Technical Evaluation Report PDF
Technical Evaluation Report PDF
Technical Evaluation Report PDF
O (P-III) 18-1/2012
GOVERNMENT OF THE PUNJAB,
HEALTH DEPARTMENT
Dated Lahore the 18.04.2013
To
1. Meditech (Pvt.) Limited 22. Ittefaq Sons (Pvt.) Limited
2. Eastern Medical Technology 23. Biotech Services
3. Shirazi Trading (Pvt.) Limited 24. Radiant Medical (Pvt.) Limited
4. Medequips (Pvt.) Limited 25. Global Marketing Services
5. Esas Technologies 26. Pakistan Microbiological Associates
6. Noor International 27. Scientific Technical Corporation
28. Seimens (Pakistan) Engg Co.
7. Medi Urge (Pvt.) Limited
29. Total Technologies
8. Vital Care 30. Golden Gulf Establishment
9. Digionics (Pvt.) Limited 31. Med Elec Corporation
10. Noorani Surgical 32. Amtronech
11. Interex 33. Prod Med Enterprises
12. Iqbal & Company 34. Iftiqar Enterprises
13. Iftikhar Ali Enterprises 35. Bio Medical Services
36. Sakuf Trading
14. Quintex Medical
37. Intexim Enterprises
15. Three Star Medical Suppliers 38. Nashuatec
16. Technology Links 39. Microtech
17. Lindey Pakistan 40. Phono Engineer
18. General Electromax 41. Med Express
19. Asher Enterprises 42. Multiware Garments
20. Dymedix Systems 43. Ashfaq Tradeers
21. Toyota Ravi Motors
M/S Eastern
S No. ITEMS DETAIL QTY PARAMETERS M/S Medequips M/S Vital Care M/S Meditech M/S Mediurge M/S Bio Tech Servises
Medical
MODEL Cardiofax P-8000 CardioExpress SL6 P-8000 EPG- 06 View Heart Screen 112 Visit
Esaote, Italy/ Esaote, Italy/
BRAND & ORIGIN
Nihon Kohden,Japan Switzerland Spacelab,USA Switzerland Progetti, italy Innomed, Europe
TECHNICAL ELIGIBILITY OF PRODUCT Non Responsive Responsive Responsive Responsive Responsive Responsive
2 DEFIBRILLATOR 15
No MHLW
No MHLW Certificate No MHLW Certificate
Remarks As per specifications Certificate As per specifications As per specifications
attached. attached.
attached.
TECHNICAL ELIGIBILITY OF PRODUCT Non Responsive Non Responsive Responsive Non Responsive Responsive Responsive
BRAND & ORIGIN APC- England/Pace APC- England/Pace APC- England/Pace APC- England/Pace
Medical, USA Medical, USA Medtronic, USA Medical, USA Medical, USA APC- England/Pace Medical, USA
As per
Remarks As per specifications As per specifications As per specifications As per specifications As per specifications
specifications
BRAND & ORIGIN APC- England/Pace APC- England/Pace APC- England/Pace APC- England/Pace
Medical, USA Medical, USA Medtronic, USA Medical, USA Medical, USA APC- England/Pace Medical, USA
Page 1 of 3
WAZIRABAD INSTITUTE OF CARDIOLOGY, WAZIRABAD
TECHNICAL EVALUATION
PACKAGE NO. 1 MONITORING
M/S Eastern
S No. ITEMS DETAIL QTY PARAMETERS M/S Medequips M/S Vital Care M/S Meditech M/S Mediurge M/S Bio Tech Servises
Medical
As per
Remarks As per specifications As per specifications As per specifications As per specifications As per specifications
specifications
1 ECG MACHINE 03 CHANNEL 10
5 CARDIAC MONITORS 40
As per
Remarks As per specifications As per specifications As per specifications As per specifications As per specifications
specifications
CENTRAL MONITORING
6 SYSTEM WITH 10 VITAL SIGN 4
No 510(K) Certificate
MONITORS
No MHLW Certificate As per attached.
Remarks As per specifications As per specifications As per specifications
attached. specifications No installation list
provided
TECHNICAL ELIGIBILITY OF PRODUCT Non Responsive Responsive Responsive Responsive N on Responsive Responsive
7 PULSE OXIMETER 10
Page 2 of 3
WAZIRABAD INSTITUTE OF CARDIOLOGY, WAZIRABAD
TECHNICAL EVALUATION
PACKAGE NO. 1 MONITORING
M/S Eastern
S No. ITEMS DETAIL QTY PARAMETERS M/S Medequips M/S Vital Care M/S Meditech M/S Mediurge M/S Bio Tech Servises
Medical
No 510(K) Certificate
7 PULSE OXIMETER 10
As per attached.
Remarks As per specifications As per specifications As per specifications As per specifications
specifications No installation list
1 ECG MACHINE 03 CHANNEL 10
provided
TECHNICAL STATUS Non Responsive Non Responsive Responsive Non Responsive Non Responsive Responsive
Page 3 of 3
WAZIRABAD INSTITUTE OF CARDIOLOGY, WAZIRABAD
TECHNICAL EVALUATION
PACKAGE NO. 2 ( INTRA AROTIC BALLON PUMP )
S No. ITEMS DETAIL QTY PARAMETERS M/S Interex M/S Iqbal and Company
MODEL CS-100 Autocat 2
Intra Aoratic
1 2 BRAND & ORIGIN Datascope,USA Arrow Teleflex,USA
Balloon Pump
Remarks As per specifications As per specifications
TECHNICAL ELIGIBILITY OF PRODUCT Eligible Eligible
MODEL Actalyhexl Hemochron Response
2 ACT Machine 2 BRAND & ORIGIN Helena Labortary,USA Internati Tech,USA
Remarks As per specifications As per specifications
TECHNICAL ELIGIBILITY OF PRODUCT Eligible Eligible
TECHNICAL ELIGIBILITY OF FIRM Eligible Eligible
TECHNICAL STATUS Responsive Responsive
Wazirabad Institute of Cardiology
Sub Campus of Punjab Institute of Cardiology
TECHNICAL EVALUATION
PACKAGE NO. 3 (E.T.T and Holter Recorder )
MODEL ERGO E600 STRESS-S2-T Cube Stress X-Scribe QRS Card CardioStress TM Q-Stress
Norav Medical, Mortara
BRAND & ORIGIN BTL,UK Cardio Line,Italy Braemer Inc,USA Nasiff,USA Cardiac Science,USA
Germany Instruments,USA
As Per Bidding
document, Check list for
1 E.T.T MACHINE 2 Quoted Prices in
Eligiblity.
As per Technial offer. As per
Remarks As per specifications As per specifications No list of Product As Per specifications
specifications Rejected as specifications
installation /
ambigious offer
Performance certificates
provided.
TECHNICAL ELIGIBILITY OF PRODUCT Eligible Not Eligible Eligible Eligible Eligible Not Eligible Eligible
MODEL H 100 DL 900 CE Cube Holter Software H-Scribe DL 800 Series CardioHoleter TM V51-6G Vision Premier
Norav Medical, Mortara
BRAND & ORIGIN BTL,UK Cardio Line,Italy Braemer Inc,USA Nasiff,USA Cardiac Science,USA
Germany Instruments,USA
As Per Bidding
HOLTER
document, Check list for
2 MONITOR AND 3 Quoted Prices in
Eligiblity.
RECORDER As per Technial offer. As per
Remarks As per specifications As per specifications No list of Product As Per specifications
specifications Rejected as specifications
installation /
ambigious offer
Performance certificates
provided.
TECHNICAL ELIGIBILITY OF PRODUCT Eligible Not Eligible Eligible Eligible Eligible Not Eligible Eligible
TECHNICAL ELIGIBILITY OF FIRM Eligible Eligible Eligible Eligible Eligible Eligible Eligible
TECHNICAL STATUS Responsive Non Responsive Responsive Responsive Responsive Non Responsive Responsive
Wazirabad Institute of Cardiology
Sub Campus of Punjab Institute of Cardiology
TECHNICAL EVALUATION
PACKAGE NO. 04 (WARD EQUIPMENT 1)
S No. ITEMS DETAIL QTY PARAMETERS M/S Mediurge M/S Eastern Medical M/S Meditech M/S Radiant Medical
Note: The technical committee has evaluated the technical aspects while the commercial evaluation be done before finalizing the
Tender.
Page 1 of 1
WAZIRABAD INSTITUTE OF CARDIOLOGY, WAZIRABAD
TECHNICAL EVALUATION
PACKAGE NO. 05 (VENTILATION)
M/S Essas M/S Noor
S No. ITEMS DETAIL QTY PARAMETERS M/S Mediurge M/S Eastern Medical M/S Vital Care
Technologies International
MODEL Elisa Newport E360 T Inspiration 5i Hamilton-G5 iTransIS BASE
Heinen+Lowenstein, Event Medical,USA/ Hamilton Medical Heyer
BRAND & ORIGIN Covidien,USA
Germany Ireland AG,Switzearland Medical,Germany
No FDA certificate of
1 ICU VENTILATOR 4
Required frequncy is Quoted model.
up to 120 BPM Quoted with Slave As per As per
Remarks As per specifications
whereas quoted is monitor, System is not specifications specifications
up to 100 BPM with built in monitor
of 12 Inch or more
TECHNICAL ELIGIBILITY OF PRODUCT Not Eligible Not Eligible Eligible Eligible Eligible
Rem Star PR Rem Star PR
MODEL Trend II Auto Sleep One auto pap Auto c-pap
SystemOne SystemOne
Philips/ Respironics/ Hoffritcher, Philips/
BRAND & ORIGIN Hoffrichter, Germany Kara Medical, EU
USA Germany Respironics/ USA
2 C-PAP UNIT 1
Country of origin
As per As per
Remarks As per specifications mentioned as EU. As per specifications
specifications specifications
Country not specified
3 BI-PAP UNIT 1
Country of origin
As per As per
Remarks As per specifications mentioned as EU. As per specifications
specifications specifications
Country not specified
Note: The technical committee has evaluated the technical aspects while the commercial evaluation be done before finalizing the
Tender.
WAZIRABAD INSTITUTE OF CARDIOLOGY, WAZIRABAD
TECHNICAL EVALUATION
PACKAGE NO. 06 (MEDICAL FURNITURE )
BRAND & ORIGIN Hospital metal craft, UK GIVAS, ITALY LOCAL CFS SRL ITALY
Paramount bed
BRAND & ORIGIN GIVAS, ITALY CHIABBA, ITALY A.A MEDICAL, GREECE
company,Japan
MIDMARK PROMOTAL
STORAGE CABINATE BRAND & ORIGIN Hospital metal craft, UK PADIGO, USA CHIABBA, ITALY
FRANCE
FOR MEDICINE AND
8 8
SURGICAL
INSTRUMENTS
Remarks As above As per specifications As per specifications
Installation reference of
quoted system are not
9 FOWLER BED 03 CRANK 20
provided.
Remarks As per specifications As above As per specifications No CE certificate Provided.
Attached Technical literature
is not in accordance with the
technical offer.
Installation reference of
10 FOWLER BED 02 CRANK 40 quoted system are not
provided.
Remarks As per specifications As above as per specifications No CE certificate Provided.
Attached Technical literature
is not in accordance with the
technical offer.
Installation reference of
EXAMINATION COUCH quoted system are not
11 15
WITH FOOT STEP provided.
Remarks As per specifications As above as per specifications No CE certificate Provided.
Attached Technical literature
is not in accordance with the
technical offer.
TECHNICAL ELIGIBILITY OF PRODUCT Eligible Not Eligible Not Eligible Not Eligible Not Eligible
MODEL 4061-01 4061-01 320 Riester
BRAND & ORIGIN Riester,Germany Riester,Germany W.A Baum,USA Dulex -de luX MDFA
2 Stethocope 50 No Manufacturer Authorization
Remarks As per specifications As above As above As above No Technica Literature
No quality certificates
TECHNICAL ELIGIBILITY OF PRODUCT Elligible Not Eligible Not Eligible Not Eligible Not Eligible
MODEL 5200 710 Oval Silicon Type 720
BRAND & ORIGIN Hersill ,S.L Spain Ambu,Denmark Ambu,Denmark Fazzinin ,Italy Gleamed,Taiwan
3 Ambu Bag Small Sizes 20 No Manufacturer Authorization
Remarks As per specifications As above As above As above No Technica Literature
No quality certificates
TECHNICAL ELIGIBILITY OF PRODUCT Elligible
MODEL 5200710 Oval Silicon Type 722 Gleamed,Taiwan
BRAND & ORIGIN HERSILL SRL SPAIN Ambu,Denmark Ambu,Denmark Fazzinin ,Italy
4 Ambu Bag Large Sizes 20 No Manufacturer Authorization
Remarks As per specifications As above As above As above No Technica Literature
No quality certificates
TECHNICAL ELIGIBILITY OF PRODUCT Elligible Not Eligible Not Eligible Not Eligible Not Eligible
TECHNICAL ELIGIBILITY OF PRODUCT Elligible Not Eligible Not Eligible Not Eligible Not Eligible
MODEL 769+755 769 769+220 S7350hr ZT-160
6 Weight Scale and Height 15
6 Weight Scale and Height 15 BRAND & ORIGIN Seca Germany Seca Germany Seca Germany Fazzinin ,Italy China
Remarks Eligible As above As above As above No Manufacturer Authorization
TECHNICAL ELIGIBILITY OF PRODUCT Eligible Not Eligible Not Eligible Not Eligible Not Eligible
MODEL 5070 5070 RI-Integral
No Manufacturer Authorization
7 Torch and Emergency Light 20 BRAND & ORIGIN REIESTER GERMANY Riester,Germany Imported Riester,Germany No Technica Literature
No quality certificates
Remarks As per specifications As above As above As above
TECHNICAL ELIGIBILITY OF PRODUCT Elligible Not Eligible Not Eligible Not Eligible Not Eligible
TECHNICAL ELIGIBILITY OF FIRM Elligible Not Eligible Not Eligible Not Eligible Not Eligible
TECHNICAL STATUS Responsive Non Responsive Non Responsive Non Responsive Non Responsive
Note: The technical committee has evaluated the technical aspects while the commercial evaluation be done before finalizing the
Tender.
WAZIRABAD INSTITUTE OF CARDIOLOGY, WAZIRABAD
TECHNICAL EVALUATION
PACKAGE NO. 08 (LABORTARY EQUIPMENT-I)
M/S Pakistan Microbiological
S No. ITEMS DETAIL QTY PARAMETERS M/S Global MKT Servises
Associates
MODEL Opti CCA-Ts Easystat
BRAND &
Optimedical,USA Medica Corpoation,USA
ORIGIN
1 Blood Gas Analyzer 1
3 Spectrophoto meter 1
Quoted is Humas,Korea whereas
Remarks required country of origin is As per specifications
USA/Europe/Japan
Page 2 of 2
WAZIRABAD INSTITUTE OF CARDIOLOGY, WAZIRABAD
TECHNICAL EVALUATION
PACKAGE NO. 09 (LABORTARY EQUIPMENT-II)
S No. ITEMS DETAIL QTY PARAMETERS M/S Scientific Technical Corporation Pvt. Ltd. M/S Three Star Medical Supplier
1 Centrifuge Machine 2
No authorization Letter attached.
Remarks As Per Specifications
No quality Certificate attached.
4 Platelet Shaker 1
No authorization Letter attached.
Remarks As Per Specifications
No quality Certificate attached.
5 Blood Shaker 1
No authorization Letter attached.
Remarks As Per Specifications
No quality Certificate attached.
7 Water bath 2
No authorization Letter attached.
Remarks As Per Specifications
No quality Certificate attached.
10 Water Still 1
No authorization Letter attached.
Remarks As Per Specifications
No quality Certificate attached.
11 Blood Mixer 0
No authorization Letter attached.
Remarks As Per Specifications
No quality Certificate attached.
13 Vortex Mixer 2
No authorization Letter attached.
Remarks As Per Specifications
No quality Certificate attached.
MODEL NU-425-400 E
MODEL Local
15 R.O System 1 1
1 MICROSCOPE 2
Remarks As per specifications As per specifications As per specifications
TECHNICAL ELIGIBILITY OF PRODUCT TECHNICAL ELIGIBILITY Not Eligibel Eligible Eligibel Eligibel Eligibel Not Eligibel
MODEL SIMPLY HP 32 EVO SIMPLY HP-32 TX-32HF-B MOBILETTE XP HYBRID VISITOR T30 M-R MobileArt Evolution
BRAND & ORIGIN IBIS, ITALY PRIMAX. ITLAY RADIOLOGIA S.A. SPAIN SIEMENS VILLA, ITALY SHIMADZU
Mobile X-Ray Machine 300
2 2
mA System As Per Specifications. Mo MHWL
Remarks As Per Specifications. As Per Specification. As Per Specification. As Per Specifications As Per Specifications
Certificate available.
TECHNICAL ELIGIBILITY OF PRODUCT TECHNICAL ELIGIBILITY Eligibel Eligibel Eligibel Eligibel Eligibel Not Eligibel
MODEL COMPACT 2 SRX-201 COMPACT 2 MXP 2000 COMPACT 2 ECOMAT 9000
BRAND & ORIGIN PROTEC GmbH, Germany KONICA, JAPAN PROTEC GmbH, Germany CARESTREAM PROTEC GmbH, Germany ELK/JAPAN
TECHNICAL ELIGIBILITY OF PRODUCT TECHNICAL ELIGIBILITY Eligibel Not Eligible Eligibel not Eligibel Eligibel Not Eligibel
MODEL Adjust A-Fit PROTECH, MAVIG Basic 640 05/025/100-M IMPORTED
BRAND & ORIGIN Shielding. Intl USA PROTECH,USA MAVIG, GERMANY Germany IMPORTED
4 Lead Aprons 15
Remarks As Per Specifications As Per Specification. As Per Specification As Per Specifications As Per Specifications No Make/model availab;e
TECHNICAL ELIGIBILITY OF PRODUCT TECHNICAL ELIGIBILITY Eligibel Eligibel Eligible Eligibel Eligibel Not Eligibel
MODEL DX4102LED CONE DX4100LED 5146209 LED-NGP-21
BRAND & ORIGIN DARRY UK CONE USA DARRY UK Germany ULTRA VIOL, POLAND
5 X-Ray Illuminatore 20
Remarks As Per Specifications No Technical Literature Available As Per Specification No Technical Literature Available 50,000 LUX instead of 60,000 LUX. No Make/model availab;e
TECHNICAL ELIGIBILITY OF PRODUCT TECHNICAL ELIGIBILITY Eligibel Not Eligible Eligible Not Eligibel Not Eligibel Not Eligibel
TECHNICAL STATUS Non Responsive Non Responsive Non Responsive Non Resonsive Non Resonsive Non Responsive
WAZIRABAD INSTITUTE OF CARDIOLOGY, WAZIRABAD
TECHNICAL EVALUATION
PACKAGE NO. 11-C ( ULTRASOUND EQUIPMENTS )
S No. ITEMS DETAIL QTY PARAMETERS M/S Sherazi Trading M/S Ittefaq Sons M/S Bio-Tech Services M/S Medequips
As per Bidding
Document,Page-31(Joint
Venture/Consortium
template) Note:02" The firm
may be formed
1 Color doppler Ultrasound 1 Offer not considered as
consortium,if the lead
Remarks temporary ban has been As per Specification As per Specification.
bidder contributes more
imposed on GE by PIC
than 50% of the total value
of major items to complete
the pakcage" Whereas firm
have quoted items of other
distributor/company.
Note: The technical committee has evaluated the technical aspects while the commercial evaluation be done before finalizing the
Tender.
WAZIRABAD INSTITUTE OF CARDIOLOGY, WAZIRABAD
TECHNICAL EVALUATION
PACKAGE NO. 11-C ( ECHOCARDIOGRAPHY EQUIPMENTS )
S No. ITEMS DETAIL QTY PARAMETERS M/S Sherazi Trading M/S Siemens M/S Medequips
Eligible Eligible
TECHNICAL STATUS
Non Responsive Responsive Responsive
Note: The technical committee has evaluated the technical aspects while the commercial evaluation be done before finalizing the
Tender.
WAZIRABAD INSTITUTE OF CARDIOLOGY, WAZIRABAD
TECHNICAL EVALUATION
PACKAGE NO. 12 (SUPPORT SERVICES EQUIPMENT)
M/S TOTAL
S No. ITEMS DETAIL QTY PARAMETERS M/S RADIANT MEDICAL M/S MEDIURGE
TECHNOLOGIES
MODEL Unisteri 336-1 101 E-1/ En 285 AmSCO Lab
BRAND & ORIGIN MMM Group, Germany MATACHANA, SPAIN STERIS USA
1 LABORTARY STERLIZER 1
Remarks As Per Specifications As Per Specifications As Per Specifications
4 MEDICAL LAUNDRY 1
Remarks As Per Specifications As Per Specifications As Per Specifications
MAINTENANCE WORKSHOP
5 1
EQUIPMENT
Remarks As Per Specifications As Per Specifications As Per Specifications
Remarks As per specifications As per specifications As per specifications As per specifications As per specifications As per specifications
Remarks As per specifications As per specifications As per specifications As per specifications As per specifications As per specifications
Remarks As per specifications As per specifications As per specifications As per specifications As per specifications As per specifications
TECHNICAL STATUS
Responsive Responsive Responsive Responsive Responsive Responsive
Note: The technical committee has evaluated the technical aspects while the commercial evaluation be done before finalizing the
Tender.
WAZIRABAD INSTITUTE OF CARDIOLOGY, WAZIRABAD
TECHNICAL EVALUATION
PACKAGE NO. 14 (General Machinery and Equipment )
MODEL GEMCO-400
BRAND &
1 Power Generator 2 Gemco,Pakistan (Perkins and Stamford)
ORIGIN
Remarks No quality certificate attached
TECHNICAL ELIGIBILITY OF PRODUCT Not Eligible
MODEL S-1800
BRAND &
Vale Master
2 Floor Scrubbing Machine 2 ORIGIN
MODEL
BRAND & ORIGIN No Brand Mentioned
MODEL GXT6000
S No. ITEMS DETAIL QTY PARAMETERS M/S VITAL CARE M/S ASHER ENTERPRISES
Mohagney
ALMIRAH BOOK SHELVE BRAND & ORIGIN Manufacturer Name not given.
1 2 Interiors,Pakistan
WITH GLASS DOOR
As per Pre-Requisites of
bidding document, firm have
Remarks As per specifications
not metioned the
Manufacurer/Brand name.
Note: The technical committee has evaluated the technical aspects while the commercial
WAZIRABAD INSTITUTE OF CARDIOLOGY, WAZIRABAD
TECHNICAL EVALUATION
PACKAGE NO. 16 (TELEPHONE EXCHANGE AND SECURITY EQUIPMENTS )
MTEL HD3200S
MODEL ADHUA DH-CA-F480F W-CP500L
MTEL HD-DVR 221 V
S No. ITEMS DETAIL QTY PARAMETERS M/S Dymedix Systems M/S MED EXPRESS
TECHNICAL STATUS Non Responsive Non Responsive Conditionally Responsive Conditionally Responsive
*Note: All the firms are required to submit their samples for physical examination and approval by the end user before proceeding further.
The Approved samples will be retained at the hospital site till delivery of consignement.