Identifying A Simple Salt: Ion Color
Identifying A Simple Salt: Ion Color
Identifying A Simple Salt: Ion Color
1. Appearance of compound
The compound will most likely be in solid form. Note the color and shape of the crystals. Ionic
compounds formed from the representative elements tend to be white or colorless, while ions of
transition elements tend to be colored. The following is a table of the colors of metal ions in solution
with NO3-.
Ion Color
Co2+ Rose
Co3+ Violet
Cr3+ Violet
Cu2+ Blue
Fe2+ pale green, pale violet
Fe3+ yellow-brown
Mn2+ pale pink
Ni2+ blue-green
2. Heating effect
Heating a compound can cause a liquid to condense on the inside of the test tube. This is probably
water, indicating that the compound is a hydrate. If a gas is given off, note the color and odor of the
gas. The nitrate, carbonate, and sulfite ions may decompose, as illustrated by the reactions:
Some bromides and iodides decompose to give Br2(g, orange-brown) and I2(g, purple).
3. Flame test
Solutions of ions, when mixed with concentrated HCl and heated on a nickel/chromium wire in a flame,
cause the flame to change to a color characteristic of the atom.Visible colors occur with the following
ions:
Add nitric acid to the compound and observe any reaction that occurs. If the compound dissolved in
water, it should dissolve in nitric acid. If it did not dissolve in water, but appears to be dissolving in
nitric acid, it is undergoing a chemical reaction. In general, compounds that contain anions that are the
conjugate bases of weak acids will react (unless the compounds are very insoluble). For example:
Add NaOH dropwise to the solution, stir or shake the solution, and observe any reaction (if the
compound was dissolved in nitric acid, the first several drops will neutralize the acid so be sure to
check the pH with litmus paper). Look for a precipitate (refer to the solubility rules for hydroxides). If a
precipitate forms, continue adding NaOH. Some metal hydroxides are amphoteric and will form a
complex ion and redissolve. See Figures 1, 2, and 3 for an example of this reaction. The following ions
are amphoteric:
Species Acidic Solution Slightly Basic Solution Basic Solution
Al3+ Al3+(aq) Al(OH)3(s) Al(OH)4-(aq)
Cr3+ Cr3+(aq) Cr(OH)3(s) Cr(OH)4-(aq)
Pb2+ Pb2+(aq) Pb(OH)2(s) Pb(OH)42-(aq)
Zn2+ Zn2+(aq) Zn(OH)2(s) Zn(OH)42-(aq)
Sn4+ Sn4+(aq) Sn(OH)4(s) Sn(OH)62-(aq)
Add NH3 dropwise to the solution, stir or shake the solution, and observe any reaction. If a metal
hydroxide precipitate forms, continue adding ammonia. Some metal hydroxides fom a complex ion
and redissolve. See Figures 4, 5, and 6 for an example of this reaction. The following ions form
ammonia complexes:
Acid Solution Basic Solution Solution with Excess NH3 Color of Complex
Ni2+(aq) Ni(OH)2(s) Ni(NH3)62+(aq) violet
Cu2+(aq) Cu(OH)2(s) Cu(NH3)42+(aq) blue
Zn2+(aq) Zn(OH)2(s) Zn(NH3)62+(aq) colorless
Ag+(aq) Ag2O(s) Ag(NH3)2+(aq) colorless
Cd2+(aq) Cd(OH)2(s) Cd(NH3)42+(aq) colorless
Add HCl dropwise until solution tests acidic to litmus paper and observe any reaction. A precipitate will
form with any cation that forms an insoluble chloride (refer to the solubility rules). For example:
Add H2SO4 dropwise until solution is acidic and observe any reaction. A precipitate will form with any
cation that forms an insoluble sulfate (refer to the solubility rules). For example:
Analysis of observations:
o The brown gas given off during the heat test indicates presence of the NO 3- ion,
since the NO3- ion reacts to form brown NO2 gas as shown below:
2 Pb(NO3)2(s) + heat 2 PbO(s) + O2(g) + 4 NO2(g)
o The white precipitate which formed and then redissolved with the addition of
sodium hydroxide indicates the presence of an amphoteric cation. The possibilities are Al, Cr,
Pb, Zn, and Sn. The reaction occurs as follows:
Cr3+(aq) + 3 OH-(aq) Cr(OH)3(s)
Cr(OH)3(s) + OH-(aq) Cr(OH)4-(aq)
o Since the cation does not form an ammonia complex, it eliminates Zn from the
list of possible cations established above.
o There are only three cations which form precipitates with hydrochloric acid, Pb 2+,
Ag+, and Hg22+. Of these three, only Pb2+ is amphoteric. The reaction with chloride occurs as
follows:
Pb2+ + 2 Cl- PbCl2(s)
Analysis of observations:
o The green color observed during the flame test indicates the presence of barium.
Although the remaining tests could be done to confirm the presence of barium, none is specific
for just the Ba2+ ion. Therefore, the specific barium test is used.
o The yellow precipitate produced by the barium test confirms the presence of
barium. The reaction occurs as follows:
Ba2+(aq) + CrO42-(aq) BaCrO4(s)
Analysis of observations:
o The precipitate formed by the addition of silver nitrate indicates the presence of
either chloride, bromide, or iodide. Although the colors are different (AgCl white, AgBr cream,
AgI yellow), they are difficult to distinguish and a specific ion test is needed to determine which
one is present.
o The specific ion test indicated that the anion present is Cl-. The reaction occurs
as follows:
Ag+(aq) + Cl-(aq) AgCl(s)
AgCl(s) + 2 NH3(aq) Ag(NH3)2+(aq) + Cl-(aq)
Specific Tests
Take a small amount of the material to be tested and place it in a 50-mL beaker. Add 6 M
NaOH and smell cautiously. The odor of ammonia indicates the presence of ammonium
ions. If you do not smell ammonia, warm the beaker and again smell the emitted vapors.
The liberated ammonia will also change the color of a moistened strip of red litmus paper
held at the entrance of the test tube.
o Sodium Ions:
The most common method of identification of Na+ is the flame test. Sodium imparts a
brilliant, long lasting, yellow flame that masks colors from other ions. The test may be
performed on a small sample of the unknown treated with concentrated HCl or a few drops
of solution unknown treated with concentrated HCl. The flame should be bright and it should
last as long as that of 0.1 M NaCl. Sodium is a common impurity and traces will be found in
almost any unknown. You must learn to distinguish between an unknown that has sodium
ion as the cation and an unknown that has sodium ion as an impurity.
o Potassium Ions:
The most common method of identification of K+ is the flame test. The test may be
performed on a small sample of the unknown treated with concentrated HCl or a few drops
of solution unknown treated with concentrated HCl. The violet flame is not intense but it is
clearly visible in the absence of sodium ions. Cobalt glass filters yellow light from sodium
impurities and allows the violet flame to be seen. Do not confuse the glowing wire for the
potassium flame.
Although Ag+, Pb2+, and Hg22+ all form insoluble white chlorides, Ag+is the only one of these
cations that forms an ammonia complex. Therefore, AgCl dissolves readily in aqueous NH 3.
When the resulting solution is acidified with HNO3, AgCl reprecipitates.
Add 3 M HCl dropwise to the solution being tested. If a white precipitate is formed,
centrifuge and remove the supernatant liquid. Add 6 M NH3 solution to the precipitate. If the
precipitate dissolves, add 6 M HNO3. Formation of a white precipitate indicates Ag+.
o Lead Ions:
To the solution to be tested add 3 M HCl dropwise. (A large excess of HCl must be avoided
because of the formation of the soluble chloro complex, PbCl 42-.) Centrifuge and remove the
supernatant from the white precipitate (PbCl 2). Add hot water to the precipitate and stir. If the
precipitate dissolves, Pb2+ is indicated. Add 3 M H2SO4 to the hot solution. Centrifuge and
remove the supernatant liquid from the white precipitate (PbSO 4). To the precipitate add 3 M
NH4(CH3COO) and stir. If the white precipitate was PbSO4, it will dissolve. To confirm, add a
few drops of 0.5 M K2CrO4 to the resulting solution. A yellow precipitate of PbCrO 4 indicates
the presence of Pb2+.
o Mercury(I) Ions:
When Hg2Cl2 is treated with aqueous NH3 a reaction occurs in which free mercury and
amidochloromercury(II) are formed.
The HgNH2Cl is a white solid, while the Hg in a finely divided state appears black. The
resultant mixture is gray to black.
Add 3 M HCl to the solution to be tested for Hg22+. If a white precipitate forms, centrifuge and
remove the supernatant liquid. To the precipitate, add 6 M NH 3 and stir. The appearance of a
gray to black precipitate is positive for Hg22+.
Identification tests for Pb2+ and Ag+ (Ag2SO4 is moderately soluble) are described above
(Cations that form Insoluble Chlorides). Ba2+, Sr2+, and Ca2+ form moderately soluble sulfates.
The alkaline earth ions Mg2+, Ca2+, Sr2+, and Ba2+ are one of the best examples of a periodic
relationship among the elements of a family. Solubilities of their compounds are graduated
nicely and the separations (qualitatively) can be accomplished readily. Flame tests are very
important.
o Barium Ions:
Barium ions can be identified by precipitation of its insoluble yellow BaCrO 4 salt. If Ca2+ or
Sr2+ are present they will also precipitate in the presence of high concentrations of
CrO42-. However, the chromates of Ca2+ and Sr2+ are moderately soluble; their precipitation
can be prevented by addition of acetic acid. This weak acid provides sufficient hydronium
ions to lower the CrO42- concentratiion enough to keep CaCrO4 and SrCrO4 in solution but to
allow the BaCrO4 to precipitate.
2CrO42-(aq) + 2H+(aq) Cr2O72-(aq) + H2O
To about 1 mL of solution add 10 drops of 6 M CH3COOH. Then add a few drops of 0.5 M
K2CrO4 solution. The appearance of a yellow precipitate indicates the presence of Ba 2+. To
confirm, dissolve the precipitate in concentrated HCl and flame test.
o Strontium Ions:
Strontium can be identified, in the absence of calcium, by precipitating its sulfate. To the
solution add 0.1 M H2SO4 dropwise. The formation of a finely-divided, crystalline, white
precipitate indicates the presence of Sr2+. (Ba2+ must be absent, of course.) To confirm,
dissolve the precipitate in concentrated HCl and flame test.
o Calcium Ions:
If Ba2+ and Sr2+ are absent, Ca2+ may be precipitated as the oxalate from neutral or alkaline
solutions. Test the acidity of the solution with litmus paper. If it is acidic, add 3 M NH 3 until
basic. Then add 0.2 M (NH4)2C2O4 solution. The formation of a white precipitate indicates
the presence of Ca2+. Confirm by adding a few drops of concentrated HCl and flame testing.
Cadmium forms a yellow precipitate with sulfide ion either from a neutral solution containing
free Cd2+ or from an ammoniacal solution of Cd(NH3)42+. Since most sulfides are insoluble,
and many of them are black, the presence of other metal ions may make it difficult to detect
the yellow color of CdS. Therefore, separations must be as complete as possible before
testing for Cd2+.
To a solution of Cd2+ or to a solution thought to contain Cd(NH 3)42+add 0.1 M Na2S solution
dropwise. The formation of a yellow precipitate confirms the presence of Cd 2+.
o Copper(II) Ions:
The very distinct deep blue color of the copper ammonia complex can be used to identify
Cu2+. This identification can be carried out in the presence of other cations which form either
colorless ammonia complexes or white precipitates. Thus, Zn 2+, Cd2+, Al3+, among others,
will not interfere.
In relatively dilute solutions the color of the ammonia complex may not be intense enough to
give an unqualified identification, and some other test for confirmation must be used.
Cu2+ forms a very insoluble reddish-brown hexacyanoferrate(II).
Other cations that react with this reagent to form highly colored precipitates must be absent
(Co2+ and Fe3+ for example). Acidify the test solution with acetic acid. Then add a few drops
of 0.1 M potassium hexacyanoferrate(II) solution (K 4Fe(CN)6). A red-brown precipitate
confirms the presence of Cu2+.
o Nickel(II) Ions:
Nickel(II) is one of the easiest cations to identify. Ni2+ forms a red precipitate with
dimethylglyoxime in a buffered acid solution. Palladium(II) is the only other cation which
forms a precipitate with this reagent. However, a few other cations can interfere. Cobalt(II)
preferentially forms a dark brown solution with dimethylglyoxime, and excess reagent must
be used in its presence.
Acidify the solution to be tested with 6 M CH3COOH. Then add about one mL of 0.2 M
NaOOCCH3 solution. Add dimethylglyoxime solution dropwise. A bright red precipitate is
positive for Ni2+.
o Zinc Ions:
Zinc forms one of the few insoluble white sulfides. It is precipitated from a solution of the
ammonia complex. Small traces of cations that form dark colored sulfides will obviously
interfere.
Add an excess of 3 M NH3 to the test solution, so that any zinc present is in the form of
Zn(NH3)42+. Then add a few drops of 0.1 M Na2S solution. A white precipitate indicates the
presence of Zn2+.
Aluminum is generally identified by making use of the amphoteric property of its hydroxide
and the red color of the "lake" AlOH3 forms with the reagent, aluminon. Aluminon is a dye
(an organic molecule, usually fairly large, that absorbs visible light). As the
Al(OH)3precipitates the dye is adsorbed on the Al(OH)3 particles. The adsorption of the dye
is called "laking." Aluminum is a fairly common impurity and care must be taken that trace
quantities are not reported. Since most laboratory manipulations are carried out in glass
containers, silica gel, which physically resembles aluminum hydroxide, is also a common
impurity.
Adjust the pH of about 1 mL of the test solution (with 3 M NaOH and 3 M HNO 3) to
precipitate the hydroxide. Centrifuge the mixture. Remove the mother liquor with a capillary
pipet and wash the precipitate with distilled water. Centrifuge the mixture. Remove the
mother liquor with a capillary pipet and wash the precipitate with distilled water. Centrifuge
the mixture and remove the mother liquor with a capillary pipet. These repeated washings
remove other ions from the precipitate. Dissolve the precipitate in 3 M HNO 3. If any
precipitate does not dissolve in the nitric acid, remove the supernatant to a clean test tube
and discard the residue. Add two drops of aluminon reagent (avoid any excess). Add 3 M
NH3(aq) until the solution is basic. Centrifuge. A red, gelatinous precipitate (sometimes
called a red lake) indicates Al3+.
Any precipitate that remains after the addition of the nitric acid is probably silica gel,
SiO2xH2O. Silica gel is present in many solutions; it is leached from glass containers. Any
silica gel present must be removed before the addition of the aluminon and the ammonia
because silica gel will also give a red lake.
Do not confuse traces of red-brown ferric hydroxide for the red lake. Other precipitates will
also form colors with the reagent. The supernatant liquid will be an intense blue-purple color
if too much reagent has been added. This color has nothing to do with the presence of
aluminum. The color of the reagent is sensitive to changes in pH, (the reagent is an acid-
base indicator).
o Chromium(III) Ions:
Chromium can be taken through a series of colored tests which leaves no doubt as to its
identity. Chromium(III) forms a steel green hydroxide which dissolves in excess strong base
to give a deeply green colored solution of the hydroxy complex. Treating this complex with
3% hydrogen peroxide gives the yellow solution of the chromate ion, which upon
acidification with dilute nitric acid gives the orange color of dichromate. Treatment of the
cold solution of dichromate with 3% hydrogen peroxide gives the intense blue color of a
peroxide of chromium. (The actual composition of this peroxide is not known, but it is
believed to have the empirical formula CrO5.) This peroxide readily decomposes to the pale
violet color of the original hydrated chromium(III) ion. In low concentrations of dichromate
the blue color is fleeting, and attention must be focused on the test tube during the addition
of the hydrogen peroxide to avoid missing the color change.
The following color changes are all indicative of Cr 3+. Add an excess of 6 M NaOH to about
one mL of test solution. To this green solution add 10 drops of 3% H 2O2. Heat the test tube
in the water bath until the excess H2O2 is destroyed as indicated by the cessation of
bubbles. Acidify the yellow solution with 3 M HNO 3. Cool the resulting orange solution in an
ice bath. To the cooled solution add a drop or two of 3% H 2O2 and observe the immediate
fleeting blue color.
o Tin(IV) Ions:
Sn4+ is most conveniently identified by reduction of Sn4+ to Sn2+ with iron. The Sn2+ solution
is treated with HgCl2 solution, whereupon Sn2+is oxidized to Sn4+ and, simultaneously,
HgCl2 is reduced to Hg2Cl2 (a silky, white precipitate). The Hg2Cl2 is further reduced by
Sn2+ to Hg, which appears black.
Add some concentrated HCl to the solution to be tested for Sn 4+. Place an iron brad (or
small iron wire) in this solution and heat in a water bath for 5 minutes. Take the clear
solution (filter if necessary) and add HgCl2 solution dropwise. The appearance of a silky,
white precipitate, which then turns black, confirms the presence of tin.
o Other Cations
o Manganese(II) Ions:
Acidify the test solution with 3 M HNO 3. Add solid NaBiO3 and stir. Centrifuge. If the
supernatant has the characteristic purple color of MnO 4-, Mn2+ was present.
o Bismuth(III) Ions:
Bismuth(III) forms a highly insoluble hydroxide which upon treatment with the hydroxy
complex of tin(II) is immediately converted to free bismuth, a black precipitate.
Precipitate Bi3+ from the test solution with 3 M NaOH and centrifuge the precipitate. Then, to
a solution of tin(II) chloride add with stirring 6 M sodium hydroxide until the precipitate of
tin(II) hydroxide which first forms just redissolves. This solution is then added dropwise to
the precipitate of bismuth(III) hydroxide. The rapid formation of a black color confirms
bismuth.
o Iron(III) Ions:
The Fe3+ ion is readily identified in a dilute nitric acid solution through the blood red color of
its thiocyanate complex. A large excess of reagent should be avoided.
Acidify the solution with 3 M HNO3. Then add a few drops of 0.1 M NH4SCN solution. The
solution turns red if Fe3+ is present.
The most characteristic reaction of carbonate is the formation of carbon dioxide upon
treatment with acid:
The colorless, odorless carbon dioxide can be identified by bubbling it through a saturated
solution of barium hydroxide, with which it forms a white precipitate of barium carbonate.
Assemble a gas-liberation apparatus from a small test tube and a section of bent tubing.
Dissolve or suspend a portion of your compound in a small amount of water and place it in
the small test tube. Add about 0.5 mL of 6 M HCl and quickly fit the tube into the small test
tube, allowing the gas liberated to bubble into a 6" test tube of saturated Ba(OH) 2 solution.
The formation of a white precipitate in the large test tube (if the gas liberated is odorless) is
a positive test for carbonate. It is imperative to test the gas-liberation apparatus by adding
HCl to Na2CO3.
o Sulfide Ions:
When treated with nonoxidizing acids (HCl, CH3COOH) sulfides react to liberate H2S gas
(rotten-egg odor). If the sulfide is very insoluble liberation of the gas may require
concentrated acids (indeed some sulfides, HgS, CuS, are so insoluble that dissolution
requires special treatment). The gas is generally identified by its odor and its precipitation of
colored sulfides of various metal ions. Sulfides or hydrogen sulfide also are oxidized to
elemental sulfur and sulfate by oxidizing agents such as permanganate, nitric acid, sulfuric
acid, Fe(III), etc.
3H2S(aq) + 2H+(aq) + 2NO3-(aq) 2NO(g) + 4H2O + 3S(s)
Acidify a sample with 6 M hydrochloric acid and warm. Cautiously smell the gas evolved and
also test the gas with a piece of filter paper moistened with lead acetate solution. A foul
smelling gas which turns lead acetate paper black constitutes a positive sulfide test.
o Sulfate Ions:
Acidify the test solution with 6 M HCl, and add a few drops of 0.2 M BaCl 2 solution. A white
precipitate indicates the presence of SO42-.
o Nitrate Ions:
The most notable feature of the chemistry of the nitrate ion is its oxidizing ability as
illustrated by the following reactions:
In the last reaction the nitrogen oxide reacts with excess Fe 2+ to give the brown complex ion
Fe(NO)2+. It is the formation of this brown complex that is used to identify NO 3- (called the
brown ring test).
Acidify about 2 mL of the test solution with 3 M H2SO4 and then dissolve one-half spatula full
of solid FeSO4.7H2O in the acidified solution. Cool the solution and then carefully introduce
about 0.5 mL of concentrated H2SO4 by allowing it to flow down the side of the tilted test
tube. Allow the solution to sit undisturbed so that the sulfuric acid forms a definite layer. The
formation of a brown color at the interface of the layer constitutes a positive test for nitrate.
o Phosphate Ions:
The precipitation usually used to identify phosphate is the formation of yellow ammonium
molybdophosphate from ammonium molybdate in acidic solution.
Acidify the sample with concentrated nitric acid and add several drops in excess. Then treat
the solution with ammonium molybdate reagent and warm. The formation of a yellow
crystalline precipitate confirms the presence of phosphate.
Silver chloride, the most soluble of the three, dissolves readily in 6 M NH 3 solution because
of formation of the ammonia complex. Furthermore, when the solution of the ammonia
complex is acidified, AgCl reprecipitates. Neither AgBr nor AgI will dissolve readily in 6 M
NH3, a much higher concentration of NH3 being required to form the complex.
Bromide and iodide are usually identified by oxidation to the free elements with chlorine.
The elements thus formed are extracted into carbon tetrachloride and identified by their
color.
o Chloride:
Acidify the test solution with 3 M HNO 3. Then add several drops of 0.1 M AgNO 3. If a
white precipitate forms, centrifuge and remove the supernatant. To the precipitate add 6
M NH3 with stirring. If the precipitate dissolves, add 6 M HNO3 to the solution. A white
precipitate will form if the original test solution contained Cl -.
Acidify the sample with several drops of 6 M HCl and add 4-5 drops of carbon
tetrachloride. Then add about 0.5 mL of chlorine water and shake. Appearance of an
orange-brown carbon tetrachloride layer indicates the presence of bromide. Formation of
a purple layer indicates iodide.