Multifunctional Public Spaces For Vibrant Community Engagement
Multifunctional Public Spaces For Vibrant Community Engagement
Multifunctional Public Spaces For Vibrant Community Engagement
community engagement
Design Dissertation
Sakshi Pawar
Sem 9
Roll. no. 35
Chapter 1: Project Introduction
1.1. Subject of research
1.2. Topic of research
1.3. Justification for topic selection
1.4. Objectives
1.5. Aim
1.6. Hypothesis statement
1.7. Research framework and methodology
Chapter 4: Site
4.1. Ranwar, Bandra
Chapter 1: Project introduction
1.4. Objectives
To understand the role of public spaces in creating a sense of community.
To study how public spaces foster social interaction and community engagement.
To learn the importance of public spaces in urban areas in improving the quality of life of its
citizens.
To analyse and understand the need of multifunctionality in urban public spaces.
1.5. Aim
To create public spaces through the idea of multifunctionality for vibrant community engagement
in urban Indian neighborhoods.
Literature review, data collection and analysis of each of the aspects mentioned above.
Research includes data from secondary sources like write ups, photographs, infographic from
readings and inferences from articles, essays, newspaper articles and research papers.
2.1. Understanding public spaces
2.1.1.What is a public space?
In the simplest way public spaces can be described as the common ground where people come
together as friends, neighbours and citizens. Places which people share together - parks,
streets, sidewalks, squares, trails, markets, waterfronts, beaches, museums, community
gardens, public buildings and more - are the primary sites for human interaction, upon which the
communities, economy, democracy and society depend. It is a gathering spot, part of
neighbourhood, waterfront or other area that helps to promote social interaction and a sense of
community.
Public spaces are all around us, a vital part of everyday urban life: the streets we pass through
on the way to school or work, the places where children play, or where we encounter nature and
wildlife; the local parks in which we enjoy sports, walk the dog and sit at lunchtime; or simply
somewhere quiet to get away for a moment from the bustle of a busy daily life. In other words,
public space is our open-air living room, our outdoor leisure centre.
Similarly, the Roman Forum was a large open space where people gather for political,
economic and social activities. It was the combination of agora and acropolis since it included
more activities (such as shrines, temples, the hall of justice and the council houses) with more
formal order.Later, Most of the open public spaces were shaped around religious
buildings.During this period commercial activities took place also in public spaces.Therefore in
middle ages, open public spaces were used mainly for religious ceremonies, and as
marketplaces.
In the neoclassical period (the Renaissance and Baroque period). Formal designs and plans
were very common in this period. Symmetry and order were the essential principles in design of
the squares .Monuments and fountains were added to the design to create aesthetically
pleasing environments axial order, balance and hierarchy became main design principles during
the Baroque period. In this period, open spaces were designed to create visual and ceremonial
effects.
In the 19th century, the industrial revolution caused dramatic changes in urban design and
planning. The establishment of broad railway networks led to population increase in urban areas
which stimulated growth of cities. New industrial areas were developed near cities and the
labour class began to move into cities to dwell. There was an emergence of shopping arcades,
shopping streets, bazaars and department stores created a new form of public space,especially
for women. Pedestrian movement and freedom were limited.
In the Indian context, Public spaces were important throughout history and typical activities
related to religion, political, commercial, leisure and recreational were much planned in these
spaces. The public spaces in Harappa and Mohenjo-Daro were very planned and given
specific importance in city planning. The public square was raised on a mound with a different
type of structures like Great Bath, Assembly Hall etc and these public spaces were accessible to
all citizens of a city, forming vital space for cities.
But later, when aristocracy came into the picture, class differences led to differentiation of
spaces. The people belonging to the Royal patronage and Brahmins would enjoy large open
leisure gardens, geometrically set out,within the palace boundary. This was not open to the
general public. These spaces were used for formal assembly or performances by dancers,
religious rituals etc. they would be grouped around ornamental elements that served as a
symbol of the State at that time. They sometimes served as parade grounds as well.
For the lower classes, the place of congregation was the temple courtyard.People of the same
faith and belief would meet and interact. This again was formal in nature to some extent owing
to the sanctity temple traditions and rules. Also, during the visit of the King, the space would be
closed for the public. Market places were another place which formed a public square. They did
not have any definite character, yet were popular users owing to the users and the function.
These ‘bazaars‘ would line along the streets creating a character of its own. During festive
times, these streets were decorated,lighted up for processions. Hence, the character was
mouldable.
The Muslim rule brought about order in the spatial planning. The unbuilt spaces were given as
much importance as the built- no distinction between street and room. There was a grouping of
rectangular pavilions along definite axes and buildings were organised in progression around it.
The pavilions and open spaces were mostly enclosed by arcades or buildings on the sides and
had defined characteristics that formed an image of the space, meant solely for leisure
Monumental structures when built had sprawling gardens, spread out in front. Everything was
organized according to this principle: the layout of architectural elements, the hierarchical
organization of decorative symbols,even the practice of gardening. The space would be divided
into quadrants by means of pathways and water channels. Intersection of two pathways would
form a nuclear element like a fountain or statue; hence interest exists throughout the grounds.
The pathways bordered patches of green lawns in between. All were at right angles to each
other, so the space had a number of parallel sight lines and perspective view from different
angles. It has been considered a specific, self-contained entity removed from its context. Its
surroundings, the city, and the environment- a religious paradise. By virtue of its newness they
have been preserved till date. But all these had defined complexes. The mosque courtyard was
another place meeting ground, open to all.
With the advent of the British rule, Indian public places lost their traditional value. Even with the
irregularities of geometric ratios, the perception of ‘disorder‘ was in harmony with the users. But
the British, introduced their own system of public squares based on length and breadth ratios,
with large gardens and central features. Though they beautified the space, they were unpopular
as the people it has been built for had no connection to them. The crossroads before their
government buildings also became squares but failed for the same reason and their size
compared to the population size of that time. These squares became nothing but meeting and
protest grounds for the freedom fighters. The fall of the British rule, came with urbanisation and
industrialisation in India, which changed the nature of public spaces.
It may be inferred that the Western public spaces and Indian public spaces were designed
keeping in mind of the difference in socio-cultural as well as climate factors. The western public
spaces were large scale, geometrical, organized and using principles of urban design since
ages while Indian Public spaces were exploring the intimate scale, organic growth, and concept
of mixed land use. The Indian Public Spaces were used as part of daily living of the people
while the Western Public Spaces were used for specific recreational purposes for a specific
time.
Enclosed or covered spaces - An enclosed or covered public space means the inside of a
building or a structure to which the public has access, including retail shops, indoor shopping
malls, restaurants, bars, places of entertainment, casinos and billiard halls. Providing for court
games, children’s play, sitting out areas etc.
Pockets, parks and green spaces - Pocket parks: Small areas of open space that provide
natural surfaces and shaded areas for informal play and passive recreation that sometimes
have seating and play equipment.
District parks: Large areas of open spaces that provide a landscape setting with a variety of
natural features providing a wide range of activities, including outdoor sports facilities and
playing fields, children’s play for different age groups and informal recreational pursuits.
A park intended to provide recreation for children may include a playground. A park primarily
intended for adults may feature walking paths and decorative landscaping. Specific features,
such as riding trails, may be included to support specific activities.
Central Park, New York Shivaji Park, Mumbai
Boulevard and linear open spaces - Boulevard: It is a wide, multi-lane arterial thoroughfare,
divided with a median down the centre, and with roadways along each side designed as a slow
travel and parking lanes and used for bicycle and pedestrian usage, with landscaping and
scenary.
Linear open spaces - Open spaces and townpaths alongside the Thames, canals and other
waterways, paths, disused railways; nature conservation areas; and other routes that provide
opportunities for informal recreation. Often characterised by features or attractive areas which
are not fully accessible to the public but contribute to the enjoyment of the space.
Public spaces offer many benefits: the ‘feel-good’ buzz from being part of a busy street scene;
the therapeutic benefits of quiet time spent on a park bench; places where people can display
their culture and identities and learn awareness of diversity and difference; opportunities for
children and young people to meet, play or simply ‘hang out’. All have important benefits and
help to create local attachments, which are at the heart of a sense of community. The social
value of public space is wide ranging and lies in the contribution it makes to people's attachment
to their locality and opportunities for mixing with others, and in people’s memory of places.
Places can provide opportunities for social interaction, social mixing and social inclusion, and
can facilitate the development of community ties. (Rowntree. J, 2010)
What is multifunctionality?
The expression ‘multifunctional’ has different meanings in different fields. For example, literally
the meaning of multifunctionality refers to something that has or fulfills several functions (Oxford,
2016).
The word ‘function’ is one of the keywords in architecture and refers to the building's purpose
and the activities done by users inside the space. This word is always used in the architectural
literature beside the words ‘form, space, stability and beauty’ in the scale of a building and it is
equivalent to the concept ;utilitas’ that Vitruvius made in the first century AD. Therefore,
‘multifunctional spaces’ concept has been used beside the mixed-use, multi-use, and
multi-purpose buildings and often without any distinction or difference. In fact, the concept of
multifunctionality could be linked with the concept of multi-uses (which means the different uses
of space in different times) (Zeidler, 1985) and the concept of mixed-usage (which means
having a combination of at least 3 different revenue-producing uses in a specific period of time)
(Florida, 2002).
Functionality refers to the ability to perform a task or a function. The meaning of
functionality is relative and depends on which medium is considered as the carrier of an ability
to perform the task/function - space, object, or activity (or even process) and for what purpose.
In that sense, multifunctionality is a feature of space, artifact or activity that means having or
fulfilling several functions and achieving multiple outputs, purposes or goals at the same time.
Multifunctionality can be also understood as a value that contributes to the simultaneous
solution of multiple problems or the achievement of multiple benefits. But it is not a value
per se; it becomes a value only when related to the specific purpose and goals [10].
Logic of multifunctional public spaces - taking into account - people, time and activity diversity.
The multifunctional spaces, in small scales, have many advantages among which we may
notice saving travel time, increasing the effective time for activity and decreasing the costs for
maintenance, repairing and security because of centralization of the activities, facilities and
infrastructure. They also guarantee that the people will revisit the space (Pourbakht & Fujii,
2009).
In large scales, urban design and land-use planning, multifunctionality can reduce urban sprawl
and increase density, promote spatial and environmental quality, save scarce space by
intensifying its use, improve the economic performance of the whole space and create a vital
attracting area (Iveson, 1998; Lloyd & Auld, 2003; Rodenburg, et al., 2003: Vreeker, et al.,
2004).
2.4. What makes a successful public space
2.4.1. Factors of a successful public space
Great and successful public spaces are those places where celebrations are held, social and
economic interactions take place such as friends running into each other, and cultures mix.
These spaces are accessible to people, engage the public with activities, are comfortable,
project a good image and foster a sense of community.
Other characteristics of a Great Public include:
● Promoting human contact and social activities
● Is safe, welcoming, and accommodating for all users.
● Has design and architectural features that are visually interesting.
● Promoting community involvement.
● Reflects the local culture or history.
● Relates well to bordering uses.
● Is well maintained.
● Has a unique or special character.
It is important for a great public space to provide a sense of comfort and safety to those people
using the space, encourage social interaction amongst users of the public space and provide
activities or events that attract and engage people in the public space.
What makes a great public space, The Place Diagram, Project for Public Spaces
In evaluating thousands of public spaces around the world, PPS has found that to be
successful, they generally share the following four qualities: they are accessible; people are
engaged in activities there; the space is comfortable and has a good image; and finally, it is a
sociable place: one where people meet each other and take people when they come to visit.
PPS (Project for Public Spaces) developed The Place Diagram above as a tool to help people in
judging any place, good or bad.
Access & Linkages
The accessibility of a place can be judged by its connections to its surroundings, both visual and
physical. A successful public space is easy to get to and get through; it is visible both from a
distance and up close. The edges of a space are important as well: For instance, a row of shops
along a street is more interesting and generally safer to walk by than a blank wall or empty lot.
Accessible spaces have a high parking turnover and, ideally, are convenient to public transit.
Comfort & Image
Whether a space is comfortable and presents itself well - has a good image - is key to its
success. Comfort includes perceptions about safety, cleanliness, and the availability of places to
sit - the importance of giving people the choice to sit where they want is generally
underestimated.
Uses & Activities
Activities are the basic building blocks of a place. Having something to do gives people a reason
to come to a place - and return. When there is nothing to do, a space will be empty and that
generally means that something is wrong.
Principles to keep in mind in evaluating the uses and activities of a place:
● The more activities that are going and that people have an opportunity to participate in,
the better.
● There is a good balance between men and women.
● People of different ages are using the space (retired people and people with young
children can use a space during the day when others are working).
● The space is used throughout the day.
● A space that is used by both singles and people in groups is better than one that is just
used by people alone because it means that there are places for people to sit with
friends, there is more socializing, and it is more fun.
● The ultimate determinant of a place's success is how well it is managed.
Sociability
This is a difficult quality for a place to achieve, but once attained it becomes an unmistakable
feature. When people see friends, meet and greet their neighbors, and feel comfortable
interacting with strangers, they tend to feel a stronger sense of place or attachment to their
community - and to the place that fosters these types of social activities.
Chapter 3 - Case Studies
The park is located in a complex area, an area that has cultural and social diversity. That area
was segnaficlly changed after introducing the design to it. According to Mengy (2017) Norrebro
was a neighborhood that suffer a lot of stress many protesting movement was start from this
neighborhood the last one was in February 2008,and it has relatively high crime rate compared
to the rest of the city.The design of Superkilen by the participation process that was done the
design was able to make connection between the residence and the space and increase the
sense of community, the feel of belonging.
Environmental context
Due to the different historical period of Copenhagen development, the city is characterised by its
diverse architectural landscape. The oldest part is Middeladerbyen with narrow streets. The
inner city includes the small island of Slotsholmen whereChristiansburg Palace is built with a
canal surrounding it. And the most distinctive part of the city isFrederiksstaden. Copenhagen
has a horizontal skyline, shaped by Baroque and Rococo palaces and occasionally
churchtowers.In recent decades Copenhagen witnessed an architectural boom. New residential
and public buildings were built by local and international architects. This made a big change in
the architectural landscape. The new development offered several areas designated for
expansion and renewal (Aksamija, 2016).
Climatic factors
Copenhagen climate is Oceanic, characterised by unstable weather through all four seasons.It
is 5 degrees above the worldwide average in the same latitude duo to the Atlantic gulfstream. It
is moderate through the year with a peak from June to August. The rain is mostly even through
the year with more rain in July and March is the driest. The warmest is augustand the coolest is
January. The snow appears from December to early March and the temperature drops to 15-30
degrees below zero. Due to that harsh winter, summer months are very pleasant in
Copenhagen with the temperature reaching a little bit above 20 degrees.June is the sunniest
month with an average of 8 hours of sunshine per day.Given that condition, outdoor public
spaces can be used through the time from April to September. Because of the rare appearance
of sunny days, Danish people enjoy the setting outside even in the very cold months of march
and April. Many restaurants and cafes are offering outdoor seatings with space heaters and
blankets.
Project Boundary
Public Transportation
Shops/Services
Child Care/Schools
Community Centre/Culture/Library
Parks/Open Space
Sociability
The plaza around the station has fulfilled its mission of local community revitalization and
providing a much needed communal space for local residents. The plaza hosts events
all-year-round for the entire community, such as dietary education classes featuring organic
food made in co-ops, exercise classes on Saturday mornings where participants can exercise to
the City's theme song, festivals, English classes for mothers and their kids, as well as Pokemon
Go events. All in all, this placemaking project has brought back vibrancy and a sense of
community to the City of Tenri.
These modern interpretations of cofun are perfect for public space. Steep layers beckon all
sorts of purposes, including seating, steps, roofs, shelves for items in shops, fences as well as
beautiful sculptural forms for navigating around on your daily commute.
Rather than being a gateway, Tenri Station plaza is in itself; a destination, and it takes on board
its responsibilities of providing space for visitors to wait, meet or simply waste time while
triggering its prospective to unite people and revitalize the community.
The variety present at the plaza creates an environment that inspires visitors to come and
explore as well as spend time in different spaces in the confines of the plaza, rather than limiting
their movements to just a single place.
Tapis Rouge public space, Haïti
Location - Haiti
Year - 2016
Type - Public Space
Architect/s - Emergent Vernacular Architecture (EVA Studio)
Basic Introduction
The program, funded by the American Red Cross and implemented by Global Communities,
aims to construct multifunctional spaces that facilitate and promote social cohesion through an
inclusive approach. Carrefour-Feuilles is one of the many informal neighbourhoods which
suffered extensive damage in the 2010 earthquake. The houses clinging to the slopes of the
ravine lack basic services such as electricity, running water and sanitation. There is little formal
infrastructure and the cheek by jowl homes are only accessible by a network of narrow corridors
that wind up the slope. It is among the tight corners and between the walls of neighbouring
houses that social life usually takes place.
Community Engagement
The design itself is inherently community-oriented and understands public space as an
anthropological ground from which identity and social relations grow. Through a participatory
approach and through placing community engagement at the core of the design process, this
public space aims to give transformative power to a local community and to provide the
residents with a sense of ownership, identity, and pride. The goal was to create a safer and
cleaner environment, which would help reduce crime, violence, and anti-social behaviour in the
area.
Design and program
The program and the architectural design have been established directly with the community.
An open-air amphitheatre, intended for community gathering, marks the centre of the space.
Dotted around the edges of the seating-steps are several Flamboyant’s that, when fully grown,
will shelter the users from the sun. The concentric rings beyond define areas within the plaza.
One, is occupied by outdoor exercise equipment and seating. In another one, near the wall, the
locally-made blue pavers give way to terraces of greenery, each with different plants. Above it,
by the top end, a row of palm trees conceals storage tanks for the adjacent water distribution
station. The well that feeds the tanks and station brings water from 100m below ground. The
revenue generated from the sales of water will be reinvested into maintaining the public space.
Materials and components
Pre-cast concrete pavers
The precast concrete pavers that create the vibrant pattern on the plaza have been locally
fabricated in Haiti. Their use in the project has been discussed directly with the community of
Carrefour-Feuilles. The vibrant colours have been tested with ARCOD and are aimed to provide
the community with a different colour palette, which is often left cement-like due to a lack of
resources for finishes.
Green Energy Solutions – Solar Lights
Carrefour-Feuilles is characterized by extreme poverty, poor vehicle and pedestrian circulation
and limited access to electricity. The installation of solar lights is aimed to provide the
community with a safer and cleaner environment.
Green Gym – Outdoor workout equipment
As part of a multi-functional programme, the low-impact workout equipment, specifically
requested by the community, is designed in an intuitive way for weight-based exercises. Green
Gym will also provide training to the users of the public space.
Chapter 4: Site
4.1. Ranwar, Bandra