Possible VAT Implications of Transfer Pricing
Possible VAT Implications of Transfer Pricing
Possible VAT Implications of Transfer Pricing
DIRECTORATE-GENERAL
TAXATION AND CUSTOMS UNION
Indirect Taxation and Tax administration
Value Added Tax
taxud.c.1(2018)2326098 – EN
Commission européenne, 1049 Bruxelles / Europese Commissie, 1049 Brussel – Belgium – Tel.: +32 2 299 11 11.
taxud.c.1(2018)2326098 – VAT Expert Group
VEG No 071 REV2
The VEG welcomes the opportunity to discuss the possible VAT implications of transfer
pricing rules laid down for the purposes of direct taxation.
It is important to note that Transfer Pricing Adjustments are direct tax driven and direct
tax and VAT are conceptually totally different taxes. As such, a Transfer Pricing
Adjustment does not usually result in an adjustment in the consideration for any supply,
even though the profit adjustment may be an indirect consequence of goods being bought
or sold and other kinds of costs being incurred.
When defining the VAT treatment of a Transfer Pricing Adjustment, the VAT neutrality
principle should be recognized, meaning that neither businesses nor tax administrations
should suffer negative consequences from the proposed treatment.
The Opinion of the VAT Expert Group is that Transfer Pricing Adjustments should
be considered as “Outside scope of VAT” where both parties have a full right to
recover VAT, in accordance with the simplification practice that we suggest to be
adopted by the Member States (see 2.2.3). It is only when one of the traders does not have
a full right of recovery, that Transfer Pricing Adjustments might require a VAT
adjustment if there is a sufficiently direct link between any payments resulting from an
adjustment and specific supplies. Transfer Pricing Adjustments resulting from a tax audit
should always be treated as outside of the scope of VAT (see 2.2.1.1) unless the parties
agree to change the consideration accordingly.
2. INTRODUCTION
The VEG welcomes Commission Paper VEG No. 65 and the opportunity to discuss the
possible VAT implications of Transfer Pricing Adjustments as laid down for the purposes
of direct taxation.
The direct tax transfer pricing rules are aimed at ensuring that the conditions of the
transactions within a multinational enterprise group ("MNE group"), including the price,
match comparable market conditions and that, as a result, profits and losses are divided
between the jurisdictions in which the multinational enterprise ("MNE") operates as they
would have been, had the transactions under transfer pricing been performed between
unrelated 3rd parties
Besides Transfer Pricing Adjustments between affiliated parties, the scope of Transfer
Pricing Adjustments needs to be expanded to adjustments executed between 3rd parties
due to contractual arrangements. This may be the case for instance in case of guaranteed
profit margins for 3rd party distribution, toll and contract manufacturing arrangements.
2/12
taxud.c.1(2018)2326098 – VAT Expert Group
VEG No 071 REV2
The aforementioned aim (proper allocation of income between related and unrelated
parties) clearly differs from the aim of the VAT system, i.e. taxation of consumption, with
the allocation of taxing rights based on the destination principle.
Nevertheless, Transfer Pricing Adjustments can also have VAT implications. Businesses
across the EU have, in practice, experienced Member States taking different approaches
on how to treat Transfer Pricing Adjustments for VAT purposes, such as:
It is therefore important to examine this topic in further detail to provide legal certainty for
businesses and tax administrations.
This document deals with the VAT aspects only. We recognize that when it comes to TP
adjustments there is also a linkage to customs with potential VAT consequences 1.
However, the specificity of the rules2 applicable to customs transactions justifies a
separate treatment of this topic. Also, this document does not consider the impact of
Transfer Pricing Adjustments on Direct Tax.
2.1. Principles
Transfer Pricing Adjustments, while mainly related to the “Taxable Amount”, have a
much broader impact.
Below is an overview of the provisions in the VAT Directive which may have an impact
to define the correct VAT treatment of Transfer Pricing Adjustments.
1
See CJEU C-529/16, Hamamatsu, para. 26: “Furthermore, the Court has already stated that the customs
value had to be determined primarily according to the ‘transaction value’ method under Article 29 of the
Customs Code. It is only if the price actually paid or payable for the goods when they are sold for export
cannot be determined that it is appropriate to use the alternative methods laid down in Articles 30 and 31
thereof (see, in particular, judgments of 12 December 2013, Christodoulou and Others, C-116/12,
EU:C:2013:825, paragraphs 38, 41, 42 and 44, and of 16 June 2016, EURO 2004. Hungary, C-291/15,
EU:C:2016:455, paragraphs 24 and 27 to 30).”.
2
See Article 70 et seq. of REG EU (Recast) no. 952/2013.
3/12
taxud.c.1(2018)2326098 – VAT Expert Group
VEG No 071 REV2
Taxable transaction
A supply of goods or services is subject to VAT when made for consideration by a taxable
person acting as such, pursuant to Article 2(1) of the VAT Directive.
Concerning the existence of consideration, from the settled case-law of the Court of
Justice of the European Union (CJEU), it is clear that a supply of services is effected for
consideration within the meaning of Article 2(1)(c) of the VAT Directive, and hence is
taxable, only if there is a direct link between the services supplied and the consideration
received.
Such a direct link is established if there is a legal relationship between the provider of the
service and the recipient pursuant to which there is reciprocal performance, the
remuneration received by the provider of the service constituting the actual consideration
given in return for the service supplied to the recipient.
Based on the existing case-law of the CJEU concerning the existence of a direct link, it
can be argued that Transfer Pricing Adjustments do not meet this requirement3.
Taxable person
A taxable person is defined as any person carrying out an economic activity, whatever the
purpose or results of that activity under Article 9 of the VAT Directive.
Taxable amount
The anti-avoidance rule in Article 80 of the VAT Directive is only applicable in the case
of transactions between persons with close (family, financial or legal etc) ties.
Also, according to the CJEU4, the conditions of application of Article 80 of the VAT
Directive are exhaustive and, consequently, national legislation cannot - on the basis of
that provision - provide that the taxable amount is to be the open market value of the
transaction in cases other than those listed in that provision, except if a Member State has
a derogation under article 395.
This is different from the direct tax concept and application of transfer pricing for intra-
group transactions.
Article 83 of the VAT Directive does not provide for a specific Transfer Pricing provision
either, as the taxable amount of an intra-Community acquisition of goods is determined in
the same way as that of supplies of goods or services.
3
See CJEU C-285/10, Campsa Estaciones de Servicio SA vs. Administración del Estado para. 27: “ It
follows that, where consideration has been agreed and actually paid to the taxable person in direct
exchange for the goods he has delivered or the service he has provided, that transaction must be
classified as a transaction for consideration, regardless of whether it is effected between connected
parties and the price agreed and actually paid is patently lower than the open market price. The taxable
amount of such a transaction must, therefore, be determined in accordance with the general rule stated in
Article 11A(1)(a) of the Sixth Directive.” (emphasis added).
4
See CJEU Joined Cases C-621/10 and 129/11
4/12
taxud.c.1(2018)2326098 – VAT Expert Group
VEG No 071 REV2
Article 85 of the VAT Directive establishes the taxable amount for an importation of
goods by reference to the corresponding customs value.
Article 90 of the VAT Directive deals with Transfer Pricing Adjustments: “where the
price is reduced after the supply takes place, the taxable amount shall be reduced
accordingly under conditions which shall be determined by the Member States”.
Following Article 63 of the VAT Directive, the chargeable event shall occur, and VAT
shall become chargeable, when the goods or the services are supplied. Some subsequent
articles allow for derogations. Article 70 of the VAT Directive dealing with the chargeable
event for the Importation of Goods provides that “The chargeable event shall occur and
VAT shall become chargeable when the goods are imported”.
The chargeable event for Transfer Pricing Adjustments should in our opinion be the
moment when the decision is made to voluntarily adjust the taxable amount for VAT
purposes. At the same time, a debit/credit note is issued.
Transfer Pricing Adjustments also have an impact on invoicing and deduction of VAT.
Article 219 of the VAT Directive mentions that “Any document or message that amends
and refers specifically and unambiguously to the initial invoice shall be treated as an
invoice”. Typically, a taxable person only has the right to deduct the VAT in case he
possesses an invoice or an import document in case goods are imported in the EU.
In our opinion, the deduction is a fundamental right of the VAT mechanism (neutrality
principle). A correction of the amount of deductible VAT via an adjusted invoice should
not result in a retro-active adjustment of the deductible VAT5. In line with the rules on
chargeable event, VAT should be deductible at the moment when the obligation or the
right to adjust the taxable amount for VAT purposes arises. The deduction of VAT should
not be impacted by the expiry of statutory limits in case of Transfer Pricing Adjustments. 6
Reporting requirements
5
See AG Opinion in CJEU Case C-8/17, point. 71 Conclusion and AG Opinion in CJEU Case C-533/16,
point. 91 Conclusion
6
See Ecotrade C-95/07 and C-96/07 and Case C-85/97 SFI
5/12
taxud.c.1(2018)2326098 – VAT Expert Group
VEG No 071 REV2
Based on the VAT Directive, it is not clear when a Transfer Pricing Adjustment is a
taxable transaction within- or outside the scope of VAT. In some cases it might be argued
that a Transfer Pricing Adjustment is an adjustment of a previous Taxable Transaction and
therefore constitutes additional consideration for the same Taxable Transaction. It may
also be arguable that the Transfer Pricing adjustment is consideration for a different
Taxable Transaction or alternatively is outside the scope of VAT.
In the absence of a specific provision to this effect, the proposed VAT treatment in this
document aims to bring certainty, simplicity and clarity on Transfer Pricing Adjustments.
Following Transfer Pricing Adjustments are not considered as taxable transactions and are
consequently defined as being outside scope of VAT:
Generally, there is only a taxable transaction where there is “consideration” (which can go
beyond cash settlement). If there is no “consideration”, there is no taxable transaction and
the Transfer Pricing Adjustment is clearly “Outside the scope of VAT”. It is our
understanding that Primary, Secondary and Corresponding Adjustments7 do not qualify as
“consideration”, and as such do not lead to a “Taxable Transaction”. These adjustments
are therefore considered as being “Outside the scope of VAT”. In addition to the absence
of Taxable Transactions, there is no “reciprocal” performance.
These non-voluntary adjustments also typically occur after the tax return has been filed.
For instance, adjustments to the price of transactions or taxable basis upon audit of a
taxable person. This can happen if the profit margin is not correctly applied if goods or
services are invoiced on a cost+ basis. Typically, the taxable basis of the person under
audit is increased while there is no corresponding decrease in the taxable basis of the
counterparty.
7
See VEG no. 65, Possible VAT implications of Transfer Pricing, page 6-10, definitions of Primary,
Secondary and Corresponding Adjustments
6/12
taxud.c.1(2018)2326098 – VAT Expert Group
VEG No 071 REV2
Compensating adjustments are defined8 as “An adjustment in which the taxpayer reports a
transfer price for tax purposes that is, in the taxpayer’s opinion, an arm’s length price for
a controlled transaction, even though this price differs from the amount actually charged
between the associated enterprises. This adjustment would be made before the tax return
is filed”.
The correct VAT treatment depends on whether there is a direct link with the initial
supply.
Where the Transfer Pricing Adjustment can be linked to the initial supply, the VAT
treatment of the adjustment is the same as the initial supply. The “link” requires that the
Transfer Pricing Adjustment can be split so as to link (part of) the adjustment to each
single good being sold or service being provided. For goods, the price of each product can
be adjusted for each supply being made. For services, the cost of each service provided
can be adjusted.
Where there is no direct link with the initial supply and no contractual obligation to make
a Transfer Pricing Adjustment payment, the assumption is that the adjusting payment aims
to reach an agreed profit margin, which is not a taxable transaction or taxable
consideration, and as such outside scope of VAT.
8
See VEG no. 65, Possible VAT implications of Transfer Pricing, page 10
7/12
taxud.c.1(2018)2326098 – VAT Expert Group
VEG No 071 REV2
Where the contract refers to the treatment of Transfer Pricing Adjustments, the agreed
treatment as per the contract should be followed. Following options are possible:
Documents may be desired for direct tax purposes to evidence payments that are made
between the parties but which are outside the scope of VAT. If such documents are
described as “invoices”, it is possible that tax authorities will assume that VAT must be
due. The VAT Expert group therefore considers that it would be helpful to both tax
authorities and business if there were an agreed description, such as “Transfer Pricing
Payment Request”, for documents requesting payments relating to transfer pricing
adjustments that are outside the scope of VAT.
Unless it has been otherwise contractually agreed, given the complexity of the treatment
of Transfer Pricing Adjustments for VAT purposes, we recommend treating all types of
Transfer Pricing Adjustments as Outside the Scope of VAT for B2B transactions where all
parties have a full right to deduct VAT.
Transfer Pricing Adjustments are Direct tax driven. Direct taxes and VAT are
conceptually totally different. This is correctly highlighted by the Commission in VEG
Paper No 65, which observes that VAT is a transaction based tax with businesses just
acting as tax collector and the VAT being borne by the final consumer. In principle, the
tax should therefore be neutral for businesses.
The VAT Expert Group’s preferred approach to Transfer Pricing Adjustments is to treat
them as being “Outside the scope of VAT’. Transfer Pricing Adjustments are executed to
determine the Taxable Basis for Direct Tax purposes. A Transfer Pricing Adjustment
should not necessarily result in a price adjustment for VAT purposes, even though the
8/12
taxud.c.1(2018)2326098 – VAT Expert Group
VEG No 071 REV2
profit adjustment may be an indirect consequence of goods being bought or sold and other
kinds of costs being incurred.
This approach is applied by at least one of the Member States. A tax authority states that
usually no correction is necessary for VAT if the omission does not have an impact on the
tax revenue and the VIES system, e.g. because the underlying transaction is a zero-rated
(exempt with credit) intracommunity supply of goods.
2.3. No negative consequences where the taxable basis for VAT should be
amended
Transfer Pricing Adjustments should not have adverse VAT impacts on businesses. Even
if adjustments are required for VAT purposes these should not lead to the application of:
penalties;
late payment interest; and
If the adjustment is within the scope of VAT, the statute of limitations should be the
same for the payment of VAT and the right to refund/or deduct VAT due that arises
from the adjustment (see also under 2.1. Principles).
9/12
taxud.c.1(2018)2326098 – VAT Expert Group
VEG No 071 REV2
ANNEX 1
Example 1:
Proposed Assessment
The recharge to the Principal of the costs for advertising and promotion exceeding
the “threshold” is a taxable transaction for VAT purposes, e.g. a “Supply of
Services” to be separately invoiced by the LRDs.
On the contrary, the (additional, if any) “compensating adjustment” aimed to reach
the agreed LRDs profit margin (ROS) is not a taxable transaction for VAT
purposes, because:
- it does not constitute consideration given in exchange for the previous supply
of goods sold by the Principal to the LRDs (e.g. it is not an adjustment to the
price already paid by the LRDs to the Principal);
10/12
taxud.c.1(2018)2326098 – VAT Expert Group
VEG No 071 REV2
- there is no direct link with the supply of finished goods sold by the Principal to
the LRDs.
In such a scenario, the “compensating adjustment” is to be considered “Outside the
scope of VAT”.
Example 2:
Example 3:
11/12
taxud.c.1(2018)2326098 – VAT Expert Group
VEG No 071 REV2
Example 4:
12/12