Ansi Awwa C516-14 PDF
Ansi Awwa C516-14 PDF
Ansi Awwa C516-14 PDF
®
AWWA Standard
Large-Diameter Rubber-
Seated Butterfly Valves,
Sizes 78 In. (2,000 mm)
and Larger
SM
lication o f a standard does not constitute endorsement o f any product or product type, nor does AWWA test, certi fy,
or approve any product. The use o f AWWA standards is entirely voluntary. This standard does not supersede or take
precedence over or displace any applicable law, regulation, or code o f any governmental authority. AWWA standards
are intended to represent a consensus o f the water supply industry that the product described will provide satis factory
service. When AWWA revises or withdraws this standard, an o f cial notice o f action will be placed in the O f cial Notice
section o f Journal - American Water Works Association . The action becomes efective on the f rst day o f the month fol -
lowing the month o f Journal - American Water Works Association publication o f the o f cial notice.
proved the standard or not, from manu facturing, marketing, purchasing, or using products, processes, or procedures
not con forming to the standard. American National Standards are subject to periodic review, and users are cautioned
to obtain the latest editions. Producers o f goods made in con formity with an American National Standard are encour -
aged to state on their own responsibility in advertising and promotional materials or on tags or labels that the goods
are produced in con formity with particular American National Standards.
C au tion n otiCe : The American National Standards Institute (ANSI) approval date on the front cover o f this standard
indicates completion o f the ANSI approval process. This American National Standard may be revised or withdrawn at
any time. ANSI procedures require that action be taken to rea f rm, revise, or withdraw this standard no later than f ve
years from the date o f ANSI approval. Purchasers o f American National Standards may receive current in formation on
all standards by calling or writing the American National Standards Institute, 25 West 43rd Street, Fourth Floor, New
York, N Y 1 0036; 21 2.642.4900; or emailing in fo@ansi.org.
ISBN-1 3, print: 978-1 -62576-1 05-7 eISBN-1 3, electronic: 978-1 -61 300-342-8
DOI: http://dx.doi.org/1 0.1 2999/AWWA.C51 6.1 4
All rights reserved. No part o f this publication may be reproduced or transmitted in any form or by any means,
electronic or mechanical, including photocopy, recording, or any in formation or retrieval system, except in the form o f
brie f excerpts or quotations for review purposes, without the written permission o f the publisher.
ii
Copyright © 201 5 American Water Works Association. All Rights Reserved.
Committee Personnel
Te AWWA standards subcommittee for Large-Diameter Butterfy Valves that reviewed this stan-
dard had the following personnel at the time of approval:
John V. Ballun, Chair
General Interest Members
J.W. Green, Lockwood, Andrews & Newman, Oakbrook Terrace, Ill. (AWWA)
R.A. Ward, Dufresne & Associates PC, Windsor, Vt. (AWWA)
Producer Members
A. Abouelleil, Henry Pratt Company, Aurora, Ill. (AWWA)
J.V. Ballun, Val-Matic Valve and Manufacturing Corporation, Addison, Ill. (AWWA)
D.E. Douro, Olson Technologies Inc., Allentown, Pa. (AWWA)
J.R. Holstrom, Val-Matic Valve and Manufacturing Corporation, Elmhurst, Ill. (AWWA)
A.W. Libke, DeZURIK Inc., Sartell, Minn. (AWWA)
T. Martin, Adams Valves Inc., Houston, Texas (AWWA)
J.H. Wilber, American AVK, Littleton, Colo. (AWWA)
User Members
S. Carpenter, San Diego Water, Escondido, Calif. (AWWA)
V.Q. Le, Los Angeles Water and Power, Los Angeles, Calif. (AWWA)
P. Ries, Denver Water Department, Denver, Colo. (AWWA)
S.Y. Tung, City of Houston, Houston, Texas (AWWA)
Te AWWA Standards Committee on Butterfy Valves, which reviewed and approved this stan-
dard, had the following personnel at the time of approval:
Mark MacConnell, Chair
A. Ali, ADA Consulting, Surrey, B.C., Canada (AWWA)
M.D. Bennett, MWH, Cleveland, Ohio (AWWA)
B.E. Bosserman, Engineering Consultants, Mission Viejo, Calif. (AWWA)
J. Hebenstreit, UL LLC, Northbrook, Ill. (UL)
F. Hinker, Santa Rosa, N.M. (AWWA)
M.C. Johnson, Utah State University, Water Research Laboratory, Logan, Utah (AWWA)
iii
Producer Members
User Members
* Liaison, nonvoting
† Alternate
iv
vi
Copyright © 201 5 American Water Works Association. All Rights Reserved.
Foreword
Tis foreword is for information only and is not a part ofANSI*/AWWA C516.
I. Introduction.
I.A. Background. Large-diameter butterfy valves are generally used for
pipelines carrying water and gases in power generation facilities, water treatment
plants, and major water supply and distribution lines. Butterfy valves are isolation
and fow-control devices that provide tight shutof; are relatively easy to operate, even
with moderate pressure drops across the valves; and require relatively little space for
installation.
I.B. History. Te need for standardization of butterfy valves was recognized
by the American Water Works Association (AWWA) with the adoption of AWWA
C504 for Rubber-Seated Butterfy Valves in 1954. Tis companion standard was
developed by the AWWA Standards Committee on Feb. 12, 2006, to meet the need
for large-diameter valves in the waterworks industry. Tis second edition of ANSI/
AWWA C516 was approved by the AWWA Board of Directors on June 8, 2014.
I.C. Acceptance. In May 1985, the US Environmental Protection Agency
(USEPA) entered into a cooperative agreement with a consortium led by NSF
International (NSF) to develop voluntary third-party consensus standards and a
certifcation program for direct and indirect drinking water additives. Other members of
the original consortium included the Water Research Foundation (formerly AwwaRF)
and the Conference of State Health and Environmental Managers (COSHEM). Te
American Water Works Association (AWWA) and the Association of State Drinking
Water Administrators (ASDWA) joined later.
In the United States, authority to regulate products for use in, or in contact with,
drinking water rests with individual states.† Local agencies may choose to impose
requirements more stringent than those required by the state. To evaluate the health
efects of products and drinking water additives from such products, state and local
agencies may use various references, including
1. An advisory program formerly administered by USEPA, Ofce of Drinking
Water, discontinued on Apr. 7, 1990.
2. Specifc policies of the state or local agency.
* American National Standards Institute, 25 West 43rd Street, Fourth Floor, New York, NY 10036.
† Persons outside the United States should contact the appropriate authority having jurisdiction.
vi i
xi i i
xv
Copyright © 201 5 American Water Works Association. All Rights Reserved.
b. If one or more of the materials included in this standard are unaccept-
able, specify the acceptable materials that are included in this standard.
c. Required mating surface. In cases where valves are to be opened fre-
quently (more than once a month), seating surfaces of stainless steel are recommended
(Sec. 4.3.4.3).
27. Whether shaft seal shall be contained in a stufng box (Sec. 4.3.6.4).
28. Required welding procedure (Sec. 4.4.1).
29. Protective coatings if other than specifed in Sec. 4.5 of this standard.
30. Te providing of test records that are specifed according to Sec. 5.1 .1 , 5.1 .2,
and 5.1 .3 of this standard. Test records required for manual actuators under ANSI/
AWWA C504, Rubber-Seated Butterfy Valves, and power actuators under ANSI/
AWWA C541, Hydraulic and Pneumatic Cylinder and Vane-Type Actuators for Valves
and Slide Gates, and ANSI/AWWA C542 Electric Motor Actuators for Valves and
Slide Gates, may also be requested. Te purchaser may require all records or may stipu-
late a breakdown of production test records or proof-of-design test records.
31. If a leakage test in both directions is required or if the valve shall be tested
with the disc in the vertical plane (Sec. 5.1 .2).
32. Special markings to be applied to a valve by manufacturer (Sec. 6.1).
III.B. Modifcation to Standard. Any modifcation of the provisions, defnitions,
or terminology in this standard must be provided by the purchaser.
IV. Major Revisions. Major revisions made to the standard in this edition
include the following:
1. AWWA Pressure Class 250B was added.
2. Additional advisory information on installation was added to the foreword.
3. Body shell thickness requirements were revised.
4. Use with reclaimed water was added.
5. Alternate purchaser-specifed test requirements were added.
V. Comments. If you have any comments or questions about this standard,
please call AWWA Engineering and Technical Services at 303.794.7711, FAX at
303.795.7603; write to the department at 6666 West Quincy Avenue, Denver, CO
80235-3098; or email at standards@awwa.org.
x vi
® AWWA Standard
Large-Diameter Rubber-Seated
Butterfly Valves, Sizes 78 In.
(2,000 mm) and Larger
SEC TI ON 1 : G EN ER AL
T
AS M A216 —Standard Speci fcation for Steel Castings, Carbon, Suitable
T
for Fusion Welding, for High- emperature Service.
T
AS M A240 —Standard Speci fcation for Heat-Resisting Chromium and
Chromium-Nickel Stainless Steel Plate, Sheet, and Strip for Pressure Vessels.
T
AS M A276 —Standard Speci fcation for Stainless Steel Bars and Shapes.
AS TM A351 —Standard Speci fcation for Castings, Austenitic, Austenitic
(Duplex), for Pressure-Containing Parts.
T
AS M A395 —Standard Speci fcation for Ferritic Ductile Iron Pressure-
Retaining Castings for Use at Elevated Temperatures.
T
AS M A436 —Standard Speci fcation for Austenitic Gray Iron Castings.
AS TM A439 —Standard Speci fcation for Austenitic Ductile Iron Castings.
AS TM A516 —Standard Speci fcation for Pressure Vessel Plates, Carbon
Steel, for Moderate- and Lower-Temperature Service.
AS TM A536 —Standard Speci fcation for Ductile Iron Castings.
AS TM A564—Standard Speci fcation for Hot-Rolled and Cold-Finished
Age-Hardening Stainless Steel Bars and Shapes.
T
AS M A582—Standard Speci fcation for Free-Machining Stainless Steel
Bars.
T
AS M A743 —Standard Speci fcation for Castings, Iron-Chromium, Iron-
Chromium-Nickel, Corrosion-Resistant, for General Applications.
T
AS M B1 27—Standard Speci fcation for Nickel-Copper Alloy (UNS
N04400) Plate, Sheet, and Strip.
T
AS M B154—Standard Test Method for Mercurous Nitrate Test for Copper
and Copper Alloys.
T
AS M B164—Standard Speci fcation for Nickel-Copper Alloy Rod, Bar,
and Wire.
T
AS M B438 —Standard Speci fcation for Sintered Bronze Bearings (Oil
Impregnated).
T
AS M C633 —Standard Test Method for Adhesion or Cohesive Strength of
Flame-Sprayed Coatings.
AS TM D471 —Standard Test f
Method for Rubber Property—E ect of
Liquids.
T
AS M D1141 —Standard Speci fcation for Substitute Ocean Water.
AS TM D1149 —Standard Test Method for Rubber Deterioration—Surface
Ozone Cracking in a Chamber.
T
AS M E165 —Standard Test Method for Liquid Penetrant Examination.
disc is perpendicular to the fow way, open when parallel to the fow way, or used
for throttling when positioned between open and closed.
5. Cylinder actuator: A fuid-powered actuator that uses hydraulic or
pneumatic pressure within a cylinder to restrain or move a valve closure member.
Air or fuid pressure acts on a piston to provide thrust in a linear motion. Te
thrust is mechanically converted to rotary motion for quarter-turn valves using a
link and lever, rack and pinion, or scotch yoke mechanism.
6. Direct-mounted: An actuator that is attached immediately to the but-
terfy valve shaft and the valve body or stufng box.
7. Disc: Te closure member that is positioned in the fow stream to permit
fow or to obstruct fow (depending on closure position) and that rotates through
an angle of 90° from full open to full shutof.
8. Electric motor actuator: An electric power-actuated device that uses
electrical energy acting through a motor with a gear train to produce a rotary or
linear output motion.
9. Fluid working pressure (also called cold working pressure [CWP]): Te
internal hydrostatic pressure for which the valve body is designed without regard
to disc position or actuator capacity.
10. Hub: Structural raised-area (boss) member on the valve body used to
support the valve-shaft bearing and valve shaft.
11. Manual actuator: An actuator that can be operated by a person without
the need for an external energy source, such as electrical power or fuid pressure.
12. Manufacturer: Te party that manufactures, fabricates, or produces
materials or products.
13. Mating surface: Te metal surface around the inside of the valve body
or the outside edge of the valve disc that seals with the rubber seat when the disc
is closed.
14. Maximum design torque: Te calculated shaft torque for operating the
valve at the worst-case conditions specifed in Sec. 1.1 .
15. Maximum operating torque: Te calculated shaft torque for operating
the valve at the purchaser-specifed operating conditions, Sec. III.A.
16. O-ring seal: A type of seal consisting of an elastomer in the shape of a
torus, i.e., a circular shape with a circular cross section.
17. Pull-down packing gland: An adjustable-type shaft seal in which the
deformable sealing material is composed of one or more ring-shaped seals that have
square or rectangular cross sections or are V-shaped (chevron).
iron. A casting and service allowance of 0.1 25 in. (3.2 mm) shall be added to the
minimum thickness. At no point shall the thickness be more than 12.5 percent
below the calculated thickness. Additional thickness may be required adjacent to
the shaft-bearing hub and the fanges to meet the requirements of Sec. 4.3.1 .6.3.
4.3.1 .4 Shaft-bearing hub. Valve bodies shall have shaft-bearing hubs
structurally tied into the body shell. Te length of the hubs is determined by the
bearing and shaft seal designs (Sec. 4.3.5 and 4.3.6).
4.3.1 .5 Actuator fange. As a minimum, the connection between the
actuator fange and actuator shall be capable of transmitting the maximum operat-
ing torque and the actuator weight based on a coefcient of friction of 0.3 and a
maximum bolt stress of 75 percent of the bolt yield strength. Alternatively, actua-
tors to valve connections shall be secured by using dowels or keys into the valve
body or other equivalent means to prevent shift during operation of the valve.
Copyright © 201 5 American Water Works Association. All Rights Reserved.
1 0 AWWA C51 6 -1 4
Where:
t 1 = torsional shear stress, psi (kPa)
d = shaft diameter, in. (mm)
T = maximum design torque at seated position or operating position,
in.-lb (N-M)
Te combined shear stress caused by torsion and bending at seating and oper-
ating positions calculated from the following equation shall not exceed 0.6 times
the lesser of ¼ of the tensile strength or 2⁄3 of the yield strength of the material
used.
2 = 16dT3 + 32 (D/d)2 P1
t
p
Where:
t 2 = combined shear stress, psi (kPa)
D = disc diameter, in. (mm)
T = maximum design torque at seated or operating positions, in.-lb
(N-M)
P1 = design pressure rating or di ferential pressure at operating position,
psi (kPa)
Te combined tensile stress at seating due to torsion and bending calculated
from the following equation shall not exceed the lesser of ¼ of the tensile strength
or 2⁄3 of the yield strength of the material used.
1 = d √ d2 d
p p
p
s
Where:
s1 = combined tensile stress, psi (kPa)
M = bending moment of guided cantilever, in.-lb (N-M)
= π D2 P L/16
TS = maximum design torque at seated position, in.-lb (N-M)
P = design pressure rating, psi (kPa)
L = unsupported shaft length, in. (mm)
4.3.2.2 Connection. Te connection between the shaft and the disc shall
be designed to transmit shaft torque equivalent to at least 70 percent of the tor-
sional strength of the minimum required shaft diameters. Rigid shaft restraint
shall be provided. Hardware used in connecting the shaft to the disc shall be stain-
less steel or free-machined stainless steel. Te disc shall be mechanically secured to
the shaft by a positive means such as bolting or cross-pinning, and shall not rely
solely on chemical bonding, adhesives, or welding. Te shaft shall be capable of
nondestructive disassembly from the disc.
4.3.2.3 Size. Te portion of the shaft that extends through the valve bear-
ings shall be full size. If the valve-shaft diameter is reduced to ft connections to the
valve operating mechanism, the smaller portion shall have fllets with radii equal to
the ofset to minimize the stress concentration at the junction of the two diferent
shaft diameters. Te smallest diameter of the shaft shall be capable of transmitting
the maximum operating torque without the torsional shear stress exceeding 40 per-
cent of the yield strength of the shaft material based on the following equation:
= K 16dT3m
t
p
Where:
t = maximum torsional shear stress, psi (kPa)
d = shaft diameter, in. (mm)
K = stress intensity factor based on geometry, dimensionless
Tm = maximum operating torque, in.-lb (N-M)
4.3.2.4 Actuator connection. Valve shafts or extensions of the valve shaft
shall be provided with a keyed or splined connection to actuators capable of trans-
mitting the full valve torque with less than 0.1 degree of backlash.
of the tensile strength for gray iron and alloy gray iron. Te design shall be based on
the combination of distributed pressure loads, seat friction loads, and shaft restraints.
4.3.3.3 External ribs. Valve discs shall be of a cast or fabricated design
with no external ribs transverse to the fow.
4.3.4 Valve seats.
4.3.4.1 Pressure classes. Valve seats shall be designed to be leak-tight in
both directions at all diferential pressures up to and including the rated pressure
of the valve.
4.3.4.2 Rubber seats. Rubber seats shall be uninterrupted by the valve
shaft and of a design that permits adjustment, removal, and replacement at the site
of the installation without removal from the pipeline. Seat removal shall be pos-
sible without removal of the valve shaft.
4.3.4.2.1 Rubber seats shall be applied to either the body or the disc and
shall be of new natural or synthetic rubber, and may be reinforced.
4.3.4.2.2 Rubber seats shall be clamped or mechanically secured to the
body or disc. Circumferential joints of rubber seats shall be bonded together. Te
design of the seat shall provide tight shutof with fow in either direction according
to the tests required by Section 5.
4.3.4.2.3 Rubber compounds shall contain no more than 8 ppm of copper
ion and shall include copper inhibitors to prevent copper degradation of the rubber
material.
4.3.4.2.4 Rubber compounds shall be capable of withstanding an ozone
resistance test when tested in accordance with AS TM D1149 using 50 parts
per 100 million minimum ozone concentration. Te tests shall be conducted
equal to the valve class shall be supplied to the lower face of the disc for the full test
duration. Te upper surface of the valve disc shall be visible and shall be covered
with a pool of water at 0 psig (0 kPa) pressure. Te duration of the test shall be at
least 5 min. Tere shall be no indication of leakage past the valve disc (visible in
the form of bubbles in the water pool on top of the disc) during the test period.
5.1 .2.2 Alternative test procedure. As an alternative to the test procedure
and disc orientation listed in Sec. 5.1 .2.1 , valves may be given a hydrostatic test at
the pressures stated in Sec. 5.1 .2.1 . During the test, the valves shall be drop-tight.
Te minimum duration of the test shall be at least 10 min. When required in the
purchase documents, the valve shall be tested with the disc in the vertical plane.
5.1 .2.3 Test direction. Unless testing in both directions is required by
the purchase documents, the valves are required to be tested only in the direction
most likely to leak.
5.1 .3 Hydrostatic test. With the disc partially open, valve bodies shall be
subjected to an internal hydrostatic pressure equivalent to twice the rated pressure.
During the hydrostatic test, there shall be no leakage through the metal, the end
joints, or shaft seal, nor shall any part have permanent visible deformation. Te
duration of the hydrostatic test shall be sufcient to allow visual examination for
leakage. Test duration shall be at least 10 min.
Sec. 5.2 Proof-of-Design Tests
5.2.1 Performance testing. One valve of each size and class shall be oper-
ated and leak tested in the vertical orientation with the shaft horizontal to simulate
feld installation in a horizontal pipeline. Te valve shall be operated three times
from the fully closed to an unseated position of at least 90° open and the reverse
under no-fow, nonpressurized conditions. Following the operations, the valve shall
be closed and hydrostatically leak tested at the rated pressure for 15 min in both
directions, during which time the valve shall be drop-tight.
5.2.2 Hydrostatic testing. One valve of each size and class shall be hydro-
statically tested in the vertical or horizontal orientation with twice the rated pres-
sure applied to one side of the disc and zero pressure on the other side. Te test is
to be performed in each direction across the disc while the valve body is bolted to
a fanged test head. Under the hydrostatic test, the manufacturer may make special
provisions to prevent leakage past the seats, and no part of the valve or disc shall
have permanent visible deformation resulting from this test. Test duration shall be
at least 60 min.
SECTION 6: DELIVERY
Tis appendix is for information only and is not a part ofANSI/AWWA C516.
23
Copyright © 201 5 American Water Works Association. All Rights Reserved.
24 AWWA C51 6 -1 4
A.5.6 Prepare pipe ends and install valves in accordance with the pipe man-
ufacturer’s instructions for the joint used. Do not defect pipe–valve joint. Do not
use a valve as a jack to pull pipe into alignment. Te installation procedure should
minimize the bending of the valve–pipe connection with pipe loading.
A.5.7. Te discs of butterfy valves, when in the fully open position, intrude
into the adjacent upstream and downstream piping or other adjacent devices. Tis
can especially be an issue with adjacent pipe having interior linings and with poly-
ethylene transmission pipe. Te piping system designer should check the valve
manufacturer’s recommendations for minimum pipe internal diameter for disc
clearance and be sure that the adjacent pipe internal diameters are sufcient to
accommodate the fully open discs.
A.5.8 Buried valves installed with valve boxes should be installed so that
the valve box does not transmit shock or stress to the valve actuator as a result of
shifting soil or trafc load.
A.5.9 When valves are installed in vaults, the vault design should provide
space for removal of the valve-actuator assembly for purposes of repair and for
access to adjust the thrust bearing assembly. Te possibility of groundwater or
surface water entering the vault and the disposal of the water should be considered.
Te valve-operating nut should be accessible from the top opening of the vault with
a tee wrench.
A.5.10 Butterfy valves are self-contained devices that may not function
properly or remain tight if subjected to external forces. If a valve is rigidly installed
in a pipeline using fanged joints, the whole assembly of pipe and valves can be
stressed by temperature changes, settlement, and exceptional surface loads. To pre-
vent a valve from being strained, there must be at least one fexible joint installed
on each side of the valve between the valve fange and the frst pipe support, as close
as deemed practical to the valve fange. Tis connection prevents piping moments
from being transmitted through the valve body, which minimizes the potential for
overstressing the valve fanges and defecting the body shell.
A.5.11 When buried, the valve should be bolted to fanges of the adjacent
piping with no other rigid support provided under or around the valve body. In no
case should the valve body be supported directly by a saddle or other structure. In
this condition, the valve becomes an anchor or a support for the piping system and
must transmit piping loads.
tor speed-control devices. When using a power tool to operate a manual actuator,
maintain an input shaft speed typical of manual operation.