Bey Ron 1954
Bey Ron 1954
Bey Ron 1954
648
B E Y R O N . . . V O L U M E 48, J U N E 1954 • 64?
ble to form a fairly good concept of what tion, within certain limits, multiplies and
constitutes optimal occlusion. It is im strengthens the trabeculae. Reduced func
portant to have a clear picture of optimal tion has the opposite effect. Both exces
occlusion as a basis of evaluation or as a sive and insufficient functional usage have
goal for treatment. As a result of hazy unfavorable effects. There is thus a func
concepts of optimal occlusion, many den tional optimum. Accordingly, a tooth
titions are allowed to remain unimproved should be subjected to a certain occlusal
under the very eyes of the dentist; and load and should not be permanently
those restorations that are provided lead without one; that is, it should always
all too frequently to dysfunction and con have an antagonist.
sequent breakdown of the dentition. The reaction of the periodontal mem
The establishment of optimal occlusion brane is of particular interest. T h e tooth
is a problem of concern to many widely is suspended in collagenous fibers. Gott
different branches o f odontology. The lieb and Orban5 and others have shown
purpose of this article is to set forth some that under longitudinal axial stress prac
of the requirements and characteristics tically all the fibers resist the load and
of the form (pattern) of optimal occlu produce traction on the bone, which
sion, especially with regard to stress on stimulates bone apposition. The alveolar
the supporting tissues. These require bone and the fibers jointly sustain the
ments will form the basis of the principles load. W hen lateral stress is acting, the
of rehabilitation. force is taken up regionally. As a result
Certain of these characteristics and only some fibers produce traction, regions
principles are already recognized and re of pressure are formed, and bone resorp
quire only a brief review; others require tion results. The supporting tissues thus
clarification. resist axial stress much better than lateral
stress.
S T R E S S O N T H E IN D IV ID U A L According to Box6 and Breitner7 it is
TOOTH
not the magnitude but the direction of
the force that is decisive. In normal mas
The investigations on the reaction of the tication a force in the axial direction can
supporting tissues to the load on a single hardly be too great; it is necessary that
tooth are of primary importance. Present it should exceed a certain minimum in
knowledge is based on general studies of order to maintain the supporting tissues
the structure of the supporting tissues. A in a healthy condition. T h e unfavorable
stress to which a tooth is subjected acts effect of lateral stress is governed, in ad
as a stimulus to this structure. It may be dition, by the frequency of application of
regarded as a force radiating from the the force and the period over which it
tooth via the cementum, the periodontal acts.
membrane and the cortical plate to the For the pattern of the occlusal surface,
supporting bone. T h e subordinate struc
tures adapt themselves to the force.
In the bone, which is architecturally a 2. Benninghoff, A . D ie A r c h ite k tu r d e r K iefer und
ih re r W e ic h te ilb e d e c k u n g , P a ra d e n tiu m 3:50, 1934.
trabecular tissue, the trabeculae are 3. S e ip e l, C . M . T ra je c to rie s of th e |aws. A c ta
adapted in number and direction to the o d o n t. S c a n d in a v . 8:81 J une 1948.
4. W e in m a n n , J . P., a n d S icher, H a r r y . Bone and
functional requirements. Benninghoff,2 bones. S t. Louis, C . V . M o s b y C o ., 1947.
Seipel,3 and W einm ann and Sicher4 have 5. S o t t lie b , Bernhard , a n d O r b a n , B a lin t. D ie V e rä n
d e ru n g en d e r G e w e b e b e i ü b e rm ä s s ig e r Beänsspruchung
demonstrated that a change in the func d e r Z ä h n e . L e ip z ig , G e o r g T h îe m e , 1931.
6. Box, H . K. Tw elve p e rio d o n ta l s tudies. T o ro n to ,
tion, an increase in the load or a change U n iv ers ity o f T o ro n to Press, 1940.
in the direction of the force leads to 7. B reitner, C a r l. A lte r a t io n o f o c clu s al re la tio n s
in d u c ed b y e x p e rim e n ta l p ro c e d u re . A m , J , O r th o d o n t.
changes in the structure. Increased func & O r a l S u rg . 29:277 M a y 1943,
650 • T H E J O U R N A L O F T H E A M E R IC A N D E N T A L A S S O C IA T IO N
the direction of the force is the essential three tooth groups comprising the cuspids
factor. Purely axial and purely lateral and incisors in the anterior segment and
stresses occur but seldom. The variations the cuspids, bicuspids and molars in each
in the inclination of the axis and the lateral segment. Functionally, the cuspid
shape of the crown give rise to complex should be included in both the anterior
stresses. Generally, the more the force and the lateral segments. A n interproxi
deviates from the direction of the long mal contact therefore is essential. The
axis, the less satisfactorily do the sup lateral forces which act on the teeth in
porting tissues resist that force. radial and transverse directions are not
Th e architecture of the bone and the distributed in this manner and are there
condition of the supporting tissues in fore more unfavorable.
general are determined not only by func The distribution of the total load in
tion but by systemic factors, such as me such a manner that many teeth make
tabolism, nutrition, vitamin level and simultaneous occlusal contact has long
hormonal balance. T h e state of the sup been considered beneficial for the indi
porting tissues is further influenced by vidual tooth and its supporting tissues.
local irritational factors. As a conse Distribution of occlusal stress is, generally
quence, the condition of the supporting speaking, a desirable characteristic.
tissues is determined by the combined It is logical that in centric position the
effect of all these factors. The occlusal total load should be distributed over all
load, in the form for instance of a lateral parts of the dental arch and thus over all
force, may therefore not in itself be said the teeth. The load is potentially the
to be “ detrimental” or “ traumatic.” The greatest in centric position.
terms “ favorable” and “ unfavorable” are In eccentric positions the load should
more appropriate. Optimal occlusion be distributed primarily over all the teeth
from the point of view of stress may be in the engaged segment, since in function
expressed as occlusion that is best calcu only one group of teeth comes into use at
lated to obviate periodontal destruction. a time. In a dentition with no large gaps,
For functionally optimal occlusion, the a force applied in incision is exerted only
teeth should receive stress consistent with on the anterior teeth and is not trans
physiologic requirements for stimulation ferred to the lateral segments.8’ 9 There
of the supporting tissues; and, in par seems to be no reduction in the load on
ticular, the direction of stress should the anterior segment through simultane
coincide as closely as possible with the ous use of bicuspids and molars. In mas
long axis of the tooth. This principle is tication the force is applied mainly on
the principle of axial stress. the side where the bolus is placed, that
is, on the working side. Even when food
STRESSES ON T H E D E N T IT IO N is finely divided or when there is no food,
the load seems to be applied similarly,
A stress that may seem unfavorable for mainly on one side at a time. The real
the individual tooth and its supporting significance of stress distribution in ec
tissues may not, in fact, be so, since the centric positions and its extent will be
tooth must be considered in relation to discussed later.
the larger system, the dentition. W hen the For functionally optimal occlusion the
teeth are in interproximal contact, the total load should be distributed through
lateral stress is distributed in a mesio-
distal direction to the adjacent teeth.
Since the dental arch changes in direc 8. S chuyler, C . H . Factors o f occlusion a p p lic a b le to
re s to ra tiv e d e n tis try . J . Pros. D en. 3:772 N o v . 1953.
tion at the cuspids, this distribution is 9. Jankelson, B ernard; H o ffm a n , G . M ., a n d H e n d -
ron, J . A . The physiology o f th e s to m a to g n a th ic system .
particularly operative within each of the J .A .D .A . 46:375 A p r il 1953.
B E Y R O N . . . V O L U M E 48, J U N E 1954 • 651
O C C L U S IO N IN C E N T R IC C L O S U R E
graphic study made by the présent au position is obtained after rotatory closure
thor12 showed that this movement is ro through an adequate interocclusal space,
tatory and constant. By superimposed on an average 3 mm. A weakness in this
laminagraphic roentgenograms the hinge concept and method of determining cen
character of the movement was further tric position is that the path of closure
confirmed, and the hinge axis was ob from the rest position to occlusion is
served to pass through, or close to, the translatory and seldom a rotation.13’ 17' 18
condyles. Posselt13 also has shown that Translatory movement seems natural in
the boundary movements of the mandi view of the character of the opening and
ble can be repeated exactly. The hinge closing movements. The rest position lies
movement is a boundary movement. in the upper distal range o f movement
T h e habitual movements of the m an but is not a boundary position (Fig. 2 ) .
dible during mastication, swallowing and For this reason the closure from the rest
speech are generally not boundary move position is a habitual movement and is
ments but occur within the range of subject to the same individual variation
movement (Fig. 1,B and Fig. 2 ) . The as other such movements. Consequently,
habitual opening and closing movement to accept the actual rest position for find
has a varying path even in the indi ing the centric position seems inadvisable.
vidual.13’ 14 Nevertheless, the basic idea of a re
M cC ollum ,11 Granger15 and others con laxed state of the musculature and un
sider that the basic position for diagnosis strained joints that underlies the concept
and rehabilitation is reached at the cor of rest position is the same as that which
rect vertical dimension by hinge closure underlies the concept of centric relation.
in the retruded relation (Fig. 2 ) . They The best initial position for obtaining
call this centric position. Since this posi centric position, however, would appear
tion is assumed in a boundary movement, to be with the teeth in closer contact than
it may be repeated exactly, a factor which they are in the rest position.
is of immense value. According to Pos The clinical procedure employed by
selt13 this position is, on an average, 1.25 the author is as follows: T h e patient,
mm. distal to the intercuspal position, sitting in an upright position with the
with rather wide variation. Since the head approximately in the Frankfort
position is an intentionally retruded po horizontal plane, is asked to open and
sition, however, it would not appear to close the mouth repeatedly, completely
involve a harmonious state of the mus relaxing the muscles while doing so. This
cles and the temporomandibular joint. action is facilitated by swallowing or by
In the retruded position occasionally the moistening the lips. W hile executing the
total load may be carried entirely by only
a few teeth in the posterior region; this
12. Beyron, H . L. O r ie n te r in g s p r o b le m v id p ro te tis ka
condition results in unfavorable loading reko n s tru k tio n e r och b e tts tu d ie r. Svensk. T a n d l.-T id s k r.
35:1 F e b . 1942.
of these teeth. It seems desirable, then,
13. Posselt, U . Studies in th e m o b ilit y o f th e hum an
from the point of view of stress, to reg m a n d ib le . A c ta o d o n t. S c a n d in a v . 10 (S u p p l. 10) 1952.
14. Posselt, U . U n d e rk a e b e b e v a e g e ls e r o g ta n d a r tik u -
ister the retruded position and to dis la tio n . N o r d . M e d .-O d o n t. H a n d b o k , 1953, p . 861.
tribute the load, in this position, too, over 15. G r a n g e r , E. R. B io-m echanics o f p e r io d o n ta l, d is
ease. J . P e rio d o n t. 21:98 A p r il 1950.
a greater number of teeth. 16. Thom pson, J . R. The rest p o s itio n o f th e m a n d ib le
a n d its s ig n ific a n c e to d e n ta l scie n ce . J .A .D .A . 33:151
T h e rest position, “ the position the F e b . 1946. '
mandible assumes in rest in a tonal con 17. Bom an, V . R. A r o e n tg e n o g ra p h ic study o f th e
positio n o f th e m a n d ib le in n o rm a l occlusion o f the
traction of the musculature without out te e th . Thesis, N orth w e s te rn U n iv e rs ity D e n ta l School,
1948.
side interference,” has been conceived by
18. Thorne, H. T e le ro n tg e n c e p h a lo m e tris k p ro fìl-
Thompson16 and others as the primary analy s: system oversikt d ia g ra m fo r Downs system sam t
m a tm e th o d fo r " p a th o f c lo s u re ." Svensk. T a n d l.-T id s k r.
and fundamental position. The centric 44:30 F e b . 1951.
B E Y R O N . . . V O L U M E 48, J U N E 1954 • 653
Fig. 2 • L e ft: H eavy-lined contour indicating range of incisive m ovem ent, in median plane, of
low er incisors. U pper posterior boundary line, P , indicates posterior hinge m ovem ent. R ig h t:
Enlargem ent o f detail on left. From intercuspal position, I, mandible may in most cases be m oved
som ewhat obliquely backward and downward to retruded contact position, D . T h e rest position,
R , lies in upper distal range of m ovem ent
relaxed opening and closing movement, As it has already been pointed out,
the patient is instructed to let the teeth occasionally it happens that only a few
occlude very lightly, to stop the occlusion teeth make contact on closure into cen
at the initial contact and to hold the tric position. In that case, the load on
position without any sliding of the teeth. the teeth in premature contact and the
Examination then may reveal closure into sliding of the mandible into a forced
the intercuspal position— the intercuspal position produce stresses unfavorable to
position coinciding with centric relation the supporting tissues of the teeth and
— or it may show that some cusps or in probably at the same time disturb the
clines make premature contact, after temporomandibular joint.
which the mandible slides into an “incor For functionally optimal occlusion,
rect” intercuspal position. the mandible on closing in centric
In actual registration, a position should relation should close without interference
be recorded that is close to the occlusal into the position where cusps and in
position, but without the cusps’ making clined planes interdigitate, that is, into
guiding contact and directing the man the intercuspal position. This principle is
dible. T h e closing movement to tooth the principle of closure without inter
contact is practically a rotation, the dis ference in centric maxillomandibular re
tance being so small that any deviation lation.
from this is negligible. Though this pro
cedure for obtaining centric is not in OCCLUSAL V E R T IC A L D IM E N S IO N
fallible, it appears to be the best pro
cedure for providing the ideal position Closely related to occlusion in centric
understood by centric position. position is the problem of occlusal verti
654 • T H E J O U R N A L O F T H E A M E R IC A N D E N T A L A S S O C IA T IO N
cal dimension. It has no direct bearing ments such as attrition. This attrition ap
on the pattern of occlusion and will pears to be due to gliding movements
therefore not be discussed at length. It is performed without food at some stage of
clear from investigations by Thompson16 life. A clear view of these processes can
and others that a proper interocclusal not be obtained through single investiga
clearance must exist between the rest tions. From the serial investigation on
position and the intercuspal, or occlusal, which a report is published in this issue
position. W ith the rest position as refer of t h e j o u r n a l , it appears that between
ence, it is then possible to determine the the occlusion and the contact gliding
correct occlusal vertical dimension. This movements there is a close reciprocal re
manner of determination seems to be the lation. The position and the occlusion of
only acceptable one at present. There is, the teeth have a decisive influence on the
however, some uncertainty, since the gliding movements, and these in their
magnitude of the occlusal clearance, at turn influence the occlusal development.
one time accepted as 3 m m ., has since T h e adult dentition is subject to con
been observed to vary widely. Clinical tinuous occlusal changes. T h e most fav
experience shows, however, that en orable development from the point of
croaching on the interocclusal clearance view of occlusal stress appears to occur
in restorative work leads to serious in when there are multidirectional gliding
crease in the stress on the supporting movements. A somewhat less favorable
tissues, as the musculature attempts to form of occlusion will result when bi
recover the individual’s original inter lateral movements predominate. W hen
occlusal clearance. A n unfavorable lever solely unilateral movements predomi
age also is introduced, since the clinical nate, the development is unfavorable.
crown becomes too high in relation to the Knowledge concerning the form of oc
clinical root. clusion that permits free gliding move
For functionally optimal occlusion, the ments is of great importance. Gliding
occlusal vertical dimension should be de movements occur from the position where
termined by proper interocclusal clear several teeth are in contact and the in
ance between the rest position and the clination of the gliding path is fairly flat.
intercuspal position, or occlusion. This Accordingly, the pattern of optimal oc
principle is the principle of proper inter clusion requires simultaneous contact in
occlusal clearance. eccentric positions between teeth in the
engaged segment and gliding paths to
O C C L U S IO N IN E X C U R S IV E wards centric position, that are flat or
M OVEM ENTS moderately steep.
A form of occlusion permitting multi
T h e occlusion must conform also to ex directional gliding movements is the best.
cursive gliding movements with the teeth A steep incisal guidance with few teeth
in contact. This principle is for the most making contact in the protrusive position
part generally accepted. is a common condition, and in such cases
Some workers, including Kurth,19 Jan- bilateral movements will predominate. It
kelson and others,9 maintain that contact is, then, of importance to note that den
gliding movements do not occur in mas titions with a bilateral movement pattern
tication and hence that excursive move have a development which is relatively
ments are not concerned in occlusion. favorable.
Jankelson’ s studies pertain only to move In treatment the steepness of the in-
ments in mastication. There is clinical
evidence, however, that most dentitions
19. Kurth, L. E. M a n d ib u la r m ovem ents in m a s tic a
present some signs of excursive move tio n . J .A .D .A . 29:1769 O c t . 1942.
B E Y R O N . . . V O L U M E 48, J U N E 1954 • 655
cisal guidance can in most cases be re tact in eccentric positions. Treatment
duced but slightly. Nevertheless, in a then must be directed primarily to the
considerable number of cases a fairly flat correction of the malposition; orthodon
lateral gliding path and simultaneous tic measures may be of value.
occlusal contact among several teeth in N o specific cuspal inclination can be
the lateral segment, involving cuspids, indicated for the shaping of the occlusal
bicuspids and molars, may be obtained on surface in restoration. Individual restora
the working side, a situation which pro tions should be in harmony with the
motes lateral gliding movements and inclinations of the remaining teeth; these
thus a relatively favorable development. inclinations have often been obtained by
It has already been said that balancing grinding. W hen restorations are made for
contact on the unengaged side does not all bicuspids and molars, harmony should
contribute to a reduction in the stress be created with the guiding factors: in
applied to the teeth on the working cisal guidance and condylar guidance. A t
side. In this connection the danger of ex the same time, the aim should be to
cessive contact of balancing cusp inclines make the cusps as flat as possible. T o this
should be emphasized, since such contact end, it is sometimes possible to modify
obstructs gliding movements. the inclination of the occlusal plane and
T h e inclination of the gliding paths the compensating curve. Occasionally the
and the number of teeth in contact that guiding factors make it necessary to form
will permit free gliding movements vary exceptionally steep cusps in order to ob
with the individual. Young persons seem tain multiple contacts, especially bal
to perform gliding movements with rela ancing contact. In such cases it is better
tively steep paths and with few teeth in to make the cusps more shallow even if it
contact. For the execution of the gliding is necessary to have fewer teeth in con
movements, it is not necessary for all tact. The advantage of extensive stress
teeth in a segment to make contact and distribution is counteracted by the less
for the gliding paths to be completely flat. favorable direction o f stress and the ob
W h at is essential is to have sufficient struction of free gliding movements.
teeth in contact and a sufficiently flat For functionally optimal occlusion, ex
gliding path to promote gliding move cursive movements with the teeth in con
ments. The establishment of this situation tact, especially lateral gliding, should be
is the real function of the simultaneous made without interference. T h e estab
occlusal contact in the engaged tooth lishment of this objective is facilitated by
segment in eccentric positions. flat gliding paths and simultaneous con
In correction by grinding, often only tact in eccentric positions between several
a small increase in the number of teeth teeth in the engaged tooth segment. This
in contact and a slight reduction in the principle is the principle of free gliding
inclination of the paths need be made to movements, especially lateral movements.
render lateral gliding movements pos
sible. In the case of young persons, in S U M M A R Y A N D C O N C L U S IO N S
particular, only minor alterations are
necessary. The aim in correction is to Functionally optimal occlusion is occlu
guide the occlusion into beneficial de sion in functional harmony with the in
velopment. Great reduction in the cuspal tegral parts of the masticatory system. It
inclination and incisal guidance is rarely ensures efficient functioning without
indicated. Malposition, resulting from de placing undue strain on the integral
velopment or extraction, often leads to a parts. In particular, the occlusion should
condition in which there are steep glid be favorable to the supporting tissues of
ing paths and few teeth in occlusal con the teeth. There is no specific pattern of
656 • T H E J O U R N A L O F T H E A M E R IC A N D E N T A L A S S O C IA T IO N
The Electricity of Viruses • H ow viruses attach themselves to the wall o f a bacterium before
they invade is a question that greatly interests virologists. Th eodore Puck and Bernard Saglik,
biophysicists at the University o f C olorado, have perform ed an ingenious experiment which
supports the idea that it is a simple electrical process.
T h e targets for the viruses in their experiment were not living bacteria but ion exchange
resins. It has been known that bacterial viruses attach themselves to cells only when positive
ions are present. This suggested that both viruses and cells normally are negatively charged,
and that the positive ions make it possible for them to get together by neutralizing the repulsive
force o f the like charges. T h e C olorado experimenters found that viruses readily attached them
selves to positive resins, and would not stick to negative resins unless positive ions were added.
T h ey proved that cells, like viruses, also are negative: they attach to positive but not to negative
exchangers.
W hen certain bacterial viruses attach to a resin, they begin at once to separate into a protein
and a nucleic acid fraction. This parallels exactly their behavior in cells, where the nucleic acid
is injected into the cell and the protein “ coat” remains outside. Puck and Saglik, writing in
The Journal of Experimental Medicine, suggest that the splitting is the result o f simple electro
static forces. Science and the Citizen. Scientific American 189:44 August 1953.