BMC Oral Health: Biotech and Biomaterials Research To Reduce The Caries Epidemic
BMC Oral Health: Biotech and Biomaterials Research To Reduce The Caries Epidemic
BMC Oral Health: Biotech and Biomaterials Research To Reduce The Caries Epidemic
BioMed Central
Open Access
Proceedings
doi:10.1186/1472-6831-6-S1-S1
Abstract
The goal of this workshop is to develop a consensus within the biomaterials/bioengineering
community for a research agenda focused on creating technologies that will address the current
dental caries pandemic. The workshop will bring together expertise from academia, industry, and
the NIH institutes in the areas of oral biofilm microbiology and innovative biomaterials. The
rationale for the workshop is that science and technology have not produced sufficient practical
tools for public health practitioners and the private delivery system to address the pandemic in
dental caries that exists for children and adults from families with low incomes and for numerous
ethnic minority and racial groups. Moreover, it is unclear whether the barriers are remediable
bioengineering and technical problems or fundamental science questions. Nevertheless, the
obligation to address the gap between scientific research and practical application is especially
relevant today. The U.S. and state governments bear the majority of the cost of trying to control
this pandemic through Medicaid, the Public Health Service, Indian Health Service and other similar
programs. These costs continue to escalate as continued applications of existing technology are
unlikely to markedly reduce disparities. The mainstays of caries prevention, topical and systemic
fluorides and pit and fissure sealants, are technologies developed in the 1950s and 1960s.
Introduction
The caries process has been well understood since 1960
when Fitzgerald and Keyes demonstrated in animals that
acidogenic bacteria are transmitted from mother to offspring and between animals sharing the same cage [1].
These bacteria metabolize carbohydrates and produce
acid, which in turn leads to demineralization of dental
enamel. Dental caries is thought to be an almost completely preventable disease. Prevention requires minimizing the frequency of ingesting simple carbohydrate foods
and beverages, regular oral hygiene measures to remove
Page 2 of 7
(page number not for citation purposes)
Challenges to Participants
The conference opened with remarks from Dr. Peter Milgrom, followed by a series of talks that described the challenges faced by clinicians and researchers in their efforts to
minimize the impact of dental caries. Dr. Burton Edelstein
discussed the term "pandemic" and the appropriateness
of using this term to describe dental caries. He made the
point that use of the term "caries pandemic" suggests a
disease that is highly prevalent globally and has severe
consequences to society. He also initiated the discussion
of caries being a disease that is amenable to prevention
and that is experienced disproportionately within the
population, with poor and disadvantaged people being
more frequently affected. This theme was continued and
refined by Dr. Clemencia Vargas who defined health disparities as the occurrence of a disproportionate share of
the burden of health being received by one particular
group of people. She went on to describe Early Childhood
Caries (ECC) as a disease with disparities in both the prevalence and treatment. Dr. Vargas presented compelling
data to show that when white children are compared to
non-white children in the U.S., non-white children have a
greater caries experience and a higher level of untreated
caries.
should be divided into segments, and the particular segment of interest can be targeted. The dental market in the
U.S. is approximately $80 Billion, and 20 percent of this
market is for consumer or professional products. In terms
of categories of expenditures, 60 percent of the total
expenditures are for either the results or effects of dental
caries. As caries detection technologies become more sensitive, there will be greater opportunities to manage the
caries process (to remineralize the enamel surface) rather
than to intervene surgically. In general, the market for new
products (such as early detection devices) is very difficult.
The marketplace will ultimately not be receptive to these
newer highly sensitive tools, even with increased specificity, unless the appropriate compensation systems are in
place.
Delivery Challenges for Caries Preventive Agents
Caries preventive agents, such as fluorides and chlorhexidine, have been shown to be very effective at remineralizing surface enamel or controlling cariogenic bacteria,
respectively. However, both of these agents rely on patient
compliance at home or regular visits to the dentist. Recent
studies also show promise for other agents such as xylitol
(a sugar alcohol) and amorphous calcium phosphate in
toothpaste and chewing gums. All of these agents require
action on the part of the patient in order to have the
desired effect. Some are not particularly palatable. That is,
the characteristics of both the agent and the delivery system have an impact on its effectiveness, and current
approaches might be redesigned to advantage.
Page 3 of 7
(page number not for citation purposes)
within the biofilm and to determine their relative frequency within plaque samples.
Dr. Howard Kuramitsu discussed the importance of interactions between S. mutans and other biofilm constituents
in determining the cariogenicity of plaque samples. In
particular, his laboratory investigated the ability of S. gordonii to weaken some of the properties of S. mutans that
contribute to its virulence, including its ability to produce
bacteriocin, its ability to form a biofilm, and its ability to
transform its genetic makeup. Research regarding these
strategies, he argued, may be valuable in findings methods to control or manage dental caries in some individuals. Additional strategies were suggested by Dr. Phil
Marsh, who focused on the importance of understanding
oral ecology and the factors that disrupt microbial homeostasis as an essential part of caries control mechanisms.
He asserted, in his lecture, that it is necessary to identify
critical control points on an individual basis in order to
interfere with the disease process rather than just treating
the consequence of disease.
Research on oral biofilms is essential to the understanding
of dental caries. Biofilms are composed of multiple bacterial species that adhere to a solid surface (the tooth) and
are held together by a matrix of extracellular polymeric
substances (EPS). Characteristics of biofilms that make
their control challenging include the increased resistance
to antimicrobial agents of the bacteria within the biofilm
and the rapidity of re-colonization after mechanical
removal. Dr. John Cisar presented research from his lab
regarding the bacteria that initiate colonization of tooth
surfaces. His lab identified streptococcal receptor polysaccharides (RPS) that interact with viridans group streptococci and Actinomyces naeslundii in early biofilm
formation. Understanding this important component of
the biofilm and how it differs from one individual to
another may provide new insights and through research
lead to new approaches to the management and prevention of dental caries.
The recognition that antimicrobial peptides are present in
saliva provides some interesting possibilities for the management of oral diseases such as dental caries and periodontal disease. Dr. Beverly Dale-Crunk measured levels of
antimicrobial peptides in school-aged children with or
without dental caries. In her study, she found that mean
levels of alpha-defensins were significantly higher in some
children without caries than in other children with caries.
These results, she argues, suggest possibilities both for
early detection of caries risk and for early preventive strategies through research.
Page 4 of 7
(page number not for citation purposes)
Emerging Technologies
Technologies with the potential to prevent or manage
dental caries could take a number of forms, including
ways to detect caries risk prior to disease occurrence, species-specific targeting of acidogenic bacteria, reduction of
bacterial adherence to tooth surfaces, and prolonged
release of therapeutic agents. Interdisciplinary research
that combines the expertise of dentistry, molecular biology, and bioengineering holds great promise for new,
innovative approaches to the prevention of dental caries.
Dr. Vincent Fischetti presented a study on the use of bacteriophage lytic enzymes to control pathogenic bacteria.
These enzymes are species specific and are capable of
destroying large numbers of bacteria in blood or on
mucosal surfaces in seconds. They target the bacterial cell
wall of the specific bacteria they were developed from and
do not attack human cells. Lytic enzymes have many
potential uses in the food industry, in hospitals and nursing homes, and in the treatment of diseases such as dental
caries that are mediated by bacteria. He suggested that an
enzyme specific to S. mutans is being developed.
One of the key ingredients in the caries process is diet. A
diet rich in sugars and simple carbohydrates provides the
oral bacterial with a substrate from which they produce
acid. Recent evidence suggests that a person's preference
for sweet-tasting foods is more complex than simply what
foods or sweets the child is exposed to early in life. Dr.
Danielle Reed demonstrated in her work that sweet perceptions and preferences have an important genetic component, suggesting that some people may actually have a
"sweet tooth." Having the genetic makeup that leads to a
preference for sweet-tasting foods does not necessarily
predict the choices an individual will make. It does, however, suggest another potential avenue for the investigation of risk factors leading to dental caries.
Technologies to control biofilm formation have been
developed in many disciplines other than in dentistry.
Management or elimination of microbial biofilms is
important in fields as diverse as medicine and the boating
industry. In the boating industry the management of biofilms has led to the development of anti-fouling polymers
such as poly(ethylene glycol) (PEG), or a poly(N-substituted glycine) (polypeptoid). Dr. Phil Messersmith discussed his research with these polymers and how these
technologies may have interesting possibilities for the
management of oral biofilms and dental disease.
Dr. Buddy Ratner expanded on the topic of anti-adhesive
polymers and discussed a number of other strategies that
have potential with future research for disrupting the oral
biofilm or delivering therapeutic agents in a controlledrelease manner. The controlled delivery systems he dis-
Page 5 of 7
(page number not for citation purposes)
Research to understand how xylitol is affecting the bacterial ecology in plaque and saliva.
Incorporation of novel technology such as quorum sensors, adherence inhibitors, bacterial toxins, and polymerreleasing salicylic acid derivatives.
Testing the ability of small molecular-weight antimicrobial compounds (peptides, etc.) tethered to antifouling
polymers to be active in controlling bacterial colonization
and biofilm formation.
Evaluation of the behavior of microorganisms in contact
with antifouling polymer coatings.
Evaluation of the ability of antifouling polymer coatings
to be combined with release of active compounds (fluoride, chlorhexidine, etc.) to more effectively treat/prevent
caries. Possibilities include entrapping nanoparticles
within coatings for long-term release of antibacterials.
Testing the ability to design antifouling polymers that
encourage colonization of tooth/device surfaces by
"good" microorganisms over "bad" (acid secreting)
microorganisms.
Development of methods to improve the residual capacity of fluoride delivery including sustained-release materials, "responsive" release materials (e.g. pH-triggered),
combination therapy (antibiotic/fluoride) release, and
biomaterials that buffer pH.
Conclusion
Successful outcomes of this conference include the promotion of a dialogue between end-users, oral microbiologists, and materials and bioengineering experts in order
to develop novel prevention technologies and implement
the transfer of such technologies to industry and practice.
Efforts to address the question of what can be done to
more effectively use the large body of basic and applied
caries science already available to speed solutions to the
public health community should be the focus of future
research initiatives.
Competing interests
The author(s) declare that they have no competing interests.
Authors' contributions
Development and testing of the chemical and structural
characteristics of glycoproteins and polysaccharides
present in oral biofilms.
Page 6 of 7
(page number not for citation purposes)
Acknowledgements
The authors would like to thank Virginia Lynn, Jackie Stein, Justin Coyne
and Mary Beth Cunningham for their assistance in the planning of this conference. This conference was supported by NIH/NIDCR grant
R13DE015798-01 and by the Whitaker Foundation. Additional financial
support was provided by generous donations from Danisco Sweeteners,
Colgate-Palmolive Co., and Kerr Corporation.
References
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
BioMedcentral
Page 7 of 7
(page number not for citation purposes)