Flatness Defect in Cold Rolling
Flatness Defect in Cold Rolling
Flatness Defect in Cold Rolling
net/publication/278816725
Flatness Defect in Thin Strip Cold Rolling and the Friction Impact on it
CITATIONS READS
4 1,176
3 authors:
Sami Abdelkhalek
Military Academy, Tunisia
20 PUBLICATIONS 197 CITATIONS
SEE PROFILE
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
All content following this page was uploaded by Sami Abdelkhalek on 18 August 2015.
Sami Abdelkhalek
IORC Research Centre
ArcelorMittal
Maizières-les-Metz, France
hal-00724786, version 1 - 23 Aug 2012
ABSTRACT
Flatness defects are one of the major problems in strip rolling. They are manifested by a wavy shape on the edge, in the
centre or in between. Waves are most of the time transverse, but all directions can be observed. These defects come from the
heterogeneity of the stress field and the resulting buckling of the compressive areas out of the roll bite. This paper is based on
the approach proposed by [1-3] and [4], and programmed previously [5-7] in the FEM software LAM3/TEC3 [8]. In the
present paper, the latter is enhanced and applied to the impact of friction and strip tension on flatness of a rolled thin strip.
The study shows e.g. that the optimal setting of Work Roll Bending force (WRB) should be changed when friction varies.
KEYWORDS
Rolling, Thin Strips, Finite Element Method, Friction, Flatness Defect.
INTRODUCTION
The origin is the heterogeneous distribution of residual
In thin sheet metal forming processes, buckling may stress: buckling occurs whenever compression exceeds a
occur and result in major defects. This is especially the case certain critical value over a significant area. Of course, this
in rolling of thin strips or sheets, e.g. tinplate in the steel out-of-plane displacement can happen only out of the roll
industry or foil in the aluminium industry. The quality of bite. Therefore, the measurement of this stress profile by
the product is affected by waviness of diverse directions shape-meter rolls (Figure 2) is a central tool in strip shape
and amplitudes, known as flatness defects (Figure 1) [9]. control. Only the distribution of the longitudinal stress in
the transverse direction, σ xx ( y ) , can be measured.
On the rolling mill, a high tension stress is applied on penetrate the roll surface, or on the contrary lose contact
the strip (1/10th to 1/4th of the yield stress typically). It often artificially.
prevents the stress profile from transforming into a wavy Another important point is the thermal – mechanical
shape on line, as it brings the stress in the positive range coupling. Due to the high Peclet number (advection
everywhere. In this case, the defect is “latent”: it is not dominates conduction heat flow), a Streamline Upwind
eliminated, and may show up as soon as the tension force is method is used [15].
cancelled, or upon cutting blanks. It then becomes a
“manifested” defect. The term “latent defect” is therefore
often used in place of “stress profile”, whereas “manifested Mesh generation, contact initialization, boundary conditions
defect” points to the shape of the sheet.
Inversely, for thinner sheets, part of the defect may Velocity and state variables computations (Newton-Raphson)
show even under tension, with generally very local defects.
This paper addresses this situation in priority. A simple Strip temperature computation (SUPG)
approach of buckling has been proposed [1-3] and first
implemented in a Finite Difference Method (FDM) context Roll temperature modelling;
[4], then by two of the present authors [5-7] in a Finite Roll and stand elastic displacement
Element Model (FEM) called Lam3/Tec3. It has allowed a
fully coupled model to be built. The stress field resulting Updating of roll surface
from rolling is computed, with strip plastic deformation and Updating of streamlines and mesh
hal-00724786, version 1 - 23 Aug 2012
roll elastic deformation taken into account, and the out-of- Updating of contact variables
bite stress map is examined for buckling in the same model.
The stress redistribution due to buckling is a result of this
analysis and the effect on the whole system can be studied. Convergence tests
This is different from most of the published, decoupled (loads, temperature, geometry)
approaches [10-12] which address the problem in two steps:
• Evaluation, measurement or computation of the
(post-bite) residual stress resulting from the plastic
deformation of the strip; End
• Semi-analytical or shell FEM modelling of the effect
of this post-bite stress field for a buckling / post- Figure 3. General algorithm of the Lam3/Tec3 FEM strip
buckling analysis of the structure. rolling model.
In the present paper, a summary of the existing model
Lam3/Tec3 is presented first. The buckling model is
described, and an enhanced algorithm correcting a defect of
the method is applied and proven efficient. The coupled
model is used to study the effect of friction on the stress
profile in a cold rolled thin strip, and to show how flatness
actuators (WRB force, strip tension) can be set up for on-
line control of (always possible) variations of friction.
r r
As many aspects of the formulation rely on streamlines, n1 .σ .n1 = 0
a structured mesh has been preferred. It is based on 8-node, r r
tri-linear hexahedra, with reduced integration of the n 2 .σ .n 2 > 0 (1)
r r
pressure in the Principle of Virtual Power [16]. Figure 4 n1 .σ .n 2 = 0
illustrates the structured mesh, formed by “extrusion in the
rolling direction” of a rectangular grid of the upstream r r
where n1 and n 2 are the directions of the principal
plane. Structuring the mesh allows a very efficient local
refinement of the mesh, in particular at bite entry and exit. Cauchy stress tensor in the buckled structure (hence the
As residual stresses are essential here, an elastic- third equation). This means that when a tension is applied
viscoplastic constitutive model is used. It is based on in a direction, the membrane is stiff; if the stress becomes
Prandtl - Reuss additive decomposition of strain rate. negative, it gets slack and in fact, the corresponding stress
Jaumann objective derivative is used to write the elastic is put to 0.
model in rate form, and associated von Mises behaviour is The essence of the model consists in determining an
assumed for plasticity. The incremental consistency is extra deformation which elastically brings the stress in the
based on the standard radial return technique. buckled direction back to 0. It may be interpreted as the
In the principle of virtual work, the updated stress is shortening of a material line due to buckling of the
obtained by streamline integration, where the time needed structure. This is more or less analogous to elastic-plastic
for matter to move from an integration point to the next in decomposition, but is activated only out of the roll bite, i.e.
hal-00724786, version 1 - 23 Aug 2012
the streamline is a substitute for time step [8] – since time where buckling may manifest.
does not exist properly speaking in a steady state
formulation. As the pseudo-time step is therefore point- Practical application
dependent due to the adapted mesh, the formulation has
been termed “Generalized Heterogeneous Time Stepping” In the context of small incremental deformation, the
(GHTS). strain tensor is the sum of two components:
The roll stack deformation model is another essential
feature. Like most of the previous ones [17], the single roll
bending and flattening model is based on Timoshenko beam ∆ε = ∆ε el + ∆ε bu (2)
theory, Boussinesq solution for a half-space under general
where ∆ε is the elastic and ∆ε is the “buckling
el bu
loading, combined after the results in [18]. Based on
extensive FEM simulations, corrections have been brought strain” increment. Plane stress is assumed (out of bite). If
for end effect and the barrel / axle transition. Hertzian buckling occurs in direction 1 (respectively 2), the
contact mechanics is assumed for work roll (WR) / back-up following conditions hold:
roll (BUR) contact. The Influence Function Method (IFM)
r r r r
is used to discretize the system, with particular refinement n1 .σ .n1 = σ c n1 .σ .n1 > 0
near the edge of the strip – WR contact. A global non-linear r r r r
system is formed with all displacements of all contact lines, n 2 .σ .n 2 > 0 respectively n 2 .σ .n 2 = σ c (3)
r r r r
with external forces (rolling load, WRB or BURB) in the n1 .σ .n 2 = 0 n1 .σ .n 2 = 0
right-hand side. This non-linear system is solved by
Newton-Raphson method. Details can be found in [13]. The extra deformation representing buckling is
computed in the principal axes then transported to the
A SIMPLE BUCKLING MODEL
reference frame. Let λi , i = I,II be the deformation
Principle representing buckling in the principal directions. It is
deduced from σi, i = I, II as follows:
Counhaye [4] has proposed a method to deal with sheet
buckling in a FDM rolling model, which seems quite σi −σc
similar to the one introduced in a more general context by λi = i = I , II (4)
Roddeman et al. [1]. The same has been implemented in E
Lam3/Tec3 by Abdelkhalek [5,6].
In [1-3], it is proposed for the membrane theory, and Moving back to the reference frame, the buckling strain
forbids the appearance of a negative stress: every time a is added to the global strain increment (u and v are the two
negative stress is about to appear, the structure buckles; this in-plane incremental displacements, θ is the angle between
principal and reference frames, ν is Poisson's ratio and E is
means that σ c = 0 ( σ c is the critical buckling stress). The
Young's modulus):
following critical conditions are therefore introduced:
Proceedings of NAMRI/SME, Vol. 40, 2012
below). Yet, it has been noticed that the non-buckling Rolling velocity 20.5 m/s
criterion is not respected until ~500 mm after roll bite exit. Work roll crown 0.0322% of radius
The numerical result is therefore locally in contradiction Sheet crown 4.81% of thickness
with the nature of the model [6]. In the following, a simple Bending force 482 KN
1D analysis of the origin is presented. Let G be a Gauss Critical stress σc -10 MPa
integration point. The algorithm implemented by Friction Law Coulomb µ = 0.03
Abdelkhalek [5] is such that: Poisson's ratio ν = 0.3
Young's modulus E = 210 GPa
σ (G ) = σ (G −1) + ∆σ (G ) = σ (G −1) + E.∆ε el (6)
σ (G ) − σ c
∆ε bu = (7)
E
σ (G −1) + E∆ε + σ c
σ (G ) = ≠ σc (8)
2
∆ε bu =
[θσ (G )
]
+ (1 − θ )σ ( G −1) − σ c
(9)
E
Figure 5. The mill structure (4-Hi) and dimensions.
Proceedings of NAMRI/SME, Vol. 40, 2012
bending, with a too large reduction in the centre resulting in when the latter varies, e.g. during mill acceleration or
a concave profile, leading to a wavy centre. deceleration.
hal-00724786, version 1 - 23 Aug 2012
Figure 16. The effect of increasing strip tension on the Figure 18. The effect of increasing strip tension on the roll
stress profile (µ = 0.025, WRB force = 482 kN). Strip load transverse distribution F(y) (µ = 0.025, WRB force =
tension stress T has been subtracted for easier comparison. 482 kN).
hal-00724786, version 1 - 23 Aug 2012
CONCLUSION
edges being cooled faster. This may bring in thermo-elastic [10] Bush A, Nicholls R, Tunstall J (2001) Stress levels for
stresses, which will be the subject of future investigations. elastic buckling of rolled strip and plate. Ironm. Steelm.
28, 481-484.
[1] Roddeman DG, Drukker J, Oomens CWJ, Janssen JD [13] Hacquin A, Montmitonnet P, Guillerault JP (1998) A
(1987) The Wrinkling of Thin Membranes: Part I- 3D semi-analytical model of rolling stand deformation
Theory. ASME Trans., J. Appl. Mech. 54, 884-887. with finite element validation. Eur. J. Mech. A (Solids)
17, 1, 79-106.
[2] Roddeman DG, Drukker J, Oomens CWJ, Janssen JD
hal-00724786, version 1 - 23 Aug 2012
(1987) The Wrinkling of Thin Membranes: Part II- [14] Yamada K, Ogawa S, Ataka M (1992) 3D analysis of
Numerical Analysis. ASME Trans., J. Appl. Mech. 54, flat rolling using rigid-plastic FEM coupled with roll
888-892. deformation analysis. Proc. Numiform 92, Chenot JL,
Wood RD & Zienkiewicz OC, eds, Balkema,
[3] Roddeman DG (1991) Finite Element Analysis of Rotterdam, 1992.
Wrinkling Membranes. Comm. Appl. Numer. Meth. 7,
299-307. [15] Pardo E, Weckman DC (1990) A fixed grid FE
technique for modelling phase change in steady state
[4] Counhaye C (2000) Modélisation et contrôle industriel conduction – advection problems. Int. J. Num. Meth.
de la géométrie des aciers laminés à froid. PhD Thesis, Engg 29, 969-984.
Liège University (in French).
[16] Gratacos P, Montmitonnet P, Chenot JL (1992) An
[5] Abdelkhalek S (2010) Un exemple de flambage sous integration scheme for Prandtl-Reuss elastoplastic
contraintes internes: Étude des défauts de planéité en constitutive equations. Int. J. Num. Meth. Eng. 33
laminage à froid des tôles minces. PhD Thesis, MINES (1992) 943-961.
ParisTech (in French).
[17] Shohet KN, Townsend NA (1968) Roll bending
[6] Abdelkhalek S, Montmitonnet P, Legrand N, Buessler P methods of crown control in four-high plate mills. J.
(2011) Coupled approach for flatness predictions in thin Iron Steel Inst. 1088-1098.
strip cold rolling. Int. J. Mech. Sci. 53, 651-675.
[18] Berger B, Pawelski O, Funke P (1976) Die elastische
[7] Abdelkhalek S, Zahrouni H, Montmitonnet P, Legrand Verformung der Walzen von Vierwalzengerüsten. Arch.
N, Potier-Ferry M (2011) Manifested flatness Eisenhüttenwes. 47, 6, 351-356 (in German).
predictions in thin strip cold rolling using a general
rolling FEM model. Steel Res. Int. Sp. Issue ICTP 2011, [19] Jiang ZY, Tieu AK, Zhang XM, Lu C, Sun WH
111-116. (2003) Finite element simulation of cold rolling of thin
strip. J. Mat. Proc. Tech. 140, 542–547.
[8] Hacquin A, Montmitonnet P, Guilleraut JP (1998) A
steady state thermo-elastoviscoplastic finite element [20] Jiang ZY, Zhu HT, Wei DB, Tieu AK (2007)
model of rolling with coupled thermo-elastic roll Asymmetric Cold Rolling of thin Strip with Roll Edge
deformation. J. Mat. Proc. Tech. 60, 109-116. Kiss. Proc. ICIEA 2007 (Harbin, PR China, May 23-25,
2007), 2781-2786, published by IEEE.
[9] Roberts WL (1983) Hot Rolling of steels.
Manufacturing Engineering and Materials Processing [21] Wang XC, Yang Q, Du XZ, Jiang ZY (2010)
Series, Vol. 10. Marcel Dekker, New York. Allowable variation of cold-rolled strip transverse
profiles in high tension. Int. J. Minerals, Metallurgy
and Materials 17, 5, 608-616.
Proceedings of NAMRI/SME, Vol. 40, 2012