Analysis of Corporate Governance and Management Control: A Case Study On SBI
Analysis of Corporate Governance and Management Control: A Case Study On SBI
Abstract
The matter of Corporate-Governance has come up fundamentally in the wake of financial-reforms
depicted by liberalization and deregulation. The Corporate-Governance has at its spine a course of action
of the explicit connection between a corporate’s management its board, financial investors and various
interested parties. For assessment reason, the study is done in two parts. With the information that is
deduced from secondary sources, this study was examined and as a result of different variables, of the
demonstration of Corporate-Governance was assessed in SBI. The Indian banking framework is among
the more successful performers on the planet. In the improved financial situation, the banking division in
India can’t ignore the noteworthiness of Corporate-Governance. The corporate-administration of banks is
the journey for sound business morals and strong expertise skill that adjusts the premiums of all interested
parties and the overall population. SBI is the most significant bank among all public and private banks
in India. It is the second largest bank on the planet measured by the number of branches. The bank gives
various domestic, international services through its incredible framework in India and abroad. SBI needs to
ensure excellent Corporate-Governance to fulfil greatness, straightforwardness, amplify investors’ value and
ROI. The paper tries to assess the Corporate Governance in State Bank of India.
Keywords: State Bank of India (SBI), Corporate, Governance, stakeholders, Board of Directors (BODs)
JEL Classification: G34
Paper Classification: Research Paper
Introduction
In the evolving monetary environment, the corporate sector on the planet can’t disregard the
significance of Corporate Governance. There were a few skullduggery and tricks in the corporate
history of the world. In a steady progression falls of driving organizations like Robert-Maxwell,
Enron, Satyam Computers and different tricks pull the fascination of speculators towards
Corporate Governance. The vast majority of the skullduggeries are identified with poor Corporate
Governance and due to carelessness of responsibilities and obligations by the board.
The corporate-governance has turned into the most recent buzz expression in the corporate
part of the world. Corporate-governance alludes to the way an enterprise is governed. India’s SEBI
board of trustees characterizes corporate-governance as “the investors are the genuine owners of
the corporation, this is the basic right.” Corporate-governance and its effect on firm conduct are a
standout amongst the most bantered about issues in literature today. As of recent years, the talk
has concentrated on the structure of the BODs, as the most exceptional governance mechanism
of the inside control systems (Jensen, July 1993). The issue of corporate-governance has come
up basically in the wake up of financial changes depicted by liberalization and deregulation. As
demonstrated by OECD, the flow of rights and obligations are decided by corporate-governance
among various members in the association, for instance, the board, BODs, investors and various
interested parties and it furthermore clarify the rules and strategies for settling on decisions on
corporate-undertakings. (Smriti Sharma, January 2013). The corporate-governance is selective of
the board of directors in a way that it turns into a method for organizational life and not only
composed standards or regulations or code of ethics (Kesseven Padachi, October 2014). Ethics and
transparence are cardinals of corporate-governance.
Corporate Governance builds up a framework wherein executives are given responsibilities
and duties in connection with the organization’s issues, suppliers, working employees, clients,
government and the general public on the large part. The viable corporate administration is vital
for any organization to be effective independent of the kind of business it does, yet for the bank
and monetary institutions, Corporate Governance expects a more prominent level of significance.
Authors considering corporate-governance have utilized a various set of hypothetical
viewpoints to comprehend the characteristics, usefulness, and impacts of the BOD (Guido
Corbetta, June 2004). Organization theoretic contentions speak to one clarification in portraying
the relation amongst investors and BODs (Ronald C. Anderson, 2004). The board is accused
of the obligation of dealing with the issues of the corporate-governance with determination,
transparency, duty, and responsibility and maximizing investors’ wealth. As per (Parker, 2006), it
is frequently assumed that there is an immediate and clear caused relation between the activities
of the board and the success of the company, measured with such factors as; profitability,
notoriety and stock cost.
principally with ensuring frail and broadly scattered investors against self-intrigued directors and
agents, i.e., also called as managers.
Objectives
The purpose of the study is to:
• Assess the corporate-governance practice in the banking part from the contextual analysis of
the State Bank of India.
• Two sections are discussed in order to ease the process of assessment of scenario.
In the very first section, the ideas of corporate-governance like the evolution of corporate-
governance in the Indian situation, role, and consequence of corporate-governance in the banking
area is being discussed. The second stated section analyzes the act of corporate-governance as
controlled by SBI with the assistance of components similar to board practices and stakeholders.
Secondary data about the activities including setting up, roles, services, and facilities offered by
the SBI was taken from libraries, annual reports, economic survey, and journals.
About SBI
The State Bank of India, the country’s most seasoned Bank and a head as far as balance-sheet
measure, number of physical branches, market capitalization and benefits, is today experiencing
an earth-shattering period of change and transformation – the two-hundred-year-old Public
segment behemoth is today mixing out of its Public Sector inheritance and moving with a capacity
to give the Private and Foreign Banks keep running for their cash. The Bank is moving forward
with front-line innovation and creative new managing account models, to grow its Rural Banking
base, taking a gander at the tremendous undiscovered potential in the hinterland and proposes
to cover 100,000 towns in the following two years. The Bank is changing obsolete front and back-
end procedures to current customer-friendly procedures to help enhance the aggregate client
encounter. With around 8500 of its own 10,000 physical branches and another 5,100 physical
branches of its Associate Banks as of now organized, today it offers the biggest money saving
system to the Indian client.
All through this change, the Bank is additionally endeavoring to change old mentalities, states
of mind and take all workers together on this evolving street to transfiguration. In its closed
mass-interior communication customized named “-Parivartan-” the Bank took off more than
3300 two day workshops the nation over and shrouded more than 130,000 representatives in
a time of 100 days utilizing around 400 Trainers, to commute home the message of Change and
comprehensiveness. The workshops showcased the creative ability of the working employees with
some different banks in India and also other Public Sector Organizations looking to imitate the
program.
Dos
• Go to Meetings of Boards and Committee thereof (aggregately alluded to as “Board” for
quickness) frequently and take an interest in the thoughts and discourses successfully, and
scrupulously satisfy his/her commitments as Director of the Bank;
• Go through the Board papers altogether and inquire about follow up gives an account of clear
time plan;
• Participate effectively in the matter of detailing of general policies;
• Be acquainted with the wide targets of the Bank and the approaches set around the
Government and the different laws and enactments;
• Keep himself/herself educated about the business, exercises and money related status of the
Bank to the degree unveiled to him/her; and
• Guarantee privacy of the Bank’s papers, notes and Minutes.
Don’ts
• Try not to meddle in the everyday working of the bank .and in the execution of their
obligations wherever the Director has motivations to accept else, he/she might forthwith
uncover his/her worries to the Board (This stipulation does not have any significant bearing
to the Chairman and the Managing Directors).
• Try not to uncover any data related with any constituent of the Bank to anybody.
• Try not to show the logo/unmistakable plan of the Bank on their own meeting cards/letter
heads (This does not keep the Chairman, Managing Directors and Core Management from
utilizing DO letterheads or going to cards with State Bank of India’s logo subsequently).
• Try not to support any proposition identifying with credits, ventures, structures or
destinations for Bank’s premises, selection or empanelment of temporary workers, draftsmen,
examiners, specialists, legal advisors and different experts and so forth.
• Try not to do anything, which will meddle with and additionally be subversive of support of
great lead and respectability of the staff.
Board Practices
• Central Board: The central BODs were constituted by the SBI Act 1955. The bank does its
duties as per the provisions of SBI Act and Regulations 1955. The duties are to incorporate,
and administer the risk-profile of the bank; checking the sincerity of its business and control
components; guaranteeing expert’s superintendence, and augmenting the interests of its
investors. This board has constituted seven board-level panels.
• ACB: Audit Committee of the Board (ACB) gives guidance and overall audit work of the
bank is administered by the board. Audit work infers the hierarchical, operational, control
of quality of interior audits and assessment inside the arena of bank, following-up of the
statutory audit and consistency with “RBI investigation”. It likewise designates statutory-
auditors of the bank and examines auditors’ execution from one time to another. This board
audits the bank’s monetary, risk administration, information system audit strategies and
accounting-arrangements of the bank to guarantee more noteworthy transparence.
• RMCB: is Risk Management Committee of the Board, is framed and constituted to regulate
the approach and the strategy for combined risk management identifying with ‘credit-risk’,
‘market-risk’, and ‘operational-risk’.
• SIGCB: Shareholders’/Investors’ Grievance Committee of the Board was framed to
investigate the redressal of investors’ and shareholders’ grievances in regard to the exchange
of various shares, the non-receipt of yearly reports, and also non-receipt of return as interest
accrued on bonds/pronounced dividends on shares, and so forth.
• Special Board for Monitoring of Large Value Frauds: The main elements of this advisory
group is to screen as well as to survey all the large valued scams with a perspective to
recognizing fundamental hiatuses, assuming any, purposes behind deferral in detection
and detailing, checking the progress of CBI/Police examination, recuperation position and
auditing the adequacy of remedial move made to avert repeat of scams.
• CSCB: Customer Service Committee of the Board was made and constituted to realize the
progressing-improvements on a constant-basis in the nature of a service given by the banks to
their customers.
• IT Strategy Committee: With a perspective to following the growth of the SBI’s technological
activities, the SBI’s “central-board” constituted the tech council of the board. The advisory
group has assumed a key role in the bank’s innovation domain.
• Remuneration Committee of the Board: It was established for assessing the execution
of whole-time BODs related to the bank regarding the payment of the remuneration or
incentives, according to the schemes proposed by GOI.
It is obtained that in State Bank of India; these advisory groups are giving viable expert
assistance in the process of managing the ‘board-level’ business in key regions.
service provider and exchanges the credit to the next given bank account. This arrangement of
reserve exchange works on a Deferred Net-Settlement premise. The acronym RTGS remains
for Real Time Gross Settlement. This is where the handling of assets exchange guidelines
happens at the time they are gotten (real-time). Likewise the settlement of funds exchange
directions happens separately on a guideline by guideline premise. SBI has the month to
month exchanges of more than 6.5 crore of NEFT and for the RTGS, SBI has the aggregate
transactions of close to 32 lakhs in a month.
Business Segment
In this section, the treasury fragment incorporates the whole investment-portfolio and the
trading in foreign-trade contracts and the derivative contracts; the corporate or wholesale banking
fragment involves the loaning exercises of corporate records group, mid-corporate record group
and focused on “assets-management group” and the retail-banking portion contains branches
in national-banking gathering, which fundamentally incorporates individual-banking exercises
including loaning exercises to corporate clients. This section additionally incorporates agency-
business and ATMs.
Geographic Segments
Domestic operations are branches having operations in India. International-operations are the
branches/workplaces that are having operations out-side India
EPS
EPS stands for Earnings-per-Share. The Bank reported essential and diluted Earnings per Share
as per Accounting Standard 20 -EPS. Fundamental income” per share is processed by separating
NEAT (Net-Earning-After-Tax) by the weighted-avg.-number of shares outstanding amid the
year. The net benefit in 2015 was Rs. 10891.17 crores and it expanded to Rs. 13101.57 crores in 2016
(India, 2016). The basic EPS in 2015 was Rs. 15.68 and it increases to Rs. 17.55 in 2016 (India, 2016).
b) Concentration of Advances
c) Concentration of Exposures
d) Concentration of NPAs
21% to 1.06 lakhs from 88,438 of every 2014-15. Of the 1.06 lakhs added-up to grievances in the
respective banking industry in 2015-2016, SBI found 29% grievances or complaints enlisted
against it for requiring of the charges, pension-delays and the ATM machines, debit card frauds.
Consumer Service board of trustees must step up ventures to attractively address clients’
grievances.
The study found that the concentration of NPAs adding up to exposure to top four NPA
accounts was Rs. 1,839.51 crores in 2015-16 showing credit risk. It is recommended that the
credit risk administration should find a way to maintain a strategic distance from this sort of
concentration of NPAs.
The SBI is directing various sorts of social service exercises in various segments like education,
healthcare services and different areas as a piece of CSR. The sum spent for this intention
was Rs.143.9 crore or 1% of its net benefit on social responsibility in financial year 2016. It
is recommended that the sum must be increased for social service exercises to draw public
consideration.
At last, it is presumed that, the corporate-governance practices in the SBI ought to enhance for
best investment approaches, proper inward control systems, better credit-risk management, better
customer-service and sufficient computerization so as to accomplish greatness, transparence and
expansion of investor’s value and profits.
References
Anderson, R., & Reeb, D. (2004, June 1). Board Composition: Balancing Family Influence in S&P 500 Firms.
Sage Publications Inc., 49(2), 209-237. doi:10.2307/4131472
Chitra, R. (2016, December 10). SBI gets most companies: Banking Ombudsman. Retrieved 2017, from
https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/business/india-business/SBI-gets-most-complaints-Banking-
Ombudsman/articleshow/55904459.cms
CII Task Force on Corporate Governance. (2009). Corporate Governance Recommendations for Voluntary
Adoption. Ministry of Corporate Affairs. Confederation of Indian Industry. Retrieved 2017,
from http://www.cii.in/PolicyAdvocacyDetails.aspx?enc=tY9RauqVx47h7V4G1rU6/
jmCHSML2OwpVJtbLaE2vPFukhx566abX9jYjSpP zUObymFCsRSpFalMSkgUR0vKQ==
Committee on the Financial Aspects pf Corporate Governance, Gee & Co. Ltd. (1992). The Financial Aspects of
Corporate Governance. London: Professional Publishing Ltd. Retrieved from ecgi.org/codes/documents/
cadbury.pdf
Corbetta, G., & Salvato, C. (2004). The Board of Directors in Family Firms: One Size Fits All? Family Business
Review, 17(2), 119-134. doi:10.1111/j.1741-6248.2004.00008.x
Deb, R. Corporate Governance Practices in Indian Banks. Journal of Business Manangement & Social Sciences
Research, 2(5), 36-50. Retrieved from https://ssrn.com/abstract=2877596
Eisenberg, P. (2016). Case Study Analysis of Corporate Governance and Management Control at Kendallville
Bank. International Journal of Applied Economic Studies, 4(3), 14-20. Retrieved from sijpurnals.com/IJAE/
wp-content/uploads/2016/06/Case-Study-Analysis-of-Corporate-Governace-and-Management-
Control-at-Kendallville-Bank.pdf
Jensen, M. C. (1993). The Modern Industrial Revolution, Exit, and the Failure of Internal Control Systems.
Journal of Finance, 48(3), 831-880. doi:10.2307/2329018
KJ, S. (2016). SBI has 34 lakh wallet users while mobile banking has 1.38 crore. Retrieved from https://www.
medianama.com/2016/08/223-sbi-wallet-mobile-banking-users/
livemint. (n.d.). RBI asked SBI to rein in CSR spending: Arundhati Bhattacharya. Retrieved from http://www.
livemint.com/Industry/8kdQSZY6QKlRHlklwodRcN/RBI-asked-SBI-to-rein-in-CSR-spending-
Arundhati-Bhattachary.html
Maheshwari, M., & Meena, S. (2015, May). Corporate Governance Practices: A Comparative Study.
International Journal of Research in IT, Management and Engineering, 5(5), 7-27. Retrieved from www.
indusedu.org
India had 31.48M credit cards and 793.83M debit cards(2017). Retrieved from https://www.medianama.
com/2017/08/223-india-had-31-48m-credit-cards-793-83m-debit-cards-in-june-2017/
Padachi, K., & U. H. (2016). Assessing Corporate Governance Practices of Mauritian Companies. International
Journal of Accounting and Financial Reporting, 6(1), 38-71. doi:10.5296/ijafr.v6i1.9281
Parker, H. (2006). Governing the corporation, Business the ultimate. Cambridge: A & C Black Publishers Ltd.
Peters, G. F., & Romi, A. M. (2013). Does the Voluntary Adoption of Corporate Governance Mechanisms
Improve Environmental Risk Disclosures? Evidence from Greenhouse Gas Emission Accounting. Journal
of Business Ethics, 125(4), 637-666. doi:10.1007/s10551-013-1886-9
Reserve Bank of India. (2014). Report of the Committee to Review Governance of Boards of Banks in India.
Sharma, S. (2014). Corporate Governanace Practices: A Case Study of ICICI Bank Ltd. International Journal of
Innovative Research & Studies, 3(2), 349-363.
Sharma, S., Saxena, P., & Saxena, N. (2013). Corporate Governance Practice of Indian Companies – An
Assessment of OECD Principles at Global Perspective. SSRN Electronic Journal ·, 1-16. doi:10.2139/
ssrn.2279413
State Bank of India. (2016). Balance Sheet as on 31st March, 2016, State Bank of India, Retrived 2017, from
https://www.sbi.co.in/portal/documents/41076/60023/Audited+Financial+Results+March+2016.
pdf/463847a4-16ef-4723-832a-2d64e67e1651
State Bank of India. (2017). Annual Report 2016-17. State Bank of India. Retrieved from https://www.sbi.
co.in/AR1617/PDF/English/CGR.pdf
State Bank of India. (n.d.). ATM Services. Retrieved 2017, from https://www.sbi.co.in/portal/web/services/
atm-services
Times of India. (2016). SBI gets most complaints: Banking Ombudsman. TNN. Chennai: Times of India. Retrieved from
https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/business/india-business/SBI-gets-most-complaints-Banking-Ombudsman/
articleshow/55904459.cmsa
Authors’ Profile
Prashant Kumar Pandey is student of BBA + MBA (Dual Program) of Amity International Business
School, Amity University, Noida, India.
Shikha Kapoor is a Professor and Area Chairperson in HR & OB in Amity International Business School,
Amity University, Noida, India. She is also the Program Director for Ph.D. Program, Consortium Member of
Amity Centre for Counseling and Guidance, Organizer Faculty Enhancement Program, Member Advisory
Board of Studies for Management Programs and Corporate Trainer. She has a total experience of 27 years
in consultancy, research, training, corporate and academics. She organized / conducted various seminars,
conferences and worked on international (ILO, USAID) and national assignments in HR and Management
consultancy. She has 15 books and 100 research papers and articles published and presented in international
and national journals newspapers. She has been guest speaker and done live chat shows on Management
related topics on T.V. and radio.