JWARP 2013032815532811-Yang
JWARP 2013032815532811-Yang
JWARP 2013032815532811-Yang
Received December 18, 2012; revised January 22, 2013; accepted January 31, 2013
ABSTRACT
Water use and access become a more and more important determinant of environmental equity and human development
according to the view held by the UN [1]. Water scarcity is one of the major crises which has overarching implications
for other world problems especially poverty, hunger, ecosystem degradation, desertification, climate change, threaten-
ing world peace and security [2]. In the decades to come, freshwater consumed by human will get to a tipping point.
Many projects and concepts have been proposed and implemented for several years to improve the effectiveness of us-
ing water. These research activities can be grouped as: desalination plants; water detention (like rainwater tanks for col-
lection and reuse); wastewater reuse; dams and reservoirs. This paper summarized the characters of these water solu-
tions. But these methods can’t provide enough fresh water due to limitations imposed by these methods as well as fol-
lowing industry and population’s development. To overcome these shortcomings, coastal reservoir strategy is proposed
in the paper. This new strategy is technically feasible, environmentally sustainable and cost effective by demonstration
and comparison.
annually. In Australia, inland reservoirs were subjected pend on local rainfall or local water quality. But this wa-
to very high siltation rates which are comparable to ter source would have very high construction costs. For
overseas [8]. In the future, soil erosion and reservoir instance, the government of Queensland in Australia has
sedimentation rates would be accelerated due to the se- considered diverting water supplies from North Eastern
verity of storms and rains as a result of global warming NSW, but this was found to be not economically viable.
[1]. This means that almost all existing inland reservoirs There were also numerous social, environmental and
may lose much of its capacity in about 100 years. There- interstate issues that were considered to be insurmount-
fore, the other water source options should be consid- able. Water could potentially be diverted from Northern
ered. Queensland. However, this would involve very high con-
The first desalination plant by the multi-stage flash struction costs and should only be considered if no alter-
(MSF) evaporation process installed in 1964 in Linarite native water sources are available locally. Another ex-
(Canary Islands), over 700 desalination plants exist ample, The South-North Water Transfer Project (SNWTP),
nowadays [9]. Desalination technologies account for a which is a multi-decade infrastructure project of the Peo-
worldwide production capacity of 24.5 million m3/day ple’s Republic of China to utilize water resources avail-
[10], the cost decreased to $0.50 - 0.80/m3 desalinated able, diverts 44.8 billion cubic meters/year of water from
water and even to $0.20 - 0.35/m3 for treatment of brack- South to North. The cost of the project is over 500 billion,
ish water [11]. However, they have potential negative which causes many experts to question if the project is
impacts [12]. These are mainly attributed to the concen- optimal [15,16].
trate and chemical discharges, which may impair coastal Reuse of wastewater does not depend directly on rain-
water quality and affect marine life, and air pollutant fall. But the level of contaminants is higher than other
emissions are attributed to the energy demand of the water supply options except seawater. Therefore, the
processes. A key concern of desalination plants is the operating cost of the treatment process would be higher.
concentrate and chemical discharges to the marine envi- It is a common practice to discharge untreated sewage
ronment, which may have adverse effects on water and directly into bodies of water or put onto agricultural land,
sediment quality, impair marine life and the functioning causing significant health and economic risks [17]. There
and intactness of coastal ecosystems [12]. WHO (World could also be public perception problems with the reuse
Health Organization) provided a general overview on the of wastewater.
composition and effects of the waste discharges in their Stormwater harvesting is used in house yards, streets
guidance document. Lattemann [12] and MEDRC [13] and parks in some countries like Australia, but there are
discussed details of the negative impacts. Reverse osmo- several shortages. Goonrey analysed the technical feasi-
sis (RO), a commonly used desalination technology, is bility of using stormwater as an alternative supply source
significantly more expensive than the standard treatment in an existing urban area [18], the shortcomings are:
of dam water for potable use. Furthermore, desalination firstly, its storage capacity is very small due to the struc-
technologies have the risk of oil pollution, as oil films tural constraints; then its water quality may be not very
can cause serious damage inside a desalination plant and good as the water comes from densely populated areas,
oil contaminants may impact the product water quality. and its cost is also very high as precious land is used to
Desalination also causes noise pollution. Most of the store the storm water.
noise is produced by the high-pressure pumps and the Now the current water solutions can’t satisfy people’s
turbines [14]. Desalination of seawater does not rely on increasing need for water. Commonly for one area, there
rainfall (it is a climate resilient water source). Desalina- is too much rain in the wet season which causes flood
tion plants are located on the coast, and as mentioned and excess rainwater discharge into the sea, but in dry
earlier this is where the majority of the water demand is season, there is not much rain, which causes water
expected to be located. But the treatment process would shortage. According to statistics, there is only about 1/6
have high energy requirements as well as high operating
of the runoff used by human in the world and about half
and maintenance costs because of the high concentrations
of all available fresh water on the earth runs into the sea
of contaminants that would have to be removed. The
from coastlines where the fresh water mixes with saltwa-
concentrate stream produced by the desalination process
ter. Therefore, the issue is not lack of water, but it is lack
can have detrimental environmental impacts. This could
of how to make use of the water. Coastal reservoir [19]
be a significant problem if the desalination plants were
was proposed to solve this problem.
located on the coast, because the discharge would be
released into a place, which is maybe a very sensitive
marine environment. Therefore, other water supply op-
3. Coastal Reservoir
tions need to be developed. Coastal reservoir is a freshwater reservoir in the seawater
Diversion of water from a remote source does not de- near a river mouth to capture the sustainable river flow
Name Catchment (km2) Dam length (m) Capacity (million m3) Year (completed) Country
Qingcaosha 66.26 48786 435 2011 China/Yangtze
Saemanguem 33900 530 2010 South Korea
Sihwa 56.5 12400 323 1994 South Korea
Marina Barrage 350 42.5 2008 Singapore
Chenhang 1.4 9.14 1992 China/Shanghai
Yuhuan 166 1080 64.1 1998 China/Zhejiang
Baogang 12 1985 China/Shanghai
Plover Cove 45.9 2000 230 1968 Hong Kong
West Sea Barrage 8000 1986 North Korea
Table 2. Cost comparison between coastal reservoirs and by the University of Wollongong, Australia. The works
other water solutions. are also supported, in part, by the research projects
Construction cost per Cost per kilolitre “Sediment Transport Processes and Mechanism of Beach
kilolitre of water (US$) of water (US$) Profile Evolution under Global Climate Change”
Coastal reservoirs 2.67 - 6.01 0.15 - 0.25 (51239001) and “Investigation on Formation Mechanism
Inland reservoirs 5.83 - 7.5 0.34 - 0.4 of Secondary Currents and Its Roles for Mass and Mo-
Desalination 6.41 - 10.08 0.43 - 1.13 mentum Transfer” (51228901) funded by National Natu-
Water recycling 5.57 - 8.30 1.44 - 1.53 ral Science Foundation of China.