Analysing Customer Satisfaction: Consumer Behaviour of Young Persons in The Textile Industry
Analysing Customer Satisfaction: Consumer Behaviour of Young Persons in The Textile Industry
Analysing Customer Satisfaction: Consumer Behaviour of Young Persons in The Textile Industry
Abstract
The aim of this survey is to examine the tendencies and consumer behaviour of the
young toward clothing and make clear the several factors that influence a young
person during the purchase process and categorize them into the traditional buyer
models or try to find out another one new model.
A survey was conducted in order to achieve our objectives with 267 young people
with rate of respond 46, 44% (124). The young people that finally composed the
sample come from various financial and educational levels. We interviewed them
using a questionnaire consisted from a variety of 19 questions divided in tow
categories (12 ordinal and 7 nominal). In our statistical analysis we worked with
Descriptive Statistics in order to group the variables given from the questionnaire and
carry out useful results.
1
The objective of this research is to examine the repercussions of the psychological
and social influences inflicted on the customer during the decision – making process.
Issues treated by this research include: effects of motives in consumer behaviour,
decision –making, loyalty to the brand, the relationship with the product, assessment
of attitudes and their changes, social and cultural effects on consumer attitude, typical
consumer models, applications related to market segmentation, product positioning
and promotion, as well as the share of preference enjoyed by clothing companies.
Our main results have to do with the reasons that a young person makes a buying
process. We have a group of people who are traditional buyers and they buy just to
cover their needs and other, who buy because they recognize buying process as a
game or a kind of entertainment and they want to show their financial class and their
status through the purchase and use of expensive brand name.
In the globalization era, when the sector in question is under various kinds of
pressure (large department store chains, illegal trade, low – cost imported products
such as Chinese ones etc) and the Greek clothing retail business is going through a
crisis, especially as far as the single proprietor is concerned, this research and its
results, can produce important answers as to what factors influence a young person
during the purchase process, what can urge them into making a purchase and what the
additional product oriented services they consider indispensable for a company.
Our suggestions for future research should be carried out and focus on the satisfaction
of young people after buying process and the factors that influence and increase this
satisfaction.
The outcomes and implications for practice of this paper is that it gives useful answers
in the question “which is the factors that influence a buyers behaviour?” and can give
some suggestions about the additional services that a company should offer to the
customer such as parking services, after sales services, pre-sales services or about the
way and the time that the companies should develop their product promotion and their
strategic marketing plan.
2
On the one hand, this paper makes clear the whole service pack that a young person
requires from a textile company. On the other hand, after a lot of years when today’s
young person will became parents we can make clear if their nowadays behaviour is
influenced only by their age or it is a diachronic and constant behaviour.
Introduction
In the shade of the socio-economic crisis that dominates in the unified world-wide market,
the need for study and analysis of modern consuming tendencies that conditions the
consuming environment, becomes easily perceptible
A lot of researches, such as that of Jen-Hung Huang, Bruce C. Y. Lee and Shu Hsun Ho,
which was published in 2004 in the International Marketing Review, verify the general
perception that the purchasing force of consumers is influenced by market’s conditions and
influences the market too, as much on an international level or on a local. Also, more
researchers in the world deal daily with the observation of tendencies that condition the
consuming market.
The sector of clothing constitutes one of the largest consuming categories. The latest
tendencies of fashion and most innovations of the market of clothing are addressed mainly to
the young persons.
Worthy of report is the fact that in the current societies, the consumers “buy” the real
transaction of purchase with all ritual. More analytically, they visit shops, they look at the
shop windows, and they make market research before they proceed to some purchase and
finally are guided to the item that covers better their needs. As Hetherington said indeed in
1992, a lot of economists consider that there exists an entire ritual, a classification of factors
of festive nature in the culture of consumerism.
3
By the end of the 80’s, changes are observed in the preferences of Greek consumers
in reference to the categorization of needs but also to the pecuniary compensation that they
use for the acquisition of goods. More concretely, the degree of reaction of the Greek
consumer to changes of the available for consumption income shows that nowadays clothing
and footwear do not constitute a priority contrary to the categories of health, transports and
communications, entertainment, education and services. Nevertheless, the forecasted
tendency of consuming expense for the category of clothing appears according to is ascendant
and at least for the last decade, to touch upon a percentage almost equal to what had been in
the late 80’s. This development is mainly the result of a continuous increase in the national
income in this decade and an increase improvement in the naturally available income of
households.
The present research studies the consumer behavior and the satisfaction of the
modern Greek consumers. It researches into the views of young persons aged 18-27 years as
for their preferences in clothing and the factors that influence their purchasing behavior. The
study and analysis of the consumer as deciding is also remarkable. Emphasis is given in the
strategic repercussions of the psychological and social influence that the consumer undergoes
during the process of decision-making. Finally, an equally important aim is the examination
of models of consumer behavior. Subjects that should be covered include: influence of
motives in the behavior of the consumer, decision-making, elaboration of information,
perceptions, concentration in the brand name of product, product’s marketing mix,
measurement and change of attitudes, social and cultural effects in the behavior of the
consumer, models of consumer behavior, applications in the apportionment of the market, the
placement and the promotion of products.
2. Literature review
2.1. Consumer Behaviour.
Definition: The official definition of consumer behaviour is given by the American
Marketing Association as: the dynamic interaction of the affect and cognition, the
behaviour and environment through which people carry out transactions in their life.
(Bennett 1995, page 59).
4
• By (human) decision making (over time).
(Prof. Dr. Maggie Geuens, Consumer Behaviour, 1999)
Consumer receives stimuli which affect on his consuming behaviour. This stimuli
comes from:
• The financial environment (favourable or ominous financial conditions).
• The political environment (smoothly or foggy political setting).
• The technological environment (technological progress or recession).
• The company’s marketing mix as for the product, the price, the place and the
promotion. (E.g. a television advertising spot or a handing-over in the price of
product).
This model implies that consumers pass through all five stages in buying a product.
This may be the case in high-involving purchases. In low-involvement purchases,
consumers may skip or reverse some of these stages. This model shows the full range
of considerations that arise when a consumer face a highly involving new purchase.
5
(Prof. Dr. Maggie Geuens, Consumer Behaviour, 1999)
Those questions find answers through the study of the factors that influences
consumer’s behaviour. Those factors are separated in four categories: social, cultural,
demographical and psychological. Those factors and its categories are the following:
1. CULTURAL FACTORS
Culture: Culture (or civilization) is the highest entity of personal identification with
the society. These entities were in the past the nations and could be in the future the
civilizations (Western, Muslim, Hindi, Chinese). Humane behaviour is largely
learned. The growing child acquires a set of values, perceptions, preferences and
behaviours through a process of socialization involving the family and other
education institutions.
Subculture: Each culture consists of smaller subcultures that provide more specific
identification and socialization for its members. We can distinguish several
subcultures in the different countries. We can distinguish:
• National groups (immigrants, Europeans and non-Europeans)
• Religious groups (Catholics, Protestants, Orthodox, Muslims, and Jews)
• Geographical areas (Regions, regional identity)
6
2. SOCIAL FACTORS:
Social class: “Social classes are relatively homogeneous and enduring divisions in a
society, which are hierarchically ordered and whose members share similar
values interests and behaviour” Social classes show distinct product and brand
preferences in such areas as clothing, home furnishing, leisure activities,
automobiles, and food and beverages. (KOTLER, 2000, p. 161)
Social roles and statuses: A person participates in many groups throughout life such
as family, clubs, and organizations. The person’s position in each group can be
defined in terms of role and status. A role consists of the activities that a person is
expected to perform according to the persons around him or her. Each role carries a
status reflecting the esteem accorded to it by society. Roles and statuses are at the
same time dynamic and static phenomena:
o they change with the economic and social progress (land owner, entrepreneur)
o People with higher status like to remain their position.
People choose products that communicate their role and status in society. But status
symbols vary for social classes and also geographically.
Reference group: “A person’s reference groups consist of all social groups that have
a direct (face to face) or indirect influence on the person’s attitudes or behaviour”
(KOTLER, 2000, p. 163-164). We distinguish different reference groups:
o Membership groups are the groups to which the person belongs.
o Non-membership groups are the groups to which a person not belongs, but
which influence the attitudes and behaviour of the person.
o Aspiration groups are groups to which a person would like to belong.
o Dissociate groups are groups whose values or behaviour are rejected.
3. PSYCHOLOGICAL FACTORS
Personality: The total internal characteristics of an individual that determines the way
how he reacts. (E.g. self-monitoring, self-concept, sociability, etc).
7
Self-concept: The picture or the perception that each individual has for his exterior
appearance, his mental faculties, his character and generally speaking what concerns
the individual as a social being.
Lifestyle: It expresses the values that an individual has in their life. It constitutes
important variable of market segmentation.
Motivation.
Perception: The process, with which an individual selects, organises and it interprets
incomes of information with an aim to create a reasonable picture for the world.
Beliefs and attitudes: The total knowledge from advertises or other promotion
energies, but also personal experiences, that the individual - consumer acquires and
maintains in his memory. Configuration of specific beliefs and attitudes for specific
products, specific brands, specific retailers, even though for specific production
countries.
4. PERSONAL FACTORS.
Age and life-cycle stage: People buy different goods and services over their lifetime.
They eat baby food in the early years, most foods in the growing and maturing years,
and special diets in the later years.
Lifestyle: People coming from the same subculture, social class, occupation but may
lead different lifestyles. A person’s lifestyle in the person’s pattern of living in the
world as expressed in the persons activities, interests, and opinions. Lifestyle portrays
the “whole person” interacting with his or her environment.
Occupation: A person’s consumption pattern is also influenced by his or her
occupation. A white-collar worker will buy other clothing and food as a blue-collar
worker.
Economic circumstances consist of their:
o spendable income
8
o savings and assets
o borrowing power
o Attitude toward spending and saving.
To sum up, we can conclude that consumer’s behaviour in interaction with the factors
that influenced it can be attributed concisely with the following diagram:
9
in extant definitions: 1) consumer satisfaction is a response (emotional or cognitive); 2) the
response pertains to a particular focus (expectations, product, consumption experience, etc.);
and 3) the response occurs at a particular time (after consumption, after choice, based on
accumulated experience, etc). As can be seen by examining Table 1, these three general
categories capture the essence of all the definitions presented. As expected, existing
definitions are inconsistent in the specifics associated with the type, focus and timing of the
satisfaction response.
TABLE 1
Conceptual and Operational Definitions in Consumer Satisfaction Literature
Tse and
Source The consumer’s
Conceptualresponse
Definition to the Response
Response Perceived
Focus Post
Time
Wilton evaluation of the perceived discrepancy to the discrepancy between consump
1988 The consumer’s
between fulfilment response.
prior expectations (or some It evaluation prior expectations (or tion
is a judgment
norm that a product
of performance) and the or actual
service some norm of
feature, or the product
performance of the or serviceasitself,
product Fulfilment performance) and the During
Oliver Product or
provided
perceived (orafter
is providing) a pleasurable
its consumption (p. response/judg actual performance consump
1997 service of
level of consumption-related
204). fulfilment, ment the product tion
Cadotte, including levels
Conceptualized as aoffeeling
under-developed
or over Feeling Use experience During
Woodruff fulfilment (p. 13)
from an evaluation of the use developed consump
and experience (p. 305). from an Product tion
Halstead,
Jenkins A transaction-specific affective evaluation performance During
Hartman,
1987 response resulting from the customer’s
Affective compared to or after
and
Westbroo comparison of product
Global evaluative performance
judgment about to Global Product During
response some consump
Schmidt
k 1987 some
productprepurchase standard (e.g.,
usage/consumption Hunt evaluative
(p. 260) usage/consumption consump
prepurchase tion
1994 1977;
AlsoOliver 1989)(1977).
cited Hunt (p. 122). judgment tion
standard
LaBarber Post purchase evaluation. Cited Attitude -
Evaluation Surprise Post
(Product satisfaction) is an attitude -
aMano
and Oliver’s
like (1981) definition:
post consumption An
evaluative
evaluative purchase
Post
and
Mazursk evaluation of the surprise inherent in a judgment Product
judgment (Hunt 1977) varying along Product consump
yOliver
1983 product acquisition and/or consumption
the hedonic continuum (Oliver 1989;
Varying along acquisiti
tion
1993 experience (p. 1991)
394). (p. 454). the hedonic on and/or
Westbrook and Oliver
continuum consump
Post purchase tion
perceived experien
product ce
Fornell An overall post purchase evaluation Overall Post
Westbroo An emotional response to the Emotional performance
Experiences provided Postpurc
1992 (p.11). evaluation purchase
k and experiences provided by and associated response compared
by and with
associated hase
Reilly with particular products or services withprepurchase
particular
1983 purchased, retail outlets, or even molar productsexpectations
or services
Westbroo patterns of behaviour such as shopping purchased, retail
A post choice evaluative judgment Specific
k and andconcerning
buyer behaviour, as well as the Evaluative outlets, or even molar Post
a specific purchase purchase
Oliver overall marketplace (p. 256). An judgment patterns of behaviour choice
selection (Day 1984) (p. 84). selection
1991 emotional response triggered by a such as shopping and
cognitive evaluative
No conceptual process(With
definition. in which
the buyer behaviour
Oliver thesalesperson)
perceptions aoffunction
(or beliefs about) an Perceptions of (or
of fairness, During
and Swan object, action, or condition are Salesperson
beliefs about) an
preference, and disconfirmation (pp. purchase
1989 compared to one’s values (or needs, object, action, or
28-29).
wants, desires) (p. 258). condition are
compared to one’s
values
Churchill Conceptually, an outcome of purchase Outcome Comparison of the Implies
and and use resulting from the buyer’s rewards and costs of after
Surprena comparison of the rewards and costs of the purchase relative purchase
nt 1982 the purchase relative to anticipated to anticipated and use
consequences. Operationally, similar to consequences
attitude in that it can be assessed as a
10
summation of satisfactions with various
attributes (p. 493).
As concluded by the literature review and validated by the group and personal
interview data, there appears to be three essential components of consumer
satisfaction:
11
1. Summary affective response which varies in intensity;
2. Satisfaction focus around product choice, purchase and consumption; and
3. Time of determination which varies by situation, but is generally limited in
duration. (Giese and Cote / Defining Consumer Satisfaction, 2002)
Dissatisfaction.
Conceptualizing dissatisfaction has received relatively little attention in consumer
research. The existing research in the area has examined the unidimensionality of the
satisfaction / dissatisfaction construct (Maddox 1981; Swan and Combs 1976).
Researchers have taken two approaches to conceptualizing and operationalizing the
dissatisfaction construct:
• Consumer dissatisfaction is portrayed as the bipolar opposite of
satisfaction (e.g., Mittal, Kumar, and Tsiros 1999 (completely
satisfied/very dissatisfied) Spreng, MacKenzie, and Olshavsky 1996
(very satisfied/very dissatisfied));
Or
12
• Consumer satisfaction and dissatisfaction are viewed as two
different dimensions (e.g., Mano and Oliver 1993 and Westbrook
and Oliver 1991 use unipolar satisfaction and unipolar
dissatisfaction measures).
Methodology
Structure of questionnaire
In order to study the need of clothing satisfaction in young persons a research
was held with the help of a suitable questionnaire. The questionnaire is constituted by
19 questions of closed type, which is divided into:
• 12 categorical (nominal) and,
• 7 ordinal, questions.
For the achievement of the research objectives a questionnaire of Vidal Diaz
Rada from the University of Navarre, was used (a single consumer or different types
of consumer, 1998) translated and modified according to the needs and the aims of
research but also according to the Greek reality.
13
The recording of place of realization of purchases.
The consuming satisfaction from the purchases that they realize.
The factors that influence the consumers in their purchases.
The satisfaction that they feel from the process of purchase.
Their preferences, by means of a list of the most popular companies of clothing.
For the answers was selected the fifth degree Linkert scale from “Disagrees
Absolutely” (1) until “Agrees Absolutely” (5). Finally, categorical and ordinal questions of
closed type were used. For the statistical analysis the statistical parcel SPSS was used. As
statistical analysis method, the descriptive statistics were used, which contribute in the
inferences of useful conclusions with the calculation of meters as the medium, the median, the
top, the breadth, the quadrants as well as the frequencies. Also for the better optical
comprehension of results were used histograms.
Selection of sample
The research took part in the wider region of Athens which demographically covers
the 40% of the country. We were addressed to the 5,57% of young persons who lives in the
wider region of Attica aged from 18 to 27 years (GREEK NATIONAL STATISTICAL
ORGANISATION). That corresponds the 1,48% of young persons in entire country (GREEK
NATIONAL STATISTICAL ORGANISATION). We were addressed in 267 individuals
form which only 124 were supplemented and filled the specifications, so the rate of the
successful answering is 46, 44 %.
14
Demographic elements
The age mean of the asked persons is the 21 years. The 43, 5% asked is men and the
56, 5% women.
43,50%
56,50%
Mean 1359,55
Median 1000
15
Mode 1000
Std. Deviation 1400,33
Skew ness 4,306
Std. Error of Skew ness ,218
Range 9800
Minimum 200
Maximum 10000
With a first view to the following diagram and to the table where is presented
the means of annual expenses of men and women we observe that there does not exist
difference in the amount that is expended by these two categories. It is more verified
also with a t - test by which it is checked if the means are same. So it is examined the
hypothesis m1=m2 (m1 the mean of men and m2 of women). From this control of
hypothesis check it results that m1=m2.
60
50
40
30
20
Q17
Percent
10
GYNAIKA
0 ANTRAS
M
30ssin
40 ,0
500,0
60 0
700,0
75 0
900,0
10 0
1200
13 0 0
15 0, 0
1800 0
23 ,
3000 0
50 ,
i
0 g
0, 0
0, 0
0, 0
0
5 ,0
00,00
00,00
00 00
,0
,0
0
Q15
16
MAN N 54
Mean 1361,57
Std. Deviation 1508,87
WOMAN N 69
Mean 1357,97
Std. Deviation 1320,47
17
3,28 1,123
STRATEGIC
LOCATION
2,97 1,309
ALTERNATIVES OF
PAY
2,79 1,385
CAPABILITY OF
PARKING
Examining the preference of consumers for the type of shop that is selected for
the purchases of clothing goods, is concluded that big part of new purchasers does not
prefer the ward shops (percentage of negative answers roughly equal with 65,3%), the
stock houses (77,4%), and hypermarkets (rate of refusal 97,6). The commercial
centers and department stores assemble the bigger percentage of positive answers. Of
course it has to be pointed out that for the department stores and commercial centers
the negative and positive answers are shared. Simply we consider these two categories
the most preferable market locations because the remainder categories present very
small percentage of positive answers.
In search of tendency for the prevailing regions that prefer the young persons for
their purchases the Centre assembles the biggest percentage of preferences (40,
3%). The region of Piraeus constitutes the second pole of attraction (22, 6%).
18
CALVIN KLEIN ,27 ,447
Table 6: Below is given the table with the means of each variable that concerns
the types of consuming behavior.
19
Mean Std. Deviation
Usually I decide the moment 3,94 1,993
where I buy something
3,76 1,134
I like to get dressed with
clothes which are in fashion
I like visit new shops 3,70 1,018
When I do shopping I appreciate 3,50 1,016
more the quality than the price
I like to accompany the others 3,21 1,233
when they go for shopping
The goods I buy are important 3,12 1,024
because they increase the quality
of life
I feel embarrassed when I see 2,91 1,319
somebody wearing the same
clothes with me
Usually I buy goods which I did 2,41 1,028
not intend to buy
The quality despite the price is something that is considered seriously by the
consumers and this appears from the affirmative answer in the relative question.
(Table 7). Very important element constitutes also the observation that big
percentage of sample is positive in clothing that is in-fashioned.
Conclusions
Considering the importance of the classic variables such as age, sex, education and social
place, becomes easily understanding that from the present research comes out a question.
20
“How much the traditional consuming behavior is opposed to the current consuming behavior
of young persons?” It was realized that there are consumers who mainly buy goods aiming to
the satisfaction that they will have for some of their basic needs and some other – the young
persons that they come from a safety socio-economic environment – who breaks the
traditional consuming habits through selecting expensive brand-name products for reasons
such as prestige and social projection. In a lot of cases the last ones, byes goods that probably
will never use because for them, the process of purchase is a way of entertainment,
characterizing thus their consuming behavior as total absurd.
In our opinion, this behavior is an outcome of a particular social growth and, even if
behavior of young persons could change from certain social circumstances in a given
moment, in long run will return in the same situation when these circumstances change again.
In the next years, when the current parents will become older and the youth replace them,
will be possible to be examined in which point this behavior is based in the age factor of
youth, or if their behavior it is actually a result of a social process.
References:
21
22