Copolymer SJ-1 As A Fluid Loss Additive For Drilling Fluid With High Content of Salt and Calcium
Copolymer SJ-1 As A Fluid Loss Additive For Drilling Fluid With High Content of Salt and Calcium
Copolymer SJ-1 As A Fluid Loss Additive For Drilling Fluid With High Content of Salt and Calcium
Hongping Quan,1,2 Huan Li,1,2 Zhiyu Huang,1,2 Tailiang Zhang 1,2 Shanshan Dai *,1,2
1
School of Chemistry and Chemical Engineering, Southwest Petroleum University,
Chengdu, P. R. China
2
Engineering Research Center of Oilfield Chemistry, Department of Education,
Chengdu, P. R. China
1
Copolymer SJ-1 as a Fluid Loss Additive for Drilling Fluid with high
(AMPS), acrylamide (AM) and allyl alcohol polyoxyethylene ether (APEG) with a
side chain polyoxyethylene ether (C2H4O)n SJ-1 were designed and synthesized in
this work. Good temperature resistance and salt tolerance of “-SO3-”of AMPS,
(GPC). The API fluid loss of drilling fluid decreased gradually with the increasing
concentration of NaCl and CaCl2 in the mud system. SJ-1 was applied well in the
modified drilling fluid showed the dispersion stability of drilling fluid system.
surface of the filter cake obtained from the drilling fluid modified by SJ-1.
Keywords: drilling fluid; fluid loss addictive; filter cake; temperature resistance;
salt tolerance
1. INTRODUCTION
Water-based drilling muds including bentonite were well known and widely used
[1-4]
in the petroleum industry recently . The main component of water-based drilling
fluid are water, salt, insert solids and clays such as montmorillonite. One of the
important functions of water-based drilling fluid was to form filter cake on the wall of
2
the well bore, prevent water leakage and maintain the stability of the well wall [5]. The
properties of the water-based drilling fluid, such as the rheology and filtration loss,
are effected by the fluid loss additive. Polymers, which are non-toxic, degradable and
[6-8]
environment friendly , are the best choice to be used as drilling fluids additives.
However, the traditional polymers as fluid loss additive are not stable at the work
condition of drilling fluid, especially at high salt condition and high temperatures. The
resulting drilling fluids often presents poor properties such as high filtration. If the
drilling fluid was applied in the high salt or calcium environment, the flocculated
structure of clay particles will appear and the value of API fluid loss will increase
severe case. To solve the problems mentioned above, a novel fluid loss additive SJ-1
To make sure the fluid loss additive has an excellent ability of absorption, the
monomer with strong absorption groups, such as amino-group, are introduced [13-14].
To make sure the additive has an excellent ability of salt tolerance, the monomer with
stable group which is not sensitive to the cation, such as -SO3-, are introduced [15-17].
To make the fluid loss additive has an excellent ability of temperature resistance, the
monomer with inflexibility groups such as big side group, are introduced. At the
same time, the monomer that are hard to hydrolyze are introduced to get rid of the
side effect hydrolysis, such as polyoxyethylene ether (C2H4O)n [18]. In this work, a
good property of filtrate loss control even at high temperatures and salt condition of
3
2. EXPERIMENTAL
2.1 Materials
APEG-1000 were industrial grade from Jiangsu Haian petrochemical factory (China).
Potassium persulfate, sodium hydroxide, sodium bisulfite, were analytical grade from
2.2 Synthesis
APEG (0.006 mol) was added in a three-necked flask, using moderate amount of
water to dissolve in a heated water bath. And then added AMPS (0.029 mol) and AM
(0.084 mol) to the mixed solution. The pH was adjusted to 7-8 with NaOH; Adding
0.2 wt% potassium persulfate and sodium bisulfite, stirred and mixed uniformly
reacted at 60oC. After completion of the reaction, the product was extracted with
ethanol, shear granulation, vacuum drying and grinding to obtain a white powdery
polymer fluid loss additive. Chemical structure of SJ-1 was shown in the Scheme 1.
14:5:1; the reaction temperature was 60oC; the concentration of monomer initiator
2.3 Characterization
The pellet samples were prepared by pressing the mixture of the SJ-1 and KBr,
4
and then measured with FTIR (WQF-520, China) spectrophotometer at range between
The molecular weight distribution of SJ-1 was measured by GPC (Waters e2695,
USA). The polymer was dissolved into distilled water forming the solution with
Freshwater base mud containing 4 wt% of sodium bentonite and 0.2 wt% of
Na2CO3 was prepared by mixing the raw bentonite, Na2CO3 and freshwater at a
certain ratio, stirring for 20 min at a high speed of 10000 rpm and aging for 24 h at
concentration of NaCl into the above freshwater base mud, and then submitted to a
different concentration of CaC12 into the above freshwater base mud, and then
adding different concentration of SJ-1 into the freshwater base mud, Salt-water base
mud and Calcium-water base mud respectively, and then submitted to a pre-hydration
period of 24 h.
5
(API) specifications and Chinese SY/T5621-93. The API filtrate volume (FLAPI) of
the mud was determined with a medium-pressure filtration apparatus (ZNS-2 type
China).
Apparent viscosity (AV), plastic viscosity (PV), yield point (YP) were measured
The filter cake of sample was tested by SEM (JSM-7500F, Japan) analysis and
the filtrate of sample was tested by Zeta electric potential (Zeta PALS/90plus,
The chemical structure of SJ-1 was analyzed by FTIR after purified, the results
vibration of N-H. The absorption peak observed at 2933.20 cm-1 and 2863.77 cm-1
were due to the stretching vibration of –CH3 and –CH2 respectively. The absorption
peak of 1673.91 cm-1 was attributed to the stretching peak of C=O. The absorption
peak of 1544.70 cm-1 was due to the stretching vibration of C-N, while 1201.43 cm-1
was attributed to C-O-C. Moreover, absorption peaks of 1112.72 cm-1 and 1041.37
cm-1 were according to the bending vibration of -SO3-. Results mentioned above were
6
consistent with the chemical structure of SJ-1 shown in scheme 1.
The molecular weight and its distribution of SJ-1 was synthesized under the best
optimum synthesis condition mentioned in 2.2. The result showed that the weight
average molecular weight was 8.1×105, and the number average molecular was 6.2×
105. Thus, the molecular weight distribution coefficient is 1.29. These all meet the
Different concentration of SJ-1 was added to the freshwater base mud. The
rheological and API fluid loss properties have been measured by rotational viscometer
Table 1.
According to Table 1, with the increase of loading of SJ-1, the API fluid loss of
drilling fluid decreased obviously. When the concentration of SJ-1 was or ever than
1.2 wt%, the values of fluid loss became stable. At the same time, the rheological
ability. If the rheological property of drilling fluid was bad, thinner might be required
for the drilling fluid, so the optimum concentration of fluid loss addictive SJ-1 in the
7
3.3 Evaluation of temperature resistance
1.2 wt% SJ-1 was added to the freshwater base mud, then, rolling 16h by
and API fluid loss have been measured by rotational viscometer and medium-pressure
The value of API fluid loss of drilling fluid raised with the increase of
temperature, when the concentration of SJ-1 was equal to 1.2 wt%. The API fluid loss
of drilling fluid was still below 13 mL even at 220oC showing its property of
temperature resistant. Three reasons account for this phenomenon: firstly, the main
temperatures. Secondly, the -SO3- of the AMPS has a strong temperature resistance
performance, introducing the -SO3- into the polymer molecule can significantly
polyoxyethylene group, which can improve the hydrophilic property and the
With the increase of temperature, the rheological property of drilling fluid which
reflected on apparent viscosity, plastic viscosity and yield value decreased. Some of
the SJ-1 was degraded at high temperature, which can lead to breaking up the network
structure to a certain extent. But these negative influence held within limits and
control. The little change on the performance of the drilling fluid was less affected.
8
3.4 Evaluation of salt tolerance
1.2 wt% SJ-1 and different concentration of NaCl were added to the freshwater
base mud, then, aged 16 h at 120oC. The rheological and API fluid loss have been
Table 3 illustrated that the API fluid loss of drilling fluid decreased gradually by
the growing concentration of NaCl in the mud system. When the salt concentration
was 30 wt%, the fluid loss achieved the lowest, namely 7.5mL, which indicated the
Five reasons account for this phenomenon: Firstly, when the NaCl was added to
the freshwater base mud, the value of the Zeta electric potential of the clay particles
would decrease and the hydration shell would be reduced, which would lead to
generate the flocculated structure in the freshwater base mud. So, the API filter loss
increases. Secondly, when the NaCl was added to the freshwater base mud, the
adsorption of the fluid loss additive on the surface of the clay particles would increase,
which would lead to the Zeta electric potential of the clay particles increase and the
hydration shell thicken. So, the API filter loss would decrease. When the
concentration of the NaCl was 2 wt%, the effect of the NaCl on the clay particles
played a leading role, and the API filter loss was increase. Meanwhile, with the
increase of the concentration of the NaCl, the effect of the NaCl on the fluid loss
9
additive was increased and the API filter loss was decrease. When the concentration
of the NaCl was 25 wt%, the effect of the NaCl on the fluid loss additive played a
leading role, so the API filter loss was lower than that without the NaCl. Thirdly, the
SJ-1 with good temperature resistant remains at a comparatively high level. And it is
benefit for adsorbing clay particles and free water to form aggregate, which form a
thin and dense mud cake on the wall. The appearance of mud cake effectively
reducing the filtrate loss. Lastly, because of the adding of fluid loss additive SJ-1, the
hydrophilic radical of this treating chemical mainly include sulfonic acid and
solubility in a saline environment. It can bring enough hydrated film to clay and
1.2 wt% SJ-1 and different concentration of CaCl2 were added to the freshwater
base mud, then, aged 16 h at 120oC. The rheological and filtration properties have
Table 4 illustrated that the fluid loss of drilling fluid decreased gradually by the
growing number of CaCl2 in the mud system. When the CaCl2 was 8%, the fluid loss
comparatively lower 12.6 ml; however, the API fluid loss remain unchanged by the
raising of CaCl2. When the CaCl2 was 10%, the API fluid loss was 12.0ml.
Two reasons account for this phenomenon: Firstly, the -SO3- of the SJ-1
10
molecular chain has strong hydration capacity, and the hydration of the clay particles
can be thickened. Meanwhile, the -SO3- and the calcium do not occur the precipitation
reaction in the drilling fluid containing calcium ions. So the SJ-1 can form a thick
hydration shell on surface of clay, which can ensure the SJ-1 has good fluid loss
the-SO3-, the SJ-1 can resist a temperature of 120oC in which polymer rarely degrade
or degrade in a small quantity, the original nature of many polymer molecules can be
maintained, and they can adsorb clay particles and free water, forming an aggregate
that acts as a thin and dense mud cake on the borehole wall, which effectively reduces
1.2 wt% SJ-1 was added to the freshwater base mud at 120oC. The Zeta electric
potential and API filter loss have been measured by Zeta potential analyzer and
following Fig. 2.
Fig. 2 shows that in different temperatures, both drilling fluid system and Zeta
electric potential have a big change. The absolute value of the Zeta electric potential
of the mud system gradually decreased with the increase of aging temperature, and the
means that with the increase of aging temperatures, the character of mud system
changes a lot, in which the absorption capacity of polymers on the surface of clay
11
particles is reducing, leading to the increase of filter loss of mud. However, because
the SJ-1 contains many -SO3- and side chain polyoxyethylene ether (C2H4O)n, which
exhibits unique and hydration and dispersion capacities at high temperature, the
negative influence held within limits. The Zeta electric potential test shows that this
1.2 wt% SJ-1 and different concentration of NaCl were added to the freshwater
base mud at 25oC. The Zeta electric potential and API filter loss have been measured
Fig. 3 shows that with an increase of NaC1, filter loss is decreasing, along with
the absolute value of Zeta electric potential rising up, which is compatible with the
data of Zeta electric potential test. With the increase of electrolyte, the coalescence of
electrolyte is gradually gentle, and the aggregation of clay particles in drilling fluid is
impeded, resulting in the increase of the small particles in the mud with the expansion
of the degree of mineralization. At the same time, SJ-1 particles is adsorbed on the
surface of clay particles; sulfonic acid group can chemically react to Na+ and Ca2+ in
salt; the steric of polyoxyethylene side chain in particles is large. Thus, it is more
difficult to aggregate clay particles, and the compression of salt on the electric double
layer is reduced, with the improvement of the resistance of fluid loss additive to salt.
In addition, with the increase of polymer, both apparent and plastic viscosities are
12
3.6 SEM analysis of filter cake
In order to explore the microstrcuture of the filter cake formation and the
filtration mechanism research, the formation of the filter cake was observed by type
JSM7500F SEM.
Fresh water base mud and polymers of 1.2 wt% density are added into drilling
fluid to test the API filter loss in normal temperature. After drying, the appearance of
Fig. 4 (a) shows that the surface of the base mud is uneven and friable, with
some ravines and small poles. Some big particles can be seen, so the mud is bad in
dispersion and the cake formed is of a poor quality, causing a terrible dehydration.
Fig. 4 (b) shows that after an aging process, the cakes are uniform and dense on
their surfaces, with no big pores and coarse particles. Polymers adsorb into clay
particles, forming a reticulated polymer, which effectively blocks the pore of borehole
wall and prevents the filtrate in the drilling fluid leaking to formation. Thus, the
drilling fluid is presented to be in good character, and the filtrate loss is less than base
mud. Then, hydration swelling and dispersion of shale is decreasing, which can better
Fresh water base mud polymers of 1.2% density are added into fresh water base
mud, which is then stirred up speedily for 10 minutes. Next, NaC1 is mixed into it and
then stirred up for 10 minutes. API filtrate loss is tested and the Fig. 5 shows the SEM
Fig. 5 (a) shows that the filter cakes, with NaCl of 30% density added into the
13
mud system mixed with the fluid loss additive, are dense on their surfaces, and
distributed regularly in tight connection, narrowing the pores for less filtration loss. It
means that filtration loss of drilling fluid can be effectively reduced by adding a large
quantity of NaCl into drilling fluid system. The polyoxyethylene side chain in the
fluid loss additive raise the resistance of polymers to salt, and its plastic-protection
function impede the coalescence of NaCl to clay particles, contributing to the regular
distribution of clay particles in the drilling fluid system. Thus, the cake formed is
dense.
Fig. 5 (b) shows that the cakes, with NaCl of 30% density added into the mud
system mixed with the fluid loss additive aging 30 min at 120oC, are dense and
smooth on their surfaces, and distributed regularly in tight connection, narrowing the
4. CONCLUSIONS
With FTIR analysis, the composition of the synthetic polymer SJ-1 was
consistent to the designed structure. The weight average molecular weight of SJ-1 was
8.1×105, and its number average molecular was 6.2×105. The molecular weight
distribution coefficient was 1.29. The character evaluation proves that the best amount
of SJ-1 in the mud is 1.2%, and the API filtrate loss is 9.2 mL. Salt-resistance of SJ-1
is effective and keep its effectiveness in the drilling fluid system in which the aging
temperature is 220oC, the mass density of NaCl is 30 wt%, and CaCl2 10 wt%. The
Zeta electric potential test on clay particles proves that with an increase of SJ-1, the
14
API filtrate loss in drilling fluid is decreasing and the absolute value of Zeta electric
drilling fluid. In addition, the SEM analysis proves that cakes with SJ-1 added in is
even and dense on their surfaces with no big pores or coarse particles, and the filtrate
loss is less than base mud. Besides, those cakes can effectively resist to the pollution
of electrolytes. And in the mud system with NaCl of 30% density, the cakes formed
are distributed regularly in tight connection, narrowing the filtrate loss pores and
ACKNOWLEDGE
REFERENCE
15
4. M. V. Kok. "A Rheological Characterization and Parametric Analysis of a
Bentonite Sample," Energy Sources, Part A: Recovery, Utilization, and
Environmental Effects, vol. 33, no. 4, pp. 344-348, 2011.
5. Y. Zhuang, Z. Zhu, H. Chao, and B. “Yang. Effect of added salt on properties of
aqueous SMP solution,” Journal of Applied Polymer Science, vol. 55, no. 7, pp.
1063–1067, 1995.
6. M. V. Kok, "Thermal Characterization of Sepiolite Samples," Energy Sources, Part
A: Recovery, Utilization, and Environmental Effects, vol. 35, no. 2, pp. 173-83,
2013.
7. M. V. Kok, "Statistical Approach of Two-Three Parameters Rheological Models
for Polymer Type Drilling Fluid Analysis," Energy Sources, Part A: Recovery,
Utilization, and Environmental Effects, vol.32, no. 4, pp.336-45, 2009.
8. M. V. Kok, "Thermal Analysis and Rheological Study of," Energy Sources, Part A:
Recovery, Utilization, and Environmental Effects, vol.35, no. 2, pp. 122-33, 2013.
9. T. Wan, Y. Jie, Z. Sun, L. Wang, and Wang Juan. "Solution and Drilling Fluid
Properties of Water Soluble AM–AA–SSS Copolymers by Inverse
Microemulsion," Journal of Petroleum Science and Engineering, vol. 78, no. 2, pp.
334-337, 2011.
10. C. Collette, F. Lafuma, R. Audebert, and R. Brouard. "Macromolecular systems in
heat-resistant drilling fluids; advantages of gels on linear polymers." Journal of
Applied Polymer Science, vol. 53, no. 6, pp. 755–762, 1994.
11. C. V. Kelessidis, C. Papanicolaou, and A. Foscolos. "Application of Greek Lignite
as an Additive for Controlling Rheological and Filtration Properties of
Water–Bentonite Suspensions at High Temperatures: A Review," International
Journal of Coal Geology , vol.77, no. 3-4, pp. 394-400, 2009.
12. R. Caenn, and G. V. Chillingar. "Drilling Fluids: State of the Art," Journal of
Petroleum Science and Engineering, vol. 14, no. 3, pp. 221-30, 1996.
13. J. Plank, N. R. Lummer, and F. Dugonjic´-Bilic.́ "Competitive Adsorption
Between an AMPS-Based FluidLoss Polymer and Welan Gum Biopolymer in Oil
16
Well Cement," Journal of Applied Polymer Science, vol. 116, no. 1, pp. 2913-2919,
2010.
14. J. Y. Ma, H. L. Zheng, M. Z. Tan, L. W. Liu, W. Chen, Q. Q. Guan, and K. Xiao.
"Synthesis, characterization, and flocculation performance of anionic
polyacrylamide P (AM-AA-AMPS)," Journal of Applied Polymer Science, vol.
129, no. 4, pp. 1984–1991, 2013.
15 C. Tiemeyer and J. Plank. " Synthesis, characterization, and working mechanism
of a synthetic high temperature (200°C) fluid loss polymer for oil well cementing
containing allyloxy-2-hydroxy propane sulfonic (AHPS) acid monomer," Journal
of Applied Polymer Science, vol. 128, no. 1, pp. 851–860, 2013
16. Y. Liu, W. P. Gates, A. Bouazza, and R. K. Rowe. "Fluid loss as a quick method
to evaluate hydraulic conductivity of geosynthetic clay liners under acidic
conditions," Canadian Geotechnical Journal, vol.51, no.2, pp. 158-163, 2014.
17. Q. Xiao, W. F. Xiao, and X. X. Liu. "A Novel Cement Fluid Loss Additive
P1402," Advanced Materials Research, vol.941-944, pp. 1203-1207, 2014.
18. S. Akimoto, S. Honda, T. Yasukohchi. "Polyoxyalkylene Alkenyl Ether-Maleic
Ester Copolymer and Use Thereof," U.S.5142036, 1989.
19. J. Plank. "Water-Based Muds Using Synthetic-Polymers Developed For
High-Temperature Drilling," Oil & Gas Journal, vol. 90, no. 9, pp. 40-45, 1992.
17
Indication of figures and tables
Table 2. Fluid loss of drilling fluid changed with aging temperature and polymer
concentration.
Fig. 2. The impact of Zeta Electric Potential and API filter loss on mud system in
different temperatures.
Fig. 3. The impact of Zeta Electric Potential and API filter loss on mud system in
different salt contents.
Fig. 4. SEM photos of (a) API filter cake formed by base mud. (b) API filter cake
modified with SJ-1 (both of aging temperature 120oC).
Fig. 5. SEM photos of (a) API filter cake formed by base mud + SJ-1 + 30 wt% NaCl.
(b) API filter cake formed by base mud + SJ-1 + 30 wt% NaCl after the aging process
of 30 min.
18
Table 1. Relationship between SJ-1 concentration and fluid loss.
SJ-1
AV PV YP API filter loss
concentration
/mPa·s /mPa·s /Pa /mL
/wt%
0.0 12.5 7.0 5.62 23.0
0.1 16.0 10.0 6.13 11.8
0.3 19.5 13.0 6.64 11.2
0.6 23.5 16.0 7.67 10.4
0.9 30.0 21.0 9.20 9.4
1.2 37.0 26.0 11.24 9.2
1.5 44.0 31.0 13.29 9.2
1.8 52.5 36.0 16.86 9.1
19
Table 3. Performance evaluation of salt resistance of drilling fluid at high
temperature.
NaCl
Experimental AV/mPa· API filter loss
concentration PV/mPa·s YP/Pa
conditions s /mL
/wt%
0.0 32.0 27.5 4.60 10.6
2.0 20.0 17.5 2.56 16.0
5.0 17.5 15.0 2.56 13.0
Aging
temperature 10.0 18.0 16.0 2.04 12.6
120oC, aging 15.0 17.0 15.0 2.04 12.6
time 16h
20.0 17.0 15.0 2.04 12.6
25.0 17.5 15.0 2.56 10.4
30.0 19.5 18.0 1.53 7.5
temperature.
CaCl2
Experimental AV PV YP API filter loss
concentration
conditions /mPa·s /mPa·s /Pa /mL
/wt%
0.0 32.0 27.5 4.60 10.6
2.0 9.5 9.0 0.51 26.0
Aging
temperature 4.0 10.0 9.0 1.02 19.0
120oC, aging 6.0 9.0 8.0 1.02 17.0
time 16h
8.0 8.5 8.0 0.51 12.6
10.0 8.5 8.0 0.51 12.0
20
Scheme 1. Chemical structure of SJ-1.
21
Fig. 2. The impact of Zeta Electric Potential and API filter loss on mud system in
different temperatures.
Fig. 3. The impact of Zeta Electric Potential and API filter loss on mud system in
different salt contents.
22
(a) (b)
Fig. 4. SEM photos of (a) API filter cake formed by base mud. (b) API filter cake
modified with SJ-1 (both at the aging temperature 120oC).
(a) (b)
Fig. 5. SEM photos of (a) API filter cake formed by base mud + SJ-1 + 30 wt% NaCl.
(b) API filter cake formed by base mud + SJ-1 + 30 wt% NaCl after the aging process
of 30 min.
23