The Heat-Kit Planning Guide: Masonry Stove Builders
The Heat-Kit Planning Guide: Masonry Stove Builders
The Heat-Kit Planning Guide: Masonry Stove Builders
Masonry Heating 2
What’s a Masonry Heater? 2
The Benefits of Radiant Heating 3
Environmental Benefits 5
Options 10
Domestic Bakeoven 10
Domestic Hot Water 11
Layout Guide 15
Standard dimensions 15
Clearances 15
Heater 15
Chimney 15
Layout Examples 16
Heated Benches 16
Examples of high output systems 18
printed on 8/25/2010
The Heat-Kit Planning Guide
Masonry Heating
What’s a Masonry Heater?
A
masonry heater allows you to heat your home with wood in a unique way. It’s main distinction is the ability
to store a large amount of heat. This means that you can rapidly burn a large charge of wood without
overheating your house. The heat is stored in the masonry thermal mass, and then slowly radiates into your
house for the next 18 to 24 hours.
You get a number of benefits, described in more detail below. If you burn wood fairly rapidly, it is a clean fuel. If
you try to burn it too slowly, the fire will change from flaming to smoldering combustion. The burning process is
incomplete and produces tars. Atmospheric pollution increases dramatically.
This is important if you are planning an energy-efficient house. The average energy demand of your house will be
quite low. For most of the time, it may require only 1 to 2 kW of heat. For most conventional woodstoves, this is
below their “critical burn rate”, or the point where they start to smolder. In other words, woodburning and energy
efficient houses don’t really suit each other very well, unless you have some way to store heat so that your stove
can operate in the “clean” range all of the time.
Masonry heaters fill the bill perfectly. If you need even a very small amount of heat, such as between seasons when
you simply want to take off the chill, you simply burn a smaller fuel charge–yet you still burn it quickly. The large
surface is never too hot to touch. You have a premium radiant heating system with a comfort level that simply
cannot be equaled by convection or forced air systems.
2
The Heat-Kit Planning Guide
M asonry heaters are radiant heating ºF. But step into the shade and you will start
systems. Radiant heating differs in sev- shivering within several minutes, even though the
eral fundamental aspects from conven- air temperature hasn't changed. The presence or
tional convection and forced air heating. absence of the sun changes your radiant
Understanding these differences is important if you environment dramatically. Similarly, even a slight
plan to include a masonry heater in your house breeze at these temperatures would change your
design. convective environment. The word "draft" in this
context immediately conjures up mental images of
discomfort.
Radiant heat is electromagnetic energy, the same as
visible light. The only difference is that it is in the
infrared range of the spectrum, with a longer
wavelength. Long wave infrared is more com-
fortable than short wave infrared. As the surface
temperature of a radiating body gets higher, the
wavelength of the radiant energy gets shorter, until
eventually it is seen as a dull glowing red. This is
the piercing heat you feel from a campfire as you
get close to the charcoal bed.
3
The Heat-Kit Planning Guide
Other aspects of radiant heating In Europe, radiant heat has been used in medicine
for therapeutic purposes for many years, and it is
systems starting to see some use here as well.
Less dust
How does this affect my choices?
With a conventional forced system, you use the air
that you breathe as a heating medium by cycling it Location important
through your furnace blower every few minutes.
Understanding some of the basic principles of
When you wake up in the morning with a “parched radiant heating is important when you decide where
throat”, you associate this with dry air. In fact, it is to locate your masonry heating system.
not dry air at all, but dust. The furnace circulates
Generally speaking, a masonry heater creates a
very fine dust throughout your house. Furnace
“comfort zone” around itself. The closer you are to
filters only get the larger particles, not the very fine
the heater, the higher is the MRT that your body
dust that causes the most sensitivity. When you add
“sees” in its environment.
a humidifier, what you are actually doing is using
moisture to help settle the dust out of the air. This means that you want the heater located where
your family spends most of its time. An open
Consider this: For a person with respiratory floorplan and a central location work best. Often the
problems, where is the best place to be in the masonry structure is designed to serve as a space
winter? Answer: Arizona, where the air is dry. divider between, say, kitchen and living room. The
fact that only minimal clearances to combustible
Less stratification materials are usually required allows for greater
flexibility in integrating the system into the home.
The reason there is less air movement with a radiant
heating system is that there is a much smaller Also consider the location of the firebox loading
temperature difference between the air at the ceiling door and its convenience to your firewood supply.
and at the floor. There is less overheating of Firewood storage inside the house is often not
upstairs bedrooms, and ceiling fans can usually be necessary, since the firebox gets loaded all at once.
eliminated. Radiant heating gives you more mileage
from a given amount of heat output by targeting it Many heaters often do double duty as fireplaces, so
better to where it is needed: in the living space this function should be considered as well.
where the radiant panels are located.
Windows affect performance
Healthy heat Many modern windows come with a special “low-
Radiant heating is beneficial for many allergy and E” coating that acts like a mirror for longwave
respiratory related problems, for the reasons radiant energy. With a masonry heater in the room,
outlined above. your body sees a reflection of the room’s warm
surfaces in the window in addition to the cold
In addition, you experience comfort at a lower air surface of the glass itself. With large, uncovered
temperature. Cooler air next to your exposed skin glass surfaces such as patio doors, low-E glass will
promotes circulation and your body's own heat improve comfort levels noticeably with vertical
production. It feels invigorating and allows you to radiant panels such as those in a centrally located
be more alert. The “sunny spring day” cited earlier masonry heater.
demonstrates this effect.
4
The Heat-Kit Planning Guide
Environmental Benefits
A sustainable technology Wood is a renewable resource
Provided that trees are grown on a sustainable basis,
S
ustainable construction is starting to come
into its own. Many people are beginning to there is almost zero contribution to global warming
question not only the energy consumption of when you burn wood.
their houses and their lifestyles, but also wider
Plants use photosynthesis to store solar energy. They
effects, such as the amount of embodied energy in
accomplish this by converting atmospheric carbon
the house materials, and the amount of pollution that
dioxide into stored carbohydrates such as cellulose.
has been generated as a result.
When a tree eventually dies, this carbon dioxide is
Masonry heating is an ancient technology. Its basic returned to the atmosphere by the action of bacteria
ingredients are earth and fire. While it is relatively and fungi as the wood decomposes. Because this is a
new to North America, it dates back several hundred closed carbon cycle there is no net impact. When
years in many of the colder regions of Europe. you burn wood, your are heating your house with
stored solar energy and simply using a speeded up
All of the materials in a heater can be recyclable, if version of this cycle.
desired, and there are heaters in Europe that have
been giving faithful service for over a hundred Proper use of wood as a heating fuel requires that it
years. be harvested sustainably. As opposed to
clearcutting, proper forestry practice requires
thinning and culling to improve the stand. This
Helping to reduce global warming could, in theory, generate enough fuel to heat a huge
The most important global environmental issue number of houses.
today is global warming and our emissions of
greenhouse gases (mainly carbon dioxide). We are Minimizing emissions from
risking the well-being of future generations because
of our consumption of fossil fuels. Every time that woodburning
we fill our car with gas we add the equivalent of a Large scale woodburning can lead to air quality
hundred pound sack of carbon to the atmosphere in problems. The main environmental issue is smoke
the form of carbon dioxide emissions from our emissions. Woodsmoke is very similar to cigarette
tailpipe. smoke from a health standpoint. It consists of tiny
droplets of tar known to regulators as PM-10, or
Hydrocarbons have been sequestered in the earth for
particulate matter smaller than 10 microns in size.
millions of years by the actions of plant life on the
Since a blood corpuscle is 6 microns, smoke
atmosphere. Through our consumption of fossil
particles can enter through the lungs directly into the
fuels we are returning this carbon into the
bloodstream. Hence, the health issue.
atmosphere at a staggering rate. As North
Americans we are the worst culprits, consuming As mentioned above, emissions from woodburning
several times the world average per capita. To have can vary dramatically depending on how it is
an meaningful impact, we need to reduce our fossil burned. For airtight metal stoves, the Unites States
fuel use by approximately 70 to 90%. Environmental Protection Agency (US-EPA) now
requires that all models must be certified to the US-
Our transportation choices are limited — we can
EPA Phase II standard for emissions. This has
drive less, or get a more efficient vehicle. We do,
resulted in clean-burn research and significant
however, have a choice in how we heat our homes.
improvements in airtight stove emissions from what
It simply doesn’t make sense to use valuable (yet
were very high levels.
ridiculously underpriced) resources simply to make
low grade heat. The Masonry Heater Association of North America
(MHA) has made a major effort to establish
emissions performance of masonry heaters through
EPA-audited field testing. As a result, the majority
of manufacturers now have emissions numbers for
their systems.
5
The Heat-Kit Planning Guide
Masonry Stove Builders has gone one step further. Installed cost can actually be very comparable to a
In partnership with Lopez Quarries Masonry conventional masonry fireplace. However, value for
Heaters (Everett, WA), we set up an emissions money is considerably higher than with a fireplace.
testing facility, Lopez Labs, and for four years have With a heater, your investment in bricks and mortar
been conducting an ongoing program of is working for you every day of the heating season
performance testing on a number of different heaters as active thermal mass storage and radiant heating
under simulated field conditions. panels.
As a result, we now have the largest database on Compared with other wood heating technologies,
masonry heating performance testing in North there is no depreciation or eventual replacement
America, with over 100 tests over a complete (24 cost. Your fire-tending chores are eliminated, and
hr) cycle, and have produced several research your maintenance chores will be minimal because
papersi. your chimney remains clean.
The results are summarized in the Table 1, and
iii
compared with US-EPA field tests for other N. Senf, Recent Laboratory and Field Testing of Masonry
woodburning appliances. The conclusion is clear: Heater and Masonry Fireplace Emissions, presented at the
87th Annual Meeting of the Air and Waste Management
masonry heaters are the cleanest way to burn Association, Cincinnati, June 19-24, 1994.
cordwood and comparable to the cleanest pellet N. Senf, Very Low Emissions Cordwood Combustion in High
stoves. Burn Rate Appliances - Early Results with Possible
Implications, presented at the 88th Annual Meeting of the
Air and Waste Management Association, San Antonio, June
A good investment 19-23, 1995.
N. Senf, Air Requirements and Related Parameters for Masonry
The higher initial cost of a masonry heating system
Heating Systems, prepared for The Research Division of
can be paid back in a number of ways. Like a Canada Mortgage and Housing Corporation, Ottawa, 1994.
masonry fireplace, it adds enjoyment and value to
your home — good masonry work is beautiful.
Table 1. Woodburning emissions - grams of smoke produced per kilogram of fuel burned.
6
Masonry Stove Builders
T raditionally, building a good masonry heater is part of the active thermal mass. It is typically
has required craftspeople with considerable installed by a local mason, and you have a wide
skill and training. The heater is not only choice of finish options.
required to perform well in terms of
efficiency and emissions, but also to be able to stand Components
up to many thousand cycles of rapid heating and The heater core consists of precast refractory
cooling. This severe thermal cycling places components that are assembled on site in
tremendous stresses on refractory materials, with conjunction with standard firebricks that are usually
which the stovemason must be intimately familiar. obtained locally. The double firebox doors are
constructed of high quality cast iron with heatproof
Our philosophy glass. All required hardware such as clean outs and
dampers is included.
We have been designing and building heaters for
many years. We are also founding members of the
Masonry Heater Association. By networking
with a very capable group of heater masons all
over North America, we’re able to benefit from
the latest knowledge and field experience.
The Heat-Kit was the first heater core developed
in North America and some of its more
innovative features have been more widely
adopted.
We are committed to masonry heater research
and development.
We developed the Heat-Kit system in 1985 to
better address both our own needs and those of
our clients. It is a system of precast refractory
components that has allowed us to reduce the
amount of expensive on-site time required to
build a heater core by 90% . Our main
innovation was to retain about 50% of the
firebrick construction in the core, including all
critical areas such as the firebox. Firebrick are
unsurpassed, for taking the heavy abuse of
thermal cycling.
We have also developed the first masonry white
bake oven (i.e., the flames do not pass through
the oven).
Description
A complete system includes a foundation, heater
and chimney.
7
The Heat-Kit Planning Guide
Gas flow
Figure 4. illustrates the gas flow through the Heat-
Kit 2. It is shown with the bakeoven option.
Outside combustion air enters at a lower level
through the foundation. It passes through the air
damper (1) and then into the firebox (2). Rapid
combustion of the fuel charge results in long flames,
which are directed around the bakeoven and then
burn out in the secondary combustion chamber. The
8
Masonry Stove Builders
9
The Heat-Kit Planning Guide
Options
Domestic Bakeoven
New design optimizes
performance
B
akeovens are readily incorporated into
Contraflow heaters, and have become a very
popular option in the last few years. There
are two types. In the traditional “black”
oven, flames pass directly through the oven, which is
then ready to bake after the fire is out.
In the “white” oven design that we have developed Figure 2. Heat-Kit white oven design is all-masonry for
for the Heat-Kit, the flames go around the oven even heat. Door is cast iron with ceramic glass.
chamber instead of through it. This allows the oven
to be used at any time. The oven floor is
unobstructed, with no throat opening to the firebox,
and the interior remains clean, with no soot or ash
deposits. The closed oven chamber and airtight cast
iron/glass oven door gives helps to retain moisture.
The design has been refined over several years of
trials and feedback from users. Benefits include:
10
Masonry Stove Builders
A
n electric domestic hot water heater usually This method allows the most flexibility in locating
accounts for the largest portion of a
household’s electricity bill, assuming that
electricity is not used for space heating.
Natural gas, where available, is less costly. However,
it is still a non-renewable resource that contributes to
global warming.
Part of the heat output of a contraflow heater can be
used to heat domestic hot water.
A heat exchanger consisting of one or more loops of
stainless steel high pressure boiler tubing is located
against the back of the firebox, in the hottest part of
the fire.
It is very important to install the proper safety
devices when adding a hot water coil. If water in the
coil is allowed to turn to steam, an explosion could
result. Also, the water in the tank can reach scalding
temperatures, so that a tempering valve may need to
be used. Never take any shortcuts when designing or
installing a domestic hot water loop into a wood
fired appliance.
Thermosyphon method
The heat transfer can take place in two ways, by
thermosyphoning, using natural convection, or by
means of a small circulation pump.
A thermosyphon system is the simplest, but also has
some drawbacks. It requires that the storage tank be
located higher than the coil. Best efficiency is
obtained when horizontal distance to the tank is 4 ft.
(1.2 m) or less and the vertical distance is 6 feet
(1.8m) or more.
This arrangement is often not convenient because the Figure 4. Hot water system -thermosyphon method
domestic hot water tank is usually located in the
basement. Sometimes you can get around this by
adding a preheat tank. The preheat tank is located for
good thermosyhoning and is plumbed to feed into
the cold water inlet of the primary tank.
Heat transfer is lower with the thermosyphon method
due to the slower water flow through the stainless
loop(s). In order to achieve good efficiency, both
lines from the coil to the tank should be insulated. A
minimum of 3/4" dia. pipe must be used to ensure
adequate flow.
11
The Heat-Kit Planning Guide
the tank(s) and provides the greatest amount of heat pump on and off.
transfer. A small pump (1 - 2 gal/min or 0.07 - 0.15
l/sec) is used to circulate water between the coil and
the tank. Usually, a standard hot water tank is used
Tempering tank
in an open system, i.e., there is not a separate heat A second tank can be installed to increase the
exchanger inside the tank itself. With an open capacity of the hot water system. This is known as
system, there is a continuous supply of oxygen in the the tempering tank method. It is often useful in
water, requiring the use of a non-ferrous circulation thermosyphon systems (see above). For both types
pump body material such as bronze. With iron pump of systems, it has the advantage of being able to
bodies, the oxygen in an open system will generate utilize more low-grade heat from the heater during
rust. periods of high usage. During high usage, water in
the tempering tank will be cold. For a
A controller is required to sense when the heater is thermosyphon system, this creates a higher
being fired or the water from the heater is warmer temperature differential for convection and
than the water in the tank. Since a considerable increases flow in the loop and therefore heat
amount of heat is stored in the firebox after a burn, transfer. For both types of systems, it allows low
water heating occurs for some time after the fire is grade heat from the firebox to be utilized for a
out. longer time after the fire is out, since the feedwater
to the coil is cold.
Two temperature sensors are used. One sensor is
placed at the hot water outlet from the heater. The
other sensor is placed at the tank where cooler water
leaves the bottom of the tank on its way to the loop.
A differential controller uses the temperature sensor
information to determine when to turn the circulation
12
Masonry Stove Builders
13
The Heat-Kit Planning Guide
14
Masonry Stove Builders
T
he diagram on this page gives typical stone. Tile or plaster facings are approximately the
dimensions for heater, chimney and optional same dimensions, since they are installed over a 4"
benches. A good place to start with the layout backing. Actual finished dimensions may vary by an
is the location of the chimney, since there will inch or two.
usually be some constraints such as passing by floor
joists or roof trusses.
Chimney
Chimney location is flexible and can be anywhere
Clearances except the front of the heater. Chimney dimensions
Clearances to combustibles are given in the table are shown for an 8"x12" flue liner, which is
below. Wing walls (partition walls) may touch heater standard. The liner can have any orientation. For an
by using a metal stud and cement board: 8" round liner, outside chimney dimension is
20"x20". An 8"x8" liner will also work in most
Clearances to Combustibles applications, for an outside chimney dimension of
2" 16"x16". Note that the chimney can be pushed 4"
Foundation
into the heater if space is a problem.
Heater 4"
In certain applications the chimney can be remote
Chimney 2"
from the heater and connected to the heater by a
heated bench.
15
The Heat-Kit Planning Guide
Layout Examples
Heated Benches
Layout for heated benches is quite flexible with the Heat-Kit system. Our special
bottom channel manifold can drive a bench on the opposite side of
the heater from the chimney, if required. Send us your floorplan.
The layout guidelines below will give you an idea of the footprint for various
heater and chimney options. You have a variety of stock as well as custom-built
options.
Consult us for your design requirements. As a general guide, bench top is 18”
above floor and 18” wide, including a 1 ½" overhang. Location of downdraft
channel cleanouts and ashbox need to be considered in laying out benches.
Figure 8. Layout for heater with standard 18 inch firebox, side chimney with
extra flue and heated bench
Figure 7. Standard 18 in. firebox with custom heat exchangers. Two flue chimney is
inside the heater facing for a more traditional fireplace look
16
Masonry Stove Builders
17
The Heat-Kit Planning Guide
18
Masonry Stove Builders
19
The Heat-Kit Planning Guide
Foundation plans
Figure 13 and Figure 14 show a typical concrete
block foundation for a heater and chimney. A
4 − 6” thick cantilevered slab provides an 18” non-
combustible hearth extension. The slab is reinforced
on 6” centers with 1/2” reinforcing rod.
For a 22” core, the cantilevered slab should be 52”
wide. For ease of construction, it is often easier to
leave the concrete block foundation at 48” to avoid
having to cut blocks.
A good way to form the slab bottom is to use “V -
pan”, a heavy gauge corrugated steel that is used in
commercial construction to form roof decks. This
avoids the problem of having to remove combustible
plywood forms. Another option is cement board.
When framing the floor cutout, provide for 2"
clearance between the foundation and combustible
framing. Figure 13. Footing, foundation and cantilevered
slab
Outside combustion air
A styrofoam plug leaves an 8” x 10” cutout for
ashes to drop down and for combustion air to come
up. Combustion air is supplied by a 6” diameter
thimble in the blocks just below the slab. Where
your local code requires it, this is hooked up to the
outside by means of a 6” insulated flex duct at
basement ceiling level.
We have conducted testing on masonry heater air
consumption rates, and shown that outside air is not
required, even in a tight house.. See referenceii
below for more details.
ii
Senf, N., Air Requirements and Related Parameters for
Masonry Heaters, for Research Division, Canada
Mortgage and Housing Corporation, Ottawa, 1994.
Figure 14. Typical foundation, plan view. Concrete block laid out
for minimal cuts. Hollow foundation is used to store ashes.
Cantilevered concrete slab provides noncombustible heart extension.
20
Masonry Stove Builders
I have a big house, what if I need more This works because you have a true radiant heating
system (large surface, low temperature). By heating
heat? surfaces directly, you are comfortable over a wider
First, determine whether efficiency upgrades to the range of air temperatures. You don’t need to control
house itself make sense. In new construction, it air temperature closely as you do with forced air
makes more sense to invest in better windows, a heat heating.
recovery ventilator, etc., rather than to build a very
large heater that will not only cost more but also Most people are used to forced air heat, so you may
consume more wood. need to experience this principle directly to convince
yourself that it works.
Secondly, integrate the heater into the house design
to maximize the radiant heating potential. This
Aren’t masonry heaters supposed to be
means putting it where your family will spend the
most time. 90% efficient?
Efficiency numbers often get bandied about with
A heater with a 22” firebox increases your peak great abandon by eager salesmen with meager math
output by about 20%. Adding a supplementary heat skills.
exchanger (see figure 7) adds an additional 10–20%.
One source of confusion is the different methods
Most heater owners fire their unit once per day. If used for measuring efficiency. The theoretical
you fire it twice per day, you will double your heat maximum efficiency obtainable from any
output. woodburning device using North American
measuring methods is 80%. That’s because some
What if the heater is too large for my energy is needed to boil off the water in the wood,
house? and some additional energy is needed to maintain
chimney draft. European methods ignore the water
This is not an issue with masonry heaters. If you loss, which is around 10% for a masonry heater
need less heat, you simply use a smaller fuel load. burning air dry cordwood.
You still burn it fast, for maximum benefit. You
make use of the main advantage of a masonry heater Combustion efficiency measures how much of the
for burning cordwood, namely the ability to store wood’s chemical energy is released during the burn,
heat. and is typically around 96 - 98% for most good
masonry heaters. The loss consists of unburned
A large heater does not mean thicker wall sections carbon monoxide and smoke that exits the chimney.
however, since the response time of the heater
becomes too sluggish and the surface temperature Heat transfer efficiency measures how good the
will be too low. appliance is at delivering the released energy to your
house instead of out the chimney.
21
The Heat-Kit Planning Guide
22
Masonry Stove Builders
Finding More
Information
If you have Internet access, you can find
additional information on our extensive
website. For example, you can visit:
• The Masonry Heater Association website, with links to other members’ websites and email links. On the MHA
Library Page, you will find numerous technical papers related to masonry heater performance.
Our website is www.heatkit.com, and the Masonry Heater Association website is t www.mha-net.org.
23
The Heat-Kit Planning Guide
Masonry core kits The biggest variable in the total cost is normally the
If you would like to build your own heater, we also mason's time, which can vary widely with the choice
supply the core components, including hardware. We of finish, and amount of detailing.
have step by step graphical assembly instructions for
each core variation. You can download a copy for a
specific configuration if you would like to evaluate Typical costs
the level of difficulty involved. Although we only
have a rudimentary assembly video at this time, we Enclosed is a pricelist for Heat-Kit cores. Prices are
will have a more complete one soon. included for some of the more popular options, such
as a wider firebox and a bakeoven. Options such as
heated benches are quoted on an individual basis
Services — consulting because of the large number of possible variations.
and design
We would be happy to assist you with planning a
masonry heating system into your new home design.
A truly successful design approach treats the heater
not only as a heating appliance, but as an integral
part of the “house as a system”.
Costs
A complete system consists of the following parts:
24