RXUK TOP500 2020 v2
RXUK TOP500 2020 v2
RXUK TOP500 2020 v2
TOP500
In partnership with
Get started at
sales@klarna.co.uk
INTRODUCTION
OUR METRICS
Our research covered seven Performance Dimensions (see page 44 for more details):
Performance clusters beyond their variation in size, reach We are grateful to SimilarWeb
We’ve ranked the UK Top500 and turnover. Throughout 2019, we for sharing data on the visits and
in statistically similar groups. will be continuing our testing and interaction that Top500 websites
Elite retailers have performed measurement of the whole group, receive, and to Pi Datametrics for
at an exceptional level across all with our findings contributing to the sharing data on brand search terms.
Dimensions, statistically separate 2020 ranking.
from the subsequent clusters. In 2019
they are Amazon, Argos, Dunelm, Elite retailers
John Lewis, Marks & Spencer and Judgement Congratulations once more to the
Next. Our congratulations to new Elite Our current system started with the InternetRetailing UK Top500 Elite
retailers Dunelm and Next, to Marks IRUK Top500 in 2015. Since then, retailers for 2019: Amazon, Argos,
& Spencer, which returns to the Elite research methods and metrics have Dunelm, John Lewis, Marks &
after three previous inclusions, and developed steadily. The criteria Spencer and Next.
to Amazon, Argos and John Lewis regarded as cutting edge this year
on retaining their positions from last will necessarily differ from those Ian Jindal,
year. Amazon has the distinction of of last year, since many one- time Editor-in-Chief
being the only retailer to have been innovations have now moved firmly
ranked Elite in all six of the Top500 mainstream.
reports published to date.
Top50 retailers bring us to the
50-retailer point and represent the Knowledge partners
current standard of UK best practice We thank BuiltWith for tracking the
in ecommerce and multichannel Top500’s websites and providing
retailing, exemplifying RetailCraft at information on the software used,
its best. such as ecommerce platform and
Between the Top100 and the payment methods; and Eggplant for
Top500, retailers are grouped in a measuring the performance and load
way that expresses their measured times of Top500 websites on mobile
performance in a way that goes and desktop browsers.
CONTENTS
CONTENTS TABLES
The RXUK Top500 2020 6 1 Research at a glance 4
The Top500 in graphics 8 2 Leading retailers: Strategy & Innovation 19
From our partner 11 3 Leading retailers: The Customer 23
Interview: Doug Gurr of Amazon on customer obsession 12 4 Leading retailers: Operations & Logistics 25
Elite and leading retailers 14 5 Leading retailers: Merchandising 28
New and bubbling under 15 6 Leading retailers: Brand Engagement 31
Strategic overview: The factors driving UK retail change 16 7 Twenty brands with the biggest UK search growth 31
Strategy & Innovation: Strategically thinking 18 8 Leading retailers: Mobile & Cross-channel 33
The Customer: Shopper-friendly retailing 21 9 Definitions 44
Operations & Logistics: How the delivery promise is evolving 24 10 Our metrics 45
Merchandising: Product information 27
Brand Engagement: Engage with customers 30
Mobile & Cross-channel: Convenient service across channels 33 FIGURES
How the store experience is changing 36 1 Top500 sectors 8
Delivery as a service 38 2 Marketplaces, brands, others in the Top500 8
Case studies: H&M and JD Sports 40 3 The most popular ecommerce platforms 8
How the RXUK Top500 fits into RetailX research 42 4 How the Top500 has performed since 2016 9
What constitutes a retailer? 44 5 How the overall index has developed since 2016 9
Research parameters 45 6 Average performance by sector 9
Knowledge partners 46 7 Average performance by Top500 cluster 9
Conclusion 47 8 More mobile apps have predictive search 19
9 How fast retailers respond to queries 22
10 Retailers choose delivery for next-day service 25
11 Fewer retailers offer brand filtering of searches 28
12 Few retailers have digitised their stores 34
13 The RetailX portfolio 43
14 Marketplaces see more UK web traffic 43
TOP 350 TOP 350 TOP 500 TOP 500 TOP 500
ANTHROPOLOGIE HEMA ATS EUROMASTER GAK PHOTOBOX
ARCO HOLLISTER AGENT PROVOCATEUR GOG.COM PLANET ORGANIC
AUSTIN REED HUGHES ELECTRICAL ALDI GARMIN PLAYSTATION STORE
AVON ITS ARIA TECHNOLOGY GEOX PLUMBASE
BALENCIAGA INTERFLORA ARMANI GLASSES DIRECT PRADA
BANANA REPUBLIC JOY ASICS GOPRO PRINTING.COM
BATHSTORE LAITHWAITE'S ASPINAL OF LONDON GOOGLE PRO-DIRECT
BENSONS FOR BEDS LANDS' END ASUS GRAZE PROTYRE
BURBERRY LEGO BT SHOP GUESS RALPH LAUREN
COS LINDEX BANG GOOD HACKETT RAPHA
CALENDAR CLUB LINKS OF LONDON BARBOUR HAWES & CURTIS RAZER
CARD FACTORY MANDM DIRECT BAREMINERALS HEAL'S REDBUBBLE
CARPETRIGHT MANGO BARKER & STONEHOUSE HERMÈS REGATTA OUTDOOR CLOTHING
CATH KIDSTON MAX SPIELMANN BERRY BROS. & RUDD HOBBY LINK JAPAN RICH TONE MUSIC
CEX MICHAEL KORS BETTYS HOTLINE ROWLANDS PHARMACY
CHAOS CARDS MOLE VALLEY FARMERS BLACKWELL'S INTERSPORT THE ROYAL MINT
CHARLES CLINKARD MONKI BOSE J CREW SCS
CLINIQUE MONTBLANC BRANDON HIRE STATION JML SCOTCH & SODA
COAST MUSIC MAGPIE BROWNS FASHION JTF SCRIBBLER
COSTCO MUSTO BUILD-A-BEAR WORKSHOP JACQUES VERT SEE TICKETS
THE COTSWOLD COMPANY NELLY.COM CARHARTT JEWSON SEVENOAKS SOUND AND VISION
CROCS NESPRESSO CHRISTIAN LOUBOUTIN JIMMY CHOO SNEAKERSNSTUFF
CYCLESURGERY NET-A-PORTER CHURCH'S JOHN SMITH'S STEAM
DEICHMANN NINTENDO CLINTONS JUNO RECORDS STUDIO (EXPRESS GIFTS)
DEMON TWEEKS NOTONTHEHIGHSTREET.COM CONVERSE KENZO SUNGLASS HUT
DIESEL NOVATECH CRABTREE & EVELYN KIEHL’S SUPREME
DIOR ORVIS CRAGHOPPERS KÄRCHER SWAROVSKI
DREAMS PERSONALISED GIFT SHOP CROMWELL L.K.BENNETT SWATCH
DULUX DECORATOR CENTRES PRETTY GREEN CRUISE LN-CC TATE SHOP
END. PUMA CULT BEAUTY LA PERLA THOMAS PINK
EBUYER.COM QVC DFS LEEKES TIMPSON
EURONICS RS COMPONENTS DELL LENOVO TOMTOM
F.HINDS THE RANGE DENBY LOAF TRIUMPH
FITNESS SUPERSTORE ROHAN DESIGUAL LOGITECH UK FLOORING DIRECT
FLANNELS ROMWE DIGIKEY LYLE & SCOTT UNITED COLORS OF BENETTON
FOSSIL RUSSELL & BROMLEY DISTINCTIVE DOORS MADE.COM VAPE CLUB
FOYLES SAMSUNG DOBBIES GARDEN CENTRES MENNACE VERSACE
FRASER HART SLATERS DOLLS KILL MOBILE PHONES DIRECT VITALSOURCE
FRENCH CONNECTION SOLETRADER DOVER STREET MARKET MOONPIG VIVIENNE WESTWOOD
G-STAR RAW STRADIVARIUS ECCO MUJI WARREN JAMES
GAMES WORKSHOP SURFDOME FARROW & BALL MUSCLE FOOD WATCHES OF SWITZERLAND
GANT TJ HUGHES FENDI NATIONAL TRUST SHOP WATCHFINDER
HMV.COM TIFFANY & CO. FIELD & TREK NEPTUNE WEDGWOOD
HP TOAST FIRED EARTH NEW BALANCE WEST ELM
HABITAT UK ECIG STORE FITFLOP OAKLEY WISH
HAMLEYS WALLS AND FLOORS FITBIT OPONEO WOLSELEY
HARRODS WEEKDAY FOOTPATROL THE ORIGINAL FACTORY SHOP WYEVALE GARDEN CENTRES
HARVEYS WYNSORS WORLD OF SHOES FORBIDDEN PLANET PC SPECIALIST YANKEE CANDLE
HATTONS YOOX FRED PERRY PATAGONIA YESSTYLE
HAWKSHEAD COUNTRY WEAR & OTHER STORIES FUNKYPIGEON.COM PEPE JEANS LONDON YVESSAINTLAURENT
FIGURE 1. FOUR IN TEN OF THE TOP500 Many Top500 retailers sell goods across several different sectors.
SELL FASHION PRODUCTS The ‘other’ category illustrates the diversity of the retail industry
FIGURE 2. ALMOST FOUR IN TEN TOP500 RETAILERS FIGURE 3. SALESFORCE AND MAGENTO ENTERPRISE ARE THE
ARE DIRECT-SELLING BRANDS MOST POPULAR ECOMMERCE PLATFORMS USED BY THE TOP500
Researched in collaboration with RetailX knowledge partner BuiltWith
7
16.0%
29.2%
182
14.6%
311
6.0%
9.4%
6.2%
9.2% 9.4%
Sell mostly third-party label products
Sell mostly own-label products
Salesforce Commerce Cloud IBM Websphere Commerce
Operate marketplaces
Magento Enterprise Oracle Commerce
Amplience Magento
Hybris Other
MEASURING PERFORMANCE
We score performance in tests to create an index value. The Aggregated Index Value (AIV) is the sum of the test results. This gives
us a way to compare performance by using relative AIV. It’s these relative values – between years, sectors, or clusters – that this
page shows. A higher AIV represents greater capability and performance. Our benchmarking suggests that Top500 performance
has markedly improved in most areas in recent years
Brand Operations
Engagement & Logistics
Dimension Dimension
2016
2016 Merchandising 2017
FIGURE 6. AVERAGE PERFORMANCE BY SECTOR
2017 Dimension 2018
2018
The Average Index Value by sector where 1.0 is the theoretical
2019
maximum. Some retailers belong
2020
to multiple sectors; sectors with
2019
20 or more retailers are shown
2020
Member
INTRODUCTION
Beauty & Cosmetics brands have long relied on celebrity endorsements to promote
products and department stores to sell products. This is changing. While the rise of online
Welcome to the RetailX Sector Analyst
Reports, where we combine RetailX’s
RX001: February 2020
shopping has had less of a direct impact on the Beauty & Cosmetics sector than might four years of in-depth company per-
be expected1, department stores – a key physical channel to consumers for Beauty & formance research with analysis of the
Cosmetics brands – have borne the brunt of the shift to online retail. The indirect impact sector dynamics.
on the Beauty & Cosmetics sector has been a loss of consumer coverage.
Our reports outline the strategic and
Beauty & Cosmetics companies have responded by investing in direct-to-consumer (D2C) commercial context in which the best
business models, as well as by setting up internal venture capital funds to capitalise on retailers and brands perform in their
the potential from startup brands and technology vendors. Disruptive startups, such as market sectors. RetailDNA Solutions Library
Revolution Beauty, are challenging the status quo by adopting Fast Fashion techniques.
tions
mer
gy
duct
YouTube, Instagram and other social media platforms have impacted on how consumers Let us know of sectors you would like to Functional Categories
Strate
Opera
Custo
perceive celebrity, leading to the rise of social influencers. Some of these have gone on see us cover: research@retailx.net
Pro
to develop their own product ranges, notably Huda Kattan, who in 2018 was ranked 37th
1. Product Development and Design
on the Forbes list of America’s richest self-made women2.
DEFINITION 2. Buying and Sourcing
SHARELINES DIRECT-TO-CONSUMER OR D2C COMMERCE 3. Merchandising and inbound logistics
The rise of ecommerce has only indirectly impacted Beauty & Cosmetics is when brands sell or promote their
products directly to consumers rather than 4. Inventory Management and Distribution
Celebrity marketing has been disrupted and diluted by the rise of influencers via wholesalers and retailers.
The companies covered in this report are, on average, 100+ years old 5. Business Management
ONLINE SALES In 2018, these represented
Leading Beauty & Cosmetics companies are now operating internal VC funds c12.5% of the Beauty & Cosmetics market 6. Marketing
11. Retention
TL;DR 12. Growth and Market Development
The internet abbreviation ‘TL;DR’ means ‘Too Long; Didn’t Read’. In that spirit, here THOMAS ANDERSSON
13. Test and Optimise
are some consideration points from this report: thomas@retailx.net
• been
Beauty & Cosmetics companies have
indirectly impacted by the shift to
new influencer-driven brands. This has
recently extended into technology
Thomas is a retail sector analyst
with more than a decade of
experience starting and divesting a multichannel
14. Physical Retail
multichannel retailing but the effect on investments, such as L’Oréal’s acquisition retail business. He is a grants evaluator for
• Social
methods of RetailX’s research
media has had a fundamental Cosmetics companies as they evolve Blue Papers focus on solutions to commercial opportunities and Publisher: InternetRetailing InternetRetailing
challenges in multichannel retail and digital direct sales. 123 Cannon Street
impact on the sector. The rise of their business models CEO: Ian Jindal
• RetailX Our White Papers, Sector Reports and Top500 performance London, EC4N 5AU
influencers has diluted the marketing forecasts a further move towards
CEO: Ian Jindal Editor: Alex Sword
power of celebrities while increasing the Head of Research: Martin Shaw rankings set out the board-level discussion for commercial success Tel: 020 7062 2525
D2C, which will continue as the relative Senior Analyst: Thomas Andersson Section: Payments and our Blue Papers examine the point solutions, technologies Commercial Director:
number of relationships that brands need Web: www.internetretailing.net
importance of ecommerce over the Commercial Director: Andy James and systems that form part of the solution. Andy James
to manage Vendor: Klarna andy.james@internetretailing.net
high street grows. This move will be Design: Marzena Zychowicz
• Beauty
Drawn from our comprehensive industry directory of technologies
In the last five years, four of the Top 10 further accelerated by entry into new Address: RetailX, 123 Cannon Street Product: Pay later and services in use by our Top500, RetailDNA, our Blue Papers Designer: Julia Webber
London, EC4N 5AU
& Cosmetics companies have geographical markets where there are form a regularly-updated library of actionable, proven solutions.
© 2019 RetailX Limited
created internal venture funds to acquire no historical reseller relations
DENMARK 2020
eCommerce Market Report
With regards,
Ian Jindal
Editor-in-Chief, InternetRetailing
Webinars Events
Amazon is halfway through a year-long pilot to use pop-up stores to work with smaller retailers that have built their businesses online. It is working
with Enterprise National to launch ten ‘Clicks and Mortar’ over a year. The first, shown above, opened in Manchester in June, and represented a
move onto the UK’s high street for a retailer that has previously sold only online. About 100 small businesses – the kind of businesses that already
sell on its marketplace website – are expected to sell through Clicks and Mortar shops. In 2018, 58% of products sold on Amazon’s site were sold
by smaller sellers
Such investment is set to continue with the type of retailers that sell on
well into the future. “In 2020 and beyond, its own website (see picture caption
we will keep innovation competitive by “We are delighted to be included above). “In June 2019, we launched
continued investment in hiring and in the RetailX UK Top500. At Clicks and Mortar, a pilot programme
training a diverse workforce,” says to help up-and-coming online brands
Gurr. “At Amazon, we believe the key Amazon, we have a relentless sell in store for the first time,” says
to innovation is diversity – whether focus on the best selection, Gurr.” By working with small business
that is having global R&D (research support network Enterprise Nation,
and development) teams across
prices and buying experience we have helped more than a hundred
geographies to understand local issues, for our customers, so it is a small online businesses test physical
or encouraging more women to enter retail for the first time with Clicks and
STEM (science, technology, engineering
great privilege to be included Mortar pop-ups in Manchester, Cardiff,
and mathematics) careers through as a top retailer” Doug Gurr, UK Edinburgh, Sheffield and Leeds, with
our Amazon Amplify programme. We country chair, Amazon more to come this year.”
want to attract and retain the best and Despite the retailer’s success so far, it
brightest talent across the world to says it won’t rest on its laurels. Instead,
foster greater innovation and raise the it still believes there’s much more to
bar for customers.” Gurr points out that in December 2019, do. “At Amazon, we often say, ‘It’s still
only 21.3% of UK retail sales were Day One’,” says Gurr. “We’ve only just
made online, according to the Office begun and there’s still so much more to
Why stores matter for National Statistics (ONS). That come. In truth, none of us know where
Despite its role as a pureplay retailer, suggests, he says, that, “79% of UK customers will take us next. That is a
Amazon is clear that it represents shopping by value remains in physical challenge, but an exciting one, and that
only one part of retail, and that shops stores.” The Amazon response? To is the beauty of innovating on behalf of
remain important to its customers. launch its own stores in partnership our customers.”
Stand-out performers
Multichannel retailers dominate the RXUK Top500, where pureplays can compete
only due to exceptional performance, primarily in operations and logistics
The RetailX Top500 – previously the occasions. But Dunelm moves straight up to the
InternetRetailing Top500 – has tracked the top echelon, having been classed as a Leading
leading ecommerce and multichannel retailers retailer on only one previous occasion, in 2018.
that sell in the UK since 2015. At the top of the Elite retailers Amazon and John Lewis can be
index are two groups that highlight the very classified as ‘department’ type retailers, selling
best performing retailers in UK retail. The across a number of distinct categories. The
Elite group features those at the cutting edge same is true, to an extent, for Marks & Spencer,
of performance, while Leading retailers are which sells clothing, homewares and food, and
those that demonstrate best practice across also Next, which trades in the fashion and
their businesses. Both lists change from year homewares categories. While Dunelm too has
to year, driven in part by the metrics selected a department-style structure, that structure is
in the Strategy & Innovation Dimension to best firmly focused around homewares.
reflect retail state-of-the-art. It’s notable that this year there are no
supermarkets ranked Elite, after three years
in which at least one grocer, variously Asda,
Elite retailers Sainsbury’s and Tesco, has consistently
Six retailers appear in this year’s Elite group: appeared in this ranking.
Amazon, Argos, Dunelm, John Lewis, Marks &
Spencer and Next. Amazon is the only retailer
to have appeared in the Top500 Elite every year Leading retailers
since the index was first compiled in 2015. Its The Leading group this year features 19
six top rankings are significant because it is retailers. Fashion clothing is the largest
the only online-only retailer ever to have been category to be represented in the group. Asos
named an Elite retailer, reflecting the way it is the only pureplay in a group of five that also
has used its performance in Operations and includes Dorothy Perkins, H&M, New Look and
Logistics to rival those with stores. River Island.
That’s because a company’s size, as measured Asda, Sainsbury’s and Tesco all appear from
in the Footprint Dimension, accounts for 30% of the supermarket sector, while health and
its ranking in the Top500 – and most of the UK’s beauty is represented by Boots, Holland &
largest retailers are multichannel, selling both Barrett and Space NK – the latter making its
online and through shops. first appearance.
Argos and John Lewis come closest to Trade and DIY tools and equipment retailers
rivalling Amazon’s track record. Both appear are well represented by B&Q, Toolstation and
in this category for the fifth time, having been Wickes. Wilko also makes an appearance,
ranked Elite all but one year. Argos was ranked although it also sells in categories from health
Leading in 2017, as was John Lewis in 2018. and beauty through to stationery, crafts and
Marks & Spencer is ranked an Elite retailer toys. Footwear retailer Schuh is ranked Leading
for the fourth time, having been ranked Leading for the fourth time, sports clothing businesses
in 2016 and 2019. Next and Dunelm both JD Sports and Evans Cycles both for the second
appear for the first time. Next has previously time, and outdoor retailer Blacks makes its first
been classed as a Leading retailer on four appearance in the group.
UK retailers are working steadily to improve their retail landscape. David Fox, co-head of retail
performance online and across retail channels agency at Colliers, has said that CVA usage
as they trade at this time of ‘retail crisis’. Yet a has lowered rents, threatening the viability of
challenging environment appears to be fostering shopping centres. One international retailer,
both innovation and a fresh commitment to IKEA, is reported to have benefited from bargain
giving shoppers the retail experiences that prices to buy a London shopping centre. It now
work for them, whether they prefer to buy and plans to open its own small format store in
browse in-store or online from desktop or mobile Hammersmith King’s Mall.
websites and apps, or social media, or across all
the channels that are relevant to them.
Thinking strategically
Retailers stand out in the Strategy & Innovation Dimension when they are early to
adopt significant new technologies and enable convenient shopper experiences
Jewellery +23pp
Shopper-friendly retailing
In The Customer Dimension, RetailX researchers measure both user experience
on retail websites and customer service from the customer’s point of view
Designing retail from the shopper’s point of view HOW EASY IS IT FOR CUSTOMERS TO GET IN TOUCH
can help boost sales. When retailers make it easy WITH RETAILERS?
for existing and potential customers to buy from
them, it’s more likely that they will do so. In The Communication channels
Customer Dimension, RetailX researchers explore When shoppers want to contact a Top500 retailer they
both the customer experience and the customer can choose to do so through an average of 10 channels,
service that Top500 retailers provide. They look at from telephone and email to live chat on their website or
whether, and how, retailers deploy tools that they mobile app and direct messages on social media. But once
judge will make the experience easier. And they a retailer offers the channel, how easy is it for shoppers
look at this across channels from the mobile web to find the information they need in order to get in touch?
and mobile apps to customer service. Researchers RetailX research found that just under a third (30%) of
measure performance in this area across 36 retailers show their contact phone number on their landing
metrics covering areas from how customer page, but only 7% show a contact email on that page, while
service is offered and how fast service teams almost all have a ‘contact us’ page with these details or a
answer shoppers’ questions through to website web submission form.
speeds, one-click ordering, product ratings and One in five retailers (23%) offer live chat on their website,
returns policies. and 11% prompt shoppers for a chat within a minute of
The findings are presented below through two them arriving on the landing page. Fewer – at 8% – offer
key questions. First, how easy do retailers make live chat on their mobile app. Of the 183 retailers with apps
it for customers to get in touch? This is important that were assessed both in 2020 and in 2019, uptake of
for shoppers both before and after they buy. live chat on the app grew by one percentage point (1pp),
Before buying, they can use different channels to from 7%. Live chat is most commonly found in mobile
apps in the sports and outdoor equipment category: 14%
ask questions about a product. Before they buy,
of retailers in this category use it, following growth of 2pp
shoppers may also look to see how they will be
over the year from 12% last year. That’s followed by sports
able to get in touch if an order goes wrong.
and leisure clothing (11%). Use has also grown among those
Certainly if they have after sales questions, they
selling trade and DIY tools and equipment (+4pp to 9%). But
will want to get in touch via a range of channels.
live chat is less likely than last year to be found on mobile
How a query is dealt with is likely to have an
apps operated by those selling fashion accessories (-2pp
effect on whether they return to buy again – and
to 7%), and cosmetics (-2pp to 8%). Live chat’s reduced
so response times matter as well as the number
usage in sectors where customer preference is subjective
of communication channels. Websites – on
will surprise some but could reveal that retailers do not view
desktop and mobile – are the primary source of
live chat interactions as analogous to a product-oriented
information for shoppers, and so the speeds at
conversation with an in-store sales representative. Instead,
which they operate are an important part of the
retailers may view live chat as providing operations-type
customer experience.
customer support covering delivery queries or returns, for
The second question is: how easy is it for
example. Finally, three sectors used live chat to the same
shoppers to find, choose and buy a product? This
extent as last year: home and industrial appliances (9%),
area of enquiry looks at how retailers support
homewares (10%) and jewellery (11%).
customers in finding the right item – and how easy
they make it to buy and return that product. All are Response times
important areas of the customer journey – getting Researchers tested customer service quality by sending
them right can make a big difference to customers’ a simple email enquiry (through a form on the retailer’s
satisfaction with their shopping experience. website, if that option was available) and making a phone
FIGURE 9. AVERAGE RESPONSE TIMES FOR RETAILERS TO AN EMAIL OR WEB FORM QUERY
100
80
60
Number of retailers
40
20
0
0-5H 5-10H 10-15H 15-20H 20-25H 25-30H 30-35H 35-40H 40-45H 45-50H 50-55H 55-60H 60-65H 65-70H
Average response time (hours)
call, again with a simple request for information on retailer. RetailX research in collaboration with knowledge
the retailer’s services. Emails were answered in an partner Eggplant found that Top500 websites were visually
average of 17 hours 35 mins (up to a maximum of 72 complete on desktop browsers in an average of 9.8s and
hours - responses after this time were considered non- took an average of 10.3s to download fully. The median
responses) and a median of 12h 59m. The time taken visual completion time of 9s was the same in both years,
to respond was higher than last year, with the median but the median download time of 9.68s is 1s slower in
response time up by 175 minutes – or two hours 55 2020 than a year earlier. Download speed is related to the
minutes – on the previous year. Response times were size of websites: desktop websites were an average of
faster than last year among those selling sports and 3.1MB, and a median of 2.8MB in size in 2020. In 2020,
leisure footwear (-48 minutes to 14 hours and 47 minutes) the median size was 38,500 bytes more than in 2010.
and sports and leisure clothing (-118m to 13 hours and Leading retailers’ landing pages are visually complete in
33 minutes). But they slowed down among those selling just over a second, although they often take a few more
homewares (+410m to 13 hours and seven minutes) and seconds to finish loading some aspects of the page. It’s
trade and DIY tools and equipment (+333m to 10 hours this prioritisation of content, more than the volume of
and eight minutes). content (and size in MB) that separates the best retailers
A call to customer service took an average of 2m 32s from the rest at website performance.
and a median of 2m (120s) to complete. Researchers rated On mobile, websites were visually complete in an average
the service they received at a median four out of four and of 8.36s, and took an average of 8.98s to download fully.
the degree to which the issue they raised was resolved at The faster mobile download speed in comparison to desktop
four. Both measures stayed the same as last year. It’s a can be explained by the finding that they were lighter than
mixed bag but, in general, retailers are responding more desktop sites, at an average of 2.6MB and a median of
slowly to consumer requests for information this year than 2.3MB. But mobile websites remained at similar speeds
last. It’s a basic performance metric but one of the few in as in 2019: the median time to visual completion (8s) and
which the average retailer isn’t improving. to full download (8s) stayed the same.
Looking at how deeply shoppers engage with retailers,
Website speed RetailX knowledge partner SimilarWeb finds that visitors
The speed of a website is key to customer service online accessed an average of 9.77 pages per session, spending
since those sites are one of the customer’s primary sources an average of 5m 25s on the Top500’s websites. Just
of information on a retailer and the products they sell and, under a third of visits (31%) to the average Top500 website
more importantly, is a key sales channel for almost every bounce; the median website sees 27% bounce.
and in 2020 more retailers than ever are matching this level
HOW EASY IS IT FOR SHOPPERS TO FIND, CHOOSE
of speed and convenience. A good customer experience
AND BUY A PRODUCT?
during the return process can be the difference in a shopper
Finding the right product trying to purchase from the same retailer again. By law,
Finding a product is easier when shoppers have good retailers must give their customers 14 days, or two weeks,
navigation tools to hand. The simple three-line ‘hamburger’ to return a product they bought online. Top500 retailers
menu is fast becoming standard on mobile websites, and in give shoppers an average of 10 weeks (70 days) to return
2020, 94% of Top500 mobile sites feature this. That’s up by a product, but the median is much lower at 3.7 weeks (26
six percentage points (pp) from 88% in 2019. The feature days). Some individual retailers offer their customers as
was adopted most quickly by those selling stationery and long as a year to return a product, a figure that is likely to
craft materials (+17pp to 88%) – although this remains distort the average.
the sector with the lowest uptake – and by those selling
children’s toys and accessories (+13pp to 92%) and home
and industrial appliances (+13pp to 95%). The feature
is most common among grocers (92%). RetailX head
of research Martin Shaw says: “It’s emblematic of the
continuing adoption by many in the Top500 of mobile-first
browsing – which until recently was only a buzzword to
hundreds of the UK’s largest retailers. In 2020, perhaps
for the first time, we can say that the Top500 in general,
rather than just the Top100, are mobile-first or, at least,
mobile-optimised retailers.”
Shoppers can now see how other customers rated
products on more than half (55%) of websites – up by
2pp from 53% in 2019. Product ratings are now most
common among grocers (+10pp to 73%), those selling
health products (+8pp to 72%), and trade and DIY tools
and equipment (71%). Product ratings are least deployed by
retailers selling in categories where opinions are perhaps
very subjective, including jewellery (40%), fashion clothing
(40%) and fashion footwear (42%). The fastest declines
in the use of product ratings were among those selling
home and industrial appliances (-7pp to 67%) and sports
and outdoor equipment (-4pp to 77%).
When it comes to making product suggestions, 39% of
retailers recommend a product that complements the one
that shoppers are looking at. Just 5% enable shoppers to
add an image to their product review.
Buying and returning items
One in five (20%) of retailers enable shoppers who have
already registered their details to buy in just one click.
Leading retailers have offered such services for years now
Saturday delivery FIGURE 10. RETAILERS INCREASINGLY CHOOSE DELIVERY WHEN OFFERING
The use of Saturday delivery is also slightly less popular, NEXT-DAY FULFILMENT
with 27% of retailers offering this service in 2020, down
Next-day fulfilment is one of the most expensive and competitive operations
from 30% a year earlier. It has most commonly fallen off
for retailers. In 2020, they’re more likely than ever to offer next-day delivery
among those selling sports and outdoor equipment (-9pp
but the same is not true for next-day collection, which is less popular this year
to 22%), home and industrial appliances (-8pp to 23%)
and sports and leisure clothing (-7pp to 19%). Retailers offering next-day delivery Retailers offering next-day collection
Customers buying groceries (30% of grocery retailers 100% 100%
offer the service), cosmetics (28%) and homewares (28%)
are most likely to be able to order for Saturday delivery,
while those buying sports and leisure footwear (21%),
jewellery (21%) and sports and leisure clothing (19%)
58% 61%
are least likely.
Sunday delivery
Sunday delivery is also less available in 2020 (11%) than 26%
19%
in 2019 (13%). Among the different shopping categories,
those selling fashion footwear (-3pp to 12%), fashion 0%
Jan 2019 Jan 2020
0%
Jan 2019 Jan 2020
accessories (-3pp to 11%) and jewellery (-3pp to 9%)
were most likely to stop offering the delivery service.
Sunday delivery is most common among retailers selling
groceries (+1pp to 16%) and consumer electronics (-2pp
to 13%) and least common at retailers selling jewellery
(-3pp to 9%), sports and outdoor equipment (-1pp to 8%), ARE ATTITUDES TO COLLECTION CHANGING?
and stationery and craft (+0pp to 1%). Click and collect is slightly less easy to find in 2020 than
in 2019, while it now takes slightly longer for retailers
Delivery costs to deliver online orders to stores or other locations for
The cost of delivery is higher in 2020 than in 2019. This collection. The more significant change is that quick
year, the median standard delivery charge at Top500 turnaround times from order to collection are much less
retailers is £4.50, up from £3.80 in 2019. The cheapest available than they were last year.
standard delivery charges are found at retailers selling Martin Shaw, RetailX head of research, says it probably
consumer electronics (median of £2.90), stationery and makes more sense for retailers to invest in competitive
craft (£2.90) and health products (£2.90). The highest delivery options than in collection. “However convenient
costs are found among those selling fashion clothing collection is, the consumer still has to do a lot of the
(median £3.80, average £4.60), homewares (median legwork,” he notes. “Not so with delivery. Consumers
£3.90, average £8.20) and trade and DIY tools and time and again say in surveys that they like collection,
equipment (median £4.70, average £4.90). but the evidence suggests that they don’t like it enough,
The median minimum order value for free delivery has when compared to other options, for retailers to invest in
stayed at £40 in 2020, the same as in 2019. Standard those systems as much as in delivery, which continues
delivery takes an average of 4.7 days. to become more speedy and customisable, in terms of
time and location, across the Top500.”
selling trade and DIY tools and equipment (-13pp to 23% HOW ARE RETURNS POLICIES CHANGING?
from 36% last year), consumer electronics (-14pp to
Under UK law, consumers can return an item they bought
21%), and sports and outdoor equipment (-14pp to 22%).
online within two weeks for a refund. Yet many retailers go
At the other extreme, it is slightly less available among
well behind this legal minimum, with the average Top500
those selling fashion footwear and jewellery (both -3pp
retailer offering 70 days – or 10 weeks – for shoppers to
to 21%) and stationery and craft products (-3pp to 14%).
change their mind. That’s likely to be a deciding factor for
Same-day collection many as they consider where to buy, with how easy it is to
The availability of speedy same-day collection has fallen make a return another key issue for shoppers.
fast during the last year – across all sectors. 7% of Top500
Returning to different locations
retailers offer the service in 2020, down by 4pp from 11%
Sending an item back in the post is the single most common
last year. It is most reduced among those selling children’s
way that shoppers can return unwanted online orders,
toys and accessories (-6pp to 10%), sports and outdoor
with this option advertised by 67% of Top500 retailers in
equipment (-6pp to 9%) and consumer electronics (-8pp
2020. That’s followed by returning to one of the retailer’s
to 8%). Availability has reduced more slowly among those
stores (43% of multichannel retailers) which is down by a
selling fashion clothing (-2pp to 3%), cosmetics (-2pp to
significant 5pp from 48% in 2019.
4%) and fashion accessories (-2pp to 4%).
In 2020, more retailers enable their customers to make
How long does collection take? their return via a third-party location, with 25% doing so in
The standard time between placing an order and collecting 2020, up from 20% a year earlier. The greatest changes
the product in-store rose by four hours to a median of 73 are to be seen in the sports and leisure footwear (+10pp to
hours – just over three days. The median time to pick-up 40%), fashion clothing (+9pp to 35%), sports and leisure
reduced by 10 hours to 55 hours (just over two days) clothing (+9pp to 37%) and fashion footwear (+8pp to
among those selling children’s toys and accessories but 38%) categories.
increased among those selling sports and leisure clothing Return via pick-up from the house continues to be offered
(+14h to 86 hours), footwear (+16h to 86) and home and by a small but significant minority (15%) of retailers.
industrial appliances (+21h to 77).
Pre-paid returns
Third-party collection points Significantly more retailers now underwrite the cost of
Collecting online orders at a third-party collection point sending back an unwanted online order. In 2020, 38% of
remains relatively uncommon in 2020 since almost two- retailers offered pre-paid returns. That’s up by 16pp on
thirds (65.8%, or 329) of retailers do not offer this service the 22% which did so in 2019. The trend was visible in all
to shoppers. But 125 retailers (25%) do enable pick-up at sectors, with the biggest rises in jewellery (+26pp to 36%),
one or more third-party services, while 37 (7.4%) offer sports and leisure clothing (+23pp to 49%), and sports and
at least two, seven retailers (1.4%) offer three, and one outdoor equipment (+22pp to 42%).
retailer (0.2%) offers collection via five networks. The
most commonly used third-party network is Collect+,
used by 68 retailers, or 13.6% of the Top500, followed by
myHermes ParcelShop (46 retailers, 8.6%), DPD collection
point (43, 8.6%), UPS (27, 5.4%), DHL (20, 4%), Doddle (8,
1.6%), HubBox (5, 1%), GLS ParcelShop (3, 0.6%), InPost
parcel lockers (3, 0.6%), and Pass My Parcel (2, 0.4%).
Product information
Retailers lead the Merchandising Dimension when they fully explain their products
to customers and give all the information they need in order to buy
Health -7pp
Cosmetics -8pp
Homeware -6pp
Jewellery -9pp
considering buying, using website navigation and no results on the website, 42% of Top500 websites show
search to narrow down the range on offer, while a blank page, while the remaining 58% show alternative
offering recommendations of other similar products information such as popular or trending products. This
that may be relevant? Second, how well do retailers is an approach thought more likely to result in a sale.
explain the products they sell, and to what extent Emerging technologies in this space include visual
do they enable people who have already bought the search. This year, just 8% of Top500 mobile apps enable
item to share their opinions? Finally, how easy is it shoppers to search using an existing image or one taken
for shoppers to buy an item? Do they have to register using their smartphone’s camera.
before checking out, and what payment options are
available for them to use?
Second, how far do retailers support TABLE 7. THE 20 BRANDS THAT SAW THE BIGGEST GROWTH IN UK SEARCHES
customers in sharing products online? The
‘SHOPDISNEY’, FOR EXAMPLE, WAS SEARCHED 10X MORE IN THE YEAR TO AUGUST 2019
focus is on the extent to which retailers support THAN IT WAS IN THE PREVIOUS 12 MONTHS
product reviews and ratings on both websites and
mobile apps. Third, how easy do retailers make KEYWORD TOTAL SEARCHES PERCENTAGE INCREASE
it for shoppers to check out? Research in this
SHOPDISNEY 101,400 1163%
section takes into account the need to balance
the ease of a guest checkout with the role of the LOOKFANTASTIC 484,300 672%
‘owned’ website in gathering data from opted- VICTORIA'S SECRET 1,091,600 204%
in customers, which is useful for building future
FENDI 985,500 169%
relationships with those shoppers.
Finally, how often do shoppers search for TIFFANY & CO 891,500 155%
retail brands that sell in the UK? The answer WAYFAIR 9,861,000 151%
to this question provides a useful measure of DR MARTENS 2,792,000 147%
how well brands are communicating with their
target audiences. YESSTYLE 523,600 144%
ROMAN ORIGINALS 1,570,500 141%
SEASALT CORNWALL 104,500 137%
AND OTHER STORIES 2,064,000 137%
BAREMINERALS 207,100 134%
TABLE 6. LEADING RETAILERS IN THIS DIMENSION
FLANNELS 5,586,000 132%
ARGOS JOJO MAMAN BÉBÉ
PAVERS 827,500 131%
AVON MARKS & SPENCER
LULULEMON 1,178,500 129%
BOOTS MATALAN
WEEKDAY 633,000 129%
DUNELM NEXT
COTSWOLD COMPANY 523,700 129%
ELLIS BRIGHAM MOUNTAIN OVERCLOCKERS UK
BONMARCHE 1,095,000 129%
SPORTS
MONKI 1,370,000 129%
EVERYTHING5POUNDS.COM SAINSBURY'S
DIOR 883,500 129%
HALFORDS WICKES
HOBBYCRAFT WILKO These 20 Top500 brand keywords enjoyed the biggest rise in searches in the 12 months
to August 2019, measured as a percentage of their total in the previous year. Researched
JD SPORTS THE WORKS
in partnership with Pi Datametrics
Is there mobile
Yes (till-less) payment in-store?
WHAT MULTICHANNEL SERVICES DO No 6%
RETAILERS OFFER?
Retailers offer a more convenient customer experience
when they connect their online business with their stores
and develop a shopping journey that is as seamless as 94%
possible. Shoppers then find it faster and more reliable
to order the product they need online and collect it in a
store. Similarly, when a product is not wanted after all,
Yes
returning to a store or a third-party return point will often No
6%
prove more convenient than sending by mail. This year’s 94%
RetailX research reveals that multichannel retailers are
now less likely to offer collection and returns in their own
stores. For more on these subjects and on delivery, see Does theYesretailer provide digital receipts for
the Operations & Logistics Dimension (page 24). No
in-store purchases?
Click and collect 15%
Slightly fewer retailers now give online shoppers the option
of picking up their order in one of their stores. Some 54%
do so – down from 56% last year. Same-day collection is 94%
less widely available in 2020, with 7% of Top500 retailers
now offering this. That’s down by four percentage points
(pp) from 11% last year. Next-day collection has also
reduced in popularity, with 19% offering it in 2020, down Yes
85% No
by 7pp from 26% last year. 6%
At the same time, the service now takes longer. The
median standard time to collect increased by four hours
to three days and one hour in 2020. But the cost collection And there’s still room for improvement in old-
remained the same, at a median £1. fashioned customer service
Yes
Reserve and collect may offer a useful option for No Were you greeted?
shoppers who prefer to pay as they pick up the order
they placed online. But it seems to be losing its appeal
for retailers. In 2020, just 4% of retailers offer this, down
from 5% in 2019. 39%
94%
One in three (34%) of Top500 retailers now offer to
deliver products to at least one third-party click and collect
service. A quarter (25%) offer collection through one 61%
third-party provider, while 7.4% offer it via two providers Yes
and 1.4% offer it via three. Just 0.2% offer five choices No
of third-party provider.
34 February 2020
Yes
© 2020 retailx.net, distributed by InternetRetailing.net
No
MOBILE & CROSS-CHANNEL
CollectPlus, with 7,000 pick-up points around the UK, UNDERSTANDING THE IN-STORE EXPERIENCE
is the most popular provider, offered by 40% of those RXUK Top500 researchers hit the ground in London during
Top500 retailers who use a third-party provider. That’s the summer of 2019 to find out to what extent stores run
followed by myHermes ParcelShop, with 4,500 pick-up by Top150 retailers incorporate multichannel and digital
points and used by 27% of retailers in this category. A features. They visited a flagship store where possible,
quarter offer DPD, which has 2,500 points, 16% use UPS with each visited twice to ensure accuracy. Not all of the
Access Point, with 2,800 points, 12% use DHL Collection retailers have stores in London, and some are pureplay
Point, while 5% offer Doddle. retailers, but in total, researchers visited 140 stores.
Only 1% enable shoppers to collect their online orders Fifteen per cent of the stores visited were in shopping
from a locker that they own. That’s the same proportion centres, while the remaining 85% were in high street
as did so in 2019. locations with ground floor access. The largest group of
Cross-channel returns stores had one floor (43%), while 36.1% had two floors
Fewer retailers now enable shoppers to return their and 3.5% had six floors.
order to a branch of their own store, yet more now
How digital in-store works in practice
support returns via a third-party provider. In 2020, 43%
Researchers found that 43% of stores had wi-fi. Of those
of retailers enable shoppers to return their online order
stores with wi-fi, 34.8% required a password, and 58%
to a store. That’s down by 5pp on 48% in 2019. But a
required shoppers to register in order to gain access. 9%
quarter (25%)of the Top500 allow customers to return
of the wi-fi networks could be accessed via social media
their order to a third-party location. That’s up by 5pp
credentials, while 12.1% were offered by a third-party,
on the same time last year. Perhaps retailers find that
not directly by the retailer.
it’s more efficient for them to outsource the process, or
Staff were equipped with tablets in 19% of stores, and
perhaps using a third-party operator is likely to be more
staff in the same proportion of stores could reserve an
convenient for shoppers who decided to buy online rather
item available on the website but in that store for later
than in a store in the first place.
collection. Almost half (48%) of stores featured stationary
tablets that customers could browse. Customers were
signposted to a special desk or place to return items in
8.8% of stores.
Of all the stores, 18% featured in-store experiences
while the remaining 82% did not.
Payment
Shoppers could checkout using mobile payment in 6%
of stores, while 2% of stores signposted app checkout.
Self-checkout was available in 3% of stores, and the
retailer provided digital receipts for in-store purchases
in 15% of stores.
The role of UK stores is changing, with the Using existing stores as collection
RXUK Top500 Elite retailers at the forefront of and returns points
this change. At a time when customers want Next’s customers spent more online (£1bn)
to make more of their purchases online, all of with it than they did in its stores (£874.3m) in
the multichannel Elite retailers have rethought the six months to July 2019, but the clothing and
what their shops are for. These retailers are homewares retailer argues that its shops remain
responding to their own experiences which tell vital because so many of its shoppers want to pick
them that while shoppers often want to buy up or return orders there. Simon Wolfson, Next’s
online, at other times they want to visit a store. chief executive, explained in those results that 50%
Argos’ sales, for example, are often made of its online orders are delivered to its shops, while
online – it turned over £2bn from mobile 82% of returns are made via its shops. “It is counter-
transactions alone in its 2018/19 full-year. Yet intuitive,” he said, “but the fact is that stores have
most of its shoppers also visit a store in the become an important part of our online service,
course of their transaction, either to place or although their rents are way out of kilter with the
pick up an online order. Dunelm, meanwhile, has value they provide as collection and returns centres.
moved its online business to a new platform that So if stores are to remain open, retail rents must fall
enables it to offer new multichannel services and, fortunately, that is exactly what they are doing.”
such as click and collect. Dunelm, meanwhile, offers free click and collect
John Lewis says its customers spend more from 170 stores and enables shoppers to return
and remain more loyal when they shop across their online orders in-store as well. Marks &
a number of channels. But as spending with Spencer is looking to a ‘clicks and bricks’ future,
department stores quickly moves online – in which shoppers use both stores and online to
according to the Office for National Statistics, buy in the way that is most convenient for them.
16.8% of department store sales took place Shoppers at its Oban food hall, for example, can
online in December 2019 – John Lewis is use a fitting room to try on the clothes that they
focusing on the in-store experience to persuade buy using click and collect before deciding whether
shoppers to visit. to keep them. John Lewis enables multichannel
Online may have overtaken store sales at returns and collection both at its own stores, at
Next but the retailer says those stores still branches of Waitrose and at third-party shops.
offer valuable multichannel services. Marks & Argos’ digital format stores enable shoppers
Spencer is reconfiguring its store estate to adapt to order and collect items within hours, using its
to how its shoppers now want to spend with it. hub and spoke logistics model. About 300 of these
Eventually, it aims to make a third of its turnover stores are now located within branches of its sister
from the clothing and home categories online. supermarket, Sainsbury’s, while others are in
It is currently reducing its floorspace accordingly, locations including underground stations.
through both reducing the size of its stores Despite being an online-only retailer, Amazon
as well as closures. enables collection and returns to a range of
As these changes occur, here are three key third-party collection points and via its network of
ways that the RXUK Top500 Elite retailers have lockers, some of which are in third-party stores
developed their use of shops: such as Morrisons.
In-store experiences
John Lewis is focused firmly on experiences as
a way to bring visitors to its stores. In November,
the retailer opened its new look ‘customer centric’
Southampton store, which it described as an
‘experience playground’ where shoppers can
listen to talks and take part in workshops offered
by a team that includes interior designers, chefs,
wine experts, gardeners, gadget specialists,
personal stylists and make-up artists. The store
includes the first Waitrose Cookery School within
a branch of John Lewis. Peter Cross, customer
experience director at John Lewis & Partners,
said at the time, “Our goal is to offer customers
Copyright © John Lewis
Delivery as a service
The way leading retailers deliver and enable collections and returns
provides a competitive advantage
the company.”
At the same time, H&M is testing new and
innovative ideas, with a fresh emphasis on
sustainability. Shoppers at its new Stockholm
store, for example, can now rent skirts and
dresses from its Conscious Exclusive collections.
The store is designed to be more inspirational,
displaying images shoppers have shared of how
they wear H&M products. But it’s also convenient,
with payment available through self-service
checkouts. In the Netherlands, H&M is testing a
bicycle delivery option that’s particularly relevant
to that market. In the UK, shoppers can recycle
clothes at any H&M store, receiving a £5 voucher
in exchange for each bag.
H&M’s strategy is about getting closer and more
Copyright © H&M Group
The RetailX Top500 (RXUK Top500) this year has offer a wider and more international range of
a new name – one that reflects its position within goods. It will look at the performance, capabilities
the larger RetailX research and publishing stable. and trends of these direct-to-consumer
The new name for the listing of the UK’s leading marketplaces that are now a vital location in
retailers, previously called the InternetRetailing trading goods, and will assess how both retailers
Top500, comes in the sixth year of publication. and brands can most effectively use them.
It comes as RetailX research refocuses on an Sustainability is a new focus for RetailX
analysis of European and global ecommerce publications, and 2020 will also see the first RetailX
and multichannel retailing that’s at the same Sustainability Report. The report will look at what it
time wider and more in-depth. That analysis means to be sustainable when selling online, and
recognises the place of the UK’s Top500 retailers how retailers can help their customers to achieve
in a connected retail landscape that also includes the reduced carbon footprint that so many now
marketplaces and retail brands, and stretches prioritise. It will build on research already covered
beyond the UK to markets across Europe. in 2020 in a new eDelivery report, Sustainability
after the buy button 2020. That report looks at
delivery emissions and plastic waste and what
Beyond retailers retailers in the UK and Europe can do to reduce
Many online retail sales no longer take place from them - in a context in which shoppers seem
regular retail websites. Rather, as the Sankey chart enthusiastic about protecting the environment but
below shows, regular retailers see only about 34% have as yet done relatively little to change their
of UK web traffic to the Top500 according to data online shopping habits or to pay more to mitigate
researched in collaboration with SimilarWeb. the environmental effects of their purchases.
The largest share (45%) goes to marketplaces,
where a relatively small number of platforms see
almost half of all retail traffic that touches Top500 Beyond the UK
retailers. A smaller share (21%) goes to brands The next RetailX Europe Top500 will bring the
that sell directly to customers. Given these insights latest ranking of leading retailers selling in the 32
into the way that customers shop, it follows that markets of the EEA plus the UK and Switzerland.
RetailX would look further and more closely at As with previous editions, it will assess how
marketplaces and at direct-selling brands. The retailers and brands approach selling to a larger
annual RetailX Brand Index was published late geographic area where customers speak a wider
last year and looks at how brands take on the number of languages and buy in a wider number
challenges of selling directly to their consumers, of currencies, but with regulatory alignment
rather than via third-party retailers. It also lists the within a single market. Case studies analyse how
leading pan-European brands that sell across the the most successful retailers, including Allegro,
countries of the EEA plus the UK and Switzerland. Argos, Darty, H&M, Rue du Commerce and Zara,
Find out more about the RetailX Brand Index 2019 use ecommerce within their businesses. Find out
at internetretailing.net/rxbx. more about the RetailX Europe Top500 report at
In the coming year that will be followed by internetretailing.net/rxeu
the latest edition of the RetailX Europe Top500, Alongside this pan-European coverage, we also
and by the first RetailX Marketplaces report. report in detail on markets worldwide, through
The marketplaces report follows the shopper’s the analyst reports produced by the Netherlands-
attention as it’s drawn towards destinations that based Ecommerce Foundation, now part of the
TOP500 TOP500
In partnership with
In partnership with
www.internetretailing.net
KINGS OF RETAILERS A
CE RAN ND B
ORMAN RAN
RF DS
PE In partnership with 2020 Reports In partnership with 2020 Reports
da
RXPE eCommerce Market Report eCommerce Market Report
TOP500
ta, con
CO
ins ditions by mark tradi
UN
PRIVATE EQUIT Y
ight
Drivers of our industry’s future
CRO ANALYSIS
eCRRX/202001 eCRRX/202001
TRIE
and analysis o
S AND MAR
RESEARCH AND ANALAYSIS FOR
THE RETAIL PROFESSIONAL
MA
RXST
TOP500 2020 Reports 2020 Reports
et
In partnership with In partnership with
n
KET
S
THE SUSTAINABILIT Y REPORT UK 2020 EU 2020
Drivers of our industry’s future eCommerce Market Report eCommerce Market Report
ng
AMERICA EUROPE ASIA, PACIFIC AMERICA EUROPE ASIA, PACIFIC
eCRRX/202001 eCRRX/202001
RETAILX SECTOR ANALYST REPORT RETAILX SECTOR ANALYST REPORT RETAILX SECTOR ANALYST REPORT
• been Thomas is a retail sector analyst drivers, including Just In Time Inditex’s produced a limited volume RETAILX
Beauty & Cosmetics companies have new influencer-driven brands. This has Thomas is a retail sector analyst and now account for one in every three luxury
with more than a decade of
manufacturing process, globalisation, of different lines to create a high on average, with English, French, German and
indirectly impacted by the shift to recently extended into technology experience starting and divesting a multichannel
with more than a decade of
purchases globally. While the emergence of the
multichannel retailing but the effect on investments, such as L’Oréal’s acquisition retail business. He is a grants evaluator for low-cost supply chains, rising Internet throughput of different garments. experience starting and divesting a multichannel
Chinese the most frequent
Martin devises the scope and methods of
retail business. He is a grants evaluator for online channel has increased the reach and
Vinnova, a Swedish R&D government agency penetration, increasing household Inditex’s interpretation – Fast Fashion – RetailX’s research.
department store chains, traditionally
a key retail channel for the sector, has
of Modiface, a technology it recently
used to promote its brands on Amazon MARTIN SHAW disposable income, historically low revolutionised the fashion industry
Vinnova, a Swedish R&D government agency.
growth prospects of luxury brands, it has also • Our semantic analysis shows the growing use martin@retailx.net.
• 2000s,
MARTIN SHAW
• important
been far greater. This has affected the martin@retailx.net interest rates, and the near-shoring of Online shopping’s growth in the of digital retail terms in the listed companies’
Acquiring D2C brands has become an martin@retailx.net increased costs
visibility of Beauty & Cosmetics brands Martin devises the scope and supply chains low-cost manufacturing and
CEO: Ian Jindal
• impact
tool for the larger Beauty & methods of RetailX’s research
• sustainability
Market inhibitors include concerns about near-shoring combined to make Fast
Martin devises the scope and
methods of RetailX’s research. • While Chinese luxury consumers have driven Annual Reports, 2008 to 2017 HEAD OF RESEARCH: Martin Shaw
on the sector. The rise of their business models and labour conditions, Fashion mainstream growth in the sector, it is prone to volatility based COMMERCIAL DIRECTOR: Andy James
• have
CEO: Ian Jindal DESIGN: Marzena Zychowicz
• D2C,
influencers has diluted the marketing CEO: Ian Jindal and supply chain exposure to political Sustainability and labour concerns on domestic and international events (a Chinese ‘recommerce’ – is a new opportunity in luxury, ADDRESS: RetailX, 123 Cannon Street,
RetailX forecasts a further move towards Head of Research: Martin Shaw
power of celebrities while increasing the Head of Research: Martin Shaw uncertainty on free trade and tariffs not to date had a major impact Senior Analyst: Thomas Andersson London, EC4N 5AU
which will continue as the relative
• around
Senior Analyst: Thomas Andersson government crackdown on graft; the cooling of covering items from luxury cars to vintage
number of relationships that brands need importance of ecommerce over the Commercial Director: Andy James
Benetton and Inditex adopted JIT on Fast Fashion retailers, nor overall Editors: Chloe Rigby, Jonathan Wright
© 2019 RetailX Limited
Commercial Director: Andy James US-Sino trade relations) watches
to manage high street grows. This move will be Design: Marzena Zychowicz the same time but interpreted customer demand. However, Fast Design: Marzena Zychowicz
• Beauty
In the last five years, four of the Top 10
& Cosmetics companies have
further accelerated by entry into new
geographical markets where there are
Address: RetailX, 123 Cannon Street
London, EC4N 5AU
the processes differently. Benetton
produced large volumes of a narrow
Fashion retailers now sell ‘sustainable
collections’ to cater to this growing
Address: RetailX, 123 Cannon Street
London, EC4N 5AU
RXS03: Published in London, © 2019 RetailX Limited. www.retailx.net Page 1 of 24
created internal venture funds to acquire no historical reseller relations
© 2019 RetailX Limited set of SKUs in raw form and dyed consumer preference. © 2019 RetailX Limited
RXS009: Published in London, © 2019 RetailX Limited, www.retailx.net Page 1 of 28 RXS004: Published in London, © 2019 RetailX Limited, www.retailx.net Page 1 of 29
RetailX family. During 2020, the Ecommerce analysis of sector dynamics to help retailers better
Foundation Country and Regional Reports will understand the current state of each sector and
include information on the performance of top plan for the next five years. Find out more about
retailers and brands selling direct to shoppers the sector reports at retailx.net/sectors.
within each market, alongside analysis of the
sector and of related economic and market drivers.
Recent Ecommerce Foundation reports FIGURE 14. MARKETPLACES RECEIVE A DISPROPORTIONATE AMOUNT OF UK WEB TRAFFIC
are currently available on markets including This chart shows the UK web traffic to the websites of the Top500
India, Australia, China and the USA, while an
Microsoft 13%
exhaustive Europe-focused programme of
Apple 2%
reports is planned for the coming year. The first Other brands 6%
two will cover the Danish and UK markets. Find
Amazon 25%
out more about the country and regional reports
at retailx.net/countries. Brands 21% eBay 18%
Marketplace AliExpress 1%
Other marketplaces 1%
hosts 45% BT Shop 3%
Across sectors Other Argos 2%
Tesco 1%
RetailX analyst reports focus on individual retail retailers 34% John Lewis 1%
sectors to give our audience of ecommerce and Google 1%
Asda 1%
multichannel retail professionals new levels Asos 1%
Currys PC World 1%
of insight into the factors driving customer Marks & Spencer 1%
behaviour, and retail performance within each. Screwfix 1%
Steam 1%
The latest sector reports are on beauty and Ikea: 1%
Sainsbury's 1%
cosmetics, fast fashion and luxury. Each provides B&Q 1%
the strategic and commercial context in which the Next 1%
CeX 1%
best retailers and brands perform in their market Others 15%
sectors. They combine more than four years of
in-depth company performance research with Unique web visits researched in collaboration with RetailX knowledge partner SimilarWeb
TABLE 9. DEFINITIONS
The multichannel landscape is more complex than merely ‘having a website’ or ‘operating a store’. In choosing which companies to
include in the RetailX Top500, we have considered companies’ intent, capabilities and activities around the recruitment and monetisation
of customers. The definition of a ‘retailer’ for inclusion in our research is:
DESTINATION: the retailer has created a destination that, in the minds of customers, is a source of product, service or
experience. Whether this destination is a shop, a site, a place, a time or an event, it’s the sense of ‘locus’
that counts.
FASCIA-FOCUSED: the assessment focuses on individual trading names, rather than a parent company that may operate more
than one brand. Since the group structure is invisible to customers, it does not have a bearing on the position
of brands owned by a group. The challenge is to turn group capabilities into trading advantages that the
customer would notice across brands.
PURPOSE: the retailer has created goods and/or services for the specific purpose of selling, for consumption by the
purchasing consumer.
MERCHANDISING: the retailer actively sells and is not just a portal for taking customers’ money. This means the selection,
promotion and tailoring of retail offers for customers.
ACQUISITION: the retailer actively markets, recruits and attracts customers with a promise or proposition to the destination.
SALE: the retailer takes the customer’s money. The retailer owns the transaction as the merchant of record.
RECOURSE: the retailer is responsible for the service, fulfilment and customer satisfaction owing from the sale.
EXCEPTIONS: in every good list there’s an exception, where we may include a certain business due to its influence upon
retailers and retailers’ customers. Some of these companies will be included within the Top500 and others
are tracked for information on their impact on retailers.
MARKETPLACES: where a candidate retailer is simply a marketplace, the company is not featured. Where a marketplace
undertakes customer acquisition, manages payment, customises offers and recommendations and offers
recourse on purchases, then the company will be eligible for inclusion.
PURE TRANSACTION/TARIFFS: where ecommerce is ancillary to the primary purpose of a business, we will not necessarily include them.
Online payment for gas or electricity is excluded since the purpose here is to supply energy. Travel companies
are not included in the Top500. We have also excluded media-streaming services.
BUSINESS-TO-BUSINESS AND while the scope of retail is normally direct to consumer, two trends are challenging this – the move for brands
DIRECT-SELLING BRANDS: and previously solely B2B businesses to sell direct to consumers; and the increasingly retail-like behaviour
of B2B brands, in terms of acquisition, promotion, personalisation and service. We have therefore included
certain B2B businesses and direct-selling brands.
2. THE CUSTOMER:
2.1 Customer service response time and helpfulness – Facebook and email
2.2 Desktop and mobile homepage performance, including engineering and responsiveness
2.3 Mobile and desktop website navigation – the ease of finding a desired product, including tabs, icons, search and filtering
2.4 Customer feedback – incorporation of customer reviews and product ratings on the product display page
2.5 Mobile app – the incorporation of customer reviews and product ratings in mobile app product display pages and the
personalisation, performance and user experience of apps [retailers with mobile apps]
4. MERCHANDISING:
4.1 Customer-perspective review, including 23 metrics covering design, navigation, the relevance of search results, product information
and visual appeal
4.2 Mobile app assessment, including nine metrics covering use of notifications, product display and personalisation [retailers with
mobile apps]
4.3 Merchandising and product review, including number and depth of promotions, the fraction of a retailer’s range with reviews and
descriptions, the number of images per product and the fraction of range that is out of stock [largest retailers]
5. BRAND ENGAGEMENT:
5.1 Social media presence and availability, including 22 metrics, taking into account size of audience and interaction with it on Twitter,
the net change over three months and use of 10 social networks, email, and blog
5.2 Mobile and desktop website review – assessing the integration of social media, sharing and social validation
5.3 An assessment of mobile apps’ incorporation of social media [retailers with mobile apps]
5.4 Brand-name keyword searches – total and YoY increase by UK consumers
THANK YOU
Our thanks go to our title sponsor Klarna for helping us to bring our insights and findings in
this report to professionals working in ecommerce and multichannel
KLARNA.COM
KNOWLEDGE PARTNERS
RetailX would like to thank the following Knowledge Partners for their original data insights
as well as support, advice and guidance in producing the RXUK Top500.
builtwith.com eggplantsoftware.com
pi-datametrics.com similarweb.com
In conclusion
This year in retail will inevitably be dominated by However, there’s one final, and perhaps more
the UK’s departure from the EU – and by planning upbeat, point to make. That to reiterate our findings
for the arrangements that are to follow the end of from the pages of this report that continue to show
the transition period in January 2021, once agreed. retail performance steadily improving across the
Brexit has now moved from general uncertainty wide-ranging metrics that RetailX researchers
to specific uncertainties. Previously there was some map. As last year, it’s not just the Elite and Leading
expectation or hope that Brexit would either not retailers who show these steady improvements, but
happen at all or would happen as a ‘soft’ rather than the Top500 as a whole. And as last year, it’s clear
a ‘hard’ Brexit. Both would have had the effect of little that businesses are moving away from features
or no change to customs, tariffs and immigration that perhaps do not work as well or as profitably for
rules. The general uncertainty of that time has now them as they might have expected, while doubling
gone, shown to be a phony war. Now the ecommerce down on those that do. To take just one example:
and multichannel retail sector is faced by specific while more are offering next-day delivery, fewer
uncertainties around labour, skills, imports, exports now enable next-day collection. This illustrates a
and the wider supply chain. Each of these represent mature, evolving industry that, we would argue, is
a specific challenge to retailers as they re-examine now very well-placed for whatever comes next.
the costs and methods of doing business. After As the next chapter unfolds, we’ll be continuing
2020, selling abroad will have new meaning. our research both in the UK and across the wider
At this point we’d be delighted to be able to give European market. And, as always, we’re interested
words of comfort or specific advice on dangers to in how we can extend our research and improve
avoid and opportunities to take. But at the time the quality of our findings. Get in touch with ideas
of writing, all we can say is that the work is to be and potential datasets via research@retailx.net or
done, rather than having been done. tweet @RetailX.
Marketing and Circulation ADDISON SOUTHAM This report is based upon our reasonable efforts to compile and analyse the best sources available
membership@internetretailing.net to us at any given time. Opinions reflect judgment at the time and are subject to change.
SALES:
Commercial Director ANDY JAMES
andy.james@internetretailing.net RetailX at InternetRetailing Media Services Ltd
Group Creative Solutions Director MARVIN ROBERTS 123 Cannon Street,
marvin@internetretailing.net London, EC4N 5AU
Tel: +44 (0) 20 7062 2525
RESEARCH:
Printed in Great Britain.
Head of Research MARTIN SHAW ISSN 1759-0582
Research Project Manager FERNANDO DOS SANTOS www.retailx.net
Download at http://etail.li/rxuk-top500-report-2020
KV2020