Cash Management
Cash Management
Cash Management
Cash Management
Learning Objectives:
Upon completing this unit, you will be able
list and explain the motives for holding cash.
understand the purpose of efficient cash management.
describe methods for speeding up the collection of accounts receivable and
methods for controlling cash disbursements.
discuss factors determining cash needs
explain the approaches to derive optimal cash balance
identify the key variables that should be considered before purchasing any
marketable securities.
2.1 Introduction
Cash and marketable securities are the most liquid of the firm’s assets.
Cash is the ready currency to which all liquid assets can be reduced.
Marketable securities are short term, interest bearing, money market instruments
that are used by the firm to obtain a return on temporary idle funds.
Cash and marketable securities are held by the firms to reduce the risk of technical
insolvency by providing a pool of liquid resources for use in making planned as
well as unexpected outlays.
The desired balances are determined by carefully considering the motives for
holding them. The higher the cash & Marketable securities, the lower the risk of
technical insolvency, and the lower they are, the higher the risk of technical
insolvency.
The term cash with reference to cash management is used in two senses.
1
In a narrow sense it is used to cover currency and generally accepted equivalents
of cash such as checks, drafts and demand deposit in banks.
The broader view of cash also includes near cash assets, such as marketable
securities and time deposits in blanks.
As a part of managing its cash, a firm must make arrangements to collect from its
customers, pay its suppliers, and invest any excess cash on hand.
Speculative motive. Holding cash as to create the ability for a firm to take
advantage of special opportunities that if acted upon quickly will favor the firm.
The speculative motive helps to take advantage of:
an opportunity to purchases raw materials at reduced price on payment of
immediate cash;
2
a chance to speculate on interest rate movements by buying securities
when interest rates are expected to decline;
delay purchases of raw materials on the anticipation of decline in prices;
and to make purchases at favorable prices.
Cash management is one of the key areas of working capital management. Apart from the
fact that it is the most liquid current asset, cash is the common denominator to which all
current assets can be reduces because the other major liquid assets, that is, receivables
and inventory get eventually converted into cash. This underlines the significance of cash
management.
The basic objectives of cash management are two-fold: (a) to meet the cash disbarment
needs (payment schedule); and (b) to minimize funds committed to cash balances. These
are conflicting and mutually contradictory and the task of cash management is to
reconcile them.
3
The relationship with the bank is not stained.
It helps in fostering good relations with trade creditors and suppliers of
raw materials, as prompt payment may help their own management.
A trade discount can be availed if payment is made with in the discount
period.
It leads to a strong credit rating which enables the firm to purchase goods
on favorable terms and to maintain its line of credit with banks and other
sources of credit.
To take advantage of favorable business opportunities that may be
availability periodically.
To meet unexpected cash expenditure with a minimum strain during
emergencies, such as strikes, fires or a new marketing campaign by
competitors.
4
The factors that determine the required cash balances are: synchronization of cash flows,
short costs, excess cash balance, procurement and management and uncertainty.
Synchronization of cash flows. The need for maintaining cash balances
arising from the non-synchronization of the inflows and outflows of cash: if the
receipts and payments of cash perfectly coincide or balance each other, there
would be no need for cash balances. The first consideration in determining the
cash needs is therefore, the extent of non-synchronization of cash receipts and
disbursements.
Short costs. Another general factor to be considered in determining cash needs
is the cost associated as shortfall in the firm’s cash needs. Expenses incurred as
a result of shortfall are called short costs. Included in the short costs are:
Transaction costs. These are associated with raising cash to tide
over the shortage. This is usually the brokerage incurred in
relation to the sale of some short-term near-cash assets such as
marketable securities.
Borrowing costs. Borrowing costs are costs associated with
borrowing to cover the shortage. These include items such as
interest on loan, commitment charges and other expenses relating
to the loan.
Loss of trade-discount
Costs associated with deterioration of the firm’s credit rating.
This is reflected in higher bank charges on loans, stoppage of
supplies, demands for cash payment, refusal to sell, loss of image
and the attendant decline in sales and profits.
Penalty rates by banks to meet a shortfall in compensating
balances.
Excess cash balances Costs. The costs of having excessively large cash
balances is known as the excess cash balance cost. If large funds are idle, the
5
implication is that the firm has missed opportunities to invest those funds and
has thereby lost interest which it would otherwise have earned. This loss of
interest is primarily the excess cost.
Procurement and management. These are the costs associated with
establishing and operating cash management staff and activities. They are
generally fixed and are mainly accounted for by salary, storage, handling of
securities, and so on.
After the examination of the pertinent considerations and cost that determine cash needs,
the next question deals with the determination of a firm’s cash needs. There are two
approaches to derive an optimal cash balance, namely, (a) cash budget and (b) cash
management models.
6
outflows over the projected period. It gives information on the timing and magnitude of
expected cash flows and the end balances over the planning period.
The key purpose of cash management is to hold optimal balance of cash that is just
enough to meet the demand for cash. Cash balance more than the optimum level will cost
the firm’s profitability, whereas cash balance that is below the optimum level will result
in poor liquidity. Thus, the crux of cash management is to determine the level of cash
which will provide sufficient liquidity without adversely affecting profitability.
Firms can use quantitative models to determine appropriate transactional cash balances.
Two quantitative models that management can use to determine desirable level of cash
balance are Baumol Model and Miller-Orr Model.
Baumol Model. The Baumol model enables companies to find out their desirable level
of cash balance under certainty. There are certain assumptions or ideas that are critical
with respect to the Baumol model of cash management:
The opportunity cost of holding cash is known and it does not change over a
period of time
The firm will incur the same transaction cost whenever it converts its securities to
cash.
7
Firms in practice do not use their cash balance uniformly nor are they able to
predict daily cash inflows and outflows.
2T F
Cash balance
K
Where:
F = the fixed cost of selling securities to raise cash
T = the total amount of new cash needed
K = the opportunity cost of holding cash: this is the interest rate.
The optimal cash balance is found where the opportunity costs equal the trading costs.
Opportunity Costs = Trading Costs
(C/2)K = (T/C) F
Thus,
Opportunity cost = K(C/2)
Transaction or trading Cost = F (T/C)
Total cost = K(C/2) + F(T/C)
Example 1: A firm utilizes Br165, 000 a week to pay bills. The fixed cost of transferring
funds is Br48. The applicable interest rate is 6%. Answer these five questions using the
Baumol model:
Instruction:
a. What is the optimal initial cash balance?
b. What is the optimal average cash balance?
c. What is the opportunity cost of holding cash?
d. What is the trading cost of holding cash?
8
e. What is the total cost of holding cash?
Solution:
a. Optimal initial cash balance
( 2T F )
C*
K
2 $165,000 52 $48
.06
$823,680,000
.06
$117 ,166.55
$117 ,167
9
Example 2. ABC Company estimates that annual cash usage of Br3.75 million will occur
uniformly throughout the year. The firm's marketable securities earn 12% per year.
ABC's management plans to meet the cash demands by selling the marketable securities
periodically. The transaction cost is Br40.
Instruction: Use the Baumol model to determine the optimal transaction size.
a. What is the optimal cash balance?
b. What is the average cash balance
c. How many transfers per year will be required?
Solution
a. Optimal cash balance(C*)
(2T F )
C*
K
2 $3, 750, 000 $40
.12
$300, 000, 000
.12
$50, 000
10
Miller- Orr Model. The Miller -Orr model of cash management is one of the various
cash management models in operation. It is an important cash management model as
well. It helps the present day companies to manage their cash while taking into
consideration the fluctuations in daily cash flow.
As per the Miller -Orr Model of cash management, the companies let their cash balance
move within two limits - the upper limit and the lower limit. The companies buy or sell
the marketable securities only if the cash balance is equal to any one of these.
When the cash balances of a company touches the upper limit it purchases a certain
number of salable securities that helps them to come back to the desired level. If the cash
balance of the company reaches the lower level then the company trades its salable
securities and gathers enough cash to fix the problem.
It is normally assumed in such cases that the average value of the distribution of net cash
flows is zero. It is also understood that the distribution of net cash flows has a standard
deviation. The Miller and Orr model of cash management also assumes that distribution
of cash flows is normal.
To use the Miller-Orr model, the manager must do four things:
Set the lower control limit. It refers to deciding of the minimum possible levels of
desired cash balance
Estimate the standard deviation of regular cash flows.
Determine the interest rate.
Estimate the trading costs at which the salable securities could be sold or bought
1/ 3
3 F 2
C* L
4 xI
U 3 C* 2 L
11
4C * L
AvgC *
3
Where Z = the amount of securities that should be converted into cash
when the cash balance hits the lower control limit
U = upper control limit
L = lower control limit (i.e. the minimum cash balance)
F = fixed cost of converting securities into cash
C* = target cash balance
= the standard deviation of the net cash flows
Example 1. The standard deviation of the firm’s cash flows is $ 15,000. The fixed cost of
transferring funds is $ 51 a transfer. The firm has established a lower cash balance limit
of $ 80,000. The weekly interest rate is .067%.
Instruction: Use the Miller-Orr model to answer these three questions:
a. What is the optimal initial cash balance?
C*= $ 80,000 +
1/3
3 $51 $15,0002
4 x0.00067
12
U * (3 C *) ( 2 L)
(3 $103,417) ( 2 $80,000)
$310,251 $160,000
$150,251
Or computed alternatively
U* = L+3Z
= $ 80,000 + 3($23,417)
= $150,251
U* = C*+2Z
= $ 103417 + 2($23,417)
= $150,251
Or computed alternatively
Average Cash Balance = L + (4/3) Z
= $ 80,000 + (4/3 x $ 23,417.26)
= $ 111,223
Example 2. Suppose that short-term securities yield 5% per year and it costs the firm Br
50 each time it buys or sells securities. The variance of daily cash flows is Br 100,000
and your bank requires Br 1,000 minimum checking account balance.
Instruction: Use the Miller-Orr model to answer these three questions:
a. What is the optimal initial cash balance?
b. What is the optimum upper limit?
13
c. What is the average cash balance?
d. Compute the opportunity costs of holding the cash.
Solution:
a. Optimal cash balance
1/ 3
3 $50 $100, 000
C*= $ 1,000 +
4 x0.05 / 365
C*= $ 1,000 + $ 3,013.8
C* = $ 4,013.8
b. The upper limit for the cash account (U*) is determined by the equation:
U* = 3C* - 2L
= 3(4,013.8) -2(1,000)
= $10.041.4
The cash management strategies are intended to minimize the operating balance
requirement. The basic strategies that can be employed are
a. Stretching accounts payable without affecting the credit of the firm
b. Efficient inventory-production management
c. Speedy collection of accounts receivable.
14
Firms can manage cash in virtually all areas of operations that involve the use of cash.
The goal is to receive cash as soon as possible while at the same time waiting to pay out
cash as long as possible.
Ways to Speedup Collections of Cash
15
Example 1. Ramsey Manufacturing uses a continuous billing system that results in an
average receipt of Br 4,000,000. It is contemplating the institution of concentration
banking instead of the current system of centralized billing and collection. It is estimated
that such a system would reduce the collection period of accounts receivable by 2 days.
Concentration banking would cost Br 75,000 annually and 8 percent can be earned by the
firm on its investments. It is also found that a lockbox system could reduce its overall
collection time by 4 days and could cost Br 120, 000 annually.
Instruction:
a. How much cash would be released with the concentration banking system?
b. How much money can be saved due to reduction in the collection period by 2
days? What is the net advantage if the firm implements the concentration
banking system?
c. How much cash would be freed up by lockbox system?
d. Between concentration banking and lockbox system, which is better?
Solution
a. Cash freed up/released by using concentration banking
= average daily receipts x Reduction in collection time
=Br 4,000,000 x 2
=Br 8,000,000
b. Saving by using concentration banking
=Cash freed up X Annual interest
= Br 8,000,000 x 0.08
=Br 640,000
Savings of the concentration banking ……………………. Br 640,000
Costs of the concentration banking ………………………. 75,000
Net advantage of the system…………..……………… Br565,000
c. Cash freed up/released by using lock box system
16
= average daily receipts x Reduction in collection time
=Br 4,000,000 x 4
=Br 16,000,000
d. Saving by using lock box system
=Cash freed up X Annual interest
= Br 16,000,000 x 0.08
=Br 1,280,000
Savings of using lock box system ……………………. Br 1,280,000
Costs of using lock box system ………………………. 120,000
Net advantage of the system…………..……………Br1,160,000
Therefore, the lock box system is better as compared to the concentration
banking. It has a net Br 595,000 (Br 1,160,000 less Br 565,000) advantage.
Example 2. Century Oil Company uses a continuous billing system that result in average
daily receipts of Br 600,000. The company treasurer estimates that a proposed lockbox
system could reduce its collection time by 2 days.
Instruction:
a. How much cash would the lockbox system free up for the company?
b) What is the maximum amount that Century would be willing to pay for the
lockbox system if it can earn 6% on available short term funds?
c) If the lockbox system could be arranged at annual cost of Br 40,000, what
would be the net gain from instituting the system?
Solution:
a. Cash freed up/released
= average daily receipts x Reduction in collection time
=Br 600,000 x 2
=Br 1,200,000
17
b. Maximum amount that Century would be willing to pay for the
lockbox system
=Cash freed up X Annual interest
= Br 1,200,000 x 0.06
=Br 72,000
c. Savings of the lockbox system……………………. Br 72,000
Costs of the lockbox system………………………. 40,000
Net advantage of the system…………..………. Br32,000
Example 3 . XYZ presently maintains a centralized billing system at its home office to
handle average daily collections of Br300,000. The total time for mailing, processing, and
clearing is about 5 days.
Instruction:
a. If the opportunity cost on short-term funds is 12%, how much is the time lag of 5
days costing the firm?
b. If the firm designs a lockbox system with a regional bank that will reduce float by
2.5 days and will also reduce the annual expenses of the credit department by
Br30,000, what is the maximum acceptable compensating balance the firm should
be willing to keep?
Solution
a. Annual float = (Br300,000/day × 5 days) = Br1,500,000
Annual cost = (0.12/yr) × Br1, 500,000 = Br180,000/yr
b. Reduced float expense
= (0.12/yr) × (2.5 days × Br300,000/day)
= Br90,000/yr
Total reduced costs = Br90,000/yr + Br30,000/yr = Br120,000/yr
18
2.7 Investing Surplus Cash
If a firm has a temporary cash surplus, it can invest in short-term securities. The market
for short-term financial assets is called the money market. The maturity of short-term
financial assets that trade in the money market is one year or less.
Firms have temporary cash surplus for various reasons. Two of the most important are
the financing of seasonal or cyclical activities of the firm and the financing of planned or
possible expenditures.
Seasonal or cyclical activities. Some firms have a predictable cash flow pattern.
They have surplus cash flows during part of the year and deficit cash flows the rest
of the year. For example, a retail toy firm has a seasonal cash flow pattern
influenced by Christmas. A firm like this may buy marketable securities when
surplus cash occur and sell marketable securities when deficits occur. Of course,
bank loans are another short-term financing device.
19
Money market is the market for short-term financial assets. The maturity of short-term
financial assets that trade in the money market is one year or less.
Treasury bills: Treasury bills are short-term government securities. Usually, they
are sold at a discount and redeemed at par. The difference is the return on security.
They can be bought & sold any time; thus they have liquidity. Also, they do not
have the default risk.
Commercial papers can be sold either directly or through dealers. Companies with
high credit rating can sell directly to investors. The denominations in which they
can be bought vary over a wide range.
Bank deposits: A firm can deposit its temporary cash in a bank for a fixed period
of time. The interest rate depends on the maturity period.
20
2.7.3 Characteristics of Short-Term Securities
Given that a firm has some temporarily idle cash, there are a variety of short-term
securities available for investing. The most important characteristics of these short term
marketable securities are their maturity, default risk, marketability, and taxability.
Maturity. Maturity refers to the time period over which interest and principal
payments are due. The longer the maturity, the greater the interest rates risk. As a
consequence, firms often limit their investments in marketable securities to those
maturing in less than 90 days to avoid the risk of losses in value from changing
interest rate.
Default risk: Default risk refers to the probability that interest and principal will
not be paid in the promised amounts on the due dates. Government and bank
issued securities generally have lowest risk.
Taxability
interest income is heavily taxed
capital gains and dividends are preferred, but these arise on risky
securities
creative strategies include dividend capture and floating rate preferred
shares
21
Discussion Questions
1. What are the four motives for holding cash?
2. What are the objectives of cash management?
3. What is the cost to the firm of holding excess cash?
4. Discuss the utility of cash budget as a tool of cash management?
5. What is the significance of speedy receivables collection? In this context briefly
explain concentration banking system and lockbox system.
6. What is the benefit from reducing float?
7. What specific strategies can be adapted to slow disbursements of account payable?
8. Which would a firm prefer: a net collection float or a net disbursement float? Why?
Problems
1. Discount Music Stores is evaluating a lockbox system which will reduce float by 3
days. The lockbox system costs Br15,000 per year. The firm’s daily collections
average Br150,000, and its opportunity cost of funds is 6% per year. Should the firm
utilize this lockbox system?
2. Suppose you receive on average 150 daily payments to lock box. Average payment is
Br1200. Daily interest rate is 0.02 percent. Time savings from using lockbox is 1.2
22
days for mailing and 0.2 days for processing. What is the maximum amount that you
are willing to pay for the lock box? The bank changes for operating the lock box by
the number of checks processed.
3. CB Inc. receives a number of checks each day. The average amount of each check is
Br125:00. Management estimates that mail delay, processing delay, and clearing
delay for these checks are 4 days, 2 days, and 2 days respectively. CB Inc. is
considering implementing a lockbox banking system. The implementation is expected
to reduce mail delay by 2 days, processing delay by 1 day, and clearing delay by 1
day. The cost of the lockbox system includes an annual fee of Br25;000 (payable at
the start of the year) and a per check fee of 2 cents. If the interest rate on short term
marketable securities is 4:5% compounded annually, how many checks does CB Inc.
need to receive each day in order to justify implementing the lockbox system?
4. The daily standard deviation of SSS’s net cash flows is Br40,000. The fixed cost of
converting securities into cash is Br264.50 per conversion. The annual opportunity
cost of funds is 9%. Use 9% / 365 for the daily interest rate. SSS has set a lower
control limit of Br100,000.
Instruction: Using the Miller-Orr Model
a. What would SSS’s upper control limit and return point?
b. What is SSS’s average cash balance?
5. DEF Corp. wishes to manage its cash using the Miller-Orr model. The variance of its
expected daily net cash flow is Br2.5 million. DEF Corp. can invest idle cash at an
annual rate of 7%, pays Br1, 000 commissions on all security transactions, and doesn't
want its cash level to drop below Br100, 000.
Instruction:
a. At which cash level should DEF Corp. invest its idle resources? What
amount should be invested at this level?
b. What is the expected annual opportunity cost of idle resources?
23
24