Dissertação The Russian Trumpet Sonata
Dissertação The Russian Trumpet Sonata
Dissertação The Russian Trumpet Sonata
APPROVED:
Keith Johnson, Major Professor
Eugene M. Corporon, Minor Professor
Vern Kagarice, Committee Member
James C. Scott, Dean of the College of Music
C. Neal Tate, Dean of the Robert B. Toulouse
School of Graduate Studies
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
I would like to thank my major professor Keith Johnson for his patience
and guidance during the writing of this project, and for his invaluable pedagogical
assistance and insightful musicianship.
I extend my gratitude to professors Eugene Corporon and Vern Kagarice
for their consistent support of my efforts and for serving as members of my
committee through my masters and doctoral degrees.
I owe a debt of appreciation to professors Vadim Novikov, Vyacheslav
Prokopov and Veniamin Margolin, as well as to my previous mentors, professor
Abbas Slashkin and Dr. Leonard Candelaria. I also want to thank my dear friend
and colleague Andrei Ikov for his valuable insider information.
I would be remiss in failing to express my heartfelt thanks to Dr. Edward
Tarr for his generous offering of the information from his yet unpublished
manuscript East Meets West, and for being an inspiration for me as a musician
and a scholar for many years.
I would also like to send thanks to Dr. Gene Cho, Dr. Thomas Sovik, Dr.
Tamara Isakova and Dr. Liliya Safiullina for advising me in the area of the
musical analysis.
This dissertation is dedicated to my wife Natalia Bolshakova, my dearly
loved partner on stage and in life.
TABLE OF CONTENTS
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
Chapter
Page
1. INTRODUCTION.....1
2. HISTORICAL PERSPECTIVE...4
The Birth of the Professional Music Education in Russia
The St. Petersburg Conservatory, the First Generations of
Teachers
The Moscow Conservatory from 1866 to 1917
The Moscow Conservatory after the Revolution
The Leningrad/St. Petersburg Conservatory in the 20th Century
The Moscow Conservatory After 1950s
The Gnesin Institute
3. THE GENRE OF TRUMPET SONATA..25
The Origins of the Genre
Sonata for Trumpet in Russia
4. SONATA FOR TRUMPET AND PIANO BY NIKOLAI PLATONOV..30
Nikolai Platonov (1894-1967)
History of Composition
First Movement. Allegro agitato
Second Movement. Adagio fantastico
Third Movement. Allegro non troppo
5. SONATA FOR TRUMPET AND PIANO BY VLADISLAV AGAFONNIKOV.41
Vladislav Agafonnikov (b. 1936)
History of Composition
First Movement. Introduction. Moderato con moto
Second Movement. Ciaccona. Listesso tempo
Third Movement. Toccata. Allegro marcato
6. CONCLUSION52
ii
APPENDIX......53
BIBLIOGRAPHY.....65
MUSICAL SCORES..69
RECORDINGS...71
iii
CHAPTER 1
INTRODUCTION
experience and the information, gathered from the trumpet professors of the
Russias major Conservatories, these two works are the most significant Russian
trumpet sonatas.
The musical traditions and the pedagogical history of the Russian school
of trumpet playing have been traced back to the middle of the 19th century. A
genealogy of the two major Russian schools, represented by the music
conservatories in Moscow and Leningrad/St. Petersburg, is presented for the
purpose of providing a clearer historical perspective on how those influences
impacted the compositions of sonatas for trumpet and piano by Russian
composers.
The author compiled a list of all known Russian trumpet sonatas as
complete as existing sources permit.
CHAPTER 2
HISTORICAL PERSPECTIVE
The Birth of the Professional Music Education in Russia
Russian music education and professional music performance emerged in
early 1860s largely through activities of the Rubinstein brothers. In 1859 Anton
Rubinstein (1829-1894) established in St. Petersburg the Russian Musical
Society (RMS) under the patronage of Grand Duchess Yelena Pavlovna. Soon
after RMS made its appearance in St. Peterburg (the capital of Russia from 1713
until 1918), its branches appeared in Moscow and other big cities. The goal of
the Society was to organize concerts and to popularize music among general
public.
The lack of the professional musicians dictated the need of the music
educational institutions.
Petersburg, which became the basis of the St. Petersburg Conservatory, founded
in 1862. Its first director was Anton Rubinstein.
In 1866 his younger brother Nikolai chartered the Moscow Conservatory.
These two music schools were modeled after the standards of the German
educational system.
The first teachers of the orchestral instrument classes in both
Conservatories, as well as most of the Russian orchestras members were
foreigners, for Tsarist Russia attracted them with its wealth.
As Yuri Usov stated in his book, in most cases the musicians who taught
wind instruments retained their positions for many years, at times, decades.
Thus, in the first fifty years there were only two or three generations of
professors.
The St. Petersburg Conservatory, the First Generations of Teachers
The first professor of trumpet and French horn at the St. Petersburg
Conservatory became Gustav Johann Metzdorff (1822-?), who was a soloist of
the St. Petersburg Italian Opera orchestra from 1849 to 1868, and the military
music Kapellmeister of the Imperial theatres (i.e. the conductor of the onstage
band). He is also known for his compositions for trumpet.
In 1868 Metzdorff was succeeded by Wilhelm (Vasili Vasilevich) Wurm
(1826-1904), whose long career as a trumpet and cornet teacher (professor from
1879) spanned for almost 40 years.
Imperial Mariinsky Theater for more than 30 years (1847-1878). Tsar Nikolai I
awarded him the title Soloist of His Highness and Imperial Theater Orchestras.
Wurm was also famous as a recitalist, performing not only in the capitals, but as
far away as in the Ural region. He left behind a vast collection of etudes, solos
and transcriptions for cornet.
For twenty years, from 1868 to 1888, he also held the important position of
Kapellmeister of the Imperial Guard Bands of the St. Petersburg garrison. Two
of the best students of Wurm later became professors at the Conservatory:
Alexander Berngardovich Gordon (1867-1942) and August Vasilevich Johanson
(1853-1916).
Upon his
graduation from the St. Petersburg Conservatory in 1871 and until 1902 he was a
soloist of the Imperial theaters in the capital. In addition, from 1885 he became a
Kapellmeister of the band of the St. Petersburg Cossack Regimen. From 1904
till his death Johanson taught at the Conservatory, becoming professor in 1908.
He was one of the first in Russia to write Daily Exercises for Cornet and B-flat
Trumpet, published in 1902.
Alexander Gordon was the first wind player to have his name posted on
the marble board of honor of St. Petersburg Conservatory graduates in 1887. He
played for two years in the Helsinki Philharmonic and was a member of the
Bolshoi Theater orchestra in Moscow from 1890 to 1895. In 1895-1912 Gordon
was the solo cornet of the ballet orchestra and the conductor of the on-stage
orchestra at the Mariinsky Theater in St. Petersburg. He was very active as a
military band director: in 1902-16 of the Finland Life-Guard Regimen, in 1916-17
of the Preobrazhensky Guard Regimen, in 1919-22 of the Petrograd Military
District. During summer seasons of 1905-1916 Gordon conducted symphony
orchestras in Sestroretsk, Pavlovsk, Peterhoff, Sevastopol, Yalta and other cities.
From 1895 till 1942 he was teaching at the St Petersburg-PetrogradLeningrad* Conservatory (professor from 1910).
St. Petersburg was renamed Petrograd in 1914, Leningrad in 1924, and again became St.
Petersburg after the collapse of the Soviet Union.
to satisfy the lips mold, work on correct articulation, tongue speed and rational
breath support.
The Moscow Conservatory from 1866 to 1917
The first trumpet teacher at the Moscow Conservatory was Friedrich
(Fyodor Bogdanovich) Richter (1826-1901), the Principal Trumpet of the Imperial
Bolshoi Theater orchestra. He taught at the Conservatory from 1866 until 1900,
becoming professor in 1879. He also taught band orchestration and at the same
time was the Kapellmeister of the Ekaterinoslav Life-Guard Regimen band. In
1877 Richter published one of the first Russian military band method books,
Practical Manual for Teaching the Military Music Choirs. Together with other
professors of the Conservatory, Richter participated in the chamber concerts,
organized by Nikolai Rubinshtein.
performance of Johan Nepomuk Hummels Military Septet for piano, violin, cello,
double bass, flute, clarinet and trumpet in C Major. In 1890 Sergei Ryazantsev,
student of Richter and the first trumpet player to graduate from the Moscow
Conservatory with the Silver Medal (1888), performed the same piece in the
ensemble with Sergei Taneyev at the piano.
Karl Wilhelm (Vasili Georgievich) Brandt (1869-1923) succeeded Richter
as the trumpet and the band orchestration professor in 1900. Willy Brandt, as he
also was called, became a principal trumpet at the Bolshoi Theater in 1890 and
changed his position to first cornet in 1903. He is considered the founder of the
Russian trumpet school, for he was the first foreign musician who incorporated in
his teaching the Russian national culture and performance traditions. His famous
Max
these outstanding masters has influenced the interpretation of the cornet parts in
some Russian ballets.
As a teacher, Adamov considered the development of the beautiful, full
and singing sound to be a priority for the student. Besides inventively using such
instructional material, as Arbans method, etudes by Wurm, Brandt, as well as
Behmes compositions for cornet or trumpet and piano, Adamov also
incorporated the orchestral material from the symphonic, operatic and ballet
repertoire.
He became a Hero of Labor in 1924 and the Honored Artist of the RSFSR
in 1934. Some of his students are: Ivan Vasilevsky (1892-1954), a soloist of the
Bolshoi Theater orchestra from 1920 and a famous pedagogue, who taught in
several Moscow colleges (N. Berdyiev, I. Volovnik, V. Yudin, as well as the
Dokshizer brothers studied with him); Mikhail Vetrov (1908-1970), professor of
the Leningrad Conservatory.
The Moscow Conservatory after the Revolution
Mikhail Innokentevich Tabakov (1877-1956) is considered a successor of
Brandt and the most influential Russian trumpet pedagogue of the twentieth
century. After playing with the several symphony and opera orchestras in the
cities of the southern region of Russian Empire, such as Odessa, Yalta,
Sevastopol, Kharkov, Kiev, Tbilisi, Rostov-on-Don, he came to Moscow in 1896
and became a member of the Moscow Private Russian Opera orchestra. In 1898
he won the position with the Bolshoi Theater orchestra, joining Willy Brandt, with
whom Tabakov was taking lessons. In 1903, after Brandt moved to the solo
10
cornet chair, Mikhail Tabakov became principal trumpet, the post he maintained
until his retirement in 1939. In 1910-17 he also performed with the Moscow
Symphony orchestra of Sergei Kusevitsky. He was considered to be the best
interpreter of the trumpet part in the works of Wagner and Scryabin. In 1922-32
Tabakov was an active member of the Persymfans, an experimental orchestra
without a conductor. Also in the 1920s he was a soloist with the exemplary band
of the Revvoensovet (Revolutionary Military Council) of the RSFSR.
From 1902 to 1914 Tabakov taught at the private school of S.
Leontovskaya-Terenteva, in 1914-19 at the Music-Drama College of the Moscow
Philharmonic Society, and from 1919 till 1956 at the Moscow Conservatory,
becoming a professor in 1923.
conducting class and was the chair of the wind faculty at the military-conducting
department of the Conservatory from 1944. From 1944 Tabakov was mainly
teaching at the Gnesin Institute*, where he also was a chair of the wind faculty.
He wrote an important method book, Progressive Trumpet Tutor, in 4
volumes, published in 1946-53. His Daily Exercises for Trumpet, published in
1952 also were widely used, as well as numerous transcriptions for trumpet and
piano, released in several collections (1948, 1954, etc.).
Tabakov was awarded the title of Honored Artist of the RSFSR (1924),
Honored Worker of Arts of the RSFSR (1956), and the Honorary Doctorate from
the Moscow Conservatory (1940).
Tabakov was praised for his sound, which was powerful and at the same
time tender and beautiful. Sound is the most valuable capital of an artist,he
*
The State MusicPedagogy Institute named after Gnesins, currently the Russian Music Academy named after Gnesins.
11
12
Tabakov. Yeryomin was the first trumpet student whose name was posted on
the marble board of honor of the Moscow Conservatory. In 1932 he completed
post-graduate studies with professor Tabakov and started teaching at the
Conservatory, succeeding his former teacher Adamov. In 1935 he became an
associate professor, in 1939a professor, in 1936-41 he was a head of the
brass faculty, in 1954-70a chair of the wind instruments department.
The
Soviet Government awarded him the Honored Worker of Arts of the RSFSR title
in 1965.
Yeryomin played principal trumpet part in the Bolshoi Theater orchestra
from 1928 to 1947. He also performed with the Moscow Philharmonic in 1928-34
and the All-Union Radio Great Symphony Orchestra (1941-44). Yeryomin was
also active as a soloist. In 1935 he was the second prize winner at the All-Union
Competition held in Leningrad. He collaborated with many composers, notably
Alexander Goedicke, who dedicated his Concerto for Trumpet and Orchestra and
Concert Etude to Sergei Yeryomin. Among other compositions, dedicated to him
are Gliers Variations, Golubevs Sonata for Trumpet and Piano, Mostras Spring
Song, and Chemberdjis Suite.
13
Students Festivals in Prague (1947, 2nd prize) and in Berlin (1951, 1st prize),
member of the Exemplary Band of the Defense Ministry of the USSR (1940-46),
Bolshoi Theater band (1946-52) and orchestra (from 1952), trumpet instructor at
the Moscow Conservatory from 1963, he premiered Concertos by Pakhmutova
and Tsybin.
Georgi Antonovich Orvid (1904-1980) started his musical studies under
the guidance of his father, the military band conductor, continuing as a trumpeter
of the cavalry division during the Civil War in Russia in 1918-21. In 1927 Orvid
graduated from the Kiev Conservatory, where he studied with Pyotr Ryazantsev
(1881-1966). He continued his studies at the Moscow Conservatory with Mikhail
Tabakov, completing the graduate course in 1930 and post-graduate degree in
1933. While in Kiev, Orvid played with the Kiev Opera Theater orchestra. In
1928-30 he was a member of the Moscow Philharmonic and of the Bolshoi
Theater orchestra from 1930 to 1935. In 1933-36 he was principal trumpet with
the All-Union Radio Great Symphony Orchestra. In 1936 Orvid joined the newly
established State Symphony Orchestra of the USSR, where he played until 1940.
Orvid is the author of the first Soviet trumpet tutor, first published in 1933,
republished in 1936 and 1940. Along with scales, exercises and studies the tutor
contains diverse music-artistic material with piano accompaniment. He joined the
faculty of the Moscow Conservatory in 1933, in 1935 becoming an associate
professor, and a professor from 1941. He succeeded Yeryomin as a chair of the
wind instruments department in 1970.
14
many cities of the Soviet Union, introducing the audiences to the new music of
Russian composers, most of which was inspired by and dedicated to Orvid, and
to the compositions of the Western composers. He was the first in the USSR to
perform trumpet works by Honegger, Absil, Bozza, Enesco, Tomasi and others.
Some of his awards are the Honored Worker of Arts of the RSFSR (1966)
and the Peoples Artist of the RSFSR (1972).
To name a few of his students: Valentin Yudin (1934-1971), the winner of
the World Festival of Youth and Students (Vienna, 1959) and of the International
Competition The Prague Spring (1963), principal trumpet with the USSR State
15
16
studied with Gordon, the soloist with the Kirov Theater orchestra (former
Mariinsky) for more than 40 years, teacher at the Conservatory in 1946-56 and
1959-64, author of the numerous works for trumpet; Nikolai Oreus (1922-),
member of the Kirov Theater orchestra from 1945 to 1981; Pavel Kobzi (1922-),
soloist with the on-stage band of the Kirov Theater and with the Leningrad Radio
and TV Orchestra in 1947-57, from 1957 to 1973 member of the Leningrad
Philharmonic.
Mikhail Semyonovich Vetrov (1908-1970) started his training in the military
band in 1921-28. In 1931 he graduated from the class of professor Adamov at
the Moscow Conservatory. He held the solo trumpet positions with the All-Union
Radio Great Symphony Orchestra, the Moscow Philharmonic, Variety Orchestra
of the RSFSR, the Leningrad Philharmonic. As a performer, Vetrov was famous
for his technical freedom, beautiful sound, expressive phrasing and good taste.
In 1945 Vetrov became a faculty member of the Leningrad Conservatory
(associate professor from 1951, professor from 1967). He trained a cohort of
trumpet players, of whom the most brilliant are: professor of the Leningrad-St.
Petersburg Conservatory Veniamin Margolin (1922-), the legendary solo trumpet
with the Leningrad Philharmonic (also studied with A. Schmidt); Vladimir Serdyuk
(1931-), the winner of the All-Union Competition (Leningrad, 1963), member of
the Kirov Theater orchestra from 1959, and others.
Yuri Andreyevich Bolshiyanov (1922-) studied with Alexander Schmidt
first at the Special secondary school, affiliated with the Leningrad Conservatory,
graduating in 1941. In the wartime (1941-45) he served in the military band.
17
After the war he continued his studies at the Leningrad Conservatory, receiving
the diploma in 1949 and completing his post-graduate work in 1951. In 1955
Bolshiyanov completed his doctoral dissertation, which also was published. The
topic of the dissertation is The Soviet Trumpet Concerto.
Bolshiyanov was a co-principal trumpet with the Leningrad Philharmonic
from 1946 to 1968. Upon his retirement from the orchestra due to health reasons
he received the title of the Honored Artist of the RSFSR for his work.
Bolshiyanov was the first prize winner at the World Festival of Youth and
Students in Bucharest in 1953.
Leningrad Brass quintet together with another legendary musician, French horn
player Vitali Buyanovsky.
He started teaching at the Conservatory in 1953. In 1968 he became an
associate professor and a professor in 1973. In 1976-80 Bolshiyanov was the
director of the Leningrad Conservatory, the first wind player to hold this position.
Many of his students are members of the Leningrad (now St. Petersburg)
Philharmonic and the Kirov (now Mariinsky) Theater orchestras:
co-principal
trumpets with the Mariinsky Theater orchestra Gennadi Kuteyev (1950-), Boris
Taburetkin (1955-) and Vasili Kan (1960-); Igor Sharapov (1961-), prize winner
at the All-Union Wind-players Competition in Tallinn (1980) and the winner of the
All-Russian Wind-players Competition in Leningrad (1988), principal trumpet with
the St. Petersburg Philharmonic, who also studied with Veniamin Margolin
Veniamin Savelevich Margolin (1922-) studied with Ivan MeschanchukChaban in 1938-1940 at the music studio of the Leningrad Palace of Pioneers.
18
He continued his education after the war in the Leningrad Conservatory under
the guidance of professors Schmidt and Vetrov, graduating in 1953.
In 1944-47 Margolin was a member of the Kirov Theater orchestra. In
1947 he became a solo trumpet with the Leningrad Philharmonic under the
direction of Evgeni Mravinsky, where he made a legendary career, influencing
generations of trumpet players. He was famous for his renditions of the trumpet
parts of Wagner, Mahler, Strauss, Scryabin and Shostakovich.
The latter,
together with Herbert von Karajan, personally thanked Margolin for his London
performance of the 8th Symphony in 1960.
playing in the Octet for Winds in 1962 (the other player was Bolshiyanov).
Margolin taught briefly at the Leningrad Conservatory in 1956-58. From
1974 to 1986 he taught at the Institute of Culture named after Krupskaya. In
1986 he joined the faculty of the Leningrad Conservatory, becoming a professor
in 1991.
In 1963 Margolin was awarded the title of the Honored Artist of the
RSFSR. His students are: Dmitri Yermilov (1971-), a member of the Mariinsky
Theater orchestra from 1990 and an active recitalist, who now lives in Norway;
Alexei Belyaev, co-principal trumpet with the St. Petersburg Philharmonic,
member of the St. Petersburg Philharmonic Brass Quintet; Kirill Gusarov (1974-),
prize winner of the Third International Trumpet Competition in Moscow (2000),
the First International Competition T. Dokshitzer (Vilnius, Lithuania2002), "City
of Porcia" International Competition (Italy, 2002), Calvia International Trumpet
19
In 1972 he
20
affiliated with the Moscow Conservatory and continued his studies with Yeryomin
at the Conservatory.
In 1957 Volodin was the first prize winner at the World Festival of Youth
and Students held in Moscow. The same he won the position of the principal
trumpet with the USSR State Symphony Orchestra, the position that he retained
until 1971 and then again from 1976. In 1971-76 he performed with the Bolshoi
Theater orchestra. As Margolin in Leningrad, Volodin was considered to be the
leader of the Moscow school of orchestral trumpet playing.
Volodin joined the faculty of the Moscow Conservatory in 1979.
He
became an associate professor in 1981 and a professor in 1991. The title of the
Honored Artist of the RSFSR was awarded to him in 1986.
The list of his students includes: Andrei Ikov (1960-), the prize-winner at
the All-Union Competition of Wind-players (Tallinn, 1980), the winner of the
Prague Spring International Competition in 1982, a member of the USSR State
Symphony Orchestra in 1982-91, a member of the Russian National Orchestra
from 1991; Konstantin Moskvin (1959-), in 1982-91 the associate principal
trumpet with the Symphony Orchestra of the USSR Ministry of Culture, coprincipal trumpet with the Moscow Philharmonic from 1991; Victor Vasin (1968-),
21
Novikov joined the Bolshoi Theater orchestra, where he worked until 1985. In
1962 he won the top prize at the World Festival of Youth and Students in
Helsinki.
Since 1985 Novikov has taught at the Moscow Conservatory (associate
professor in 1989, professor from 1993). In 1992 he became the first president
of the Russian Trumpet Guild.
Boris Shlepakov
(1963-), the prize winner at the All-Union Competitions of the Windplayers (3rd
prize in Alma-Ata, 1984; 1st prize in Minsk, 1988), member of the Bolshoi
Theater orchestra from 1983, the solo trumpet from 1993, now lives in Israel;
Mikhail Naidin (1961-), a member of the Moscow Music Theater orchestra in
1982-91, from 1991 a member of the New Opera Theater; Alexander Kozlov
(1974-), the principal trumpet with the Great Symphony Orchestra of the Russian
Broadcasting Corporation from 2002.
In 1996 Evgeni Fomin (1946-), who studied with Orvid in the late 1960s,
the former principal trumpet of the Moscow Philharmonic and the Russian
National Orchestra, was invited to teach the class of the late professor Volodin.
Prior to that he was teaching at the Gnesin Institute. Yuri Vlasenko (1962-),
mentioned above among the students of Usov, was assisting his teacher in the
22
late 1990s.
legacy.
The Gnesin Institute
Since its inception in 1944 The Gnesin Institute has rivaled the Moscow
Conservatory. Mikhail Tabakov was the first trumpet teacher there in 1944-56.
His first assistant was Nikolai Yavorsky, who graduated from Tabakovs class in
the Moscow Conservatory in 1943. In 1946 he started teaching his own class
(associate professor from 1968, professor from 1987). Perhaps, Tabakovs most
celebrated student Timofei Dokshizer (1922-) graduated from this school in 1950
and joined the faculty in 1954 (associate professor from 1960, professor from
1971).
Competition in 1941. He also won the first prize in 1947 at the World Festival of
Youth and Students in Prague. The Honored Artist of the RSFSR (1959) and the
Peoples Artist of the RSFSR (1976), Dokshizer was principal trumpet with the
Bolshoi Theater orchestra from 1945 to 1984.
23
arrangements for trumpet and piano or orchestra. In this aspect Dokshizers art
was similar to that of the legendary Mexican-American musician Rafael Mendez.
The next generation of the Gnesin Institute faculty are the students of
Dokshizer and Yavorsky: Vyacheslav Prokopov (1946-), principal trumpet of the
Bolshoi Theater orchestra from 1970 and the faculty member from 1972;
Vladimir Pushkaryov (1954-), prize winner at the All-Union Competition in Tallinn
in 1980, principal trumpet with the Symphony Orchestra of the USSR Ministry of
Culture in 1982-91, associate principal trumpet with the Russian National
Orchestra from 1991 to 2002, on the faculty from 1986, he is also teaching at the
Ippolitov-Ivanov Music College.
24
CHAPTER 3
The genre
Tarr, Edward H. The Trumpet, translated by S.E. Plank. Portland: Amadeus Press, 1988,
pp. 126-7.
25
**
26
sonatas in general, adding that even the Sonata by Hindemith is not worth
performing.
Young
man,
you
should
change
the
topic
of
the
The younger
generation of trumpet players could not get through the system and launch a solo
career.
postponed without any reason. Finally, he was told that the company has the
state plan, according to which only one trumpet recording per year is produced,
27
and as long as Dokshizer is in good health and is performing, he is the one who
makes a recording*.
Timofei Dokshizer influenced both the style of playing and the repertoire.
With some exceptions, he promoted and commissioned compositions of lighter
nature; more flashy, showy, and accessible for the general public. The majority
of Dokshizers programs included transcriptions and concert miniatures. He also
performed concertos for trumpet and orchestra.
factor, too:
soloist, the composers, in hope to have their piece performed and recorded, tried
to satisfy the taste of the Master.
There were only two sonatas for trumpet and piano, composed before
1960s. The first Russian trumpet sonata, composed by Boris Asafev (noted
Soviet musicologist and composer, who also was known as Igor Glebov) in 1939
and first published in 1940; and Sonata, op.36, No.2 by Evgeni Golubev,
dedicated to Sergei Yeryomin and published in 1956.
Only owing to the activities of professor Georgi Antonovich Orvid does the
genre of the Russian trumpet sonata now exist. Orvid, as it was mentioned
earlier, resumed his performing career in 1961 after almost two decades of
absence from the concert stage and started giving solo performances.
As a
serious chamber musician, Orvid popularized the genre of trumpet sonata and
commissioned a number of them. Trumpet sonatas by the Western composers,
such as Hindemith, Hubeau and Kennan were often included in his recitals. Very
soon new compositions by the Russian composers emerged.
*
28
In November of 1964 Orvid gave a recital in the Small Hall of the Moscow
Conservatory on which in addition to the Hindemiths Sonata and shorter works
of Honegger, Enesco and Tomasi, three Russian trumpet sonatas (all dedicated
to Orvid) were performed. Two of them, sonatas by Mark Mil'man and Nikolai
Platonov were heard earlier, and Yuri Alexandrovs Sonatina for Trumpet and
Piano received it premiere performance*.
Three years later Orvid performed all the then known Soviet trumpet
sonatas in one recital.
Chumov, Leonid. The Life and Time of Russian Trumpeter Georgi A.Orvid, Journal of the
***
29
CHAPTER 4
30
Nikolai Platonov wrote several method books for flute, among them the
first Russian Flute Tutor, published in 1933. Among his compositions are an
opera Lieutenant Schmidt, Trombone Concerto, Concerto for Voice, Flute and
Orchestra, sonatas for flute, oboe, clarinet, bassoon, trumpet with piano, Poem
for Trumpet, Poem for Horn and others.
Vladimir
Dokshizer, who studied with Georgi Orvid at the Conservatory in early 1960s,
mentioned in conversation that Platonov used to come to his lessons and listen
while Dokshizer was working on the Sonata with his teacher. In spite of some
minor technical difficulties, the composer found his interpretation of the
composition convincing **. Platonovs Sonata was a set work for the IV All-Union
Brass Competition, held in Tallinn in1980.
31
movements; C major mediants, A/a and E, in the middle movement. All of these,
in addition to the frequent use of the multi-tertian structures (7th, 9th and 11th
chords), chords with the integrated tones, as well as the major and minor thirds
replacements, are typical features of the romantic harmony. Some harmonies,
especially in the opening of the second movement, are playing a coloristic, i.e.
impressionistic role. The functional basis is in subdominant group, which
represents the so-called Russian plagality.
First Movement. Allegro agitato
Sonata form.
Exposition.
Main theme. Sonata opens with the impetuous and invocatory melody,
starting with the sequence of the ascending fourths in the trumpet part over the
rich arpeggiated passages in the piano. The combination of the dotted rhythm
and triplets, as well as the motives are reminiscent of the early works of Scriabin
and Glier.
Double-phrase period with the expansion in the second phrase based on
sequence (2+2+1+1).
32
Secondary theme.
33
There are
expressive tonal shifts by ascending minor second: e minormono-tertial EflatF Major (flat ii, or Neapolitan of e minor), remote Major-minor relationship.
Recapitulation.
Main theme and the closing theme are exact repetitions, except the
dominant preparation at the end of the main theme, since the secondary theme,
which is one phrase shorter, is in C Major.
Coda.
Main theme reappears in the reverse order: the second phrase is followed
by the first. The theme reaches its climactic peak in the ecstatic and radiant key
of C Major.
34
Exposition
Main Theme
+
15
a b a
c
4+4 4
2+2+1+1 1
sequence
c
-[Eb]
4
D
[Eb]eb eb-(c)
8
8
a_
4+4
eb--Gb -- eb
Episodic theme
(c)
4 + 4 + 4
g
g_
eb
35
F(c)
Recapitulation
Main Theme
8
15
Coda
Secondary Theme
6
Closing t.
Main Theme
4 + 4
10 + 12
(c)
c
C-c
c-C
(a)
this
movement
Adagio
fantastico,
calls
for
imaginative
36
It is
Introduction
14
Main part
a transition a_
4+4
4
4+4
A-a
Eb-eb
Closing/Coda
b
8
E
a_
4
F
14
37
movements development section. The last two measures of the closing material
prepare a new key of the section B.
38
Section A
Section B
8+8
Contrasting t. Closing
16 + 16
8 8
c c-Eb
Eb (F)
11
8 8
F g-F F F
c Eb
39
Wide leaps, upper tessitura, extended passages without rests could bring an
endurance issues. The composer suggested using a lip trill at the end of the
cadenza and provided an auxiliary fingering.
The piano part of the sonata has an equal role. Although it is not extremely
challenging, it requires a high level of proficiency from the pianist.
Some
technical concerns could be wide leaps in the legato passages, octave runs
simultaneously in both hand in a brisk tempo, fairly frequently changing chordal
progressions, expanded harmonic structures, such 9th chords, etc.
40
CHAPTER 5
internationally known boys choir of the Moscow Choral School (now Academy)
under the direction of Alexander Vasilevich Sveshnikov.
Rodion Shchedrin,
In
The
festivals in Russia and other republics of former the USSR as well as in many
foreign countries.
Among his compositions are four operas, two ballets, many symphonic,
chamber, choral and vocal compositions.
41
Russian folk and quasi-folk melodic and harmonic structures and forms unique to
Russian music, like the variation,says the program of the Russian
Contemporary Music Festival, held by the Center for New Music at the University
of Iowa School of Music in 2000.
History of Composition
The Sonata for Trumpet and Piano was written in 1974 and dedicated to
Georgi Orvid, who premiered it soon after. It was first published in 1979*. In
1990 Edward Tarr published the Sonata in Germany**.
42
class session and was impressed with the last movement, so the
rest is history. It was only after McNaughtan published the piece
that I learned that it had already been published in a Soviet
anthology (which I now own).*
The sonata very quickly became popular among Russian trumpet players.
The fact that the 3rd movement of the sonata, Toccata, was included in the
program of the IV All-Union Brass Competition (as well as the Sonata by
Platonov, which was mentioned earlier), contributed to its popularity.
After the German publication of the Sonata it became internationally
known.
In 1990 the sonata was the set piece for the Elsworth Smith
43
ranges, called for in the composition. Agafonnikov was ready to change that, but
the old trumpeter said: It would be beneficial for students, let them practice.
The composer also told me that he did not have any printed edition left to
give Dr. Tarr when they met, so he gave him a manuscript copy. Unfortunately,
the copyist had made two mistakes in the score, one of which was fixed in the
Soviet edition. Professor Agafonnikov showed me the misprints, pointing out that
they are very minor.
The first misprint (McNaughtan edition only): in measure 5 of square 3 of
the 1 st movement the bass line should be dotted quarter A and dotted quarter E,
the next measure should be deleted.
Example 1: wrong.
44
Example 2: correct.
The next misprint (in both editions): 2nd movement, second measure
before the endthe bass clef before the third beat is missing in the left hand,
thus instead of e it should sound G.
Example 3: wrong.
Example 4: corrected.
45
46
A_
a_
b_
c
12
a_
10
c_
11
stretta
contrasting recap.
47
Chaconnevariations on the
2nd
48
admitted that he did not have an intention of using this motive in the sonata, but
found my discovery quite interesting.
Sonata form.**
Exposition
Main theme
a
#12
b
#13
a_
#14
Transition
b_
#15
##16-17
Caldwell, John. Toccata, in The New Grove Dictionary of Music and Musicians, edited by
Stanley Sadie. New York: Grove's Dictionaries Inc., 1980, v.19: 17-20.
**
49
Development
M.t./Trans.
##23-24
Sec. t.
##25-26
M.t./Trans.
##27-29
Recapitulation
Main t. M.t./S.t. Sec.t. Ending (augm.)
c.-p.
[climactic zone]
a
b/c
#30 ##31-32 ##33-35
#36
50
Coda
M.t. & Trans. motifs/
II mvm. Theme
c.-p.
##37-38
I mvm. Theme-thesis/
Ending
c.-p.
#39
There are no technical challenges in the first movement. The trumpet part
has long sustained phrases mostly in the softer dynamics, once in the extreme
low register. Ciaccona has some endurance challenge, since there is no rest for
almost entire length of the movement.
Toccata is the most technically and physically challenging movement.
Both trumpet and piano have the intricate runs at a brisk tempo. The trumpet
player must have good double-tonguing in the upper range of the instrument.
The secondary theme is not as rapid, but very angular.
before coda ascends to the concert d. The pick-up to the last measure is an
octave glissando from written e-flat to e-flat with the flatter-tongue.
51
CHAPTER 6
CONCLUSION
I would hope this study might spark interest in the repertoire, heretofore
little known by Western musicians.
Agafonnikov, Vladislav. Sonata for Trumpet and Piano, in Bret Jackson, Trumpet and Jed
52
APPENDIX
THE MOSCOW AND ST. PETERBURG
SCHOOLS OF TRUMPET PLAYING
53
Abbreviations:
(E)
(K)
(L)
(M)
(RD)
(T)
M.A.
Y.B.
T.D.
A.G.
I.G.
V.M.
M.-C.
V.N.
G.O.
A.S.
K.S.
Y.S.
V.S.
M.T.
Y.U.
I.V.
M.V.
L.V.
W.Y.
S.Y.
Erevan
Kiev
Leningrad/St. Petersburg
Moscow
Rostov-on-Don
Tashkent
Adamov
Bolshiyanov
Dokshizer
Gordon
Granitsky
Margolin
Meschanchuk-Chaban
Novikov
Orvid
Schmidt
Serostanov
Sharapov
Shlepakov
Tabakov
Usov
Vasilevsky
Vetrov
Volodin
Yablonsky
Yeryomin
54
Marqwardt, August:
Brandt, Vasili*:
Lyamin, Pyotr*:
Eismont, Pyotr:
Adamov, Mikhail:
Sergei
Bolotin
[S.Y.,
M.V.
(L)]
(L),
Valentin
Tabakov, Mikhail:
Alexander
Balakhonov,
Alexander
Boryakov
(E)],
Grigori
Kanevsky,
Anatoli
(M)(Baku)(Odessa)(Kishinyov)(Kazan),
55
Mikhail
Khachatryan
[Tarayan
(E)]
(E),
Aikaz
Vladimir
Surin
[Donskoi
(RD)],
Tsolak
Vasilevsky, Ivan:
Timofei
Dokshizer
[M.T.],
Vladimir
Gandel,
Vladimir
Shlepakov
[G.O.],
56
Yeryomin, Sergei:
(Odessa)],
Viktor
Denisov
[Grusho-
Maximenko,
Orvid, Georgi:
[M.V.
(L.)],
Evgeni
Matyushin
57
(Kazan)]
(Kazan),
Valentin
Yudin
Dokshizer, Timofei:
Yakov
Brodsky,
Mikhail
Granitsky
[I.G.],
Vasili
Korolyov
[I.G.],
Poteyenko
Alexander
[Kafelnikov
Molostov,
(K)]
(K),
Yavorsky, Nikolai:
58
Usov, Yuri:
V.M.
(L)],
Sergei
Lutsenko,
Ivan
Volodin, Lev:
Novikov, Vadim:
TX),
Kisnichenko
Johnson
[I.G.,
Eklund
(Denton,
TX)],
(Gteborg,
Viktor
Sweden)],
[V.S.],
Shlepakov [Rigin].
59
Mikhail
Naidin
[K.S.],
Boris
Granitsky, Ilya:
Prokopov, Vyacheslav:
Miscellaneous**:
Malkov
(L)],
Viktor
Shulgin
[Shishkov
(Kharkov)].
Although Yablonsky (1889-1977) lived and taught in Kiev, several of his students are important
representatives of the Moscow School. He studied in Kiev with Wurms student Podgorbunsky
and played with the Moscow Symphony Orchestra of Kusevitsky in 1913-18. He taught at the
Kiev Conservatory in 1927-1977.
**
Some of the Moscow trumpet players and teachers, who did not study with the listed
professors.
60
Wurm, Wilhelm:
Johann
(Ivan)
Armsgeimer,
Alexander
Gordon,
Armsgeimer, Johann:
Semyon Goldberg.
Johanson, August:
Gordon, Alexander:
Pavlov
[Brandt
(Saratov)],
Yakov
61
Bhme, Oskar:
Trogne, Emile:
Dmitri
Chudnenko,
Viktor
Schmidt
[A.S.],
Karl
Meschanchuk-Chaban, Ivan:
Veniamin
Margolin
[A.S.,
M.V.],
Alexei
Mitronov [A.S.]
Pavlov, Alexander:
Schmidt, Alexander:
Pavel
Bizyuk
[A.P.],
Yuri
Bolshiyanov,
Daniil
Vetrov, Mikhail:
62
Bolshiyanov, Yuri:
Vladimir
Bokhtenkov
[Oreus],
Valeri
Utkin
(Petrozavodsk)]
[Kiselyov
(Magnitogorsk),
(Ulyanovsk),
Georgi
Budanov
Yudashkin
63
Margolin, Veniamin:
Miscellaneous*:
Some of the Leningrad/St. Petersburg trumpet players and teachers, who did not study with the
listed professors.
64
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Bolotin, Sergei. Entsiklopedicheskii Biograficheskii Slovar MuzykantovIspolnitelei Na Dukhovykh Instrumentakh [Encyclopedic Biographical
Dictionary of Wind Instrument Performers], second, revised and expanded
edition. Moscow: Radunitsa, 1995.
____________. Outstanding Master, Russian Brass News 2 (1992): 2-3.
Bowman, Joseph. An Annotated Bibliography of Published Twentieth-century
Sonatas for Trumpet and Piano, DMA Dissertation. Arizona State
University, 2002.
Briney, Bruce. The Development of Russian Trumpet Methodology and Its
Influence On the American School, DMA Dissertation. Northwestern
University, Evanston, IL, 1997.
Buyanovsky, Vitali. Musicians of Mravinsky's Orchestra, Russian Brass News
2 (1992): 7-9.
Caldwell, John. Toccata, in The New Grove Dictionary of Music and Musicians,
edited by Stanley Sadie. New York: Grove's Dictionaries Inc., 1980, v.19:
17-20.
Chumov, Leonid. History of Russian Brass Ensembles, Journal of the
International Trumpet Guild 19:1 (September 1994): 31-43.
_____________. Mnogogrannyi Talant [Multifacetet Talent], Sovetskii
Muzykant [Soviet Musician] 10 (1150) (26 September 1990): 3.
_____________. The Life and Time of Russian Trumpeter Georgi A.Orvid,
Journal of the International Trumpet Guild 26:1 (October 2001): 58-61.
_____________. Tvorcheskoye Dolgoletiye [Creative Longevity], Russian
Brass News 7-8 (1995-1996): 67-68.
Dokshizer, Timofei. Ttrubach Na Kone [Trumpeter on a Horse, an
Autobiography], Moscow: Radunitsa, 1996.
Drucker, Vladimir. Nobility of Tone on the Trumpet, Symphony 5 (April 1951):
10.
Dubinec, Elena. Moskovskim Kompozitoram Budut Aplodirovat' v Amerike [The
Moscow Composers Will Get Applauds in America], in Moskovskii
Muzykal'nyi Vestnik [Moscow Music News] Vypusk 2 (32).
65
66
67
68
MUSICAL SCORES
Agafonnikov, Vladislav. Sonata for Trumpet and Piano, in Proizvedeniya
Sovetskikh Kompozitorov, [Works by the Soviet Composers], Vypusk
[Volume] 3. Moscow: Sovetskii Kompozitor, 1979.
___________________. Sonata for Trumpet and Piano. Coburg, Germany:
Musikverlag David McNaughtan, 1990.
Alexandrov, Yuri. Sonatina for trumpet and piano, Moscow: Muzyka, 1965.
Arutyunyan, Erik. Sonata for Trumpet and Piano, Moscow: Muzyka, 1975
Asafev, Boris. Sonata for Trumpet and Piano, Leningrad: Muzgiz, 1940
Baryshev, A. Sonatina for Trumpet and Piano, in Proizvedeniya Sovetskikh
Kompozitorov, [Works by the Soviet Composers], Vypusk [Volume] 2.
Moscow: Sovetskii Kompozitor, 1976.
Berdyiev, Nikolai. Sonata for Trumpet and Piano, Kiev: Muzichna Ukaraina,
1975.
Chichkov, Yuri. Sonatina for trumpet and piano, Moscow: Muzgiz, 1953.
Chitchyan, Geguni. Sonata for Trumpet and Piano, in Proizvedeniya Sovetskikh
Kompozitorov, [Works by the Soviet Composers], Vypusk [Volume] 6.
Moscow: Sovetskii Kompozitor, 1984.
Dorokhov, Igor. Sonata for Trumpet and Piano, in Proizvedeniya Sovetskikh
Kompozitorov, [Works by the Soviet Composers], Vypusk [Volume] 2.
Moscow: Sovetskii Kompozitor, 1976.
Golubev, Evgeni. Sonata, op. 36, no. 2, Moscow : Muzgiz, 1956.
Kazaryan, Yuri. Sonata for Trumpet and Piano, Erevan: Sovetakan Grok, 1977.
Kogan, Nikolai. Sonata for Trumpet and Piano, Leningrad: Sovetskii
Kompozitor, 1986.
Lyubovsky, Leonid. Sonata for Trumpet and Piano, in Proizvedeniya
Sovetskikh Kompozitorov, [Works by the Soviet Composers], Vypusk
[Volume] 3. Moscow: Sovetskii Kompozitor, 1979.
Milman, Mark. Sonata for Trumpet and Piano, Op.40, Moscow: Muzyka, 1967.
___________. Second Sonata for Trumpet and Piano, Op. 56 bis in
69
70
RECORDINGS
Agafonnikov, Vladislav. Sonata for Trumpet and Piano, in Bret Jackson,
Trumpet and Jed Moss, Piano, Summit Records: DCD 153, 1993.
Arutyunyan, Erik. Sonata for Trumpet and Piano, in Works by Armenian
Composers, Yuri Balyan, Trumpet, A. Arutyunyan, T. Asmaryan and Y.
Kazaryan, Piano, Melodiya: C10-07873-4.
Asafev, Boris. Sonata for Trumpet and Piano, in Music by Soviet Composers,
Yuri Usov, Trumpet, Yuliya Kogan and Tatyana Smirnova, Piano,
Melodiya: M10-39303-04, 1977.
Chichkov, Yuri. Sonatina for trumpet and piano, in Music by Soviet Composers,
Yuri Usov, Trumpet, Yuliya Kogan and Tatyana Smirnova, Piano,
Melodiya: M10-39303-04, 1977.
Kazaryan, Yuri. Sonata for Trumpet and Piano, in Armenian Chamber Music,
Yuri Balyan, Trumpet and Igor Yavryan, Piano, Melodiya: C10-07617-18.
Kazaryan, Yuri. Sonata for Trumpet and Piano, in Works by Armenian
Composers, Yuri Balyan, Trumpet, A. Arutyunyan, T. Asmaryan and Y.
Kazaryan, Piano, Melodiya: C10-07873-4.
Smirnova, Tatyana. Sonata-Ballada for Trumpet and Piano, in Music by Soviet
Composers, Yuri Usov, Trumpet, Yuliya Kogan and Tatyana Smirnova,
Piano, Melodiya: M10-39303-04, 1977.
71