CUADRO COMPARATIVO DE COLECTORES DE DATOS - ENERO 2007 – VIBRO TECHNOLOGY SRL

DLI Watchman®
DLI Watchman®
Enpac, CMXA50
DLI Watchman®
Pruftechnic SPM Commtest
DCA-50 CSI-2120 CSI-2130 SKF CMVA60
DCX DCA-31 VibXpert Leonova VB

Feature

Max simultaneous 4 4 2 2 2 1 2 2 2
dynamic inputs
Real time rate 20.5 KHz (4 CH 20.5 KHz (4 CH 40 KHz 19 KHz 19 KHz ?? ?? ?? ??
Simultaneous) Simultaneous)
Real time display Tri-Axial Tri-Axial Single Axis Single Axis Single Axis Single Axis None None None
Maximum 25,600 (x 4) 25,600 (x 4) 12,800 6400 6400 6400 ?? 6400 3200
resolution (lines)
Waterfall plots Yes Yes No Yes Yes No Yes No No
Time synchronous Yes Yes No Yes Yes Yes No Yes Yes
averaging
Order normalized Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes No Yes
data
Filtered orbits Yes Yes Optional No Yes No Yes No No
Full spectrum Yes Yes No Yes Yes No No No No
Bode plots Yes Yes No Yes Yes Yes No No No
Nyquist plots No No No Yes Yes No No No No
Run-up / Yes Yes No Yes Yes No Yes No Yes
coastdown
Bearing fault BearingALERT™ Demodulation, Demodulation Demodulation Demodulation Demodulation Demodulation Demodulation Demodulation
detection automated 6 band-pass filters 5 band-pass filters 600Hz HP filter 600Hz HP filter 4 band-pass filters Cepstrum Shock Pulse Method 20 band-pass filters
diagnostics Cepstrum (PeakVue) (PeakVue) Bearing fault frequency Bearing fault frequency
Demodulation (4) Bearing fault overlay overlays
6 band-pass filters frequency overlays
Cepstrum
(4) Bearing fault
frequency overlays
No. channels @ Four Channels Four Channels Single Channel @ 40 Single Channel Single Channel Single Channel ?? Single Channel Single Channel
maximum FFT (Simultaneous) (Simultaneous) KHz (two channel @ 80 KHz (two channel @ 80 KHz (two @ 20 KHz @ 20 KHz (two @ 20 KHz (two
frequency @16 KHz @16 KHz option) option) channel option) channel option) channel option)
Dynamic range >90 dB >90 dB Typical 90 dB > 90 dB > 90 dB 80 dB ?? ?? Typical 95 dB
16 bit 16 bit 20 bit 16 bit 16 bit 14 bit 16 bit
Window types Hanning, Hamming, Hanning, Hamming, Hanning, Hamming, Hanning, Uniform Hanning, Uniform Hanning, Flat-top, Hanning, Hamming, ?? Hanning, Rectangular
Flat top, Uniform Flat top, Uniform Rectangular Uniform Flat top, Uniform
Tri-axial support Simultaneous Simultaneous Multiplexed Multiplexed Multiplexed Multiplexed No Multiplexed No
Low frequency 0.2Hz 0.2 Hz 0.16 Hz 0.2 Hz 0.2 Hz 0.5 Hz ?? ?? ?? - No setting for
capability high-pass filter
Embedded rule- Yes No No No No No No No No
based diagnostics
 CUADRO COMPARATIVO DE COLECTORES DE DATOS - ENERO 2007 – VIBRO TECHNOLOGY SRL
DLI Watchman®
DLI Watchman®
Enpac, CMXA50
DLI Watchman®
Pruftechnic SPM Commtest
DCA-50 CSI-2120 CSI-2130 SKF CMVA60
DCX DCA-31 VibXpert Leonova VB

Feature

Online capability Yes – DCX No No No No No No No No

Convertible Option
Point ID Route , Barcode Route , Barcode Route , Barcode Route Route Route Route Route, Optional RFID Route
Optional Optional Optional
Sealing IP-67 IP-67 IP-65 IP-65 IP-65 IP-64 IP-64 ?? ??
Data storage System: 256 Mbytes System: 256 Mbytes 4 Mbytes internal RAM Data: 2.5 Mbytes System: 16 Mbytes System: 2 Mbytes Data: PCMCIA card System: 64 MB RAM Data: 8.5 MB internal
RAM (upgrade to 512 RAM Add on with PCMCIA internal RAM internal RAM internal RAM (assmd) Data : Compact Flash Data: 32 MB Flash
Mbytes) Data: 500 Mbytes Flash memory cards Data: PCMCIA card Data: 32 Mbytes Data: 4 MB internal NO internal storage memory
Data: 20 Gbytes (solid state Compact internal RAM Flash
(shock mounted hard Flash system and data Data: PCMCIA card
drive - system and data memory)
memory)
Ext. memory card N/A(1) N/A(1) PCMCIA PCMCIA PCMCIA No Compact Flash No No
Microprocessor(s) Intel Pentium® III Intel-based x586 MIPS 75 MHz and General Purpose and ?? Intel 32-bit, 25 MHz ?? StromARM 206 MHz General Purpose and
Processor-M 800 MHz and Motorola DSP 80 MHz DSP 30MHz DSP
933 MHz and TI DSP 40MHz
TI DSP 40MHz
Operating system Windows® XP Tablet Windows® XP Windows® CE Proprietary Proprietary Proprietary Linux Embedded Windows® CE Proprietary
Embedded
Physical size (H x W 8.25 x 11 x 1.6 8 x 11 x 1.8 8.0 x 5 x 2 10.7 x 6.8 x 1.5 8 x 10.25 x 1.9 10.5 x 7.9 x 2.5 ?? ?? 9.7 x 6.1 x 3
x D)
Weight 4.2 lbs 4.9 lbs 1.5lbs 4.8 lbs 4.5 lbs 5 lbs ?? 22 oz 4.4 lbs
Operating 0-60 oC 0 - 50 oC 0 - 60oC -10 - 45oC -10 - 45oC -10 - 50oC ?? ?? 0 - 50 oC
temperature
Display 10.4” SVGA 6.3” SVGA 800 x 1/8 VGA 240 x 160 5” 320 x 240 4.47” VGA 640 x 480 6.6” Monochrome ½ VGA 480 x 320 4.0” ¼ VGA 240 x 320 4.9” 240 x 128
800x600 600 Monochrome Monochrome Color TFT Monochrome Monochrome Monochrome
Color Active Matrix Color TFT
Power 4 hours typical (DCX 8 hours typical (DCA- 4 hours 11 hours 8 hours 10 hours 8 hours 8 hours 6 hours - backlight on,
v.3.0 APM compliant 50 v.3.0 APM (quick change battery 9 hours – no backlight
driver) compliant driver) available)

Standard Data Collection Data Collection Data Collection Data Collection Data Collection Data Collection Data Collection Data Collection Data Collection
application Software Software Software Software Software Software Software Software Software
programs Off-Route Data Off-Route Data Off-Survey Data Off-Route Data Off-Route Data Off-Route Data Off-Survey Data Off-Survey Data Off-Survey Data
Collection Collection Collection Collection Collection Collection Collection Collection Collection
ExpertALERT™ ALERT™ Analysis
Software
 CUADRO COMPARATIVO DE COLECTORES DE DATOS - ENERO 2007 – VIBRO TECHNOLOGY SRL
DLI Watchman®
DLI Watchman®
Enpac, CMXA50
DLI Watchman®
Pruftechnic SPM Commtest
DCA-50 CSI-2120 CSI-2130 SKF CMVA60
DCX DCA-31 VibXpert Leonova VB

Feature

Optional application Four-plane Four-plane Two-plane balancing Transient Analysis Transient Analysis Two-plane balancing, Two-plane balancing Four Run-Single Plane Two-plane balancing
programs balancing balancing Balancing Balancing Tracking Filter, Motor Balancing (no trial)
ME-Scope Laser Alignment Laser Alignment current monitor, Cyclic Two-plane balancing
SignalAQ™ Data MotorView® MotorView® Measurement SPM Spectrum
Acquisition Utility Lubrication Analysis
Sybase Replication EVAM vibration
DLI Online Engine™ analysis
Long time recording
Host Software NO Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
System Required
External USB to PC USB or Ethernet to Serial to Host Serial to Host USB, Ethernet, Serial Serial to Host USB, Ethernet, Serial Serial, USB to Host Serial to Host
Communications Ethernet to Network Host to Host to Host
Data Load / Unload N/A Complete Plant Route file Route file Route file Route file Route file Route file Route file
Database Replication - Database onboard –
DCX contains Unloaded to ALERT
complete ALERT software
database.
Communications 12 Megabit per second 12 Megabit per second 115K Baud 115K Baud 115K Baud 115K Baud 115K Baud 115K Baud 57.6K Baud
Speed USB or Ethernet USB or Ethernet 4,000K Baud (integral 12 Megabits per 12 Megabits per 12 Megabits per
Connection Connection IR IrDA 1.1 Serial)* second USB or second USB or second USB
Ethernet Connection Ethernet Connection
Printing Print any report, HP Deskjet 450ci Serial Printer Serial Printer Serial Printer Serial Printers ?? No Serial Printer
data plot to all mobile printer
Windows®
printers – USB,
parallel local or
network printers.
User programmable Yes – Third-party No No No No No No No No
Windows® Apps
can be loaded.
Comments Complete condition Low cost, high feature Diagnostics Newer version of 2120 Upgrade of CMVA55, SPM has a program to Low cost, low feature
monitoring system / data collector. Instruments DI-225-D platform, includes more memory, more lease product based on data collector
database sold by DLI, SKF and color screen, more software options. number of No real time display
Entek freq. ranges Palamar is measurements
predecessor.

Ciro Martínez T Gerente de Vibro Technology SRL Telf. 511-3652630 Celular 511-96502804, Web Site http://www.vibrotechnology.org email: vibrotec@amauta.rcp.net.pe vibrotec@vibrotechnology.org