Aquatic Centre Masterplan Report
Aquatic Centre Masterplan Report
Aquatic Centre Masterplan Report
MASTERPLAN REPORT
P R E P A R E D F O R
FINAL REPORT
H O R S H A M A Q U A T I C C E N T R E
FINAL REPORT
H O R S H A M A Q U A T I C C E N T R E
5 3 H A M I L T O N S T , H O R S H A M V I C 3 4 0 0
TABLE OF CONTENTS
- PRELUDE
- MASTER PLAN STEERING COMMITTEE
- LEAD CONSULTANT COMMITTEE
- INTRODUCTION
- LOCATION
STAGE 1..........................................................................................................................................04
STAGE 2..........................................................................................................................................10
STAGE 3..........................................................................................................................................13
STAGE 4..........................................................................................................................................20
APPENDICES..................................................................................................................................31
1 of 31
FINAL REPORT
H O R S H A M A Q U A T I C C E N T R E
PRELUDE
This report has been prepared by Energy Architecture, Hames Sharley, Trento Fuller & FMG Engineering
for Horsham Rural City Council and Horsham Aquatic Centre Master Plan Working Group. The purpose
of this report is to summarise and document work undertaken during stages 1, 2, 3 and 4 of the
Horsham Aquatic Centre Master Plan/ Concept Design Development. It forms the final project
deliverable of stage 4 as outlined in the brief supplied by Horsham Rural City Council.
Members as follows:
- Cr Les Power (HRCC)
- Dick Gill (Community Representative)
- Faye Smith (Community Representative)
- Roger Armstrong (Community Representative)
- YMCA (Scott Bryant, Sam Winter, Mark Meyer)
- Peter Walsgott/Deidre Harrington (Swimming Club Representative)
- Anne Richards (Wimmera Health Care Group)
- HRCC Director Community Services (Kevin O’Brien)
- HRCC Coordinator, Building and Asset Management (Brett Ellis and Tanya Hahne)
- HRCC Recreation and Sustainability Manager (Rhonda McNeil)
STATE GOVERNMENT
2 of 31
FINAL REPORT
H O R S H A M A Q U A T I C C E N T R E
INTRODUCTION
The Horsham Outdoor War memorial Pool is owned by the Horsham Rural City Council and managed on
their behalf by the YCMA group. The Aquatic centre is around 10years only and the main 50m outdoor is
over 50yrs old and predominantly of the original design. In 2012 Council conducted a
feasibility/investigation study of the Outdoor War Memorial pool to determine its long-term options for the
main 50m pool and associated toddler pool and intermediate pool. The 2012 Horsham outdoor Pool
Feasibility/investigation study provided council with options for future of the War Memorial Swimming
Pool, together with an understanding from the of the views of the local community.
LOCATION
The Horsham Aquatic Centre is located at 53 Hamilton Street, Horsham, VIC, 3400. The aquatic centre
grounds are bound by Hamilton St, Firebrace St, Urquhart St and O’Callaghan’s Parade and comprise of
around 1.8ha including the car park.
DISCLAIMER
The information contained in this report has been prepared with care by our Energy Architecture and
other sub consultants, or it has been supplied to us by apparently reliable sources. In either case, we
have no reason to doubt its completeness or accuracy. However, neither this company nor its
employees guarantee the information, nor does it or is it intended to form part of any contract.
Accordingly, all interested parties should make their own inquiries to verify the information, as well as any
additional or supporting information supplied, and it is the responsibility of interested parties to satisfy
themselves in all respects. This report is for the use only of the party to whom it is addressed and Energy
Architecture and its consultants disclaim responsibility to any third party acting upon or using the whole
or part of its contents. Energy Architecture and the engaged consulting team are not services engineers
and cannot review the facilities current aging mechanical, electrical and hydraulic systems.
3 of 31
FINAL REPORT
H O R S H A M A Q U A T I C C E N T R E
STAGE 1.0
HORSHAM AQUATIC CENTRE
4 of 31
FINAL REPORT
H O R S H A M A Q U A T I C C E N T R E
SUMMARY OF EXISTING 2012 FEASIBILITY STUDY
In 2012 Horsham Rural City Council engaged Smart Connection Company to undertake a Feasibility and
Investigation Study of the outdoor 50m pool and surrounding facilities.
Since the 2012 Horsham Outdoor Pool Feasibility Study was undertaken a number of minor
improvements have been made on the 50m pool. These include replacing the chemical dosing
controller, repairs to the expansion joints, painting the 50m pool, disconnection for the intermediate
pools and a number of operational adjustments as per the recommendations.
Of the minor suggestions with the 2012 Feasibility Report; installations of shade structures, additional
seating, BBQ picnic zones and water fountains have also not been installed.
Of the three significant recommendations to derive from the 2012 Horsham Outdoor Pool Feasibility
Study, Option a) – Prefabricated Concrete shell, Option b) - Replace all existing pools and plant and
Option c) – Replace the 50m pool, ‘NIL’ are yet to be implemented however early conversations with
Horsham Council representatives indicated that Horsham Rural City Council concurrently engaging with
a separate engineer for the option of installing a ‘bladder’ type device into the 50m outdoor pool in an
effort to reduce the volume of water in the pool and minimise ongoing maintenance costs and chemical
use. Further details of the current activities will need to be consulted with Horsham Rural City Council
directly; we have not received a copy of the new engineer’s report or directions.
Separate to the Feasibility Study, recently the pool has been re-painted and hydrostatic values have
been installed in an attempted to maintain the ongoing use of the aging outdoor pool.
For further information regarding the engineering aspects carried out on the outdoor pool in particular
what is contained in the 2012 Horsham Outdoor Pool Feasibility/Investigation Study and any subsequent
reports Please refer to the attached FMG – Engineering Investigation Report FMG REF S31563 –
252359.
5 of 31
FINAL REPORT
H O R S H A M A Q U A T I C C E N T R E
DDA ACCESS REVIEW
The following attachment prepare by Trento Fuller for the Horsham Aquatic Centre has been
undertaken to provide an indication of compliance with statutory obligations required under the
Building Code of Australia and the Commonwealth Disability Discrimination Act 1992.
Current legislation governing the design of buildings requires new building work to comply with the
provisions of the Building Code of Australia 2016 and the referenced suite of Australian Standards
for disability access for buildings and facilities (Appendix A). Areas that fall outside of the BCA defer
to the Commonwealth Disability Discrimination Act 1992 (DDA).
The report has been assessed based on photographic evidence, liaison with the design team, and
Architectural documentation.
Please refer to the attached Horsham Aquatic Centre DDA Access Review - Stage 1
6 of 31
FINAL REPORT
H O R S H A M A Q U A T I C C E N T R E
AQUATIC CENTRE TRENDS
Perhaps the most notable trend in leisure facility design is the importance of connectivity to the
community. They are becoming community hubs, offering social integration opportunities and
building social capital. The contemporary leisure facility now offers more than just a place to swim,
they are now a destination; a place to gather and to socialise. This is being reflected in an increased
attention to facility comfort and design, where comfortable cafes and meeting spaces are becoming
the norm. Increasingly, facilities are designed to provide access to all ages and to all cultures.
Facilities must be flexible to ensure capacity to offer new programs as they develop.
Leisure facilities must be enticing. They must be comfortable places for people of all ages and all
cultures to relax and enjoy their recreation activities. They should encourage participation as a
means to encourage community integration, well-being and social cohesion. Wet, dry and ancillary
components of a facility are located with consideration of the intended operational / management
model, with capability to control patron access to different components if required. Successful
Aquatic halls are orientated for solar gain, and are planned to allow some degree of separation
between active leisure spaces and more passive well-being and program spaces. Furthermore the
ideal scenario for outdoor aquatic components are having them located for solar access and for
protection from prevailing breezes.
Within facilities, demand for leisure water provision is growing rapidly. Traditionally, learn-to-swim
programs and dry fitness have been revenue drivers for community facilities, but increasingly,
participation is now being driven by aquatic play grounds and super slides for the younger users
and indoor heated pools for hydrotherapy to cater for multiple users of all ages. Change facilities are
evolving to reflect these trends with increased provision of family change villages. Community
facilities are now competing with Health Clubs, offering a higher standard of programs, service and
accommodation, particularly for dry fitness. There is a growing movement towards wellness /
wellbeing, with the emergence of spa facilities including suites for massage, physiotherapy, and the
like. The contemporary leisure facility now offers more than just a place to swim, they are now a
destination; a place to gather and to socialise. This is being reflected in an increased attention to
facility comfort and design, where comfortable cafes and meeting spaces are becoming the norm.
Increasingly, facilities are designed to provide access to all ages and to all cultures.
Aquatic centres are most successful when they are easily navigable. Successful facilities are
planned around a clear wayfinding strategy developed early in the design process. On approaching
and entering a facility, the patron should have a sense of where they’re going because the
architecture guides them through the building with subtle cues: they can see what they’re looking
for. Not only does this strategy assist in providing a comfortable, safe, inclusive and welcoming
experience for the patron, it serves to cross sell the activities and services offered.
7 of 31
FINAL REPORT
H O R S H A M A Q U A T I C C E N T R E
SERVICES AND OPPORTUNITIES
The Horsham Aquatic centre at present is quite a diverse complex catering for many different activities
including;
After several conversations and meetings with members of the Horsham Aquatic Centre Steering
Committee to ascertain key council/and or other services that could be incorporated into the
complete, the following list of potential services were canvassed;
- Better inclusion for people with disabilities, it was noted that the current aquatic centre had
several hurdles to overcome to enable inclusion for those with acute and extreme disabilities.
The entry into the facility, access into the pools, storage of scooters & lifting devices,
consultation or flexible mutli-use rooms, change facilities and general hazards were all amongst
the key elements that required upgraded
- Access for Community Health Providers and other allied health professionals, it was established
that the current facility did not cater for the needs of external allied health professionals. The
Master plan should consider how these services may expand under the recent National
Disability Insurance Scheme (NDIS) rollout and what potential inclusion was possible.
- Community Lounge, providing flexible multiuse spaces to enhance the facilities that offered by
Horsham Rural City Council. The Community lounge enables a separate space that could be
booked by the community for events in a similar fashion to library resource centres.
- External Consultancy Rooms, by providing opportunity for private sector providers to establish a
physiotherapy, massage, Pilates or simular type business would enhance the attraction for the
Horsham aquatic centre and enable further income generation.
- Splashpark / Waterplay Activity, an emerging trend in aquatic centre design in the inclusion of
purpose built splashpark or water play facilities to attract tourists from the wider region. BBQ
areas, static playgrounds and open spaces would also be used to complement the current
facilities of the aid in the creation of a regional level facility in attracting the younger generation
and enable further income generation for the service agent and Horsham Rural City Council.
- Outdoor function spaces, enabling birthday parties or events to further strengthen the facilities
provided.
- 50m pool, the master plan process will review with the Horsham aquatic centre steering
committee the potential for additional events and carnivals to be hosted at the site. Throughout
the PCG meetings, the Horsham Swimming club has raised concerns that regarding the
limitations with the current 50m length knowing that it currently does not comply and will need to
be modified to attract state level events.
- Regional level facility, consideration should also be given to what’s required to create a regional
level facility to support funding applications with Horsham Rural City Council.
8 of 31
FINAL REPORT
H O R S H A M A Q U A T I C C E N T R E
ATTENDANCE PATTERNS
Attendance patterns are valuable in determining when best to target specific services. Below is a table of
the attendance figures taken from Horsham Aquatic Centre over the past three years. The data shows
that over a three year average the busiest month for attendance is November, followed by October and
February.
People visited the centre the least in the months of April, June (two year average) and July.
9 of 31
FINAL REPORT
H O R S H A M A Q U A T I C C E N T R E
STAGE 2.0
HORSHAM AQUATIC CENTRE
10 of 31
FINAL REPORT
H O R S H A M A Q U A T I C C E N T R E
MASTERPLAN DEVELOPMENT
After consultation with the Horsham Aquatic Centre – Steering Group Committee, the following desires
were tabled as key design considerations for implementation/consideration into the Horsham Aquatic
Centre Master plan, these included;
Change Area's/WC's
o Inadequate change facilities for parents/ people with disabilities, to be reviewed.
o Review extent of existing W/C’s for integration of larger access toilets
o Consider lifting devices for the leisure pool and supplementary support offices.
Fitness Facilities
o It was noted that the gym layout was not conducive to people with disabilities. Open
spaces was on the opposite side of the room to the entry point, no scooter/wheel chair
parking.
o Consider requirement for Gym to have 24hr access.
o Outdoor space for PT is currently not available; review how this may take place.
o RPM has poor ventilation, consider how to improve.
o Consider consultation/ allied health services in connection with the current Gym.
Admin/Office
o Consider a new location for meeting room for better use by operators/others.
o Consider separate meeting rooms for the YMCA and or others
o Review entry/offices within the facility.
Cafe/Seating
o Café Seating was inadequate, review café and internal function space/RPM space.
11 of 31
FINAL REPORT
H O R S H A M A Q U A T I C C E N T R E
o Review the external Kiosk
Crèche
o No storage, consider additional storage onsite
Masterplan – Option 1 was developed after consultation with the Horsham Aquatic Centre – Steering
Group Committee.
12 of 31
FINAL REPORT
H O R S H A M A Q U A T I C C E N T R E
STAGE 3.0
HORSHAM AQUATIC CENTRE
13 of 31
FINAL REPORT
H O R S H A M A Q U A T I C C E N T R E
COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT PROCESS
Community consultation is valuable in determining the broader needs and expectations held by the
public for major facilities such as the Horsham Aquatic Centre. During master plan design stage,
information gathered from community engagement processes is instrumental in shaping the program
and usage of the proposed development. As a part of the Horsham Aquatic Centre master plan/ concept
design process, community feedback was sought in a number of ways to assist the facility’s potential of
meeting the needs as expressed by the community. A number of different engagement methodologies
were chosen to maximise the input of different sections of Horsham’s residents. These included:
The consultation process was conducted between April 21st and mid-May, 2017 and collected 106
responses in total.
RESIDENT SURVEY
Survey questions were directed at gauging the community’s opinion of both the current facility conditions
and the desired outcomes for future upgrades. Of those that participated in the survey, 63% of the were
from the locality of Horsham (3400 postcode), 14% from suburban Horsham areas (3401 postcode), 6%
of respondents were from various other regions and 11% did not disclose.
Usage Patterns
The majority of aquatic centre users attended the centre 20 times or more within the past year (45.3%)
while the second largest group have visited only occasionally 0-5 times (20%). 13.7% had visited
between 10 – 20 times and 12.6% responded that they had not visited the centre at all.
13%
45% 20%
8%
10%
4%
14 of 31
FINAL REPORT
H O R S H A M A Q U A T I C C E N T R E
Currently, the leading reason for attendance is for the indoor swimming pools (74.2%) followed by the
outdoor 50m Pool (38.2%). Other reasons such as Gym and fitness activities drew between 17-19% of
survey population while school, Club and other organised events made up 13.5%. The lowest ranking
activity was rehabilitation/ Therapy (4.5%) and Child Care (2.2%).
3% 11%
1% 7%
39%
10%
9%
20%
Accessibility
Feedback was collected on whether the Horsham Aquatic Centre is meeting the needs of the community
in terms of accessibility. This was broken into the following aspects:
- Opening hours -
Respondents were divided about the suitability of opening hours. 45% of the 80 respondents
express no need for change and 47.5% would like to see an increase in opening hours.
- Access from the Carpark –
89.8% were satisfied that needs were being met, 5.1% felt improvement was necessary and
5.1% were undecided or did not respond.
- Access by foot into the building –
89.3% were satisfied that needs were being met, 5.3% felt improvement was necessary and
5.3% were undecided or did not respond.
- Accessibility into the pools –
82.2% were satisfied that needs were being met, 10.9% feet improvement was necessary and
6.8% were undecided or did not respond
- Accessibility into Gym/ Fitness Rooms –
65.7% were satisfied that needs were being met, 8.2% felt improvement was necessary, and
26% either did not use the facilities or did not respond.
15 of 31
FINAL REPORT
H O R S H A M A Q U A T I C C E N T R E
Pool Facilities
People were also asked to score the pool facilities in terms of their effectiveness in meeting needs. The
area that ranked the highest in this regard was the Car Park, the 25m Indoor Pool and the Indoor
Program & Leisure Pool (Beach Access Pool). The areas deemed most in need of improvement were the
Toilets & Amenities and the Outdoor Grassed Areas. The Child Care, Main Gym and Fitness Rooms
received the highest amount of NIL responses.
The facility areas were broken into the categories below and received the following ratings.
16 of 31
FINAL REPORT
H O R S H A M A Q U A T I C C E N T R E
When asked to consider whether the overall needs of the community are being met by the Horsham
Aquatic Centre in terms of the level of accessibility and the suitability of the facilities, the average score
out of 10 was between 6 and 7. (78 responses in total)
20
18
16
14
12
RESPONSE
COUNT
10
8
6
4
2
0
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
SCORE
The survey participants were asked to provide indication of what area they would prioritise the upgrades.
The order of priority was as follows (75 respondents in total)
17 of 31
FINAL REPORT
H O R S H A M A Q U A T I C C E N T R E
Participants were asked to elaborate further on what measures would improve the suitability of the
Horsham Aquatic Centre in meeting the needs of the community. These ideas were grouped into the
below categories depending on their response rate. (Refer appendix for the complete list of written
responses.)
table a:
MOST RESPONSES:
SOME RESPONSES:
- Spa / Sauna
- Other outdoor recreational – beach volleyball / trampolines etc.
- Splash Park / children’s pool
- Existing 50m pool upgrades
- Spectator seating for indoor pool
- Gym + RMP room expansion / improvements
- Hydrotherapy pool
FEW RESPONSES:
- Diving board/pool
- Master plan is over developed
- Acoustic measures for sound sensitive children
- Child Care facility upgrades
- Allied health rooms
- Outdoor kiosk
- Passive heating to the outdoor pool
18 of 31
FINAL REPORT
H O R S H A M A Q U A T I C C E N T R E
The data was reviewed alongside Master Plan - Option 1.
40% of the respondents felt that master plan option 1 was meeting their needs as it was. Further
adjustments were made to the plan relating to the findings outlined in table a.
o Adding a mobile hoist entry to 50m pool in lieu of a ramp to maintain 8 lanes clear for
competition standards.
o Inclusion of spa and sauna facilities
o Inclusion of a hydro therapy pool
o Tilt-up doors between hydro pool and indoor pool area for improved accessibility
o Reception wall re-aligned to free up walkway improving accessibility
o Astro turf to outdoor PT session space / flexible to accommodate a range of outdoor
recreation activities described in survey comments.
o Increased marshalling area to improve conditions for competition/ school events
o Improvements to parent change area
Master plan – Option 2 was developed following the analysis of community feedback.
19 of 31
FINAL REPORT
H O R S H A M A Q U A T I C C E N T R E
STAGE 4.0
HORSHAM AQUATIC CENTRE
20 of 31
FINAL REPORT
H O R S H A M A Q U A T I C C E N T R E
SUMMARY RECOMMENDED REDEVELOPMENT
STAGING PLAN
The master plan has been separated into six stages of development, outlined as follows. With each
stage of the development, it is recommended to review opportunities for upgrading the environmental
performance of the facility. Energy Architecture and the consulting team are not services engineers and
are unable to review the aging of existing equipment. It’s recommended that a separate single ESD
report be prepared to align with the staging options below and major construction works be undertaken
at suitable times.
STAGE 1 WORKS
21 of 31
FINAL REPORT
H O R S H A M A Q U A T I C C E N T R E
STAGE 2 - Indoor works B + Ramp:
Works includes a new outdoor function area, parent change rooms, Spa & Sauna facilities, a new WC
compliant with accessibility standards, and the widening/ extension of the existing front entry ramp (this
will accommodate mobility scooter turning etc.)
STAGE 2 WORKS
STAGE 2A WORKS
22 of 31
FINAL REPORT
H O R S H A M A Q U A T I C C E N T R E
STAGE 3 - Indoor works A:
Works include indoor renovations to the corridor, kiosk, reception resize, office, accessible change,
scooter charge bay, storeroom, including hydro pool equipment, hoist, hydro pool plant room, tilt up
glass doors & single tier seating.
STAGE 3 WORKS
STAGE 4 WORKS
23 of 31
FINAL REPORT
H O R S H A M A Q U A T I C C E N T R E
STAGE 5 - Gym works + Community Lounge
The final stage will include gym and fitness associated items; modifying the existing entry to the
gymnasium to have large operable doors, provision of new gym offices/ consult rooms, new outdoor
personal training session space and revisions to the current RPM area. Upgrades to the community
lounge include replacing floor coverings, installing folding door banks, new joinery and seating area.
STAGE 5 WORKS
24 of 31
FINAL REPORT
H O R S H A M A Q U A T I C C E N T R E
SUMMARY COST BREAKDOWN
Refer to the Horsham Aquatic Centre Master Plan Costing Report (Appendix D) and Horsham Aquatic
Centre Master Plan Summary (Appendix E) for detailed breakdowns.
25 of 31
FINAL REPORT
H O R S H A M A Q U A T I C C E N T R E
FUNDING OPPORTUNITY
The Community Sports Infrastructure Fund is a Victorian Government funding program that supports
improvements in sport and active recreational infrastructure across Victoria. This aids in planning for new
or redeveloping existing facilities.
Better Pools is one of the funding categories where grants are offered of up $3 million to provide high-
quality, accessible aquatic leisure facilities.
The community sports infrastructure fund programs open in March with project proposals closing in
June. Further information about this grant is available in the; Community Sports Infrastructure Fund
Guidelines 2018-19 (PDF, 1.31 MB)
26 of 31
FINAL REPORT
H O R S H A M A Q U A T I C C E N T R E
EX I ST I NG P HO T O SU R V E Y
War Memorial Pool plaque Original Filter & Pump room (still in use)
Existing toddler pool (Cracked) Existing intermediate pool (Unused & Fenced)
27 of 31
FINAL REPORT
H O R S H A M A Q U A T I C C E N T R E
EX I ST I NG P HO T O SU R V E Y
RPM room (Poor ventilation) Existing Pump room (25m & Leisure Pools)
Rear service yard Existing Pump room (25m & Leisure Pools)
Indoor Leisure pool + Beach Entry In active water indoor water play
28 of 31
FINAL REPORT
H O R S H A M A Q U A T I C C E N T R E
EX I ST I NG P HO T O SU R V E Y
Access ramp into 25m indoor lap pool Cafe & Common Corridor
29 of 31
FINAL REPORT
H O R S H A M A Q U A T I C C E N T R E
EX I ST I NG P HO T O SU R V E Y
30 of 31
FINAL REPORT
H O R S H A M A Q U A T I C C E N T R E
APPENDICES
HORSHAM AQUATIC CENTRE
31 of 31
FINAL REPORT
H O R S H A M A Q U A T I C C E N T R E
APPENDIX A
The work carried out in the preparation of this document has been performed in accordance with the requirements of FMG
Engineering’s Quality Management System which is certified by a third party accredited auditor to comply with the requirements
of ISO9001.
This document is and shall remain the property of FMG Engineering. The document is specific to the Client and site detailed in
the document. Use of the document must be in accordance with the Terms of Engagement for the commission and any
unauthorised use of this document in any form whatsoever is prohibited. No part of this document including the whole of same
shall be used for any other purpose nor by any third party without the prior written consent of FMG Engineering.
The opinions expressed in this document are based upon a visual inspection conducted with reasonable care. Areas not
reasonably accessible and not readily viewed without disturbing the existing structure, finishes or furnishings have not been
inspected, unless noted otherwise.
FMG Engineering reserves the right to append, amend and / or modify the contents of this document upon receipt of additional
information.
The document is not a guarantee or warranty, but is a professional assessment of the condition of the premises, or part thereof,
at the time of inspection.
Document Status
Adelaide Melbourne
42 Fullarton Road 2 Domville Avenue
Norwood Hawthorn
SA 5067 VIC 3122
P 08 8363 0222 P 03 9815 7600
E adl.forensic@fmgengineering.com.au E mel.forensic@fmgengineering.com.au
Sydney
Suite 28, 38 Ricketty Street
Mascot
NSW 2020
P 1300 975 878
E syd.forensic@fmgengineering.com.au
Page 2 of 14
FMG Ref: S31563 - 252359
Site Address: Horsham Aquatic Centre, 53 Hamilton Street, HORSHAM, VIC 3400
Client: Energy Architecture
TABLE OF CONTENTS
1.0 Introduction ................................................................................................................ 4
Page 3 of 14
FMG Ref: S31563 - 252359
Site Address: Horsham Aquatic Centre, 53 Hamilton Street, HORSHAM, VIC 3400
Client: Energy Architecture
1.0 Introduction
1.1 FMG Engineering (‘FMG’) has been engaged by Energy Architecture to review previous
engineering reports and to assess the condition of the existing outdoor aquatic facility
based upon the findings of these reports. FMG has also been requested to advise any
additional testing which may provide a better understanding of the existing facility’s
condition.
1.2 FMG has considered the following reports in order to formulate its opinion;
(1) CO-OP – Proposed Early Works – Consultant Advice Notice No. 001 – Date: 25
June 2016
(2) CO-OP – Outdoor Pool Plant Review – Revision A – Date: 16 August 2016
(3) CO-OP – Schematic Design Report revision – Consultant Advice Notice No. 003 –
Date: 30 August 2016
(4) Horsham Rural City Council – Feasibility / Investigation Study – Date: June 2012
(5) Geoff Ninnes Fong and Partners (‘GNFP’) – Interim 50m Pool Works
Recommendations – Pool and Tank Structures and Finishes, Filtration and Water
Treatment – Date: 7 December 2012
1.3 FMG has also reviewed the original construction documentation for the outdoor 50m
pool and toddler pool, photographs of the facility and a survey of the existing facility
undertaken in July 2004.
1.4 The reports mention multiple defects in the filtration system of the outdoor facility as well
as concerns with the structural efficacy of the 50m concrete pool shell. The learn-to-
swim pool was found to be in relatively good condition but is hydraulically linked to the
50m pool and toddler pool. The toddler pool has been found to be unsalvageable.
Page 4 of 14
FMG Ref: S31563 - 252359
Site Address: Horsham Aquatic Centre, 53 Hamilton Street, HORSHAM, VIC 3400
Client: Energy Architecture
(1) An indoor 25m reinforced concrete pool constructed on reinforced concrete piles.
This pool includes a disabled access ramp and is 900mm to 1600mm deep. It
features a wet deck gutter collection on all sides to return soiled water to a balance
tank.
(2) An indoor reinforced concrete leisure pool, also constructed on reinforced concrete
piles. This pool includes a beach entry and is 0mm to 1400mm deep. It has a wet
deck gutter system on all sides to return soiled water to a balance tank.
(3) An outdoor reinforced concrete 50m pool with an average depth of 1.67m.
(4) An outdoor reinforced concrete learn-to-swim pool with an average depth of 0.67m.
(5) An outdoor reinforced concrete toddler pool with an average depth of 0.15m.
2.2 The indoor pools are constructed on piles. The 50m pool is constructed over an
extensive underdrain system. All of the outdoor pools share a common balance tank and
filtration system. The indoor pools are reticulated separately from each other and have
individual balance tanks.
Page 5 of 14
FMG Ref: S31563 - 252359
Site Address: Horsham Aquatic Centre, 53 Hamilton Street, HORSHAM, VIC 3400
Client: Energy Architecture
3.1 In order to review whether or not sufficiently comprehensive investigative works have
already been undertaken, FMG has summarised the past investigations. Other salient
information has also been included in the summary. Please note that where the same
information is repeated in multiple reports, then it is only included under one of the
headings below, not all. Our summary is not set out in any particular chronological order.
Horsham Rural City Council – Feasibility / Investigation Study – Date: June 2012
Geoff Ninnes Fong and Partners (GNFP) – Interim 50m Pool Works Recommendations – Pool
and Tank Structures and Finishes Filtration and Water Treatment – Date: 7 December
2012
(13) A CCTV inspection video of the scum gutter pipes and return-to-pool pipes with a
sketch plan of the pipes, as prepared by Beckers Drain Cleaning Services was
Page 6 of 14
FMG Ref: S31563 - 252359
Site Address: Horsham Aquatic Centre, 53 Hamilton Street, HORSHAM, VIC 3400
Client: Energy Architecture
CO-OP – Proposed Early Works – Consultant Advice Notice No. 001 – Date: 25 June 2016
This report essentially sets out the findings of the recommended investigations in the
earlier works proposals. It is limited to the pool filtration and sanitation systems.
(18) The filtration pump has been extensively repaired over the years and requires
replacement.
(19) The toddler pool and learn-to-swim pool are not in use and have been isolated. The
50m pool is reportedly operating at a water turn-over rate between 5.5 hours and
8.5 hours.
(20) The 50m pool loses the order of 100mm of water level over a 24-hour period.
(21) The external concourse water is collected and directed to the balance tank.
(22) Groundwater is being collected and pumped into the balance tank. [Note: FMG has
assumed that the water has been tested and found to be chlorinated and is hence
water from the swimming pool leaks].
(23) Hydrostatic pressure relief valves have been installed.
(24) There are suction pipelines located in the pool walls near the floor which require
Virigina Graeme Baker Pool and Spa Safety (VGB) compliant covers.
Page 7 of 14
FMG Ref: S31563 - 252359
Site Address: Horsham Aquatic Centre, 53 Hamilton Street, HORSHAM, VIC 3400
Client: Energy Architecture
(25) There is no containment bund located at the sodium hypochlorite delivery area
which is on Cameron Street just off O’Callaghan’s Parade. The filling procedure
requires a minimum of two people because of the distance between the fill point and
the storage tank. Remedial options for compliance were outlined by CO-OP in
section 11 of their report.
(26) There are a number of OWHS risks in the existing plant room. Essentially these
risks include;
(a) An ill-fitting pit cover which requires replacement.
(b) Filter access is via a ladder which is not compliant with AS1657.
(c) The plant room does not include a sink for chemical testing.
(27) The report provided three options for increasing water quality.
(a) Maintain existing pool filter hydraulics.
(b) Maintain existing filters and provide new pipework to and from the pool.
(c) New filters and pool hydraulics.
(28) The scum gutter inverts vary by 37mm.
CO-OP – Schematic Design Report revision – Consultant Advice Notice No. 003 – Date: 30
August 2016
(29) The base of filter cells are constructed of a perforated corrugated asbestos sheet.
Three separate recommendations for dealing with the asbestos sheet were
provided within the report. It is unclear as to which of these options, if any, may have
been undertaken.
(30) A Natare pool retrofit wet deck system was suggested as a potential solution to
replacing filtered water return pipework under the 50m pool.
Page 8 of 14
FMG Ref: S31563 - 252359
Site Address: Horsham Aquatic Centre, 53 Hamilton Street, HORSHAM, VIC 3400
Client: Energy Architecture
4.1 In order to ascertain what needs to be done to upgrade a facility of this nature, FMG
would propose the undertaking of additional testing. Some relevant tests have already
been undertaken and the results can still be relied upon in our opinion. Below is a
summary of tests FMG would normally undertake when investigating an aged pool
complex.
(1) Leak detection in the form of dye testing with a qualified diver + observer whilst the
pool remains full. It is recommended that this be undertaken as soon as practically
possible after the pool has been filled. Balance tanks are not typically tested in this
manner because it is often too dark in the tank to give meaningful results.
FMG suggests that the dye test performed a number of years ago is no longer valid.
Additional leaks in different locations may have now formed in the pool shell.
(2) Concrete coring of the pool shell in order to aid in the assessment of structural
integrity.
FMG understands that concrete cores have been tested but it is uncertain as to the
location of these cores. Regardless, the results indicated that the concrete was in
excess of 40MPa and as such the concrete is relatively strong. However, chloride
content was not measured in the concrete. As chlorides are absorbed into the
concrete they progressively increase in concentration. At low concentrations,
chlorides are effectively harmless, but once they surpass a critical level they can,
and often do, cause significant corrosion of the steel reinforcement.
(3) Concrete cores from the balance tank to aid in the assessment of structural integrity
FMG do not believe this has yet been undertaken. If there is no sign of structural
distress in the balance tank, then this could possibly be overlooked.
(4) Visual inspection of the pool shell in order to determine if there is any structural
cracking.
Structural cracking has been noted in the pool shell. It is strongly recommended that
a visual inspection of the pool shell be undertaken again by an experienced
professional if a pool shell is to be retained and repaired.
Page 9 of 14
FMG Ref: S31563 - 252359
Site Address: Horsham Aquatic Centre, 53 Hamilton Street, HORSHAM, VIC 3400
Client: Energy Architecture
(5) Visual inspection of the balance tank to determine if the tank has any structural
cracking.
Due to the depth of the existing balance tank inspecting it will be relatively difficult.
FMG would typically design a much shallower balance tank with a larger footprint
area in order to more easily maintain the foot-valve and strainer assembly
(assuming the pump system does have a foot-valve and strainer fitted) as well as
cleaning off of any accumulated debris from within the balance tank. In
circumstances such as this it would typically be FMG’s recommendation that the
existing balance tank be abandoned and a new purpose-built tank be constructed.
(6) Pressure testing of the pipework to determine if any of the pipe network is leaking.
To a lesser extent CCTV may be relied upon to more accurately determine the
position of leaks should any be found by the initial pressure testing.
This was undertaken a number of years ago now and it is currently unclear as to
whether the leaks detected have been, or were, rectified. Should it be determined
that sections of pipework are to remain in service, then FMG recommends that is
the reticulation system be pressure tested again.
(7) Survey the pool to determine if it has been subjected to differential ground
movement. Usually this is conducted along a scum gutter.
This was also done many years ago. Conducting another levels survey now and
comparing it to the previous survey will provide an insight into the history of
movement of the structure. Should the survey result be similar to the previous
survey then a traditional wet deck system could be retrofitted onto the existing pool
structure. If is found to be significantly different, then the reticulation system would
either need to remain as a scum gutter collection for soiled water or have a new
Natare wet deck system fitted. The Natare wet deck water reticulation system has
additional benefits which will be discussed later in this report.
(8) Assess the facility for WHS issues. Particular attention is usually paid to the quality
of the tiling, quality of the concourse and particularly to chemical storage / delivery
locations, along with PPE and storage of MSDS literature.
Page 10 of 14
FMG Ref: S31563 - 252359
Site Address: Horsham Aquatic Centre, 53 Hamilton Street, HORSHAM, VIC 3400
Client: Energy Architecture
(9) Assess the disinfection and filtration system for efficiency, reliability, suitability for
purpose and to determine if the facility complies with recommended public health
guidelines.
[This has recently been addressed in the CO-OP report. FMG has provided some
additional input into the 3 overall options put forward by CO-OP].
(10) FMG would potentially recommend the exposure of some steel reinforcement. In an
aggressive environment, such as a pool, it is possible for the structural reinforcing
steel to corrode in such a way that it does not cause spalling of the concrete (i.e. by
electrolysis). It is FMG’s opinion that the structural steel should be exposed in a
minimum of two locations in the 50m pool shell to determine if this form of
deterioration may be occurring. This is of most concern at points of high stress such
as the base of pool walls, as such the investigation should be done at this location.
This has not been undertaken at any time in the past in so far as FMG can
determine.
4.2 In summary FMG recommends the minimum amount of testing that should be
contemplated before a final decision is made with regard to the possibility of retaining
the existing 50m pool structure.
(1) Dye testing should be undertaken again as soon as practically possible after filling
of the pool.
(2) A current visual inspection of the pool shell should be undertaken by an experienced
professional. A scope of work, or the need for a more focused investigation of shell
defects, will be identified during this inspection.
(3) If any pipework is to be retained without being relined (refer section 5 of this report)
then it should be pressure tested to confirm that the pipework can be retained.
(4) The pool should be level surveyed again to determine if it is subject to periodic
differential movement and to determine if a wet deck conversion is a viable option
to consider.
(5) Exposure of steel reinforcement at locations of high stress (base of pool wall) is
recommended in a minimum of two locations to check for chloride contamination in
concrete and electrolysis attack of the reinforcement.
Page 11 of 14
FMG Ref: S31563 - 252359
Site Address: Horsham Aquatic Centre, 53 Hamilton Street, HORSHAM, VIC 3400
Client: Energy Architecture
5.1 CO-OP has provided the following three options in its report concerning the disinfection
and filtration system;
(1) Option 1 – Maintain existing pool filter pool hydraulics. This option assumes the
permanent shutting down of the toddler and learn-to-swim pools.
(2) Option 2 – Maintain existing filters and provide new pipework to and from the pool.
This option assumes the permanent shutting down of the toddler and learn-to-swim
pools.
(3) Option 3 – New filters and pool hydraulics. This option includes items 3a and 3b
which relate to options available regarding the toddler and learn-to-swim pools.
Options 3a and 3b in theory could be undertaken in conjunction with options 1 or 2.
5.2 Option 1, whilst this could be undertaken, is not recommended by FMG because the
current water turnover rate exceeds that which is recommended for public health. CO-
OP did not adjust all of their figures for a smaller filter cell than they had anticipated. This
means the maximum achievable turnover rate for option 2 would not be 4.5 hours but
rather 5.28 hours. As CO-OP has stated, a filtration rate of 15 m3/m2/hr may not be
achievable which means that they also may not achieve the required flow rate. Similarly
to option 1, option 2 is also not recommended as there is, in FMG’s opinion, a strong
chance that it will exceed the maximum water turnover rate recommended for public
health.
5.3 In addition to option 3 the following work would be required in order to salvage the 50m
pool shell based upon the investigations which have been undertaken to date.
Full construction joint retrofit repairs on all joints. FMG has assumed that this has
not yet been undertaken.
Repair of structural cracking noted within the GNFP report. This is typically
undertaken using a hydro-reactive and permanently flexible resin injection
process.
Removal of all existing painted surfaces and any render that may exist on the
pool shell. This will hopefully expose any concealed older cracking in order to
allow repairs to be undertaken. FMG typically recommends that the pool shell be
tilled. This entails, amongst other things, the provision of a high quality and
flexible waterproof lining membrane to be installed which is protected by the tiles.
Page 12 of 14
FMG Ref: S31563 - 252359
Site Address: Horsham Aquatic Centre, 53 Hamilton Street, HORSHAM, VIC 3400
Client: Energy Architecture
Painting the surface does not provide anywhere near the same level of
protection.
The installation of a new pipe network would be extremely intrusive. FMG would
recommend, in this instance, that the centrally located filtered water return line
be simply relined with a reinforced polymer lining sock. New pipework can then
be installed around the exterior of the pool, along with new wall inlets. Similar to
the Natare system this approach avoids concrete demolition. If a new survey
determines that the pool is only being subjected to minimal differential soil
movement, then FMG would recommend the installation of a new retrofitted wet
deck system. If there is more than a small amount of movement, then FMG would
recommend the installation of the Natare system. Due to the unique nature of the
Natare system the same effect as a wet deck system can be achieved whilst it
should allow for some minor ground movement.
If a new survey determines that the pool is subjected to significant seasonal
movement then it must be clearly understood from a structural efficacy
perspective that the existing pool will continue to have issues with water leaks
and it is highly unlikely that they can be permanently eliminated.
FMG also recommends the installation of a dignity for disabled access ramp into
the pool, should extensive works be contemplated for the outdoor facility. If any
structural work is undertaken, then it is FMG’s understanding that dignity for
disabled (DDA) access must be addressed by the installation of either a ramp or
a lifting device. A lifting device may be in place which FMG is not aware of at this
time.
5.4 CO-OP has provided three options regarding the chemical delivery system. FMG agrees
with the options put forward. The available options are summarised as;
(1) Provide a containment bund for a dedicated outdoor facility chemical delivery area
within the site boundary.
(2) Increase the chemical storage capacity of the indoor facility and use this storage
also for the outdoor facility.
(3) Convert the chemical disinfection system from sodium hypochlorite to calcium
hypochlorite (granular chlorine)
Page 13 of 14
FMG Ref: S31563 - 252359
Site Address: Horsham Aquatic Centre, 53 Hamilton Street, HORSHAM, VIC 3400
Client: Energy Architecture
6.0 Conclusion
6.1 There are still some remaining investigations which FMG strongly recommend should
be undertaken prior to determination as to whether or not the 50m pool can be salvaged
and to determine if the pool can have a wet deck conversion undertaken/considered.
6.2 It is FMG’s opinion that the existing 50m pool, based on the information available, could
be salvaged, however, extensive retrofit works will be required. There is also the
potential that when the existing concrete surfaces are stripped of their paint coatings
that some older concealed structural defects may be revealed which will result in
unforeseen variations to the work.
6.3 FMG is of the opinion that an entirely new filtration system is required for the facility and
that the existing filter system should be abandoned. Based on the information available
there will be minimal work required on the learn-to-swim pool in order to retain it, but a
new filtration system is required.
6.4 As stated in the CO-OP report there is some work required in order to make the chemical
delivery area compliant.
Page 14 of 14
APPENDIX B
Prepared for
Mr Daniel Manno
Energy Architecture
109 Grote Street
Adelaide SA 5000
Prepared by
Trento Fuller Building Certifiers & Consultants
Suite 410 147 Pirie Street, Adelaide SA 5000, Australia
T 7071706 F 7100 6499 www.trentofuller.com.au
ABN 47 160 056 397
25 October 2016
Quality Information
Document DDA Access Review – Stage 1
Ref J167119
Revision History
Authorised
Revision Revision Date Details
Name/Position Signature
Trento Fuller Building Certifiers & Consultants Pty Ltd. All rights reserved.
Trento Fuller has prepared this document for the sole use of the Client and for a specific purpose, each as expressly stated in the document, no
other party shall rely on the document without the prior written consent of Trento Fuller. Trento Fuller undertakes no duty, nor accepts any
responsibility, to any third party who may rely upon or use this document. This document has been prepared based on the Client’s description of
its requirements and Trento Fuller’s experience, having regard to Assumptions that Trento Fuller can reasonably be expected to make in
accordance with sound professional principles. Trento Fuller may also have relied upon information provided by the Client and other third parties
to prepare this document, some of which may not have been verified. Subject the above conditions, this document may be transmitted,
reproduced or disseminated only in its entirety.
Trento Fuller Building Certifiers & Consultants Horsham Aquatic Centre - DDA Access Review
Table of Contents
INTRODUCTION ..................................................................................................................................... 5
BUILDING AND SITE DETAILS ............................................................................................................... 5
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY .......................................................................................................................... 6
BCA QUERY ITEMS................................................................................................................................................. 6
DDA QUERY ITEMS................................................................................................................................................. 7
DEFINITIONS .......................................................................................................................................... 9
BCA REQUIREMENTS FOR ACCESS FOR PEOPLE WITH A DISABILITY REVIEW ........................... 10
PART D3 – ACCESS FOR PEOPLE WITH DISABILITIES .................................................................................................. 10
D3.1 General building access requirements ................................................................................................................ 10
D3.2 Access to buildings ............................................................................................................................................ 11
D3.3 Parts of buildings to be accessible ..................................................................................................................... 12
D3.4 Exemptions......................................................................................................................................................... 13
D3.5 Car Parking ......................................................................................................................................................... 14
D3.6 Signage .............................................................................................................................................................. 15
D3.7 Hearing Augmentation ........................................................................................................................................ 16
D3.8 Tactile Indicators ................................................................................................................................................ 16
D3.9 Wheelchair seating spaces in Class 9b assembly buildings ................................................................................ 17
D3.10 Swimming Pools ................................................................................................................................................. 18
D3.11 Ramps ................................................................................................................................................................ 18
D3.12 Glazing on an accessway ................................................................................................................................... 18
SPECIFICATION D3.6 - BRAILLE AND TACTILE SIGNS .................................................................................................. 18
2. Location of braille and tactile signs ..................................................................................................................... 18
3. Braille and tactile sign specification .................................................................................................................... 19
4. Luminance contrast ............................................................................................................................................ 19
5. Lighting............................................................................................................................................................... 20
6. Braille ................................................................................................................................................................. 20
SPECIFICATION D3.10 – ACCESSIBLE WATER ENTRY/EXIT FOR SWIMMING POOLS ........................................................ 20
2. Fixed or moveable ramp ..................................................................................................................................... 20
3. Zero depth entry ................................................................................................................................................. 20
4. Platform swimming pool lift ................................................................................................................................ 20
5. Sling-style swimming pool lift ............................................................................................................................. 21
6. Aquatic wheelchair ............................................................................................................................................. 22
PART F2 – SANITARY AND OTHER FACILITIES ............................................................................................................ 22
F2.2 Calculation of number of occupants and facilities............................................................................................... 22
F2.3 Facilities in Class 3 to 9 buildings ....................................................................................................................... 22
F2.4 Accessible Sanitary Facilities .............................................................................................................................. 24
Page 3 of 45
Trento Fuller Building Certifiers & Consultants Horsham Aquatic Centre - DDA Access Review
Page 4 of 45
Trento Fuller Building Certifiers & Consultants Horsham Aquatic Centre - DDA Access Review
Introduction
The purpose of this DDA Access Review is to identify potential difficulties a person with a
disability may face when accessing the Horsham Aquatic Centre. The objective is to ensure that
all people are provided with safe, equitable and dignified access to buildings and premises. This
assessment is based on the requirements of the Commonwealth Disability Discrimination Act
1992 (DDA), Disability (Access to Premises- Buildings) Standards 2010, and the referenced suite
of Australian Standards for disability access for buildings and facilities (Appendix A).
The definition of ‘premises’ in the DDA is broader than the Access to Premises Standard and
BCA. A ‘premises’ includes service counter heights, fixtures and fittings, common area facilities,
public outdoor eating areas and furniture and safe egress from a building, which are all subject
to the existing DDA provisions and potential complaints system. The complaints that may arise
have been listed under the heading Disability & Discrimination Act (DDA) 1992 Review (Risk
Response). Since a complaint is subjective and there may be different levels of risk in regards to
whether a complaint will be upheld by the Courts we will, following development of the Stage 2
Masterplan, complete a DDA risk assessment (in accordance with AS/NZS ISO 31000:2009) to
inform the team and the client on any perceived risk exposure.
The mandatory requirements for disability access to be provided to buildings is regulated in the
National Construction Code (BCA Volume 1 - 2016 edition) Part D3 Requirements for Access for
People with a Disability. The items that are either non-compliant with the BCA or requiring further
review are listed under the heading BCA Requirements for Access for People with a Disability
Review (Compliance Query).
The Aquatic Centre is an existing 2,800 m2 single storey Class 9b building located within the
regional City of Horsham, Victoria. The site is bound by a roadway to the West and North with a
carpark located between the building and road. The building is fenced so that the external pool area
cannot be accessed. The main entry point is the Northern entry from Hamilton Street both for
vehicles accessing the carpark and for pedestrian movement along the pathway to the building
entrance. Retaining walls surround the site which is built up higher than the adjacent footpaths.
Australian Bureau of Statistics (ABS) data suggests that the demographic makeup of Horsham
includes a higher percentile of people over the age of 70 years in comparison to the National and
Victorian average. There are also a number of retirement communities and aged care buildings
nearby that we would assume make use the Aquatic facilities for rehabilitation, therapy, and
relaxation.
In light of the above we have considered the likelihood that the Aquatic Centre will be used by a
person with a disability as greater than if the same facility was located in another city or large
township. Access provisions should, as a result, address not only the BCA non-compliances but also
the potential for a DDA complaint.
Page 5 of 45
Trento Fuller Building Certifiers & Consultants Horsham Aquatic Centre - DDA Access Review
Executive Summary
The following report has been undertaken to provide an indication of compliance with statutory
obligations required under the Building Code of Australia and the Commonwealth Disability
Discrimination Act 1992.
Current legislation governing the design of buildings requires new building work to comply with
the provisions of the Building Code of Australia 2016 and the referenced suite of Australian
Standards for disability access for buildings and facilities (Appendix A). Areas that fall outside of
the BCA defer to the Commonwealth Disability Discrimination Act 1992 (DDA).
The report has been assessed based on photographic evidence, liaison with the design team,
and Architectural documentation. We note that no building audit was undertaken by Trento Fuller
or consultation with any of the user groups. If further analysis is required we are more than
willing to undertake a details building audit and discuss our findings with the City Council,
Disability groups, and other stakeholders for additional feedback.
(b) There is insufficient detail on the plan to confirm compliance requirements of the
entrance ramps, however we note:
1. Non-compliant turning for wheelchairs onto the zig-zag ramp at the base,
mid landing and top;
2. Tactiles non-compliant (only 300 mm) to the top of the ramp adjacent the
main entry auto-door;
(c) Most doors appear to only have a clear opening width (scaled from plan) of 800 mm;
(d) Signage required to indicate the location of accessible toilets (to other facilities) and
signage to accessible changeroom to indicate either left handed or right handed toilet
facility;
(f) Tactiles Ground Surface Indicators may be required at path from the footpath to the
accessible carpark;
(g) No handrail provided to the program/leisure zero depth entry pool and no access for
people with disabilities identified to within the external 50 m pool;
(h) Based on 140 participants (carnivals, etc) a further 2 showers and 1 toilet pan for
Males is required;
(j) No backrest with luminance contrast provided to the accessible Toilet Pans;
(k) No access for people with disabilities is provided to the external 50 m pool.
Page 6 of 45
Trento Fuller Building Certifiers & Consultants Horsham Aquatic Centre - DDA Access Review
The following queries have been identified from the review of the aforementioned drawings as not
meeting the spirt and intent of the DDA – these items will be included in the Risk Assessment as part
of Stage 4 and can be discussed further in due course;
(a) The footpath at the intersection of Hamilton Road and Urqhart Road (north-east
corner) does not provide an accessible pathway surface, only a grassed path, to the
main entry point to the building on Hamilton Street;
(b) Four ramps are required on the accessible path of travel to enter the building. This
presents undue fatigue to elderly occupants or those with a disability attempting to
access the Aquatic Centre facilities. A large crowd of elderly occupants or people with
disabilities have limited room to navigate the ramps and once near the entrance there
is also no open area or landing or an internal lobby space for rest;
(c) Access from the street to the building entrance is also a long distance. In addition to
the above difficulties, seating should be provided (sheltered from the sun, rain, and
prevailing wind) at the base of the stair. Drinking fountains could also be provided;
(d) Access from the carpark to the building entrance requires accessible pathway past
the road crossing which may be unsafe for people with a vision or hearing impairment.
Consider installing bollards to the widened path adjacent the road as well as tactiles.
Warning signs and slow speed signs could also be provided to reduce risk of any
accidents at the crossing;
(e) Provide signage to direct vehicles at the street entrance to the accessible carparking
bays;
(f) An additional accessible parking bay should be provided (3 total with 3 shared zones);
(g) Adequate distance is provided between the pool filtration grates and side walls
however any storage including signage boards and equipment shall be removed to
allow wheelchair users to pass;
(h) Skirtings have poor contrast to the floor material. Also consider using contrast in the
central part of the floor to provide visual ques for access into main parts of the
building including the control room, café and pool area;
(i) Enhanced access seating should be provided to allow wheelchair users to manoeuvre
from their wheelchair onto seating and then to an aquatic wheelchair;
(j) General seating in the pool area should include arm and backrests as well as lowered
seat heights;
(k) Escape from the building to be by way of a hearing augmentation system that is
connected to the occupant warning, or visual and tactile vibration signals, or a buddy
system to alert hearing impaired or deaf occupants. Further discussion required with
staff / employees;
(l) Change room / changing place facilities should be provided (and have emergency call
buttons installed). Refer http://changingplaces.org.au/;
Page 7 of 45
Trento Fuller Building Certifiers & Consultants Horsham Aquatic Centre - DDA Access Review
(m) Consider additional Unisex accessible sanitary facilities adjacent Hall, Gymnasium
and Creche sanitary facilities;
(n) Incorporate signage perpendicular to the control room and pool area so that they can
be viewed from the building entrance;
(o) Location for aquatic wheelchairs should be provided in a position that is readily
available. Management of the wheelchairs may require lifeguards to retrieve and then
assist people with disabilities back onto the wheelchair;
(p) The entry method into the pool (fixed ramp and zero-depth) have their drawbacks
however both comply with the Building Code requirements. A person can lodge a
complaint however it is unlikely to be supported. The method of entry depends on the
user group and their specific preference. Further discussion required;
Page 8 of 45
Trento Fuller Building Certifiers & Consultants Horsham Aquatic Centre - DDA Access Review
Definitions
Accessway - means a continuous accessible path of travel to, into or within a building.
Alternative Solution - means a Building Solution which complies with the Performance Requirements
other than by reason of satisfying the Deemed-to-Satisfy Provisions.
Braille - a system of touch reading for the blind or vision impaired which employs raised dots, evenly
arranged in quadrangular letter spaces or cells.
Continuous accessible path of travel - an uninterrupted path of travel to, from or within a building,
providing access to all required facilities. A continuous accessible path of travel should not
incorporate any step, stairway, turnstile, revolving door, escalator or other impediment that would
prevent it from being safely negotiated by people with disabilities.
Disability - a condition or state of being, which is covered by the broad Disability Discrimination Act
1992 definition. The term includes physical, sensory, psychiatric, intellectual and neurological
disabilities, physical disfigurement and the presence in the body causing, or capable of causing,
disease.
Disability Action Plan - a disability action plan or DAP, is a document that organisations prepare
and use in order to reduce and remove barriers experienced by people with a disability.
Grabrail – A rail used to give a steadying or stabilising assistance to a person engaged in a particular
function.
Handrail - a rail used in circulation areas such as corridors, passageways, ramps and stairways to
assist in continuous movement.
Luminance contrast - the light reflected from one surface or component, compared to the light
reflected from another surface or component.
Ramp - an inclined surface on a continuous accessible path of travel between two landings with a
gradient steeper than 1 in 20 but not steeper than 1 in 14.
Ramp, kerb - an inclined surface on a continuous accessible path of travel with a maximum rise of
190 mm, a length not greater than 1520 mm and a gradient not steeper than 1 in 8, located within or
attached to a kerb.
Ramp, threshold - an inclined surface on a continuous accessible path of travel with a maximum rise
of 35 mm, length not greater than 280 mm and a gradient not steeper than 1 in 8.
Tactile ground surface indicators - truncated cones and/or bars installed on the ground or floor
surface, designed to provide pedestrians who are blind or vision-impaired with warning or directional
orientation information.
Tactile signs- signage incorporating raised text, and/or symbols and Braille to enable touch reading
by people who are blind or who are vision-impaired.
Walkway – any surface on a continuous accessible path of travel with a gradient not steeper than 1 in 20.
Page 9 of 45
Trento Fuller Building Certifiers & Consultants Horsham Aquatic Centre - DDA Access Review
Class 1b
(a) Dwellings located on one allotment(1) and used
for short-term holiday accommodation,
consisting of:
i. 4 to 10 dwellings to and within 1 dwelling
i. 11 to 40 dwellings to and within 2 dwellings
ii. 41 to 60 dwellings to and within 3 dwellings
iii. 61 to 80 dwellings to and within 4 dwellings
iv. 81 to 100 dwellings to and within 5 dwellings
v. more than 100 dwellings to and within 5
dwellings plus 1 additional dwelling for each
additional 30 dwellings or part thereof in excess
of 100 dwellings.
(1) A community or strata-type subdivision or
Class 2, 3 & 9c
Common areas: From a pedestrian entrance required to
be accessible to at least 1 floor containing sole-
occupancy units and to the entrance doorway of each
sole-occupancy unit located on that level.
To and within not less than 1 of each type of room or
space for use in common by the residents, including a
cooking facility, sauna, gymnasium, swimming pool,
common laundry, games room, TV room, individual
shop, dining room, public viewing area, ticket
purchasing service, lunch room, lounge room, or the
like.
Where a ramp complying with AS1428.1 or a passenger
lift is installed—
(a) to the entrance doorway of each sole-occupancy
unit; and
(a) to and within rooms or spaces for use in common
by the residents,
located on the levels served by the lift or ramp.
Class 3
Sole-occupancy units: Not more than 2 required
accessible sole-occupancy units may be located
adjacent to each other.
Class 3 & 9c
Where more than 2 accessible sole-occupancy units are
Page 10 of 45
Trento Fuller Building Certifiers & Consultants Horsham Aquatic Centre - DDA Access Review
Class 7a
Access is required to and within any level containing
accessible carparking spaces.
Class 10a
Non-habitable building located in an accessible area
intended for use by the public and containing a sanitary
facility, change room facility or shelter. To and within
(a) an accessible sanitary facility; and
(a) a change room facility; and
(b) a public shelter or the like.
Class 10b
Swimming pool: To and into swimming pools with a
total perimeter greater than 40 m, associated with a
Class 1b, 2, 3, 5, 6, 7, 8 or 9 building that is required to
be accessible, but not swimming pools for the exclusive
use of occupants of a Class 1b building or a sole-
occupancy unit in a Class 2 or Class 3 building.
Page 11 of 45
Trento Fuller Building Certifiers & Consultants Horsham Aquatic Centre - DDA Access Review
Figure D3.2
Doorways and pedestrian entrances for access purposes
AS1428.1-2009
Part 6 – Continuous Accessible Paths of Travel
Part 7 – Floor or Ground Surfaces on Continuous
Accessible Paths of Travel and Circulation Spaces
Part 12 – Handrails
Part 13 – Doorways, Doors and Circulation Space at
Doors
Page 12 of 45
Trento Fuller Building Certifiers & Consultants Horsham Aquatic Centre - DDA Access Review
In a building required to be accessible— Doors (including double doors) scale less than 850
(a) every ramp and stairway, except for ramps and mm in width. In particular the doors into accessible
stairways in areas exempted by D3.4, must comply change rooms / facilities scales as 800 mm.
with—
i. for a ramp, except a fire-isolated ramp, clause Drainage Grates
10 of AS1428.1; and Some grates were identified on photos. Not know
i. for a stairway, except a fire-isolated stairway, whether the openings comply with requirements (see
clause 11 of AS1428.1; and below).
ii. for a fire-isolated stairway, clause 11.1(f) and (g)
of AS1428.1; and
(a) every passenger lift must comply with E3.6; and
(b) accessways must have—
i. passing spaces complying with AS1428.1 at
maximum 20 m intervals on those parts of an
accessway where a direct line of sight is not
available; and
i. turning spaces complying with AS1428.1—
(A) within 2 m of the end of accessways where
it is not possible to continue travelling along
the accessway; and
(A) at maximum 20 m intervals along the
accessway; and
(d) an intersection of accessways satisfies the spatial
requirements for a passing and turning space; and
(e) a passing space may serve as a turning space; and
(f) a ramp complying with AS1428.1 or a passenger lift
need not be provided to serve a storey or level
other than the entrance storey in a Class 5, 6, 7b or
8 building—
i. containing not more than 3 storeys; and
i. with a floor area for each storey, excluding the
entrance storey, of not more than 200 m2; and
(g) clause 7.4.1(a) of AS1428.1 does not apply and is
replaced with 'the pile height or pile thickness shall
not exceed 11 mm and the carpet backing
thickness shall not exceed 4 mm'; and
(h) the carpet pile height 11 mm, pile thickness
dimension 4 mm, carpet backing thickness
dimension 15 mm.
AS1428.1-2009
Part 6 – Continuous Accessible Paths of Travel
Part 7 – Floor or Ground Surfaces on Continuous
Accessible Paths of Travel and Circulation Spaces
Part 12 – Handrails
Part 13 – Doorways, Doors and Circulation Space at
Doors
Part 14 – Switches and General Purpose Outlets (Power
Points)
Part 17 - Grabrails
Page 13 of 45
Trento Fuller Building Certifiers & Consultants Horsham Aquatic Centre - DDA Access Review
Table D3.5
Carparking spaces for people with a disability
Class of building to which the carpark or carparking
area is associated: Number of accessible carparking
spaces required :
Class 1b and 3
(a) Boarding house, guest house, hostel, house,
backpackers accommodation, or the residential
part of a hotel or motel: To be calculated by
multiplying the total of carparking spaces by the
percentage of
i. accessible sole-occupancy units to the total
number of sole-occupancy units; or
i. accessible bedrooms to the total number of
bedrooms; and the calculated number is to be
taken to the next whole figure.
(a) Residential part of a school, accommodation for the
aged, disabled or children, residential part of a
healthcare building which accommodates members
of staff or the residential part of a detention centre:
1 space for every 100 carparking spaces or part
Class 5,7, 8 or 9c
1 space for every 100 carparking spaces or part thereof
Class 6
(a) Up to 1000 carparking spaces; and thereof: 1
space for every 50 carparking spaces or part
thereof
(a) for each additional 100 carparking spaces or part
thereof in excess of 1000 carparking spaces: 1
space.
Class 9a
(a) Hospital (non-outpatient area): 1 space for every
100 carparking spaces or part thereof
(a) Hospital (outpatient area):
i. up to 1000 carparking spaces: 1 space for every
50 carparking spaces or part and thereof
i. for each additional 100 carparking spaces or
part thereof in excess of 1000 carparking
Page 14 of 45
Trento Fuller Building Certifiers & Consultants Horsham Aquatic Centre - DDA Access Review
spaces: 1 space
(b) Nursing home: 1 space for every 100 carparking
spaces or part thereof
(c) Clinic or day surgery not forming part of a hospital:
1 space for every 50 carparking spaces or part
thereof.
Class 9b Carpark
(a) School: 1 space for every 100 carparking spaces or Total of 94 parks requires two to be accessible.
part thereof
(a) Other assembly building—
i. up to 1000 carparking spaces: 1 space for every
50 carparking spaces or part thereof
i. for each additional 100 carparking spaces or
part thereof in excess of 1000 carparking
spaces: 1 space
Page 15 of 45
Trento Fuller Building Certifiers & Consultants Horsham Aquatic Centre - DDA Access Review
Page 16 of 45
Trento Fuller Building Certifiers & Consultants Horsham Aquatic Centre - DDA Access Review
Table D3.9
Wheelchair seating spaces in Class 9b Assembly
Buildings
Number of fixed seats in a room or space: Number of
wheelchair seating spaces: Group and location
i. Up to 150: 3 spaces: 1 single space; and 1
group of 2 spaces.
i. 151 to 800: 3 spaces; Not less than 1 single
space
ii. plus 1 additional space for each additional 50
seats or part thereof in excess of 150 seats: Not
less than 1 group of 2 spaces; and not more
than 5 spaces in any other group.
iii. 801 to 10,000: 16 spaces; Not less than 2 single
spaces;
iv. plus 1 additional space for each additional 100
seats or part thereof in excess of 800 seats: Not
less than 2 groups of 2 spaces; and not more
Page 17 of 45
Trento Fuller Building Certifiers & Consultants Horsham Aquatic Centre - DDA Access Review
Page 18 of 45
Trento Fuller Building Certifiers & Consultants Horsham Aquatic Centre - DDA Access Review
Page 19 of 45
Trento Fuller Building Certifiers & Consultants Horsham Aquatic Centre - DDA Access Review
5. Lighting Noted
Braille and tactile signs must be illuminated to ensure
luminance contrast requirements are met at all times
during which the sign is required to be read.
6. Braille Noted
The following applies to Braille:
(aaa) Braille must be grade 1 braille
(uncontracted) in accordance with the criteria set
out by the Australian Braille Authority.
(bbb) Braille must be raised and domed.
(ccc) Braille must be located 8 mm below the
bottom line of text (not including descenders).
(ddd) Braille must be left justified.
(eee) Where an arrow is used in the tactile
sign, a solid arrow must be provided for braille
readers.
(fff) On signs with multiple lines of text and characters,
a semicircular braille locator at the left margin must
be horizontally aligned with the first line of Braille
text.
Page 20 of 45
Trento Fuller Building Certifiers & Consultants Horsham Aquatic Centre - DDA Access Review
Figure 5 Noted
Clear swimming pool surround space for sling lift
Page 21 of 45
Trento Fuller Building Certifiers & Consultants Horsham Aquatic Centre - DDA Access Review
Page 22 of 45
Trento Fuller Building Certifiers & Consultants Horsham Aquatic Centre - DDA Access Review
Page 23 of 45
Trento Fuller Building Certifiers & Consultants Horsham Aquatic Centre - DDA Access Review
Table F2.3
Sanitary facilities in Class 3, 5, 6, 7, 8 or 9 buildings
NOTES:
Number: means the number of facilities required.
> : means greater than
Employees: a reference to employees includes owners
and managers using the building.
A reference to "+1/100 (add 1 per 100) or 150, 250, 500"
etc. includes any part of that number.
Page 24 of 45
Trento Fuller Building Certifiers & Consultants Horsham Aquatic Centre - DDA Access Review
Table 2.49(a)
Minimum accessible unisex sanitary compartments to
be provided
Class 1b
(a) Not less than 1; and
(b) where private accessible unisex sanitary
compartments are provided for every accessible
bedroom, common accessible unisex sanitary
compartments need not be provided.
Class 2
Where sanitary compartments are provided in common
areas, not less than 1.
Class 3 and 9c
(a) In every accessible sole-occupancy unit provided
with sanitary compartments within the accessible
sole-occupancy unit, not less than 1; and
(b) at each bank of sanitary compartments containing
male and female sanitary compartments provided
in common areas, not less than 1.
Table 2.49(b)
Minimum accessible unisex showers to be provided
Class 1b
(a) Not less than 1; and
(b) where private accessible unisex showers are
provided for every accessible bedroom, common
accessible unisex showers need not be provided.
Class 2
Where showers are provided in common areas, not less
than 1
Class 3 and 9c
(a) In every accessible sole-occupancy unit provided
with showers within the accessible sole-occupancy
unit, not less than 1; and
Page 25 of 45
Trento Fuller Building Certifiers & Consultants Horsham Aquatic Centre - DDA Access Review
Page 26 of 45
Trento Fuller Building Certifiers & Consultants Horsham Aquatic Centre - DDA Access Review
External
2. Street Furniture & Rubbish Bins Rest Seating & Drinking Fountain
As per the above, rest seating should be provided near
(a) Street furniture should be located along main paths the drop off zone. A drinking fountain would also be of
of travel adjacent to entrances, major crossover some benefit.
areas and no more than 60 metres apart.
(a) Where furniture is provided along a streetscape, all
Page 27 of 45
Trento Fuller Building Certifiers & Consultants Horsham Aquatic Centre - DDA Access Review
3. Carparking Parking
If only 2 accessible carparks are provided there should
Car parking spaces for people with disabilities must be be consideration for a third accessible parking bay
provided as per the following percentiles: keeping in mind the demographics of occupants.
Commercial 1 – 2%
Retail 2 – 3% Signage at the street entrance points should also
Transport 1 – 3% direct vehicles wishing to use the accessible
Community/Recreation 2 – 3% carparking bays to their location.
Education Facilities 2 – 3%
Entertainment 3 – 4%
Medical 3 – 4%
Residential Total number of car
parking spaces x % of
accessible units
Off-street parking
(a) Bollards shall be at least 1300mm in height and
possess a surface 30% luminance contrast to the
Page 28 of 45
Trento Fuller Building Certifiers & Consultants Horsham Aquatic Centre - DDA Access Review
surrounding surfaces.
(a) Appropriate kerb ramps must be provided at the
top of each shared area linking the continuous
accessible path of travel. The kerb ramp may not
encroach on the shared area (refer External Paths
of Travel – Kerb ramp design).
(b) Where parking bays for people with disabilities are
on the opposite side of a traffic thoroughfare a
pedestrian crossing marked in indicative colour
should be installed.
(c) Vertical signage indicating terms of parking in a bay
for people with disabilities incorporating the
international symbol of access. Where vertical
signage is not visible from the carpark entrance,
additional signage indicating the direction of the
parking spaces for people with disabilities must be
provided.
On-street parking
(a) The shared area may be at a higher level than the
dedicated space in which case it shall be separated
by a kerb (150mm high preferred) however the path
of travel must be increased in width to
accommodate kerb ramps and landings (approx
2530mm).
Page 29 of 45
Trento Fuller Building Certifiers & Consultants Horsham Aquatic Centre - DDA Access Review
5. Lighting Carpark
Lighting should be provided adjacent accessible
For external locations a person should be able to move parking bays and the road crossing.
around the designated path of travel with the provision
of consistent lighting that avoids shadows and dark
areas.
Internal
Page 30 of 45
Trento Fuller Building Certifiers & Consultants Horsham Aquatic Centre - DDA Access Review
8. Stairs
(a) Stair treads and nosings must not overhang beyond
the face of the riser. An angled riser with a
maximum set back of 25mm may be provided.
(b) A tread width of 275mm – 300mm and riser height
of 150mm – 165mm is preferred.
Facilities for Children
Where a high proportion of users are children or
adolescents with physical disabilities, dual height
handrails are to be provided.
9. Lifts / Elevators
(a) A through car is the preferred platform type, as a
wheelchair user is not required to reverse to exit the
lift.
(b) Controls to enable independent operation of the
platform controls. That is, key operation not
preferred.
(c) Any operating instructions to be provided with
Braille and tactile features which achieve
appropriate luminance contrast of no less than
30% to the background to which it is viewed.
Page 31 of 45
Trento Fuller Building Certifiers & Consultants Horsham Aquatic Centre - DDA Access Review
Page 32 of 45
Trento Fuller Building Certifiers & Consultants Horsham Aquatic Centre - DDA Access Review
Page 33 of 45
Trento Fuller Building Certifiers & Consultants Horsham Aquatic Centre - DDA Access Review
Page 34 of 45
Trento Fuller Building Certifiers & Consultants Horsham Aquatic Centre - DDA Access Review
15. Accessible Toilets and Showers Change Rooms & Changing Place
The potential for falls in areas subject to wet
Refer to BCA F2.3 and F2.4 for details conditions may result in occupants not being able to
To provide an emergency call push button minimum 25 call for assistance particularly because of sound levels
mm in diameter, located no less than 300 mm and not within the Aquatic Centre. Emergency call buttons
more than 1100 mm above the finish floor level and not should be provided in these rooms and linked to the
less than 500 mm from internal corner, connected to an life guard / first aid room.
audible & visual alarm located outside sanitary facility
and to a point that is continually staffed when building is
occupied.
17. Accommodation
Bedrooms
(a) At least one bedroom should be capable of
accommodating a queen size bed and a wardrobe.
Page 35 of 45
Trento Fuller Building Certifiers & Consultants Horsham Aquatic Centre - DDA Access Review
Page 36 of 45
Trento Fuller Building Certifiers & Consultants Horsham Aquatic Centre - DDA Access Review
Page 37 of 45
Trento Fuller Building Certifiers & Consultants Horsham Aquatic Centre - DDA Access Review
19. Functions Rooms, Halls, Corporate Boxes, Hall, Gymnasium & Creche
Dining Rooms No accessible sanitary facilities are provided for
occupants of the Gymnasium, Hall and Creche noting
(a) Provide appropriate door opening widths into all that sanitary facilities are located nearby for patrons
function rooms, corporate boxes and dining rooms who do not have a disability.
of a minimum of 850mm clear opening.
(b) Appropriate circulation space must be provided at
all manual doors (refer Door mechanisms).
(c) Manual doors must have an operating force of not
more than 19.5N and a swing force of 6N.
(d) Provide appropriate circulation space between
airlock doors of 1350mm unless the doors
encroach into the airlock. Should this be the case
then the distance shall not be less than 1350mm
plus the door width.
(e) Provide a path of travel of a minimum width of
1200mm to all facilities provided within the
Function rooms, Corporate Boxes and Dining
rooms.
(f) Provide accessible unisex toilet facilities adjacent
to all gender facilities within the Function rooms,
Corporate and Dining rooms.
Page 38 of 45
Trento Fuller Building Certifiers & Consultants Horsham Aquatic Centre - DDA Access Review
Page 39 of 45
Trento Fuller Building Certifiers & Consultants Horsham Aquatic Centre - DDA Access Review
Page 40 of 45
Trento Fuller Building Certifiers & Consultants Horsham Aquatic Centre - DDA Access Review
counter edge
(c) Provide the counter face with minimum 30%
luminance contrast with the surrounding floor finish
(d) Provide a hearing augmentation listening system to
the counter, inclusive of appropriate tactile and
Braille signage incorporating the international
symbol for hearing impairment. Where multiple
counters are provided, including one accessible
counter for people with disabilities, a hearing
augmentation listening system should be provided
to service the accessible counter and one high
counter.
(e) Unobstructed sightlines between counter staff and
visitor shall be provided. Therefore any opaque
structures between both parties shall be limited in
height, per the following:
i. 1000mm in height where the staff member is
seated at a standard height (450mm).
i. 1100mm where the staff member is standing or
seated on a high stool.
(f) The staff side of counter areas should be
ergonomically designed in accordance with
occupational health and safety workstation
requirements (refer recommendations for
workstations and reach ranges).
Lighting
Appropriate lighting levels at the counter areas must be
provided. Generally, a task lighting of no less than 320lx
must be provided with environmental lighting of no less
than 160lx. That is:
(a) where general lighting only is provided to provide
both task and environmental lighting, the
illuminance throughout the area shall be no less
than 320lx; or
(b) where a system of local lighting is provided for
tasks in combination with reduced environmental
lighting, this may be provided as noted above.
Page 41 of 45
Trento Fuller Building Certifiers & Consultants Horsham Aquatic Centre - DDA Access Review
Page 42 of 45
Trento Fuller Building Certifiers & Consultants Horsham Aquatic Centre - DDA Access Review
Page 43 of 45
Trento Fuller Building Certifiers & Consultants Horsham Aquatic Centre - DDA Access Review
Page 44 of 45
Trento Fuller Building Certifiers & Consultants Horsham Aquatic Centre - DDA Access Review
Summary Requirements of DDA Access Code / NNC Reference Clauses & Australian Standards:
Continuous Accessible
Part A1 Definitions AS 1428 Part 1-2009; Section 6
Pathways
Sanitary and other facilities F2.4 & Table F2.4 AS 1428 Part 1-2009; Section 15
Page 45 of 45
APPENDIX C
HORSHAM
AQUATIC CENTRE
53 HAMILTON ST, HORSHAM VIC 3400
AUGUST 2017
Contact
HAMES SHARLEY
Saralee Aufderheide
Project Architect
S.Aufderheide@hamessharley.com.au
www.hamessharley.com.au
This report is for the use only of the party to whom it is addressed and Hames Sharley disclaims
responsibility to any third party acting upon or using the whole or part of its contents.
2.0 BENCHMARKING
2.1 WIMMERA REGION
AUGUST 2017 3
Introduction
This report has been prepared by Hames
Sharley for Horsham Rural City Council
and Horsham Aquatic Centre Master Plan
Working Group. The purpose of this report is
Hamilton St
to outline the present and future development
potential of the site at 53 Hamilton Street,
Firebrace St
Horsham, Vic 3400.
Urquhart St
investigations including urban analysis, gap
Oc
al
analysis and a survey of site conditions. This
la
gh
data is then compared with surrounding
an
sP
townships in the Wimmera, through the
de
process of benchmarking. Cameron St
AUGUST 2017 5
1.1 Study Area
LOCATION
Firebrace St
approximately 300 kilometres north-west of Harvey A: 835m2 A: 790m2 A: 802m2 A: 803m2 A: 804m2 A: 805m2 802m2 A: 802m2 A: 839m2 A: 817m2
Melbourne in the heart of the Wimmera region Norman
of Victoria. The municipality has a population of 55 53
19,774 and covers an area of 4,267 km2.
Representing a ‘Recreation and Leisure’ site, 19-18
PP5386
A: 18,168m2
Urquhart St
the Horsham Aquatic Centre is a well used A: 4,357m2
facility with strong membership numbers,
11-18 12-18 13-18 14-18 15-18 16-18 17-18 18-18
that accommodates all users including those PP5386 PP5386 PP5386 PP5386 PP5386 P5386 PP5386 18P5386
who require rehabilitation to restore physical A: 484m2 A: 758m2 A:1,413m2 A: 805m2 A: 478m2 A: 423m2 A: 378m2 A: 686m2
Oc
Statewide YMCA Awards, one of which for
al
la
exceptional customer service, and has as
gh
an
a consequence, seen a significant increase 4
s
Burson
Pd
in young people learning to swim, and local PETstock
Auto Parts 2
e
community members seeking a more active Horsham
and social lifestyle. Country City Cameron St
11 Motor Inn
The Study Area is well serviced by public
transport and accommodates users with off-
street car parking in Bolton Car Park, entered
from Urquhart Street to the east. The primary
frontage and main pedestrian entrance is
from Hamilton Street. Significant landmarks Robertsons
Furniture
surrounding the Study Area are Capital Bistro,
Peach’s Fruit Market, Harvey Norman, Barengi
Gadjin Land Council Aboriginal, PETstock
Horsham, Horsham Botanical Gardens and N
Wimmera River.
20m
Study Area
6 HAMES SHARLEY AUGUST 2017
1.2 Gap Analysis
SERVICES
Emergency
1. Horsham Ambulance Station
2. Vic State Emergency Services Office
14 18
3. Vic State Emergency Services Site
4. Horsham Police Station
5. Country Fire Authority 26 11
6. State Emergency Service - Mid West Region 6 12
23 5 13
Health 10 22
28 4 25
7. Tristar Medical Group
8. Goolum Community Health Centre
Western Hwy
9. Maternal and Child Health Centre 21 9 20
10. Centrelink and Medicare Centre 19 24
11. Wimmera Health Care Group Pynsent St
12. Wimmera Medical Centre
13. Read Street Medical Centre
14. Lister House Medical Clinic Wimmera Hwy
27
Transport
15. Hentry Highway Coach PTY Ltd. Hamilton St
16. VicRoads - Horsham Customer Service Centre 7 8 17
17. Horsham Cycling Track
2
Urquhart St
18. Horsham Railway Station (1.5km north of site)
15 3
1
Community
19. NEXUS (Youth Social Services) 16
20. Horsham Rural City Council
21. EW Tipping Foundation (Disability Support)
22. Wimmera Community Options (Health Club)
Oc
23. Horsham Community Correctional Services
al
la
gh
Religion
an
s
24. Horsham Uniting Church
Pd
25. Catholic Diocese of Ballarat
e
26. Christian Emergency Food Centre
27. Horsham Seventh-day Adventist Church N
Other
28. Australian Post - Horsham Post Office
The Study Area is surrounded by a variety of services such as Horsham Post Office. 100m
Study Area
services, including health services such as Lister There appears to be a gap in religious and
800m /
House Medical Clinic, Emergency services such as community services within 800m/10minutes 10min walk
Horsham Ambulance Station, Transport services walk of the Study Area. 1600m /
such as Hentry Highway Coach, and general 20min walk
AUGUST 2017 7
COMMERCIAL
Entertainment
1. Horsham Visitor Centre
2. Horsham Country Music Festival
3. Centre Cinema Horsham
4. Horsham Town Hall
5. Wesley Performing Arts Centre
6. West Side Horsham (Sports Bar)
5
Home and Office 32
7. Horsham Betta Home Living 40
8. Harvey Norman
Western Hwy
39
9. Aussie Horsham 32 30
33 34 31 29
10. JG King Homes
11. Rural Finance Horsham
37 35 Pynsent St
36 4 3
12. First National Real Estate
6 18
38
13. Reece Plumbing 28
14. Samios Plumbing Supplies Wimmera Hwy
19 17
15. Horsham Lawnmower centre
16. L&H Horsham (Electrical Supply) 27 11 12 10 20 26
21 Hamilton St
17. Horsham Carpet Court 13
22 9 8
18. Wimmera Floorworld Horsham 7 23
19. Wimmera Office Equipment
Urquhart St
Industry 14 16
20. Bunnings Warehouse 15
21. Horsham Bearings & Industrial Supplies
22. Supercheap Auto Horsham 1
23. Horsham Agricultural Society
24. Wilson Bolton Mitsubishi
Oc
25. Wilson Bolton Holden
a
lla
26. Horsham Tyre and Battery Service 2
gh
24
an
25
s
Retail
Pd
e
27. Cheap as Chips
28. Leading Edge Electronics
29. Camera House N
30. Miss Horsham Shop
31. Horsham Menswear
32. Chisholm Hi-Fi & TV Centre 100m
33. Horsham Plaza The Study Area is surrounded by a variety of and Horsham Bearings & Industrial Supplies. Retail Study Area
34. Autograph Fashion commercial options, including entertainment options are limited within 800m/10min of the Study 800m /
35. Cotton On facilities such as the Horsham Cinema, home and Area, but become more abundant to the north-west 10min walk
36. Kmart
37. Spotlight
office options such as Horsham Betta Home Living, of the 1600m catchment, with options of Kmart, 1600m /
20min walk
38. Horsham Gateway Centre and industry options such as Bunnings Warehouse Spotlight and Cotton On at Horsham Plaza.
39. Telstra Shop
40. Showcase Jewellers
8 HAMES SHARLEY AUGUST 2017
HOSPITALITY
Western Hwy
8. The Fig Tree Cafe
Supermarket 19 7 6 33
9. Waack’s Bakery 8 32
41. Aldi 18 5
10. Nourish Eatery
15
42. Woolworths Pynsent St
11. Funkalicious Cakery 38 17 31 3
43. Coles 42 37 1 36
12. The Oven Door Bakery 4 30 2
Wimmera Hwy
13. Cheeky Fox 29
14. Wimmera Cake Centre 35 28 27
26 34
15. Brumby’s Bakery Hamilton St
41
Fast Food / Takeaway
Urquhart St
16. Horsham Charcoal Chicken
25
17. Bonnie and Clyde’s Pizzeria
18. Horsham Palace
19. Jade Lantern 16
20. Tasty Express
21. Subway
Oc
al
22. Domino’s Pizza
la
gh
23. Chicken Express
an
s
24. Damena’s Pizza & Pasta Cafe
Pd
e
Hotel / Bar
25. Country City Motor Inn N
26. Comfort Inn
27. Royal Hotel
100m
28. Locarno Hotel There is an abundance of cafe and restaurant site, and two hotels, the Comfort Inn to the Study Area
29. Bull & Mouth Hotel offerings existing within 800m/10minutes walking north and Country City Motor Inn to the south. 800m /
10min walk
30. Commercial Hotel - Bar 68 distance of the Study Area, with limited offerings There appears to be a gap in juice bars,
31. Exchange Hotel 1600m /
of fast food and fine dining. Of note is the close grocery markets and takeaway stores within 20min walk
32. White Hart Hotel proximity of Aldi supermarket to the west of the the Study Area’s catchment.
33. Horsham House Bed & Breakfast
AUGUST 2017 9
RECREATION AND LEISURE
Passive Recreation
1. Horsham Botanical Gardens
2. Sawyer Park 6 19
3. Wimmera River Reserve
21 32
4. Dog Track 32
20
5. Coughlin Park
6. May Park
7. Horsham Recreation Reserve
7 31 18
Western Hwy
30
8. Horsham Aquatic Centre
9. Fuzion Fitness Horsham 29
Pynsent St
10. Curves Gym Horsham 12 11
11. Anytime Fitness 27 28 5
12. Snap Fitness 23 Wimmera Hwy
17
10
Active Recreation Outdoor
13. Horsham City Oval Hamilton St
14. Horsham City Tennis Courts 26 8 16
15. Horsham Showground
Urquhart St
9
16. Horsham Cycling Track 25
17. St Brigid’s College Sporting Oval
18. St Michaels and John’s Sporting Grounds 24
19. Sunnyside Horsham Bowling Club
1 15
20. Scout & Guide Recreation Reserve 13
14
Oc
21. Central Park Tennis Courts
a lla
22. Horsham Racecourse and Harness Track
gh
4
an
23. Horsham Horse Track 2
s Pd
e
Leisure / Wellness Centre 3
24. Back 4 Life Wellness Centre
N
25. Bubble & Snip Pet Spa & Salon
26. Salon Mode Spa & Beauty
27. Sassie Beauty Bar & Hair There are two recreational open space offering Park to the east. There is an abundance of leisure 100m
Study Area
28. Wimmera Spas & Pools (Horsham Botanical Gardens and Horsham City facilities within 800m/10min walking distance of the
800m /
29. Equipt Physiotherapy Oval) existing within 800m/10min walking distance of Study Area, including Back 4 Life Wellness Centre 10min walk
30. Ella Blache Horsham the Study Area. The variety of offerings increases in and Salon Mode Spa & Beauty. Similarly, there are 1600m /
31. Sirs & Hers Hair Salon the 1600m catchment along Wimmera River. These four indoor active recreation facilities within the 20min walk
32. Amour Beauty Boutique offerings include Sawyer Park to the south, one dog catchment, including Curves Gym, Fuzion Fitness and
33. Horsham Physiotherapy and Podiatry park to the south-east, and a cycling track and Coughlin Anytime Fitness.
10 HAMES SHARLEY AUGUST 2017
EDUCATION + COMMUNITY
Child Care / Early Learning Centre
1. Goodstart Early Learning Horsham 15
9
2. Horsham & District Kindergarten
3. Maternal & Child Health Centres 6 14
4. Roberts Ave Kindergarten 21
5. Horsham Community Child Care Centre 16
6. Horsham ‘Out of School Hours’ Care 8
13 6
7. Wimmera Uniting Care
Western Hwy
Primary School 20 3 4
12 5
8. St Michael and John’s Primary School Pynsent St
9. Horsham Primary School
19
Secondary School Wimmera Hwy
10. St Brigid’s College 18
10
Community Centre Hamilton St
11. Horsham Aquatic Centre 11 17
22
12. Nexus Youth Social Services 1
Urquhart St
13. Horsham Rural City Council
14. Horsham Sports & Community Club
15. Wimmera Community Care
Library
16. Wimmera regional Library Corporation
Oc
2
al
la
Training Facility
gh
an
17. Australian Institute of Personal Trainers
s Pd
18. Wimmera Huh Inc
e
19. Advanced Career Training
20. Sureway Employment and Training N
21. MEGT Horsham
22. Wimmera Business Centre There are moderate education and community options John’s Primary) and one secondary school (St 100m
Study Area
within 800m/10min of the Study Area. These include Brigid’s College). There appears to be a gap in online
800m /
three training facilities, two community centres and three learning centres and physical learning centres such 10min walk
child care / early learning centres. Options expand to the as libraries. Similarly, with the close proximity of St 1600m /
20min walk
north of the Study Area within 1600m/20min walking Michael and John’s Primary and St Brigid’s College,
distance, however, there are still limited education there may be potential to host off-site educational
offerings with only one primary school (St Michael and activities within the Study Area.
AUGUST 2017 11
1.3 Community Profile
Warracknabeal
COMMUNITY ANALYSIS Buy: $117,500
Rent: $175 PW
In order to gain an understanding of the existing
and potential future demographic of the Study Nhill
Buy: $129,750
Area, Horsham has been examined using the Rent: $200 PW
ABS 2011 census data and Realestate Australia
property prices.
AUGUST 2017 13
2011
363 NEW
OCCUPANCIES
r e s i d e n t i a l
p o p u l a t i o n
Donald IN DWELLINGS
1,693 10-14
2.3
IN HORSHAM
2006
Edenhope
2.1 976 50-54
h o u s e h o l d
Horsham
g r o u p
2.3 14,285 0-4 DENSITY
2011
Nhill Mean gross occupied dwellings (per km)
2.3 2,278 50-54
for the Horsham Rural City Council
a g e
1.8
p e r
Stawell
2.3 6,150
l a r g e s t
60-64
p e r s o n s
Western Hwy
Surrounding the Study Area is a mixture
CC Pynsent St
of Medium Density Commercial, which
increases in density along Hamilton Street,
Ocallaghans Parade, Wimmera Highway and Wimmera Hwy
the Western Highway. 800m to the south and
south-east of the Study Area are reserves and
public open space along Wimmera River, and Hamilton St
to the south-west is low to medium density
residential areas.
Urquhart St
The township’s Commercial Centre is to
the north of the site along Firebrace Street
and Darlot Street, with Neighbourhood
Centres located along major intersections
NC
with Western Highway, Wimmera Highway,
Oc
Firebrace Street / Ocallaghans Parade and
all
ag
Urquhart Street.
ha
ns
Pd
r
e
Rive
era
mm
Wi N
100m
Study Area
800m /
10min walk
1600m /
20min walk
AUGUST 2017 15
CONNECTIVITY:- ROAD HIERARCHY,
CYCLE AND PEDESTRIAN NETWORKS
Urquhart St
Firebrace St
easy access to the Western Highway north-
south corridor (via Hamilton Street), eastern
districts (via the Western Highway to Baillie
Street), northern and southern districts (via
the Western Highway) and western districts
(via Hamilton Street).
Pynsent St
On-road shoulder bike lanes are limited
surrounding the Study Area, with lanes only
appearing on Wimmera Highway and Western Wimmera Hwy
Highway in areas near the township’s centre.
Western Hwy
Primary Arterial Road
Oc
Primary Arterial Road with Bike Lane
all
ag
ha
Secondary Arterial Road
ns
Pd
e
Secondary Arterial Road with Bike Lane
Secondary Road N
1600m /
20min walk
Western Hwy
Additionally, Horsham Airport is located 7.1 Pynsent St
Urquhart St
Hamilton St
Oc
1600m /
al
the Study Area
la
20min walk
gh
2
an
Horsham -
sP
Train Line
de
Natimuk Rd
(Route 5)
Airport N
Horsham -
Haven (Route 6) 100m
AUGUST 2017 17
PUBLIC REALM:
SURROUNDING POINTS OF INTEREST
Western Hwy
5. Horsham Agricultural Society
6. Horsham Visitor Centre
11 Pynsent St
Key features within a 20 minute walk / 4
1600 metre distance from the Study Area:
Wimmera Hwy
7. Horsham Showgrounds
13
8. Sawyer Park 3
9. Wimmera River Hamilton St
10. Horsham Riverside Caravan Park 2 5
11. Horsham Plaza
Urquhart St
12. Wesley Performing Arts Centre
13. St Brigid’s College and Sporting Grounds
1 6
7
Oc
al
la
gh
8
an
s Pd
e
10 9
N
100m
Points of interest to the west of the Study Area and Wimmera River. Points of interest to the east Study Area
include Aldi Shopping Centre, Harvey Norman and include the Urquhart Street Commercial District 800m /
Salon Mode Spa and Beauty. To the south is the and the Horsham Showgrounds, and to the north 10min walk
Ocallaghans Parade Commercial District, which is the township’s Community and Commercial 1600m /
20min walk
leads to Horsham Botanical Gardens, Sawyer Park Centre, bordered by the Western Highway.
AUGUST 2017 19
2.1 Benchmarking
WIMMERA REGION Horsham Aquatic Edenhope Aquatic Centre Ballarat Aquatic & Bendigo Aquatic Warracknabeal
Building Facilities Centre / Sports Stadium Lifestyle Centre Centre Leisure Centre
This section of township facilities within and in
close proximity to the Wimmera region, has Swimming Pool
been benchmarked against Horsham Aquatic - Outdoor / Seasonal 50m 25m 50m
Centre to highlight key opportunities to explore.
- Heated / Leisure Solar
The earlier appraisal of the current condition - Lap / Diving Pool 25m 50m 50m 50m
of Horsham’s existing facilities and conditions - Spa 24 Seat
should be considered together with this picture - Kids Pool
of provision.
- Water Slide
Swimming Classes
Adjacent Sports facilities Basketball, Netball,
Adjacent Squash and
Sport Court Surfaces including Alexandra Hockey, Soccer,
Soccer Courts hired out
Croquet Club and Volleyball, Squash,
through Edenhope College
Ballarat Hockey Centre Cricket, Badminton
Steam Room
Health Club
Gymnasium Adjacent Stadium hired out
through Edenhope College
Cycle Studio
Fitness Rooms / Classes
2 x Studios
Change Rooms
Toilets
Creche / Child Care
Eateries (cafe, restaurant)
Outdoor BBQ Area
Function Space
Car Parking
Educational Program in
collaboration with Schools
Land Size (approx.) 1.8 ha 0.4 ha 2.9 ha 1.1 ha 0.6 ha
1
1
1
1
2
N
AUGUST 2017 21
SMALL TOWNSHIP FACILITIES
Outdoor Swimming Pool, Dimboola: Outdoor Swimming Pool, Hopetoun: Lowan Sports Centre & Swimming Pool, Nhill:
Facilities include a solar heated 50m, six lane Facilities include a seasonal solar heated 25m The sports centre is located directly adjacent
pool, toddlers pool, shaded picnic areas, showers outdoor pool, with a wading pool to cater for Nhill College, servicing the school and local
and locker rooms. younger children and open picnic space. community. The facility offers badminton,
basketball, a gymnasium, squash and a solar
Health and Fitness Centre, Dimboola: Hopetoun Gymnasium, Hopetoun: heated outdoor pool. The pool area offers a play
pool, lap pool and shaded picnic area.
The Centre is a modern, multi-purpose complex The recently opened faculty offers a range of
opened in 2012. Facilities include a fully equipped cardio equipment including treadmills, bikes, x Outdoor Swimming Pool, St Arnaud:
gym, a synthetic sports field with competition trainers and rowers as well as machine weights
standard lighting for night play, a versatile function and free weights Facilities include a seasonal, seven-lane, 50m
room along with two change rooms, separate solar heated pool, toddlers’ wading pool, one
umpires’ room and well equipped kitchen. Salon Mode Spa and Beauty, Horsham: metre diving board and three metre diving board.
Additionally, there is shaded seating and open
Kowree Sports Centre, Edenhope: The facility offers treatments such as facials,
lawn space for picnics and barbecues.
massages, waxing, make up, tanning, pregnancy
The facility offers badminton, basketball, massage, body, hand, foot and skin treatments. Health and Fitness Centre, St Arnaud:
gymnasium, squash, swimming with solar
heated outdoor pool. Equip Physiotherapy, Horsham: Facilities include a fully equipped gym with
change rooms and toilets.
Outdoor Swimming Pool, Goroke: The facility is a private physiotherapy practice
providing high quality, hands-on service, covering Outdoor Swimming Pool, Warracknabeal:
Facilities include a seasonal solar heated 25m a wide range of health and wellbeing issues.
outdoor pool, with a wading pool to cater for Facilities include a seasonal solar heated outdoor
younger children. Kanvia Memorial Swimming Pool, Kanvia: Olympic Pool, with a wading pool to cater for
younger children and open picnic space.
Facilities include a seasonal, solar heated
outdoor pool, with spacious grounds for seating
and barbecues. Open from November to March.
No. Up %
Trade : 1 NEW INDOOR WORKS ADJACENT INDOOR POOL, PROGRAM LEISURE POOL, RAMP
WIDENING
1 Outdoor function area 48.00 m2 625.00 30,000.00
2 Parent change rooms 81.00 m2 2,350.00 190,350.00
3 Spa & Sauna area 42.00 m2 1,190.48 50,000.00
4 Accessible WC 17.00 m2 2,500.00 42,500.00
5 Widen & extend existing ramp to accommodate Item 10,000.00
mobility scooter turning etc
NEW INDOOR WORKS ADJACENT INDOOR POOL, PROGRAM LEISURE POOL, Total : 322,850.00
RAMP WIDENING
No. Up %
Trade : 2 PLAYGROUND
1 Allowance for creating new playground area including Item 200,000.00
play equipment
PLAYGROUND Total : 200,000.00
No. Up %
Trade : 1 Indoor Works to Corridor, Kiosk, Reception, Office, Accessible change, Scooter Charge,
Storeroom, including Hydro Pool, equipment, plant room etc
1 Indoor Works to Corridor, Kiosk, Reception, Office, 268.00 m2 1,250.00 335,000.00
Accessible change, Hydro Pool, Scooter Charge,
Storeroom
2 Hydro Pool Plant Room 50.00 m2 1,000.00 50,000.00
3 Allowance for Hydro Pool incl. enclosure, single tier 1.00 Item 327,000.00 327,000.00
seating, etc
Indoor Works to Corridor, Kiosk, Reception, Office, Accessible change, Scooter Charge, Total : 712,000.00
Storeroom, including Hydro Pool, equipment, plant room etc
No. Up %
No. Up %
No. Up %
Net Costs Figures Design Contractor's Locality Construction Total Budget Total Budget OOC
SECTION Total Excl GST 10% GST
rounded Contingency Preliminaries Allowance Contingency OOC excl GST incl GST
Outdoor Function Area 30,000 4,500 4,140 3,864 6,376 48,880 48,880 4,888 53,768
Parent Change Rooms 190,500 28,575 26,289 24,536 40,485 310,385 310,385 31,039 341,424
SPA & Sauna Area 50,000 7,500 6,900 6,440 10,626 81,466 81,466 8,147 89,613
Accessible WC 42,500 6,375 5,865 5,474 9,032 69,246 69,246 6,925 76,171
Ramp Extension & Widening 10,000 1,500 1,380 1,288 2,125 16,293 16,293 1,629 17,923
STAGE 2 WORKS TOTAL 323,000 48,450 44,574 41,602 68,644 526,270 526,270 52,627 578,897
STAGE 2A WORKS
Waterplay and Splash Park area 700,000 105,000 96,600 90,160 148,764 1,140,524 1,140,524 114,052 1,254,576
Demolish existing pools 30,000 4,500 4,140 3,864 6,376 48,880 48,880 4,888 53,768
Hoist to Hydro Pool 20,000 3,000 2,760 2,576 4,250 32,586 32,586 3,259 35,845
Canopy over SplashPark 195,500 29,325 26,979 25,180 41,548 318,532 318,532 31,853 350,385
STAGE 2A WORKS TOTAL 1,145,500 171,825 158,079 147,540 243,442 1,866,386 1,866,386 186,639 2,053,025
Hydro Pool Complete 347,000 52,050 47,886 44,694 73,744 565,374 565,374 56,537 621,911
-
Hydro Pool Plant Room 50,000 7,500 6,900 6,440 10,626 81,466 81,466 8,147 89,613
-
Tilt Up Glass Doors 60,000 9,000 8,280 7,728 12,751 97,759 97,759 9,776 107,535
-
Other Areas 335,000 50,250 46,230 43,148 71,194 545,822 545,822 54,582 600,404
STAGE 3 WORKS TOTAL 791,700 118,800 109,296 102,010 168,316 1,290,421 1,290,421 129,042 1,419,464
Landscaping 219,300 32,895 30,263 28,246 46,606 357,310 357,310 35,731 393,041
-
Pool Shade Structure 367,200 55,080 50,674 47,295 78,037 598,286 598,286 59,829 658,115
STAGE 4 WORKS TOTAL 586,500 87,975 80,937 75,541 124,643 955,596 955,596 95,560 1,051,156
NOTES:
Exclusions: The following are excluded from this estimate
Costs for Upgrading of existing power supply or transformer;
Professional Fees and Disbursements;
Council costs;
Legal costs.
APPENDIX F
- No wheel chair change room big enough or hoist a spa and sauna could be useful
- Addition, revamp of outdoor areas. Additional entry/ exit for pool users.
- Access to the outdoor pool without having to go through the main building
- 1. Contrast on floor finishes, better use of tactile indictors 2. Lighting around the pool needs to
be considered (DDA compliance)
- 1. Hydrotherapy pool to be included for people with disabilities 2. More staffing around the
pool
- Hydrotherapy pool is a must, can also be used for children to learn to swim
- 1. Requires a Rehabilitation Pool 2. Leisure pool is not sufficient 3. Acute needs are not catered
for
- Hydrotherapy pool to be included for people with disabilities 2. More staffing around the pool
- improvement outdoor pool area and a good music system for the water aerobics, some ladies
would not be able to hear the music at the present time
- Outdoor pool needs to be made deeper at shallow end, heating in outdoor pool needs to
improve and permanent shade structures need to be erected.
- Large sized impressive outdoor water splash park. Outdoor 50m pool to be completely
refurbished and modernised including options to heat via solar.
- Fix and modernise outdoor 50 m pool, add a playground, install two spiral water slides
(different heights)
REPORT TITLE
P R O J E C T N A M E
-
- Indoor area around 25 pool be extended to enable tiered seating for spectators to encourage
the use of the pool for sports, events, games and swim meets
- Larger indoor pools, tiered seating, indoor water play/features for children, expansion of
fitness rooms and better toilet and change facilities. Expansion and upgrade overall
- Fix and modernise outdoor 50 m pool, add a playground, install two spiral water slides
(different heights)
- More aquatic play equipment - slides etc, suitable for older children/ teens
- Install a water slide to bring the teenagers to the pool instead of river
- Horsham is a hub for the region and its climate is hot over Summer it would be great to have
splashdowns slides and a spa or 2 would be great too. For the size of our city and distance
from beach I think we should have the latest facilities. There are great facilities at Waurn
Ponds in Geelong and suburbs throughout Melbourne.
- More aquatic play equipment - slides etc, suitable for older children/ teens
- No. Indoor splash park, water slides. Aquanation in Ringwood is good example.
- Create a great family vibe on weekends over summer in the outdoor pool area. Open in the
evenings on the weekend, activities in the 50m pool, BBQ's, live music/DJ's to create a 'party
atmosphere' for teens, a playground is great, bring back 'night swimming' occasionally (there
used to be lights in the 50m pool)
- More family areas for eating, longer hours for accessibility after hours. Would benefit from
greater flexibility in family areas.
- Make the outdoor pool more appealing for families. Add a playground, outdoor kiosk and
more shade
1 of 7
- Some of the master plan addresses this. Outdoor water play, more shaded areas, better
opening hours, needs to be more flexible around opening later into evenings when it is hot.
Create a family hangout atmosphere during the hot summer evenings. Better pool surrounds
creates better supervision of swimmers. Warmer water in the outdoor pool. Not hot, just more
inviting.
- Non-tokenistic infrastructure to promote summer fun at the outdoor pool. There are kids
swimming in the river. Why? Swing ropes, big jumps etc. Better to have them in a better
environment.
- would be great to have more outside in the way of picnic tables, water play area, bbqs to
make the most of the hot summer nights. These are nice things and not imperative but it
would be great for this facility to be better suited to family picnics on warm nights.
- Make the outdoor pool more appealing for families. Add a playground, outdoor kiosk and
more shade
- More children’s facilities, better crèche for parents to access gym/pool. Proper kiosk so we
can purchase lunch etc there to avoid having to leave if we come down for the day.
- Make the outdoor pool more appealing for families. Add a playground, outdoor kiosk and
more shade
- Splash park needs to be bigger and the largest investment and a large development of an
impressive 'regional best ever nature' including a large water slide similar to Bendigo. It will
also act as a tourism drawcard for the entire Wimmera Mallee region as well as western
highway travellers bringing an economic boost to the city and act as another tick to encourage
new residents to the city and new users of the facility. If done properly and an impressive
scale it will be a social and economic winner. Too small and it will get boring real quick.
- The baby pools need to be opened so parents can be with their younger and older children.
- Update the 2 small pools outside and create more shade with new trees on this area around
these pools and the 50m pool. Bring back the diving board at the 10ft end.
- Larger indoor pools, tiered seating, indoor water play/features for children, expansion of
fitness rooms and better toilet and change facilities. Expansion and upgrade overall
- No. Indoor splash park, water slides. Aquanation in Ringwood is good example.
- Cater more to swimming clubs. We want to encourage swimming as an elite sport in his
district, but we have nowhere to do that.
2 of 7
- It needs to be on par with other centers so as to enable hosting of majors comps (such as the
countries in Jan) which would bring revenue into the district for swimming clubs and
businesses.
- Competition standard outdoor 50m pool
- 5. Move the ramp outside the 8 lanes of the outdoor pool
- Fix and modernise outdoor 50 m pool, add a playground, install two spiral water slides
(different heights)
- It really does need to be 8 lanes, deep enough for competitive diving at both ends, and be a
wetdeck in order to comply with swimming Victoria's requirement for a championship event
pool.
- No the loss of an eighth lane in the outdoor pool is problematic for swim comps. The depth of
the pools are problematic (too shallow), insufficient shade.
- I like the proposed changes provided - however a few things need to be considered. The
access ramp being added will reduce this 8 lane pool to 7 lanes for swim meets. The pool
depth at the shallow end needs to be increased to 1.2 metres as a minimum to allow dive
entry for events at swim meets. The marshalling area needs to be wider to meet the width of
the pool. The proposed right hand side of marshalling area needs to be the same as the
proposed left hand side. Permanent shade structures need to be erected over marshalling
and seating areas. These modifications would make this facility up to the standard which
would be required to host Victorian LC Country Championships which would bring in huge
financial benefits to the region. If the access ramp is put in then Wimmera District 12 would
have no hope of hosting such an event with just 7 lanes and no diving at the shallow end.
-
- Trampolines in the outdoor area for additional fitness and recreational choices
- More activities for young people, like beach volleyball courts outside and maybe other fun
activities like in some of the caravan parks- there is a bouncy ground thing too and
playground equipment
- Trampolines
- Something like beach volleyball but I like the bbq area and playground. Must keep the outdoor
pool.
- An outdoor play area that includes beach volleyball, badminton, totem tennis etc would be
fun, not just formal volley ball. The toilets and change rooms are fine for current usage.
Having used the family disability rooms the only issue is lack of dry seat bench and clothes
hooks. It would be a nightmare having 3 kids in there... just some basic thought put into the
how do people use the area rather than total remodelling
- More casual outdoor activities like Croquet, quoits mini golf... anything that encourages a
longer stay. I wouldn't call it volleyball, so whilst I've put volleyball as important... I'm meaning
a variety of activities. I'm not sure that a community lounge would work, unless it is more
incorporated into the cafe area.
- 24 hour gym in order to compete with other gyms in Horsham and create more business
3 of 7
- 1. RPM rooms is not large enough 2. Requires some type of outdoor PT Space 3. 24hr
access to the Gym
- 1. RPM rooms needs to be larger, maybe with tiered bikes 3. Add consulting rooms for allied
health to the bottom of the site 6. 24/7 Gym
- Larger indoor pools, tiered seating, indoor water play/features for children, expansion of
fitness rooms and better toilet and change facilities. Expansion and upgrade overall
-
Changerooms / Showers / Toilets upgrades (9)
- An update on the outside is definitely due, the proposed plan looks good. My only thought
was as a mother of a toddler that used to attend swimming lessons there on a weekly basis,
is that either a few more showers be installed in the parents room or they still have a change
table in the male and female bathrooms as most of the parents take their kids in for a rinse off
and then dress them after swimming lessons
- More change rooms for when dads take young children swimming- family change areas
- 1. Upgrading the showers in the female toilets, curtains are not acceptable. Using cubicles. 2.
Upgrading the change rooms 3. Replace all curtains with doors. 4. Adding hooks to the
change rooms for towels.
- Larger indoor pools, tiered seating, indoor water play/features for children, expansion of
fitness rooms and better toilet and change facilities. Expansion and upgrade overall
-
Spa / Sauna (7)
- Spa/sauna, bigger warm pool as often go with kids but can have multiple classes going and
can access pool very well if not involved
- Horsham is a hub for the region and its climate is hot over Summer it would be great to have
splashdowns slides and a spa or 2 would be great too. For the size of our city and distance
from beach I think we should have the latest facilities. There are great facilities at Waurn
Ponds in Geelong and suburbs throughout Melbourne.
- No wheel chair change room big enough or hoist a spa and sauna could be useful
- Spa/sauna
- Spa and slides. Check out other leisure centres for ideas too.
4 of 7
- Add a spa, sauna, water slides
- No. Add a spa and a sauna/steam room.
Shade (8)
- Outdoor pool needs to be made deeper at shallow end, heating in outdoor pool needs to
improve and permanent shade structures need to be erected.
- Outdoor shade req
- Update the 2 small pools outside and create more shade with new trees on this area around
these pools and the 50m pool. Bring back the diving board at the 10ft end.
- Make the outdoor pool more appealing for families. Add a playground, outdoor kiosk and
more shade
- Some of the master plan addresses this. Outdoor water play, more shaded areas, better
opening hours, needs to be more flexible around opening later into evenings when it is hot.
Create a family hangout atmosphere during the hot summer evenings. Better pool surrounds
creates better supervision of swimmers. Warmer water in the outdoor pool. Not hot, just more
inviting
- More shaded outdoor grassed areas- we don't need to fry ourselves. And some passive pool
heating outdoor pool.....pool soooo... cold once weather changes...use all year!!!
- 1. Shade over the outdoor door is a great idea
- Grass area, lack of potential for burnt feet on scalding summer days
- Shade in the car park and entrance.
- outdoor shaded spaces and seating
- More shaded outdoor grassed areas- we don't need to fry ourselves. And some passive pool
heating outdoor pool.....pool soooo... cold once weather changes...use all year!!!
- Some of the master plan addresses this. Outdoor water play, more shaded areas, better
opening hours, needs to be more flexible around opening later into evenings when it is hot.
Create a family hangout atmosphere during the hot summer evenings. Better pool surrounds
creates better supervision of swimmers. Warmer water in the outdoor pool. Not hot, just more
inviting
Other suggestions
- Keep up with technology, social media and top quality equipment and services
- I believe this centre has the scope to include more water activity for all aged children - eg
water slide for older and improved area for toddlers. I also believe that the dance hall could be
used for more older adult’s activities, and perhaps could also include activities for those with
other disabilities. I noticed that there were some activities listed on the Horsham Indoor
Sports Stadium survey, that I believe should be kept at the Aquatic Centre for a number of
reasons. Pryme mover membership could include additional activities making additional
activities affordable for older adults, things like "chance to dance", tai Chi Quigong, walking to
music, etc. The Aquatic Centre is central to town, has central access for those with gophers,
and walking. I also believe that the membership rules/costs could be improved to encourage
more membership. Eg pryme movers often go away on extended holidays, but suspension of
membership without cost is only for 30 days - I cancelled my membership due to this and
know others who also have. I would really like to see something like "happy hour" with an
applicable "low rate" which would be from say 3.45-4.45 for an after school swim -
grandparents/parents could bring children after school for some exercise and if it was
affordable. I looked into doing this with my grandchildren and it was going to cost me $18 a
visit - so obviously I didn't bring them. If community members see something as "great value"
they are more likely to take up the offer. Maybe even have "monthly advertised specials" that
would encourage people to trial a certain activity or area to expose them to it, then a
membership offer at the conclusion of the month.
5 of 7
Too much (2)
- The new proposal I feel is an over estimate of what is required. Do some landscaping and fix
the 2 small pools outside and we're done. Why after a new building gets put in do we have to
widen the access ramp? Should this not be thought of already. I don't believe all of what is
proposed is needed. Who will pay for this? How much is the total cost (accurate cost)?
Horsham ratepayers cannot afford to cover this when we are all still paying for the town hall.
Our rates are extremely high compared to other municipalities, where is the funding coming
from?
- The long ramp entry into the outdoor pool seems a huge effort for very limited use when the
indoor pools have this access. The level of disability that requires that length of access ramp
would also require a warm water pool. The two requirements essentially cancel each other
out. Short ramp entry around the current step entry extended should suffice instead of taking
up a whole lane. Once you are in about 60cm of water you are floating, even if you are
entering via a wheelchair, so there should be no need for a long ramp.
- Plan looks great - very loud & difficult with sound sensitive child
- Child Care Store: This is currently used by the Hall exercise classes, where would their
equipment go? The proposed accessible pool ramp intrudes on the 8 lane pool, for swim
meets (the only one with 8 lanes in the wimmera area), the marshalling area needs to cover
the width of the pool area
6 of 7
APPENDIX G
Question 1.
(personal details)
3400
10%
3401
2% 5000
3392
3409
14%
3402
3381
68%
3373
3377
Unknown
Question 2.
During the previous 12 months, how often have you used the Horsham Aquatic
Centre?
Response Response
Answer Options
Percent Count
Never 12.6% 12
0-5 20.0% 19
5-10 8.4% 8
10-15 9.5% 9
15-20 4.2% 4
20 - over 45.3% 43
answered question 95
skipped question 3
Question 3.
What is the main reason you attended the Horsham Aquatic Centre?
Response Response
Answer Options
Percent Count
Indoor Pools 74.2% 66
External 50m Pool 38.2% 34
Gymnasium 16.9% 15
Fitness Activities (excluding pools) 19.1% 17
Child Care 2.2% 2
School, Club or organised Events 13.5% 12
Rehabilitation or Therapy 4.5% 4
Other (please specify) 20.2% 18
answered question 89
skipped question 9
Question 4.
Please comment on the level of accessibility (for each of the following options) of the Horsham
Aquatic Centre in meeting your needs?
Opening Hours
7%
5% 5%
90%
Access by foot into the building
5%
5%
90%
7%
11%
OK/ meets needs
Needs improvement
N/A
82%
26%
OK/ meets needs
Needs improvement
8% N/A
66%
Question 5. Please comment on the suitability of the facilities at the Horsham Aquatic Centre in
meeting your needs?
0% 22%
OK
N/A
57% Needs improvement
21%
OK
5%
0% 21%
N/A
25%
Needs improvement
OK
13% 9%
0% N/A
Needs improvement
28% 34%
Should be re-opened
20%
0%
OK
12% N/A
Needs improvement
68%
15%
0%
OK
N/A
27% 58% Needs improvement
MAIN GYM
11%
0%
42% OK
N/A
Needs improvement
47%
FITNESS ROOMS
18%
0%
42% OK
N/A
Needs improvement
40%
RECEPTION / ENTRY
22% 0%
OK
4% N/A
Needs improvement
74%
KIOSK
14%
0%
OK
16%
N/A
Needs improvement
70%
TOILETS & AMENITIES
0%
OK
43%
N/A
55%
Needs improvement
2%
CAR PARK
19%
0%
0% OK
N/A
Needs improvement
81%
0%
42% OK
43%
N/A
Needs improvement
15%
CHILD CARE
4%
17%
0%
OK
N/A
Needs improvement
79%
Question 6
Overall, would you say that the Horsham Aquatic Centre is meeting the needs of the community?
Rating Response
Answer Options 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 Average Count
1 2 4 5 11 16 18 13 4 4 6.33 78
answered question 78
skipped question 20
.....................
Questions 7, 8 and 10 are written response questions. Please refer separate attachment.
....................
Question 9