A Study On Ratio Analysis PDF
A Study On Ratio Analysis PDF
A Study On Ratio Analysis PDF
A PROJECT REPORT
(Faculty Guide)
Dr. Shakti Prasad Tiwari ( Mob:-9430434342)
(Industry Guide)
Md. Tashfeen, Chief Manager (Cost & Budget)
Mr. Roshan Kumar, Assistant Manager (Central Accounts)
Submitted by
Srabani Dutta
Roll No. – 1411004502
Submitted for the partial requirements for the degree of Masters in
Business Administration in Sikkim Manipal University, India.
Page | 2
Student Declaration
has named under my supervision and guidance and no part of this report
has been submitted for the award of any other degree, diploma,
fellowship or other similar title or prizes and that the work has not been
published in journal or magazine.
Srabani Dutta
Examiner:
Name: _________________
Qualification: _________________
Designation: ____________________
Acknowledgement
Page | 5
I express my warm thanks to Mr. Kajal Dey for his support and guidance
at Sikkim Manipal University.
I would also like to thank my project external guide Mr. Md. Tashfeen
from Cost & Budget and Mr. Roshan Kumar from Central Accounts
and all the people who provided me with the facilities being required and
conductive conditions for my MBA project.
Thank you,
Srabani Dutta
Page | 6
Table of Contents
Executive Summary ................................................................................................................... 7
Introduction...................................................................................................................................... 8
Industry Profile ........................................................................................................................... 11
History ............................................................................................................................................. 13
Title: A Brief Study on Ratio Analysis in Eastern Coalfield Limited ............... 16
Company Profile ........................................................................................................................... 17
Research Methodology.............................................................................................................18
Financial Statement...................................................................................................................19
Limitations......................................................................................................................................93
Findings............................................................................................................................................94
Suggestions....................................................................................................................................95
Conclusion.......................................................................................................................................96
Bibliography...................................................................................................................................97
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Page | 7
Classification of Ratios
I. TRADITIONAL CLASSIFICATION
E.g. Gross Profit Ratio, Net Profit Ratio, Operating Ratio etc.
1. Liquidity ratios
a) Current Ratio
b) Quick Ratio
2. Leverage ratios
a) Debt-equity Ratio
b) Current Asset to Proprietor’s fund Ratio
Company Profile
INDUSTRY PROFILE
EASTERN COALFIELDS LIMITED
(A subsidiary of Coal India Limited) Page | 11
Background
SUNDRY DEBTORS
With dawn of the Indian independence a greater need for coal production Page | 13
was felt in the First Five Year Plan. In 1951 the Working Party for the coal
Industry was set up which included representatives of coal industry,
labour unions and government which suggested the amalgamation of
small and fragmented producing units. Thus the idea for a nationalized
unified coal sector was born. Integrated overall planning in coal mining is
a post-independence phenomenon. National Coal Development
Corporation was formed with 11 collieries with the task of exploring new
coalfields and expediting development of new coal mines.
With the Government's national energy policy the near total national
control of coal mines in India took place in two stages in 1970s. The
Coking Coal Mines (Emergency Provisions) Act 1971 was promulgated by
Government on 16 October 1971 under which except the captive mines of
IISCO, TISCO, and DVC, the Government of India took over the
management of all 226 coking coal mines and nationalised them on 1
May, 1972. Bharat Coking Coal Limited was thus born. Further by
promulgation of Coal Mines (Taking over of Management) Ordinance 1973
on 31 January 1973 the Central Government took over the management
of all 711 non-coking coal mines. In the next phase of nationalization
these mines were nationalized with effect from 1 May 1973 and a public
sector company named Coal Mines Authority Limited (CMAL) was formed
to manage these non coking mines.
Coal India is a holding company with seven wholly owned coal producing
subsidiary companies and one mine planning & consultancy company. The
producing companies are:
Eastern Coalfields Limited (ECL) owes its origin to “Raniganj Coalfields” Page | 14
which is the birth place of coal mining in the Country. In 1774, first
mining operation in the Country was started in Raniganj Coalfields by
Sumner & Heatly, a British mining firm at the instance of Warren Hestings
to procure coal mainly for the manufacture of arms and ammunition. In
1820, first Coal Company, M/s. Alexander & Company was established in
India. In 1835, first Indian enterprise, M/s. Carr & Tagore Company was
formed when Raniganj coalfields passed into the hands of Prince
Dwarakanath Tagore, the grandfather of Nobel Laureate Poet
Rabindranath Tagore. In 1843, the first joint stock Coal Company, M/s.
Bengal Coal Company, was formed after amalgamating M/s. Carr &
Tagore Company and another coal company, M/S Gilmore Homfray & Co.
then in existence. Since then, underground coal mining operation had
been continuing in Raniganj Coalfields by numerous small owners.
Raniganj Coalfields remained the principal producer of coal in India in the
19th Century and for a considerable period of the 20th Century.
In 1973, all Non-coking Coal Mines were nationalized and brought under
Eastern Division of Coal Mines Authority Limited. In 1975 Eastern
Coalfields Limited, a Subsidiary of Coal India Limited (C.I.L) was formed
and inherited all the private sector coal mines of Raniganj Coalfields.
Area of Operations
1. Primary Data
2. Secondary Data
1. Primary Data:
It will be collected with the help of interaction with the employee of
ECL, and the internal guide.
2. Secondary Data:
Source like company annual report 2014-15.
Company Profile
Methodology
Period: The Study covers a period of two years data from 2013-14, 2014-
15 mean an Accounting year of the company consisting of 365 working
days.
Accounting Ratios.
Financial Statements of the Company.
FINANCIAL STATEMENT
A financial statement is a organized collection of data according to logical
and consistent accounting procedures. Its purpose is to convey
Page | 19
understanding of some financial aspects of business firm. It may show a
position at a moment in time as in the case of balance sheet or may
reveal a series of activities over a given period of time as in case of
income statement.
a. Status of investments.
b. Results achieved during a given period under review a financial
statement
generally refers to the following;
Page | 20
EASTERN COALFIELDS LIMITED
BALANCE SHEET (CONSOLIDATED)
As at 31st March, 2015
(Rs. In Crores)
I EQUITY AND
LIABILITIES
1) Shareholder’s Fund
a. Share Capital 1 4,269.42 2,218.45
b. Reserves &
Surplus 2 (2716.00) (3804.82)
1,553.42 (1,586.37)
2) Non-Current
Liabilities
a. Long Term
Borrowing 3 164.33 681.29
b. Deffered Tax
Liabilities -- --
c. Other Long
Term 4 18.92 17.99
Liabilities
d. Long Term
Provisions 5 3,135.23 4,042.55
3,318.48 4,741.83
_ _
3) Minority Interest
4) Current Liabilities
a. Short Term
Borrowing 6 129.01 1,714.51
b. Trade
Payables 7 72.56 63.86
c. Other Current
Liabilities 8 3,334.07 2,854.20
d. Short Term
Provisions 9 1,051.41 858.76
4,587.05 5,491.33
Total 9,458.95 8,646.79
II ASSETS
1) Non-Current Assets
a. Fixed Assets
i. Tangible
Assets- Gross 10A 5,276.83 4,863.43
Block
Less: Depreciation,
Impairment & 3,843.25 3,607.44 Page | 21
Provisions
Net Carrying Value 1,433.58 1,255.99
ii. Intangible
Assets- Gross 10A 1,341.88 1,295.49
Block
Less: Depreciation,
Impairment & 1,210.06 1,167.69
Provisions
Net Carrying Value 131.82 127.80
iv. Intangible
Assets Under 10C 80.19 30.36
Development
b. Non-Current
Investment 11 0.08 0.13
c. Deferred Tax
Asset (Net) 91.95 510.99
d. Long Term
Loans & 12 172.71 99.86
Advances
e. Other Non-
Current Assets 13
17.41 16.33
2) Current Assets
a. Current
Investments 14 0.03 0.03
b. Inventories 15 551.02 450.52
c. Trade
Receivables 16 1,426.88 1,720.01
d. Cash & Bank
Balance 17 4,563.88 3,852.00
e. Short Term
Loans & 18 377.81 205.25
Advances
f. Other Current
Assets 19 345.7 270.65
7,265.35 6,498.46
Total 9,458.95 8,646.79
INCOME
Expenses
Finance Costs 28 -- --
Exceptional Items -- -- --
The Notes referred to above form an integral part of Profit & Loss
Account.
EASTERN COALFIELDS LIMITED
CASH FLOW STATEMENT
FOR THE YEAR ENDED 31ST MARCH, 2015
Page | 24
(Rs. In Crores)
31.03.2015 31.03.2014
SHARE CAPITAL
i. 250,00,000 Equity
Share of Rs. 1000.00 2500.00 2500.00
each.
ii. 210,00,000 (P.Y.
NIL), 6% Non
Convertible
Cumulative,
Redeemable 2100.00 --
Preference Shares of
Rs. 1000/- each
4,600.00 2,500.00
Issued, Subscribed &
Paid up :
Note 1.1: Shares in the company held by each shareholder holding more
than 5% Shares.
NOTE – 2
(Rs. In Crores)
AS AT 31-03-2015 AS AT 31-03-2014
RESERVES :
Capital Reserve
As per last Balance Sheet -- --
Interim Dividend -- --
Proposed Dividend on -- --
Equity Shares
Preliminary -- --
Expenses
Pre-Operational -- --
Expenses
Total : (2,716.00) (3,804.82)
NOTE – 3
(Rs. In Crores)
AS AT 31-03-2015 AS AT 31-03-2014
Term Loan
IBRD -- --
JBIC -- --
Secured -- --
Unsecured 164.33 681.29
CLASSIFICATION 2
Loan Guaranteed by
directors & others
NOTE – 4
(Rs. In Crores)
AS AT 31-03-2015 AS AT 31-03-2014
Shifting & Rehabilitation
Fund
Opening Balance -- --
NOTE – 5
(Rs. In Crores)
AS AT 31-03-2015 AS AT 31-03-2014
For Employee Benefits
- Gratuity 256.56 1,515.36
- Leave Encashment 499.71 451.72
- Other Employee 304.14 276.91
Benefits
- -
For Foreign Exchange
Transactions (Marked to - -
Market)
OBR Adjustment Account 1,785.17 1,610.75
Mine Closure 148.06 73.52
For Others (Post Retirement 141.59 114.29
Medical Benefit)
TOTAL 3.135.23 4,042.55
Note 5.1: The year end liability of Gratuity, Leave encashment, Medical
benefit for retired executives and other employees benefit like Group
Personal Accident Insurance Policy, Leave Travel Concession,
compensation to dependents in case of mines accidental death are valued
on actuarial basis.
Note 5.2: Provisions of long term gratuity is after adjustment of gratuity
trust fund balance of Rs. 2042.35 Crores (Rs. 662.31 Crores).
NOTE – 6
(Rs. In Crores)
AS AT 31-03-2015 AS AT 31-03-2014
Loan From Bank -- --
Loans Repayable on
Demand
Balance with Coal India
Limited & other Subsidiaries 129.01 1,714.51
of Coal India Limited
Deferred Credits -- --
Total 129.01 1,714.51
CLASSIFICATION 1
Secured -- --
Unsecured 129.01 1,714.51
CLASSIFICATION 2
Loan Guaranteed by
directors & others
NOTE – 7
TRADE PAYABLES
(Rs. In Crores)
AS AT 31-03-2015 AS AT 31-03-2014
Sundry Creditors For
Revenue Stores 72.56 63.86
Total 72.56 63.86
NOTE – 8
(Rs. In Crores)
AS AT 31-03-2015 AS AT 31-03-2014
Current Maturities of
Long Term Borrowings
FOR EXPENSES :
Unpaid Dividend -- --
Ex-Owner Account -- --
Advance Deposit other Pre- -- --
Nationalisation
NOTE – 9
(Rs. In Crores)
AS AT 31-03-2015 AS AT 31-03-2014
For Employee Benefits
- Gratuity 74.84 76.09
- Leave Encashment 73.60 75.03
- PPLB 261.78 217.39
- PRP 330.29 264.46
- Other Employee 65.57 69.12
Benefits
NOTE - 10 A
FIXED ASSETS
(Rs. In Crores)
Tangible
Assets
Land
a. F 69. 34. (31.85) 72. 5.5 -- (5.58) 0.0 -- -- -- -- 0.01 72. 64.
r 68 90 73 9 1 72 09
e
e
h
o
l
d
Telecom 31. 0.2 -- 31. 18. 1.0 -- 19. -- -- -- -- 19.67 12. 13.
municati 71 8 99 61 6 67 32 10
on
Railway 26. 1.5 -- 28. 19. 0.9 0.94 21. -- -- -- -- 21.78 6.4 6.8
Sidings 75 0 25 91 3 78 7 4
Furniture 10 8.6 -- 11 77. 4.4 4.57 86. -- -- -- -- 86.71 29. 29.
& 7.4 7 6.0 67 7 71 36 73
Fixtures/ 0 7
Office
Tools&
Equipme
nts/Elect
rical Page | 35
Fittings/
Fire
Arms
Vehicle 13. 0.4 (0.26) 14. 11. 0.2 (0.25) 11. -- -- -- -- 11.85 2.2 2.1
96 4 14 84 6 85 9 2
Aircraft -- -- -- -- -- -- -- --
Develop
ment
Intangibl
e Assets
Compute
r
Software
Prospecti 20 0.6 -- 20 13 1.1 (0.20) 13 61. 0.2 -- 61. 199.43 3.9 4.8
ng & 2.7 4 3.3 6.7 6 7.7 06 6 68 5 9
Boring 4 8 9 5
NOTE - 10 B
CAPITAL WORK-IN-PROGRESS
(Rs. In Crores)
COST PROVISION IMPAIRMENT LOSS TOTAL CARRYIN
PARTI G VALUE
CULA As Ad Adj./Sa As As Ad Adj./Sa As As Ad Adj./Sa As Total As As
RS on diti les/Tra on on diti les/Tra on on diti les/Tra on Depreciat on on
01. on nsfer 31. 01. on nsfer 31. 01. on nsfer 31. ion/Impai 31. 31.
04. du during 03. 04. du during 03. 04. du during 03. rment 03. 03.
14 rin the 15 14 rin the 15 14 rin the 15 Loss 15 14
g period g period g period
the the the
per per per
iod iod iod
Tangi
ble
Asset
s
Buildi 19. 29. (20.62) 28. 5.9 0.0 -- 5.9 -- -- -- -- 5.92 22. 13.
ng/W 46 74 58 1 1 2 66 55
ater
Suppl
y
/Road
&
Culve
rts
Plant 12 32 (196.15 25 36. 0.2 (0.01) 36. -- -- -- -- 36.96 21 85.
& 2.3 7.8 ) 4.0 69 8 96 7.1 68
Equip 7 7 9 3
ment
s
Railw 7.1 17. (1.21) 23. 2.6 -- -- 2.6 -- -- -- -- 2.63 21. 4.5
ay 4 81 74 3 3 11 1
Siding
s
Devel -- 0.0 -- 0.0 -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- 0.0 --
opme 8 8 8
nt
Other 4.0 11. (9.71) 5.8 0.9 0.0 -- 0.9 -- -- -- -- 0.98 4.8 3.1
s 8 49 6 5 3 8 8 3
TOTA 15 38 (227.6 31 46. 0.3 (0.01) 46. -- -- -- -- 46.49 25 10 Page | 37
L 3.0 6.9 9) 2.3 18 2 49 6.8 6.8
5 9 5 6 7
Tangi 10 31 (273.31 15 46. 0.1 -0.05 46. -- -- -- -- 46.18 10 61.
ble 7.4 8.9 ) 3.0 09 4 18 6.8 32
Asset 1 5 5 7
s
(As
on
31.03
.2014
)
Note- 10B.1:- Total provision for Tangible Assets upto the end of the period is Rs. 46.49 crores (Rs. 46.18 crores)
NOTE - 10 C
INTANGIBLE ASSET UNDER DEVELOPMENT
(Rs. In Crores)
Intan
gible
Asset
s
Deve 62. 57. (40.13) 79. 10. 0.0 (2.27) 8.2 22. 1.7 (0.35) 24. 32.22 47. 29.
lopm 70 11 68 47 1 1 58 8 01 46 65
ent
Pros 4.8 32. (0.64) 36. 2.7 -- -- 2.7 1.3 -- -- 1.3 4.11 32. 0.7
pecti 2 66 84 3 3 8 8 73 1
ng &
Borin
g
TOTA 67. 89. (40.77) 11 13. 0.0 (2.27) 10. 23. 1.7 (0.35) 25. 36.33 80. 30.
L 52 77 6.5 20 1 94 96 8 39 19 36
2
Intan 54. 46. (33.16) 67. 13. -- (0.74) 13. 19. 4.0 (0.03) 23. 37.16 30. 20.
gible 12 56 52 94 20 97 2 96 36 21
Asset
s
(As
on Page | 38
31.03
.2014
)
Note 10 C. 1: Total provision / Impairment loss upto the end of the year is 36.33 Crores ( 37.16 crores) under intangible
Assets.
NOTE – 11
(Rs. In Crores)
UP -- -- -- --
Haryana -- -- -- --
Maharashtra -- -- -- --
Madhya Pradesh -- -- -- --
Gujarat -- -- -- --
West Bengal -- -- -- --
Others -- -- -- --
Equity Shares in
Joint Venture
Companies (with -- -- -- --
name of joint
ventures)
Equity Shares in
Subsidiaries
Companies (with -- -- -- --
name of
Subsidiaries)
NON-TRADE
7.55% Non
Convertible IRFC
Tax Free Bonds -- -- -- --
2021 Series
Total 0.08 0.13
Aggregate of
Quoted -- --
Investment
Aggregate of
Unquoted -- --
Investment
Market Value of
Quoted -- --
Investment Page | 40
Provision made
for diminution in -- --
the value of
Investment
NOTE – 12
(Rs. In Crores)
AS AT 31-03-2015 AS AT 31-03-2014
LOANS
ADVANCES
For Capital
-Secured considered -- --
goods
-Unsecured considered 162.29 88.57
goods
-Doubtful 3.95 4.80
166.24 93.37
-Secured considered -- --
goods
-Unsecured considered -- --
goods
-Doubtful -- --
172.71 99.86
Note
MAXIMUM AMOUNT
DUE AT ANY TIME
PARTICULARS CLOSING BALANCE DURING
NOTE – 13
(Rs. In Crores)
AS AT 31-03-2015 AS AT 31-03-2014
Long Term Trade
Receivable
- Secured considered -- --
goods
- Unsecured considered -- --
goods
- Doubtful -- --
-- --
Less: Provision for bad and
doubtful Trade Receivable -- --
-- --
Exploratory Drilling Work
- Secured considered -- --
goods
- Unsecured considered -- --
goods
- Doubtful -- --
-- --
Less: Provision for bad and -- --
doubtful
Receivables for Mine
Closure Expenses 1.09 --
Other Receivables
- Secured considered -- --
goods
- Unsecured considered 16.32 16.33
goods
- Doubtful 4.98 5.22
21.30 21.55
Less: Provision for bad and
doubtful Receivables 4.98 5.22
16.32 16.33
Total 17.41 16.33 Page | 43
Note:
NOTE – 14
(Rs. In Crores)
Mutual
Fund
Investm
ent (
with
name of -- -- -- -- --
mutual
fund )
7.55%
Non
Converti
ble IRFC
Tax Free Page | 44
Bonds
2021
Series
TRADE
8.5%
Tax
Free
Special
Bonds
(Fully
Paid
up) :
(on
securitis
ation of
Sundry
Debtors)
Major
State-
wise
Break-
up
(2 Bonds
of `
1,65,000
/- each)
UP 0.03 0.03
Total 0.03 0.03
Aggregat
e of
Quoted -- --
Investm
ent
Aggregat
e of
Unquote -- --
d
Investm
ent
Market
Value of -- --
Quoted
Investm
ent
Market
Value of
Unquote -- --
d
Investm
ent
Provision
made for Page | 45
diminuti -- --
on in the
value of
Investm
ent
NOTE – 15
INVENTORIES
(Rs. In Crores)
AS AT 31-03-2015 AS AT 31-03-2014
Stock of Coal 386.00 299.95
Coal Under Development -- --
Less : Provision 1.76 1.76
A. Stock of Coal (Net)
at lower of cost or 384.24 298.19
net realisable
value
Stock of Stores & Spares 188.06 177.68
(at cost)
Stores -in –transit 0.34 0.06
Less : Provision 38.81 43.97
B. Net Stock of
Stores & Spares 149.59 133.77
(at cost)
C. Workshop Jobs :
Work-in-progress
and Finished Goods 16.50 18.06
E. Stock of Medicine at
Central Hospital (at 0.81 0.70
cost)
F. Prospecting &
Boring/ Development
Exp./Coal Blocks -- --
meant for Sale
Total ( A to F ) 551.02 450.52
Note - 15.1:- Closing Stock of stores at Central and Area Stores have
been valued at weighted average cost. Provision at the end of the year for
Rs. 38.81 crore (Rs. 43.97 crore) consists of the following:
Page | 46
ANNEXURE TO NOTE – 15
TABLE – A
B) Adjustment
in Opening Stock 0.00 0 0.00 0 0.00 0
8. Break-up of
Difference:
9. Closing stock
adopted in A/c. 39.22 43256 4.71 4656 34.51 38600
(6-8A+8B)
NOTE – 16
TRADE RECEIVABLES
(Rs. In Crores)
AS AT 31-03-2015 AS AT 31-03-2014
Debts outstanding for a
period exceeding six
months from the due date
-Secured considered -- --
good
-Unsecured considered 761.31 1142.74
good
-Doubtful 455.07 423.70
1216.38 1566.44
Less: Provision for bad and
doubtful trade receivables 455.07 423.70
761.31 1142.74
Other Debts
-Secured considered -- --
good
-Unsecured considered 665.57 577.27
good
-Doubtful 8.07 --
673.64 577.27
Less: Provision for bad and
doubtful trade receivables 8.07 --
655.57 577.27
Total 1426.88 1720.01
Notes: Page | 48
Note 16.2:-
The details of provision are Rs. In Crore Rs. In Crore
as under: 31.03.15 31.03.14
Opening Provision 423.70 399.39
Less: Settled/Written
off/Adjusted against -- --
opening debtors
NOTE – 17
CASH & BANK BALANCE
AS AT 31-03-2015 AS AT 31-03-2014
Balances with Scheduled
Banks
-SBI Dividend Account Page | 49
(unpaid/unclaimed dividend
account)
-In Deposit Accounts
with maturity upto 3 318.28 529.32
months
-In Current Accounts 219.09 584.43
-In Cash Credit Accounts -- --
Remittance - in transit -- --
Cheques, Drafts and
Stamps on hand 0.83 0.08
Cash on hand 0.57 0.72
2. Deposit for more than 1 (one) year from the date of purchase nil nil
3. Rs. 66.49 crores has been deposited with Union Bank of India towards Mine
closure Escrow a/c during the period.
4. Rs. 8.05 crores has been deposited with Union Bank of India as Interest towards
Mine closure Escrow a/c during the year.
(Rs. In Crores)
AS AT 31-03-2015 AS AT 31-03-2014
LOANS
ADVANCE
( Recoverable in cash or in
kind or for value to be
received)
ADVANCE TO SUPPLIERS
For Revenue
-Secured considered -- --
good
-Unsecured considered 75.21 74.09
good
-Doubtful 0.49 2.50
75.70 76.59
Less: Provision for bad and
doubtful Advance 0.49 2.50
75.21 74.09
75.21 74.09
ADV PAYMENT OF
STATUTORY DUES
Sales Tax -- --
-Secured considered -- --
good
-Unsecured considered 28.03 24.08
good
-Doubtful -- --
28.03 24.08
Less: Provision for bad and -- --
doubtful Advance
28.03 24.08
NOTE – 19
(Rs. In Crores)
AS AT 31-03-2015 AS AT 31-03-2014
Interest Accrued
-Investment -- --
-Deposit with Banks 257.35 127.72
-Others -- --
Ex Owner’s Account -- --
Other Advances 0.06 0.06
Less: Provision -- --
0.06 0.06
DEPOSITS
NOTE – 20
(Rs. In Crores)
OTHER OPERATING
REVENUE (B) 221.99 221.66
NOTE – 21
OTHER INCOME
(Rs. In Crores)
Interest from
Government Securities
(8.5% Tax Free Special
Bonds) (Trade) 7.55% Non -- --
Convertible IRFC Tax Free
Bonds 2021 Series (Non-
Trade)
Income From Others
Interest (Gross)
From deposit with banks 421.89 189.86
From loans and advances to 0.10 0.10
employees
From income tax refunds -- 0.09 Page | 55
From Coal India -- --
Others 0.01 0.01
NOTE – 22
(Rs. In Crores)
C) Change in Inventory
of Closing Stock of Press
Job made finished goods
and WIP (5-6) -- --
-- --
-- --
-- --
Total Change in
Inventory of Stock (84.84) 5.64
(A+B+C )
NOTE – 24
(Rs. In Crores)
NOTE – 25
TOTAL 24.85 --
NOTE – 26
REPAIRS
(Rs. In Crores)
NOTE – 27
CONTRACTUAL EXPENSES
(Rs. In Crores)
FINANCE COSTS
(Rs. In Crores)
Deferred Payments -- --
Bank Overdraft/ Cash Credit -- --
Interest on IBRD & JBIC -- --
Loan
CIL Fund Loan Interest -- --
Interest to Subsidiaries -- --
Others -- --
TOTAL (A) -- --
OTHER BORROWING
COSTS
NOTE – 29
PROVISIONS
(Rs. In Crores)
NOTE – 30
WRITE OFF
(Rs. In Crores)
Others 2.27 --
TOTAL 73.42 127.70
NOTE – 31
OTHER EXPENSES
(Rs. In Crores)
NOTE – 32
(Rs. In Crores)
NOTES – 33
2.3.1 Certain Grant / Funds received under S&T, PRE, EMSC, CCDA
etc. as an implementing agency and used for creation of assets
are treated as Capital Reserve and depreciation thereon is
debited to Capital Reserve Account. The ownership of the asset
created through grants lies with the authority from whom the
grant is received.
2.3.2 Grant / Funds received as Nodal/Implementing Agency are
accounted for on the basis of receipts and disbursement.
5.0 Investments:
Current investments are valued at the lower of cost and fair value
as at the Balance Sheet date. Investments in mutual fund are
considered as current investments.
6.0 Inventories:
11.1 Sales
11.2 Dividend
14.0 Provision:
A provision is recognised when an enterprise has a present
obligation as a result of past event; it is probable that an outflow of
resources embodying economic benefit will be required to settle the
obligation, in respect of which a reliable estimate can be made.
Provisions are not discounted to present value and are determined
based on best estimate required to settle the obligation at the
balance sheet date.
Contingent liabilities are not provided for in the accounts and are
disclosed by way of Notes.
Page | 69
I II
% Quantum
(in Mill.Cu.Mtr.)
NOTE – 34
1. BACKGROUND :
3. INVENTORY:
4. SUNDRY DEBTORS:
A) CURRENT LIABILITIES:
a. As required by section 22 of Micro, Small & Medium
Enterprises Development Act, 2006, as on 31-03-2015
Principal amount remaining unpaid to MSME is ` 0.16 crore (`
0.19 crore) and interest due thereon is NIL (NIL).
B) PROVISIONS: Page | 71
b. The year end provision towards Gratuity, Leave Encashment,
and Gross Personal Accident Insurance, LTA / LTC, Life Cover
Scheme, Settlement Allowances, Fatal Accident Benefits and
Medical Benefits of retired employees has been made on
actuarial valuation as per the certificate given by the Actuary.
As at 31/03/2015
Present Value of Obligation at Beginning of year 25334144509
Acquisition Adjustment 0
Interest Cost 1815831560
Past Service Cost 0
Current Service Cost 1282602212
Curtailment cost 0
Settlement Cost 0
Benefits Paid 5272500000
Actuarial gain/loss on Obligations 2937260348
Present Value of Obligation at end of Year 26097338630
6.1 Coal issued to employees (free issue) amounting to Rs. 10.68 crore
(Rs. 17.65 crore) and for internal consumption amounting to Rs.
75.27 crore (Rs. 76.68 crore) are accounted for on the basis of
norms fixed by the management and valued at related grade selling
price and the same is exhibited in the accounts as a specific contra.
6.2 Subsidy from appropriate authority for stowing and protective work
undertaken during the year amounting to Rs. 49.58 crore (Rs.
58.65 crore) has been shown under Other Income (Note – 21).
Subsidy receivable out of the same amounting to Rs. 11.88 Crore
(Rs. 45.28 crore) has been shown under Other Current Assets (Note
– 19).
6.3 Depreciation on fixed assets for the year has been calculated on the
basis of the useful life of assets prescribed as per Schedule II of the
Companies Act 2013 (effective from Financial Year 2014-15
onwards) instead of that being followed as per Schedule XIV of the
Companies Act 1956 hitherto. This change has resulted in the profit
for the year being lower by Rs. 84.67 Crore.
6.4 A) During the year based on technically estimated useful life
depreciation rates of the following assets are revised:
SL No. Assets Useful Life
1 Photocopy Machine 4
2 Fax Machine 3
3 Mobile Phone 3
4 Digitally enhance cordless telephone 3
5 Computer (including printer & scanner) 3
Dumper Up to 50T 7
Hydraulic Shovels up to 1.2 CUM 7
Hydraulic Shovels up to > 1.2 to 2.2 7
Hydraulic Shovels up to >2.2 to 5.0 CUM 7
Hydraulic Shovels up to > 5.0 to 10.0 CUM 7
B.H.Drill < 160mm 6
6.5 Export Sales: Sales includes Export Sales of coal, in Indian Rupee
terms, to Dumgsam Cement Corporation Limited Bhutan, details of
which is as under:
Page | 74
Quantity Coal Value Gross Value
3720.29 Tonne Rs. 1.33 Crore Rs. 1.83 Crore
8.b
(*) Does not include coal issued for domestic consumption by Employees
and boiler consumption of 2.50 lakh tonnes ( 2.77 lakh tonnes)
(**) Net surplus/shortage – (-) NIL lakh tonne { Nil lakh tonne}.
13. GENERAL:
The Bench also directed the Company to file auditor’s certificate stating
status of the net worth of the Company along with its current Balance
Sheet immediately after implementation of the unimplemented part of the
sanctioned scheme.
State Bank of India vide its letter dated 1st November 2014 to ECL
proposed modification of terms of relief and concession from CIL from
“Waiver of unsecured loan of Rs. 519 Crore and conversion of Current
Account Balance of Rs. 1532 Crore as on 31st March 2003 into Equity
Share Capital” to “issue of nonconvertible, redeemable, cumulative
preference shares for an aggregate value of Rs. 2051 Crores to CIL by
ECL in full satisfaction of Unsecured Loan and Current Account Balance as
on 31st March 2003”.
Page | 77
After detailed deliberation in 310th CIL Board Meeting held on 8th
November 2014 and as recommended by Audit Committee, Board
accorded its approval to convert Unsecured Loan of Rs. 519 Crore and
Current Account Balance of Rs. 1532 Crore, aggregating to Rs. 2051
Crore, as on 31st March 2003 of ECL with CIL into fully paid-up 6% non-
convertible, cumulative, redeemable, Preference Shares of face value of
Rs. 1000/ - each to CIL. The Preference Shares are to be redeemed on
expiry of 7 years from the date of issue and allotment. However, CIL
would have the option to redeem at any time after the expiry of 5 years
from the date of issue and allotment. Redemption of preference shares
shall be at the face value (no redemption premium). Annual cumulative
dividend is 6%.
Accordingly Authorized Capital of ECL was raised from Rs. 2500 Crore to
Rs. 4600 Crore (Refer Note 1) and in the 275th ECL Board meeting held
on 25th December 2014 the Board approved the proposal for offer and
allotment of Preference Shares amounting to Rs. 2050.97 Crore to CIL.
On 26th December 2014, 20509700 6% non-convertible, cumulative,
redeemable, Preference Shares of Rs. 1000/- each amounting to Rs.
2050.97 Crores was allotted and issued to CIL, in accordance with the
above, and consequently the net worth of ECL became positive.
Having considered the submissions made during the hearing and material Page | 78
on record, the Bench issued the following directions inter-alia:
13.8 MAT Credit Entitlement: During the year the Company is required
to pay Minimum Alternative Tax (MAT)as the same exceeds the normal
Income Tax payable for the year. MAT credit being the excess of MAT
over the normal Income Tax payable is recognized as an asset – “MAT
Credit Entitlement” for adjustment against the normal Income Tax during
the specified period under the Income Tax Act, in accordance with
the recommendation contained in the guidance note issued by the
Institute of Chartered Accountants of India. The Company shall review the
“MAT Credit Entitlement” at each Balance Sheet date and make necessary
adjustment during the specified period.
Company Secretary
a. Shri V. R. Reddy
Besides the above, Directors have been allowed to use car for private
journey up to a ceiling of 750 Kms. per month on payment of Rs. 400/-
per month as per service rules.
Balance with Subsidiaries of Coal India Limited:
Name of Company Amount (Debit) Amount (Credit)
Bharat Coking Coal Limited 17,48,146.60 --
Central Coalfields Limited 13,32,382.45 --
Western Coalfields Limited 8,12,213.08 --
CMPDIL 2,46,85,124.00 --
Northern Coalfields Limited 4,62,681.10 --
South Eastern Coalfields 27,99,07,314.56 --
Limited
Mahanadi Coalfields Limited 18,47,729.25 --
Balance with Coal India Limited (Holding Company): Rs.
1,29,01,16,099.58 (Credit).
Page | 80
3. AS – 20 Earning per share: Earnings per share is calculated by
dividing the profit earned by the company for the year with the
weighted average number of equity share of the company
outstanding during the year as per details given below :-
i) Profit during year ended 31ST March, 2015 – Rs. 1,139.40
Crore
ii) Weighted average number of shares - 22184500 Nos.
EPS - (Basic & diluted) (a/b) – Rs. 513.60
16.0 Figures of the previous year have been regrouped, re-arranged and
recast wherever necessary in conformity with those of the current year.
Analysis and Interpretation of Ratio
1. Current Ratio:
This ratio indicates the rupees of current assets available for each rupee
Page | 83
of current Liability. By this ratio we can see the stability of the firm or
short term financial position of the firm.
The ratio is calculated as follows;
Ratio
1.6
1.4
1.2
1
Ratio
0.8
0.6
0.4
0.2
0
2014-15 2013-14
Interpretation:
Page | 84
Ratio
1.6
1.4
1.2
1
0.8 Ratio
0.6
0.4
0.2
0
2014-15 2013-14
Interpretation:
3. DEBT-EQUITY RATIO:
It measures the relation between debt and equity in the capital
structure of the firm. In other words, this ratio shows the
relationship between the borrowed capital and owner’s capital, this
ratio shows relative claim of the creditors and shareholders against
the assets of the company.
This ratio is calculated as follows,
Debt Equity Ratio=Long Term Debt/Shareholder’s Fund
2.5
Page | 85
2
1.5 Ratio
1
0.5
0
2014-15 2013-14
Interpretation:
Ratio
3
2.5
2
Ratio
1.5
1
0.5
0
2014-15 2013-14
Interpretation:
Ratio
20.00%
15.00%
Ratio
10.00%
5.00%
0.00%
2014-15 2013-14
Interpretation:
Higher ratio, say more than 75% shows lesser dependence on external
sources.
Lower ratio, say less than 60% shows more dependence on external
sources.
Ratio
8
7
6
5
Ratio
4
3
2
1
0
2014-15 2013-14
Interpretation:
9
Page | 88
8
7
6
5 Ratio
4
3
2
1
0
2014-15 2013-14
Interpretation:
8. Return on Investment:
This ratio helps indicate how much return the company has earned
per rupee of capital invested in the business. Here return refers to
net profit and investment to capital employed in the company.
Ratio Page | 89
60
50
40
Ratio
30
20
10
0
2014-15 2013-14
Interpretation:
11.5
Page | 90
11
10.5
Ratio
10
9.5
9
2014-15 2013-14
Interpretation:
A company with high net margin ratio would ensure adequate return to
the owners as well as enable a firm to withstand adverse economic
condition when selling price is declining, cost of production is rising and
demand for the product is falling. It would really be difficult for a low net
margin ratio company to withstand these advantageous.
40
Page | 91
30
Ratio
20
10
0
2014-15 2013-14
Interpretation:
Ratio
3
Ratio
2
0
2014-15 2013-14
Interpretation:
Higher the ratio better is the utilization of capital employed and shows the
ability of the firm to generate maximum profits with the minimum amount
of capital employed.
Page | 92
12. Return on Net Worth:
This ratio is similar to Return on equity share capital ratio, the only
difference is that the denominator should not be restricted to paid
up capital alone. It should include Reserves and surplus as well.
Ratio
80
60
Ratio
40
20
0
2014-15 2013-14
Interpretation:
Page | 93
1. Ratios become reliable only when they are based on correct data.
2. Since ratios based only on data of two years cannot reveal much,
they are not found to be much useful.
3. They cannot help much in decision making as they are based on the
past. Sometimes standard ratios are used for budgeting.
4. Accounting data should be compiled on uniform basis, otherwise
meaningful inter-firm and inter-period comparison will not be
available.
5. It may appear from the ratios that, as if, a particular factor is
responsible for the ups and downs in a business. But financial
results are the outcome of various factors, like general economic
condition, Changes in price level, local factors, specific competition,
management policy.
FINDINGS
Page | 94
1. The Current ratio is below the standard ratio and it is not good from
company’s point of view. It shows that it is not good position to
meet the short term liabilities.
2. The liquidity ratio is according to standard ratio (1:1) and it is good
from company’s point of view. It shows the company is able to meet
its liabilities is short period.
3. The debtor turnover ratio is good. It shows the collection of debtors
is very prompt.
4. Net profit Ratio in the 2013-14 was 9.81% but in the 2014-15
increased 11.37% it shows favourable of the company.
SUGGESTIONS
Page | 95
Page | 96
Page | 97
BOOKS
WEBSITES
www.google.com
www.easterncoal.gov.in
www.coalindia.org.nic