Classification and Prognosis of Pulmonary Hypertension in Adults
Classification and Prognosis of Pulmonary Hypertension in Adults
Classification and Prognosis of Pulmonary Hypertension in Adults
HYPERTENSION IN ADULTS
All topics are updated as new evidence becomes available and our peer review process is
complete.
Literature review current through: Dec 2017. | This topic last updated: Oct 27, 2017.
The classification and prognosis of PH are reviewed here. The epidemiology, pathogenesis,
clinical features, diagnostic evaluation, and treatment of PH are discussed separately.
PAH refers to group 1 PH. PH refers to any of group 2 through group 5 PH, and is also used
when referring to all five groups collectively.
Group 1 pulmonary arterial hypertension (PAH) — Patients in this class have PAH due to
the following conditions:
●Drugs and toxins – Several drugs are either definite or possible risk factors for the
development of PAH.
●Connective tissue diseases – Systemic sclerosis (also called
scleroderma) and several other connective tissue diseases (eg,
rheumatoid arthritis, systemic lupus erythematosus, Raynaud disease,
mixed connective tissue disease) can be associated with PAH.
●PVOD (Group 1') – Unlike PAH which involves the small muscular
pulmonary arterioles, PVOD is characterized by extensive diffuse
occlusion of the pulmonary veins resulting in tortuous dilation of the pulmonary
capillaries. The resulting appearance mimics that of pulmonary capillary
hemangiomatosis. PVOD is a rare cause of PH and is discussed separately.
Group 2 PH (left heart disease) — PH due to left heart disease (LHD) is characterized by
PH associated with an elevated left atrial pressure (eg, mean LA pressure >14 mmHg)
resulting in pulmonary venous hypertension (ie, post-capillary PH).
While PH due to left ventricular systolic heart failure is evident, heart failure with
preserved ejection fraction (HFpEF; diastolic dysfunction) is a growing cause of WHO
group 2 PH [3]. Patients with HFpEF are characterized by chronic elevation of left atrial
and pulmonary venous pressure. The pulmonary artery pressure increases in proportion
to the elevated pulmonary venous pressure (passive elevation; post-capillary PH). If the
pressure remains elevated, over time the small pulmonary arteries and arterioles can
remodel resulting in an occlusive vasculopathy similar to that seen in patients with
WHO group 1 PAH (post-capillary and pre-capillary PH).
Patients with obesity can also develop an extreme form of diastolic dysfunction
sometimes referred to as an "obesity-associated restrictive cardiomyopathy" . It is
characterized by fatty infiltration of cardiac myocytes, restrictive physiology, and
marked elevation in left and right heart filling pressures. These patients can also
progress to severe pulmonary hypertension secondary to an occlusive vasculopathy of
the small pulmonary arteries and arterioles [6].
•Patients with left ventricular systolic dysfunction can develop PH . The exact
incidence varies with the population studied. As an example, in a study of 108
patients with dilated cardiomyopathy, 26 percent had an estimated pulmonary
artery systolic pressure (PASP) above 40 mmHg, measured by echocardiography
[9]. This was associated with a greater likelihood of death or hospitalizations (89
versus 32 percent), compared with those with a PASP ≤40 mmHg.
History — All patients with CTEPH have dyspnea. The dyspnea initially occurs during
exertion only, but then progresses to occur at rest and becomes more severe [23]. Dyspnea
and exercise intolerance are usually more troubling to patients who are active and, therefore,
such patients tend to be evaluated earlier than patients who live a sedentary lifestyle.
Many patients provide a history consistent with an acute venous thromboembolic event (eg,
pleuritic chest pain, lower extremity discomfort, or a prolonged atypical pneumonia) months
to years prior to the onset of the dyspnea, although a documented history of venous
thromboembolism may be absent in as many as 38 percent of patients with surgically-
accessible CTEPH [24]. Alternatively, they may describe a hospitalization or surgical
procedure from which they never fully recovered. The absence of a diagnosis of venous
thromboembolism is not surprising since venous thrombosis and pulmonary embolism are
frequently overlooked in the population at large [25]. The absence of a documented history
of acute venous thromboembolism should not dissuade a clinician from considering this
diagnosis in patients with unexplained dyspnea.
As the CTEPH progresses, patients may begin to report symptoms or signs related to
progressive pulmonary hypertension complicated by right ventricular dysfunction. This may
include lower extremity edema, exertional chest pain, near-syncope, or syncope [23].
More obvious physical findings become apparent once significant right ventricular
hypertrophy or overt right ventricular failure develops. Findings include a right ventricular lift,
jugular venous distension, prominent A and V wave venous pulsations, fixed splitting of the
second heart sound, a right ventricular S3, murmurs of tricuspid regurgitation or pulmonic
insufficiency, hepatomegaly, ascites, and peripheral edema. The peripheral edema may be a
result of chronic lower extremity venous outflow obstruction related to the venous
thromboembolic disease or right ventricular failure related to the progressive pulmonary
hypertension.
A unique physical finding in some patients with CTEPH is the presence of flow murmurs over
the lung fields. These subtle bruits appear to originate from turbulent flow through partially
obstructed or recanalized pulmonary arteries. They are high pitched and blowing in quality,
heard over the lung fields rather than the precordium, accentuated during inspiration, and
frequently heard only during periods of breath-holding. They have not been described in
patients with other types of pulmonary hypertension.
DIAGNOSTIC EVALUATION
●Pulmonary function tests – Most patients have a reduction in the single breath
diffusing capacity for carbon monoxide (DLCO), which is out of proportion to any
abnormalities in spirometry. A mild restrictive or obstructive defect may be present,
although spirometry is often normal. The restrictive defect may be related to
parenchymal scarring [29], while the obstructive defect may be due to mucosal
hyperemia caused by bronchial arterial collateral circulation. For those patients who
have an arterial blood gas performed as part of their pulmonary function tests, an
increased alveolar-arterial (A-a) oxygen gradient and a decline in the arterial oxygen
tension (PaO2) with exercise are typical. The resting PaO2 may be normal.
The prognosis of PH is highly variable and depends upon the etiology and severity of PH.
Group 1 PAH — The natural history and prognosis of group 1 pulmonary arterial
hypertension (PAH) is better studied than that of groups 2 through 5.
Prognosis without therapy — Without therapy, the prognosis of patients in group 1 PAH is
poor. Data from the Registry to Evaluate Early and Long-term PAH Disease Management
(REVEAL registry) reported that, from the time of diagnostic right heart catheterization,
patients with PAH had one-year survival rate of 85 percent, three-year survival of 68 percent,
five-year survival of 57 percent, and seven-year survival rate of 49 percent [17].
The one-year survival of patients with newly diagnosed group 1 PAH may be predicted using
a risk score derived from REVEAL registry data. The risk score is the sum of points derived
from clinical data including group 1 subgroup, demographics, and comorbidities; functional
class, vital signs, six-minute walk test, and brain natriuretic peptide level; echocardiogram,
pulmonary function tests, and right heart catheterization findings. Data were prospectively
collected from 504 patients with a mean six-minute walk distance of 308 m, 62 percent of
whom were classified as World Health Organization (WHO) functional class III . One-year
survival correlated with risk score: 1 to 7 (95 percent), 8 (92 percent), 9 (89 percent), 10 to 11
(72 percent), and ≥12 (66 percent). This risk score calculates survival only and should
not be used to make decisions for treatment. This and other models (eg, The French
Pulmonary Hypertension Network [FPHN] registry) require prospective validation before
they can be routinely used in clinical practice .
Prognosis was reported using data derived from the COMPERA (Comparative, Prospective
Registry of Newly Initiated Therapies for Pulmonary hypertension) database . Patients were
risk stratified using a model that incorporated World Health Organization functional class, six
minute walk distance, brain natriuretic peptide levels, right atrial pressure, cardiac index, and
mixed venous oxygen saturation. Mortality rates in patients at one year after diagnosis was 3
percent for low risk patients, 10 percent for intermediate-risk patients and 21 percent for high
risk patients .
Among the etiologies of group 1 PAH, compared to idiopathic PAH (IPAH), symptomatic
patients with PAH associated with another disease (eg, liver disease, systemic sclerosis)
generally have a worse prognosis; an exception is patients with PAH due to Eisenmenger's
syndrome, who have a better prognosis than patients with IPAH [21-23]. The prognosis of
patients with disease-associated PAH, is discussed in the following sections:
●Systemic sclerosis
●Portopulmonary hypertension
●Schistosomiasis
Prognostic factors — Data from prospective trials have described factors that portend a poor
prognosis in patients with PAH . While these factors indicate poor prognosis when PAH is
newly diagnosed, some may not be reliable for ongoing assessment of prognosis during
follow-up.
●Male gender
•Low right ventricle fractional area change and oxygen pulse during exercise on
stress echocardiography
●Decreased pulmonary arterial capacitance (ie, the stroke volume divided by the
pulmonary arterial pulse pressure)
●Hypocapnia
Increased age and male gender are frequently cited as factors that are associated with worse
survival . The reason for this is unknown but thought to be due to age- and gender-related
differences in cardiopulmonary hemodynamics . In addition, the worse prognosis in older
patients may reflect the presence of multifactorial disease or the presence of comorbidities
that impact survival.
●A registry in the United Kingdom and Ireland of patients with PAH diagnosed between
2001 and 2009 found that compared to patients less than 50 years of age, individuals
over 50 years had worse survival at one year (90 versus 95 percent), three years (76
versus 91 percent), five years (57 versus 87 percent), and seven years (44 versus 75
percent)
●Data from the REVEAL registry found that, among individuals with PAH who were
older than 60 years, men had a lower two-year survival than women (64 versus 78
percent, hazard ratio 1.67, 95% CI 1.3-2.2) . In contrast, there was no difference in
survival among men and women with PAH who were 60 years or younger (84 versus 86
percent).
Indices of severe PAH including poor functional class and evidence of right heart failure are
poor prognostic signs. As an example, patients with severe PAH or right heart failure die
sooner without treatment (usually within one year) than patients with mild PAH or no right
heart failure. Patients with IPAH and a mean right atrial pressure ≥20 mmHg have a
median survival of approximately one month .
Cause of death — The main cause of death in patients with PAH is thought to be right heart
failure with circulatory collapse and superimposed respiratory failure. A similar course of
circulatory collapse can occur when these patients are placed on mechanical ventilation or
undergo anesthesia or conscious sedation. Patients with PAH who experience cardiac arrest
rarely survive. In a retrospective study of 132 patients with PAH who required
cardiopulmonary resuscitation (CPR) for circulatory arrest, CPR was unsuccessful in 80
percent and only 6 percent survived more than 90 days without residual neurologic deficit .
While early studies in the 1990s reported a high prevalence (73 to 84 percent) of death from
circulatory collapse due to right heart failure, analyses done during the era of PAH-specific
therapies report lower rates (44 to 50 percent), suggesting that although right heart failure and
circulatory collapse remains important causes of death in patients with PAH, it may be
declining with evolving trends in therapy. As examples:
●One prospective analysis from a single-center cohort of 84 patients with PAH reported
that 44 percent of deaths were directly due to right heart failure or sudden death. In
another 44 percent, PH contributed to, but was not the direct cause of, death. In 8
percent, PH played no role in the cause of death, and in 4 percent, the cause of death
could not be determined . Most deaths were in a healthcare environment with the vast
majority on prostanoid therapy (76 percent) and less than half had advance care
directives.
●Another small retrospective case series from a single center cohort reported that death
from right ventricular failure (32 percent) or sudden death (18 percent) occurred in
patients with PAH and a variety of other causes were identified in the remainder .
●In our clinical experience, it is not uncommon to have success treating PAH in patients
with systemic sclerosis (SSc) or liver disease, only to have the patients then die of other
SSc-related complications or progression of their cirrhosis.
A multicenter prospective study is required to establish the true prevalence of conditions that
contribute to death in patients with PAH.
Groups 2 to 5 — The prognosis of other groups with PH likely varies with the prognosis of
the underlying disease, severity of the PH, and response to therapy. These are discussed
separately:
Here are the patient education articles that are relevant to this topic. We encourage you to
print or e-mail these topics to your patients. (You can also locate patient education articles on
a variety of subjects by searching on "patient info" and the keyword(s) of interest.)
●Group 1 PAH may be idiopathic; additional causes include PAH due to heritable
genetic defects, drugs and toxins, connective tissue diseases, human immunodeficiency
virus infection, portal hypertension, congenital heart disease, and schistosomiasis. PH
can also be due to left heart disease (group 2), lung disease and/or hypoxemia (group 3),
chronic thromboembolic disease (group 4), and unclear multifactorial mechanisms
(group 5).
●PH is a progressive disease that may be fatal, if untreated. However, the rate of
progression is highly variable and depends upon the type and severity of the PH. In
general, patients with group 1 PAH who are not on therapy and patients with severe PH
have a poor prognosis.
●Survival rates among patients in group 1 PAH have been reported as 85 percent at one
year, 68 percent at three years, 57 percent at five years, and 49 percent at seven years.
PAH-directed therapy may improve mortality. Factors associated with poor prognosis
include age older than 50 years, male gender, functional class III or IV, failure to
improve functional class with therapy, indices of right ventricular failure, connective
tissue disease-associated PAH, and others. Many patients die from circulatory collapse
from right heart failure (44 to 50 percent).
●The prognosis of patients on group 2 through 5 likely varies with the prognosis of the
underlying disease, severity of the PH, and response to therapy.