Autonomous: Autonomous Corrosion Corrosion Control Control
Autonomous: Autonomous Corrosion Corrosion Control Control
Autonomous: Autonomous Corrosion Corrosion Control Control
Autonomous
Corrosion
Control
N early a ll me tals a nd t heir a lloys a re
subject to corrosion that causes them
to l ose t heir s tructural in tegrity o r
other f unctionality. I t i s e ssential t o
detect corrosion when it o ccurs, a nd
preferably at its early stage, so that action can be taken to
avoid structural damage or loss of function of metals and
their alloys. Because corrosion is mostly an electrochem-
ical p rocess, pH a nd ot her e lectrochemical cha nges a re
synthesis, as well as selected test results of the smart
coating w ith pH- sensitive m icrocapsules fo r c orrosion
indication and inhibition.
Corrosion and pH
Corrosion i s la rgely a n e lectrochemical phe nomenon,
because, in most cases, it involves the transfer of electrons
between a metal surface and an aqueous electrolyte solu-
tion. F or i nstance, whe n i ron c orrodes i n ne ar neu tral
often ass ociated w ith it, s o it is expected that materials environments, the typical electrochemical reactions are:
that a re pH o r ot herwise e lectrochemically r esponsive
can be used to detect and control corrosion. The authors Cathodic reaction: O2 + 2H 2O +4e – N 4 OH –
developed a s mart c oating w ith a c ontrolled-release
system that uses pH-triggered release microcapsules for Anodic reaction: Fe N Fe2+ + 2e –
early detection of corrosion and for corrosion protection.
This article describes the relation between pH and corro- In the case of localized corrosion, such as pitting cor-
sion, t he design of pH- sensitive m icrocapsules a nd t heir rosion as shown in Figure 1, the anodic reaction hap-
pens i n a c onfined a rea, t he me tal ion s p roduced a re
precipitated a s s olid c orrosion p roducts, s uch a s i ron(II)
FIGURE 1 | The electrochemical cell set up between anodic and cathodic sites on
an iron surface undergoing pitting corrosion.
oxide, F e(OH)2, (of ten f urther o xidized t o i ron(III) o xide,
Fe(OH)3), wh ich c overs t he mou th of t he p it. Th is c over-
ing traps the solution in the pit and allows the buildup of
Porous cap
hydrogen ion s, H +. The o verall e ffect i s t hat, wh ile lo cal-
O2 + H2O
ized corrosion happens, the anode area often has an acidic
Passive film pH and the cathode has an alkaline pH.1
O2 + H2O CI- Besides p itting, c revice c orrosion a nd d issimilar me tal
OH- corrosion result in pH changes as illustrated by the simple
Fe(OH)3
demonstration sho wn i n F igure 2 , whe re a u niversal pH
indicator was used to show the pH cha nges that occur dur-
ing corrosion of a metal, such as steel. In this demonstra-
e- CI-+ H2O tion, most of t he steel was exposed to agar gel while a s trip
Fe(OH)2
in the middle was wrapped in copper tape. The color change
of the pH i ndicator shows that the exposed steel tends to be
+CI-+ H+ acidic ( yellow c olor) wh ile t he s trip w rapped i n t he c opper
Fe2+ tape tends to be basic (purple color) due to the oxygen reduc-
e- Acid chloride tion reaction and the release of the hydroxide ion, OH-.
pit electrolyte Since pH a nd ot her e lectrochemical cha nges a re of ten
associated w ith c orrosion, i t is e xpected th at m aterials
Iron that are pH or otherwise electrochemically responsive can
be u sed t o d etect a nd c ontrol c orrosion. Various pH a nd
By Luz M. Calle | NASA, Kennedy Space Center, FL; and Wenyan Li, Jerry W. Buhrow and Scott T. Jolley | ASRC Aerospace, Kennedy
Space Center, FL
pH-Sensitive Microcapsules
The a uthors d eveloped a c ontrolled-release s ystem t hat
combines the advantages of corrosion sensing and protec- Slightly 0h 5h
tion by using pH-triggered release microcapsules for early Acidic
corrosion d etection a nd p rotection.2,6,7,8 The key c om-
ponent of th is technology is a pH-sensitive m icrocapsule Neutral
with a wall designed to break down and release the encap-
sulated contents in response to the pH of the cathodic site
Slightly
of localized corrosion (Figure 3).
Basic
PA I N T & C O A T I N G S I N D U S T R Y 䡲䡲䡲 69
or mo re e ster a nd me rcapto g roups. A t ypical c ross- Capsule w all br eakdown u nder ba sic c onditions c an
linker is pe ntaerythritol te trakis ( 3-mercaptopropionate be ob served v isually. F igure 5 sho ws s uch br eakdown
or PTT), a tetra-functional molecule. occurring i n r esponse t o ex posure t o a s mall a mount
Since this crosslinker is not a good film former, other of w ater c ontaining s odium hydroxide, N aOH, ( pH 12).
prepolymers o r mon omers a re ne eded t o p rovide t he Soon a fter t he N aOH s olution w as ad ded, t he s olution
structural integrity of the microcapsule wall. Examples starts to penetrate the microcapsule wall, as indicated by
of f ilm-forming m onomers an d p repolymers in clude the color change inside the microcapsules (Frames b-d).
urea formaldehyde and melamine formaldehyde mono- In Frame e, the microcapsule begins to slowly release its
mers and prepolymers. contents (a s ev idenced by t he s mall d roplet t hat b egins
to form on the bottom left quadrant of the frame). The
FIGU RE 5 | Microcapsule breakdown in basic solution. content c ontinues t o b e r eleased u ntil ( Frame i) it d issi-
pates into the solution. The microcapsule wall eventually
a b c d e f g collapses as shown, in Frames j through n.
Encapsulation Process
h i j k l m n
Encapsulation Methods
pH-sensitive microcapsules are the key c omponent of t he
smart c oatings. S everal me thods s uch a s s pray d rying,
emulsion p olymerization, i nterfacial p olymerization, a s
well as in-situ polymerization have been used to synthe-
FIGU RE 6 | Schematic representation of the steps involved in the interfacial poly- size p H-sensitive m icrocapsules. I nterfacial p olymeriza-
merization of an oil-in-water microemulsion for making oil core microcapsules. Oil tion is illustrated in Figure 6 as an example. There are
is shown in yellow and water in blue. two main steps involved in the interfacial polymerization
Capsule with process: microemulsion formation and microcapsule wall
Surfactant Prepolymer formation. This technique can be used to form both oil (or
polymer wall
hydrophobic) core and water (or hydrophilic) core micro-
capsules. F igure 6 sho ws a s chematic r epresentation of
Oil the s teps i nvolved i n forming oi l c ore m icrocapsules: t he
microemulsion i s fo rmed by ad ding t he oi l pha se ( with
prepolymer, sho wn i n y ellow) t o t he w ater pha se ( with
surfactant, shown in blue) and mixing; the last step is the
formation of the microcapsule wall (shown in green) by
interfacial p olymerization. F igure 7 sho ws a s chematic
representation of the steps involved in forming water core
microcapsules: in this case, the microemulsion is formed
Water by adding water (shown i n blue) to the oi l (with prepoly-
mer and the surfactant, shown in yellow) followed by mix-
ing; the last step is the formation of the microcapsule wall
Addition of oil and Mixing Polymerization (shown in green) by interfacial polymerization.
prepolymer These two illustrations involve the use of oi l, or hydro-
phobic s olvent-soluble w all-forming p repolymer. A s im-
ilar p rocess ha s b een d eveloped t o u se w ater-soluble
FIGU RE 7 | Schematic representation of the steps involved in the interfacial poly- wall-forming ma terials b y d issolving t he wa ll-forming
merization of a water-in-oil microemulsion to synthesize water core microcapsules. prepolymer in the water phase and the catalyst in the oil
Oil is shown in yellow and water in blue. phase. The reaction at the interface will form the capsule.
In situ polymerization is also used to form pH-sensitive
Prepolymer Surfactant Capsule with microcapsules. T he in si tu po lymerization p rocess is
polymer wall
similar t o i nterfacial p olymerization; t heir d ifference i s
the lo cation whe re t he p olymerization r eaction o ccurs.
For i nterfacial p olymerization, r eaction o ccurs at t he
interface; the polymerization reaction occurs in the con-
tinuous phase for in situ polymerization and the polymer
is formed th rough the reaction deposits at the i nterface
Water to form the capsule wall.
Spray d rying i nvolves d ispersing t he wa ll-forming
prepolymer and substance to be encapsulated (the core
material) into a c ontinuous phase (water for instance).
Oil Oil The mixture is sprayed into a mist and in a hot gas flow
where t he l iquid d roplets a re d ried i nto s olid p articles.
In the process, the core material is encapsulated inside
Addition of water Mixing Polymerization the wall materials.
Microcapsule Synthesis
Different a ctive core co ntents h ave b een en capsulated,
including c orrosion i ndicators, c orrosion i nhibitors, dy e
50 μm
and s elf-healing a gents. B oth w ater c ore m icrocapsules
and oi l c ore m icrocapsules w ere s ynthesized u sing t he
FIGURE 9 | SEM images of the water core microcapsule. methods described above.
To t ailor t hese p rocesses fo r e ncapsulating c orrosion
inhibitors an d in dicators, v arious in dicators an d inhi bi-
tors w ere s elected a nd t ested fo r t heir i ndicating a nd
inhibiting e fficiency r espectively. The s olubility a nd d is-
persibility of t he ac tive c ompounds w ere s urveyed o r
tested to find a suitable method for their encapsulation.
An active compound that can be dissolved or dispersed
in a hydrophobic solvent, such as oil, can be encapsulated
into oi l core m icrocapsules. Normally, oi l core m icrocap-
sules a re used for encapsulating oil-soluble materials but
not w ater-soluble m aterials, s uch a s s alts o r p olar mol -
1 µm NASA 10/22/2009 1 µm NASA 10/22/2009
X 3,000 0.30kV SEI GB_HIGH WD 3mm X 7,000 0.30kV SEI GB_HIGH WD 3mm
ecules. However, these materials can still be encapsulated
by dissolving them first into a polar co-solvent and adding
Interfacial p olymerization a nd in si tu po lymerization the r esultant s olution t o t he oi l pha se. A lternatively, a
are t he m ain ap proaches u sed by t he a uthors fo r m icro- surfactant can be added to the oil phase. This will dissolve
capsule synthesis. Spray drying has been used to synthe- or disperse the polar or water-soluble reagents into the oil
FIGURE 12 | Six-month salt fog test results of selected coating systems. Summary
B1-1 B1-2 B1-3
A m ultifunctional s mart c oating fo r t he a utonomous
control of c orrosion i s b eing d eveloped u sing pH- sen-
sitive m icrocapsules. The m icrocapsules a re d esigned
specifically to detect the pH changes that are associated
with the onset of c orrosion a nd respond autonomously
Visit ads.pcimag.com
76 䡲䡲䡲 NOV EMBER 2011 | W W W . P C I M A G . C O M