Differentiated Instructional Reading Strategies and Annotated Bibliography
Differentiated Instructional Reading Strategies and Annotated Bibliography
Differentiated Instructional Reading Strategies and Annotated Bibliography
Shannon D. Cook
Troy University
T5/2017
DIFFERENTIATED INSTRUCTIONAL STRATEGIES 2
3rd Grade
4th Grade
5th Grade
Based on the 2015-2016 ACT Aspire test results, the area in the biggest need of
improvement is reading in all grade levels. The highest percentage of students fall in the “Needs
Improvement” area in reading in all three grade level. One way to increase student achievement
is to use various differentiated instruction strategies so that all students are receiving instruction
at their level. These educational techniques accommodate each student’s learning style,
readiness, and interest. Differentiated instruction strategies use a variety of educational methods
to teach students the same information. These techniques may also require teachers to teach
content at varying levels based on students’ readiness. The goal of differentiated instruction
strategies is to ensure that all students are engaged in the learning process by providing tasks that
product.
Content
The teacher may differentiate content by designing activities for groups of students that
cover various levels of Bloom’s Taxonomy. Students who are unfamiliar with a lesson may be
required to complete tasks on the lower levels: remembering and understanding. Students with
some mastery may be asked to apply and analyze the content, and students who have high levels
of mastery may be asked to complete tasks in the areas of evaluating and creating.
Process
Each student has a preferred learning style, and successful differentiation includes
delivering the material to each style: visual, auditory and kinesthetic and through words. Not all
students require the same amount of support from the teacher, and students could choose to work
DIFFERENTIATED INSTRUCTIONAL STRATEGIES 4
in pairs, small groups or individually. While some students may benefit from one-on-one
interaction with a teacher or classroom aide, others may be able to progress by themselves.
Product
The product is what the student creates at the end of the lesson to demonstrate the
mastery of the content. This can be in the form of tests, projects, reports or other activities.
Teachers may assign students to complete activities that show mastery of an educational concept
Examples of differentiating the product: learners who can read and write can write a book
report; visual learners can create a graphic organizer of the story; auditory learners can give an
oral report; and kinesthetic learners can build a diorama illustrating the story (Wesley, 2014).
Implementation
Implementation looks different for each student and each assignment. Before beginning
formal or informal. Teachers can give pre-tests, question students about their background
knowledge, or use KWL charts (charts that ask students to identify what they
already Know, what they Want to know, and what they have Learned about a topic).
2. Determine student interest. This can be done by using interest inventories and/or
including students in the planning process. Teachers can ask students to tell them what
specific interests they have in a particular topic, and then teachers can try to incorporate
3. Identify student learning styles and environmental preferences. Learning styles can be
measured using learning style inventories. Teachers can also get information about
DIFFERENTIATED INSTRUCTIONAL STRATEGIES 5
student learning styles by asking students how they learn best and by observing student
work best in large or small groups and what environmental factors might contribute to or
inhibit student learning. For example, a student might need to be free from distraction or
Teachers incorporate different instructional strategies based on the assessed needs of their
students. Throughout a unit of study, teachers should assess students on a regular basis. This
assessment can be formal, but is often informal and can include taking anecdotal notes on student
progress, examining students' work, and asking the student questions about his or her
understanding of the topic. The results of the assessment could then be used to drive further
instruction.
range of skills including, phonics, comprehension, fluency, word prediction, and story
prediction. The chart below offers a variety of strategies that can be used (Access Center, 2004).
Focus of
Strategy Definition Example
Differentiation
Interest Centers:
Centers can focus on
specific reading skills,
such as phonics or
Interest centers (usually used vocabulary, and provide
with younger students) and examples and activities
interest groups (usually used that center on a theme of
Interest
with older students) are set up interest, such as outer
Centers or Readiness
so that learning experiences space or students'
Interest Interest
are directed toward a specific favorite cartoon
Groups
learner interest. Allowing characters.
students to choose a topic can Interest Groups: For a
be motivating to them. book report, students can
work in interest groups
with other students who
want to read the same
book.
Tiered Assignments
Tiering assignments is a fair way to differentiate learning. It allows teachers to meet the
needs of all students while using varying levels of tasks. It's a concept that can be inserted into
homework assignments, small groups, or even learning centers. Make it a point to tell students
that each group is using different materials or completing different activities so they can share
what they learned with the class. Be neutral when grouping students—use numbers or colors for
group names, and be equally enthusiastic while explaining assignments to each cluster.
Also, it’s important to make each tiered assignment equally interesting, engaging, and fair in
terms of student expectations. The more flexible groups and materials you use, the more students
There are six main ways to structure tiered assignments: challenge level, complexity,
specific learning tasks that are being focused on—to determine the best approach.
Challenge Level
Tiering can be based on challenge level where student groups will tackle different
assignments altogether. Teachers can use Bloom’s Taxonomy as a guide to help them
1. Group 1: Students who need content reinforcement or practice will complete one
2. Group 2: Students who have a firm understanding will complete another activity
Complexity
When you tier assignments by complexity, you are addressing the needs of students who are
at different levels using the same assignment. The trick here is to vary the focus of the
assignment based upon whether each group is ready for more advanced work or simply
trying to wrap their head around the concept for the first time. You can direct your students
one group will focus on a singular perspective, while the other will consider several points of
Outcome
students will use the same materials, but depending on their readiness levels, will actually
have a different outcome. It may sound strange at first, but this strategy is quite beneficial to
Process
This differentiated instruction strategy is exactly what it sounds like—student groups will use
Product
Tiered assignments can also be differentiated based on product. Teachers can use the Howard
Gardner’s Multiple Intelligences to form groups that will hone particular skills. For example,
one group would be bodily/kinesthetic and their task is to create and act out a skit. Another
Resources
Tiering resources means that you are matching project materials to student groups based on
readiness or instructional need. One flexible group may use a magazine while another may
use a traditional textbook. As a tip, you should assign resources based on knowledge and
readiness, but also consider the group’s reading level and comprehension (Cox).
Much like a menu offers patrons a variety of options to satisfy their appetite, interest
centers expose students to a variety of strategies and choices that address many learners’ needs.
Interest centers are fluid and can span multiple levels. This gives both students and teachers
insight as to how a particular individual learns best. These centers offer students the opportunity
For many teachers, centers are a staple in their classroom. There is a significant difference
Differentiated centers have tiered assignments, which include varied student responses,
whereas a traditional learning center only has one level of response for all.
Differentiated centers have tiered activities, whereas traditional centers do not (Cox).
DIFFERENTIATED INSTRUCTIONAL STRATEGIES 10
Reading materials, activity sheets, graphic organizers, and other learning materials such
as word cards all need to be differentiated for the three levels of activities. Reading materials
should be provided at each student’s independent reading level (95–100 percent accuracy rate for
fiction, 97–100 percent for nonfiction). In this way, you modify tasks while still allowing
students to participate in the same activity as their peers. These modifications maintain students’
Flexible Grouping
Flexible grouping is a term that covers a range of grouping students for delivering
instruction, such as whole class, small group, and partner. How and when to group students is a
information and considering learner profiles. To promote maximum learning, the teacher should
ensure that assessment is frequent, that high-quality instruction is always provided, and that the
students are frequently moved into appropriate instructional groups according to their needs. In
order to differentiate instruction, teachers can group students who do not understand a concept or
skill and find time to reteach the concept or skill in a different way, providing additional practice.
At the same time, those students might be participating with a more heterogeneous mix of
students in other classroom activities. In another setting, teachers may learn that a number of
students in a grade who have mastered the standards for that grade, and are ready to go on to the
standards for the next grade, benefit by being grouped together for as long as the grouping meets
There are a number of instructional benefits to flexible grouping. Teachers use this
strategy because it’s a great way to meet the academic, social, and emotional needs of each
DIFFERENTIATED INSTRUCTIONAL STRATEGIES 11
student, and it allows the teacher to zero in on any specific needs of one student. It allows
students to have the opportunity to work with, and learn from, their peers in a way that lets them
feel comfortable contributing. When students work in a variety of groups, they learn to work
Flexible grouping means a lot of preplanning. Teachers need to look at assessment data,
test results, student needs, and abilities in order to determine the group size. It’s essential when
grouping students to not place them in the same group for every activity. The key to successful
grouping is to be flexible so you can meet each individual’s needs. Here are a few things to
Ask yourself, “What is the best type of configuration to meet my learning outcome for
pairs).
Evaluate all assessment data and look over student-leaning profiles to help you form
groups.
Identify the most effective grouping design. For example, group students by gender,
Flexible grouping is a strategy that is developed over a period of time. To ensure successful
grouping and promote maximum learning, it is essential that assessment is frequent, and that
students are moved into appropriate groups regularly. To avoid any classroom chaos and
Homogeneous/Ability/Cluster Grouping
Based on some type of pre-assessment such as prior school performance, teacher observation,
Heterogeneous Grouping
Those who have learned the material can mentor those who have not. (Use sparingly!)
Teaches independent learning, organizational skills, time management and the development of
individual responsibility.
Pairs/Partners
Choice Boards
Choice boards have become extremely popular with students because they are given the
option to choose how they will learn a concept. Teachers love this technique because choice
boards keep students more engaged. These boards—in large part because they are given free
choice—also seem to let students challenge themselves more. Furthermore, choice boards give
teachers the opportunity to tap into their students’ interests, find out how they like to learn, and
Choice boards are activities or assignments that give students the option of choosing what
they will do to meet the teacher’s requirements. As a general rule, these boards outline a variety
of instructional options that are targeted towards a specific academic goal. The teacher directs
the choice board, but the students are given control over their choices and may select the
Choice Boards provide students with the power to choose “how” to learn a particular
subject or concept. This freedom encourages them to be more responsible, accountable and
independent in their learning. It also allows them to work on the activities at their own pace. The
boards are useful for teachers as it enables them to identify and use student interests and
learning style, student interest, readiness, learning preference, or even questioning. As a tip, it’s
DIFFERENTIATED INSTRUCTIONAL STRATEGIES 14
best to focus on just one of these types when creating your board. As far as appearance is
concerned, a choice board is essentially a graphic organizer that mimics a game of tic-tac-toe—a
nine-square grid with activity choices in each row. Students should complete one activity from
each row, depending on their interest. Much like the tic-tac-toe game, the goal here is to select
adjacent or diagonal tasks to complete. Each exercise should vary in content, product, and
Here are ways to adapt choice board activities to better support students in your
classroom:
Allow students to choose which three activities they want to complete even if they do not
Work with students to determine specific tasks based on their abilities and learning needs.
Design different choice boards based on learning style (e.g., visual, kinesthetic, and
auditory learners each get their own boards, or one choice board can include three tasks
from each category) or type of student population (e.g., English Language Learners,
Create choice boards based on the three learning domains (cognitive, affective, and
Add additional spaces to your choice board to increase the number of opportunities
students have to demonstrate their learning and practice skills (Using Choice Boards..).
To introduce students to choice boards, start small with just three or six boxes and expand it
slowly throughout the year. Be sure to teach students the routine, then practice and provide
Formal assessments (summative assessments) have data which support the conclusions
made from the test. We usually refer to these types of tests as standardized. These tests have
been tried before on students and have statistics which support the conclusion such as the student
is reading below average for his age. The data is mathematically computed and summarized.
Scores such as percentiles, stanines, or standard scores are mostly commonly given from this
type of assessment.
Informal assessments (formative assessments) are not data driven but rather content and
performance driven. For example, running records are informal assessments because they
indicate how well a student is reading a specific book. Scores such as 10 correct out of 15,
percent of words read correctly, and most rubric scores are given from this type of assessment.
The assessment used needs to match the purpose of assessing. Formal or standardized
measures should be used to assess overall achievement, to compare a student's performance with
others at their age or grade, or to identify comparable strengths and weaknesses with peers.
according to these objectives, and then assessing these performance objectives. Moreover, for
any objectives not attained, intervention activities to re-teach these objectives are necessary
(Weaver, 2017).
DIFFERENTIATED INSTRUCTIONAL STRATEGIES 16
Summative Assessments are given periodically to determine at a particular point in time what
students know and do not know. Many associate summative assessments only with standardized
tests such as state assessments, but they are also used at and are an important part of district and
Although there are many types of summative assessments, the most common examples
include:
State-mandated assessments.
Scores that are used for accountability for schools (AYP) and students (report card
grades).
time, student learning relative to content standards. Although the information that is gleaned
from this type of assessment is important, it can only help in evaluating certain aspects of the
learning process. Because they are spread out and occur after instruction every few weeks,
months, or once a year, summative assessments are tools to help evaluate the effectiveness of
programs. Summative assessments happen too far down the learning path to provide information
at the classroom level and to make instructional adjustments and interventions during the
learning process.
DIFFERENTIATED INSTRUCTIONAL STRATEGIES 17
classroom practice, it provides the information needed to adjust teaching and learning while they
are happening. In this sense, formative assessment informs both teachers and students about
student understanding at a point when timely adjustments can be made. These adjustments help
to ensure students achieve, targeted standards-based learning goals within a set time frame.
Formative assessment helps teachers determine next steps during the learning process as the
as assessors of their own learning and as resources to other students. There are numerous
strategies teachers can implement to engage students. In fact, research shows that the
involvement in and ownership of their work increases students' motivation to learn (Garrison &
Ehringhaus, 2016).
Most formative assessment strategies are quick and easy to use and fit seamlessly into the
instruction process. The information gathered is never marked or graded. Descriptive feedback
may accompany a formative assessment to let students know whether they have mastered an
Deciding on what type of formative assessment strategy to use will depend on a number of
factors. Teachers need to determine what aspect of student learning they want to measure. They
then need to consider the learning preferences of their students. Formative assessment strategies
can be given to students individually, as partners, in small groups, or as a class. The type of
grouping used for the formative assessment will also influence the choice of strategy. Teachers
DIFFERENTIATED INSTRUCTIONAL STRATEGIES 19
should not rely on one type of assessment strategy. A variety of individual and group formative
assessment strategies should be used. Individual strategies allow teachers to get a clear picture of
each student and their understanding of the concept or skill being measured. Group strategies
provide teachers with general information about student learning that can be used to plan
instruction. Students can also use formative assessment information to make changes to their
Test scores in reading continue to fall below average on state testing even with changes
made to teachers and curriculum. Teachers know they should differentiate instruction in order to
meet each student’s needs but they are not confident in how they should differentiate effectively.
After presenting these strategies to teachers and helping them implement them in the classroom,
I feel that the teachers will become more confident which will strengthen their instruction
practices which will increase student achievement. After learning the differences between
formative and summative assessments and being given examples of both, teachers will have
concrete information to guide them in their classrooms. I will continue to work with the teachers
and model how to use the various forms of assessments to guide instruction and intervention
practices. Students will become more actively engaged in the learning process which will also
Annotated Bibliography
Access Center. (2004). Differentiated Instruction for Reading. Washington D.C.: Author.
This article provides a thorough explanation of what differentiation is, how it is implemented in
the classroom, and strategies that can be used in the classroom during reading instruction. It
would be very informative to a beginning teacher who needs a quick overview of what
Coil, C. (2005). Teaching Tools for the 21st Century – Third Revised & Expanded Ed. Saline,
This article describes the various types of flexible groupings. It gives descriptions for the
http://www.teachhub.com/classroom-management-differentiated-instruction-menus
Cox explains how choice boards are used to differentiate instruction. She gives step-by-step
instructions on how to set up the choice board system in the classroom. She also provides
examples of activities for multiple intelligences, reading, and science to place on the choice
boards.
http://www.teachhub.com/differentiated-instruction-strategies-using-tiered-assignments
Cox explains how differentiated instructional strategies are used in a classroom to reach all
students based on their individual needs. She focuses on how to use tiered assignments in
reading to help students. She discusses the six ways you can structure tiered assignments:
http://www.teachhub.com/differentiated-instruction-strategies-using-learning-stations
Cox discusses how to use interest groups or learning stations in the classroom to differentiate
instruction. She focuses on the differences between traditional centers and interest centers that
http://www.teachhub.com/flexible-grouping-differentiated-instruction-strategy
Cox explains what flexible grouping is and how it is unlike other differentiated instructional
strategies. She discusses the benefits of flexible grouping and how to create groups based on
data and student needs. She gives tips on how to create groups and rules to guide the activities in
the groups.
http://www.teachhub.com/top-ways-implement-differentiated-instruction-strategies
Cox explained the meaning of differentiated instruction and provided various strategies for
teachers to use in their classrooms. Some strategies that were discussed were: flexible grouping,
learning centers, independent study, tiered assignments, adjusting questions, and choice
activities.
http://k12teacherstaffdevelopment.com/tlb/how-to-use-choice-boards-in-the-classroom/
This article explains why you should use choice boards in your classroom, the benefits of using
choice boards, and how to set up a choice boards system. It also explains how to differentiate
http://exclusive.multibriefs.com/content/using-choice-to-motivate-and-
differentiate/education
Flakes describes how choice is one of the biggest motivators in setting up a differentiated
classroom. She explains how giving students choices in their learning creates an environment
where students want to learn. She provides links to examples of choice boards and gives an
illustration of how to provide students with multiple ways to demonstrate their mastery of
groupings.html
This article has lots of information on flexible groupings. It describes what flexible groups are,
the background of using flexible groups, and how flexible groups are currently being used in
classrooms. It explains the benefits of flexible grouping and provides additional resources on
flexible grouping.
content/uploads/2014/11/Formative-and-Summative-Assessments.pdf
This article defined formative and summative assessments. It then explained the teacher’s and
student’s role in each. It provided examples of both to show how they were used in the
classroom.
Garrison, C. & Ehringhaus, M. (2016). Formative and summative assessments in the classroom.
ArtMID/888/ArticleID/286/Formative-and-Summative-Assessments-in-the
Classroom.aspx
DIFFERENTIATED INSTRUCTIONAL STRATEGIES 23
Garrison and Ehringhaus defined informal and formal assessments and how both are used in the
classrooms by teachers. They explained the purposes of both and gave examples of each. They
provided references and resources to teachers for further information on how to use informal and
Heacox, D. (2002). Differentiating instruction in the regular classroom. Minneapolis, MN: Free
Heacox provides specific activities for each way you are able to structure tiered assignments.
She also provides additional resources on using tiered assignments and websites for teachers to
http://www.stma.k12.mn.us/documents/DW/Q_Comp/FormativeAssessStrategies.pdf
Reiger begins by explaining how assessment fits into instruction. She then focuses on the use of
formative assessments and how to determine which assessment to use based on what is being
assessed by the teacher. She also discusses how both teachers and students can use the
strategies and an explanation of how to use each in the classroom. She also provides additional
teachers/articles/teaching-content/how-does-differentiation-work-literacy-centers/
Southall explains the difference between traditional centers and learning centers. She also
discusses the three core literacy centers that can be used to develop skills in key literacy areas:
comprehension, fluency, and word study. She also explains how differentiated centers support
Tomlinson explains what differentiated instruction is and its relationship with standards based
teaching. She provides positive and negative examples of how standards based teaching and
differentiated instruction were applied in classrooms and school districts. She also provides
guiding questions that help ensure that grading practices are productive for all students.
https://www.advancementcourses.com/blog/choice-boards
This article explains how to set up choice boards in your classroom and how to make adaptations
to them based on individual student needs. It also provides links to examples of ELA, History,
https://www.scholastic.com/teachers/articles/teaching-content/formal-vs-informal-
assessments/
Weaver explained what formal and informal assessments are and then explained how they differ
from one another. She discussed the purpose of using each and how the scores of each should be
portland.edu/blog/teaching-strategies/examples-of-differentiated-instruction/
Weselby explained the definition and history of differentiated instruction. She described ways to
differentiate instruction in the classroom. She gave examples of how to differentiate instruction
based on content, process, product, and learning environment. She also described the pros and
DIFFERENTIATED INSTRUCTIONAL STRATEGIES 25
cons of using differentiated instruction in the classroom. A link to related resources was also
profdev/articles/valentino.html
Valentino explains the concept behind flexible grouping and how teachers can apply the strategy
in their classrooms to address deficits in learning. She discusses the various ways that students
can be grouped together and the differences between teacher-led groups and student-led groups.