Gaboya v. Cui - Usufruct

(/)
LIBRARY
GABOYA V. CUI- USUFRUCT

Comprehensive Legal Library
LAW FIRM (/)

Excellence is our Standard
☰
BATASnatin LIVE! Free legal advice every Wednesday and Friday at 6pm.
Category: Property, Ownership and Its Modifications (/law-library/civil-law/property.html)
THE BAR
Annual Exam Archive
FORMS
Free Legal Forms
FREE LEGAL ADVICE

BATASnatin Forum
JURISPRUDENCE
Supreme Court Cases
LEGAL E-CONSULTATION
Private Consultation
GABOYA V. CUI- Usufruct
FACTS:
Don Mariano sold his 2 lots to two of his children. Later on, he and his children became co-owners of the
property. Don Mariano executed a deed authorizing the children to apply for a loan w/ mortgage with a
stipulation reserving his right to the fruits of the land. The children then constructed a building on the
land and collected rent from the lessee thereof. Much later, when Don Mariano died, his estate was
claiming the fruits of the building.
ISSUE:
Whether or not Don Mariano had a right to fruits of the building?
RULING: NO.
The deed expressly reserved only to his right to the fruits of the land. He only owned the rent for the
(/) only claim the rent on that piece of land
portion of land occupied by the building; thus, the estate could
and not on the entire parcel of land. The children are entitled to the rents of the building. (A usufruct on
the land may be separate from the building.
LIBRARY
There Legal
Comprehensive should
Librarybe no rescission of the contract coz the exact amount of rent due and owing to the Don
Mariano’s estate is still unliquidated and undetermined. The trial court has the discretion to grant the
LAW FIRM (/)
debtor
Excellence (children) a period within which to pay the rental income from the portion of land owned by the
is our Standard
☰
building because
BATASnatin theadvice
LIVE! Free legal same has
every not yet
Wednesday beenat determined.
and Friday 6pm. Article 1191 of the Civil Code grants the right to
THE BAR
rescind but subject to the period that the court will grant.
Annual Exam Archive
FORMS
Moreover, on the issue of co-ownership, the court held that a co-owner cannot simultaneously be a
Free Legal Forms
usufructuary of the same land owned.
FREE LEGAL ADVICE
BATASnatin Forum
JURISPRUDENCE Are You Ready for Talk?

Supreme Court Cases
Ad datemyage.com
Rules on Security
Deposit
batasnatin.com
 Prev (/law-library/civil-law/property/1931-vda-de-albar-v-carandang-106-phil-855-usufruct.html)
Next  (/law-library/civil-law/property/1860-chua-kai-v-kapunan-104-phil-110-possession-of-chattels.html)
MARIATEGUI V. CA 205 SCRA 337- Co-ownership (/law-library/civil-law/jurisprudence/1206-mariategui-v-ca-205-scra-337-co-

ownership.html)
MARIANO V. CA 222 SCRA 736 (/law-library/civil-law/jurisprudence/1202-mariano-v-ca-222-scra-736.html)
ADILLE V. CA 157 SCRA 455- Co-ownership (/law-library/civil-law/persons-and-family/1205-adille-v-ca-157-scra-455-co-
ownership.html)
DELIMA V. CA 201 SCRA 641- Co-ownership (/law-library/civil-law/property/1204-delima-v-ca-201-scra-641-co-
ownership.html)
PALMITUAN V. CA 215 SCRA 866 (/law-library/civil-law/property/1199-palmituan-v-ca-215-scra-866.html)
SI V. CA 342 SCRA 653 (/law-library/civil-law/property/1197-si-v-ca-342-scra-653.html)
CONDOMINIUM ACT (/law-library/civil-law/property/1196-condominium-act.html)
CO-OWNERSHIP (/law-library/civil-law/property/1195-co-ownership.html)
CAISIP V. PEOPLE 36 SCRA 17 (/law-library/civil-law/property/1145-caisip-v-people-36-scra-17.html)
CO-OWNERSHIP- Action Reinvindicatoria (/law-library/civil-law/property/283-co-ownership-action-reinvindicatoria.html)
MORE ABOUT THIS TOPIC: (/)
MARIATEGUI V. CA 205 SCRA 337- Co-ownership (/law-library/civil-law/jurisprudence/1206-

mariategui-v-ca-205-scra-337-co-ownership.html)
MARIANO V. CA 222 SCRA 736 (/law-library/civil-law/jurisprudence/1202-mariano-v-ca-222-scra-
LIBRARY 736.html)
ADILLE V. CA 157 SCRA 455- Co-ownership (/law-library/civil-law/persons-and-family/1205-adille-
v-ca-157-scra-455-co-ownership.html)
LAW FIRM (/)
DELIMA V. CA 201 SCRA 641- Co-ownership (/law-library/civil-law/property/1204-delima-v-ca-201-
☰
scra-641-co-ownership.html)
PALMITUAN V. CA 215 SCRA 866 (/law-library/civil-law/property/1199-palmituan-v-ca-215-scra-
THE BAR
866.html)
Annual Exam Archive
SI V. CA 342 SCRA 653 (/law-library/civil-law/property/1197-si-v-ca-342-scra-653.html)
FORMS CONDOMINIUM ACT (/law-library/civil-law/property/1196-condominium-act.html)
Free Legal FormsCO-OWNERSHIP (/law-library/civil-law/property/1195-co-ownership.html)
CAISIP V. PEOPLE 36 SCRA 17 (/law-library/civil-law/property/1145-caisip-v-people-36-scra-
FREE LEGAL17.html)
ADVICE
BATASnatin ForumCO-OWNERSHIP- Action Reinvindicatoria (/law-library/civil-law/property/283-co-ownership-
action-reinvindicatoria.html)
JURISPRUDENCE
Supreme Court Cases
(https://www.batasnatin.com/7-news/2497-batasnatin-live-1.html)
The Next LIVE Free Legal Advice Episode
Episode 7: October 12, 2018

at 6:00 pm
Facebook Event (https://web.facebook.com/events/828532614203496/?event_time_id=844799749243449) | YouTube Channel
(https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCVyNJy0q_Q2XB873gEkmgjQ)
Season One
Episode 1: August 31, 2018

Facebook Video (https://web.facebook.com/BATASnatin/videos/261581844465850/) | YouTube Video
(https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Kmosry08haM)
Episode 2: September 7, 2018

Facebook Video (https://www.facebook.com/BATASnatin/videos/1061442454024488/) | YouTube Video
(https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WxlwYkg7lHo)

Facebook Video (https://www.facebook.com/BATASnatin/videos/1761618313887550/) | YouTube Video
(https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pSZBUD5VXDc)
(/)

(https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pPtmb-Bedtg)
LIBRARY
(https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=m7F8E_RO30U)
LAW FIRM (/)
ExcellenceEpisode
is our Standard
☰
6: October 5, 2018
Facebook
BATASnatin LIVE! Free Video
legal advice (https://web.facebook.com/BATASnatin/videos/283022252313866/)
every Wednesday and Friday at 6pm. | YouTube Video
THE BAR
(https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2-0m6Jco298)
Annual Exam Archive
FORMS
Free Legal Forms
FREE LEGAL ADVICE

BATASnatin Forum
JURISPRUDENCE
Supreme Court Cases
(http://www.firm.batasnatin.com/free-legal-advice/index.html)
(/)
LIBRARY
LAW FIRM (/)

☰
THE BAR
Annual Exam Archive
FORMS
Free Legal Forms
FREE LEGAL ADVICE

BATASnatin Forum
JURISPRUDENCE
Supreme Court Cases
(http://www.firm.batasnatin.com/practice-areas/pro-bono-legal-services-for-laborers-no-really-its-
free.html)
BATASnatin Legal Services (https://firm.batasnatin.com)

"Excellence is our Standard"
Mobile Globe: +63 (915) 954-6080

Mobile Smart: +63 (949) 589-8377
Landline: (632) 359-4203
Email: batasnatin@gmail.com (mailto:batasnatin@gmail.com)
2nd Floor LC Building,

31 Gen. Luna St., Tuktukan
1632 Taguig City, Philippines
Civil Law
Collection of Debts
Unlawful Detainer
Forcible Entry
Recovery of Real or Personal Property, Damages, etc...
Labor Standards and Relations Law

Labor Standards and Relations Law
Illegal Termination (/)

Constructive Dismissal
Non-payment / Underpayment of Salaries and Benefits
Others...
LIBRARY
Criminal Law
All crimes as defense lawyer or private prosecutor.
LAW FIRM
Corporation
(/) Law
☰
Creation of Corporate Bodies
Litigation of Corporate Courts
THE BAR
Others
Annual Exam Archive
Environmental Law
FORMS
WritForms
Free Legal of Kalikasan
Protection of the Environment and Natural Resources
FREE Land
LEGALTitles
ADVICEand Deeds
BATASnatin Forum
JURISPRUDENCE
Election Law
Supreme Court Cases
Alternative Dispute Resolution
Socials
(https://www.facebook.com/BATASnatin)
(https://goo.gl/maps/jFzGyeNaUvx)
(https://twitter.com/batasnatin)
Terms and Conditions (https://batasnatin.com/terms.html) Privacy Policy (https://batasnatin.com/privacy.html)
© 2018 Philippine Laws Library | BATASnatin - Filipino's Comprehensive Online Law Resource and Community Back to Top

Gaboya v. Cui - Usufruct

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

Gaboya v. Cui - Usufruct

Uploaded by

Document Information

Original Description:

Original Title

Copyright

Available Formats

Share this document

Share or Embed Document

Sharing Options

Did you find this document useful?

Is this content inappropriate?

Copyright:

Available Formats

Gaboya v. Cui - Usufruct

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

(/)

GABOYA V. CUI- USUFRUCT

LAW FIRM (/)

FREE LEGAL ADVICE

GABOYA V. CUI- Usufruct

JURISPRUDENCE Are You Ready for Talk?

MARIATEGUI V. CA 205 SCRA 337- Co-ownership (/law-library/civil-law/jurisprudence/1206-mariategui-v-ca-205-scra-337-co-

MARIATEGUI V. CA 205 SCRA 337- Co-ownership (/law-library/civil-law/jurisprudence/1206-

Episode 7: October 12, 2018

Episode 1: August 31, 2018

Episode 2: September 7, 2018

Episode 3: September 13, 2018

Episode 4: September 21, 2018

FREE LEGAL ADVICE

LAW FIRM (/)

FREE LEGAL ADVICE

BATASnatin Legal Services (https://firm.batasnatin.com)

Mobile Globe: +63 (915) 954-6080

Email: batasnatin@gmail.com (mailto:batasnatin@gmail.com)

2nd Floor LC Building,

Labor Standards and Relations Law

Illegal Termination (/)

Terms and Conditions (https://batasnatin.com/terms.html) Privacy Policy (https://batasnatin.com/privacy.html)

You might also like