Language Notes: Studying Text Structure
Language Notes: Studying Text Structure
Language Notes: Studying Text Structure
page 251
language notes
European languages organise information in sentences and texts in roughly similar ways,
moving from known to new. Students whose languages work differently may still find it
difficult to write continuous texts in ways that English-speaking readers find natural.
page 252
language notes
Not all languages typically begin sentences with the grammatical subject. Some may
topicalise bringing some other known element to the front (as spoken English
often does: see page 257). Speakers of these languages may need practice in choosing
appropriate subjects and verbs so that they can begin with known information in a way
that is natural to written English.
The structure with have illustrated here (X had something happen to him/her) is a
convenient way of talking about things that happen to people, when neither an ordinary
active nor a passive works well.
page 253
Oxford English Grammar Course Advanced Michael Swan and Catherine Walter 2012
pages 254256
language notes
Linking words in European languages work in more or less the same ways, though
punctuation may not. Other languages may not have a clear distinction corresponding to
that between our conjunctions and adverbs. Speakers of these languages may have quite a
lot of difficulty in mastering the English conventions for clause- and sentence-linking.
page 257
pages 258259
page 260
Oxford English Grammar Course Advanced Michael Swan and Catherine Walter 2012
page 261
pages 262267
language notes
Actually (page 267) is a false friend for speakers of many European languages, in which
similar words (actuellement, aktuell etc) mostly mean at present.
Students may also misunderstand the special concessive use of certainly and it is true that
(page 265), thinking that they just have their literal meanings and not realising that they
imply a following but.
pages 270273
Oxford English Grammar Course Advanced Michael Swan and Catherine Walter 2012
page 274
pages 276277
language notes
The restrictions on the use of do so are hard to define the explanation on page 277 gives a
rough guide.
page 278
page 279
Oxford English Grammar Course Advanced Michael Swan and Catherine Walter 2012
Im afraid so.
Im afraid not.
pages 282283
language notes
There are various grammatical differences between informal speech and formal writing.
Many of these are to do with processing: written language can be more dense and complex
than speech, because readers, unlike listeners, can process sentences at their own speed
and go back over difficult material if necessary. Also, since speakers and listeners are
generally in the same situation and place, not so much has to be explained, and words can
often be dropped. Because of these differences, many native-speaking children, although
they are fluent speakers, find it hard to master the conventions of formal writing. For literate
non-native speaking learners of English, the problem is often the opposite. They may be
very familiar with the typical structures of written English these are what is normally
taught in textbooks and illustrated in grammars but they may have learnt little or nothing
about spoken sentence structure.
Spoken sentences often begin by fronting something that is not the subject (see also page
257). This structure topicalisation is rare in written English. While advanced learners
dont necessarily need to produce native-like informal speech, it is important for them to
be familiar with the way sentences like these are constructed, so that they can understand
them more easily when they hear natural conversational English.
Back at work, then, is she, Maggie?
That discussion, Peters new idea, what did you think of it?
Gets on everybodys nerves, she does.
Note, however, that in some languages (e.g. Japanese) topicalisation is common in writing
as well as speech. Speakers of such languages may need to learn not to use these structures
in written English. Comparing the grammar of speech and writing will help them in this.
In some cultures written language has very high prestige, and the grammar of informal
speech may be regarded as inferior or incorrect. Students from this kind of background may
need to be persuaded that the structures discussed here are valid and worth studying in
their own right.
Oxford English Grammar Course Advanced Michael Swan and Catherine Walter 2012
Speech in films etc Watch part of a film or a recorded TV sitcom or cartoon with the class
and study some of the dialogue. Look for examples of spoken grammar. Are there also
examples of unrealistic speech with grammar more typical of written language?
pages 284285
Scripting dialogues Get students, in groups of three or four, to prepare, practise and
perform dialogues containing examples of all the structures practised here. They will need
quite some time to do this. Suggest topics if necessary.
pages 286288
page 289
pages 290291
page 293
Oxford English Grammar Course Advanced Michael Swan and Catherine Walter 2012
page 294
page 295
Oxford English Grammar Course Advanced Michael Swan and Catherine Walter 2012