Dunbar Shore and Harbour Neighbourhood Group Report For AGM - Feb 2019-1
Dunbar Shore and Harbour Neighbourhood Group Report For AGM - Feb 2019-1
Dunbar Shore and Harbour Neighbourhood Group Report For AGM - Feb 2019-1
- F E B R U A R Y 2 0 1 9
Dunbar
Shore and Harbour
Neighbourhood Group
...making it better beside the sea…
OUR MEMBERS
Annual Report DSHNG MEMBERSHIP has remained largely static
for AGM over the past year despite a push to attract new
members at the end of 2017. We currently have about
We are obliged by our
70 members, all of whom live or work in our area for
constitution to publicise
all or part of the year.
a report annually so here
it is with a brief update Our monthly open meetings attract a regular cohort
of all that we have been of between 10 and 18 and we circulate minutes and
up to in yet another very news to all members who have access to email.
Dunbar Community Council and Dunbar Trades
busy year. A huge vote
Association also get copies of minutes for their
of thanks to all our
information.
active members!
Members who are involved with Dunbar Harbour
Contact Us: Trust ensure that strong links are maintained there.
shore_harbour@yahoo.co.uk
Our Diary
Keep up to date: Meetings Other Dates
www.ourlocality.org/ 1st Tuesday of each month We set dates for
dunbarshoreandharbour Meetings were held at the Methodist specific projects and
Church, Victoria St. All were open events throughout
the year and
DunbarsEastBeach meetings. They started at 7pm and publicised these by
we tried to be finished by 8.30pm email and on our
website.
FEBRUARY 2019
DUNBAR SHORE AND HARBOUR NEIGHBOURHOOD GROUP
Our Projects
2018 has been another productive year. Some of
our projects have become annual events and
some are one off excitements!
Kelp Management
The kelp management plan has continued to work relatively
well this year and remains of primary importance to DSHNG
members to prevent smells and fly infestations. Pippa Swan is
the key player on this project. She liaises with ELC and local
contractor, Kevin Thomson, who has been wonderful in
supporting this management plan. Kevin gathers his team and
equipment at short notice and will hit the beach between tides.
In response to heavily negative comment from East Links
residents last year and this, kelp moves are now generally simple
relocations over the sewage interceptor pipe at East Beach.
For the one very serious dump in 2018 that had to be moved off site,
material was transported to Winterfield Golf Club, Phantassie Farm
and Forth Resource Management. Off site removal is costly both in
cash and environment terms and we try to avoid it if possible.
(Thanks to Ian Scrimgeour for identifying alternative dump sites)
FEBRUARY 2019
DUNBAR SHORE AND HARBOUR NEIGHBOURHOOD GROUP
In 2019, works will commence to reinstate the critical shore section of groyne with a new
concrete ‘biowall’ and timber superstructure and 2 very large breakwaters will be constructed
which will not only protect the sea wall (which collapsed three times in 2018) but will also allow
for the aggregation of any sand that comes our way.
DRG No.
PB8131-001 DO NOT SCALE NOTES
1. ALL DIMENSIONS ARE IN MILLIMETRES UNLESS NOTED
OTHERWISE.
PREVENTSTREET
CHURCH
WOODBUSH
EXISTING
STONE
BEACH
MANHOLE
STONES
DAMAGE
BRAE
TO
ROCK
PLACED
TO
OF
SELECTED
BE
BEHIND
3-6t
FROM
TO
THE
AGREED
ARMOUR
TOBE
ARMOUR
BE
TOE
3NEW
-REMOVED
6tWITH
OFSTONE.
STONES
THE
PROJECT
EXISTING
AND
EXACT
50m MANAGER
LONG
WALL. CREST
800
SEWER
REDUNDANT
CL
MANHOLE
EXISTING
IL
1
: : -1.84
4000
PLANT
LARGER
GRADING
CL
MANHOLE
IL
FIRST
1000
BEAM
DIA.
+0.32
EXISTING
GROYNE
ROCK
+2.00
+1.95
LOCALISED
ELEVATION
: : -0.58
-1.63
PIPE
PE
+2.70
+2.01
CONCRETE
LONG
TO
4BAY
HIGH
No.
ROCKS
TO
TIE
TIMBER
+3.00
CONCRETE
BAYS
ROCK
REMAIN
INTO
SELECTED
FROM
BAYS
OF
ARMOUR
3 - 6t
LOCATION PLAN
NOT TO SCALE
500
00
S1 368200.793 678904.698
MHW
R ST
S2 368203.843 678896.670
D
S3 368212.609 678873.257
REET
002
S
SOPS1
E
002
SOPS2
E
002
NOT FOR
CONSTRUCTION
EXISTING
MANHOLE
CL : +1.95 SOPS3
IL : -1.84
EXISTING
MANHOLE
CL : +2.00 SOPS4
IL : +0.32
D
002
EXISTING TIMBER
DUNBAR EAST BEACH
REE
GROYNE TO REMAIN
T
PLANT BAY
TITLE
1000 LONG CONCRETE
BEAM TO TIE INTO
EXISTING TIMBER
GROYNE
GENERAL ARRANGEMENT
74 / 2 Commercial Quay
Commercial Street
EXISTING Leith
MANHOLE Edinburgh, EH6 6LX
CL : +2.01 Tel +44(0)131 5550506
Email info@rhdhv.com
IL : -0.58 Website www.royalhaskoningdhv.com
EXISTING
MANHOLE
CL : +2.70
IL : -1.63 DRAWN CHECKED PASSED
A.I.K - -
NUMBER 100023381.
c HaskoningDHV UK Ltd.
PB8131-001 -
FEBRUARY 2019
DUNBAR SHORE AND HARBOUR NEIGHBOURHOOD GROUP
DRG No.
PB8131-003 DO NOT SCALE NOTES DRG No.
PB8131-004 DO NOT SCALE NOTES
1. ALL DIMENSIONS ARE IN MILLIMETRES UNLESS NOTED 1. ALL DIMENSIONS ARE IN MILLIMETRES UNLESS NOTED
OTHERWISE. OTHERWISE.
D
NORTH
1000 4420 4000 2. STAINLESS STEEL TO DESIGNATION 1.4301. 2. ALL LEVELS ARE IN METRES RELATIVE TO ORDNANCE
DATUM UNLESS NOTED OTHERWISE.
3. ALL EDGES TO HAVE 25 x 25 CHAMFERS UNLESS
NOTED OTHERWISE. 3. ALL EXPOSED EDGES TO HAVE 25 x 25 CHAMFERS
UNLESS NOTED OTHERWISE.
4. DOWELS TO BE S32 RIBBED BARS DESIGNATION 1.4302
FIXED WITH RESIN ANCHOR HILTI HIT RE 500 V3 OR
SIMILAR APPROVED.
100 x 310 RECESS 100 x 310 RECESS 5. DOWELS TO BE FIXED ACCORDING TO RESIN ANCHOR
FOR POST FOR POST MANUFACTURER'S INSTRUCTIONS / METHODOLOGY.
EXISTING GROYNE
POST 8. ALL BOLTS SUPPLIED WITH 2 No. 75 DIA x 10 THK
WASHERS AND 1 No. NUT.
A A
100 x 310 RECESS SELECTED 305 x 305 SELECTED 305 x 305
AROUND TIMBER POST REUSED TIMBER POST REUSED 400 DIA. RECESS FOR FUTURE POSTS
EXISTING POST FROM OLD STRUCTURE FROM OLD STRUCTURE WALL
210 210
100 100
EXISTING EXISTING PILES KEY
BALCONY
EXISTING ROCK PROFILE (2018
LASER SCAN SURVEY)
EXISTING PLANKING
TO REMAIN 4m PLANT BAY
GROYNE PROFILE
4m LONG CONCRETE BAYS
FOR NEW GROYNE
5 5
SOUTH
?
D
PLAN ON PLANT BAY SAFETY, HEALTH AND ENVIRONMENT INFORMATION 4 4
SINGLE LAYER OF 3 - 6t ROCKS
SCALE 1:20 IN ADDITION TO THE HAZARDS/RISKS NORMALLY ASSOCIATED +3.17 HAT
PLACED ON FORESHORE
WITH THE TYPES OF WORK DETAILED ON THIS DRAWING, NOTE 3 3
Level
THE FOLLOWING SIGNIFICANT RESIDUAL RISKS: +2.50 MHWS
SAFETY, HEALTH AND ENVIRONMENT INFORMATION
CONSTRUCTION IN ADDITION TO THE HAZARDS/RISKS NORMALLY ASSOCIATED
2 2
305 x 305 POST 1000 HIGH FIXED WITH M20 WORKING IN INTER-TIDAL ZONE. WITH THE TYPES OF WORK DETAILED ON THIS DRAWING, NOTE
+1.30 MHWN
POLLUTION OF MARINE ENVIRONMENT.
EXISTING GROYNE POST STAINLESS STEEL THREADED BARS INTO HIS-(R)N 710 DIA. PE PIPE THE FOLLOWING SIGNIFICANT RESIDUAL RISKS:
COSH ASSESSMENT - CONCRETE, RESIN, TIMBER & TIMBER
ANCHORS FIXED WITH HILTI HIT-RE 500. BOLTS PRESERVATIVES. 1 1
RECESSED INTO TIMBER POSTS. 200 DEEP EXCAVATION OF ROCK CONSTRUCTION
BELOW GROYNE FOOTPRINT WORKING IN INTER-TIDAL ZONE.
IL : -0.19
POLLUTION OF MARINE ENVIRONMENT.
1 No M20x400 LONG BOLT PER PLANT BAY PLANK 3no. 200 x 100 PLANKS FIXED TO POSTS USING 0 0
MAINTENANCE/CLEANING/OPERATION COSH ASSESSMENT - CONCRETE, RESIN, TIMBER & TIMBER
BOLTS 800 DIA. PE PIPE PRESERVATIVES.
WORKING IN INTER-TIDAL ZONE. -0.80 MLWN
40.000
41.000
42.000
43.000
44.000
45.000
46.000
47.000
48.000
49.000
00.000
01.000
02.000
03.000
04.000
05.000
06.000
07.000
08.000
09.000
20.000
21.000
22.000
23.000
24.000
25.000
26.000
27.000
28.000
29.000
30.000
31.000
32.000
33.000
34.000
35.000
36.000
37.000
38.000
39.000
50.000
10.000
11.000
12.000
13.000
14.000
15.000
16.000
17.000
18.000
19.000
COSH ASSESSMENT - CONCRETE, RESIN, TIMBER & TIMBER
DECOMMISSIONING/DEMOLITION Chainage PRESERVATIVES.
WORKING IN INTER-TIDAL ZONE. PLANT BAY IS INTENDED TO ALLOW ACCESS BY
POLLUTION OF MARINE ENVIRONMENT. ARTICULATED HAULER VEHICLE.
600
COSH ASSESSMENT - CONCRETE, RESIN, TIMBER & TIMBER
2.661
2.391
2.051
1.781
1.071
1.301
1.301
2.906
2.844
2.616
2.372
2.272
2.096
2.120
3.320
3.149
3.142
2.868
2.783
2.533
2.578
2.529
2.437
2.343
2.369
2.118
2.105
2.023
0.992
0.932
1.976
1.994
1.823
1.797
1.728
1.606
1.506
1.248
1.074
1.000
1.339
1.316
1.339
1.138
1.169
1.098
1.095
PRESERVATIVES.
Existing Levels DECOMMISSIONING/DEMOLITION
WORKING IN INTER-TIDAL ZONE.
1000
1210
SECTION A-A
400 APPROX DEEP
SCALE 1:20
BEAM AT PLANT
CROSSING
NORTH SOUTH
4000
NOT FOR
NORTH AND SOUTH FACE OF THE NORTH AND SOUTH FACE OF THE GROYNE
TO INCORPORATE RECKLI FORMLINER
NOT FOR
GROYNE TO INCORPORATE RECKLI
FORMLINER FINISH. PATTERN TO FINISH. PATTERN TO BE RECKLI 2/186 NORTH AND SOUTH FACE OF THE
BE RECKLI 2/186 DALARNA. DALARNA. PATTERN TO BE HORIZONTAL GROYNE TO INCORPORATE RECKLI
CONSTRUCTION
CONSTRUCTION
PATTERN TO BE HORIZONTAL AND AND SET WITHIN A 100mm BOARDER FORMLINER FINISH. PATTERN TO BE
1050
1000
500 500 500 100 WIDE RECESS FOR RECKLI 2/186 DALARNA. PATTERN TO
950
400
100
S12 REINFORCEMENT BARS
VARIES TO SUIT
ROCK PROFILE VOID FILLED WITH SAND
1200
1500
400
200
200
400
100
400 DIA. RECESS FOR FUTURE POSTS
275
200
200
100
ROCK TO BE SAW CUT 200
1000 2000 1000 DEEP PRIOR TO PLANING
400
500
USING ROCK CUTTING WHEEL REVISIONS
/ DRUM OR SIMILAR APPROVED
S32 DOWELS (RIBBED) 955 REVISIONS
CLIENT
UNBENT LENGTH EMBEDDED
MIN 500 INTO ROCK, 275 INTO CLIENT
CONCRETE BLOCK WITH 120
SECTION B-B SECTION C-C HOOK LENGTH AT 500 CENTRES
C
B
CONCRETE UNIT
SCALE 1:20
120 WIDE RECESS FOR PLANK PROJECT
PROJECT
NORTH SOUTH
1200 DUNBAR EAST BEACH
4-S12-02-200
DUNBAR EAST BEACH
2-S12-03-200
TITLE
2-S12-02-200 2-S12-02-200
A B C D E/R
400
MEMBER BAR
MARK
TYPE
AND
No. OF
MBRS
No. OF
BARS IN
TOTAL No. LENGTH OF SHAPE
EACH BAR CODE
CONCRETE GROYNE DETAILS CONCRETE GROYNE
mm mm mm mm mm mm
SIZE EACH
(PHASE 1) LONG SECTION
CONCRETE
01 S12 7 16 128 2700 46 350 750 500 705 350
BLOCK UNIT (PHASE 1)
SAW CUT SAW CUT
CONCRETE 74 / 2 Commercial Quay
02 S12 7 8 56 800 00 1000 Commercial Street
BLOCK UNIT 74 / 2 Commercial Quay
Leith
S32 DOWELS (RIBBED) 955 Edinburgh, EH6 6LX Commercial Street
UNBENT LENGTH EMBEDDED Tel +44(0)131 5550506 Leith
PLANT BAY Edinburgh, EH6 6LX
03 S12 1 4 4 3850 00 3850 MIN 500 INTO ROCK, 275 INTO Email info@rhdhv.com
Website www.royalhaskoningdhv.com Tel +44(0)131 5550506
CONCRETE BLOCK WITH 120
Email info@rhdhv.com
HOOK LENGTH AT 500 CENTRES Website www.royalhaskoningdhv.com
PLANT BAY
04 S12 1 2 2 3425 00 3425
SECTION D-D
This schedule complies with the requirements of BS 8666:2005 Specified in multiples of 5mm. Specified in multiples of 25mm. SCALE 1:20
DRAWN CHECKED PASSED
A.I.K - -
DRAWN CHECKED PASSED
DATE CLIENT'S REF. A.I.K - -
Oct. 2018
1000mm 750 500 250 0 400 800 1200mm 5m 4 3 2 1 0 2 4 6m DATE CLIENT'S REF.
SCALE AT A1 AUTOCAD REF. Oct. 2018
4-S12-01-200 RC PLAN 4-S12-01-200
SCALE IN MILLIMETRES
AS SHOWN PB8131-003
SCALE IN METRES SCALE AT A1 AUTOCAD REF.
SCALE 1:20 1:20 AS SHOWN PB8131-003
DRAWING No. REVISION 1:100
c HaskoningDHV UK Ltd.
PB8131-003 - DRAWING No. REVISION
c HaskoningDHV UK Ltd.
PB8131-004 -
DRG No.
PB8131-002 DO NOT SCALE NOTES
1. ALL DIMENSIONS ARE IN MILLIMETRES UNLESS NOTED
OTHERWISE.
ROCK GROYNE TO BUTT EXISTING OUTFALL 3. SEE Drg. No. PB8131-001 FOR SECTION LOCATIONS.
AGAINST EXISTING MASONRY PIPE SURROUND
SEAWALL STRUCTURE 4. ALL MATERIAL AND WORKMANSHIP WILL BE AS
DEFINED IN THE SPECIFICATION UNLESS NOTED
5 5 OTHERWISE.
4 4
3 3
2 2
1 1
Level
Level
0 0
There is
-1 -1
-2 -2
20.000
21.000
22.000
23.000
24.000
25.000
26.000
27.000
28.000
29.000
40.000
41.000
42.000
43.000
44.000
45.000
46.000
47.000
48.000
49.000
20.000
21.000
22.000
23.000
24.000
25.000
26.000
27.000
28.000
29.000
00.000
01.000
02.000
03.000
04.000
05.000
06.000
07.000
08.000
09.000
30.000
31.000
32.000
33.000
34.000
35.000
36.000
37.000
38.000
39.000
50.000
51.000
52.000
53.000
54.000
55.000
55.528
00.000
01.000
02.000
03.000
04.000
05.000
06.000
07.000
08.000
09.000
30.000
31.000
32.000
32.604
10.000
11.000
12.000
13.000
14.000
15.000
16.000
17.000
18.000
19.000
10.000
11.000
12.000
13.000
14.000
15.000
16.000
17.000
18.000
19.000
Chainage Chainage
no guar
-0.551
-0.511
-0.651
-1.101
-1.181
-1.271
-1.411
-0.022
-0.132
-0.332
-0.826
-0.783
-0.712
-0.686
-0.946
-1.043
-1.133
-1.073
-1.080
-1.150
-1.173
-1.186
-1.202
-1.220
-1.340
-1.282
-1.174
-0.069
-0.084
-0.223
-0.220
-0.304
-0.294
-0.247
-0.403
-0.418
-0.559
-0.415
-0.564
-0.599
-0.686
-0.769
-0.747
-0.765
-0.724
-0.617
-0.573
-0.494
-0.430
-0.563
-0.598
-0.774
-0.813
-0.758
-0.898
-0.905
-0.905
-1.145
-1.045
-1.235
-1.235
-1.225
-1.298
-1.338
-1.409
4.750
3.397
3.275
0.916
0.902
0.853
0.816
0.862
0.852
0.862
0.799
0.643
0.692
0.533
0.673
0.503
0.626
0.342
0.300
0.147
0.014
1.213
1.184
1.072
1.156
1.169
an
SECTION A-A (ALONG NORTH GROYNE CREST) SECTION E-E (SOUTH ROCK REVETMENT)
beach w
ill reapp tee that a
SCALE: H 1:200,V 1:200 SCALE: H 1:200,V 1:200 SAFETY, HEALTH AND ENVIRONMENT INFORMATION
CONSTRUCTION
WORKING IN INTER-TIDAL ZONE.
5 POLLUTION OF MARINE ENVIRONMENT.
LIFTING OPERATIONS.
4
STABILITY OF ADJACENT STRUCTURES.
ear
3 INTERACTION WITH PUBLIC.
Level
must br
MAINTENANCE/CLEANING/OPERATION
3
00.000
01.000
02.000
03.000
04.000
05.000
06.000
07.000
08.000
09.000
23.009
10.000
11.000
12.000
13.000
14.000
15.000
16.000
17.000
18.000
19.000
Level
Chainage 2 DECOMMISSIONING/DEMOLITION
WORKING IN INTER-TIDAL ZONE.
1
POLLUTION OF MARINE ENVIRONMENT.
LIFTING OPERATIONS.
0
0.851
0.511
0.809
0.714
0.818
0.516
0.394
0.382
0.438
0.356
0.500
0.574
0.545
0.378
0.476
0.576
0.609
0.649
0.504
0.479
0.364
0.214
1.120
1.136
Existing Levels
nd for th
STABILITY OF ADJACENT STRUCTURES.
-1 INTERACTION WITH PUBLIC.
but we a
-2
40.000
41.000
42.000
43.000
44.000
45.000
46.000
47.000
48.000
49.000
00.000
01.000
02.000
03.000
04.000
05.000
06.000
07.000
08.000
09.000
20.000
21.000
22.000
23.000
24.000
25.000
26.000
27.000
28.000
29.000
30.000
31.000
32.000
33.000
34.000
35.000
36.000
37.000
38.000
39.000
50.000
51.000
52.000
53.000
54.000
54.563
10.000
11.000
12.000
13.000
14.000
15.000
16.000
17.000
18.000
19.000
Chainage
SECTION B-B (NORTH GROYNE)
at…
SCALE: H 1:200,V 1:200
-1.341
-1.241
-1.181
-1.131
-1.422
-1.444
-1.398
-1.298
-1.363
-1.284
-1.307
-1.250
-1.314
-1.310
-1.248
-1.258
-1.250
-1.248
-1.208
-1.183
-1.063
-1.099
-1.026
-1.006
-0.935
-0.677
-0.829
-0.838
-0.703
-0.684
-0.636
-0.618
-0.553
-0.318
-0.212
-0.530
-0.284
-0.477
-0.465
-0.510
-0.414
-0.447
-0.335
-0.274
-0.153
-0.129
-0.046
0.441
0.246
0.003
0.017
0.110
0.423
0.472
0.486
0.195
Existing Levels
re giving
the bea
SCALE: H 1:200,V 1:200
the very ch
recover w best chance to
4
3
Level
2 10m 8 6 4 2 0 5 10 15m
1
SCALE IN METRES
0 1:200
-1
NOT FOR
-2
20.000
21.000
22.000
23.000
24.000
25.000
25.366
00.000
01.000
02.000
03.000
04.000
05.000
06.000
07.000
08.000
09.000
10.000
11.000
12.000
13.000
14.000
15.000
16.000
17.000
18.000
19.000
Chainage
CONSTRUCTION
hilst pro
-0.351
-0.931
-0.122
-0.022
-0.060
-0.246
-0.307
-0.258
-0.258
-0.232
-0.299
-0.299
-0.319
-0.412
-0.643
-0.659
-0.684
-0.803
-0.689
-0.828
-0.802
-0.892
-0.856
-0.828
-0.934
-0.055
-0.765
Existing Levels
tecting t
SECTION C-C (NORTH GROYNE)
SCALE: H 1:200,V 1:200
he
REV DATE DESCRIPTION BY CHK APP
sea wall
REVISIONS
VARIES CREST WIDTH MIN 2000 VARIES
CLIENT
SELECTED LARGER
CREST LEVEL ROCKS FROM 3 - 6t +3.17 HAT
+3.00 GRADING
+2.50 MHWS
2 2
1 1
PROJECT
3 LAYERS OF 3 - 6t ROCK
SELECTED LARGER
SELECTED LARGER ROCKS FROM 3 - 6t TITLE
ROCKS FROM 3 - 6t GRADING
GRADING
ROCKS TO BE PLACED
ONTO FORESHORE TYPICAL SECTION EXISTING ROCK PROFILE
SCALE 1:50
c HaskoningDHV UK Ltd.
PB8131-002 -
Work will also commence on the design development and delivery of a new promenade and seating area
to ensure that the new sea defences do end up adding to the amenity of this very important part of
Dunbar – much loved by residents and visitors alike. Thanks to OOBE Design.
FEBRUARY 2019
DUNBAR SHORE AND HARBOUR NEIGHBOURHOOD GROUP
Estate Inspections
Now an annual event, volunteers record infrastructure
defects and environmental issues that that we think need
to be addressed by ELC or other statutory authorities. In
2018, the inspection reiterated the need to continue to
work with East Beach and Lamer Street issues and we have
been doing this with ELC.
Works are still required to stabilise dangerous walls in the
area and vacant sites remain an issue.
Thanks to Alasdair Swan, Ian Dane, Kenny Maule, Mike
Shaw, Colin and Teresa Barnes, Millie Cornwall, Brian Cox.
Civic Engagement
v Mike Shaw organised and ran the tombola stall again to help to raise funds on RNLI day. Huge
thanks go to Neil and Janis Adams for assistance in prize gathering and to all the members who
volunteered on what was a really profitable and successful event.
v Great fun was had by all!
2
1
DUNBAR SHORE AND HARBOUR NEIGHBOURHOOD GROUP FEBRUARY 2019
Dunbar Shore and Harbour Neighbourhood Group remains a sociable and active group with a
reputation for getting things done. We like to feel that we have the concerns of all of our
neighbours in mind when we start a project or address an issue but are aware that this may not
always be so. Despite reaching out to all 600 homes in our area, we know that we only actively
engage with a relatively small constituency and it remains important to us that people who live in our
area should feel able to approach us with their views, whatever they may be. It will remain our
ambition to make it better beside the sea … for everybody … so do stay in touch!
CO M MI TT E E FOR 2 018/19
www.ourlocality.org/dunbarshoreandharbour
shore_harbour@yahoo.co.uk