Risk and Returns
Risk and Returns
Risk and Returns
The Required Rate of Return: The required rate of return is the nominal rate of return that an investor
needs in order to make an investment worthwhile.
Real risk-free rate of return: The real risk-free rate of return (Rf) is the minimum return an investor
requires. This rate does not take into account expected inflation and the capital market environment.
Answer:
Rf = (1 + 0.08) - 1 = 4.85%
(1 + 0.03)
Answer:
Rnominal = (1 + 0.03) x (1 + 0.03) - 1 = 6.09%
In an investment setting, an investor sets his required rate of return as the base return he requires from an
investment. However, given the usual uncertainty in the market, it is difficult to meet that required rate of
return exactly. As such, an investor would set his return above his required rate of return to diminish the
risk that his required rate of return will not be met. The excess return above the investor's required rate of
return is known as the risk premium. The fundamental sources of risk that contribute to the need of the
risk premium, such as:
1. Business risk
2. Financial risk
3. Liquidity risk
4. Exchange rate risk
5. Political risk.
These risks comprise systematic risk, and cannot be avoided through diversification since they affect the
entire market.
1. Business Risk: Business risk is the risk that a business' cash flow will not meet its needs due to
uncertainty in the company's business lines.
2. Financial Risk: Financial risk is the risk to equity holders as a company increases its debt load.
As debt load increases, interest expense also increases, leading to less income to be paid out to
investors.
3. Liquidity Risk: Liquidity risk is the uncertainty around the ability to sell an investment. The more
liquid an investment is the easier it is to sell.
4. Exchange-Rate Risk: Exchange-rate risk is the risk a company faces when it has businesses in
other countries. When a company is in the business of producing or buying products in a country
other than its own, a company can face exchange-rate risk when in the process when it needs to
exchange currency to transact business as a part of its normal business routine.
5. Political Risk: Political risk is the risk of changes in the political environment of a country in
which company transacts its businesses. This risk could be caused by changes in laws relating to
a specific business or even more serious as a country revolution that would cause disruption in a
company's operations.
The security market line (SML) is the line that reflects an investment's risk versus its return, or the return
on a given investment in relation to risk. The measure of risk used for the security market line is beta.
The line begins with the risk-free rate (with zero risk) and moves upward and to the right. As the risk of
an investment increases, it is expected that the return on an investment would increase. An investor with
a low risk profile would choose an investment at the beginning of the security market line. An investor
with a higher risk profile would thus choose an investment higher along the security market line.
Given the SML reflects the return on a given investment in relation to risk, a change in the slope of the
SML could be caused by the risk premium of the investments. Recall that the risk premium of an
investment is the excess return required by an investor to help ensure a required rate of return is met. If
the risk premium required by investors was to change, the slope of the SML would change as well.
When a shift in the SML occurs, a change that affects all investments' risk versus return profile has
occurred. A shift of the SML can occur with changes in the following:
1. Expected real growth in the economy.
2. Capital market conditions.
3. Expected inflation rate.
The portfolio management process is the process an investor takes to aid him in meeting his investment
goals.
Policy Statement
A policy statement is the statement that contains the investor's goals and constraints as it relates to his
investments. This could be considered to be the most important of all the steps in the portfolio management
process. The statement requires the investor to consider his true financial needs, both in the short run and
the long run. It helps to guide the investment portfolio manager in meeting the investor's needs. When
there is market uncertainty or the investor's needs change, the policy statement will help to guide the
investor in making the necessary adjustments the portfolio in a disciplined manner.
Investment Constraints
When creating a policy statement, it is important to consider an investor's constraints. There are five types
of constraints that need to be considered when creating a policy statement. They are as follows:
1. Liquidity Constraints - Liquidity constraints identify an investor's need for liquidity, or cash. For
example, within the next year, an investor needs $50,000 for the purchase of a new home. The
$50,000 would be considered a liquidity constraint because it needs to be set aside (be liquid) for
the investor.
2. Time Horizon - A time horizon constraint develops a timeline of an investor's various financial
needs. The time horizon also affects an investor's ability to accept risk. If an investor has a long
time horizon, the investor may have a greater ability to accept risk because he would have a longer
time period to recoup any losses. This is unlike an investor with a shorter time horizon whose
ability to accept risk may be lower because he would not have the ability to recoup any losses.
3. Tax Concerns - After-tax returns are the returns investors are focused on when creating an
investment portfolio. If an investor is currently in a high tax bracket as a result of his income, it
may be important to focus on investments that would not make the investor's situation worse, like
investing more heavily in tax-deferred investments.
4. Legal and Regulatory - Legal and regulatory factors can act as an investment constraint and must
be considered. An example of this would occur in a trust. A trust could require that no more than
10% of the trust be distributed each year. Legal and regulatory constraints such as this one often
can't be changed and must not be overlooked.
5. Unique Circumstances - Any special needs or constraints not recognized in any of the constraints
listed above would fall in this category. An example of a unique circumstance would be the
constraint an investor might place on investing in any company that is not socially responsible,
such as a tobacco company.
The ideal asset allocation differs based on the risk tolerance of the investor. For example, a young
executive might have an asset allocation of 80% equity, 20% fixed income, while a retiree would be more
likely to have 80% in fixed income and 20% equities.
Citizens in other countries around the world would have different asset allocation strategies depending on
the types and risks of securities available for placement in their portfolio. For example, a retiree located
in the United States would most likely have a large portion of his portfolio allocated to U.S. treasuries,
since the U.S. Government is considered to have an extremely low risk of default. On the other hand, a
retiree in a country with political unrest would most likely have a large portion of their portfolio allocated
to foreign treasury securities, such as that of the U.S.
Risk Aversion
Risk aversion is an investor's general desire to avoid participation in "risky" behavior or, in this case, risky
investments. Investors typically wish to maximize their return with the least amount of risk possible. When
faced with two investment opportunities with similar returns, good investor will always choose the
investment with the least risk as there is no benefit to choosing a higher level of risk unless there is also
an increased level of return.
Insurance is a great example of investors' risk aversion. Given the potential for a car accident, an investor
would rather pay for insurance and minimize the risk of a huge outlay in the event of an accident.
Risk of a portfolio is affected by the risk of each investment in the portfolio relative to its
return, as well as each investment's correlation with the other investments in the portfolio.
A portfolio is considered efficient if it gives the investor a higher expected return with the same or lower
level of risk as compared to another investment. The efficient frontier is simply a plot of those efficient
portfolios, as illustrated below:
Efficient Frontier
While an efficient frontier illustrates each of the efficient portfolios relative to risk and return levels, each
of the efficient portfolios may not be appropriate for every investor. Recall that when creating an
investment policy, return and risk were the key objectives. An investor's risk profile is illustrated with
indifference curves. The optimal portfolio, then, is the point on the efficient frontier that is tangential to
the investor's highest indifference curve.
The optimal portfolio for a risk-averse investor will not be as risky as the optimal portfolio of
an investor who is willing to accept more risk.
Individual Investment: The expected return for an individual investment is simply the sum of the
probabilities of the possible expected returns for the investment.
Example:
For Newco's stock, assume the following potential returns.
Given the above assumptions, determine the expected return for Newco's stock.
Answer:
E(R) = (0.10)(10%) + (0.80)(14%) + (0.10)(18%)
E(R) = 14.0%
Portfolio
To determine the expected return on a portfolio, the weighted average expected return of the assets that
comprise the portfolio is taken.
Answer:
E(R) = (0.30)(20%) + (0.70)(15%)
= 6% + 10.5% = 16.5%
The expected return of the portfolio is 16.5%
Variance =
Where: Pn = probability of occurrence
Rn = return in n occurrence
E(R) = expected return
Standard Deviation =
Answer:
σ2 = (0.10)(0.10 - 0.14)2 + (0.80)(0.14 - 0.14)2 + (0.10)(0.18 - 0.14)2
= 0.00032
Given that the standard deviation of Newco's stock is simply the square root of the variance, the standard
deviation is 0.0179 or 1.79%.
Covariance
The covariance is the measure of how two assets relate (move) together. If the covariance of the two assets
is positive, the assets move in the same direction. For example, if two assets have a covariance of 0.50,
then the assets move in the same direction. If however the two assets have a negative covariance, the assets
move in opposite directions. If the covariance of the two assets is zero, they have no relationship.
Covariancea,b=
Returns
N Ra Rb
1 10% 18%
2 15% 25%
3 5% 2%
4 13% 8%
5 8% 17%
Answer:
Correlation
The correlation coefficient is the relative measure of the relationship between two assets. It is between +1
and -1, with a +1 indicating that the two assets move completely together and a -1 indicating that the two
assets move in opposite directions from each other.
Example: Calculate the correlation of Asset A with Asset B.
Given our covariance of 18 in the example above, what is the correlation coefficient for Asset A relative
to Asset B if Asset A has a standard deviation of 4 and Asset B has a standard deviation of 8.
Answer:
Correlation coefficient = 18/(4)(8) = 0.563
The equation for the standard deviation for a two asset portfolio is as follows:
The capital market theory builds upon the Markowitz portfolio model. The main assumptions of the capital
market theory are as follows:
1. All Investors are Efficient Investors - Investors follow Markowitz idea of the efficient frontier
and choose to invest in portfolios along the frontier.
2. Investors Borrow/Lend Money at the Risk-Free Rate - This rate remains static for any amount of
money.
3. The Time Horizon is equal for All Investors - When choosing investments, investors have equal
time horizons for the chosen investments.
4. All Assets are Infinitely Divisible - This indicates that fractional shares can be purchased and the
stocks can be infinitely divisible.
5. No Taxes and Transaction Costs -assume that investors' results are not affected by taxes and
transaction costs.
6. All Investors Have the Same Probability for Outcomes -When determining the expected return,
assume that all investors have the same probability for outcomes.
7. No Inflation Exists - Returns are not affected by the inflation rate in a capital market as none
exists in capital market theory.
8. There is No Mispricing Within the Capital Markets - Assume the markets are efficient and that
no mispricings within the markets exist.
Answer:
The expected return of the new portfolio is: (0.9)(16%) + (0.1)(4%) = 14.4%
With the addition of the risk-free asset, the expected value of the investor's portfolio was decreased
to 14.4% from 16%.
Answer:
The standard deviation equation for a portfolio of two assets is rather long, however, given the
standard deviation of the risk-free asset is zero, the equation is simplified quite nicely. The standard
deviation of the two-asset portfolio with a risky asset is the weight of the risky assets in the
portfolio multiplied by the standard deviation of the portfolio.
Similar to the affect the risk-free asset had on the expected return, the risk-free asset also has the
affect of reducing standard deviation, risk, in the portfolio.
As seen previously, adjusting for the risk of an asset using the risk-free rate, an investor can easily alter
his risk profile. Keeping that in mind, in the context of the capital market line (CML), the market
portfolio consists of the combination of all risky assets and the risk-free asset, using market value of the
assets to determine the weights. The CML line is derived by the CAPM, solving for expected return at
various levels of risk.
Markowitz' idea of the efficient frontier, however, did not take into account the risk-free asset. The CML
does and, as such, the frontier is extended to the risk-free rate as illustrated below:
Unsystematic risk is the risk inherent to a stock. This risk is the aspect of total risk that can be diversified
away when building a portfolio.
When building a portfolio, a key concept is to gain the greatest return with the least amount of risk.
However, it is important to note, that additional return is not guaranteed for an increased level of risk.
With risk, reward can come, but losses can be magnified as well.
The capital asset pricing model is a model that calculates expected return based on expected rate of return
on the market, the risk-free rate and the beta coefficient of the stock.
E(R) = Rf + ß( Rmarket - Rf )
Answer:
E(R) = 4% + 1.2(12% - 4%) = 13.6%.
Using the capital asset pricing model, the expected return on Newco's stock is 13.6%.
Beta
Beta is the measure of a stock's sensitivity of returns to changes in the market. It is a measure of systematic
risk.
Beta = B = Covariance of stock to the market
Variance of the market
Example: Beta
Assume the covariance between Newco's stock and the market is 0.001 and the variance of the market is
0.0008. What is the beta of Newco's stock?
Answer:
BNewco = 0.001/0.0008 = 1.25
Newco's beta is 1.25.
Example: Calculate the expected return on a security and evaluate whether the security is undervalued,
overvalued or properly valued.
An investor anticipates Newco's security will reach $30 by the end of one year. Newco's beta is 1.3.
Assume the return on the market is expected to be 16% and the risk-free rate is 4%. Calculate the expected
return of Newco's stock in one year and determine whether the stock is undervalued, overvalued or
properly valued with a current value of $25.
Answer:
E(R)Newco = 4% + 1.3(16% - 4%) = 20%
Given the expected return of Newco's stock using CAPM is 20% and the investor anticipates a 20% return,
the security would be properly valued.
If the expected return using the CAPM is higher than the investor's required return, the
security is undervalued and the investor should buy it.
If the expected return using the CAPM is lower than the investor's required return, the
security is overvalued and should be sold.
SUPPLEMENTARY:
Covariance
Covariance is a measure of the relationship between two random variables, designed to show the degree
of co-movement between them. Covariance is calculated based on the probability-weighted average of the
cross-products of each random variable's deviation from its own expected value. A positive number
indicates co-movement (i.e. the variables tend to move in the same direction); a value of 0 indicates no
relationship, and a negative covariance shows that the variables move in the opposite direction.
Correlation
Correlation is a concept related to covariance, as it also gives an indication of the degree to which two
random variables are related, and (like covariance) the sign shows the direction of this relationship
(positive (+) means that the variables move together; negative (-) means they are inversely related).
Correlation of 0 means that there is no linear relationship one way or the other, and the two variables are
said to be unrelated.
A correlation number is much easier to interpret than covariance because a correlation value will always
be between -1 and +1.
-1 indicates a perfectly inverse relationship (a unit change in one means that the other will have a
unit change in the opposite direction)
+1 means a perfectly positive linear relationship (unit changes in one always bring the same unit
changes in the other).
Moreover, there is a uniform scale from -1 to +1 so that as correlation values move closer to 1, the two
variables are more closely related. By contrast, a covariance value between two variables could be very
large and indicate little actual relationship, or look very small when there is actually a strong linear
correlation.
Correlation is defined as the ratio of the covariance between two random variables and the product of
their two standard deviations, as presented in the following formula:
As a result: Covariance (A, B) = Correlation (A, B)*Standard Deviation (A)*Standard Deviation (B)
Both correlation and covariance with these formulas are likely to be required in a calculation in which the
other terms are provided. Such an exercise simply requires remembering the relationship, and substituting
the terms provided. For example, if a covariance between two numbers of 30 is given, and standard
deviations are 5 and 15, the correlation would be 30/(5)*(15) = 0.40. If you are given a correlation of 0.40
and standard deviations of 5 and 15, the covariance would be (0.4)*(5)*(15), or 30.
Variance (σ2) is computed by finding the probability-weighted average of squared deviations from the
expected value.
Example: Variance
In our previous example on making a sales forecast, we found that the expected value was $14.2 million.
Calculating variance starts by computing the deviations from $14.2 million, then squaring:
Answer:
Variance weights each squared deviation by its probability: (0.1)*(3.24) + (0.3)*(0.64) + (0.3)*(0.04) +
(0.3)*(1.44) = 0.96
The variance of return is a function of the variance of the component assets as well as the covariance
between each of them. In modern portfolio theory, a low or negative correlation between asset classes will
reduce overall portfolio variance. The formula for portfolio variance in the simple case of a two-asset
portfolio is given by:
Stock Bond
Stock 350 80
Bond 80
From this matrix, we know that the variance on stocks is 350 (the covariance of any asset to itself equals
its variance), the variance on bonds is 150 and the covariance between stocks and bonds is 80. Given our
portfolio weights of 0.5 for both stocks and bonds, we have all the terms needed to solve for portfolio
variance.
Answer:
Portfolio variance = w2A*σ2(RA) + w2B*σ2(RB) + 2*(wA)*(wB)*Cov(RA, RB) =(0.5)2*(350) + (0.5)2*(150)
+ 2*(0.5)*(0.5)*(80) = 87.5 + 37.5 + 40 = 165.
Standard Deviation (σ), as was defined earlier when we discuss statistics, is the positive square root of
the variance. In our example, σ = (0.96)1/2, or $0.978 million.
Standard deviation is found by taking the square root of variance: (165)1/2 = 12.85%.
A two-asset portfolio was used to illustrate this principle; most portfolios contain far more than two assets,
and the formula for variance becomes more complicated for multi-asset portfolios (all terms in a
covariance matrix need to be added to the calculation).
Scatter Plot
Sample Covariance
To quantify a linear relationship between two variables, we start by finding the covariance of a sample of
paired observations. A sample covariance between two random variables X and Y is the average value of
the cross-product of all observed deviations from each respective sample mean. A cross-product, for the
ith observation in a sample, is found by this calculation: (ith observation of X - sample mean of X) * (ith
observation of Y - sample mean of Y). The covariance is the sum of all cross-products, divided by (n - 1).
To illustrate, take a sample of five paired observations of annual returns for two mutual funds, which we
will label X and Y:
Average X and Y returns were found by dividing the sum by n or 5, while the average of the cross-products
is computed by dividing the sum by n - 1, or 4. The use of n - 1 for covariance is done by statisticians to
ensure an unbiased estimate.
Interpreting a covariance number is difficult for those who are not statistical experts. The 99.64 we
computed for this example has a sign of "returns squared" since the numbers were percentage returns, and
a return squared is not an intuitive concept. The fact that Cov(X,Y) of 99.64 was greater than 0 does
indicate a positive or linear relationship between X and Y. Had the covariance been a negative number, it
would imply an inverse relationship, while 0 means no relationship. Thus 99.64 indicates that the returns
have positive co-movement (when one moves higher so does the other), but doesn't offer any information
on the extent of the co-movement.
Sample Correlation Coefficient
By calculating a correlation coefficient, we essentially convert a raw covariance number into a standard
format that can be more easily interpreted to determine the extent of the relationship between two variables.
The formula for calculating a sample correlation coefficient (r) between two random variables X and Y is
the following:
r = (covariance between X, Y) / (sample standard deviation
of X) * (sample std. dev. of Y).
Answer:
As with sample covariance, we use (n - 1) as the denominator in calculating sample variance (sum of
squared deviations as the numerator) - thus in the above example, each sum was divided by 4 to find the
variance. Standard deviation is the positive square root of variance: in this example, sample standard
deviation of X is (136.06)1/2, or 11.66; sample standard deviation of Y is (99.14)1/2, or 9.96.