Mine 2019: Resourcing The Future
Mine 2019: Resourcing The Future
Mine 2019: Resourcing The Future
www.pwc.com/mine
Shifting
expectations
Welcome to our annual review of futures markets, not present markets. And Copper and battery metals, which stand to
global trends in the mining industry, when investors and other stakeholders gain as the energy mix moves away from
as represented by the Top 40 mining look at the future of the mining industry, combustion engines to electricity including
companies by market capitalisation. it is clear they have concerns about the renewable energy, are receiving the bulk
industry’s perception on vital issues such of capital investment. (However, as coal
Judged by traditional metrics, things are as safety, the environment, technology and contributes 38% to global electricity
looking good for the world’s top miners. consumer engagement. generation, it remains an important part
In 2018, the world’s 40 largest miners of the basket and continues to receive
consolidated the stellar performance In spite of the strong operating substantial capital investment and
of 2017. As a group, they increased performance, both investors and transaction focus.)
production, boosted cash flow, paid down consumers seem to be down on the brand
debt, and provided returns to shareholders of mining. They question whether the Mining companies are also streamlining
at near record highs. And there was still industry can responsibly create sustainable their operating portfolio by disposing of
cash left to increase capital expenditure value for all stakeholders. Discrete events, non-core assets and optimising project
for the first time in five years. All while such as safety or environmental incidents, portfolios in line with long-term strategies.
delivering significant value to stakeholders have contributed to these challenges. In 2018 and early 2019, a key focus of
like employees, governments and merger activity among the Top 40 was
communities, as well as supplying the raw consolidation in the gold sector. It remains
materials underpinning global economic
growth. The benefits of mining have
‘Big questions’ to critical that potential acquirers evaluate
their strategic options before taking action,
flowed far and wide. address but we may see further transactions to
drive efficiencies and improve productivity.
Yet investors seemed unimpressed,
But far-reaching structural changes in
at least judging by market returns and
the environment – and in the operating
valuations. What accounts for this
environment – are also raising questions
discrepancy? Stock markets are famously
about the industry’s future. Foremost
among them is the impact of climate
change, highlighted by the rising frequency
of extreme weather events. As the
finder and provider of carbon-based
raw materials in the form of coal and
a substantial creator of CO2 emissions
via mining and metals processing, the
mining industry is firmly involved in the
climate change debate. The Top 40
response is varied: some have adopted
a climate change strategy and others are
seemingly indifferent.
Financial capital
Market cap
as at 31 December 2018 $757bn (down by 18%), M&A activity up to $30bn
as at 30 April 2019 $849bn
Manufactured capital
Costs up by 8.6% driven largely Capex up for first time in five years by
Modest growth in production
by commodity-based input costs 12% to $57bn
Steady but
the heat is on
The Top 40 continued to see steady
growth in revenue and profitability,
Figure 1: Top 40 mining companies performance trends ($bn)
as predicted in our forecast last year.
800 250
Dividends to shareholders are at an all-
time high and balance sheets are strong.
Capital expenditure showed an increase 700
100
0 0
2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019*
Trade sanctions
against Russia, Iran
Ongoing Brexit
uncertainty
9%
6%
9%
7%
6%
9%
12% 9% China abolishes presidential term
6% India: auction of new coal limits in 2018
46% 8%
and other mineral mines are
behind schedule and 14%
9% Philippines: new
possible supply disruptions
regulations restricting
as a result 8% mining activities
15%
increases
120
In 2018, revenue increased 8% with most
commodities experiencing increased
Index value
average prices for the year. The decreases 100
in prices towards the end of 2018 reflected
the economic uncertainty at the time and
the evident pressure on economic growth. 80
40
Jan 17 Mar 17 May 17 Jul 17 Sep 17 Nov 17 Jan 18 Mar 18 May 18 Jul 18 Sep 18 Nov 18 Jan 19 Mar 19
Index Coal Index Copper Index Gold Index Iron Ore Index Nickel Base Metal Index
consumer
sentiment and the 2018
Coal Iron Ore
commodity mix of
23%
28%
2006
Over half of the Top 40 produce copper, Coal remains the largest revenue- Mine and plant closures in China, driven
either as a primary metal or as a by- or co- generating commodity, supporting 38% of by environmental concerns, supported
product. These producers are responsible global electricity generation. Top 40 coal demand for seaborne coal and iron ore
for ~55% of global copper production. production has increased despite the sell- and therefore increased the price in
Year on year copper production grew off of coal assets by some. Glencore and 2017. In 2018, the increase in iron ore
almost 7% for the Top 40, as companies Yangzhou acquired Rio Tinto’s remaining production caught up with demand and
responded to higher copper demand. coal assets in Australia. prices are expected to flatten over time.
In general, copper producers forecast a Top 40 production of iron ore increased
decline in 2019 production, as declining Coal offtake agreements are often not at as Australian and Brazilian producers
grades and higher costs make it difficult spot, explaining the difference between expanded mines. However, the tragic
to meet demand and new projects are not revenue and price growth. Many parts of tailings dam collapse at Brumadinho has
able to come online fast enough to avoid the world — e.g. China, India and South cut back supply in the first half of 2019.
a supply deficit. Inventory levels are at ten- East Asia — are expected to continue to
year lows, but this is not yet reflected in use coal to meet primary energy needs. The
the copper price. above average economic growth in these
countries suggests that the coal demand
will continue in the near to medium term.
In the long term, renewable energy
will reshape the energy mix and coal
consumption is expected to plateau
from 2023*. *IEA, Coal 2018
Impairments
Impairment provisions were unexpected
and substantial at $12bn. Impairments
were mostly transaction related and
regulatory induced. The impairments
of Goldcorp ($4.7bn) and BHP Billiton
($3.1bn) became evident through
transactions, with sale prices being
less than carrying amounts. Glencore’s
impairment ($1.6bn) related to copper Change
assets in the Democratic Republic $bn 2019 Outlook 2018 2017
(%)
of Congo and Zambia and changes
to regulatory and tax requirements. Cash flow relating to operating activities
Approximately half of Barrick’s impairment Cash generated from operations 168 168 152 11%
($0.9bn) related to increased government
imposts and higher energy costs in Income taxes paid (32) (32) (26) 23%
Argentina.
Other (1) (2) (6) (67%)
Market capitalisation covered net asset
Net operating cash flows 135 134 120 12%
value by 1.4 times, well below the 1.7 ratio
from 2017. Although the overall position Source: Annual reports, PwC analysis
doesn’t indicate further impairments,
12 of the Top 40 companies had net
asset values exceeding their market Return on capital employed and Return on equity remained relatively stable on the back
capitalisation at 31 December 2018. At 30 of lower denominators because of the significant distributions to shareholders and the
April 2019, this position improved to 10. weakening of emerging market exchange rates at year end.
Cash generated from operations was $16bn, or 11%, stronger in 2018 and $3bn better
than EBITDA primarily because of a $5bn reduction in debtors across the group.
Taxes paid were also $5bn higher than the income statement tax expense. The Top 40
income tax expense reduced by 10%, with cash taxes paid to government authorities
increasing by 23%. The difference relates to the recognition of previously unrecognised
deferred tax assets, the prior year impact of US tax reform measures on deferred taxes
and the deferred tax impact of the large impairments.
The Top 40 currently have a significant balance of unrecognised tax losses, which may
confer a future tax benefit of approximately $12.7bn. Interestingly, of the Top 40, Vale
recognised a deferred tax asset of $1.5bn on its carry-forward tax balance. This move
perhaps suggests the start of a shift in the tax landscape, and we could see other miners
follow suit where forecasts support the recoverability of any previously unrecognised
deferred tax balances.
Diversity 19
Board size
11
improving, but 6
more to do Biggest Average Smallest
>80 years 2%
Boards
28% or 11 of
the Top 40 do not
have any females in 9 female appointments,
senior management
positions representing 12% of total
In 2018, the proportion of women on Developing a diverse, talented and future- This disaster, which is not reflected in
Top 40 boards was up marginally to fit workforce requires a robust workforce 2018 safety numbers, led to a significant
21%, putting miners on par with the strategy. But miners should not assume loss of life and reminds the industry of the
average for Fortune1000 companies their current approach will deliver the risk associated with mining activities, not
(21.3%). Disappointingly, there was no workforce they will need down the track. just for employees but for surrounding
improvement in the number of women in As we explored in our recent report communities.
senior management, which hovered at a Preparing for tomorrow’s workforce,
lacklustre 11%. Miners still have serious today, traditional talent practices can The second major tailings disaster in three
work to do to attract, retain and promote inadvertently filter out diversity and sideline years, it has already triggered significant
women into leadership roles. older workers. PwC has developed a legislative changes in Brazil, while a
diagnostic tool https://www.pwc.com/ number of the Top 40 are revisiting the
It’s less clear how miners are doing on gx/en/services/people-organisation/ governance and risk management of their
other critical aspects of diversity, such as workforce-strategy-diagnostic.html tailings facilities.
skills and generational composition. More that can help miners assess the longer-
than ever, shareholders and investors Despite a concerted effort to improve safety,
term effectiveness of their current there was an increase in fatalities from 96
are expecting companies to disclose workforce strategies.
progress against a wide range of diversity to 102 for the 20 companies in the Top 40
metrics that are known to be linked to that disclose safety statistics. While these
tragedies continue, safety does show an
improved performance. They want to
know whether miners have the right mix of Safety remains a overall improvement with fewer accidents
reported. There were also significantly
skills, ethnicity, gender and generations to
deal with the rapidly evolving challenges challenge fewer lost time injuries recorded by those
facing the industry. We encourage the who report additional injury metrics. As
It is impossible to reflect on safety in the PwC has mentioned in previous editions of
Top 40 to improve their diversity reporting,
mining industry without acknowledging Mine, using technology and automation in
particularly at the board and senior
the tragic impact of the Brumadinho particularly risky activities may go some way
management levels.
tailings dam failure in Brazil. to reducing the risk in the future.
significant 1%
2%
contributions to 7%
2018
Funds retained
22%
14%
The following graph compares the mining 30% 24% 22%
0%
2018 5YA 2018 5YA 2018 5YA 2018 5YA 2018 5YA
Top 40 Mining Oil & Gas Manufacturing Tech & Comm FAANG*
Direct Taxes Royalties Dividends Share Buyback Net Finance Cost Capex
$4.1bn
$6.5bn $4.1bn ($2.2bn+$1.7bn+ $0.2bn) $3.9bn
Barrick Gold Corp merged Tianqui’s acquisition Rio Tinto’s sale of coal Freeport and Rio Tinto
with Randgold Resources of 24% in SQM from assets to PT Adaro Energy sold a portion of a portion
to create “industry-leading Nutrien Ltd, as previously Tbk (Kestral mine - $2.2bn), of the Grasberg Mine to
gold company with the mentioned, to secure Glencore Plc (82% stake in PT Indonesia Asahan
greatest concentration of enough raw materials for Hail Creek Joint Venture and Aluminium (Persero)
Tier One Gold Assets in China’s push for lithium. 71.2% stake in Valeria Coal because of Indonesia’s
the industry”.1 Development Project - $1.7bn) divestment regulations.
and Whitehaven Coal Limited
(Winchester South coaking
coal project - $0.2bn).
1.
https://www.barrick.com/news/news-details/2018/Barrick-and-Randgold-Combine-to-Create-Industry-Leading-Gold-Investment-Vehicle/default.aspx
1.
Does not include deal value associated with the Barrick/Newmont JV
Current liabilities
Accounts payable 87 89 2%
Borrowings 34 44 (23%)
Other 55 54 2%
Total current liabilities 176 187 (6%)
Non-current liabilities
Borrowings 217 229 (5%)
Other 147 150 (2%)
Total non-current liabilities 364 379 (4%)
Key ratios
Gearing ratio 28% 32%
Current ratio 1.62 1.48
Quick ratio (times) 1.18 1.05
14%
*2019 Outlook
Source: PwC analysis
2019
$bn 2018 2017 Change
Outlook
Cash flow related to investing activities
Purchases of property, plant and equipment (68) (57) (51) 12%
Purchase of investments (7) (19) (7) 171%
Proceeds from sale of property,
4 4 3 33%
plant and equipment
Proceeds from sale of investments 6 18 6 200%
Other (5) (9) (1) 1349%
Net investing cash flows (70) (63) (50) 26%
Nickel
23%
16%
23%
15%
* https://www.pwc.com/Mine-2018
Disclaimer
This paper makes a number of predictions and presents PwC’s vision of the future environment for the mining industry. These
predictions are, of course, just that – predictions. These predictions of the future environment for the mining industry address matters
that are, to different degrees, uncertain and may turn out to be materially different from what is expressed in this paper. The information
contained in this report includes certain statements, calculations, estimates and projections that reflect various assumptions. Those
assumptions may or may not prove to be correct due to known and unknown risks, uncertainties and other factors. PwC has exercised
reasonable care in collection, processing and reporting of this information but has not independently verified, validated, or audited the
data to verify the accuracy or completeness of the information. PwC gives no express or implied warranties, including but not limited
to any warranties of merchantability or fitness for a particular purpose or use and shall not be liable to any entity or person using this
document, or have any liability with respect to this document.
The information provided in this paper is not a substitute for legal, investment or any other professional advice. If any reader requires
legal advice or other professional assistance, each such reader should consult his or her own legal or other professional advisors and
discuss the specific facts and circumstances that apply to the reader.
Aggregate market capitalisation 757 926 714 494 791 958 1234 1202 1605 1259
Aggregated income statement
Revenue 683 600 496 539 690 719 731 716 435 325
Operating expenses (518) (454) (390) (448) (531) (554) (553) (487) (246) (217)
EBITDA 165 146 106 91 159 165 178 229 189 108
Impairment charges (12) (4) (19) (53) (27) (57) (45) (16) (1) (11)
Amortisation, depreciation and impairment (47) (41) (44) (42) (48) (42) (34) (26) (33) (20)
Net finance cost (13) (11) (9) (19) (15) (16) (6) (6) (7) (6)
PBT 93 90 34 (23) 69 50 93 181 148 71
Income tax expense (27) (29) (15) (4) (24) (30) (25) (48) (38) (22)
Net profit/(loss) 66 61 19 (27 45 20 68 133 110 49
EBITDA margin 24% 24% 21% 17% 23% 23% 24% 32% 43% 33%
Aggregated cash flow statement
Operating activities 134 119 89 92 127 124 137 174 137 83
Investing activities (63) (46) (40) (69) (93) (125) (169) (142) (79) (74)
Financing activities (70) (63) (44) (31) (31) (3) 21 (28) (35) 10
Dividends paid (43) (36) (16) (28) (40) (41) (38) (33) (22) (15)
Share buy backs (15) (7) (4) (7) (6) (4) (5) (26) (5) 0
Free cash flow 77 71 40 23 24 (6 11 76 70 19
Aggregated balance sheet
Cash 101 102 86 82 83 168 104 113 105 74
Property, plant and equipment 610 663 616 579 745 712 701 601 511 467
Total assets 1080 1129 1063 1047 1231 1256 1245 1139 943 801
Total liabilities 540 573 563 569 630 624 563 482 387 354
Total equity 540 556 500 478 601 632 682 657 556 447
Note: The information included above includes the aggregated results of the Top 40 mining companies as reported in each respective
edition of Mine
Argentina India
Leo Viglione, PwC Argentina Yogesh Daruka, PwC India
+54 11 4850 4690 leonardo.viglione@ar.pwc.com +91 (33) 4404 4288 yogesh.daruka@pwc.com
Africa Indonesia
Michal Kotze, PwC South Africa Sacha Winzenried, PwC Indonesia
+27 (11) 797 4603 michal.kotze@pwc.com +62 21 5212901 sacha.winzenried@id.pwc.com
Australia
Chris Dodd, PwC Australia Wim Blom, Global Mining Deals Leader, PwC Australia
+61 3 8603 3130 chris.dodd@pwc.com +61 (7) 3257 5236 wim.blom@pwc.com
Marketing
Jacqui Thurlow, PwC Australia
+61 7 3257 5311 jacqui.thurlow@pwc.com