PE Chat 2013
PE Chat 2013
PE Chat 2013
September 2013
Q&A
KNOWLEDGE FOR ACTION MBA Career Management 2
MBA Career Management: Advising from experience
Todd Carson
Career Advisor, Private Equity & Venture Capital
Pre-Wharton CV
Private Equity: Pension Corporation LLP (London, UK)
Member of investment team responsible for management of $1bn portfolio of
private operating company assets
PC funded with $2.5bn total capital from JP Morgan, JC Flowers, Swiss Re
and others
RECRUITING MISSION
BACKGROUND STRATEGY ACCOMPLISHED
The Problem: In years past, Wharton students struggled to gain traction with
top tier PE firms. Relatively limited support from Career Management
Result:
Between 2010-2012, 25% of all PE offers were from Top 40 firms
(up from <10%; 150%+ increase)
143% increase in student applications/ acceptances from Top 40
firms
57% of these Top 40 PE firm hires came from candidates whose
prior private equity experience was outside the Top 40
Acquire, operate and exit (sell) companies to earn a profit over the long-term (typically 5 years,
subject to market conditions)
Employ leverage to increase returns; 25% IRR typical benchmark
Goal: return a multiple of the equity invested via increase in company valuation
Achieved via growth/increased profitability, debt reduction/refinancing or higher valuation
multiple (re-rating)
Investment Small teams Small teams Small Sizable teams Broad teams
teams by sector by sector generalist with generalist Sector/
teams or sector focus operational
expertise
In addition to dedicated private equity funds, may house other businesses including
operational consultancies, hedge funds, and real estate funds.
PE firm investments
Portfolio Company Company management operates under oversight of GP
Evaluate
Identify Negotiate/ Restructure/ Position
Raise Capital Market Exit
candidates structure optimize for sale
Segments
Total: 6 13 years
Positives Positives
Growth in fundraising targeting Re-focus on the asset class following
emerging markets ($40bn/20% of recent big wins in social media/tech
total), $25bn of which non-BRIC Growth in interest in
Europe slowly turning the corner Entrepreneurship as a career path
Challenges Challenges
Fundraising bar higher than ever Track record of unimpressive returns
Days of the generalist fund coming Short list of funds dominating the
to an end marquee exits
Apollo Management First Reserve Hudson Clean Energy Novitas Capital TA Associates
Bain Capital & Bain General Atlantic Oaktree Capital
KKR TPG
Capital Ventures Partners Management
Global Environment Kleiner Perkins,
Bamboo Finance Permira Warburg Pincus
Fund Caulfield & Byers
Edinburgh
Moscow
London
Paris
Toronto Seoul
Beijing
Shanghai
Hong Kong
Dubai
Mexico City Mumbai
Singapore
Jakarta
Lima
Wharton part of the a core group of focus schools for the top firms
Venture Capital
Alta Ventures Mexico Lux Capital
Crosslink Capital Maveron
Detroit Venture Partners Oak Investment Partners
DreamIt Ventures Osage Partners
GoodCompany Group RTP Ventures
Greycroft Partners Valor Capital Group
Hasso Plattner Ventures Venrock Associates
Impact Amplifier Vox Capital
Longitude Capital Wharton Entrepreneurship
Internship Opportunities:
Warburg Pincus is offering internship opportunities in the firms London office during summer 2010 in each of the following investing teams: 1)
Technology, Media & Telecoms (TMT), 2) Central & Eastern Europe (CEE), 3) Healthcare, 4) Energy and 5) Consumer/Industrial. Working alongside
the firm's investment professionals, the role will give an individual interested in private equity an excellent opportunity to experience all aspects of
private equity investing and working with portfolio companies.
Requirements:
All candidates should have a well-developed analytical skill set, probably gained at either a major strategy consulting firm, investment
bank or private equity/investment firm.
TMT Team
Prior experience in Europe and exposure to the TMT or business services sectors are an advantage.
CEE Team
Prior experience in the Central & Eastern European region and exposure to the consumer/retail sector are an advantage. Applicable language skills
would be beneficial.
Healthcare
Prior experience in Europe and exposure to the healthcare sector are required.
Energy
Prior experience in Energy or Natural Resources is required.
Consumer/Industrial
Prior experience in Europe and fluency in French, Italian, Spanish or Portuguese are required. Internship will last 10
weeks so applicants should have required availability.
Who says VC firms dont hire interns? This summer, Battery Ventures is looking for an all-star intern to help build a variety of web monitoring
tools. Weve had seven IPOs in the past nine months, and need your help to continue building on this success. You will work out of our Silicon
Valley office and spend 20% of your time shadowing members of the investment team and the remaining 80% leading a major internal initiative for
how our firm interprets web and mobile data.
This is a very technical role and you need to be an awesome developer/hacker. We arent picky about which programming languages you prefer,
but you must be comfortable writing code to extract data from a multitude of APIs. Once extracted, you will need to develop an appropriate
storage methodology as well as a light-weight user interface to help us analyze the data in perpetuity.
It goes without saying that you need to be smart, detail-oriented, and hard-working, but you also need to be clever and funny.
This is a paid opportunity, and to apply, please fill out this form.
Overall
Sector specific knowledge/insight Dedication and detail-oriented
Increasing focus on legal skillset High achiever
Strong grasp of financing markets Political ability
Ability to network Passion for investing
Between 2010-2012:
214 students accepted offers in private equity (c.8% of all students)
Of these students, the vast majority (86%) had prior finance experience including private equity, real
estate investment, public buy-side (investment management & hedge fund) or investment banking
Remaining 14% coming from consulting and those with relevant industry/business development
experience
08-12: Principal
PRIVATE EQUITY/VENTURE
CAPITAL
Opportunities Challenges
Skill Development Skill Development
Financial and strategic analysis Steep learning curve
High level strategic opportunities Challenging interview hurdles
Management of cross functional teams Narrow focus - can spend all your time on one portfolio
Industry depth and breadth company
Relationships/People Relationships/People
Deal directly with senior management Multiple stake holders with multiple agendas
Network with top layer of finance industry Political savvy required
Dynamic and motivated peers
Career Path
Career Path Independent development of personal franchise is critical to
Flat structures; unlimited responsibility success
Subject to performance, relatively quick route to equity Progression can be hindered without nurturing supportive
key senior relationships
Other
Other
Variety of industry exposure and varying roles
Competition for jobs
Driving landmark, company defining events
Low tolerance for underperformance; high performance
Compensation at/near highest levels of any industry
thresholds
Prestige
Lifestyle: long hours required when executing; significant
travel including long term postings at portfolio companies
possible
Working for a mega fund is the only way to Mega funds dont typically hire post-MBAs,
get into PE but there are scores of other firms which
offer compelling opportunities
PE offers a good lifestyle (and provides Lifestyle at mega funds is similar to bulge-
more free time and money than investment bracket banking; deal execution requires the
banking) same effort regardless of the size
Because of the Wharton MBA, PE shops will Funds are looking for experience.
actively recruit me Employees must add value from day one
(few offer training programs)
Mature Enterprise
Established employer relationships Developing employer relationships
Annual, steady demand Inconsistent demand year-to-year
Extend multiple offers/yield multiple students Just-in-time hiring
Understand MBA recruiting value prop Less clear on MBA recruiting value prop
Consulting, Banking, Sales & Trading, CPG PE, VC, Media, Retail, Social Impact
Healthcare, Technology, Energy, Hedge funds, Real Estate
Recruiting Employer Info Sessions, Employer Networking Postings, resume book, networking
Strategy / Timing Night, Sponsorships, On Campus Recruiting Throughout year; late in year/summer offers
Heavy Fall/Winter Recruiting
04-06: Consultant
Solid business
06-08: Business Dev. foundation
12
10
0
2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013
On-Campus Recruiting
Services
1% 1% 1% Job Board Posting
3%
4%
Personal Networking
12% Connection
60% Other
Trek Networking
Connection
18% Career Fair
1%
4% 4%
Personal Networking
29% Connection
15% Other
On-Campus Recruiting
Services
Job Board Posting
8%
Other
8%
Wharton Alumni Contact
Personal Networking
15% 46%
Connection
Job Board Posting
Trek Networking
Connection
23%
25
20
15
10
Presence
Gravitas; dynamic personality
Reputation
Would colleagues describe you as a superstar? References are important
Where were you quartiled?
Maturity
Wharton Private
Career Treks Workshops & Panels Equity Conference
6 US-based Training The Street Financial Largest of any MBA program
8 international Modeling Held in early February
take place during holidays Interview Prep Sessions Impressive roster of keynote
VC treks to Bay Area, Boston Day in the Life Panels speakers (eg. Stephen
Leadership Opportunities Networking Events Schwarzman, David
Build your own Speaker a week Rubenstein, Carl Thoma,
Howard Marks, David Blitzer)
Provide our 800+ members with resources to learn more about the PE/VC industry
Build relationships with industry professionals
Club Mission: Secure attractive career opportunities for our members
Establish Wharton as a pre-eminent brand in the investment community
Career related
Skill Development
Regional treks to meet employers
Education workshops developed to increase
job search skills (resumes, cover letters, Alumni mentoring
interviews, networking, research and online Mock interviews, club resume review
resources, etc.)
Other resources
Resume review process
PE Conference
Advising Networking events
Partner with you on self assessment, Speaker series
setting priorities, job search planning, Student mentoring, coffee chats
career education and matching, coaching,
etc. International opportunities
Events for women
KNOWLEDGE FOR ACTION MBA Career Management 41
Sample job search timeline
August - October
Self-Assessment
Explore your interests, skills and values
September - February
Research & Strategy
Research and identify target industries, functions and geographies. Create a job search plan.
September - May
General Research
Keep current on recent transactions and industry trends; interview preparation
October - May
Networking
Engage in conversations to build relationships, gather information and identify potential opportunities
January - May
Interviewing
Prepare for and engage in conversations about your interest and qualifications for specific jobs
October - May
Back-up Plan
Evaluate job in context of your risk profile
MBACM
Assess time investment/opportunity cost reality check
One-on-One Advising (begins 10/1)
Develop a strategic plan/target list with MBACM
Join the PE/VC Club
Weekly events
CareerPath
Complete your profile and set email preferences
Create job search agents
Wharton Community
Begin networking with your classmates. Stay motivated and
positive!
Read emails from MBACM for important information on
upcoming events and deadlines
Website: http://mbacareers.wharton.upenn.edu/student
General Email Inquires: mbacareers@wharton.upenn.edu
What is the process for getting a PE job? Attend MBACM sessions and club job search planning events
How do I find lists of firms? MBA website: Greyhouse Guide, Capital IQ, Lippincott library:
Galantes, Venturexpert, Thomson one, Zephyr, Vault, Wikipedia
How do I find alumni? Wharton Community, Linkedin, CareerPath, firm websites
How do I network? Attend networking educations events and develop then refine a
networking strategy with your career advisor, mentors and peers
I am interested in PE and VC-how do I decide? Self assessment, advising appointment, club education events
When can I meet with an advisor? System opens in September, PE/VC appointments for First Years as of
Oct 1
What do I do if there are no jobs at the firm I want? Search for a comparable role at another firm (dont limit yourself)
What if I have a back up job, but no PE job yet? Work with an advisor to set priorities in the context of your risk profile