20 Issues For Businesses Expanding Internationally
20 Issues For Businesses Expanding Internationally
20 Issues For Businesses Expanding Internationally
© Ernst & Young Australia and the Institute of Chartered Accountants in Ernst & Young
Australia 2010. Address: Ernst & Young Centre, 680 George Street, Sydney
All rights reserved. Business briefing series: 20 issues for businesses expanding internationally
First edition
ISBN: 978-1-921245-62-6
ABN 50 084 642 571 The Institute of Chartered Accountants in Australia Incorporated in Australia Members’ Liability Limited. 0910-37
ABN 75 288 172 749 Ernst & Young.
Business briefing series
20 issues for Anyone who has made the bold step of starting their own business has at some
stage dreamed about taking that business offshore in a bid for increased expansion
businesses expanding
and to generate additional revenue.
internationally
Although ambitious and potentially very lucrative, such a move could also prove
very costly if not done correctly.
To assist business leaders with the process of taking on globalisation, the Institute
of Chartered Accountants in Australia (the Institute), in conjunction with Ernst &
Young (EY) has produced this thought leadership paper entitled Business briefing:
20 issues for businesses expanding internationally.
The publication is the third part of the Institute’s Business Briefing series designed
to help businesses to successfully navigate challenging issues. The commentary
in the report is divided into three key phases of an international expansion project:
• Planning for expansion
• Choosing your location
• Conducting business overseas.
Business briefing: 20 issues for businesses expanding internationally has been written
and presented in such a way as to maximise the reader’s understanding of the
issues. Each of the three sections contains a series of pull-out boxes which guide
the reader as to the types of questions that they should be asking with regard
to the business. These questions are consolidated into a detachable checklist at
the back of the publication which can be used when consulting the paper.
I trust that you will find this thought leadership paper interesting and
worthwhile reading.
Checklist . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 21
Contact details . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Back cover
The Globalization Index1 supports many market indicators Regardless of the size of their international footprint,
that the trend towards ambitious international expansion the research identified the top five drivers for
will continue. This research depicts a global landscape businesses expanding internationally as overall growth
where organisations execute their international opportunities, profitability, access to materials, access
expansion strategies at a rapid pace. This speed of to human resources, and the ability to innovate.
expansion may indicate the strong desire by companies
to be the first-to-market and/or the imperative to
Benefits for international companies
capitalise on new market developments.
from globalisation
The survey was conducted in August 2009, with 520 In which of the following ways has globalisation
senior executives worldwide. 38% of respondents had a positive impact on your business over the
indicated that they currently derive over half of their past three years?
revenue from overseas operations. As indicated in the
chart below, by 2012 more than half of the respondents 86%
Overall growth
expect this to be the case, with one in four respondents 80%
53%
expecting to derive more than three quarters of their
revenue from overseas. 68%
Profitability 51%
32%
Only one in 50 executives surveyed believes containing
their operations within their home country or earning 35%
Access to materials 27%
less than 10% of their revenue from overseas markets 39%
by 2012, to be a viable option.
42%
Access to 27%
human resources 21%
What proportion of your company’s revenues is derived
from its overseas operations (i.e. outside your company’s 27%
home market) currently, and in three years time?* Ability to innovate 33%
31%
Proportion of
30%
Investment revenue from
27%
Now 13 10 17 23 20 18 opportunities international clients:
29%
25 – 75%
Three 16%
years 2 7 15 21 28 26 Access to finance 20% 10 – 24%
time 15%
0 – 9%
0% 100%
0 – 9% 15 – 24% 50 – 75%
10 – 14% 25 – 49% Over 75%
1. The Globalization Index 2009 is a report written by Ernst & Young with the Economist Intelligence Unit. The 2010 edition of the report is expected to be
released in January 2011.
Don’t know
Civil Law
Common Law
Muslim Law
Customary Law
Mixed System
2. Ernst & Young Passport (includes the 2010 Worldwide Corporate Tax Guide, the 2010 VAT Guide, the 2009 Global Executive and the
2009 Transfer Pricing Global Reference Guide)
information technology
• Labour law will regulate employment matters
For many businesses, the decision to relocate research
• There is real estate, planning and construction
and development activities to an emerging market will
law to consider.
be influenced by a number of strategic and business
drivers. These may include using the target location as
a strategic hub for market expansion into that region.
Conducting research in emerging and fast growth
markets can drive new ideas by tapping into a new pool
of innovative and market leading talent.
9.0 – 10
8.0 – 8.9
7.0 – 7.9
6.0 – 6.9
5.0 – 5.9
4.0 – 4.9
3.0 – 3.9
2.0 – 2.9
1.0 – 1.9
0 – 0.9
The Corruption Perceptions Index (CPI) measures the perceived level of the corruption in 180 countries and territories around the world. The CPI is a ‘survey of
surveys’, based on 13 different expert and business surveys. Scores range from 0 (perceived to be highly corrupt) to 10 (perceived to have low levels of corruption).
are highly likely to have a diverse management team 12. Global human resources considerations
whilst those with only domestic operations are unlikely
What benefits will you provide to expatriates and
to have a significant proportion of senior management
what are the tax consequences? Do your employees
from another country. require security protection?
Do you have a team that can deal with assignment
More global companies are more likely management, immigration and tax compliance?
to have international management
Should these functions be outsourced?
Roughly what proportion of senior management are
nationals of another country? Although expatriates know your business and may
Foreign
enjoy the opportunity to work overseas; they may also
operations in
11 or more 30 16 19 9 26 lack local knowledge. Relocating and remunerating
countries expatriates can be more expensive than local hires,
Foreign
operations
% so you should first consider the objectives of the
in 1 –10 55 22 9 6 5
countries
assignment and your desired return on investment. If
Domestic
you decide to use expatriates rather than local hires, you
operations
only
88 5 1 4 must also consider what happens when the assignment
is finished. A repatriation plan should be implemented
0% 100% so the knowledge and skills gained on assignment are
Senior management from another country: retained within your organisation. You must also ensure
Less than 5% 5 – 14% 15 – 24% 25 – 49% 50%+ that you have the resources to manage the related local
and international compliance obligations, particularly if
Source: The Globalization Index Survey 2009
you are expanding into more than one country.
* Figures may not add up to exactly 100%, due to rounding.
5
8 2
34 14
8 1
4 5
3
1
USA 3 1
6
~2.7 2 2 100
24 27
1 7 2
181 82 6
4
Malaysia
~5.1
1 KSA Kuwait
~22.8 ~4.0 177
13
Bahrain UAE 3
Islamic AuM ~1.2 ~6.1
26
by Country
(US$ billion):
10+
1
1 – 10 9
0.5 – 1
0.1 – 0.5 Note: Funds per country include those managed by
0.01 – 0.1 players headquartered in that respective jurisdiction.
14. Choosing the operating structure 16. Foreign exchange management and
Are you looking for slow organic growth? currency risk/controls
Will you start out with a sales office or are you Is the local currency stable or volatile?
looking for a green field development?
Is currency hedging available at a reasonable cost?
Are you looking to establish an immediate local
Could currency restrictions inhibit or even prohibit
presence? If so, will you set up a joint venture
the flow of international funds?
or will you acquire an existing local business?
Organisations generally can hedge international internal
There are a number of factors that will determine the
transactions effectively without adverse outcomes,
method of entry into your chosen location. The market
although the tax and accounting treatment can be
conditions and the opportunities to capture immediate
complicated. The risk and commercial exposure rises
market share will impact the design of your initial
exponentially where transactions with external suppliers
business model and structure. For example, you may
and customers are involved.
have time to establish various operating entities and
build up your infrastructure such as factories or, you may The diagram below illustrates the fall of the Euro against
only have time to set-up a simple representative office the US Dollar initially triggered by the sovereign debt
from which you can immediately negotiate customer crisis in Greece. The fall of the Euro accelerated when
contracts. These factors may in turn drive your choice the crisis spread to other European countries. The rise
of legal operating structure and also the method you and fall of a currency can impact the economics of an
adopt to gain a foothold in the market. For example, entire project or production set-up. It can significantly
will you establish a joint venture with a host country alter the margins of goods sold on the world market, as
partner or operative and/or set-up various contracts well as the cost of overseas sourced inputs. The hedging
to establish your operations? There will be costs and of cross currency supply or loan contracts may remove
benefits associated with these choices which must be some of the risk but will also come at a cost.
considered, including those concerning commercial,
legal, regulatory and tax issues.
1.55
country? What is the level of red tape and how will 1.20
you go about cutting through it? You may have local
accounting and reporting obligations and other legal
Nov Dec Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug
statutes that you must comply with at start-up and on 2009 2010
an ongoing basis. Penalties for non-compliance may
Source: Yahoo Finance
be severe, including criminal prosecutions and prison
sentences. How will you make sure that you have
identified all obligations and how you will satisfy them?
In addition to foreign exchange management, you need
It may be cost effective to outsource your corporate
to ensure that the target location does not impose
secretarial, accounting and tax functions to local experts.
limitations on the movement of currency in and out of
the country.
19. Risk management an emerging market for example, moved from rank 12
in 2009 to rank 5 in 2010. You should also recognise
Have you identified areas of risk and how you
that in such an environment, to manage existing and
will address them?
newly emerging risks, an effective risk management
Are your foreign operations susceptible to fraud? strategy and process should be implemented. Obtaining
appropriate insurance in your selected host country is
There are a number of business risks that should be
an important consideration to mitigate against potential
considered when entering an emerging or international
business risks.
market. To identify these risks, Ernst & Young conducted
You should also consider your organisation’s exposure
research to ascertain the top 10 business risks facing
to potential fraud. Are you at greater risk if the control of
multinational firms.
your organisation resides in only a handful of managers,
The Ernst & Young Business Risk Report 2010 4 is based rather than a structure with a board of directors and
on interviews with industry executives and analysts policy and process around corporate governance,
representing 14 industry sectors. The survey asked internal/ external audit and other external controls?
each interviewee to identify and rank the top business
risks for 2010. Aggregating the results worldwide
20. Exit or wind-down
and across industry sectors, resulted in the following
top 10 business risks for multinational firms ranked Will you continue to maintain a presence
by importance: in this location?
1. Uncertainty around regulation and compliance What are the legal and commercial issues
associated with terminating business
2. Access to credit and the impact of rising levels
and employment contracts?
of government debt
What is your strategy for redeploying
3. The withdrawal of global stimulus programs
your resources?
4. The global war for talent and compensation
structures There are different ways to exit or wind-down your
5. The strategic imperative of succeeding in an operations in a host country. You will need to take into
emerging market, as these markets continue to account local laws, tax and financial issues. You must
drive global growth also determine if you wish to maintain a presence in the
host country. Options may include liquidation, the sale
6. Increased cost pressures as the result of commodity
of shares or even floating the business. The exit strategy
price inflation and low cost competitors
should be part of your overall business plan.
7. Incumbent firms in transitional sectors adjusting
to non-traditional entrants There are also reputational risks to consider, particularly
if your business was an important employer in a country
8. Staying ahead of consumer preferences and
or region. To avoid costly litigation or compensation
government regulation on environmental issues
payments you must also be aware of the industrial
9. Political backlash and reputational risks triggered relations environment. Consider whether local
by corporate social responsibility breaches regulations restrict the transfer of funds overseas.
10. Rescue mergers and regulatory changes that may
force new transactions.
• Create a short list of new and emerging markets, tap into existing
networks, talk to your advisors and visit your short listed locations
4. Political and • Is the political system stable? How do you assess sovereign risk?
social climate
• Does the country suffer under high levels of sovereign debt?
5. Local tax and • Is the tax regime business friendly and/or competitive?
regulatory
• Does the country have free trade agreements or double tax treaties?
environment
• Does the regulatory regime set the scene for a sound corporate
governance framework?
6. Legal system • Is it a common law system? If not, do you understand the outcomes?
• Do the laws and the legal and judicial system provide support for and
protection of commercial activities?
7. Innovation and • Should you develop your products in emerging or fast growth markets?
incentives
• Should you have a presence at global innovation clusters?
9. Cultural • Are there significant cultural differences that may impact the way you
compatibility conduct your business?
• Are there likely to be language barriers?
10. Local workforce • What is the availability, skill-set and cost structure of the local work force?
11. Global management • Who will negotiate with government, customers, suppliers and business
team partners? How should you manage risks such as bribery and corruption?
12. Global human • What benefits will you provide to expatriates and what are the tax
resources consequences? Do your employees require security protection?
considerations
• Do you have a team that can deal with assignment management,
immigration and tax compliance?
13. Financing • What are the cash flow needs of your business? What is your projected
revenue growth? Are your financial models sound or overly optimistic?
• What is the debt equity mix of funding? What are the tax consequences?
14. Choosing the • Are you looking for slow organic growth? Will you start out with
operating structure a sales office or are you looking for a green field development?
• Are you looking to establish an immediate local presence? If so, will you
set up a joint venture or will you acquire an existing local business?
15. Implementing the • What are the legal and administrative procedures and regulatory
operating structure requirements for setting up the operating structure and starting
the business?
17. Business and • Are you aware of how the new Australian attribution regime in
international taxation relation to controlled foreign companies may allow you to take
better advantage of efficiencies overseas?
18. Supply chain, • Have you identified all possible supply chain efficiencies?
transfer pricing and
• Have you considered potential Australian tax issues as you
intellectual property
move functions, intellectual property and risk offshore?
Is your intellectual property and data protected?
19. Risk management • Have you identified areas of risk and how will you address them?
20. Exit or wind-down • Will you continue to maintain a presence in this location?