Chap 04
Chap 04
Chap 04
I. CHAPTER OVERVIEW
There is a common expression among people who think about economic issues: “It’s all a matter of supply and
demand.” This expression is, for the most part, exactly correct. Properly framed, the essence of most
economic questions can be approached using the basic market analysis you learned in Chapter 3; properly
interpreted, the answer to almost any question concerning resource allocation can be explained in terms of
supply-demand intuition.
In Chapter 3 you learned the laws of supply and demand, and you became familiar with the effects of
changes in supply and demand on market prices and quantities exchanged. For example, you found that when
demand increases in a market, prices rise and quantities exchanged increase.
This leads naturally to the related question: “By how much?” How large are the responses to changes in
the market, and upon what does this responsiveness depend? This chapter will provide you with the tools you
need to answer this question and with the opportunity to apply your tools in the arena of policy-making.
After you have read Chapter 4 in your text and completed the exercises in this Study Guide chapter, you should
be able to:
1. Define the term price elasticity of demand.
2. Discuss the factors that determine whether price elasticity of demand is elastic, unitary-elastic, or
inelastic, and compare consumer behavior in the short run and the long run. Describe elastic and inelastic
regions that exist along most demand curves.
3. Calculate price elasticity of demand using a method of averages and interpret your result.
4. Explain, using diagrams, the relationship between total revenue and price elasticity of demand.
5. Define the term price elasticity of supply.
6. Discuss the factors that determine whether price elasticity of supply is elastic, unitary-elastic, or
inelastic, and compare producer behavior in the short run and the long run.
7. Calculate price elasticity of supply using a method of averages, and interpret your result.
8. Apply supply, demand, and elasticity concepts to the following situations and markets: (a) agriculture
markets, (b) taxes, and (c) price ceilings and price floors.
Match the following terms from column A with their definitions in column B.
A B
__ Price elasticity 1. The ultimate economic impact or burden of a tax.
of demand
__ Price elasticity 2. Legal maximum price that sellers can charge for a good or service
of supply as defined by government.
__ Elastic demand 3. Demand or supply is infinitely responsive to changes in price.
__ Inelastic demand 4. The multiplicative product of price and quantity sold.
__ Unit-elastic 5. Measures the percentage change in quantity demanded of a good
demand when its price changes.
__ Perfectly elastic 6. Legal minimum price that sellers can receive for a good or service as defined by
government.
__ Perfectly 7. Percentage change in quantity demanded is less than percentage
inelastic change in price.
__ Total revenue 8. Demand or supply is not responsive at all to changes in price.
__ Tax incidence 9. Percentage change in quantity demanded is greater than percentage change in
price.
__ Price ceiling 10. Measures the percentage change in quantity supplied of a good when its price
changes.
62
__ Price floor 11. Means that total revenue will not change when the price of the good changes.
Notice that the numerator and the denominator both contain percentage changes rather than absolute changes in
quantities and prices. These percentage changes (and any percentage change, for that matter) are found by taking
an absolute change and dividing it by a reference point. For example, to find percentage change in quantity
demanded, find the difference between the initial and final quantities at two points on your demand curve.
Divide this difference by your reference point, which in our case will be the average quantity. This gives you
the percentage change in quantity demanded. Follow the same method for the percentage change in price;
divide the absolute difference in prices by the average price. Plug these values into the equation above to find a
coefficient for price elasticity of demand between two points on your demand curve.
Notice that the sign of this coefficient will always be negative. That is, as long as the demand curve is
downward-sloping, there will be an inverse relationship between price and quantity demanded. Therefore, when
you interpret this coefficient, just look at its absolute size, or absolute value. Ignore the negative sign and
simply ask yourself if the coefficient is greater than, less than, or equal to 1.
3. a. Demand is defined as elastic when the percentage change in quantity demanded is greater
than the percentage change in price. (ED > 1)
b. Demand is defined as inelastic when the percentage change in quantity demanded is less than
the percentage change in price. (ED < 1)
c. Demand is defined as unit elastic when the percentage change in quantity demanded is equal
to the percentage change in price. (ED = 1)
4. The demand for any good is more elastic when there are more substitutes available, when the item is
considered to be more a luxury than a necessity and when a longer time frame is considered. Demand for most
goods will be more elastic in the long run than in the short run, since a longer time frame allows consumers
to search more carefully for substitutes.
5. Demand curves that are flat tend to be relatively more elastic than demand curves that are steep. However,
all linear demand curves are elastic at the top, are unitary elastic at their midpoint, and are inelastic at the
bottom. Notice that when prices are high, the same percentage change means a greater absolute change in
price. For example, suppose the price of a good is $1.00. A 10 percent increase in price means the new price
is $1.10. Suppose the price of a good is $100. The same 10 percent increase in price means the new price is
$110! Consumers tend to be more responsive to a $10 change in price than to a $.10 change in price.
6. Price elasticity of supply describes how much quantity supplied increases when the price of a product rises.
Thus, it helps us to describe movement along a supply curve.
7. Price elasticity of supply between any two points on a supply curve can be calculated using the following
formula:
63
Price elasticity of supply takes the same general form as price elasticity of demand. Again, you are using
percentage changes in the numerator and denominator rather than absolute changes, and again, you are using
average quantity supplied and price for your reference points.
8. The supply of any good is more elastic when there is greater flexibility in the production process, allowing
increases in output without significant increases in the price of inputs, and when a longer time frame is
considered.
V. HELPFUL HINTS
l. Elasticities make an important contribution to the study of economics. As we have seen, they help to
define responsiveness to changes at the margin. You will find many interesting uses for the concept of
elasticity as you make your way through this course.
2. The elasticity of demand is not the slope of the demand curve. Remember that the slope of the demand
curve as we draw it always measures the absolute change in the price divided by the absolute change in the
quantity demanded between any two points on the curve. Elasticity, on the other hand, is the percentage
change in quantity demanded divided by the percentage change in price. There is a relationship between these
two concepts, but they are not the same thing.
3. The elasticity of demand is not constant as you move down a linear demand curve. Remember that the
same percentage changes result in smaller absolute changes as you move down the curve; consumers tend to be
less responsive to smaller changes in price than they are to larger changes.
4. Some of the most fun and challenging uses for economics are in the area of government policy. By
applying basic economic concepts, you can get a feel for the impact of policy in the areas of taxation and price
controls, among others. However, remember that policymakers often have normative economic goals that they
are trying to achieve. For example, using the positive economics generated in this chapter, you can see that
minimum wage policy raises wages and costs for firms and also restricts employment. This may seem
inefficient. However, wages do increase for some workers; as an antipoverty measure, it may achieve desired
results. The bottom line is that good policymakers have to consider both positive and normative economics.
5. Remember, the person who actually sends the tax money into the government (producer or consumer) may
not be the one actually bearing the burden of the tax. The burden is determined by the relative elasticities of
the supply and demand curves. For example, taxes on gasoline are most often collected by suppliers.
However, when a new tax is levied by government, prices on the gas pumps often rise, indicating that
consumers are bearing at least some of the burden of the new tax.
64
These questions are organized by topic from the chapter outline. Choose the best answer from the options
available.
Figure 4-1
c. FCHO.
d. AEB.
e. EBIF.
7. Between points B and C demand is:
a. relatively elastic.
b. relatively inelastic.
c. perfectly elastic.
d. perfectly inelastic.
e. unit-elastic.
8. If a l0 percent reduction in a commodity’s price brings a 5 percent increase in the amount of money people
spend to buy that commodity, then in this region of the demand curve, price elasticity of demand is:
a. elastic.
b. unit-elastic.
c. inelastic although not perfectly so.
d. perfectly inelastic.
e. perhaps any of these—the information given is insufficient to determine elasticity.
9. If a 10 percent reduction in price causes a 5 percent increase in the quantity of a commodity that people
buy, then in this region of the demand curve, price elasticity of demand is:
a. elastic.
b. unit-elastic.
c. inelastic, although not perfectly so.
d. perfectly inelastic.
e. perhaps any of these—the information given is insufficient to determine elasticity.
l0. Which of the following observations would indicate that demand for a good is price-inelastic?
a. The good in question is more of a necessity than a luxury for most people.
b. Good substitutes for this good do not exist.
c. The time period allowed for responding to a change in price is very small.
d. All or any of the above.
e. None of the above.
l1. Betty notices that no matter how many paper cups she buys, she always pays the same price per cup. This
means that the supply curve which confronts her is:
a. perfectly inelastic.
b. perfectly elastic.
c. unit-elastic.
d. elastic, but not necessarily perfectly elastic.
e. none of these things, necessarily
12. A perfectly inelastic supply curve would be shown in the ordinary supply-and-demand graph as a:
a. vertical line.
b. horizontal line.
c. straight line, but neither horizontal nor vertical.
d. curved line.
e. any of the above.
13. Which alternative in question 12 would be correct for the graphical portrayal of a perfectly inelastic demand
curve?
a. vertical line.
b. horizontal line.
c. straight line, but neither horizontal nor vertical.
d. curved line.
e. any of the above.
14. If a demand curve displays unitary price elasticity throughout its entire length, then the demand curve is:
a. a straight line, and total expenditure by buyers is the same at all prices.
b. not a straight line, and total expenditure by buyers falls as price falls.
c. a straight line, and total expenditure by buyers first increases and later decreases as price falls.
d. not a straight line, and total expenditure by buyers rises as price falls.
e. none of the above is correct.
Use the diagrams in Figure 4-2 to answer questions 15 and 16.
66
Figure 4-2
15. A patient must purchase some exact quantity of a particular drug (no more, no less) and will pay any price,
if necessary, in order to obtain it. Which of the five diagrams could be used to illustrate this situation?
a. (a)
b. (b)
c. (c)
d. (d)
e. (e)
16. Over the past century, consumers of food in the United States have not purchased much more to eat, in
spite of the fact that tremendous improvements in technology have led to lower real food prices. Which of
the five diagrams could be used to illustrate this situation
a. (a)
b. (b)
c. (c)
d. (d)
e. (e)
17. Assume that consumers buy 100 widgets at $10 and 200 widgets at $5. What is the elasticity of demand
in this price range?
a. elastic
b. inelastic
c. unitary
d. not enough information to answer this question
Figure 4-3
19. Which of the diagrams in Figure 4-3 reflects the effect of crop restrictions when they are placed on markets
for agriculture products?
a. (a)
b. (b)
c. (c)
67
d. (d)
20. The government levies an excise tax of 5 cents per unit sold on the sellers in a competitive industry. Both
supply and demand curves have some elasticity with respect to price. When this tax is represented on the
supply-and-demand diagram, the entire:
a. supply curve shifts upward by exactly 5 cents, but (unless demand is perfectly elastic) the market price
remains constant.
b. supply curve shifts upward by less than 5 cents, but (unless demand is highly elastic) the market price
rises by the full 5 cents.
c. supply curve shifts downward by less than 5 cents and the market price falls.
d. supply curve shifts upward by exactly 5 cents, but (unless supply is perfectly elastic) the market price
rises by less than 5 cents.
e. demand curve shifts upward by exactly 5 cents, but the market price rises by less than 5 cents.
21. Suppose that the demand curve for wheat is perfectly inelastic with respect to price. If a tax of 50 cents per
bushel sold were imposed on the market and collected by producers, then price would:
a. rise, but by less than 50 cents, and there would be some reduction in the quantity bought and sold.
b. rise by the full 50 cents, but there would be no reduction in the quantity bought and sold.
c. rise, but by less than 50 cents, and there would be no reduction in the quantity bought and sold.
d. rise by the full 50 cents, and there could definitely be a reduction in the quantity bought and sold.
e. fall, but by less than 50 cents, and there would be some reduction in the quantity bought and sold.
22. The change brought about by the tax levy described in the question above could be described as a decrease
in:
a. supply followed by an increase in quantity demanded.
b. quantity supplied followed by a decrease in quantity demanded.
c. supply followed by a decrease in demand.
d. quantity supplied followed by a decrease in demand.
e. none of the above.
23. Suppose the government imposes an additional tax of $1.00 per bottle of whiskey. In response to this tax,
the market price rises from $12.00 to $12.63 per bottle. From this information, you can say that:
a. the supply curve is relatively more inelastic than the demand curve.
b. the demand curve is relatively more inelastic than the supply curve.
c. price elasticity of demand and supply are equal.
d. the sellers bear the entire burden of the tax.
e. none of the above.
Figure 4-4
Use Figure 4-4, which describes a hypothetical market for carpenters, to answer questions 23 through 25.
24. Suppose the government passes a law stating that carpenters must be paid no less than $50 per hour. This
sort of price control would be called a(n):
a. price ceiling.
b. price floor.
c. wage subsidy.
d. tax.
e. equilibrium price.
68
25. Between the old equilibrium and the new minimum wage, price elasticity of demand is:
a. -.66.
b. -.73.
c. -1.37.
d. -1.50.
e. none of these.
26. Between the old equilibrium and the new minimum wage, price elasticity of supply is:
a. .43.
b. .66.
c. 1.00.
d. 2.33.
e. none of these.
27. Energy price controls are a type of:
a. tax.
b. price floor.
c. subsidy.
d. price ceiling.
28. Assume the demand for wheat is inelastic and that a blight destroys 1/4 of the wheat crop. What happens
to the total revenue of farmers as result of this blight.
a. increases.
b. decreases.
c. stays the same.
d. not enough information.
The following problems are designed to help you apply the concepts that you learned in the chapter.
TABLE 4-1
Price
Quantity Total Elasticity
Price Demanded Revenue of Demand
$8 0 ______________ _______________
7 2 ______________ _______________
6 4 ______________ _______________
5 6 ______________ _______________
4 8 ______________ _______________
3 l0 ______________ _______________
2 12 ______________ _______________
1 14 ______________ _______________
0 16 ______________ _______________
a. Use the numbers in Table 4-1 to draw a demand curve in Figure 4-5.
b. Calculate the total revenue received by Sam’s at each price in Table 4-1.
c. Plot the total revenue curve along with your demand curve.
d. Calculate the price elasticity of demand at the midpoint between the prices listed in Table 4-1. Use
your diagram and explain the relationship between price, elasticity of demand, and total revenue.
3. Use your answers to question 2 to complete the following:
69
a. Notice the interesting behavior of the total revenue curve as you move down the length of the straight-line
demand curve. As price falls, total revenue (remains the same at all quantities / falls throughout the entire
price range / rises first, reaches a peak, and then falls / falls first, reaches a minimum, and then climbs)
b. If the price falls from $7 to $6, total revenue (rises / stays the same / falls). How is this possible when
the lower price means that each unit that was purchased at $7 is now purchased at $6? For the 2 units
demanded at $7, lowering the price by $1 results in $2 less revenue being collected. The lower price means a
larger quantity is demanded. Is the revenue collected from the sale of these extra units enough to overcome the
initial loss just noted? Four units are demanded if the price is $6—an increase in the quantity
demanded—yielding an additional $___ in revenue. In this case, the increase in revenue generated by selling
more units (is / is not) enough to offset the initial loss.
c. Now suppose that the price falls from $4 to $3. Selling the units demanded at $4 for a dollar less results
in a revenue loss of $__. The associated increase in the quantity demanded of units brings a counterbalancing
revenue gain of $__. The loss (outweighs / exactly balances / falls short of) the gain, and total revenue (falls
/ stays the same / increases).
Figure 4-5
supply. The same sort of relationship between elasticity and time (can / cannot) be defined for the demand
side.
Figure 4-6
5. Suppose Figure 4-6 shows the supply curve in the market for sweatshirts at Anywhere State University.
a. The slope of this supply curve is ___.
b. The price elasticity of supply between points A and B is___; between B and C is___; and between C and D
is ___.
c. (advanced concept) The equation for this supply curve is: ____________________________________.
d. (advanced concept) The relationship between the slope of a supply curve and its elasticity at a given point
can be described as follows: _____________________________________________________________.
Figure 4-7
7. Price controls have been used by many governments in order to achieve policy objectives. Sometimes, as in
the case of price supports in the dairy industry, policymakers are trying to protect sellers’ incomes. Other times, as
in the case of rent control, policymakers are trying to protect buyers from high prices.
Consider Figure 4-8. The equilibrium price of X is $___ and the equilibrium quantity is ___ units. Suppose the
government is considering a number of policy options designed to restrict consumption to 500 units. First, it
could impose a price (ceiling / floor) of $___; the quantity demanded would then be ___ units, but the quantity
supplied would be ___ units. A (shortage / surplus) of ___ units would result in the short run. Second, the
government could set a production quota at 500 units; suppliers would receive a price of $___ for every unit that
they sold. Finally, the government could issue ration tickets and announce that one ticket and no more than $5
would be required to purchase 1 unit of X. If the tickets could be bought and sold, they would command a price of
$____. Carefully explain why this is true.
Figure 4-8
72
Answer the following questions, making sure that you can explain the work you did to arrive at the answers.
l. Are the following statements true or false?
a. If demand is price-elastic, then a 10 percent increase in price is associated with a reduction in the
quantity demanded of more than 10 percent. This means that quantity is falling faster than price is rising,
and total revenue will fall. (T/F)
b. If demand displays unitary price elasticity, then a 10 percent increase in price is matched by a 10
percent increase in quantity demanded. This means that total revenue will remain unchanged. (T/F)
c. If demand is price-inelastic, then a 10 percent increase in price is associated with a reduction in the
quantity demanded of less than 10 percent. This means that total revenue will actually rise with the price.
(T/F)
2. Put (E) for price-elastic, (U) for unitary-elastic, or (I) for price-inelastic in the blanks below according to
which term most accurately describes each demand situation:
___ a. Price falls from $6 to $5 and revenue falls from $60 to $55.
___ b. Price falls from $6 to $5 and revenue stays the same.
___ c. Price climbs from $5 to $6 and quantity purchased falls from 80 to 60.
___ d. Price drops from $6 to $5 and there is no increase in quantity demanded.
___ e. Price climbs from $300 to $301 and there is no reduction in quantity demanded.
___ f. Price climbs and revenue climbs by $10.
___ g. Price climbs from $5.00 to $5.01 and people stop buying the stuff completely.
3. Although we have discussed the extreme case of a good that has a perfectly inelastic demand in all price
ranges, there are very few goods that can be categorized in this way. Why is this? Explain.
4. Carefully explain why all linear demand curves have elastic, unit-elastic, and inelastic regions. Given this,
and the relationship between elasticity and total revenues, which of the following two firms is more likely to
increase the price of its product: (a) a producer of canned soup, whose price elasticity of demand is currently .5;
or (b) a producer of fur coats, whose price elasticity of demand is currently -3.8?
5. An example in your textbook discusses the relationship between price elasticity of demand and airline
pricing policies. Low-elasticity business travelers are charged higher prices than are higher-elasticity vacation
travelers. Explain the form that this sort of pricing policy might take. Can you think of another market in
which price differentials exist for consumers with different price elasticities of demand?
6. (a) Use a diagram to show the impact of a price ceiling in the market for butter. Why might government
policymakers adopt such a plan? Can you think of any time during this century when this policy might
have been appropriate?
(b) Now use a diagram to show the impact of a price floor in the market for butter. Why might
government policymakers adopt such a plan? Can you think of any time during this century when this
policy might have been appropriate?
7. During the summer of 1993, severe flooding in the midwestern United States destroyed corn, wheat, and
soybean crops. During the summer of 1994, severe flooding in the southeast destroyed a large portion of the
peanut and cotton crops. Use supply-and-demand diagrams to show the effects of this flooding if demand is
relatively inelastic in the markets for these agriculture products. Now, show the effects of this flooding if the
demand for these agriculture products is relatively elastic. Explain the difference, and make predictions
concerning farm incomes in light of these disasters.
2 Price ceiling
6 Price floor
TABLE 4-1
Quantity Total Elasticity
Price Demanded Revenue of Demand
$8 0 $0 xxx
7 2 14 15.00
6 4 24 4.33
5 6 30 2.20
4 8 32 1.29
3 10 30 .77
2 12 24 .45
1 14 14 .23
0 16 0 .07
Figure 4-9
l. a. T
b. F
c. T
2. a. I
b. U
75
c. E
d. I
e. I
f. I
g. E
3. For most goods and most consumers, price eventually reaches a level beyond which further consumption is
impossible.
4. At higher prices, the same percentage change in price is a larger absolute change; thus consumers are more
responsive to it. The producer of canned soup is more likely to raise the price. Because demand is inelastic, a
price increase will lead to higher total revenues.
5. Vacation travelers must stay over a Saturday night in order to guarantee lower fares. In movie theaters,
adults pay more for tickets than children do.
6. a.
A price ceiling in the market for butter might be appropriate if the government is trying to protect
buyers from high prices. This might have happened during World War II, when much of the economy’s
productive capacity was directed toward military equipment and away from consumer products.
b.
A price floor in the market for butter might be appropriate if the government is trying to protect sellers
from low prices. This might be used currently, as new technology in the dairy industry threatens to bring
prices and farm income down further.
76
7. In either case, a significant decrease in supply will raise prices and reduce the quantities of the goods
exchanged. If demand is elastic, the price change will be relatively small while the quantity change is relatively
large. If demand is inelastic, the price change will be relatively large while the quantity change is relatively
small. For those farmers unaffected by the floods, incomes will rise as long as demand is inelastic.