I. Omnibus Election Code (Sec 118)
I. Omnibus Election Code (Sec 118)
I. Omnibus Election Code (Sec 118)
"Subject to reasonable regulation and the payment of fees in such amounts as may
be fixed by the Commission, the candidates, political parties, accredited citizens'
arms, and all other interested persons shall be furnished copies thereof: Provided,
That nongovernmental organizations and other civil society organizations accredited
by and working with the Commission as partners on overseas voters' education and
participation shall be exempt from the payment of fees."
Section 21. Section 14 of the same Act is hereby renumbered as Section 21 and is
amended to read as follows:
"SEC. 21. Printing and Transmittal of Ballots, Voting Instructions, Election Forms and
Paraphernalia. -
"21.1. The Commission shall cause the printing of ballots for overseas voters, and all
other accountable election forms in such number as may be necessary, but in no
case shall these exceed the total number of approved applications. Security
markings shall be used in the printing of ballots for overseas voters.
"21.2. The Commission shall present to the authorized representatives of the DFA
and of the accredited major political parties the ballots for overseas voters, voting
instructions, election forms and other election paraphernalia for scrutiny and
inspection prior to their transmittal to the posts.
"21.3. The Commission shall transmit, as far as practicable, but not later than forty-
five (45) days before the day of elections, by special pouch to all posts the exact
number of ballots for overseas voters corresponding to the number of approved
applications, along with such accountable forms necessary to ensure the secrecy
and integrity of the election.
"21.4. The authorized representatives of accredited major political parties shall have
the right to be present in all phases of printing, transmittal, and casting of mailed
ballots abroad. Unclaimed ballots properly marked as such, shall be cancelled and
shipped to the Commission by the least costly method."
Section 22. Section 15 of the same Act is hereby renumbered as Section 22 and is
amended to read as follows:
"SEC. 22. Regulation on Campaigning Abroad. - Personal campaigning, the use of
campaign materials, as well as the limits on campaign spending shall be governed by
the laws and regulations applicable in the Philippines: Provided, That all forms of
campaigning abroad within the thirty (30)-day overseas voting period shall be
prohibited."
Section 23. A new Section 23 of the same Act is hereby inserted to read as follows:
"SEC. 23. Voting. - Voting may be done either personally, by mail or by any other
means as may be determined by the Commission. For this purpose, the Commission
shall issue the necessary guidelines on the manner and procedures of voting.
"The OFOV, in consultation with the DFA-OVS, shall determine the countries where
voting shall be done by any specific mode, taking into consideration the minimum
criteria enumerated under this Act which shall include the number of registered
voters, accessibility of the posts, efficiency of the host country's applied system and
such other circumstances that may affect the conduct of voting.
"The Commission shall announce the specific mode of voting per country/post at
least one hundred twenty (120) days before the start of the voting period."
Section 24. Section 16 of the same Act is hereby renumbered as Section 24 and is
amended to read as follows:
"SEC. 24. Casting and Submission of Ballots. -
"24.1. Upon receipt by the SBEI of the ballots for overseas voters, voting instructions,
election forms and other paraphernalia, they shall make these available on the
premises to the qualified overseas voters in their respective jurisdictions during the
thirty (30) days before the day of elections when overseas voters may cast their vote.
Immediately upon receiving it, the overseas voter must fill-out her/his ballot
personally, in secret, without leaving the premises of the posts concerned.
"24.2. The overseas voter shall personally accomplish her/his ballot at the post that
has jurisdiction over the country where she/he temporarily resides or at any polling
place designated and accredited by the Commission.
"24.3. The overseas voter shall cast her/his ballot, upon presentation of the voter
identification card issued by the Commission or such other documents deemed by
the SBEI at the post as sufficient to establish the voter's identity.
"24.4. x x x
"24.5. The posts concerned shall keep a complete record of the ballots for overseas
voters, specifically indicating the number of ballots they actually received, and in
cases where voting by mail is allowed under Section 25 hereof, the names and
addresses of the voters to whom these ballots were sent, including proof of receipt
thereof. In addition, the posts shall submit a formal report to the Commission and
the Joint Congressional Oversight Committee created under this Act within thirty
(30) days from the day of elections. Such report shall contain data on the number of
ballots cast and received by the offices, the number of invalid and unclaimed ballots
and other pertinent data.
"24.6. Ballots not claimed by the overseas voters at the posts, in case of personal
voting, and ballots returned to the posts concerned, in the case of voting by mail,
shall be cancelled and shipped to the Commission by the least costly method within
six (6) months from the day of elections.
"24.7. Only ballots cast, and mailed ballots received by the posts concerned in
accordance with Section 25 hereof before the close of voting on the day of elections
shall be counted in accordance with Section 27 hereof. All envelopes containing the
ballots received by the posts after the prescribed period shall not be opened, and
shall be cancelled and shipped to the Commission by the least costly method within
six (6) months from the day of elections.
"24.8. A special ballot Reception and Custody Group composed of three (3)
members shall be constituted by the Commission from among the staff of the posts
concerned, including their attached agencies, and citizens of the Philippines abroad,
who will be deputized to receive ballots and take custody of the same preparatory
to their transmittal to the SBEI.
"24.9. x x x
"24.10. x x x."
Section 25. Section 17 of the same Act is hereby renumbered as Section 25 and is
amended to read as follows:
"SEC. 25. Voting by Mail. -
"25.1. x x x
"(a) x x x;
"(b) x x x; and
"(c) x x x.
"25.2. The overseas voter shall send her/his accomplished ballot to the
corresponding post that has jurisdiction over the country where she/he temporarily
resides. She/He shall be entitled to cast her/his ballot at any time upon her/his
receipt thereof: Provided, That the same is received before the close of voting on
the day of elections. The overseas absentee voter shall be instructed that her/his
ballot shall not be counted if not transmitted in the special envelope furnished
her/him.
"25.3. Only mailed ballots received by the post before the close of voting on the day
of elections shall be counted in accordance with Section 27 hereof. All envelopes
containing the ballots received by the posts after the prescribed period shall not be
opened, and shall be cancelled and disposed of appropriately, with a corresponding
report thereon submitted to the Commission not later than thirty (30) days from the
day of elections."
Section 26. A new Section 26 of the same Act is hereby inserted to read as follows:
"SEC. 26. Voting Privilege of Members of the SBEI, SBRCG and SBOC. - Government
employees posted abroad who will perform election duties as members of the SBEI,
SBCRG and SBOC shall be allowed to vote in their respective posts: Provided, That
they are registered either in the Philippines or as overseas voters."
Section 27. Section 18 of the same Act is hereby renumbered as Section 27 and is
amended to read as follows:
"SEC. 27. On-Site Counting and Canvassing. -
"27.1. x x x
"27.2. For these purposes, the Commission shall constitute as many SBEIs as may be
necessary to conduct and supervise the counting of votes as provided in Section 27.2
hereof. The SBEIs to be constituted herein shall be composed of a Chairman and two
(2) members, one (1) of whom shall be designated as poll clerk. The ambassador or
consul-general, or any career public officer posted abroad designated by the
Commission, as the case may be, shall act as the Chairman; in the absence of other
government officers, the two (2) other members shall be citizens of the Philippines
who are qualified to vote under this Act and deputized by the Commission not later
than sixty (60) days before the day of elections. All resolutions of the SBEIs on issues
brought before it during the conduct of its proceedings shall be valid only when they
carry the approval of the Chairman.
"Immediately upon the completion of the counting, the SBEIs shall transmit via
facsimile and/or electronic mail the results to the Commission in Manila and the
accredited major political parties.
"x x x
"27.3. x x x
"27.4. The SBOC composed of the highest ranking officer of the post as Chairperson,
a senior career officer from any of the government agencies maintaining a post
abroad and, in the absence of another government officer, a citizen of the
Philippines qualified to vote under this Act and deputized by the Commission, as vice
chairperson and member-secretary, respectively, shall be constituted to canvass the
election returns submitted to it by the SBEIs. Immediately upon the completion of
the canvass, the chairperson of the SBOC shall transmit via facsimile, electronic mail,
or any other means of transmission equally safe and reliable the Certificates of
Canvass and the Statements of Votes to the Commission, and shall cause to preserve
the same immediately after the conclusion of the canvass, and make it available
upon instructions of the Commission. The SBOC shall also furnish the accredited
major political parties and accredited citizens' arms with copies thereof via facsimile,
electronic mail and any other means of transmission equally safe, secure and
reliable.
"x x x
"27.5. x x x
"27.6. x x x. For purposes of this Act, the returns of every election for President and
Vice-President prepared by the SBOCs shall be deemed a certificate of canvass of a
city or a province.
"27.7. x x x."
Section 28. A new Section 28 of the same Act is hereby inserted to read as follows:
"SEC. 28. Authority to Explore Other Modes or Systems Using Automated Election
System. - Notwithstanding current procedures and systems herein provided, for the
proper implementation of this Act and in view of the peculiarities attendant to the
overseas voting process, the Commission may explore other more efficient, reliable
and secure modes or systems, ensuring the secrecy and sanctity of the entire
process, whether paper-based, electronic-based or internet-based technology or
such other latest technology available, for onsite and remote registration and
elections and submit reports and/or recommendations to the Joint Congressional
Oversight Committee."
Section 29. A new Section 29 of the same Act is hereby inserted to read as follows:
"SEC. 29. Procurement of Facilities, Equipment, Materials, Supplies or Services. - To
achieve the purpose of this Act, the Commission may, likewise, procure from local
or foreign sources, through purchase, lease, rent or other forms of acquisition,
hardware or software, facilities, equipment, materials, supplies or services in
accordance with existing laws, free from taxes and import duties, subject to
government procurement rules and regulations."
Section 30. A new Section 30 of the same Act is hereby inserted to read as follows:
"SEC. 30. Establishment of an Office for Overseas Voting (OFOV) Under the
Commission. - The Commission is hereby authorized to establish an OFOV tasked
specifically to oversee and supervise the effective implementation of the Overseas
Voting Act: Provided, That its secretariat shall come from the existing secretariat
personnel of the Commission on Elections."
Section 31. A new Section 31 of the same Act is hereby inserted to read as follows:
"SEC. 31. Creation of the Department of Foreign Affairs Overseas Voting Secretariat
(DFA-OVS). - A secretariat based in the DFA home office is hereby created to assist
the OFOV, and to direct, coordinate and oversee the participation of the DFA in the
implementation of the Overseas Voting Act: Provided, That its secretariat shall come
from the existing secretariat personnel of the DFA."
Section 32. Section 19 of the same Act is hereby deleted.
Section 33. Section 20 of the same Act is hereby renumbered as Section 32 and is
amended to read as follows:
"SEC. 32. Information Campaign. - The Commission, in coordination with agencies
concerned, shall undertake an information campaign to educate the public on the
manner of overseas voting for qualified overseas voters. It may require the support
and assistance of the DFA, through the posts, the DOLE, the Department of
Transportation and Communications (DOTC), the Philippine Postal Corporation
(PPC), the POEA, the OWWA and the Commission on Filipinos Overseas.
Such information campaign shall educate the Filipino public, within and outside the
Philippines, on the Philippine Electoral System, the rights of overseas voters,
overseas voting processes and other related concerns. Information materials shall
be developed by the Commission for distribution, through the said government
agencies and private organizations. No government agency shall prepare, print,
distribute or post any information material without the prior approval of the
Commission."
Section 34. Section 21 of the same Act is hereby renumbered as Section 33.
Section 35. Section 22 of the same Act is hereby renumbered as Section 34 and is
amended to read as follows:
"SEC. 34. Assistance from Government Agencies. - All government officers,
particularly from the DFA, the DOLE, the DOTC, the PPC, the POEA, the OWWA, the
Commission on Filipinos Overseas and other government offices concerned with the
welfare of the Filipinos overseas shall, to the extent compatible with their primary
responsibilities, assist the Commission in carrying out the provisions of this Act. All
such agencies or officers thereof shall take reasonable measures to expedite all
election activities, which the Commission shall require of them. When necessary,
the Commission may send supervisory teams headed by career officers to assist the
posts.
"Likewise, consular and diplomatic services rendered in connection with the
overseas voting processes shall be made available at no cost to the overseas voters."
Section 36. Section 23 of the same Act is hereby renumbered as Section 35 and is
amended to read as follows:
"SEC. 35. Security Measures to Safeguard the Secrecy and Sanctity of Ballots. - At all
stages of the electoral process, the Commission shall ensure that the secrecy and
integrity of the ballots are preserved. The OFOV of the Commission shall be
responsible for ensuring the secrecy and sanctity of the overseas voting process. In
the interest of transparency, all necessary and practicable measures shall be
adopted to allow representation of the candidates, accredited major political
parties, accredited citizens' arms and nongovernment organizations to assist, and
intervene in appropriate cases, in all stages of the electoral exercise and to prevent
any and all forms of fraud and coercion.
"No officer or member of the foreign service corps, including those belonging to
attached agencies shall be transferred, promoted, extended, recalled or otherwise
moved from his current post or position one (1) year before and three (3) months
after the day of elections, except upon the approval of the Commission."
Section 37. Section 24 of the same Act is hereby renumbered as Section 36 and is
amended to read as follows:
"SEC. 36. Prohibited Acts. - In addition to the prohibited acts provided by law, it shall
be unlawful:
"36.1. For any officer or employee of the Philippine government to influence or
attempt to influence any person covered by this Act to vote, or not to vote, for a
particular candidate. Nothing in this Act shall be deemed to prohibit free discussion
regarding politics or candidates for public office;
"36.2. For any person to deprive another of any right secured in this Act, or to give
false information as to one's name, address, or period of residence for the purposes
of establishing the eligibility or ineligibility to register or vote under this Act; or to
conspire with another person for the purpose of encouraging the giving of false
information in order to establish the eligibility or ineligibility of any individual to
register or vote under this Act; or, to pay, or offer to pay, or to accept payment
either for application for registration, or for voting;
"36.3. For any person to steal, conceal, alter, destroy, mutilate, manipulate, or in
any way tamper with the mail containing the ballots for overseas voters, the ballot,
the election returns, or any record, document or paper required for purposes of this
Act;
"36.4. For any deputized agent to refuse without justifiable ground, to serve or
continue serving, or to comply with one's sworn duties after acceptance of the
deputization;
"36.5. For any public officer or employee or accredited or deputized organization or
association to cause the preparation, printing, distribution or posting of information
or material, without the prior approval of the Commission;
"36.6. For any public officer or employee to cause the transfer, promotion,
extension, recall of any member of the foreign service corps, including members of
the attached agencies, or otherwise cause the movement of any such member from
the current post or position one (1) year before and three (3) months after the day
of elections, without securing the prior approval of the Commission;
"36.7. For any person who, after being deputized by the Commission to undertake
activities in connection with the implementation of this Act, shall campaign for or
assist, in whatever manner, candidates in the elections;
"36.8. For any person to engage in partisan political activity abroad during the thirty
(30)-day overseas voting period;
"36.9. For any person who is not a citizen of the Philippines to participate, by word
or deed, directly or indirectly through qualified organizations/associations, in any
manner and at any stage of the Philippine political process abroad, including
participation in the campaign and elections.
"The provision of existing laws to the contrary notwithstanding, and with due regard
to the Principle of Double Criminality, the prohibited acts described in this section
are electoral offenses and shall be punishable in the Philippines.
"The penalties imposed under Section 264 of the Omnibus Election Code, as
amended, shall be imposed on any person found guilty of committing any of the
prohibited acts as defined in this section: Provided, That the penalty of prision mayor
in its minimum period shall be imposed upon any person found guilty under Section
36.3 hereof without the benefit of the operation of the Indeterminate Sentence Law.
If the offender is a public officer or a candidate, the penalty shall be prision mayor
in its maximum period. In addition, the offender shall be sentenced to suffer
perpetual disqualification to hold public office and deprivation of the right to vote."
Section 38. Section 25 of the same Act is hereby renumbered as Section 37 and is
amended to read as follows:
"SEC. 37. Joint Congressional Oversight Committee. - A Joint Congressional Oversight
Committee is hereby created, composed of the Chairperson of the Senate
Committee on Constitutional Amendments, Revision of Codes and Laws, and seven
(7) other Senators designated by the Senate President, and the Chairperson of the
House Committee on Suffrage and Electoral Reforms, and seven (7) other Members
of the House of Representatives designated by the Speaker of the House of
Representatives: Provided, That, of the seven (7) members to be designated by each
House of Congress, four (4) should come from the majority to include the chair of
the Committee on Foreign Affairs and the remaining three (3) from the minority.
"The Joint Congressional Oversight Committee shall have the power to monitor and
evaluate the implementation of this Act."
Section 39. Sections 26, 27 and 28 of the same Act are hereby renumbered as
Sections 38, 39 and 40, respectively.
Section 40. Section 29 of the same Act is hereby renumbered as Section 41 and is
amended to read as follows:
"SEC. 41. Appropriations. - The amount necessary to carry out the provisions of this
Act shall be included in the budgets of the Commission on Elections and the DFA in
the annual General Appropriations Act."
Section 41. Implementing Rules and Regulations. - The Commission shall promulgate
rules and regulations for the implementation and enforcement of the provisions of
this Act within sixty (60) days from the effectivity thereof.
In the formulation of the rules and regulations, the Commission shall coordinate
with the DFA, the DOLE, the POEA, the OWWA and the Commission on Filipinos
Overseas. Nongovernment organizations and accredited Filipino organizations or
associations abroad shall be consulted.
Section 42. Amending Clause. - Consistent with the amendments introduced by this
Act, Section 2 of Republic Act No. 9189, on the declaration of policy, is, hereby
amended to read as follows:
"SEC. 2. Declaration of Policy. - It is the prime duty of the State to provide a system
of honest and orderly overseas voting that upholds the secrecy and sanctity of the
ballot. Towards this end, the State ensures equal opportunity to all qualified citizens
of the Philippines abroad in the exercise of this fundamental right."
VII. Macalintal v. COMELEC
FACTS:
This is a petition for certiorari and prohibition filed by Romulo B. Macalintal, a
member of the Philippine Bar, seeking a declaration that certain provisions of
Republic Act No. 9189 (The Overseas Absentee Voting Act of 2003) suffer from
constitutional infirmity. Claiming that he has actual and material legal interest in the
subject matter of this case in seeing to it that public funds are properly and lawfully
used and appropriated, petitioner filed the instant petition as a taxpayer and as a
lawyer.
Petitioner posits that Section 5(d) is unconstitutional because it violates Section 1,
Article V of the 1987 Constitution which requires that the voter must be a resident
in the Philippines for at least one year and in the place where he proposes to vote
for at least six months immediately preceding an election. Petitioner cites the ruling
of the Court in Caasi vs. Court of Appeals to support his claim. In that case, the Court
held that a green card holder immigrant to the United States is deemed to have
abandoned his domicile and residence in the Philippines.
Petitioner further argues that Section 1, Article V of the Constitution does not allow
provisional registration or a promise by a voter to perform a condition to be qualified
to vote in a political exercise; that the legislature should not be allowed to
circumvent the requirement of the Constitution on the right of suffrage by providing
a condition thereon which in effect amends or alters the aforesaid residence
requirement to qualify a Filipino abroad to vote. He claims that the right of suffrage
should not be granted to anyone who, on the date of the election, does not possess
the qualifications provided for by Section 1, Article V of the Constitution.
ISSUE:
Is RA 9189 [Overseas Absentee Voting Act of 2003], valid & constitutional?
RULING:
Contrary to petitioner’s claim that Section 5(d) circumvents the Constitution,
Congress enacted the law prescribing a system of overseas absentee voting in
compliance with the constitutional mandate. Such mandate expressly requires that
Congress provide a system of absentee voting that necessarily presupposes that the
“qualified citizen of the Philippines abroad” is not physically present in the country.
The petition was partly GRANTED. The following portions of R.A. No. 9189 are
declared VOID for being UNCONSTITUTIONAL:
a) The phrase in the first sentence of the first paragraph of Section 17.1, to wit:
“subject to the approval of the Joint Congressional Oversight Committee;”
b) The portion of the last paragraph of Section 17.1, to wit: “only upon review and
approval of the Joint Congressional Oversight Committee;”
c) The second sentence of the first paragraph of Section 19, to wit: “The
Implementing Rules and Regulations shall be submitted to the Joint Congressional
Oversight Committee created by virtue of this Act for prior approval;” and
d) The second sentence in the second paragraph of Section 25, to wit: “It shall
review, revise, amend and approve the Implementing Rules and Regulations
promulgated by the Commission” of the same law;
for being repugnant to Section 1, Article IX-A of the Constitution mandating the
independence of constitutional commission, such as COMELEC.
Pursuant to Section 30 of R.A. No. 9189, the rest of the provisions of said law
continues to be in full force and effect.
VIII. People v. Corral
Facts:
Appellant was charged having voted illegally at the general elections held on June 5,
1934. After due trial, he was convicted on the ground that he had voted while
laboring under a legal disqualification. The judgment of conviction was based on
section 2642, in connection with section 432 of the Revised Administrative Code.
It is undisputed that appellant was sentenced by final judgment of this court
promulgated on March 3, 1910 to suffer eight years and one day of presidio mayor.
No evidence was presented to show that prior to June 5, 1934, he had been granted
a plenary pardon. It is likewise undisputed that at the general elections held on June
5, 1934, the voted in election precinct No. 18 of the municipality of Davao, Province
of Davao.
Counsel for the appellant contend that inasmuch as the latter voted in 1928 his
offense had already prescribed, and he could no longer be prosecuted for illegal
voting at the general election held on June 5, 1934.
Issue:
1. W/N the state has the right to deprive a person’s right to suffrage
2. W/N the appellant’s contention that the end of his punishment thus ends of
his disqualification for election has merit.
Held:
Yes. The right of the State to deprive persons to the right of suffrage by reason of
their having been convicted of crime, is beyond question. "The manifest purpose of
such restrictions upon this right is to preserve the purity of elections. The
presumption is that one rendered infamous by conviction of felony, or other base
offense indicative of moral turpitude, is unfit to exercise the privilege of suffrage or
to hold office. The exclusion must for this reason be adjudged a mere
disqualification, imposed for protection and not for punishment, the withholding of
a privilege and not the denial of a personal right.
No. Neither is there any merit in the contention advanced by counsel for the
appellant that the disqualification imposed on the latter must be considered as
having been removed at the expiration of his sentence. This claim is based upon an
erroneous theory of the nature of the disqualification. It regards it as a punishment
when, as already indicated, the correct view is that it is imposed, "for protection and
not for punishment,.the withholding of a privilege and not the denial of a personal
right." Judicial interpretation and long established administrative practice are
against such a view.