Chapter - 11 CH
Chapter - 11 CH
Chapter - 11 CH
7/300) to
FINAL FEASIBILITY
Natham (Km.36/690) Stretch of Madurai-Natham Section (Package-II) of NH-785
REPORT
on EPC mode under Bharatmala Pariyojana Phase-I in the state of TamilNadu.
CHAPTER - 11
11.1 Introduction
National Highways Authority of India (NHAI) has been entrusted to implement the
development of projects for few selected stretches / corridors through various funding
mechanism either through Public Private Partnership (PPP) basis or its own budgetary
sources or loan assistance from Asian Development Bank (ADB), World Bank etc. The
National Highways Authority of India has accordingly taken up project preparation of
certain stretches / corridors of existing National Highways that passes through various
states of the country.
Accordingly, six sections have been identified for implementation under this programme
and one part of the programme is to develop Chettikulam – Natham stretch on NH-785
for a total length of 29.390 kms in the state of Tamil Nadu.
Subsequently, NHAI has appointed M/s. Feedback Infra in JV with M/s. Mukesh &
Associates in association with M/s. Cos Consultancy services, as DPR Consultant for the
Consultancy Services for Feasibility Studies and Preparation of Detailed Project Report
of 4-laning of Chettikulam to Natham (Total Length – 29.390 kms) on NH-785 in the
State of Tamil Nadu.
Certain negative social impacts are inherent and unavoidable in any of the development
projects and our project is also no exception, as the following negative impacts are
anticipated due to the implementation of the project.
Loss of source of income to PAP’s
Loss of private, immovable properties, including agriculture land, commercial &
residential buildings, shops, wells, trees, standing crops, etc.,
Loss of civil amenities
This chapter summarizes the resettlement and rehabilitation action plan for the 4-laning of
Chettikulam – Natham section of NH-785 from km 7/300 to 36/690 in the State of Tamil
Nadu. This mainly focuses on the approaches for minimizing / mitigating social and
economic impacts due to the implementation of the project, especially on vulnerable
group.
In most of the development projects, some people or groups of people or the entire
community are directly or indirectly benefited and some are adversely affected. Even
though the project contributes to some positive benefits, it will have some adverse
impacts associated with land acquisition and displacement of people.
The existing ROW along the entire length of the project road is only 13.50 – 66.50 m
only and therefore involves large scale land acquisition to have the prescribed 60.0m
ROW, which will affect large number of people living along the project road and some of
whom will be displaced.
This resettlement and rehabilitation action plan (RAP) addresses the issues related to land
acquisition and involuntary displacement of people. The aim of the RAP is to minimize
the hardship of the displaced and the otherwise impacted people. The RAP also aims to
help the PAPs’ to have better or at least maintained their pre-project economic status.
The RAP meets the requirement of Government of India’s Resettlement & Rehabilitation
(R&R) policy, consistent with the World Bank’s (Operational Directive 4.30) regulations,
policies and procedures including those on public participation, environmental assessment
and indigenous people.
The resettlement and rehabilitation principles adopted for this project will provide
compensation, resettlement & rehabilitation assistance to all Project Affected Persons
(PAPs) (i.e., people affected due to the loss of land, residences, business establishments,
etc.,) in the corridor of impact which is 60.0 m along the existing alignment.
Where land acquisition is required, it will be carried out according to the National
Highway Act (NH Act), 1956 and in a way to minimize the adverse impacts and
to avoid displacement as much as possible.
Cash compensation for the land, at the market value will be provided to
households affected by the loss of acquired land by the competent authority
appointed under NH Act.
Cash compensation for the affected structures of the title holders will be paid by
the competent authority. The replacement cost will be calculated by the certified
value as per PWD schedule of rates (without depreciation) of the concerned
district / division / zone of Tamil Nadu for the structure of the title holders. For
items not covered in the SOR, market rates will be considered.
Provision for relocation of the SBE’s (Small Business Enterprises) in the form of
vendor market as well as assisting restoration of business and local economics.
Before taking possession of the acquired land, compensation will be paid to the
PAP’s, prior to commencement of construction work.
The resettlement plan will include a fully item-wised budget and implementation
schedule.
Based on the assessed impacts and the broad entitlement framework, the project affected
persons will be entitled to the following five types of compensation and assistance:
Compensation for loss of land, crops / trees
11.6.1 Location
The starting point of the project road is located within the non - urban limits of
Chettikulam at km 7/300 and ends at km 36/690 at Natham, Dindigul district. The project
area is located within the geographical co-ordinates of
The project envisages widening of the existing road from km 7/300 to km 36/690 of
Chettikulam to Natham section of NH-785 to 4-laning divided carriageway configuration
with improved facilities. The improvement works mainly comprise 4-laning of the
existing road, raising of formation level, provision for service roads at built-up areas,
provision for drains and CD structures, etc.
Reconstruction of 8 Slab culvert as Box culvert and Repair & Widening of 5 Slab
culverts to 4 lane standards is recommended along the realignment portion.
Provision of slip road totaling to a length 18.010 Km and service road totaling to a
length 2.720 Km has been proposed.
11 nos. of Major Junctions and 12 nos. of Minor Junctions has been proposed at
Chettikulam to Natham stretch.
24 Bus lay bay with Bus Shelters has been proposed along the Project road.
11.7 LA proposals
The available ROW along the entire length of the project road varies from 10.0m to
30.0m. The existing road has 7.0m to 7.6m wide carriageway throughout the entire
length with 1.5m wide paved shoulders on both sides at built-up areas. The project road
predominantly passes through plain terrain over shallow embankment. The existing
vertical profile of the project road is within acceptable standards as per IRC: SP 84-2014.
In the entire stretch of the project road, the land use predominantly seen is of the types
built up area and agricultural land. The Project road has agriculture lands either on one
side or on both sides of the project road. This land use comprises of the major types of
built up land use as residential, commercial, public buildings. The project road passes
through the heavily built up area, Agricultural land and the present road has the 4-lane
road standards. More number of educational institutions, hospitals, fuel retail outlets,
police stations, religious places, commercial buildings etc are also present along the
project road.
The existing horizontal alignment of the project road mostly runs in straight alignment
with around 33 Nos. of horizontal curves of easy curvature.
A total of 49 nos. of various types of cross drainage structures are present all along the
project road. The various cross drainage structures are 6 minor bridges, 18 slab culverts
and 25 pipe culverts.
Based on the proposed improvements and as per NHAI’s requirements, the proposed right
of way is kept as 60m, which emerged to the need for acquisition of additional land.
To frame the proposal for acquisition of land, due care was emphasized in finalizing the
proposed alignment, so as to avoid large-scale acquisition of land and buildings.
Generally, eccentric widening is proposed to be adopted along the existing alignment and
as such the plan of acquisition has been prepared in such a way that from the proposed
centre line, proposed ROW on either side would be 60.0 m. Total land required for the
project is 116.43 hectares.
The preliminary studies carried out to prepare this RAP, show extensive occupancy of
project roadside areas including rural settlements, consisting of numerous homes,
business and public facilities. The proposed widening scheme along with other
improvements proposed would impact road side residential structures, business
establishments, religious shrines and structures, agriculture lands, public buildings, etc.,
However, resettlement will be required only where residential and commercial buildings
are to be either fully demolished or taken to the extent that they are rendered
uninhabitable or useless. Displaced residents of these buildings will have to be relocated.
Similarly affected business establishments, public buildings and religious structures are
also to be relocated.
In most cases, the project will not require either full demolishing or the taking of
residential / commercial structures to the extent that either resettlement or relocation will
be necessary.
Considering the above, it is essential to prepare the resettlement and rehabilitation plan
for the entire project area, which would essentially include:
The social, cultural and economic structures in Indian society are heterogeneous and
complex. Large sections of the society suffer social deprivation and live below poverty
line (BPL). Among the total population in the project area, the Scheduled Castes and
Scheduled Tribes accounted for 18.19% and 0.187% of the population respectively and
around 27.50% of people live below poverty line in Madurai and Dindigul districts.
Agriculture is the predominant occupation in the project area, besides small trade, as most
of the work depends upon agriculture. Therefore, the employment opportunities have not
been diversified enough to give villagers, better non-farming work.
Since agriculture is the main occupation of these groups and for being land less, they are
much more dependent on the big and medium farmers who are having lands along the
proposed right of way. Due to the proposed acquisition of land, these land owners will get
compensation due to loss of their land but the dependent of these lands, the vulnerable
groups will be left unhelpful. Their specific need is that, if they are displaced, they should
get jobs or opportunities with necessary up gradation of skills through training.
These groups of people would need to be given special assistance and help in attaining a
better living standard, once they are resettled.
Similarly, the resettlement action plan addresses the provision for necessary support and
assistance to the other vulnerable groups such as handicapped, children, etc., particularly
those who are poor, illiterate and lacking in various skills to get employment.
Vulnerable people would receive targeted support and special attention from the project
and are to be provided with more options and support mechanisms than those not
considered vulnerable.
The prime objective of the RAP is to minimize / eliminate negative impacts on the people
/ community because of the project execution. As such, due consideration has been given
during project preparation to minimize the negative impacts within the limitations of
technical requirements and cost effectiveness.
Even though many benefits are expected from the project, social assessments indicate
potential adverse impacts on roadside communities, which include loss of land, assets and
livelihood. Every effort has however been made to reduce potential direct negative
impacts of the project, both in terms of environment and social issues. Designs have been
so prepared to minimize the negative impacts, where possible from a technical and
economical perspective.
The project corridor passes through broad land use category namely built-up areas. The
built-up areas generally have scattered developments on either side of the road.
Considering the above concentric widening is proposed in built-up settlement areas and
eccentric widening in other areas, to reduce the environmental and social impact and
consequently to minimize displacement.
Even though significant benefits are anticipated through development projects, it may
have certain adverse impact on the income of project affected persons. They also have a
negative impact on the socio-cultural systems of affected communities. The basic
postulates of all developmental activities should be that, no one is worse of than the pre-
project level. Restoration of pre-project levels of income is an important part of
rehabilitating socio economic and cultural system in affected communities.
Moving resettlers to the newly irrigated command areas without affecting the
social balance.
Helping them in building more durable houses and their non-land assets.
It is essential to understand the background of the PAP’s and their options, so that
suitable skill training programme could be designed and targeted.
The main aim of the resettlement action plan is to minimize / eliminate the adverse
impact on the people and community due to the implementation of the project. The
following key elements are considered while designing the resettlement plan. As such the
following key elements are considered for framing the resettlement plan:
Carrying out socio economic surveys and census of affected people to identify all
losses and all affected persons.
Compensation to all affected persons including non-title holders for all their losses
at replacement rates.
The proposed widening scheme involves large scale land acquisition which is estimated
as 116.43 ha. Besides, large number of non-land assets such as public buildings,
commercial structures, residential buildings, etc. is required to be acquired for the
proposed widening.
The major direct impacts anticipated due to the implementation of any such development
projects are loss of lands. The project is likely to have more impacts on agricultural lands
and on the allied activities related to agriculture. Standing crops including commercial
and food crops, trees, agricultural structures, such as wells, etc., are also going to be
affected.
Direct losses of assets or livelihoods are also anticipated due to the proposed project
which may lead to loss of residential houses (permanent & semi-permanent) and other
structures like cattle sheds, compound wall, toilets, etc., The common loss is the
displacement of road side small houses.
The displacement caused by the proposed project may lead to loss of livelihood or income
opportunities, either temporarily or permanently. The common loss is the displacement of
business structures such as small road side shops, hotels, etc.,
In addition to direct losses of assets or livelihoods, the project is likely to have more
impact on the population living along the corridor of influence. While many of these
impacts are positive, some adverse impacts are also anticipated. This may include road
safety, access to water and sanitation, access to common property resources, highway
related diseases and impact on non-motorized traffic such as pedestrians, bullock carts,
etc., Community owned assets such as temples, mosques, schools, places of worships and
burial grounds, etc., may also be affected.
11.13 Entitlements
The acquisition of land proposed along the project road for the proposed widening
scheme would be carried out as per National Highways Act-1956, which provide
compensation for properties to be acquired and support to be extended for meeting the
replacement value of the property. The persons affected by the project, both title holders
and non-title holders, who have economic interest or loss of livelihood shall be assisted as
per the broad principles of the principles and policy frame work of NHAI.
As per ‘Principles and Policy Frame work’ of the National Highways Authority of India,
the broad entitlement framework is applicable to 3 categories of support group, as
follows:
Specific entitlements and unit costs have not been provided in the policy. However,
based on the assessed impacts and the broad entitlement frame work, the affected persons
in the project will be entitled for the following 5 types of compensation and assistance:
The PAP’s are categorized based on the degree of impact and the specific entitlement for
each category.
The Chief General Manager is the incharge of the overall project activities and
participates in the state level committee to facilitate land acquisition and pre-construction
activities.
Co-ordinate the implementation of R&R activities with Corporate and staff at PIU
level.
Appoint NGO for R&R implementation and evaluation consultants for end of
project evaluation and impact assessment.
The project implementation unit (PIU) is the unit, set up by NHAI at State level / project
level, and is fully responsible for smooth implementation of RAP and civil construction
work. The Project Director will head the PIU and will be assisted by adequate number of
experts in the areas of Resettlement & Rehabilitation, Environment, Engineering &
Finance, Clerks, etc. The members of the PIU will be selected among Govt. Officials on
deputation basis, who have right skills in the appropriate field.
The PIU will work as an integrated unit and the key responsibilities of the Project
Director, CRRO / Manager (R&R) at PIU level would include:
Liaison with district administration for support for land acquisition and
implementation of R&R.
Monitor physical & financial progress on land acquisition and R&R activities.
Organizing fortnightly meetings with the NGO’s to review the progress on R&R.
The RAP will be implemented through district level committees that will be established
in each district where the project is active. These committees will provide co-ordinating
nodes for land acquisition and compensation, relocation & rehabilitation, distribution of
project provided assistance and PAP’s access to most government programmes. The
district level committee (DLC) will be constituted by the PIU. The NGO will assist
NHAI in constituting DLC. The responsibilities of DLC would include:
Facilitate the implementation of the RAP programs in the project affected area
The resettlement co-ordination committees will be constituted among the PAP’s at village
/ block level, through special meetings in village. The RCC shall mainly comprise of
members from each village panchayat, project affected women, representatives of host
population and other stakeholders with interest in the project. The RCC shall select a
Chair Person from among its members. The key responsibilities of the RCC would
include:
Assist the DLC / PIU in setting disputes and resolving conflicts in connection with
resettlement & rehabilitation.
A good rapport with the affected community will facilitate a satisfactory resettlement and
rehabilitation of the PAP’s and minimise disturbances particularly physical and
economic. To meet out the above objectives, experienced and well qualified NGO in this
field will be engaged to assist the NHAI in the implementation of the RAP.
The role of the implementing NGO would be to mitigate the adverse effects of the
project, to ensure timely completion of the project and to ensure that the rehabilitation
process is taken up in a right spirit with a comprehensive livelihood system. The prime
responsibility of the implementing agency is to ensure that each and every eligible PAP’s
receive appropriate and due entitlement within the overall frame work of R&R policy and
entitlement matrix.
The NGO will work as a link between the PIU and R & R cell and the affected
community. They will educate the PAPs on the need to implement the project, on aspects
relating to LA and R&R measures and ensures proper utilization of various compensation
extended to the PAP’s under the R&R entitlement matrix.
Educate PAPs on their rights, entitlements and obligations under the RAP.
Providing advice to PAPs on relative benefits of each option, where options are
available.
Generate awareness about the alternate economic livelihood and enable the PAPs
to make informed choice.
Enable the PAPs to identify the alternate site for agriculture, residential and
commercial plots.
Identify training needs and institutions for the PAPs for income generating
operations.
The R&R cell / PIU will have to establish important network relationships with many
departments and organizations.
The Revenue Department has an influence role in land acquisition proceedings and
initiation of resettlement process. Hence the R&R Cell / PIU will have to coordinate with
the project Land Acquisition Officer to expedite the land acquisition process.
For restoring the pre-project level incomes of the PAP’s, the NGO will facilitate linkages
to be established with the Government poverty alleviation programs for income
restoration.
The Public Health Engineering Departments are to be coordinated for the restoration of
community assets such as hand pumps, bore wells, drainage facilities, etc.,
Coordination will be required from the District Officer of Education Department, where
schools are affected.
11.16 Recommendations
Based on the baseline socio economics study the following recommendations are made:
Cash compensation for land shall be paid at replacement value, free of fees and
other charges.
Compensation shall be given for perennial crops and trees at the rate of annual net
product value multiplied by numbers of years required for new crops to yield.