Effect of Incubation Temperature On The Diagnostic Sensitivity of The Glanders Complement Fixation Test
Effect of Incubation Temperature On The Diagnostic Sensitivity of The Glanders Complement Fixation Test
Effect of Incubation Temperature On The Diagnostic Sensitivity of The Glanders Complement Fixation Test
(1) Friedrich Loeffler Institut, Federal Research Institute for Animal Health, Institute of Bacterial Infections and
Zoonoses, Naumburger Strasse 96a, 07743 Jena, Germany
(2) Section of Epidemiology and Public Health, College of Veterinary and Animal Sciences, 12-Km Chiniot
Road, Jhang, 35200, Pakistan
(3) Institute of Microbiology and Epizootics, Free University Berlin, Berlin, Robert-von-Ostertag-Str. 7–13,
14163 Berlin, Germany
(4) Department of Clinical Medicine and Surgery, University of Agriculture, Faisalabad 38040, Pakistan
(5) Laboratório Nacional Agropecuário, Ministério da Agricultura, Pecuária e Abastecimento, Rua Dom Manoel
De Medeiros, S/N, Dois Irmãos, Recife, Pernambuco, 52171-030, Brazil
*Corresponding author: drkhan_uaf@yahoo.com
Summary
The complement fixation test (CFT) is the only serological test prescribed by
the World Organisation for Animal Health (OIE) for the diagnosis of glanders in
international trading of equids. However, false-positive reactions have caused
financial losses to the animal owners in the past, and false-negative tests
have resulted in the introduction of glanders into healthy equine populations
in previously glanders-free areas. Both warm (incubation at 37°C for 1 h) and
cold (overnight incubation at 4°C) procedures are recommended by the OIE for
serodiagnosis of glanders. In a comparison of the sensitivity and specificity of the
two techniques, using the United States Department of Agriculture antigen, warm
CFT was found to be significantly less sensitive (56.8%; p < 0.0005) than the cold
CFT (83.6%). Cold CFT thus increases the detection rate of glanders but a lower
diagnostic specificity has to be accepted. The immunoblot was used as the gold
standard.
Keywords
Burkholderia mallei – Complement fixation test – Equids – Glanders – Immunoblot –
Incubation temperature – Sensitivity – Serodiagnosis.
No. 17062014-00035-EN
870 Rev. sci. tech. Off. int. Epiz., 33 (3)
in well-kept clinically healthy carriers (1, 16). Improved Complement fixation test procedures
serodiagnostic tests with higher diagnostic specificity and
sensitivity are therefore regularly called for (18). Both All serum samples were tested using the CFT method
warm and cold CFT procedures are described in the OIE according to the OIE Terrestrial Manual (18). To minimise
Manual of Diagnostic Tests and Vaccines for Terrestrial Animals the inherent errors of the CFT, a commercially available
(Terrestrial Manual) (18). According to the OIE (2008), the CFT antigen (United States Department of Agriculture,
temperature and duration of incubation can interfere with Ames, Iowa, USA) (18) and a ready-to-use complement
the analytical performance of an assay (19). Nevertheless, as and haemolytic system (Institut Virion/Serion GmbH,
the glanders CFT is a widely used and cheap test, the effect of Würzburg, Germany) were used (19).
incubation temperature does not attract sufficient attention.
No literature on the effect of temperature on the glanders The detailed procedure was as follows. Sera were
CFT is available, although there is some old literature on diluted 1/5 in veronal-buffered saline containing
the Wassermann reaction (CFT) for diagnosis of syphilis. In 0.1% gelatin and inactivated in a water bath for 30 min
1909, Satta and Donati were the first to address this subject at 58°C for horse sera and 63°C for sera from mules,
and to publish their observations (20). donkeys and non-equids. The inactivated test sera were
mixed well on a shaker before pipetting into 96-well
In the present study, the warm and cold CFT procedures round-bottomed microtitre plates. Two-fold dilutions of
were compared and the recently evaluated immunoblot was the sera were then prepared. First, 25 μl of veronal buffer
used as the gold standard (21). The immunoblot is the most was added to all rows except the second row, then 25 μl of
specific and sensitive test and can also be used to test sera diluted inactivated test serum was pipetted into the first,
that show anti-complementary activity in CFT (21, 22). second and third rows. Two-fold serial dilutions were made,
starting from the third row until the end, and discarding the
final 25 μl from the last row. Antigen (25 μl) at a working
Materials and methods dilution was then added to all rows except the first. Lastly,
25 μl of complement, diluted to the number of units required,
Origin of serum samples was added to each well. Negative control wells containing
diluent only, complement/diluent, or complement/diluent/
The 342 equid sera included in this study were divided into antigen were prepared (75 μl in each well). Positive and
two groups. In group I, 196 sera were randomly collected negative serum control wells were also prepared. Plates
(Mersenne Twister software, SPSS Inc., Chicago, USA) from were shaken for 60 s on a shaker before incubation. For
among 2,282 horse and donkey sera in Germany. These cold CFT, plates were covered and incubated at 4°C for
sera were declared true negative because glanders was 16 to 20 h; for warm CFT, plates were incubated at 37°C
eradicated in Germany more than 50 years ago and the sera for 1 h only.
were immunoblot negative (21, 23).
To compare the sensitivity of warm and cold CFT procedures, In a second step, the haemolytic system was prepared
a set of 146 true-positive sera were selected (group II). This by careful mixing of amboceptor at the working
group included 123 samples from Brazil (Pernambuco) dilution 1:1 with 1% erythrocyte suspension, followed by
and Pakistan (Punjab) that were collected during glanders incubation for 30 min in a 37°C water bath. The plates
outbreaks between 2007 and 2009 from microbiologically from the first day were also pre-warmed for 30 min in a
or clinically (mallein test) positive glanderous animals. 37°C incubator to ensure that the haemolytic system and
The Pakistani sera were collected from clinically positive plates were at the same temperature. Freshly prepared
and culture-positive equids during two separate outbreaks haemolytic system (50 μl) was added to each well and
of glanders among police horses (Faisalabad Metropolis), shaken carefully. Plates were moist-incubated at 37°C for
polo ponies (Lahore Polo Club, Lahore), animals on private 15 to 30 min.
farms (Sargodha district) and draught equines (Faisalabad
City). The samples from Brazil were collected from clinically Incubation was stopped when the complement control
positive glanderous animals in different endemic areas of wells with 2 and 1 units showed complete haemolysis.
Pernambuco State (National Animal and Plant Laboratory, Plates were centrifuged for 5 min at 670 g. The absence of
Ministry of Agriculture, Livestock and Food Supply, Recife, anti-complementary activity was checked for each serum in
Brazil). In addition, 25 sera from B. mallei-immunised the first row. The first row was regarded as a serum control
horses were collected (21): of these, 23 sera tested positive (no antigen). Sera were considered negative when 100%
in immunoblot and were included in group II; the remaining haemolysis occurred at 1:5 dilution, 25% to 75% haemolysis
two sera were immunoblot negative and were excluded from was considered equivocal and absence of haemolysis was
the study (21, 23). The animal experiment was authorised considered to indicate a positive serum (18). Complement
by the government of Thuringia, Germany (registration no. fixation test titres were defined at the step at which the
04-105/07). serum dilution showed inhibition of haemolysis.
No. 17062014-00035-EN
Rev. sci. tech. Off. int. Epiz., 33 (3) 871
Results
A total of 342 equid sera were evaluated in warm and cold 300
CFTs (Table I). In group I (true negatives; 196 sera), all sera
250
(100%) were negative in the warm CFT; in the cold CFT
192 sera (97.95%) tested negative and four (2.04%) were 200
positive. CFT titre
150
Table I
Warm and cold procedures for complement-fixation testing of sera from glanders-free (Group I) and glanderous
and immunised animals (Group II)
Group II
Positive glanderous animals 117 2 4 57 (b) 8 (c) 58 (d) 95 (e) 4 (f) 24 (g)
(mallein test)
(n = 123)
No. 17062014-00035-EN
872 Rev. sci. tech. Off. int. Epiz., 33 (3)
No. 17062014-00035-EN
Rev. sci. tech. Off. int. Epiz., 33 (3) 873
Résumé
L’épreuve de fixation du complément est la seule épreuve sérologique prescrite
par l’Organisation mondiale de la santé animale (OIE) pour le diagnostic
de la morve aux fins des échanges internationaux d’équidés. Néanmoins,
des réactions faussement positives ont fait perdre beaucoup d’argent aux
propriétaires de chevaux, tandis que des réactions faussement négatives ont eu
pour conséquence d’introduire la morve dans des populations équines saines
de régions précédemment indemnes de morve. Le protocole recommandé par
l’OIE pour le diagnostic sérologique de la morve prévoit une incubation à chaud
(à 37 °C pendant 1 heure) ou à froid (pendant une nuit à 4 °C). Dans une étude
comparative sur la sensibilité et la spécificité de ces deux techniques, utilisant un
antigène préparé par le Département de l’agriculture des États-Unis d’Amérique,
la méthode de fixation du complément à chaud s’est avérée significativement
moins sensible (56,8 % ; p < 0,0005) que la méthode à froid (83,6 %). La méthode
de fixation du complément à froid accroît le taux de détection de la morve, mais
au prix d’une spécificité diagnostique moindre. L’immunoblot a été utilisé comme
épreuve de référence.
Mots-clés
Burkholderia mallei – Diagnostic sérologique – Équidés – Immunoblot – Morve –
Sensibilité – Température d’incubation – Test de fixation du complément.
Resumen
La técnica de fijación del complemento (FdC) es la única prueba serológica
prescrita por la Organización Mundial de Sanidad Animal (OIE) para diagnosticar
el muermo en operaciones de comercio internacional de équidos. Sin embargo,
ya ha habido falsas reacciones positivas que han causado pérdidas económicas
a los propietarios de animales, y falsos resultados negativos que se han saldado
con la introducción del muermo en poblaciones equinas sanas de zonas que
hasta entonces estaban libres de la enfermedad. Para el diagnóstico serológico
del muermo la OIE recomienda tanto el procedimiento en caliente (1 hora de
incubación a 37°C) como en frío (una noche de incubación a 4°C). Tras comparar
la sensibilidad y especificidad de ambas técnicas empleando el antígeno del
Departamento de Agricultura de los Estados Unidos, se observó que la prueba
No. 17062014-00035-EN
874 Rev. sci. tech. Off. int. Epiz., 33 (3)
de FdC era significativamente menos sensible en caliente (56,8%; p < 0,0005) que
en frío (83,6%). El método de FdC en frío incrementa pues el índice de detección
del muermo, si bien a costa de aceptar una menor especificidad de diagnóstico.
Como referencia absoluta se utilizó la prueba de inmunoblot.
Palabras clave
Burkholderia mallei – Diagnóstico serológico – Équidos – Inmunoblot – Muermo – Prueba
de fijación del complemento – Sensibilidad – Temperatura de incubación.
References
1. Neubauer H., Sprague L.D., Zachariah R., Tomaso H., 11. Wernery U., Zachariah R., Wernery R., Joseph S. & Valsini L.
Al Dahouk S., Wernery R., Wernery U. & Scholz H.C. (2005). (2005). – Ten years of freedom from notifiable equine diseases
– Serodiagnosis of Burkholderia mallei infections in horses: in the United Arab Emirates. In Proc. of the 15th International
state-of-the-art and perspectives. J. vet. Med. B, 52 (5), 201– Conference of Racing Analysts and Veterinarians (P.H. Albert,
205. T. Morton & J.F. Wade, eds). R & W Publications, Dubai,
United Arab Emirates, 1–4.
2. Whitlock G.C., Estes D.M. & Torres A.G. (2007). – Glanders:
off to the races with Burkholderia mallei. FEMS Microbiol. Lett., 12. World Organisation for Animal Health (OIE) (2012). – World
277 (2), 115–122. Animal Health Information Database (WAHID). Available at:
www.oie.int (accessed on 28 October 2013).
3. Al-Ani F.K., Al-Rawashdeh O.F., Ali A.H. & Hassan F.K. (1998).
– Glanders in horses: clinical, biochemical and serological
13. Jana A.M., Gupta A.K., Pandya G., Verma R.D. & Rao K.M.
studies in Iraq. Vet. Arhiv., 68 (5), 155–162.
(1982). – Rapid diagnosis of glanders in equines by counter-
4. Arun S., Neubauer H., Gurel A., Ayyidiz G., Kuscu B., immuno-electrophoresis. Ind. vet. J., 59, 5–9.
Yesidere T., Meyer H. & Hermanns W. (1999). – Equine
glanders in Turkey. Vet. Rec., 144 (10), 255–258. 14. Misra V.C. & Arora A.K. (1998). – Diagnosis of glanders by
counter-immuno-electrophoresis test and its efficacy vis-a-vis
5. Bazargani T.T., Tadjbakhs H., Badii A. & Zahraei T. (1996). – other test. J. Remount vet. Corps., 27, 177–185.
The outbreak of glanders in some racehorses in three states of
Iran. J. equine vet. Sci., 16 (6), 232–236. 15. Naureen A., Saqib M., Muhammad G., Hussain M.H. &
Asi M.N. (2007). – Comparative evaluation of Rose Bengal
6. Hornstra H., Pearson T., Georgia S., Liguori A., Dale J., plate agglutination test, mallein and some conventional
Price E., O’Neill M., Deshazer D., Muhammad G., Saqib M., serological tests for diagnosis of spontaneous equine glanders.
Naureen A. & Keim P. (2009). – Molecular epidemiology of J. vet. diagn. Invest., 19 (4), 362–367.
glanders, Pakistan. Emerg. infect. Dis., 15 (12), 2036–2039.
16. Sprague L.D., Zachariah R., Neubauer H., Wernery R.,
7. Ma C.L., Fan S.M., Wang X., Jiang L. & Fang S.Q. (1986). Joseph M., Scholz H.C. & Wernery U. (2009). – Prevalence-
– Diagnosis of glanders in horses by the indirect fluorescent dependent use of serological tests for diagnosing glanders in
antibody (IFA) technique. Chin. J. vet. Sci. Technol., 9, 3–5. horses. BMC vet. Res., 5, 32.
8. Malik P., Khurana S.K., Singh B.K. & Dwivedi S.K. (2009).
17. Zhang W.D. & Lu Z.B. (1983). – Application of an indirect
– Recent outbreak of glanders in India. Ind. J. anim. Sci.,
haemagglutination test for the diagnosis of glanders and
79 (10), 1015–1017.
melioidiosis. Chin. J. vet. Med., 9, 8–9.
9. Mota R.A., Brito M.F., Castro F.J. & Massa M. (2000). –
Glanders in horses and mules of the states of Pernambuco and 18. World Organisation for Animal Health (OIE) (2008). –
Alagoas, Brazil. Pes. Vet. Bras., 20 (4), 155–159. Glanders. Chapter 2.5.11. In Manual of Diagnostic Tests
and Vaccines, Vol. I, 6th Ed. OIE, Paris, 919–928. Available
10. Odontsetseg N., Mweene A.S. & Kida H. (2005). – Viral and at: www.oie.int/fileadmin/Home/eng/Health_standards/
bacterial diseases in livestock in Mongolia. Jpn J. vet. Res., tahm/2.05.11_GLANDERS.pdf (accessed on 28 October
52 (4), 151–162. 2013).
No. 17062014-00035-EN
Rev. sci. tech. Off. int. Epiz., 33 (3) 875
20. Dean H.R. (1916). – The influence of temperature on the 26. Ris D.R. (1974). – The complement fixation test for the
fixation of complement. Available at: http://onlinelibrary.wiley. diagnosis of Brucella ovis infection in sheep. N.Z. vet. J.,
com/doi/10.1002/path.1700210204/abstract (accessed on 22, 143–146.
28 October 2013).
27. Burgess G.W. & Norris M.J. (1982). – Evaluation of the cold
21. Elschner M.C., Holger C., Scholz M., Peggy M., Rassbach A., complement fixation test for diagnosis of ovine brucellosis.
Dietzsch M., Melzer F., Schmoock G., de Assis Santana V.L., Aust. vet. J., 59, 23–25.
de Souza M.M.A., Wernery R., Wernery U. & Neubauer H.
(2011). – Use of a Western blot technique for the serodiagnosis 28. Anuntagool N. & Sirisinha S. (2002). – Antigenic relatedness
of glanders. BMC vet. Res., 5, 7. between Burkholderia pseudomallei and Burkholderia mallei.
Microbiol. Immunol., 46 (3), 143–150.
22. Khan I., Wieler L.H., Neubauer H. & Gehlen H. (2011). –
Serodiagnosis of glanders with reference to endemic and non- 29. Misra V.C. & Arora A.K. (1990). – Serological cross-reactions
endemic settings. Doctoral thesis, Free University, Berlin. between Pseudomonas mallei and some other bacteria. Indian J.
comp. Microbiol. Immunol. infect. Dis., 11 (1), 28–31.
23. Khan I., Wieler L.H., Melzer F., Gwida M., de Assis Santana V.L.,
de Souza M.M.A., Saqib M., Elschner M.C. & 30. Piven’ N.N., Iliukhin V.I., Timoshin V.B., Viktorov D.V.
Neubauer H. (2011). – Comparative evaluation of three & Abramenko A.V. (2005). – Cross-reacting antigens of
commercially available complement fixation test antigens for pathogenic Burkholderia and some dangerous causative agents
the diagnosis of glanders. Vet. Rec., 169 (19), 495. doi:10.1136/ of infectious diseases [in Russian]. Zh. Mikrobiol Epidemiol.
vr.d5410. Immunobiol., 2, 14–19.
No. 17062014-00035-EN