See the sidebar 2013 Africa Consumer
Sentiment Survey.) According to the same
survey, 47 percent of African consumers aspire to trading up in mobile electronics.
Two-thirds reported that brands reflect their
identity, values, and sense of belonging, compared with just 34 percent of Chinese, Indian,
and Brazilian respondents and only 24 percent of respondents in mature markets.
Furthermore, 40 percent of Africans live in
citiescompared with 30 percent in India.
Since city dwellers spend more than rural residents, a wide range of industries are expected to benefit from urbanization.
It Takes an Ecosystem
Companies have a great opportunity to benefit from Africas rebirth by conducting their
business on the continent in a new way. They
must abandon the old model of shipping in
finished goods and shipping out resources
and profits. Instead, they must prepare to actively engage and commit to a rapidly maturing continent. In the words of former U.S.
Secretary of State Hillary Clinton, businesses
need to craft sustainable partnerships in Africa that add value rather than extract it.
They must treat Africa as an ecosystem, not
just a trading post.
tion levels. The survey explored topics related to income, spending, and budgeting;
technology, mobile, and Internet usage;
preferred retail-shopping locations; and
banking habits.
Additionally, the survey assessed planned
expenditures, trading up and down, brand
preferences, and shopping behaviors in 20
product categories: automobiles; baby and
toddler products; beauty care; beer;
breakfast cereals and foods; chocolate and
candy; clothing, footwear, and accessories;
coffee and tea; consumer electronics; hair
care products; health care; home appliances; insurance; mobile phones and devices;
packaged food; restaurants and out-ofhome eating; snacks; soft drinks and other
nonalcoholic beverages; spirits and other
alcoholic beverages; and wine.
12 | Winning in Africa
What is
changing
about Africa
Bring Africa
into the
boardroom
Companies serve
pockets of wealth
with an opportunistic
approach
Address
Africas
diversity
Talent, market
knowledge, and
risk are
bottlenecks
Build 2020
Africa
capabilities
now
Companies target
a small, affluent
elite without tailoring
the offering and
distribution
The African
customer is rising
and has specific
needs
Meet the
new African
customer
Africa is a place to
trade and sell but not
to manufacture or
add value
Africa has an
ambitious
socioeconomic
development
agenda
Commit to
Africa
tained, and public support from senior leaders for their Africa teams. Without such
support, companies Africa business will fly
below the radar and not receive the corporate attention that a complex set of emerging
markets demands.
At General Electric, Africa is top of mind. In
the companys 2013 annual report, CEO Jeff
Immelt said, We could sell more gas turbines
in Africa than in the U.S. in the next few
years. Similarly, Barclays Bank has created
an African region in order to facilitate faster
decision making, easier adaptation of business models, and more funding from the center. In addition, Maria Ramos, the chief executive of Barclays Africa Group, reports
directly to Barclays chief executive, Antony
Jenkins.
Africa needs to be on the CEOs agenda, calendar, and itinerary. It is hard to imagine the
CEO of a major company not visiting Asia
several times during his or her tenure. But
until recently, that was the norm in Africa.
We surveyed 27 companies with an active
presence on the continent and found that,
until 2008, their CEOs had collectively made
five or fewer trips annually. But in 2012, their
visits more than tripled to 16, and they are on
pace to make 24 visits in 2013or nearly one
per year. (See Exhibit 4.)
24
20
16
15
14
10
13
9
7
5
4
3
3
2
0
2000
2001
2002
2003
2004
2005
2006
2007
2008
2010
2009
2011
2012 2013E
Address Africas
Diversity
16 | Winning in Africa
Automotive
5.07.0
15.117.0
151,000300,000
7.111.0
17.130.0
1,00050,000
301,000700,000
11.115.0
31.057.0
51,000150,000
701,0001,000,000
Telecommunications
0.0
0.262.00
4.06.5
20.126.0
0.1
2.012.50
6.612.5
26.160.0
0.110.25
2.512.75
12.620.0
60.189.0
Sources: World Bank; United Nations Development Program; African Development Bank, The Middle of the Pyramid: Dynamics of the Middle
Class in Africa, April 2011; IHS Automotive; BP Statistical Review of World Energy, June 2012; GSMA, African Mobile Observatory 2011; BCG analysis.
sacrifice speed and agility. They need to energize and empower the local organizations in
order to take advantage of market opportunity. In June, Bharti Airtel decentralized its Africa operations by making each country head
responsible for investments, market-related
decisions, and financial targets. Previously, all
such major decisions had been made centrally in Nairobi.
Companies, too, often did not invest significantly in the training and development of
their people during the lost decades. Their
leadership-development programs did not rotate rising stars throughout Africa. They did
not look inside Africa for the next generation
of leaders. And they did not invest in training
and development programs for their African
staff. Especially at the middle-management
20 | Winning in Africa
Decades of underinvestment
have created large deficits in
the continents talent pool.
The second gap involves traditional market
intelligence. Until recently, few marketresearch firms operated in Africa. Even today,
government statistics are often unreliable.
The World Banks chief economist for Africa
says that only 11 African nations have yearover-year comparable data.
The third gap is in risk management. For all
the progress made in the past 10 to 15 years,
Africa is still the riskiest continent in which
to do business. This risk extends beyond the
geopolitical sphere to the nuts and bolts of
doing business. Infrastructure and services
that companies take for granted in other
marketssteady electrical service, smooth
port operations, reliable delivery options
are missing in many places in Africa. To
address these issues, companies must do the
following:
30
20
10
0
1990
China
1992
1994
1996
Brazil
1998
2000
North Africa
2002
India
2004
2006
2008
2010
Sub-Saharan Africa
Sources: United Nations Educational, Scientific, and Cultural Organization; World Bank; BCG analysis.
Some companies are starting to crack the talent and leadership code in Africa, giving them
a running lead over their competitors on the
continent. For example, spirits maker Diageo
has reduced its share of expatriate managers
in Africa from 70 percent to 30 percent
through rigorous local training.
lished on the continent. At the moment, Nigerias GDP estimate, like many statistics in
Africa, is wildly inaccurate, The Economist
wrote in January 2013.
Companies frequently rely on networks of
law firms, NGOs, suppliers, and trade associations to fill the gaps in official data. This
can provide a competitive advantage. Nokia
creates its own market-share statistics within
several African countries by sending field
teams to retail stores to gather information
on product availability, selling rates, and other relevant data. The company allocates resources based on the data collected.
Oswaldo Cruz Foundation (Fiocruz), a Brazilian public-health-research institute, worked
closely with the Mozambique government to
gather data on the spread of infectious and
chronic diseases. That information gave Fiocruz an insiders view into the nations public-health challenges. In early 2013, Fiocruz
opened a plant to manufacture antiretrovirals, used in the treatment of HIV, for SubSaharan Africa.
22 | Winning in Africa
Respondents likely to
spend more (%)
100
75
50
51
48
56
45
40
34
25
51
49
29
20
18
34
22
0
Algeria
Angola
Egypt
Ghana
South
Africa
Africa
average
U.S.
India
Brazil
China
Sources: BCG 2013 Africa Consumer Sentiment Survey; BCG 2013 Global Consumer Sentiment Survey; BCG analysis.
Note: Nongrocery categories include clothing, consumer electronics, durables, beauty, health care, and away-from-home food; nongrocery
categories exclude food and beverages. The survey question was: For each of the following categories, please indicate those in which you are likely
to spend more to get a product that is better than the rest, those for which you are indifferent about how much you spend, and those for which you
choose to spend less. The Africa average is the average of the eight countries surveyed.
available in the rest of the world. For forward-looking companies, the African market
will be worth well over $1 trillion by 2020
and offer access to millions of new customers.
For their income levels, African consumers
are heavy users of the Internet and mobile
technologies, although this varies by country.
In BCGs survey, nearly half of African Internet users said they spend two hours or more
each day surfing the web. (See Exhibit 8.)
The way consumers access the Internet varies
tremendously. In Sub-Saharan Africa, they
primarily use their smartphones, while consumers in Algeria, Egypt, and Morocco rely
more on desktop or laptop computers. (See
Exhibit 9.) Mobile technology, in particular, is
enabling the continent to overcome its lack of
infrastructure and has enhanced consumers
access to information and knowledge.
Digital technologies cannot cure all of
Africas problems. While urbanization is
increasing, most Africans still live in rural
areas and in small villages and towns.
Distribution to this last mile is difficult,
given that only 19 percent of the roads are
paved and 70 percent of the continents rural
population lacks access to all-season roads.
Vehicles tend to be in poor condition, and the
destinations that companies must reach are
Control distribution.
Exhibit 8 | Nearly One-Half of Internet Users Spend at Least Two Hours Online Daily
How much time do you spend on the Internet each day?
Respondents who spend more than
2 hours online each day (%)
100
75
60
50
39
38
54
56
Morocco
Nigeria
59
47
39
26
25
0
Algeria
Angola
Egypt
Ghana
Kenya
South
Africa
Africa
average
24 | Winning in Africa
Exhibit 9 | Smartphones Are the Most Popular Way to Access the Internet
Which device do you use most to access the Internet?
Respondents (%)
100
86
75
71
71
68
64
59
60
84
81
58
55
50
44
43
35
28
25
37
35
33
22
22
14
25
20 18
23
23
12
0
Algeria
Smartphone
Angola
Egypt
Ghana
Laptop computer
Kenya
Morocco
Nigeria
Desktop computer
South
Africa
Africa
average
100
79
70
75
50
49
77
78
68
67
59
53
34
24
25
0
Algeria
Angola
Egypt
Ghana
Kenya
Morocco
Nigeria
South
Africa
Africa
average
Mature Emerging
markets markets
Sources: BCG 2013 Africa Consumer Sentiment Survey; BCG 2013 Global Consumer Sentiment Survey; BCG analysis.
Note: The Africa average is the average of the eight countries surveyed.
quickly dilute the brand equity that companies spend years building.
Pepsi used the 2010 World Cup football
championship in Africa to promote its products. The company created a viral musicvideo campaign featuring a number of famous football players, Senegalese-American
singer Akon, American singer-songwriter Keri
Hilson, and the Soweto Gospel Choir. Proceeds from the song were donated to charity.
The campaign garnered so much media attention that many Africans believed that Pepsi was the official sponsor of the World Cup,
when in fact it was sponsored by Coca-Cola.
Control Distribution
Many companies have historically relied on
local distributors to deliver their goods to
consumers who do not live in a port city or in
one of a few other locations that they serve
directly. These companies have not wanted to
go to the trouble of understanding the local
conditions and practices that would enable
them to extend their footprint deep into the
continent. It is an approach that exemplifies
the trading-post mentality.
By delegating distribution, companies have
often ceded control of pricing, branding,
channel management, inventoryand, ulti26 | Winning in Africa
mately, profitability and competitive advantage. In our work in Africa with manufacturers of consumer goods, construction
materials, and even fertilizer, distribution
consistently emerges as a critical part of the
puzzle. Companies cannot be successful in
Africa unless they control distribution. They
do not necessarily need to do it themselves.
But they need to do it right, and doing it right
will often require novel approaches.
About one-third of Nestls sales in Africa occur through informal channels, and in order
to facilitate these sales, the company has
turned to a small army of distributors who
travel by foot, bicycle, and car. In 2011, Nestl
was able to double its number of sales outlets
in South Africa by relying on these unconventional distributors. Similarly, Vodacom has
created more than 100,000 points of sale in
Africa through wholesalers and independent
contractors. Its Gimme That! program recruits
and trains young people to sell prepaid
vouchers on commission. Top performers are
awarded distributor franchises. Diageo, meanwhile, trains its distributors in basic financial
and sales-demand analysis and health and
safety issues. The training program, called
Platform for Growth, has helped increase revenues for both Diageo and its distributors.
Commit to Africa
In todays ecosystem era, companies are starting to manufacture in Africa, taking advantage of government incentives and lower labor costs. They are also actively engaging
with governments and communities on numerous levels and in numerous ways. Many
of Africas new democracies have strong economic-development policies that encourage
investment, skills transfer, and social engagement. Governments are also imposing trade
restrictions that make it more costly to import products that can be manufactured locally. The days of taking out raw materials
and shipping in finished products are over. In
this sort of environment, companies need to
do the following:
Building an
African Ecosystem
(continued)
Commit to Africa
30 | Winning in Africa
Acknowledgments
32 | Winning in Africa
Abu Dhabi
Amsterdam
Athens
Atlanta
Auckland
Bangkok
Barcelona
Beijing
Berlin
Bogot
Boston
Brussels
Budapest
Buenos Aires
Canberra
Casablanca
Chennai
Chicago
Cologne
Copenhagen
Dallas
Detroit
Dubai
Dsseldorf
Frankfurt
Geneva
Hamburg
Helsinki
Hong Kong
Houston
Istanbul
Jakarta
Johannesburg
Kiev
Kuala Lumpur
Lisbon
London
Los Angeles
Madrid
Melbourne
Mexico City
Miami
Milan
Minneapolis
Monterrey
Montral
Moscow
Mumbai
bcg.com | bcgperspectives.com
Munich
Nagoya
New Delhi
New Jersey
New York
Oslo
Paris
Perth
Philadelphia
Prague
Rio de Janeiro
Rome
San Francisco
Santiago
So Paulo
Seattle
Seoul
Shanghai
Singapore
Stockholm
Stuttgart
Sydney
Taipei
Tel Aviv
Tokyo
Toronto
Vienna
Warsaw
Washington
Zurich