TSPP8
TSPP8
TSPP8
SPECIFICATION FOR
March 2010
© National Grid plc 2010 – All rights reserved
T/SP/P/8
CONTENTS Page
FOREWORD iii
BRIEF HISTORY iv
KEY CHANGES iv
1. SCOPE 1
2. REFERENCES 2
4. QUALITY SYSTEM 2
5. EQUIPMENT 3
6. WELDING PROCESS 3
7. WELDING CONSUMABLES 4
14. RECORDS 16
TABLES
FIGURES
2 WELDING POSITIONS 36
APPENDICES
A REFERENCES 39
B DEFINITIONS 41
FOREWORD
This Specification was approved by Gas Engineering Policy Manager on 20/03/2010 for use
by Managers, Engineers and Supervisors throughout National Grid Gas.
National Grid Gas documents are revised, when necessary, by the issue of new editions.
Users should ensure that they are in possession of the latest edition by referring to the
Document Library of safety and engineering documents available on the company intranet.
Compliance with this safety and engineering document does not confer immunity from
prosecution for breach of statutory or other legal obligations.
BRIEF HISTORY
KEY CHANGES (Identifies the key changes from the previous document)
Section Amendments
DISCLAIMER
This safety and engineering document is provided for use by National Grid Gas and such of
its contractors as are obliged by the terms and conditions of their contracts to comply with this
document. Where this document is used by any other party it is the responsibility of that party
to ensure that this document is correctly applied.
In this document:
Should: indicates best practice and is the preferred option. If an alternative method is used
then a suitable and sufficient risk assessment shall be completed to show that the alternative
method delivers the same, or better, level of protection.
SPECIFICATION FOR
WELDING OF STEEL ONSHORE NATURAL GAS INSTALLATIONS DESIGNED TO
OPERATE AT PRESSURES GREATER THAN 7 BAR
1. SCOPE
This specification contains the requirements for the welding of carbon, carbon manganese
and low alloy steels used in the construction of onshore natural gas installations designed to
operate at pressures greater than 7 bar, but not exceeding 100 bar in accordance with the
recommendations given in IGEM/TD/1 (Section 11 - Installations) and IGEM/TD/13.
All welding, excluding connecting field welds of sub-assemblies and diversionary pipe work
within the confines of the installation site, shall be carried out in a workshop.
This specification details requirements for the production of welded joints that meet national
and international welding standards. Welds produced to this specification are considered
equivalent in quality to welds produced to BS 4515-1 or to BS EN 12732 (category D) quality
requirements.
In case of conflict between this specification and the codes, standards and specifications
referenced in Appendix A, the requirements of this specification shall apply.
Subject to the approval of the Employer, Skid Unit pipe-work may be manufactured to an
alternative national or international welding standard. If the use of an alternative welding
standard is agreed by the Employer, then the manufacturer or contractor shall submit a
Project specific welding fabrication and inspection specification to the Employer for approval
(see Appendix G).
2
The SMYS of the pipe shall not exceed 555 N/mm (i.e. grade L555 or X80) and all pipe,
fittings and attachments used shall comply with the National Grid specifications listed in Table
1. Should the Employer approve the use of alternative pipe or fittings not manufactured in
accordance with the specifications given in Table 1, the design of the pipe or fitting shall be fully
compliant with National Grid design requirements and the mechanical and chemical properties
of the pipe or fitting should comply with the applicable specification listed in Table 1.
.
This specification is not intended for the welding of carbon steel pipelines (see T/SP/P/2) or
the in-service welding of pressurised pipe work (see T/SP/P/9) and shall not be used for the
production of pipe work intended for the processing or transportation of sour natural gas.
2. REFERENCES
This specification incorporates requirements from other referenced publications and unless
specified by dated reference, the latest edition of the document, including all addenda and
revisions shall apply. The documents referred to are listed in Appendix A.
3.1 Definitions
For the purposes of this specification the definitions given in BS 499-1 and BS EN 13622
apply. Additional definitions of terminology used in this specification are listed in Appendix B.
3.2 Abbreviations
4. QUALITY SYSTEM
The manufacturer or contractor should apply the quality management system principles stated in ISO
9001. To ensure effective quality control of all *stages of the welding process, a quality management
system typical of that described in BS EN ISO 3834-1 and BS EN ISO 3834-2 shall be adopted. With
prior agreement of the Employer, other technically equivalent supporting standards and documents
may be substituted for the documents specified in BS EN ISO 3834-5.
* To include as a minimum, the planning, design, qualification, execution, inspection, testing and
recording stages.
The manufacturer or contractor shall ensure that all information necessary to carry out the welding
process to the requirements of this specification is complete and available prior to work commencing
(see Table 2).
The manufacturer or contractor shall ensure that their project Quality Plan incorporates the
specific items subject to approval by the Employer (see Table 3).
4.3 Sub-contracting
The use of a sub-contactor by a manufacturer or main works contractor shall be subject to the
approval of the Employer (see Table 3). Any sub-contractor shall work under the order and
responsibility of the manufacturer or main works contractor and fully comply with the relevant
requirements of this specification (see BS EN ISO 3834-2).
5. EQUIPMENT
Welding equipment shall be suitable for the welding process employed and be calibrated and
maintained in a condition that allows production of acceptable welds, continuity of operation
and the safety of personnel. Arc welding equipment shall be capable of operating and
controlling the welding parameters detailed in Table 4 within the limits stated in the approved
WPS sheet. Equipment that does not meet this requirement shall either be repaired or
replaced.
The manufacturer or contractor shall provide calibrated arc monitoring equipment that is
independent of the welding plant. It shall be used to record welding process or procedure
qualification parameters and for the surveillance of production welding. The equipment shall
be made available to the Employers Inspector for monitoring purposes when requested.
Note: Copper contact tips and backing strips when used should be checked regularly for
damage which could indicate copper contamination of welds.
Pipe handling equipment, rollers and line up clamps shall be such that they avoid damage to
the pipe and fittings, ensure that axes are aligned in accordance with 10.4 and Table 9 and
allow the unhindered application of the welding procedure.
6. WELDING PROCESS
This specification covers the following manual or partially mechanised welding processes:
111 Shielded Metal Arc welding
121 Submerged Arc welding
131 Metal Inert Gas welding
135 Metal Active Gas welding
136 Tubular cored Metal Arc welding with active gas shield
137 Tubular cored Metal Arc welding with inert gas shield
141 Tungsten Inert Gas welding
Note: Welding processes are numbered in accordance with BS EN 4063.
6.1 Welding process and welding system approval
When required by the Employer, the manufacturer or contractor shall demonstrate that any
proposed welding process, combined welding process, or welding system has the technical
capability to consistently produce sound welds with the desired metallurgical properties using
the approved welding procedure.
The extent of any welding process or welding system consistency trials shall be agreed
between the manufacturer or contractor and the Employer. This should preferably be agreed
at tender or contract award stage and in all cases shall be prior to the welding of procedure
qualification welds.
As a minimum, the consistency trials shall include sufficient test welds to qualify the proposed
welding procedure, followed by five consistency test welds made using the approved welding
procedure.
All consistency trial and welding procedure qualification test welds shall be subject to the
destructive tests specified in Appendix C of this specification and in the event of specimen
failure, any additional tests required by the employer. The number of CTOD test specimens
(when required), will be specified by the Employer or shall be agreed between the Employer
and the manufacturer or contractor prior to welding commencing.
One of the five consistency welds (chosen at random by the Employer) shall be subject to full
destructive testing. The extent of CTOD testing for this weld may be varied by agreement between
the Employer and the manufacturer or contractor prior to welding commencing. The test welds shall
fully meet the specified acceptance criteria.
Where a gas or self shielded flux cored wire process is proposed (either individually or as part of a
combined process procedure), all five consistency test welds shall be subject to full destructive
testing. The extent of mechanical testing for these welds may be varied by agreement between the
Employer and the manufacturer or contractor prior to welding commencing.
7. WELDING CONSUMABLES
7.1 General
Welding consumables shall be approved by the Employer before use (see 4.2 and Table 3)
and shall be in accordance with the classification standard applicable to the proposed welding
process (see Table 5).
The chemical composition of the deposited weld metal shall be compatible with the materials
being welded and shall provide adequate resistance to degradation of the pipe work from the
contents under the intended operating conditions. The Employer will indicate whether specific
compositional controls are required (see Table 2).
When tested in accordance with clause C.5.1, the weld metal produced by any of the above
welding processes or combination of these processes, shall have a tensile strength greater
than the parent material.
The weld metal tensile strength of joints between dissimilar materials, when tested in
accordance with C.5.2, shall meet the specified minimum tensile strength of the higher
strength parent material.
When tested in accordance with clause C.5.2 the weld metal yield strength of welds in pipe
material of L555 or X80 grades shall overmatch the SMYS by at least 5%.
Welding electrodes or consumables achieving the low hydrogen requirements of Scale D, as
defined by BS EN 1011: Part 2; shall be used to weld all un-pupped fittings equal to or greater
than 914mm OD (see Appendix B).
When submerged-arc welding wire and flux combinations are proposed for use they shall, as
a minimum, achieve the low hydrogen requirements of Scale C as defined by BS EN 1011:
Part 2 (see Appendix B).
Limitations apply to the use of Cellulosic coated electrodes to weld L555 or X80 pipe grades
and fittings with a diameter equal to greater than 914mm OD (see Table 3).
Shielding gases used shall be in accordance with BS EN ISO 14175.
7.2 Storage and Handling
All consumables shall be identified by type, classification and individual batch number.
Different grades and types of welding electrodes and welding consumables shall be stored
separately.
The manufacturer or contractor shall produce a welding consumable storage and handling
procedure for approval by the Employer. In addition to the requirements of the storage
recommendations provided by the consumable manufacturer, any special measures identified
by the contractor for the storage, handling and the use of welding consumables in the field
(e.g. vacuum packaging of electrodes at a location other than the manufacturers factory) shall
be fully described in this procedure.
At the discretion of the Employer, the manufacturer or contractor shall be required to perform
such additional tests that demonstrate that the storage and handling of welding consumables
has not lead to any deterioration of the required consumable specification or properties.
Welding consumables that show sign of damage or deterioration shall not be used.
Submerged-arc welding flux shall only be recycled or re-dried in accordance with the flux
manufacturer’s recommendations.
Where there is a requirement for mixed gases to produce field welds, the gas mixtures shall
be provided in proprietary pre-mixed gas bottles supplied by the gas manufacturer and shall
not be mixed in the field.
Compressed gases shall only be stored and handled in accordance with industry guidelines
and best practice.
8.1 GENERAL
All testing qualification and approval of welding procedures shall be in accordance with BS
EN ISO 15614-1 (except where amended by this document) and Appendix C of this
specification.
In case of conflict between this specification and BS EN ISO 15614-1, the requirements of
this specification shall apply.
The welding and testing of all procedure qualification test joints shall be witnessed by the
Employer or the Employer’s representative
* That remains valid within the changes affecting approval given in BS EN ISO 15614-1 and Table
4a & 4b of this specification.
Previously qualified welding procedures will not be considered where one or both of the pipe
materials joined are L555 (or X80) grade or an equivalent material.
9.1 General
All welders and welding operators shall be qualified in accordance with BS EN 287-1, except
where amended by the requirements of this specification.
For the purpose of welder qualification, set-on branch attachment welding shall be classed as
a butt weld. Subject to satisfying the welding procedure essential variables listed in Table 4,
butt welds may qualify fillet welds. Where the majority of the work is fillet welding, the welder
shall be qualified by an appropriate fillet weld test. Simulation of a fillet weld using flat plate is
permitted (see Table 3).
9.2 Positional Welding
The welder’s test for butt welds in pipe shall include the PF and/or PG positions as specified
by the qualified welding procedure (see Figure 2). The test shall demonstrate the ability of the
welder to produce an acceptable joint by welding in all the positions covered by the qualified
welding procedure. Alternatively at the discretion of the Employer, a welder may be qualified
on the first production weld, not to include fittings. This shall include not less than 100% of
one side of a complete weld joint from 12 o’clock through to 6 o’clock position or the
equivalent specified welding positions. The range of qualification for welding positions is given
in BS EN 287-1, Table 7.
For single process mechanised welding, each welder or welding operator shall be qualified for
all parts of the operation of making the joint (except where they are not required to make an
internally deposited root pass).
Non-destructive testing shall be carried out in accordance with T/SP/NDT/2. All test welds
shall meet the acceptance criteria specified in Table 8.
Destructive testing of butt welds shall be carried out in accordance with BS EN 287-1 or when
needed to confirm interpretation of non-destructive testing results.
If any tests fail to comply with the requirements of BS EN 287-1 and it can be established that
the cause of failure is not due to the welder’s skill level, the welder shall be allowed to
produce one further test weld for examination, with the approval of the Employer or his
nominated representative. No further re-tests shall be permitted until proof of further training
of the welder is submitted by the manufacturer or contractor to the Employer.
The welder’s qualification shall remain valid for two years from the date of successful testing
of the test piece. Every six months the welder’s production performance shall be reviewed to
confirm that the welder has been satisfactorily working within the initial range of qualification.
Providing that evidence (see BS EN 287-1) is available to confirm this, the welder’s
qualification remains valid. If the required evidence is not available the welder shall be re-
tested.
9.7 Records
A complete record of all tests and re-tests undertaken by the welder shall be produced and
maintained by the manufacturer or contractor on a welder qualification test certificate for each
National Grid contract. The certificate shall satisfy the requirements of BS EN 287-1.
10. PRODUCTION WELDING
10.1 General
Adequate provision shall be made for the removal of welding fumes and dust at the
workplace, the provision of PPE shall be considered a secondary level of employee
protection.
All welding, including tack welding shall be performed by qualified welders in accordance with
the approved WPS.
All fittings shall be welded in accordance with the approved WPS and the weld completed in a
single heat cycle. Welds produced using process 111 (shielded metal arc) for joints in the
fixed horizontal position shall have the root run deposited in the vertical up direction (PF/5G -
see Figure 2).
Copies of the approved welding procedures shall be available at the work location. Welders
and Welding Inspectors shall be fully familiar with the approved welding procedures.
Full penetration forged set-in branch welds adjacent to circumferential or longitudinal welds
shall normally be not less than 100 mm apart.
Set-on welded attachments and fillet welds shall have a weld toe-to-toe distance from any
other weld of not less than four times the pipe thickness or 25 mm whichever is the greater.
The Employer shall be informed of any deviation to this requirement and will decide whether
the joint may be welded or whether further modification to the pipe-work is required to ensure
compliance.
In-situ welding of fittings (equal to or greater than 457 mm outside diameter) during the
assembly of installation pipe work should have pipe-pups welded to them under fabrication
shop conditions before being welded in the field. The pup length shall be not less than 250
mm.
When space restrictions prohibit bends, tees or valves fitted with pipe-pups being installed or
results in a fitting being welded to a fitting, special care shall be taken with the joint set-up and
the application of pre-heat.
The production route shall be planned to ensure that, where necessary, back grinding of root
beads and inspection of the root weld is maintained. This is particularly important for fittings
e.g. set-in sweep-o-let type (see Table 2). To facilitate welding, repair and inspection, the use
of pipe-pups interposed between fittings and branches is preferred.
Pipe ends shall be bevelled by machining or machine thermal cutting (which may be manually
or mechanically operated). Manual thermal cutting shall not be used. Alternatively, with the
approval of the Employer the bevel may be produced by grinding to the dimensions specified
in the WPS.
With the approval of the Employer, minor imperfections such as burrs, small score marks,
indentations or similar flaws on the bevel face shall be removed by grinding or the joint shall
be fully *re-prepared. Correction by grinding may be approved providing that the specified
bevel dimensions are maintained within the specified tolerances.
*Most bevel configurations designed for welding by automatic or fully mechanised processes
are produced by machining and subsequently may be intolerant of bevel flaws or damage.
Damage to the surface of the pipe or fitting by bevelling machines shall be repaired by
dressing. After dressing the remaining wall thickness shall be measured to confirm that the
thickness of the pipe or fitting remains within the permitted tolerances of the material
specification.
The manufacturer or contractor shall ensure that the bevelled surface and the adjacent pipe
or fitting surface shall be free of scale, rust, paint, grease, fins, tears, moisture or other foreign
matter immediately prior to welding. Cleaning to base metal shall extend a minimum of 25mm
from the edge of each fusion face on both the external and internal surfaces of the joint.
Pre-fabrication weldable primers may be applied and left on fusion faces provided that it has
been demonstrated during welding procedure qualification that they do not adversely affect
the quality of welding or produce unacceptable fumes.
The non-destructive requirements for ultrasonic testing of cut pipe ends and pipe areas for
welded attachments, is specified in T/SP/NDT/2.
Fusion faces not complying with these requirements shall be re-prepared before welding.
All coatings other than fusion-bonded epoxy (FBE) shall be cut back not less than 150 mm.
Except for FBE, all coatings and their adhesive mastics shall be prevented from attaining
temperatures sufficient to cause the emission of toxic fumes. Where a non-FBE coating has
been cut back, all traces of adhesive mastic shall be removed. Scraping, blast cleaning or a
suitable stripping agent is an acceptable removal method. The removal by heating shall not
used.
Consideration shall be given to providing personnel protection and effective collection and
disposal of fumes particularly in cases where a polyethylene or urethane coating may be
heated during the welding process to temperatures that cause the emission of toxic fumes.
Fumes from coating removal and welding can be particularly hazardous in confined spaces.
10.5 Alignment
For pipes, fittings and valves of different nominal wall thickness, joint alignment shall be
achieved in accordance with T/SP/P/16.
Prior to welding commencing the manufacturer or contractor shall submit a method statement
for the correction of excessive joint misalignment for approval by the Employer.
Correct joint alignment shall be achieved prior to welding and shall ensure that:
• Line up clamps shall be used to support and align the weld joint wherever possible.
When the internal root offset (after rotation of the abutting ends to achieve best
alignment) is greater than the tolerance range given in Table 9, excessive
misalignment shall be corrected in accordance with the approved method statement
before welding.
• No force other than that exerted by approved line up clamps shall be used to spring
or superimpose additional stresses on any component for alignment purposes during
construction.
• Mitres at welded joints are not permitted. Angular misalignment at the weld of less
than 3° is not classed as a mitre, and is acceptable provided that the misalignment is
equally distributed on both sides of the joint to a maximum of 1.5° per side.
• For socket joints, the pipe end must be inserted fully into the socket and then
withdrawn 2.0 mm + 0.5 mm - 0 mm (see Figure 1). This gap is vital to the integrity of
the finished joint. The assembly shall be checked to be squarely aligned and any
necessary adjustment made prior to tack welding (see 10.7 and 10.7.2).
When required by the Employer the contractor shall demonstrate that the correct alignment
and expansion spacing has been achieved for socket welded joints by destructively testing a
production weld chosen at random by the Employer or their representative. Alternatively, the
joint can be examined by radiography to confirm the original joint fit-up.
Line up clamps shall be used where practicable to align and hold components prior to and
during welding. Any other method of alignment shall be approved by the Employer prior to
use (See Table 3). Under no circumstances shall brackets, cleats or other temporary
attachments be welded to the components for alignment purposes.
Internal line up clamps shall not be released before completion of the root run or at a later
stage specified on the qualified WPS. External line up clamps shall not be released until at
least 50% of the root run, equally spaced around the joint, has been completed. The joint
shall remain fully supported either side of the weld during welding.
When external line-up clamps are used, precautions shall be taken to minimize coating
damage. Such clamps, and also earth returns, must not be dragged along the pipe but lifted
into place. When using mechanised welding machines, the support frames shall be
adequately padded and the buttons, on externally fitted bands, shall be profiled to eliminate
coating damage.
Tack welding (excluding bridge-tacks) shall be carried out in accordance with that part of the
approved welding procedure that is used for the root run. Pre-heating shall be in accordance
with the approved WPS. The tack welds shall be of suitable shape and profile to be
incorporated in the root run and shall be free of cracks or other unacceptable defects. Tack
welds which include unacceptable defects or have cracked shall be completely removed prior
to welding.
When the joint is to be welded using a fully mechanised or automatic welding process, the
type and extent of tack welds (if required) shall be specified in the WPS.
10.7.1 Bridge-tacks
Bridge-tack welding may only be carried out when approved by the Employer. The
manufacturer or contractor shall submit a bridge tack welding procedure for approval by the
Employer.
Bridge–tack welding shall be carried out in accordance with that part of the approved welding
procedure that is to be used for welding the filler passes.
Pre-heating shall be in accordance with the approved bridge tack welding procedure.
The number of bridge-tacks required per joint shall be as specified in Table 10. The bridge-
tack welding procedure shall as a minimum describe the following items:
• The maximum diameter of pipe that may be bridge-tack welded and then moved to
another position or location to complete the weld.
* Removal of bridge-tack welds shall be by grinding and care shall be taken to maintain the
original bevel preparation.
When socket joints have reached the minimum pre-heat temperature, the assembly may be
tack welded in accordance with Table 10 in order to maintain alignment during the welding
cycle. The tack welds must be equally spaced. When welding pipes in the horizontal position,
the tack welds must be placed at the 3 o'clock and 9 o'clock positions. The tacks shall be
ground smooth and the ends tapered to ensure fusion of the remainder of the weld run.
Weather canopies or habitats must be of adequate size to provide unhindered access for all
heating, welding and inspection activities. Provision shall be made for adequate welding
fume extraction.
Material affected by an arc strike, shall with the agreement of the Employer, either be repaired
or rejected. Not more than one arc strike per weld may be repaired and two or more arc
strikes will be cause for the complete removal of the weld and damaged pipe material.
Where the Employer agrees that an arc strike may be repaired, it shall be removed in
accordance with a documented procedure that defines the methods for mechanical removal
of the defective material, blending of the excavation, magnetic particle inspection and
ultrasonic wall thickness measurement of the dressed area to confirm that the pipe or fitting is
within permitted tolerances.
With the prior agreement of the Employer in each case, weld deposition repairs to restore
pipe wall thickness shall only be carried out to an approved welding procedure specific to this
type of repair. The repaired area shall be examined using complimentary NDT methods
capable of detecting all surface and sub-surface weld defects in any orientation.
The application of a weld deposition repair is limited to pipe material grade ≤ L450 (or X65)
2
and shall not be carried out on pipe material with a SMYS ≥ 485 N/mm (X70).
Weld deposition shall not be applied to pipe work that will be subject to pressure cycling that
could affect the designed fatigue life of the component.
10.13 Preheating
10.13.1 General
Preheating shall be uniformly applied to the components to be welded by gas or electrical
methods. The minimum preheat temperature to be applied and the method of heating shall be
in accordance with the approved welding procedure. A zone of at least 75 mm from each side
of the weld (extending completely around the circumference of the joint for pipe work welds)
shall be maintained at the specified temperature.
The method of electrical heating proposed by the manufacturer or contractor shall be
approved by the Employer.
Oxy-propane heating shall only be used with the agreement of the Employer and when
permitted, used in the qualification of the welding procedure. Measures shall be taken by the
manufacturer or contractor to prevent component materials being overheated and where
applicable to prevent unnecessary damage to the component coating.
The minimum preheating and weld inter-pass temperatures shall be as specified in Table 11
(unless a higher pre-heat temperature is required based on the results of material weldability
trials or if specified in the manufacturer or contractor’s proposed welding procedure).
10.13.2 Preheating
The joint shall be preheated to the minimum temperature specified in the WPS and shall not
exceed this temperature by more than 50°C.
* The method of thermocouple attachment and removal shall be approved by the Employer.
The weld inter-pass temperature shall not fall below the minimum pre-heat temperature
specified in the approved welding procedure specification (see Table 11).
Where air-arc gouging is undertaken, both components shall be pre-heated to the minimum
temperature specified in the repair welding procedure prior to air-arc gouging commencing
(see Table 11).
Guidance is given in Appendix D of this specification for the post weld heat treatment of
welded joints, the PWHT welding procedure shall be to an appropriate standard e.g. BS 2633.
10.15 Branches
All branch connections shall be at right angles to the pipe, they shall be made using
specialised fittings (e.g. forged or pressed tees, or forged set-in or set-on components) in
accordance with the requirements of T/SP/PW/11: Part 1
Where pipes are to be lagged, branch connections shall have not less than 100 mm of plain
pipe before any flanged fittings, to ensure that the fittings are clear of the lagging.
The spacing of branches on the main pipe and the length of flanged branches shall allow
access for welding and subsequent NDT.
Prior to cutting out a branch opening in a main pipe, ultrasonic examination of the area of
branch attachment shall be carried out in accordance with the requirements of T/SP/NDT/2.
Branch connections and branch openings in the main pipe shall be cut by machine or by
thermal cutting methods. The edges of the pipe shall then be prepared by filing or grinding to
the dimensions specified in the approved WPS (see also 10.2 and 10.3).
Branch fittings shall be fully supported during alignment and welding. Special jigs or clamps
may be required to support set-in type fittings (see 10.6).
A constant root gap shall be maintained during deposition of the root run. Tack welding shall
be in accordance with 10.7. The use of an internal weld bead shall only be permitted when
specified in the approved WPS.
The welding of socket joints shall be completed in a single heat cycle, with care being taken
to prevent overheating of the pipe and fitting during welding (see Table 11).
For horizontal socket joints, unless otherwise agreed by the Employer, welding shall be in the
vertical-up direction (PF). Socket fillet weld leg lengths shall be equal. The weld profile shall
not be concave, i.e. the fillet weld throat thickness must be greater than 0.7 times the leg
length. Care shall be taken to prevent the top edge of the socket fitting being removed or
melted.
The weld shall be visually inspected between runs to ensure that slag and other visible flaws
or deposition faults have been identified and removed before welding continues.
Particular attention shall be paid to the cleanliness of the junction between the weld metal and
the fusion faces. Clusters of surface porosity, individual pores and/or high points shall be
removed by grinding. Where necessary, stops and starts may be ground smooth to ensure
fusion of the subsequent weld run pick up.
The cause of any visible cracks or crack-like indications found during welding shall
immediately be investigated by the manufacturer or contractor and reported to the Employer
or to the Employers representative.
Should a crack be confirmed then the complete joint shall be cut-out and removed. When a
crack-like indication is proven not to be a crack, it may be *removed by grinding and the joint
completed.
* Any delay to the normal welding cycle shall be within the maximum welding time-lapse
requirements specified on the WPS.
Where production conditions are such that welds have to be left partially completed, the
following conditions shall apply:
• The minimum number of runs deposited shall be as stated on the approved WPS.
• Upon discontinuation of welding the weld shall be fully supported and allowed to
cool in a slow uniform manner.
• The movement of partially welded joints shall be subject to the approval of the
Employer. Partially completed welds shall not be moved unless the joint can be
fully supported during transportation.
• Prior to recommencement of welding, the joint shall be dry and reheated to within
the specified inter-pass temperature range stated in the approved WPS.
When the final weld run(s) is completed the joint shall be thoroughly cleaned using hand or
power tools. The weld cap shall be visually examined and any deposition faults or
unacceptable defects remedied before the joint is finally allowed to cool below the minimum
inter-pass temperature. All weld spatter shall be removed taking care not to damage the
component surface in any way.
* If the Employer requires an alternative time delay prior to the NDT of qualification test welds or
production welds this shall be agreed with the manufacturer or contractor prior to welding
commencing.
* Supplementary NDT methods to be used to examine welds that will not be hydrostatically
tested (golden welds) are specified in T/SP/NDT/2.
All inspection personnel shall be qualified in the appropriate grade for the duties they are to
perform (see T/SP/NDT/2).
12.1 General
The results of all visual inspection and NDT carried out to examine the weld shall be collated
and the quality of the joint determined in accordance with the acceptance criteria given in 12.2
and Table 8. Should the Employer require a higher acceptance standard to be applied for the
flaw types described in Table 8, then this shall be specified by the Employer in the contract
documents.
Engineering critical assessment (ECA) shall not be used to establish acceptance criteria for
welds made in accordance with this specification.
The Employer can reject any weld that appears to meet the weld acceptance criteria specified
in Table 8 if, in the opinion of the Employer, the depth of the flaw is considered detrimental to
the weld. In such cases the flaw shall be removed by grinding and repaired in accordance
with the approved WPS.
Should a dispute arise between the manufacturer or contractor and the Employer regarding
the depth of a particular flaw in a weld and it is possible to *accurately measure the depth of
the flaw using a supplementary NDT method then, subject to the approval of the Employer,
the alternative method of measurement shall be employed.
Surface breaking flaws shall not exceed a depth greater than 10% of the pipe thickness, or
1.5 mm whichever is the smaller. Embedded flaws shall not exceed a depth greater than 25%
of the pipe thickness, or 3 mm whichever is the smaller. Branch welds are excluded from
these tolerances and shall either be repaired or removed.
* The accurate measurement of the height or depth of a surface breaking or embedded weld flaw
shall take into account any inherent sizing error ± values associated with the combined system
performance.
13.1 General
No weld shall be repaired without the approval of the Employer. The manufacturer or
contractor shall record and report to the Employer all remedial and/or repair welding carried
out to each welded joint. Welds that fail to meet the requirements of clause 12 and 13.4 shall
either be repaired locally or the weld shall be completely removed.
The requirements for qualification of remedial or repair welding procedures for butt welds are
given in clause 8, Appendix C , C.3.2 and Table C.2.
Defects or flaws in butt or fillet welds shall be removed by chipping, machining, grinding or air-
arc gouging, followed by grinding. If air-arc gouging is used, preheating shall be applied prior
to metal removal (see 10.13.4 and Table 11). When air-arc gouging is used for a full
penetration repair, the last 3 mm of the original weld shall be removed by mechanical means,
such as grinding.
The weld repair excavation shall be sufficiently deep and long enough to ensure complete
removal of the defect or flaw. A gradually taper (e.g. one in one) shall extend from the weld
surface to the base of the excavation at each end. The angle or slope of the sides of the
excavation shall be in accordance with the approved WPS.
Repairs shall be limited to 30% of the weld length for a partial penetration repair or 20% of the
weld length for a full penetration repair. If repairs cannot be completed within the stated
tolerances the joint shall be completely removed.
Complete welds shall be removed by mechanised thermal or cold cutting methods, such as
machining.
13.3 Re-welding
Weld repairs shall be carried out in accordance with a written repair welding procedure
specification. The welding procedure details contained therein shall be in accordance with the
original approved WPS or to a qualified and approved repair WPS.
During production welding, single woven and multiple pass external weld cap repairs shall
match the original weld profile and width and shall be in accordance with the approved WPS.
Repair welding shall only be performed by qualified welders. Separate welder qualification
tests may be required for repair welding subject to the limitations of clause 9.
Weld repair shall only be implemented under constant supervision and shall be monitored by
the Employer’s and the manufacturer or contactors representative in accordance with the
approved quality plan (see 4.3).
Multiple attempts to repair a weld are not permitted unless specifically approved by the
Employer (See Table 3).
Weld repair areas shall be subject to the same level of inspection as the original weld joint
(see T/SP/NDT/2).
NDT of the repair area shall extend for a minimum of 25 mm from the weld toe on each side
of the repaired portion of the joint and beyond each end of the repair excavation.
Surface weld repairs that do not involve re-welding, for example the removal of excessive
internal root penetration by grinding, may not require examination by the original NDT method
used to establish the presence of the flaw or defect. However, the repair method used to
remove the flaw or defect including the subsequent visual examination and re-measurement
to establish acceptance shall be recorded. The Employer shall approve any proposed repair
methods and subsequent re-examination methods prior to production welding commencing.
Should re-examination of the repair area reveal further flaws or defects they shall be
evaluated as new flaws or defects in accordance with clause 12.
14. RECORDS
Records shall be produced by the manufacturer or contractor to confirm that the requirements
specified in this document for welding, examination, inspection and testing of each weld have
been met. The records shall ensure complete identification and traceability for all activities
associated with the planning, design, qualification, execution, inspection and testing of the
welded components.
The records shall include but not be limited to, when applicable:
• Quality plan.
• Material inspection documents.
• Welding consumable documents.
• Preliminary welding procedure (pWPS).
• Welding-procedure qualification records (WPQR).
• Welding-procedure specifications (WPS).
• Heat-treatment procedure specification and records.
• Welder or welding-operator qualification certificates.
• Non-destructive testing and destructive testing procedures and reports.
• Non-destructive testing personnel certificates.
• Dimensional reports.
• Records of remedial welding, weld repairs and non-conformance reports.
• Any other pertinent documents, when required.
Valves T/SP/V/6
New procedure 8 9 10
to be qualified
Results acceptable to code or specification Produce WPS
submit to
8a 8b 8c 8d 8e Employer for
Procedure Retest or Re-test acceptable – go to stage 9 Issue for production welding
approval and
unacceptable produce a new Re-test failed or correct any
Review cause of test weld as Reject Return to stage
procedure errors found.
failure applicable procedure No.1
unsuitable
Stage 11 12 13 14 15 17
Produce pWPS
and submit to
Confirm that all All essential variables met Employer with
essential WPQR for
Review materials variables approval
to be welded and Select and relating to the
Previously 14a 16
select appropriate review previous qualified WPS Issue for production welding
qualified WPS
welding process WPQR data meet the Revise pWPS
Essential Return to stage
and procedure requirements for when required
variables No.1 and 2 or 11
the new by Employer
infringed and 12 as
materials and re-submit
appropriate.
for approval
Table 4b A guide to the application of the material grouping system and corresponding T/SP/P/8 Tables
Apply the following stages when assessing the suitability of a previously qualified welding procedure
a)
1.1 ● - - - - - -
a)
1.2 ● ● - - - - -
a)
1.3 ● ● ● - - - -
a)
2.1 ● ● ● ● - - -
a)
2.2 ● ● ● ● ● - -
a)
3.1 ● ● ● ● ● ● -
a)
3.2 ● ● ● ● ● ● ●
Notes:
a) Covers the equal or lower specified yield strength steels of the same group.
b) The range of qualification may not apply to test welds or production welds which involve post
weld heat treatment.
Dimensions in millimetres
Thickness t of line
pipe tested
Steel Steel Steel
2 2 2
Re ≤ 290N/mm Re >290 to ≤ 360N/mm Re >360N/mm
• Qualification of a higher yield strength material will cover a lower yield strength
material in the same range but not vice-versa.
• Where more than one thickness of project pipe will be used within the yield strength
ranges given above, the thicker pipe shall be used to qualify the welding procedure.
• The range of qualification for the steel materials used shall be that permitted by BS
EN ISO 15614-1 and Table 6.
≤ 114.3 mm 3 25 mm
> 457 mm 4 50 mm
Notes:
2. The tack welds shall be of suitable shape and profile to be incorporated in the root run
(see 10.7).
Minimum
Minimum
weld
Component Material Grade Wall thickness preheating
1 inter-pass
temperature
temperature
See applicable
Air –arc
All All WPS to be -
gouging
used
Notes:
2. Socket joint assemblies shall not be heated above 150°C care shall be exercised to
prevent overheating of the pipe and fitting.
3. When welding socket assemblies adjacent to isolation joints or ball valves, the body
of the component shall not be allowed to exceed a temperature of 50°C for an
isolation joint or 100°C for a ball valve respectively. These components shall only be
welded under constant supervision.
Visual 100%
-
Radiographic or
Production butt ultrasonic testing 100%
1.
Surface crack 100%
2.
detection
Visual 100% -
-
Visual 100%
1. The primary method and any supplementary method of weld examination shall be agreed
with the Employer.
2. Surface crack detection of the root run of fitting welds is required subject to safe access to
the internal surface. The manufacturer or contractor shall agree the limits of safe access with
the Employer prior to welding commencing.
3. Radiographic testing is only required when needed to confirm acceptable expansion gap
fit-up of sockets joints (see 10.5).
4. The primary method and any supplementary method of weld examination shall be agreed
with the Employer (see 11.1 and T/SP/NDT/2).
Flat
PA
Horizontal vertical Horizontal vertical
PB PB
Horizontal Horizontal
PC PC
PD
PD
Horizontal overhead Horizontal overhead
PE
Overhead
PF / PG
(5F)
PB (2F)
PD (4F)
PA (1F)
PA (IG)
PC (2G)
PG (5G)
H or J-LO (6G)
PF (5G)
PF (3F) PD (4F)
PG (3F)
Plate fixed vertical position Plate fixed vertical position Plate fixed overhead position
Welding direction vertical up Welding direction vertical Welding direction overhead
down
PB (2F)
PA (1F)
45°
Plate fixed horizontal/vertical position
Plate fixed inclined 45° position Welding direction horizontal
Welding direction flat
APPENDIX A REFERENCES
This specification incorporates requirements from other referenced publications and unless
specified by dated reference, the latest edition of the document, including all addenda and
revisions, shall apply. The documents referred to are listed below in Table A.1
External standards
Reference Title
Welding terms and symbols Part 1 – Glossary for welding, brazing, and
BS 499-1:2009
thermal cutting
Class 1 arc welding of ferritic steel pipe work for carrying fluids
BS 2633 + A1 to 5
BS 4515-1 Part1: Carbon and carbon steel pipelines
BS EN 287-1 Qualification test of welders – Fusion welding Part: 1 Steels
Welding consumables - Solid wires, solid wire flux and tubular cored
BS EN 756 electrode-flux combinations for submerged arc welding of non-alloy and fine
grain steels - Classification
Welding consumables - Covered electrodes for manual metal arc
BS EN 757
Welding of high strength steels - Classification
Welding consumables - Fluxes for Submerged Arc Welding -
BS EN 760
Classification (F)
Destructive tests in welds in metallic materials – Impact tests – Test
BS EN 875
specimen location, notch orientation and examination
Destructive tests on welds in metallic materials – longitudinal tensile
BS EN 876
test of weld metal in fusion welded joints
Destructive tests on welds in metallic materials – Transverse tensile
BS EN 895
test
Welding – Recommendations for welding metallic materials: Part 2: Arc
BS EN 1011-2
welding of ferritic materials
BS EN 1435 Non-destructive testing of welds – Radiographic testing of welded joints -
Destructive tests on welds in metallic materials – Macroscopic and
BS EN 1321
Microscopic examination of welds
Destructive tests on welds in metallic materials – Hardness testing Part 1:
BS EN 1043-1
Hardness test on Arc Welded joints
Welding and allied processes – Nomenclature of processes and
BS EN 4063
reference numbers
Charpy impact test on metallic materials – Part 1: Test method (V and U
BS EN 10045-1
notches)
BS EN 10204 Metallic products – Types of inspection documents
BS EN 12732 Gas supply systems – Welded steel pipe work – Functional requirements
Gas welding equipment – Terminology – Terms used for gas welding
BS EN 13622
equipment
Welding consumables – Rods, wires and deposits for tungsten gas
BS EN ISO 636
welding of non-alloyed and fine grain steels - Classification
Welding consumables – Covered electrodes for manual metal arc welding
BS EN ISO 2560
of non-alloyed and fine grain steels - Classification
Quality requirements for fusion welding of metallic materials Part 1:
BS EN ISO 3834-1
Criteria for the selection of the appropriate level of quality requirements
Quality requirements for fusion welding of metallic materials Part 2:
BS EN ISO 3834-2
Comprehensive quality requirements
Quality requirements for fusion welding of metallic materials Part 5:
BS EN ISO 3834-5 Documents with which it is necessary to conform to claim conformity to
ISO 3834-2, ISO 3834-3 or ISO 3834-4
Metallic materials – Tensile testing Part 1: Method of test at ambient
BS EN ISO 6892-1
temperature
Welding consumables – Gases and gas mixtures for fusion welding and
BS EN ISO 14175
allied processes
Specification and qualification of welding procedures of metallic materials
BS EN ISO 15609-1
- Welding procedure specification – Part 1: Arc welding
Specification and qualification of welding procedures for metallic
BS EN ISO 15614-1 materials – Welding procedure test Part 1: Arc and gas welding of steels and
arc welding of nickel and nickel alloys
Welding consumables - Wire electrodes, wires, rods and deposits for gas-
BS EN ISO 16834
shielded arc welding of high strength steels - Classification
Welding consumables – Tubular electrodes for gas- shielded and non-gas
BS EN ISO 17632
shielded metal arc welding of non-alloyed and fine grain steels
Welding consumables – Tubular cored electrodes for gas- shielded and non
BS EN ISO 18276
gas shielded metal arc welding of high strength steels - Classification
PD CEN ISO/TR
Welding – Guidelines for a metallic grouping system
15608
The Institution of Gas Engineers Recommendations on Transmission
IGEM/TD/1
and Distribution Practice – Steel pipelines for high pressure gas
transmission
The Institution of Gas Engineers Recommendations on Transmission and
IGEM/TD/13 Distribution Practice – Pressure regulating installations for transmission and
distribution systems
APPENDIX B DEFINITIONS
Design temperature: The minimum test temperature required by the designer for weld
metal and HAZ impact testing.
Lack of cross penetration: The un-fused area between an internally applied weld bead and
the external passes.
Welding operator: Person who controls fully mechanised or automatic fusion welding
processes
Dressing: Light grinding in the weld area where the parent pipe is not
reduced in wall thickness below the minimum allowed in the pipe
purchase specification.
Golden weld A production weld that will not be subject to hydrostatic testing.
Internal repair: A repair from the internal surface of the original weld consisting of
two weld runs only, one on top of the other.
Multi-pass backweld repair: An internal weld repair consisting of three or more weld runs.
Remedial welding: Welding carried out to correct visual defects while the weld is still
above the original minimum inter-pass temperature stated in the
approved welding procedure.
Statutory Authority: The body or organisation that, through the power vested in it by
Government Statute regulates the requirements with which
particular pipelines have to comply.
Supply condition: This term is taken to mean the heat-treated condition of the materials to be
welded.
Tie-in weld: A welded joint that connects two sections of pipe work together in such a
manner that direct access to that internal surface of the joint is precluded.
APPENDIX C
REQUIREMENTS FOR THE EXAMINATION, TESTING AND APPROVAL
OF WELDING PROCEDURES
C.1 GENERAL
The examination, testing and approval of butt welds, fillet welds, remedial and repair welds shall
be in accordance with BS EN ISO 15614-1 and the requirements of this specification.
Unless specified by National Grid, transverse bend tests are not required.
In case of conflict between this specification and BS EN ISO 15614-1, the requirements of this
specification shall apply.
The preliminary welding procedure specification (pWPS) shall be prepared in accordance with BS
EN ISO 15609-1 and taking into account the requirements specified in this document.
The welding and testing of all procedure test welds shall be witnessed by the Employer or the
Employer’s representative.
C.2 MATERIALS
Welding procedure qualification tests shall be carried out on pipe or fittings made from the same
material and of the same outside diameter and thickness as that to be used in production.
When approved by the Employer, the range of approval specified in PD CEN ISO/TR 15608 may
be applied to qualified welding procedures (see Table 4 item b and Table 6). Separate welding
procedure qualifications are required for each parent material or combinations of parent material
not covered by the grouping system.
When the pWPS proposes the application of PWHT of the completed weld, the ability of the
PWHT to affect the properties of the original pipe or fitting material and cause unacceptable
degradation shall be considered and avoided.
When a welding procedure will be used on existing installation pipe material, confirmation of the
pipe chemical analysis and estimated material grade is required. This may be confirmed through
the production of the original mill certificate or by material sampling in accordance with
T/PM/Q/10.
The length of any pipe or pipe pup used for procedure qualification shall be agreed with the
Employer prior to welding and should be of suitable size to allow simulation of production welding
conditions and to accommodate the required mechanical test specimens. The minimum individual
pup length permitted is 150 mm.
The procedure test weld shall be prepared and set-up in accordance with the requirements of BS
EN ISO 15614-1, the approved pWPS and clause 8 of this specification.
The qualification of all welding procedures shall simulate the intended production application. If it
is intended that tack welds are to form part of the final joint, then they shall be included in the test
piece. A calibrated welding arc monitor that provides a printed record shall be used to record the
welding parameters of all welding procedure qualification test welds (see 5.0).
A test weld shall be produced that demonstrates that the welding system is capable of producing
a sound weld at the extremes of joint fit-up tolerances.
The procedure test weld shall be welded in accordance with the requirements of BS EN ISO
15614-1, the approved pWPS and clause 8 of this specification.
The procedure test weld(s) for semi-automatic or mechanised welding systems shall qualify the
minimum and maximum welding parameter range to be used. Should the proposed limits of the
welding parameter range need to be more tightly controlled or be outside the tolerances permitted
by BS EN ISO 15614-1 and Table 4 of this specification, the limits of the range shall be agreed
between the Employer and the manufacturer or contractor prior to welding commencing (see also
C.9).
The manufacturer or contractor shall produce sufficient test welds to fully qualify the proposed
welding process or procedure in accordance with this specification.
When a qualified welding procedure is intended to be used outside the workshop environment, a
minimum of two welders shall be used to weld pipe or fittings ≥ 457 mm OD.
Roll welding of joints shall only be permitted by the approval of the Employer. If allowed, the
components to be welded shall be fully supported with the axial alignment of the joint maintained
throughout the welding cycle.
The sequence of joint completion shall be agreed between the Employer and the manufacturer or
contractor prior to welding procedure qualification tests commencing.
Where production conditions are such that pipe-to-pipe joints cannot be completed in one welding
heat cycle, the welding of the procedure test welds shall simulate the number of heat cycles
where the joint has been allowed to cool to ambient temperature before completion.
Minimum preheat and weld inter-pass temperatures used in the qualification of a welding
procedure test weld shall be in accordance with Table11 of this specification. The actual minimum
and maximum preheat and weld inter-pass temperatures attained during the welding of the test
joint shall be measured and recorded on the welding procedure qualification record sheet.
When the qualified welding procedure is intended to cover a range of thicknesses, it may be
necessary to complete the cap with a split or multi run cap rather than a single weave cap, the
welding procedure qualification tests shall cover both capping options.
The welding of branch *set-on fittings (e.g. weldolets) and branch set-in fittings (e.g. sweepolets)
procedure test welds shall be welded in accordance with the approved pWPS and clause 10.
* Note: National Grid specification T/SP/PW/11: Part 1 limits the maximum size of a set-on fitting to
80mm DN.
All fillet welds shall be welded using a low hydrogen process. The procedure shall provide for a
minimum of two passes. The major portion of the first pass shall be deposited preferentially on
the pipe or major component body.
Remedial welding carried out to the joint during the original weld heat cycle shall only require
procedure qualification testing when the pWPS contains changes that affect the essential
variables of the original joint WPS (see Table 4).
Qualification of a single pass root bead remedial procedure is only permitted for mechanised
welding systems that use internal welding heads. For vertical-down welding the test weld shall be
made at the 12 o’clock pipe position and for vertical-up welding the test weld shall be made at the
3 o’clock pipe position. The length of the test weld shall be of sufficient length to accommodate all
necessary destructive tests.
The qualification of remedial welding procedures shall simulate the production welding conditions
and shall be subject to the same qualification and testing requirements as repair procedures.
Note: Remedial procedures are those that will be used to correct defects or flaws while the
production joint is still above the minimum inter-pass temperature specified on the WPS.
Full penetration and partial penetration repairs shall only require procedure qualification testing
when the pWPS contains changes that affect the essential variables of the original joint WPS
(see Table 4).
When required, full penetration repairs and partial penetration repairs shall be made between the
4 o’clock and 6 o’clock pipe position. Partial penetration repair welds shall be centred on the weld
cap fusion line and shall be equal or greater in depth than 50% of the pipe wall thickness (see
Figure C.8 d).
Single pass (root sealing) internal repair procedures shall not be permitted, except for those
welds covered by the remedial welding procedure identified in C.3.2.1.
Multi-pass internal partial penetration repairs to double sided joints shall only require procedure
qualification testing when the pWPS contains changes that affect the essential variables of the
original joint WPS (see Table 4).
Multi-pass internal partial penetration repairs to single sided joints shall be prepared and welded
in accordance with the approved pWPS. The excavation shall be centred on the weld root
between the 4 o’clock and 6 o’clock pipe position and shall be equal or greater in depth than 50%
of the pipe wall thickness (see Figure C.7 c).
Where it is proposed to carry out a root repair at the inner surface of the original weld, the test
weld to qualify this type of repair shall be made into an excavation sufficiently deep to
accommodate two individual weld runs deposited one on top of the other (see Figure C.7 d).
When the internal repair is carried out in accordance with the original WPS parameters for
deposition of the root run, the test weld shall be subject to macro and hardness testing only (see
C.5.3.1 and C.5.5). For the vertical down welding direction the test specimen shall be removed
from the 12 o’clock pipe position. For the vertical up welding direction the specimen shall be
removed from the 3 o’clock pipe position.
Multiple attempts to repair a weld are not permitted unless specifically approved by the Employer.
This option shall only be considered in exceptional circumstances and will require full technical
justification to be supplied by the manufacturer or contractor before further welding. Where a re-
repair is permitted by the Employer, it is conditional on further repair welding procedure
qualification tests (that simulate the additional number of heat cycles applied), being satisfactorily
carried out. All supplementary testing records, including the new repair WPS and the technical
justification for a multiple repair attempt shall be submitted for the approval of the Employer.
The extent of examination and testing of a procedure test weld shall be in accordance with BS EN
ISO 15614-1: Table 1 and as applicable, Table C.1 and Figures C.1 to C.10 of this specification.
The NDT examination techniques used shall be in accordance with T/SP/NDT/2.
All test welds not subject to PWHT shall have a delay of at least 24 hours from completion of
welding to commencement of *final non-destructive testing. If the Employer requires an
alternative delay prior to NDT this shall be agreed with the manufacturer or contractor prior to
welding the test joint (see 11.3).
* Note: The manufacturer or contractor may decide to carry out provisional NDT examination of a
weld (for quality control purposes) prior to the final NDT after 24 hours.
In order to be deemed acceptable, welding procedure test welds shall meet the defect
acceptance criteria specified in Table 8 (see also Table 3 item f) and the destructive test
requirements of this appendix.
Due to the geometry of a typical set-on fitting, limited mechanical tests can be obtained from the
test weld. When required by the Employer a butt weld test, using the same welding consumables
and parameters shall be qualified on equivalent materials to provide further information with
respect to the joint impact and tensile properties.
When the qualified welding procedure is intended to cover both woven and split or multi-pass
capping options, the intended primary method of weld capping will be tested as part of the original
procedure qualification test. To test the alternative capping method, two additional macro
specimens shall be removed from the weld, one taken from the area of highest heat input and
one taken from the area of lowest heat input. Both macro specimens shall be hardness tested
(see C.5.3 and C.5.5).
The extent of examination and testing of a remedial or repair procedure test weld shall be in
accordance with Table C.2 and as applicable, Figures C.7 to C.9 of this specification. NDT shall
be carried out in accordance with T/SP/NDT/2.
The preparation and testing of transverse tensile specimens for butt joints shall be in accordance
with BS EN 895.
• For pipes > 114.3 mm OD, the weld reinforcement shall be removed on both faces to
give the test specimen a thickness equal to the wall thickness of the pipe.
• Transverse tensile testing is not required for butt welds in pipe ≤ 114.3 mm OD.
C.5.1.1 Transverse tensile test requirements
• The tensile strength of the test specimen shall not be less than the corresponding
specified minimum value for the parent metal.
• The tensile strength of the weld, including the fusion zone of each specimen, shall be
equal to or greater than the minimum value specified for the parent metal.
• For dissimilar parent metal joints the tensile strength of the parent metal shall not be less
than the minimum value specified for the parent metal having the lower tensile strength.
• For dissimilar parent metal joints the tensile strength of the weld metal shall not be less
than the minimum value specified for the parent metal having the higher tensile strength
(see Table 3 item c of this specification).
The weld metal yield strength for butt welds in L555 (or X80) grade pipe material shall overmatch
the nominal specified minimum yield strength of the pipe by at least 5%.
Macro specimens shall be taken from the applicable locations shown in Figure C.1 to C.4 and
Figures C.7 to C.9). All specimens shall be hardness tested in accordance with C.5.5.
All macro test specimens shall be examined at a magnification of x 5. Photographs of each macro
specimen showing the location of the hardness impressions shall be provided with the
mechanical test records. The degree of photographic magnification of the specimens shown on
the test report shall be accurately recorded.
Where L555 (or X80) grade material is examined, a macro specimen shall be removed at the
intersection of the pipe seam weld and girth weld location for hardness testing. Where there are
two seam welds junctions, the specimen shall be removed from the side of the joint with the
highest carbon equivalent percentage.
The macro specimens shall be free of cracks or lack of fusion. Any other defects revealed shall
be within the limits specified in Table 8.
The dimensions of impact test specimens and requirements for testing shall be in accordance
with BS EN 875. Test specimens shall be taken and prepared in accordance with BS EN 10045-1
in such a way that the axis of the notch is perpendicular to the pipe surface. The location for the
removal of test specimens from the test weld is specified in C.5.4.2.
The Charpy V-notch test specimens for weld metal and HAZ testing shall be notched in the
through thickness direction (see Figure C. 5). In the HAZ the notch shall be a maximum of 1 mm
from the fusion line and in the weld metal the notch shall be at the weld centreline.
From each specified Charpy impact location, each impact test set shall comprise of three
individual test specimens.
C.5.4.2 Specimen location
The locations for the removal of Charpy impact test specimens is dependent on welding direction
(see Figures C.1 to C.4, C.7, C.8 and C.9)
Specimens with Charpy V-notch shall be used and taken within 1 mm to 2 mm above the inner
surface of the parent metal and transverse to the weld (see Figure C 5 a).
C.5.4.2.1 Additional test specimens for thicknesses greater than 20 mm
For thicknesses > 20 mm, two additional sets of specimens shall be taken, one from weld metal
and one from the HAZ, taken within 1mm to 2 mm below the outer surface of the parent metal
and transverse to the weld (see Figure C.5 b).
When the welding is in the vertical up direction the additional specimens shall be taken from the 3
o’clock position. When the welding is in the vertical down direction the additional test specimens
shall be taken from the 6 o’clock position.
* Other than the composite procedure where the root pass is welded vertical–up and the remainder
of the passes are welded in the vertical-down direction
When the majority of welding is in the vertical up direction the test specimens shall be taken from
the 3 o’clock position. When the majority of welding is in the vertical down direction the test
specimens shall be taken from the 6 o’clock position.
When the volume of weld deposited in different directions is approximately equal, the root impact
specimens shall be taken from the appropriate position corresponding with the direction of the
majority of welding in the lower half of the joint. The additional cap impact specimens shall be
taken from the position that corresponds with the direction of the majority of welding in the upper
half of the joint.
Unless otherwise *indicated, the impact test temperature shall be 0°C for buried pipelines, minus
10°C for pipe-work for use in outdoor ambient conditions, or the actual gas temperature,
whichever is the lesser.
* Note: Circumstances may exist that require various minimum impact test temperatures at different
pipe work locations. The manufacturer or contractor shall confirm the required minimum weld metal
impact test temperature(s) for test welds in discussion with the installation designer and the Employer
prior to testing taking place.
Hardness testing is required on all macro specimens. Vickers hardness testing with a load of
*HV10 shall be performed in accordance with BS EN 1043-1. Hardness measurements shall be
taken in both parent metals, the weld metal and in both heat affected zones, to evaluate the
range of hardness values across the welded joint. The hardness survey shall include two rows of
indentations made at a depth of up to 2 mm below the upper and lower surfaces of the welded
joint (see Figure C.6). For double sided welds or internal weld repairs one additional row of
indentations shall be made through the root area (see Figure C.6).
Each row of the hardness survey shall have at least one individual indentation in both parent
metals and three individual indentations in both heat affected zones and in the weld metal. The
first indentation in each HAZ shall be placed as close to the fusion line as possible (see Figure
C.6 a).
* Due to the narrow HAZ in some welds made by mechanised processes it may be necessary to carry
out hardness testing using a 5 kg load, in such cases this shall be clearly indicated in the test house
report.
The results of the hardness test shall meet the requirements of Table C.4
When required for procedure qualification the Employer will specify the CTOD and AWT
acceptance or re-testing criteria.
The destructive tests required when qualifying a small diameter (21.3 mm to 88.9 mm OD) branch
attachment welding procedure, (e.g. a weld-o-let fitting) shall consist of two macro sections taken
at 90º to each other (the specimens shall be taken from the top and side of the weld as shown in
Table C. 4 for set-in fittings).
The destructive tests required for the qualification of the skirt and branch welds of forged set-in
branch attachments (i.e. sweep-o-let fittings) shall be as specified in Table C.1 and Figure C.4.
The designed shape of some sweep-o-let fittings may limit the extent of practical destructive tests
that may be carried out. In such cases, any variation to the type or number of specimens tested
shall be agreed with the Employer prior to production of any test welds.
C.6.1 General
Destructive testing for the qualification of full penetration, partial penetration and two pass internal
repair welds shall be in accordance with Table C.2. The specimens shall be removed from the
appropriate locations shown in Figures C.8 and C.9. Alternatively, the repair may be located at
the same position on the opposite side of the joint.
The Employer may require additional destructive tests (i.e. CTOD and/or all-weld tensile tests)
from weld repair procedures joints. When CTOD testing is required by the Employer the
requirements for testing shall be as specified in T/PS/P/2.
When required for procedure qualification the Employer will specify the CTOD and AWT
acceptance or re-testing criteria.
Destructive testing shall be in accordance with BS EN ISO 15614-1, except where amended by
the requirements of this specification.
The extent of destructive testing of fillet welds and the location within the test joint shall be as
shown in Table C.1 and Figure C.10.
C.7.1 Fracture test specimens
Fracture test specimens shall be taken from the locations shown to have the greatest and the
least root gap.
Test specimens shall be prepared as shown in Figure C.10 and shall be at least 25 mm wide and
at least 50 mm long.
The test specimens shall be prepared by machine or thermal cutting, followed by grinding. The
sides of the specimens shall be smooth and parallel.
C.7.2 Fracture test
The specimen shall be broken using one of the following methods in such a way that the root of
the weld is in tension:
a) supporting both ends and striking the centre of the specimen;
b) gripping one end of the specimen and striking the other.
C.7.2.1 Fracture test requirements
The exposed surface of each broken specimen shall be free of cracks, lack of fusion and lack of
penetration. Other defects in the weld metal shall be within the following limits:
a) Inclusions. Inclusions shall not exceed 1 mm in depth and 3 mm or 50% of the pipe
thickness in length, whichever is the shorter. There shall be at least 12 mm of sound
weld metal between adjacent inclusions.
b) Gas pores. The greatest dimension of any gas pore shall not exceed 20% of the
pipe thickness or 3 mm, whichever is the smaller. The combined area of all pores
shall not exceed 5% of the exposed face cross-sectional area.
C.7.3 Macro-examination
Macro test specimens shall be taken from the location shown in Figure C.10. They shall be
prepared, tested and examined in accordance with C.5.3.
C.7.3.1 Macro test requirements
The profile, dimensions and number of runs of the fillet weld shall be as specified in the welding
procedure. The specimen shall be free from cracks, lack of fusion and lack of penetration. The
total area of any cavities or inclusions shall not exceed 5% of the fillet weld cross-sectional area.
The required number and location of indentations in each hardness traverse shall be as shown in
Figure C.6 d.
The results of the hardness test shall meet the requirements of Table C.5.
In the event of a failure of any destructive test specimen, the type and number of re-tests required
shall be as specified in Table C.7.
In the event of the failure of any destructive test specimen the Employer shall be informed.
Subject to meeting the criteria given in Table C.7 of this specification and the following
requirements, a re-test will be allowed:
• The reason for the original failure shall be established and reported to the employer. All
re-test results shall be reported to the Employer who will determine if the welding
procedure can be approved, or whether complete re-qualification of the welding
procedure is required.
• If there is insufficient material available for any re-test a new test piece shall be produced
using the same welding procedure and a replacement specimen or set of specimens for
the failed specimen, as appropriate, shall be tested.
• Should any of the additional test specimens not comply with the requirements of this
specification, the proposed welding procedure shall be rejected.
• The range of approval for the CEV of materials tested by the welding procedure
qualification test shall be within the tolerances specified in Table C.8, or the welding
procedure shall be re-qualified.
• Even though a new material is considered equivalent to the procedure material tested
and may be grouped in accordance with PD CEN ISO/TR 15608 and Table 6 of this
specification, when required by the Employer, a weld (or welds) shall be produced using
the approved welding procedure and tested in accordance with this specification to
confirm that welds made in the new material meet the service requirements.
• Procedure qualification of partial penetration and full penetration repair welds shall only
be required when the proposed repair procedure contains changes that would affect the
qualification and approval of the original welding procedure (see Table C.2).
• When impact requirements apply, the upper limit of the heat input shall be a maximum of
10% greater than the range qualified by the test weld (see C.3.1.1).
• When hardness requirements apply, the lower limit of heat input qualified is 10% lower
than that used in welding the test weld (see C.3.1.1).
• When welding procedure tests have been carried out in accordance with the pWPS at
both a high and a low heat input level, then all intermediate heat input values are also
qualified.
• When impact testing is not required, with the approval of the Employer, filler materials
that have equivalent mechanical properties, the same type of covering, core or flux,
nominal composition and the same or lower hydrogen content, according to the
designation or classification in the appropriate standard for the original filler material
concerned, may be substituted for the original filler material without the need for further
testing. Where this is approved by the Employer the original WPS sheet shall be revised
to show the permitted filler material.
The range of approval for set-on fittings shall be as specified in Table 7. The range of approval for
the welding position of set-on branch connections is ± 25° of the position tested except for
position PB according to BS 499-1 which is qualified by position PE, PF or PG (see
Figure 2).
A complete record of the welding procedure qualification test shall be produced by the
manufacturer or contractor, this shall include all tests and re-tests undertaken during the
qualification of the welding procedure. The WPQR (an example of which may be found in BS EN
ISO 15614-1) shall detail all relevant items required to produce a WPS in accordance with BS EN
ISO 15609-1. The WPQR shall be submitted along with the pWPS, the WPS and other necessary
records (e.g. material and consumable certificates) for approval by National Grid.
Table C.1 Examination and destructive testing of procedure qualification test welds
Table C.2 Examination and destructive testing of remedial and repair procedure
qualification test butt welds
Table C.4 Permitted maximum hardness values (HV10) for butt welds
Table C.5 Permitted maximum hardness values for fillet welds on the external surface
of the pipe
Table C.6 Test specimens for procedure approval of repair welds not identical to the
original mechanised or semi mechanised welding procedure
Full Penetration 1 1 1 1 1
3
Repair
Partial Penetration 1 1 1 2 1
1
Repair
3
Internal Root Repair 0 0 1 1 1
1. AWT testing only for L555 (or X80) grade material or when required by the Employer.
2. Hardness survey made on macro-examination specimen.
3. For typical locations see Figures C.8 and C.9.
4. CTOD testing shall only be required when specified by the Employer.
Table C.7 Destructive testing of welding procedure test welds – Permitted re-tests
1: For each invalid specimen, a further two specimens shall be tested. Where three individual
specimens comprise a set of specimens and failure is due to an invalid specimen, one additional
set of three individual specimens shall be tested.
2: Providing that not more than one of the original valid specimens tested failed to meet test
requirements, two additional test specimens shall be taken from a location either side of the failed
specimen.
3: Where three individual specimens comprise a set of specimens and a single specimen has
failed, one additional set of three individual specimens shall be tested. If two of the original
individual test specimens fail to meet specification requirements the test weld shall be rejected.
Each additional specimen shall meet the individual minimum value required and the combined
average value of all six specimens tested (the additional set and the original set) shall meet the
required minimum average value for a set.
4: If a single hardness impression fails to meet test requirements, two additional hardness
impressions, one either side of the original failed impression may be tested. The additional
hardness impressions shall not be influenced by deformation caused by the failed impression.
Should it be impractical to re-test adjacent to the original failed hardness impression e.g. due to a
narrow HAZ or more than one failed impression, the original macro specimen surface shall be
reground (or with the approval of the Employer the specimen reversed), re-prepared in
accordance with C.5.5 and re-tested.
Table C.8 Qualified range of chemical analysis – Carbon Equivalent Value (CEV)
Top of weld
Figure C.1 Locations for test specimens for butt welds ≤ 114.3 mm outside diameter.
Top of weld
Figure C.2 Locations for test specimens for butt welds > 114.3 mm outside diameter.
Top of weld
4 1
3 2
Figure C.3 Location of additional test specimens for butt welds made with a mechanised
welding process
Top
Fitting
Pipe
Top
Side
Fitting
Pipe
Side
Location Specimens
1 Macro and hardness
a
2 Set of Charpy impact tests, weld metal centre line
a
3 Top Set of Charpy impact tests fusion line pipe side
a
4 Set of Charpy impact tests fusion line fitting side
b
5 Transverse Tensile
6 Macro and hardness
a
7 Set of Charpy impact tests, weld metal centre line
a
8 Set of Charpy impact tests fusion line pipe side
Side a
9 Set of Charpy impact tests fusion line fitting side
b
10 Transverse Tensile
c
11 All weld metal tensile specimen
a When the pipe wall thickness exceeds 20mm or combined welding processes or welding
directions are used, additional Charpy impact test sets are required (see 5.4).
b Due to fitting geometry it may be necessary to employ reduced section tensile specimens.
2
c When required by the employer (i.e. for fitting material of 555N/mm SMYS), an all weld
metal tensile specimen (taken from a convenient side location of the fitting weld) shall be
tested in accordance with C.5.2.
Figure C.4 Location of test specimens for forged set-in branch connections
1 to 2 mm
Figure C.5 b) Location of notch for Charpy test specimen from a partial penetration weld
repair.
2 6 5
4 3
5 6
Key b) Partial penetration repair
1 Top of Weld
2 Charpy 6 5 5 6
3 Tensile
4 Macro/hardness
5 Original weld fusion line
6 Original weld heat-affected zone
t Wall thickness of test pipe c) Multi-pass backweld repair
1
Specimen Location
Figure C.8 Location and number of additional test specimens for full penetration repairs
to butt welds made with a mechanized welding process
Specimen Location
Macro Hardness 1
1
Set of Charpy Tests Weld Centre Line 2
2 Set of Charpy Tests Weld Fusion Line 3
7 Tensile 9
Note 1: The minimum requirement may increase depending
8 on wall thickness and the use of any mixed welding
process
9 Note 2: The hardness survey is made on the macro
specimen.
Note 3: The number of CTOD specimens required may be
varied by National Grid agreement
Figure C.9 Location and number of additional test specimens for partial penetration repairs to
butt welds made with a mechanized welding process.
B
A
Notes: 1. The fracture specimens shall be at least 25mm wide by 50mm in length.
2. The off-cut sections may be used to prepare the macro specimens.
3. The macro specimens shall be used for the hardness surveys.
APPENDIX D
GUIDANCE ON POST WELD HEAT TREATMENT
D.1 Post-weld heat treatment of circumferential butt welds may be required in the following
circumstances:
a) When the carbon equivalent of the material based on ladle analysis is greater than
0.53%.
b) When the pipe thickness is greater than 32 mm.
c) When hardness limitations cannot be met in the as-welded condition.
When materials of differing thickness or carbon equivalents are to be welded, the greater
thickness or carbon equivalent should be used in determining the post-weld heat treatment
requirements.
D.2 Where residual stresses are to be controlled, it is normally necessary to carry out a
stress relieving heat treatment which will involve heating the pipe or component to a temperature
within the range 580 °C to 620 °C, maintaining this for a period of time followed by controlled
cooling. This heat treatment procedure can take some hours to complete.
Reference should be made to an appropriate standard (e.g. BS 2633) for the details of carrying
out such heat treatment.
Where hardness reduction is required, normally a short term tempering procedure is used. This
involves rapid heating of the pipe to a temperature higher than 450 °C followed by air-cooling.
The extent of this heat treatment should be ascertained by experimental work to ensure that the
required properties are achieved for a specific application.
D.3 When there is a high risk of cold cracking, hydrogen release may be accelerated by
either maintaining the minimum inter-pass temperature or raising the temperature to 200 °C to
300 °C immediately after welding and before the weld region cools to below the minimum inter-
pass temperature. The duration of post-heating should be at least 2 hours and is a function of the
thickness. Large thicknesses require temperatures at the upper end of the stated range as well as
prolonged post-heating times.
APPENDIX E
PIPE END MAGNETISM
E.1 Introduction
Excessive magnetism at the pipe ends can prevent satisfactory weld deposition; this is
particularly so when a magnetic pig has been passed through an existing pipeline but also may
be present in new components.
To overcome this magnetic effect, a number of alternative actions may be carried out, depending
upon the strength of the effect.
Sometimes ac is not effective at these levels and it must then be treated as a high level effect.
a) Step 1
Separate all components and de-magnetize them all, if necessary, before setting
up the joint. The pipe and component ends need to be not less than 300 mm
apart during de-magnetization.
b) Step 2
Measure the magnetic field at a number of points round the pipe, taking the
readings on the root face. Keep the gaussmeter in line with the pipe and the end
of the probe holder should be in gentle contact with the pipe. Identify the area
where the field is at its maximum, mark the position and note the reading.
c) Step 3
Wrap welding cable of 300 A minimum capacity round the pipe to give 18 to 20
turns. The edge of the coil must be 50 mm to 80 mm from the end of the pipe.
Aluminium cored cable is not recommended but can be used if necessary on
larger diameters. Short lengths of pipe (pups) may not require a full number of
turns. The amount of cable needed is as given in Table E.1.
d) Step 4
Connect the coil to a welding generator and, setting a low current (less than 80
A), switch on using the polarity change switch. Observe the change in reading
shown on the gauss-meter. If the reading reduces or reverses, note the position
of the polarity switch. If the reading increases, reverse the polarity and check the
decrease. Note the polarity. Switch off.
e) Step 5
Turn the generator controls to maximum and, using the polarity switch, turn on
the current to the same polarity as noted in operation d) above. After 10 s switch
off. The current level must drop immediately. Do not reduce current gradually.
f) Step 6
Take gaussmeter reading at the point noted in operation b) above and compare
with original reading. If everything has been done correctly, the field should have
reduced or reversed. If not, return to operation b) above and repeat operations
b), d) and e) above.
g) Step 7
Check the reading and:
1) If reading after de-magnetization is less than 50 gauss, welding is possible
with dc durrent - no further action necessary.
2) If reading is less than 120 gauss, welding should be possible with ac current.
At this stage, there is the choice of either welding with ac or carrying out the
procedure in operation h) below.
4) If reading is greater than 120 gauss, further de-magnetization is necessary
as in operation h) below. If polarity has reversed, return to operation d)
above.
h) Step 8
If reading is greater than 400 gauss, repeat operations e), f) and g) above.
If reading is between 120 gauss and 400 gauss, reduce current to 60% and
repeat operation e) above.
NOTE - If there has been a field reversal, the procedure should be modified so
as to use opposite polarity as used in operation e) above.
i) Step 9
Degauss other components where necessary prior to fitting up.
168.3 10 762 50
219.1 15 914 60
273.1 20 1067 70
323.9 25 1219 80
457 30 1422 90
*The above cable lengths refer only to the coils. Additional cable is necessary to connect the
coil to the welding generators.
APPENDIX F
TYPICAL BELL- HOLE EXCAVATION DETAILS
Plan view
Sectional View
Minimum of 2.0m
for rain cover
cover
2.0m 2.0m
0.6m
APPENDIX G
G.1 Scope
G.3 Materials:
• Contract piping & material specifications.
• Company specific or international standards.
• Material certification.
• Receipt inspection.
• Storage & preservation.
G.4 Fabrication:
• Fit up.
• Alignment of bores and fabrication tolerances for pipework.
• Permitted misalignment.
• Proximity of welds.
G.5 Welding:
• Preparation of pWPS, WPS and welding procedure qualification.
• Arc monitoring equipment.
• Welding consumables.
• Weld metal & parent material requirements, impact energy values, minimum test
temperature.
• Welder qualification.
• Material control and handling.
• Production welding.
• Pre heating.
• Post Weld Heat Treatment.
G.6 NDT
• Inspection personnel qualifications.
• Visual examination.
• UT, RT, MPI, PT.
• Acceptance criteria.
• Golden Welds.
• Applicable specification.
• Materials to be used.
• Method statement, including environmental considerations and acceptance criteria
• Personnel qualification.
ENDNOTE
Comments
Comments and queries regarding the technical content of this document should be directed to:
Buying Documents
Contractors and other users external to National Grid should direct their requests for further
copies of National Grid documents to the department or group responsible for the initial issue of
their contract documentation. Alternatively, enquiries may be made to the Asset Specifications
Manager, GNI Transmission Asset Management at the above address.
Copyright National Grid ©, all rights reserved. No part of this publication may by reproduced in any material form
(including photocopying and restoring in any medium or electronic means and whether or not transiently or
incidentally) without the written permission of National Grid plc except in accordance with the provisions of the
Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988.
© National Grid plc 2010 – All rights reserved 71