Aop 07 2
Aop 07 2
Aop 07 2
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
ALLIED
ORDNANCE
PUBLICATION
(TOC)
June 2003
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
Edition 2
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
Edition 2
3. AOP-7 (Edition 2) contains only factual information. Changes to these are not subject to the
national ratification procedures; they will be promulgated on receipt by the nations concerned.
Jan H ERIKSEN
Rear Admiral, NONA
Director, NSA
(TOC)
I
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
Edition 2
RESERVATIONS
NATION RESERVATIONS
(TOC)
II
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
Edition 2
RECORD OF AMENDMENTS
Identification of
Amendment/Change – Section Date By whom
Remarks
No. Entered Entered
III
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
Edition 2
IV
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
Edition 2
TABLE OF CONTENTS
SECTION PAGE
NATO LETTER OF PROMULGATION I
RESERVATIONS II
TABLE OF CONTENTS V
1. INTRODUCTION 1-1
2. OBJECTIVES 3-1
3. SCOPE 3-1
4. DEFINITIONS AND REFERENCED POLICY DOCUMENTS 4-1
5. METHODS TO RECORD AND ISSUE DATA 5-1
6. REVIEWS AND REVISIONS OF THIS MANUAL. 6-1
7. ASSESSMENT PRINCIPLES AND COMMON REQUIREMENTS FOR THE
7-1
QUALIFICATION OF EXPLOSIVES
V
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
Edition 2
VI
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
Edition 2
CHAPTER 1
1.0 INTRODUCTION
1.1 Explosive materials such as high explosives, propellants and pyrotechnics are used in weapon
systems to perform a variety of functions. They provide the energy required to deliver the
payload to the target and to obtain the desired terminal effect. Because of their high energy
content, these materials are sensitive and can be initiated by stimuli such as heat, shock, friction,
impact, and electrostatic discharge. All of these stimuli may be encountered in development
programs, and later in the manufacture, transport, storage, and operational or training use of
explosive materials.
1.2 The careful and judicious selection of explosives is important since it will affect the sensitivity and
safety of munitions and the vulnerability of weapon platforms. Trade-off with performance can be
made, but in general, the more powerful the explosive used, the more sensitive it is to stimuli, and
the more protection must be provided to shield munitions in hazardous areas. Since in many
applications space is limited, it is often impossible or unfeasible to provide the increased
protection. Therefore, in qualifying explosives, National Authorities must exercise caution and
concern for the sensitivity and the suitability for service of the explosive materials being
considered for all military applications. Further, munition designers should select the least
sensitive explosive material that meets the operational requirements defined for their application.
1.3 In the past, the tests, and criteria used by each North Atlantic Treaty Organization (NATO)
country to accept explosives for military use have not been readily available nor, in general, well
documented. This has delayed the NATO-wide acceptance of explosives, hindered munitions
interoperability programs, caused unnecessary testing redundancy, and wasted the valuable
material and financial resources of countries in the Alliance.
1.4 The use of modeling to assess the behavior of explosive materials under a wide range of stimuli
and scenarios is important. The Qualification phase lends itself to the determination of the
intrinsic properties of the explosive materials and allows for the generation of a range of modeling
parameters. This then will allow those nations wishing to model small and intermediate-scale
testing the opportunity to develop appropriate models and computer codes. In addition, it will
facilitate the development of generic test vehicles and test methods that will underpin and support
weapons safety and suitability for service activities. The AC/310 Subgroup 1 will consider further
development along these lines in the future.
1.5 The recognition of the differences in weapon sensitivity evaluations and in the explosives
selection processes among NATO nations, led to the establishment of the AC/310 Cadre Group
and four Subgroups. This organization operates under the aegis of the Conference of National
Armament Directors (CNAD). Since 1997 the AC/310 group has admitted non-aligned,
Partnership for Peace (PfP), nations who wish to participate in these activities. The four
Subgroups in AC/310 address, respectively, Explosive Materials, Fuzing Systems, Environment,
and Generic Classes of Munitions.
1.6 Subgroup 1 (Explosive Materials) has developed an approach and is standardizing the tests used
to acquire the data deemed necessary for the Qualification of military explosives. The Subgroup
recognizes that substantial continuing efforts must be directed toward the following:
1.6.1 The development of Standardization Agreements, STANAGs, on test equipment, and test
procedures used to acquire the data to satisfy national requirements for the Qualification of
explosives used by the military.
1.6.2 The formation and identification of central repositories of data on qualified explosives in each
member country to facilitate the exchange of information used in munitions co-development or
cross-procurement programs.
1-1
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
Edition 2
1.6.3 The documentation of tests and acceptance criteria which may be unique to one nation to permit
other NATO members to understand and interpret the data exchanged in terms of the specific
test apparatus, procedures, and criteria employed.
1.6.4 The development of STANAGs to assure that the explosives used by the NATO forces are
produced to the same or equivalent material specification and to the same or equivalent quality
assurance principles.
1.7 STANAG 4170, "Principles and Methodology for the Qualification of Explosive Materials for
Military Use," documents the agreement to standardize the assessment principles and
methodology. This manual supplements STANAG 4170 and presents the specific requirements,
techniques, and tests used by the participating nations to implement the STANAG.
1.8 This document is officially designated Allied Ordnance Publication No. 7, "Manual of Data
Requirements and Tests for the Qualification of Explosive Materials for Military Use." The
abbreviated designation "AOP-7" is used throughout this manual.
(TOC)
1-2
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
Edition 2
CHAPTER 2
2.0 OBJECTIVES
2.1.1 To promote standardization and interoperability of munitions among the NATO countries. This
can be achieved by documenting the policies established by the participating countries to
implement the explosive materials Qualification process established by STANAG 4170.
2.1.2 To supplement STANAG 4170 by identifying the organizational elements and unique national
requirements involved in the explosive materials development and Qualification process for each
participating country.
2.1.3 To identify the National Authorities responsible for the Qualification of military explosives in each
nation.
2.1.4 To identify the minimum explosives safety data that must be reported to the National Authority to
satisfy STANAG 4170 Qualification requirements.
2.1.5 To provide both summaries and references to complete descriptions of tests used by member
nations to evaluate the properties of explosive materials and, within the limits of national
regulations, standardize methods for recording and exchanging data on explosive materials.
2.1.6 To provide the recipients of data with the information necessary to assess the experimental and
theoretical basis used by each nation in qualifying military explosives.
(TOC)
2-1
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
Edition 2
2-2
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
Edition 2
CHAPTER 3
3.0 SCOPE
3.1 This manual documents Qualification procedures and tests used by the National Authorities of
each participating nation to assess the safety and suitability of explosives used in their intended
role, e.g. high explosive, booster, etc. The Qualification of a new explosive in accordance with
STANAG 4170 and this AOP does not imply Final (or Type) Qualification for use in a specific
hardware application.
3.2 This document is not a substitute for legislative and regulatory requirements (e.g. UN tests,
hazard classification tests, etc.) relating to the manufacture, transportation, storage, and disposal
of explosive substances. These requirements are, in general, the responsibility of other
government organizations. However, many of the tests included in this manual may also be used
to satisfy those legislative or regulatory requirements.
(TOC)
3-1
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
Edition 2
3-2
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
Edition 2
CHAPTER 4
4.1.1 ASSESSMENT. This is an evaluation of the properties of an explosive material, including the
results of appropriate tests, to determine its relationship, with particular regard to safety, to other
explosive materials already in service use.
4.1.2 COMPARISON EXPLOSIVE. This is an in-service explosive with proven safety characteristics
whose properties are used to assess the relative safety and suitability of a new explosive
intended for use in a similar role.
4.1.4 MAIN CHARGE EXPLOSIVE. An explosive material (high explosive, propellant, or pyrotechnic)
used as the final charge and functioned to obtain the desired effect in the end item application.
4.1.5 FINAL (OR TYPE) QUALIFICATION. This relates to the use of the explosive material in a
specific application or munition. Final Qualification is given when the explosive has been
assessed as part of the design of the specific munition, and predicted to be safe and suitable for
military operational or training use in that role. The database of results provides a means of
undertaking “Risk Assessments”.
4.1.6 INTENDED ROLE. The main roles are as follows. Nations may define other roles or add the
specific information for the intended application of a particular explosive material.
b. Booster Explosive: An explosive material used to augment and transmit the reaction
(initiated by the primary explosive) with sufficient energy to initiate a detonation reaction in
the main charge high explosive.
d. Solid Gun Propellant: This is a substance (or a mixture of substances) that is required to burn
in a controlled manner within a gun combustion chamber producing hot gases capable of
propelling a projectile at high velocity. Combustible cases may also be included as they
contribute to the overall energy of the propellant.
e. Solid Rocket Propellant: This is a substance (or a mixture of substances) that is required to
burn in a controlled manner within a rocket motor producing hot gases that are vented
through a nozzle to propel the munition. Propellants used in cartridge activated or other non-
propulsive devices are also included in this category.
4-1
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
Edition 2
f. Liquid Propellant: This is a substance (or a mixture of substances) that is required to react in
a combustion chamber in controllable manner in order to generate propulsive force. These
may be monopropellants, bi-propellants or hybrids comprised of liquids and solids.
g. Pyrotechnic Compositions: These are substances (or a mixture of substances) that when
ignited, undergo an energetic chemical reaction at a controlled rate intended to produce on
demand and in various combinations, specific time delays or quantities of heat, noise, smoke,
light or infrared (IR) radiation. Pyrotechnic compositions may be used to initiate burning
reactions such as in igniters.
4.1.7 MANDATORY DATA. These are the results of mandatory tests that provide a basis for a decision
concerning the military application of the explosive.
4.1.8 MANDATORY TESTS. These are tests that should always be required by a National Authority to
produce data for assessing the safety and suitability of an explosive material. The tests compiled
in chapter 7 of this document are considered to be the minimum safety, performance, and
application-oriented tests required. Each nation reserves the right to use additional or
supplementary (optional) tests for Qualification. Where this is the case, the specific national
requirements are documented and the tests are identified in Chapter 10 of this manual.
4.1.9 NEW EXPLOSIVE. The term "new explosive" encompasses the following:
b. An explosive material for which the existing specification defining its composition, its material
constituents or process by which the composition is prepared has been modified.
d. An explosive material used in a role (See 4.1.5) for which it has not already been Qualified.
4.1.10 OPTIONAL DATA. Test results introduced to supplement data acquired in the mandatory tests or
to provide additional information where mandatory test results may be inconclusive.
4.1.11 OPTIONAL TESTS. Tests that may be required by a National Authority to produce data for
assessing the safety and suitability of an explosive material being considered for military
application. Optional tests are compiled by each nation in Chapter 10 of this manual.
4.1.13 QUALIFIED EXPLOSIVE MATERIAL. This is an explosive material that has successfully
completed the Qualification process of a National Authority. This is an intermediate risk reduction
stage prior to Final (or Type) Qualification.
4.1.14 REFERENCE STANDARD EXPLOSIVE. This is an explosive whose properties are consistent
and sufficiently well defined to enable its use for the calibration of test apparatus. The explosive
nominated as a reference standard, together with its lot number when appropriate, must be
identified on the relevant national test information sheet.
4-2
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
Edition 2
4.2 The following policy documents are referenced in this manual:
b. STANAG 4170 - "Principles and Methodology for the Qualification of Explosive Materials for
Military Use".
o
c. STANAG 4297 – Implementation of Allied Publication N 15 (AOP-15).
e. STANAG 4439 - Policy for Introduction, Assessment, and Testing for Insensitive Munitions
(MURAT).
f. AOP-15 - "Guidance on the Assessment of the Safety and Suitability for Service of Munitions
for the NATO Armed Forces".
(TOC)
4-3
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
Edition 2
4-4
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
Edition 2
CHAPTER 5
5.1 The participating countries have agreed on the following ways to record and issue data:
5.1.1 A formal Qualification report will be issued by the National Authority or by a National Authority
approved organization for each explosive Qualified. This report must include, in so far as
possible, all the information required to enable other participating countries to accept the
explosive with minimal or no additional testing. In general, the information reported must comply
with Tables 1 to 3 of STANAG 4170.
5.1.2 The technical report issued must identify the developer and manufacturer of the explosive, the
organization that conducted the tests and the qualifying National Authority. It will also include the
following:
5.1.3 Background information on the development of the explosive and the advantages expected from
its use.
5.1.4 The data required in Chapter 7 of this document. In addition, sensitivity and stability data acquired
during the development program, including any other pertinent information acquired in the
development and pre-production phases.
5.1.5 The description of the properties of the explosive that are relevant to its nature and intended use.
5.1.6 Information on tests performed to provide data relating to any unique characteristic.
5.1.7 An Assessment of the properties by comparing test data with that of comparison explosives of
known and proven satisfactory use in similar applications.
5.1.8 An evaluation of the physical, chemical, and aging properties of the explosive.
5.2 The formal Qualification Certificate issued by the National Authority (Annex B of STANAG 4170
Edition 2) and the reports issued to support Qualification will be released to requesting nations in
accordance with paragraph 3 of STANAG 4170.
5.3 For ease of reference and simplicity, a data sheet consistent with the format used in AOP-26 shall
be prepared by the National Authority or by a National Authority approved organization for each
explosive Qualified by a NATO country. These data sheets shall be forwarded to the custodian
nation for inclusion in AOP-26, “NATO Catalogue of Explosives”.
(TOC)
5-1
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
Edition 2
5-2
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
Edition 2
CHAPTER 6
6.1 This manual and the tests included herein will be reviewed upon the request of a participating
nation. If any changes are proposed the national delegate of the submitting country shall request
that the Chairman of AC/310 Subgroup 1 include this as an agenda item for the next meeting of
the Subgroup.
6.2 Requests to revise AOP-7 must be accompanied by supporting documentation and should be
presented to the Chairman of AC/310 Subgroup 1 for inclusion on the agenda of the next meeting
of the Subgroup. Subgroup 1 will rewrite and approve the revisions of Chapters 1 through 9 and
the leading section of Chapter 10 of this manual. Such revisions will be provided to the
Custodian Nation and to the International Staff secretary for publication. The United States is the
Custodian Nation for this document.
6.3 National Authorities shall perform regular reviews of their respective sections of Chapter 10 of this
document to verify that the information is still applicable. Subgroup 1 will review proposed
revisions of Chapter 10 of this manual and provide comments as appropriate. The Subgroup has
no authority to change the content of the National sections of Chapter 10 of this manual. This
authority resides solely within the purview of the National Authority of the submitting country.
(TOC)
6-1
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
Edition 2
6-2
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
Edition 2
CHAPTER 7
7.1 This chapter sets forth the minimum data requirements and assessment principles agreed upon
and used by the NATO and participating PfP countries for qualifying explosive materials in
accordance with STANAG 4170. National Authorities may require additional data in order to
qualify explosives for potential applications by their forces.
7.1.1 Unique requirements such as mandatory data, tests, criteria, etc., which may be imposed by a
country are included in the respective national sections of Chapter 10 of this manual. For
example, some nations have pass and fail criteria for booster explosives.
7.1.2 For each requirement, the information provided must be accompanied with data on comparison
explosives as defined in section 4.1.2. The selection of comparison explosives should be such
that each explosive selected is familiar to the nations participating in the collaborative weapons
development or procurement program.
7.1.3 In general, Qualification decisions made by the National Authority must be based on an
assessment of the relative safety of the new explosive compared to that of an explosive material
with proven safety characteristics that has been used in a similar role.
7.1.4 It is very important to determine whether the safety and performance characteristics of an
explosive will change during its life cycle. Accelerated aging studies shall be considered during
the explosives Qualification process. Basic information on aging is obtained during the
Qualification phase; however, the results of a more complete study of the aging characteristics of
the explosive material should be available before the Final (or Type) Qualification process is
completed. Example aging protocols are presented in Chapter 8 of this document.
7.1.5 Toxicity data on the explosive material, its components, and its reaction products shall, in-so-far-
as possible, be determined and included in the Qualification report.
7.1.6 Information on the ability of the explosive material to be reused, recycled or destroyed with
minimum effect on health and environment is required.
7.1.7 The condition of having been assessed as satisfactory on the basis of the information and tests
described herein is necessary but not sufficient for an explosive material to be Final (Type)
Qualified for a specific application in an operational or training device. Final (Type) Qualification
is subject to the demonstration of safety and suitability of the explosive in that specific application
with testing performed in accordance with STANAG 4297 and AOP-15. A general discussion on
Final (or Type) Qualification is provided in Chapter 9 of this document.
7.1.8 For ready reference, the STANAGs on agreed tests that are used by participating nations to
obtain data to support the Qualification of explosive materials in accordance with STANAG 4170
are listed in Chapter 10 of this document.
(TOC)
7-1
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
Edition 2
7-2
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
Edition 2
7.2.0 PRIMARY EXPLOSIVES
7.2.1 Primary explosives are sensitive materials used to initiate a detonation or a burning reaction. By
nature, these materials are sensitive to thermal, mechanical and electrical stimuli. In general,
they are not used beyond the safety and arming device. The information required for Qualification
is used to make an assessment of the safety of the explosive in comparison with in-service
explosives for which adequate safety has been demonstrated. Materials used in initial and
intermediary charges for primers, igniters, detonators, caps, relays, electric matches, fuze heads,
delays, explosive bolts, explosive switches, explosive valves, explosive cutters, and explosive
pistons are included when these do not qualify for evaluation and assessment under other
sections of this chapter.
7.2.2 The following data and information are necessary for the Qualification of primary explosives.
However, because of the sensitive nature of these explosives the tests identified below may not
always be appropriate. Thus on a case-by-case basis, the National Authority may substitute
other tests when the test apparatus or the test procedures required by the STANAGS listed in this
section are not appropriate.
a. Composition. A specification for the explosive material with its ingredients and, if
applicable, their permissible ranges specified shall be provided. The samples used for
the Qualification tests must comply with the specification and must be made by the
approved method of manufacture.
c. Loading. Information on the final state of the material in its intended application (i.e.,
pressed, cast, etc.) and, as appropriate, its nominal loading density in the anticipated
applications shall be provided.
c. Aging. Data acquired following accelerated aging to determine whether the material
characteristics will change with time shall be provided. Any change that could affect
safety and reliable performance is of particular concern. Example aging protocols are
presented in Chapter 8 of this document.
7-3
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
Edition 2
7.2.2.3 Hazard Assessment.
d. Impact. Drop-weight impact data acquired in accordance with appropriate national test
procedures which may include those of STANAG 4489 shall be provided. National
Authorities may require information on the degree of sensitization by grit on a case-by-
case basis.
e. Friction. Data acquired in accordance with appropriate national test procedures which
may include those of STANAG 4487 shall be provided.
(TOC)
7-4
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
Edition 2
7.3.0 BOOSTER EXPLOSIVES
7.3.1 Booster explosives are used to transmit and augment the reaction initiated by the primary
explosive with sufficient energy to initiate a detonation reaction in the high-explosive charge. A
detonation reaction of the booster explosive would normally be communicated to the high-
explosive charge when the fuze is in both the armed or unarmed condition. Booster explosives
need to be relatively sensitive materials, but to be Qualified, they must have been shown to be
sufficiently safe to be used beyond the safety and arming device or in-line fuze systems.
7.3.2 Explosives used in leads, relays, detonating cords, boosters, or in any other element used in
direct line (uninterrupted) with the high-explosive charge of an end item application are included
under the booster explosive requirements. The Qualification documents issued by the National
Authority should specify any restrictions in the role for which the booster explosive is qualified.
7.3.3 Historically, tetryl was deemed to be an acceptable comparison explosive and often used to
assess the sensitivity of new booster materials. It was used successfully in fuzes for many years
but many countries no longer produce it. Also, tetryl is not acceptable for operational use in
munitions designed to meet the Insensitive Munitions (MURAT) requirements per STANAG 4439
and AOP-39. Thermal heating of tetryl loaded items such as occurs in fast and slow cook-off tests
often leads to a detonation reaction that can transmit to the high-explosive charge in a weapon.
7.3.4 The data and other information obtained during the Qualification process are used by the National
Authority to assess the safety and suitability for service of the explosive material used in a
particular role. The following table provides the minimum criteria that should be considered by
National Authorities to judge the suitability for service of a booster explosive. The thresholds
established are based on test results obtained with tetryl; however, the values shown therein are
not necessarily the values obtained with all tetryl batches. A material that does not meet the
requirements set forth in table 1 should not be considered for use as a booster explosive. The
pass-fail criteria may be waived by the National Authority depending on the use of an explosive in
a specific application such as, for example, detonating cords.
7.3.5 In addition to table 1 (shown below), the following data and information are necessary for the
Qualification of booster explosives:
7-5
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
Edition 2
TABLE 1
MINIMUM REQUIREMENTS FOR BOOSTER EXPLOSIVES
TEST STANAG/PARAMETER
TEST PERFORMED CRITERIA
MEASURED
3
4556 MANOMETER/ NO MORE THAN 1.0 cm /g
o
VACUUM THERMAL STABILITY TRANSDUCER AT 100 C FOR 40 HOURS
DECOMPOSITION EXOTHERM
4515 DTA/DSC
PEAK > 180°C AT 5°C/min
THERMAL PROPERTIES
OR
4491
TEMPERATURE OF TEMPERATURE OF IGNITION
THERMAL PROPERTIES
IGNITION T of I > 180°C AT 5°C/min
NO EVIDENCE OF REACTION
BAM
AT 80 N FOR 10 OUT OF 10 TRIALS
4487
FRICTION
FIGURE OF FRICTION
ROTARY FRICTION
F of F > 3.0
NO EVIDENCE OF DETONATION AT
SMALL SCALE
1 GPa AT DENSITY OF APPLICATION FOR
GAP TEST
10 OUT OF 10 TRIALS
4488
SHOCK
NO EVIDENCE OF DETONATION AT 1.4
INTERMEDIATE SCALE
GPa AT DENSITY OF APPLICATION FOR
GAP TEST
10 OUT OF 10 TRIALS
4490 SMALL-SCALE
SEE NATIONAL SECTIONS IN
ELECTROSTATIC DISCHARGE SPARK TEST
CHAPTER 10
NO REACTION AT
BAM IMPACT
3 JOULE LEVEL FOR 10 OUT
TEST
OF 10 TRIALS
7-6
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
Edition 2
7.3.5.1 General Characteristics.
a. Composition. A specification for the explosive material with its ingredients and, if
applicable, their permissible ranges specified shall be provided. The samples used for
the Qualification tests must comply with the specification and must be made by the
approved method of manufacture.
c. Loading. Information on the final state (i.e., pressed, cast, etc.) and the density of the
material in its intended application shall be provided.
a. Stability & Thermal Characterization. Data acquired in accordance with STANAG 4515
and 4556, as appropriate, to support a determination of how the explosive reacts to
elevated temperatures over a period of time shall be provided.
b. Aging. Data acquired following accelerated aging to determine whether the material
characteristics will change with time shall be provided. Any change that could affect
safety and reliable performance is of particular concern. Example aging protocols are
presented in Chapter 8 of this document.
d. Density. Data on theoretical maximum density and acceptable loading density reported
in accordance with National procedures shall be provided.
e. Melting Point. When applicable. Data acquired in accordance with STANAG 4515 or
other methods found acceptable for use in explosive materials STANAGs, i.e., STANAG
4284 (HMX) shall be provided.
f. Glass Transition Point. Data acquired in accordance with STANAG 4540 shall be
provided for explosives made with polymeric binders.
g. Mechanical/Rheological Properties: Data per STANAG 4443, 4506, 4507, and 4525 may
be required for boosters made with polymeric binders.
(1) Ignition Temperature. Data acquired in accordance with STANAG 4491 or 4515,
as appropriate.
(2) Explosive Response when Ignited (Confined and Unconfined). Data acquired in
accordance with STANAG 4491.
7-7
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
Edition 2
(3) Electrostatic Discharge. Data acquired in accordance with STANAG 4490.
(4) Impact. Drop-weight impact data acquired in accordance with STANAG 4489.
b. Critical diameter. Minimum size required to sustain a steady state detonation shall be
provided. This may be estimated or measured by any method accepted by the National
Authority.
(TOC)
7-8
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
Edition 2
7.4.0 HIGH EXPLOSIVES
7.4.1 High explosives are compounds or formulations that are used as the final charge and detonated
to obtain the desired effect for the end-item application. The information acquired for
Qualification is used to assess the safety of the new explosive in comparison with in-service high
explosives for which adequate safety has been demonstrated. Materials demonstrated to be in
the same range of sensitivity in the hazard tests as in-service booster explosives, such as CH-6,
should be classed as booster rather than high explosives. National Authorities may allow a
booster explosive to be used as a main charge high explosive in certain instances. However
before a booster explosive is considered for a main charge application a safety assessment must
be performed and the potential application approved by the National Authority. The following data
and information are necessary for the Qualification of high explosives:
a. Composition. A specification for the explosive material with its ingredients and, if
applicable, their permissible ranges specified shall be provided. The samples used for the
Qualification tests must comply with the specification and must be made by the approved
method of manufacture.
c. Loading. Information on the final state (i.e., pressed, cast, etc.) and the density of the
material in its intended application shall be provided.
a. Stability & Thermal Characterization. Data acquired in accordance with STANAG 4515
and 4556, as appropriate, to support a determination of how the explosive reacts to
elevated temperatures over a period of time shall be provided.
b. Aging. Data acquired following accelerated aging to determine whether the material
characteristics will change with time shall be provided. Any change that could affect
safety and reliable performance is of particular concern. Example aging protocols are
presented in Chapter 8 of this document.
d. Density. Data shall be provided on the theoretical maximum density and the acceptable
loading density. The data shall be acquired in accordance with National procedures.
e. Melting Point. When applicable. Data acquired in accordance with STANAG 4515 or
other methods found acceptable for use in explosive materials STANAGs, i.e., STANAG
4284 (HMX) shall be provided.
f. Glass Transition Point. Data acquired in accordance with STANAG 4540 shall be
provided for explosives that are made with polymeric binders.
7-9
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
Edition 2
g. Mechanical/Rheological Properties: Data per STANAG 4443, 4506, 4507, and 4525 may
be required for high explosives made with polymeric binders.
(1) Ignition Temperature. Data acquired in accordance with STANAG 4491 or 4515,
as appropriate.
(2) Explosive Response When Ignited (Confined and Unconfined). Data acquired in
accordance with STANAG 4491.
(4) Impact. Drop-weight impact data acquired in accordance with STANAG 4489.
b. Critical Diameter. Minimum size required to sustain a steady state detonation shall be
provided. This may be estimated or measured by any method accepted by the National
Authority.
(TOC)
7-10
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
Edition 2
7.5.0 SOLID GUN AND ROCKET PROPELLANTS
7.5.1 Solid gun and rocket propellants are substances or mixtures of substances that are required to
burn in a controlled manner in devices such as guns, rocket motors, or gas generators.
Propellants comprise a wide range of formulations each of which is tailored to a specific
application. It is thus difficult to define a concise list of data requirements for Qualification
common to all propellants. It is possible, however, to establish basic requirements and indicate,
where appropriate, the types of propellants that apply. Because final adjustments to the
formulations must be made throughout the propulsion or gas generator unit development period,
the Qualification of solid propellants may be concurrent with Final (or Type) Qualification of the
propellant for use in a specific application. The following data and information are necessary for
the Qualification of solid propellants:
a. Composition. A specification for the explosive material with its ingredients and, if
applicable, their permissible ranges specified shall be provided. The samples used for
the Qualification tests must comply with the specification and must be made by the
approved method of manufacture.
b. Intended Application. Information on the intended application (i.e. gun, rocket motor, gas
generator, etc.) shall be provided.
c. Loading. Information on final state of the material (i.e. cast, pressed, extruded, etc.) and
the density of the material in its intended application shall be provided.
a. Stability & Thermal Characterization. Data acquired in accordance with STANAG 4515
and 4556 to support a determination of how the propellant reacts to elevated
temperatures over a period of time shall be provided. Also, data on stabilizer depletion
shall be provided. Depending on the formulation, stabilizer depletion shall be measured in
accordance with either STANAG 4117, 4527, 4541, or 4542. (see NOTE at chapter 8,
section 8.4)
b. Aging. Data acquired following accelerated aging to determine whether the material
characteristics will change with time shall be provided. Any change that could affect
safety and reliable performance is of particular concern. Example aging protocols are
presented in Chapter 8 of this document.
d. Density. Data on theoretical maximum density and acceptable loading density acquired in
accordance with National procedures shall be provided.
e. Glass Transition Point. Data acquired in accordance with STANAG 4540 shall be
provided for solid propellants that use a polymeric binder.
7-11
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
Edition 2
f. Tensile Strength. Data on uni-axial tensile properties acquired in accordance with
STANAG 4506 and data on stress relaxation in tension in accordance with STANAG
4507 shall be provided for solid rocket propellants.
(1) Ignition Temperature. Data acquired in accordance with STANAG 4491 or 4515,
as appropriate.
(2) Explosive Response When Ignited (Confined and Unconfined). Data acquired in
accordance with STANAG 4491.
(4) Impact. Drop-weight impact data acquired in accordance with STANAG 4489.
(6) Shock. Shock sensitivity data acquired in accordance with STANAG 4488 shall
be provided. For gun propellants, tests are performed with propellant grains
loaded into the gap-test tube.
a. Critical Diameter. Minimum size required to sustain a steady state detonation shall be
provided. This may be estimated using data on similar compositions or measured by any
method accepted by the National Authority. This is not required for compositions that do
not detonate in the shock sensitivity test performed in accordance with STANAG 4488.
(TOC)
7-12
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
Edition 2
7.6.0 LIQUID PROPELLANTS
7.6.1 Liquid propellants are substances or mixtures of substances that are required to react in a
combustion chamber in a controllable and predictable manner. Liquid propellants are as varied
as the uses in which one finds them. These may be mono-propellants, bi-propellants, or hybrids
comprised of liquids and solids. Mono-propellants are generally single substances or mixtures of
pre-mixed substances that burn when ignited. Bi-propellants are generally comprised of
separately stored fuels and oxidizer materials that are mixed and ignited in a combustion
chamber. The fuel and oxidizer components may be hypergolic and ignite spontaneously on
contact or may require an ignition source to initiate the reaction. The hybrids are generally
comprised of solid fuels, which are reacted with liquid oxidizers. The following data and
information are required for the Qualification of liquid propellants:
a. Composition. A specification for the explosive material with its ingredients and, if
applicable, their permissible ranges specified shall be provided. The samples used for
the Qualification tests must comply with the specification and must be made by the
approved method of manufacture.
b. Propellant Type and Intended Application. Information on the type of propellant and its
intended application, e.g. gun propellant, rocket propellant, naval torpedo propellant etc.
shall be provided.
c. Loading. Information shall be provided on the proposed mixing and handling procedures
and on any unusually hazardous conditions in these operations.
a. Stability & Thermal Characterization. Data acquired in accordance with STANAG 4515 to
determine if its properties change with time shall be provided. Also, where appropriate
data on stabilizer depletion shall be provided. Analytical techniques used to determine
stabilizer depletion must be approved by the National Authority.
b. Aging. Data acquired following accelerated aging shall be provided to determine whether
the material characteristics will change with time shall be provided. Any change that
could affect safety and reliable performance is of particular concern.
d. Toxicity. Information shall be provided on the toxicity hazards of the explosive and on its
component materials in accordance with national procedures.
(1) Ignition Temperature. Data acquired in accordance with STANAG 4491 or 4515
as appropriate.
(2) Explosive Response when Ignited (Confined and Unconfined). Data acquired in
accordance with STANAG 4491.
(4) Shock. Shock sensitivity data acquired in accordance with STANAG 4488.
(5) Critical Film Thickness. For materials that detonate in the shock sensitivity test,
data on the critical diameter or critical liquid film thickness for detonation
propagation is required. Test procedures must be documented and approved by
the National Authority.
(TOC)
7-14
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
Edition 2
7.7.0 PYROTECHNIC COMPOSITIONS
7.7.1 Pyrotechnic compositions undergo an energetic chemical reaction at a controlled rate intended to
produce, on demand, time delays or quantities of heat, noise, smoke, light, or IR radiation. In
general, pyrotechnic compositions can be readily ignited, burn rapidly, and are very hot when
they burn. Because final adjustments to the formulations must be made throughout the end-item
development phase, Qualification of pyrotechnic materials may be concurrent with Final (or Type)
Qualification. The following data and information are required for their Qualification:
b. Intended Application. Information shall be provided on the intended application (i.e. flare,
smoke, etc.).
c. Loading. Information shall be provided on the final state of the material (i.e. granular,
cast, pressed, extruded, etc.), and the density of the material in its intended application.
a. Stability & Thermal Characterization. Data acquired in accordance with STANAG 4515 to
support a determination of how the pyrotechnic material reacts to elevated temperatures
over an extended period of time shall be provided.
b. Aging. Data acquired following accelerated aging to determine whether the material
characteristics will change with time shall be provided. Any change that could affect
safety and reliable performance is of particular concern. Chapter 8 of this document
provides examples of aging protocols.
d. Density. Data shall be provided on theoretical maximum density and acceptable loading
density reported in accordance with national procedures.
e. Glass Transition Point. Data acquired in accordance with STANAG 4540 shall be
provided for pyrotechnics that use a polymeric material as the binder shall be provided.
f. Mechanical/Rheological Properties: Data per STANAG 4506, 4507, and 4443 may be
required for pyrotechnics made with polymeric binders.
7-15
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
Edition 2
7.7.1.3 Hazard Assessment.
(1) Ignition Temperature. Data acquired in accordance with STANAG 4491 or 4515
as appropriate.
(2) Explosive Response When Ignited (Confined and Unconfined). Data acquired in
accordance with STANAG 4491.
(4) Impact. Drop-weight impact data acquired in accordance with STANAG 4489.
(6) Shock. Shock sensitivity data acquired in accordance with STANAG 4488, if
appropriate.
(TOC)
7-16
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
Edition 2
CHAPTER 8
8.1 Accelerated aging studies on new explosives are recommended and should begin early during
the qualification-testing phase. Aging studies should be started shortly after the physical and
chemical characteristics of the new explosive have been defined. It may often be desirable to
request Qualification by the National Authority before the accelerated aging studies are
completed. But in any case, these studies should be in progress and continue until there is
reasonable assurance that no unanticipated aging problems exist. The objective of beginning an
aging protocol before Qualification is to determine, early, if characteristics of the explosive
material are apt to change with time and if any of the changes are likely to affect the safety and
suitability for service of the material in an end-item application.
8.2 The decision to grant or deny Qualification before the accelerated aging studies are completed is
left to the National Authority. In so far as possible, the data acquired along with safe-life and
service-life predictions based on changes in the explosive properties, if any, should be submitted
to the National Authority with the Qualification request package. Based on the data available at
the time and, if it is deemed appropriate, the Qualification request submission should contain a
recommendation concerning the need to conduct additional aging studies before or after Final
(type) Qualification of the explosive material for the end-item application.
8.3 Tables 2 through 7, provided on the following pages, are examples of aging protocols used by
some of the participating countries. These can serve as examples that can be used by other
countries to develop their own aging protocols.
8.4 NOTE: STANAGs 4117, 4527, 4541, and 4542 referred to in the tables below will be replaced by
AOP-48 – “Explosives, Nitrocellulose Based Propellants, Stability Test Procedures and
Requirements Using Stabilizer Depletion” and its covering document, STANAG 4620.
(TOC)
8-1
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
Edition 2
8-2
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
Edition 2
TABLE 2
AGING PROTOCOLS – PRIMARY EXPLOSIVES
UNITED
PROCEDURE FRANCE GERMANY NETHERLANDS SWITZERLAND USA (NAVY)
KINGDOM
71°C for 4
70 ºC for 6, 12
weeks National
months in
Aging in sealed Authority to
1 60 ºC for 6, 12 sealed
conditions: containers decide if
2 No criteria given months in sealed containers
a. Without 60 ºC for 2 months [80qC/4 weeks ] aging is
containers and 25ºC at
nitrate esters 23 °C for 4 appropriate
30%RH until
present weeks at 30, 50, on a case by
Final (Type)
65, & 83% RH case basis
Qualification.
b. With nitrate
As above As above As above As above As above As above
esters
Impact
AOP-7 Yes Yes
sensitivity
Friction
AOP-7 Yes Yes Yes
sensitivity
Priming ability Yes Yes
ESD sensitivity Yes
Chemical
Yes
analysis
Hot wire
Yes
ignitability
Temperature of
Yes
ignition
Thermal stability
DSC/DTA/TG STANAG 4515 DSC Yes
Closed vessel 3
Yes
test
Heat of 3
Yes
explosion
Notes:
Note 1. HFC glass ampoules
Note 2. If extreme thermal stress within service lifetime can be predicted
Note 3. Only for non-detonating mixtures
8-3
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
8-4
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
TABLE 3
AGING PROTOCOLS - BOOSTER EXPLOSIVES
UNITED
PROCEDURE FRANCE GERMANY NETHERLANDS SWITZERLAND USA (NAVY)
KINGDOM
90qC for 1 month;
sealed containers1
60qC for 1,2 & 4 60qC for 1,2,4,6,8
(65qC for 2 months2)
months months
Temperature cycle 60qC for 3 & 6
Aging conditions: No criteria given 70qC for 1,2 & 4 70qC for 1,2,4,6
program: months at ambient
60qC for 6 months months months
-40qC [3hr] to +63qC and 40% relative
a. Without nitrate esters present sealed containers3 sealed containers
[3hr]. (Max. 100 humidity4
(polyester binders (polyester binders
cycles) Temperature
also at 30%RH) also at 30%RH)
change within 1 hr
sealed containers1
50qC for 1,3, 6, 9 &
12 months
60qC for 1,2,4,6,8
50qC for 1,3,6,9 &
60qC for 1,2, & 3 months
Aging conditions: 12 months;
months at ambient 25qC at 30%RH
60qC for 6 months As above 60qC for 1,2,4,6 & 8
and 40% relative until final (type)
b. With nitrate esters months5
humidity4 qualification
sealed containers
(polyester binders
also at 30%RH)
Impact sensitivity STANAG 4489C Yes STANAG 4489B8 Yes
Friction sensitivity STANAG 4487A Yes STANAG 4487B8 Yes
Uniaxial tensile test STANAG 4506 20qC Yes Yes Yes (3 temp’s)
Uniaxial compression test STANAG 4443 20qC Yes Yes Yes
DMA glass transition temp. Yes (if relevant) STANAG 4540
Shock sensitivity STANAG 4488B Yes11
Friability AOP-7
Temperature of ignition Yes STANAG 44918 Yes
Thermal stability STANAG 44918 Yes
Vacuum thermal stability STANAG 4556
DTA/DTG or DSC Yes Yes Yes10
X-ray Yes12
Cube crack test Yes (cylinder)6 Yes 30 d/ 80qC9 Yes13
Heat flow calorimetry Yes7
Projectile impact Yes
Safe life or service prediction Yes (if applicable) Yes
Sol/gel level Yes (if applicable)
Weight and volume change Yes
Stabilizer/antioxidant content Yes (if applicable) Yes (if applicable) Yes (if applicable)
See Notes on following page.
8-5
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
8-6
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
TABLE 4
AGING PROTOCOLS - HIGH EXPLOSIVES
PROCEDURE FRANCE GERMANY NETHERLANDS SWITZERLAND UNITED KINGDOM USA (NAVY)
90qC for 1 mon
th; sealed containers1
Time and 60qC for 1,2 & 4
(65qC for 2 months2)
temperature months 60qC for 1,2,4,6,8 months
Temperature cycle
dependant on 70qC for 1,2 & 4 60qC for 3 & 6 months at 70qC for 1,2,4,6 months
Aging conditions: 60qC for 6 program:
specific composition months ambient and 40% relative sealed containers
a. Without nitrate esters present months -40qC [3hr] to +63qC [3hr]
sealed containers3 humidity4 (polyester binders also at
(Max. 100 cycles).
(polyester binders also 30%RH)
Temperature change
at 30%RH)
within 1 hr
sealed containers1
50qC for 1,3, 6, 9 & 12
months
50qC for 1,3,6,9 & 12 60qC for 1,2,4,6,8 months
months; 60qC for 1,2, & 3 months 25qC at 30%RH
60qC for 6
b. With nitrate esters As above As above 60qC for 1,2,4,6 & 8 at ambient and 40% until final (type)
months
months5 relative humidity4 qualification
sealed containers
(polyester binders also at
30%RH)
Impact sensitivity STANAG 4489C Yes Yes STANAG 4489B8 Yes
Friction sensitivity STANAG 4487A Yes Yes STANAG 4487B8 Yes
STANAG 4506
Uniaxial tensile Yes Yes Yes Yes (3 temp’s)
20qC
STANAG 4443
Uniaxial compression Yes Yes Yes Yes
20qC
Stress relaxation Yes
DMA glass transition temp. Yes (if relevant) STANAG 4540
Shock sensitivity STANAG 4488B Yes11
Friability AOP-7
Hardness Shore A Yes
Temperature of ignition Yes STANAG 44918 Yes
Thermal stability Yes STANAG 44918 Yes
Vacuum thermal stability STANAG 4556
DTA/DTG or DSC Yes Yes Yes10
X-ray Yes12
Cube crack Yes (cylinder)6 Yes 30 d/ 80qC9 Yes13
Heat flow calorimetry Yes7
Projectile impact Yes
Exudation Yes
Safe life or service prediction Yes (if applicable) Yes
Sol/gel level Yes (if applicable)
Weight and volume change Yes
Stabilizer/antioxidant content Yes (if applicable) Yes (if applicable) Yes (if applicable) Yes (if applicable)
See Notes on following page.
8-7
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
8-9
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
TABLE 5
AGING PROTOCOLS – SOLID GUN PROPELLANTS
UNITED
PROCEDURE FRANCE GERMANY NETHERLANDS SWITZERLAND USA (NAVY)
KINGDOM
60qC for 1, 2, 4 60qC for 1,2,4,6,8
months 70qC for 1,2,4 months
Time and temperature
Aging conditions:
50qC for 3,6,12,24
dependant on specific months in 60qC for 1,2,4,8 70qC for 1,2,4,6
60qC for 3 months
weeks and 12, 24 sealed containers months at ambient months
a. Without nitrate esters present in sealed containers2 composition
months ( if polyester binder and 40%RH6 sealed containers
present also at ( if polyester binder
30%RH) present use 30%RH)
50qC for 1,3,6,9, 12
50qC for 3, 6, 9 months
months 60qC for 1,2,3,6 60qC for 1,2,4,6,8
b. With nitrate esters
As above As above As above 60qC for 1,2, 3, 6 months at ambient months
months and 40%RH6 sealed containers
70qC for 2,4,8 weeks5 25qC at 30%RH until
final (type) qualification
Impact sensitivity Yes Yes7 Yes
Friction sensitivity Yes Yes7 Yes
Shock sensitivity Yes8
Ignition temperature Yes (DTA) Yes Yes7 Yes
DSC/DTA Yes Yes9
HFC STANAG 4582 Yes3 STANAG 4582
Stabilizer/Antioxidant content Yes Yes Yes (if applicable) Yes Yes Yes (if applicable)
Safe life prediction Yes Yes Yes (chem & ser.)
Compressive strength Yes1 Yes Yes Yes
DMA STANAG 4540
Closed vessel Yes Yes4
Thermal stability STANAG 44917 Yes
Vacuum stability STANAG 4556
X-ray Yes10
Sol-gel determination Yes (if applicable)
GPC Yes
See Notes on following page.
8-10
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
8-11
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
TABLE 6
AGING PROTOCOLS – SOLID ROCKET PROPELLANTS
UNITED
PROCEDURE FRANCE GERMANY NETHERLANDS SWITZERLAND USA (NAVY)
KINGDOM
50qC for 4,8,16, 32 63qC for 1, 2, 4, 8
60qC for 3 months in 60qC for 1,2,4,6,8
weeks months 74qC for
sealed containers1 months
Aging conditions: Temp program 60qC for 2,4,8,16 1,2,4, 6 months in 60qC for 1,2,4,8
70qC for 1,2,4,6 months
60qC for 6 months weeks sealed containers3 months at ambient
-46qC [2hr] to 23qC [2hr] sealed containers
a. Composite propellants sealed bags, low RH. ( if polyester binder and 40%RH7
to 63qC [2hr] up to 100 ( if polyester binder
[40qC and 70qC may present also at
cycles; 'T 5 secs present use 30%RH)
also be used] 30%RH)
50qC for 1,3,6,9, 12
50qC for 1,3, 6, 9 months
(12) months 60qC for 1,2,3,6 60qC for 1,2,4,6,8
b. Nitrate ester propellants
50qC for 6 months As above As above 60qC for 1,2, 4, 6 months at ambient months
8 months and 40%RH7 sealed containers
25qC at 30%RH until
final (type) qualification
Impact sensitivity STANAG 4489C Yes Yes8 Yes
Friction sensitivity STANAG 4487A Yes Yes8 Yes
Shock sensitivity Yes
Ignition temperature Yes Yes8 Yes10
DSC/DTA Yes Yes11
HFC
Stabilizer/Antioxidant content Nitrate ester only Yes Yes (if applicable) Yes Yes
Chemical analysis Nitrate ester only Yes (plasticizer) Notes 4 & 5
Safe life prediction Yes (safe & serv)2 Yes (safe & serv) Yes (safe & serv)
Uniaxial tensile test STANAG 4506 20qC Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes (3 temp’s)
Compressive strength
Stress relaxation test Yes Yes
Shore A hardness Yes
DMA Yes
Closed vessel test
Linear burning rate Yes
Thermal stability Yes Yes Yes8 Yes
Vacuum stability STANAG 4556
Microscopy Control of aspect
Cube crack test Yes6(if applicable) Yes9(if applicable) Yes12(if applicable)
X-ray Yes13
Density Composite only
Sol-gel determination Yes Yes (if applicable)
See Notes on following page.
8-12
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
8-13
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
TABLE 7
AGING PROTOCOLS - PYROTECHNICS
UNITED
PROCEDURE FRANCE GERMANY NETHERLANDS SWITZERLAND USA (NAVY)
KINGDOM
23qC for 4 weeks
at 30, 50, 65, & Time, temperature 70qC for 3, 6, 12 70qC for 6, 12
83% RH and humidity vary months sealed National Authority months in sealed
Aging conditions: Temp program depending on containers under to decide if aging is containers
60qC for 2 months
-35qC [3hr] to specific controlled appropriate on a and 25qC at
63qC [3hr] 4 composition humidity case by case basis 30%RH until final
weeks sealed (Type) qual.
1
containers
Impact sensitivity STANAG 4489C
Friction sensitivity STANAG 4487A
Chemical life prediction Yes
Ignitability Yes (by black p’r) Yes
Temperature of ignition Yes Yes
Thermal stability Yes
STANAG 4515
DSC/DTA/TG Yes Yes (DSC/TG) Yes (DSC/TG) Yes
DSC
2
HFC Yes (3-4 temps) Yes
Notes:
Note 1. Welded aluminum bags
Note 2. 60% relative humidity; 70qC/30 days, 60qC/90 days
(TOC)
8-14
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
8-15
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
CHAPTER 9
9.1 This chapter provides information about Final (or Type) Qualification of an explosive material. A
national or a military service authority generally reviews the safety and suitability data and grants
this approval level. This is generally the final approval level and it allows an explosive to be used
operationally by the military forces. Some call this step “Final Qualification” while others call it
“Type Qualification”. Whatever name is given to this level of approval however, this final review
and assessment should be executed, in some way, by all countries before an item loaded with
this explosive is released for operational or training use. Final (or Type) Qualification was the
name agreed by the NATO AC/310 for this approval level for military explosive materials.
9.2 The Final (or Type) Qualification process provides the explosive materials scientists and safety
experts an opportunity to perform a final review of the safety and the suitability for service data
acquired on the material. This generally includes a review of the stability, compatibility, aging,
mechanical and physical properties, and sensitivity data acquired during both the explosive
Qualification program and the end-item application research, development, and sensitivity test
programs. After reviewing this information, the safety authorities are in a better position to provide
the national approval authority a complete evaluation and a recommendation on the safety and
suitability for service of the explosive in the intended application.
9.3 The Final (or Type) Qualification process requires that tests and assessments be performed in
accordance with STANAG 4297 and AOP-15. In some cases, Qualification (as required by
STANAG 4170) and Final Qualification evaluations are performed at the same time. This is
especially true for solid propellants and pyrotechnics because formulations are often modified
until the desired end-item performance is achieved.
9.4 Data submitted to the National Authority for Final (or Type) Qualification of an explosive should
be sufficient to show that the explosive is safe and suitable for operational or training use in the
intended application. Tests to acquire the data may be performed on the complete ordnance
package or on subsystems, e.g., warhead, rocket motor, etc., as long as extrapolation of
vulnerability characteristics to all-up ordnance item can be justified.
9.5 In some instances assessments may be used to satisfy some of the testing requirements. This is
particularly true where data from generic tests conducted on the explosive material in simulated
application-type containers are available. Justification for such assessments, with supporting
data, should be included in the Final (or Type) Qualification data package. Computer modeling
may be used in conjunction with generic tests results and data from the Qualification phase (see
chapter 7) as a tool to assess the behavior of explosive materials under a wide range of stimuli
and scenarios. Qualification data define many of the intrinsic properties of the energetic material
and allow for the generation of a range of modeling parameters that can be used in the
assessment.
9.6 For Final (or Type) Qualification, chemical compatibility with materials the explosive is likely to be
in contact with and accelerated aging data should be available. The chemical compatibility data
should include information obtained with the explosive in contact with all materials (both energetic
and inert) with which it will come in contact in production and in the specific end item in which it
will be used.
9.7 The following are some of the sensitivity test STANAGS that relate to Final (or type) Qualification
and are used in conjunction with STANAG 4297 and AOP-15:
a. Liquid Fuel Fire: This test is performed in accordance with STANAG 4240
(TOC)
9-2
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
CHAPTER 10
10.1 This chapter identifies the National Authorities and provides information on the procedures used
to Qualify explosive materials in each participating nation. In addition, it contains a list of NATO
STANAGs used to describe Qualification tests and brief descriptions of tests that are used by
member nations to satisfy the Qualification requirements but are not detailed by NATO
STANAGs.
10.2 Countries that have not provided information to include in this chapter are invited to send their
contribution to the Chairman of AC/310 Subgroup 1 (Explosive Materials) and to the Custodian
Nation. Even if a country does not have a formal qualification procedure per STANAG 4170 in
place, it is important to note that fact along with a description of the process used to accept an
explosive material for use by its military in this chapter. The Custodian Nation will add new inputs
to this chapter upon receipt.
10.3 All nations accept, as a minimum, the information and data requirements documented in Chapter
7 of this manual. Some nations have unique tests and passing criteria for certain types or classes
of explosives. Where these exist, they are documented in the national sections of this chapter.
a. STANAG 4117 - Explosives, Stability Test Procedures for Propellants Stabilized with
Diphenylamine, Ethyl Centralite, or Mixtures of Both. (See Note below)
10.4.1 NOTE: STANAGs 4117, 4527, 4541, and 4542 referred to above will be replaced by AOP-48 –
“Explosives, Nitrocellulose Based Propellants, Stability Test Procedures and Requirements Using
Stabilizer Depletion” and its covering document, STANAG 4620.
(TOC)
10-2
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
10.5.0 TEST INFORMATION SHEETS
10.5.1 Test information sheets are used to provide summaries of the national tests used to supplement
the STANAGs referenced in this document.
10.5.2 For consistency among nations and ease of reference, each test information sheet is assigned an
AOP-7 registry number. The qualification test categories and sub-categories for each explosive
material are identified under “Type of Test” in the Test Information Sheets. The tests are divided
into three major categories: (a) Chemical, Mechanical, and Physical properties; (b) Hazard
Assessment; and (c) Performance. Each category and sub-category is assigned a number as
shown below:
10-3
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
Category 200 Hazard Assessment
201.01.XXX Impact
201.02.XXX Friction
201.03.XXX Electrical Discharge
201.04.XXX Shock
201.05.XXX Projectile Impact
201.06.XXX Fragment Impact
201.07.XXX Shaped Charge Jet Impact
201.08.XXX Other
203.XX.XXX Compatibility
203.01.XXX Reactivity
203.02.XXX Other
10.6 Results from reference standard explosives are included in "typical results" on the Test
Information Sheets.
10-4
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
10.7 NATIONAL QUALIFICATION PROCEDURES
NOTE: The information in this section is as approved by the National Authority in each participating
nation. Any changes made to the national sections must comply with the methods outlined in
Chapter 6 of this manual.
(TOC)
10-5
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
10-6
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
10.7.1 QUALIFICATION PROCEDURES OF CANADA
PARAGRAPH PAGE
b. PROPELLANTS CN-6
c. PYROTECHNICS CN-7
CN-1
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
CN-2
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
10.7.1.1 MILITARY DEPARTMENTS RESPONSIBLE FOR QUALIFICATION
10.7.1.1.1 The National Authority has established an Explosive Qualification Advisory Committee to
advise on all matters pertaining to the qualification of explosives. This committee decides
on the tests, reviews results, and recommends whether an explosive satisfies the criteria
for qualification.
10.7.1.1.2 The committee is chaired by the Director of Ammunition Procurement and Maintenance
(DAPM) of the Department of National Defense. He reports directly to the National
Authority. Members of the committee consist of a Secretary from the DAPM staff and
experienced personnel from the following Government organizations:
10.7.1.1.3 The Explosives Qualification Advisory Committee selects expertise from other
departments of Government or private industry, when necessary.
10.7.1.2.1 The National Authority for Military Explosives is the Director Ammunition Procurement
and Maintenance (DAPM) of the Department of National Defense. This office is
responsible for the design of all munitions for the Canadian Armed Forces.
CN-3
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
10.7.1.3 QUALIFICATION PROCEDURES
10.7.1.3.1 Requests for qualification are submitted to the National Authority who normally refers the
request to the Explosives Qualification Advisory Committee for consideration and
appropriate actions.
10.7.1.3.2 In Canada most of the research on military explosives of all types is performed in the
following two defense research establishments of the Department of National Defense:
10.7.1.3.3 Most of the qualification tests used by Canada are identical to or based on tests
developed and used by the United Kingdom and United States. Although the reasons for
this are historical, there is a present-day advantage in terms of standardization and
interoperability. US MIL-STDs and NATO STANAGs are extensively used for specifying
Canadian military items.
10.7.1.3.4 In general, formal qualification testing is not done until an explosive has successfully
passed all stages of research and development including pilot-scale production. The
explosive also must have been produced in pre-production lots using full scale production
equipment, conditions and methods. However, it is customary to use appropriate
qualification tests during the research and development phases to ensure that when an
explosive finally reaches production it will be unlikely to encounter unforeseen problems.
10.7.1.3.5 Before qualification it is necessary for an explosive to have its transportation and storage
hazard classification determined in accordance with NATO STANAG 4123, "Methods to
Determine and Classify Hazards of Ammunition." This action is the responsibility of the
Department of National Defense for Military Explosives and of the Department of Natural
Resources.
10.7.1.4.1 DAPM has no test facilities. Therefore tests are normally done by the Defense Research
Establishments, the Canadian Explosives Research Laboratory or other Government
agencies. In some cases tests may be conducted in the test laboratories of industry with
DAPM providing an observer or test supervisor. The establishment or agency which has
conducted the tests must report to the Secretary of the Explosives Qualification Advisory
Committee the results and any observations. The Secretary is then responsible for
arranging a review meeting of the Advisory Committee to decide the following:
CN-4
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
10.7.1.4.2 When the Advisory Committee is satisfied that the explosive warrants qualification, the
Secretary prepares the appropriate papers and data sheets for approval and issuance by
the National Authority.
d. Optional Data for Main-ChargeHigh Explosives: Some of these and other tests
may be required to augment the data derived from mandatory tests:
10.7.1.4.4 PROPELLANTS:
c. Solid propellants are tested in two stages, as formulations and in specific motors:
(a) compatibility
(b) chemical, physical properties including mechanical properties,
(c) sensitivity
(d) ballistic properties
(2) In specific rocket motors, the following data are obtained and evaluated:
NOTE: Most Canadian gun propellants are developed in other countries and adapted to
Canadian needs when required. Manufacturing processes and equipment are
usually based on those used in other countries. The qualification tests are either
identical or similar to tests used in other countries.
CN-6
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
Test Registry/STANAG Number
NOTE: The liquid propellants used by the Canadian forces in naval torpedoes or other
uses are generally procured from other countries. The data required for these
materials is as documented in Chapter for liquid propellants.
10.7.1.4.5 PYROTECHNICS
NOTE: The Test Information Sheets are listed consecutively in accordance with the
Registry number.
CN-9
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
CN-10
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
Canada/102.01.003
1. TYPE OF EXPLOSIVE:
b. Description: 0.4 X 0.4 X 4.0 in (10 X 10 X 10 mm) specimen is cut from block with
band saw. Wooden tabs are bonded to specimen with 5-minute epoxy. A 5% strain is
applied by a spring-actuated relaxation testing machine equipped with a
temperature/humidity conditioning box. After conditioning at the specified test
temperature (from -82°C to 72°C), the spring mechanism is actuated and the decay of
force is measured as time progresses. Four replicates at each test temperature are
tested. Test duration of the order of 1000 minutes is required to define the relaxation
curve. Time duration of aging and humidity are important. A master curve in the form of
a Prony series as a function of reduced time using a non-linear curve fitting technique or
the original WLF equation is reported.
d. Typical Results: A master curve of the relaxation modulus as a function of shifted time
often presented in the form of a Prony series.
CN-11
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
Canada/102.01.010
b. Description:
d. Typical Results:
CN-12
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
Canada/102.01.023
1. TYPE OF EXPLOSIVE:
b. Description: Sample is normally 4-in. diameter by 0.7-in. thick, but any smooth surface is
suitable. There are two possibilities: tester applied by hand or mounted on a "CONVE
LOADER". When applied by hand, a light pressure must be applied and the reading is
taken after 15 sec. The reading varies with time, pressure, surface quality and
homogeneity of the sample.
A CONVE LOADER is a stand that holds the tester and depresses it on the sample with
constant pressure. More repetitive results are obtained. Three readings are taken at
various locations on the sample and a mean value is given.
c. Information Requirements for Assessment: The test gives the hardness of a rubbery
(composite) material in the Shore "A" range. Hardness is used with curable materials to
monitor the curing reaction of polymers or polymer bounded composites. Readings are
taken with time (from day to day) and when the hardness ceases to increase the curing is
considered complete.
e. Repeatability and Reproducibility: Repeatability and reproducibility are good, but depend
on the operator unless the "conveloader" is used.
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
CN-13
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
Canada/102.01.051
(1) Application: Thermal conductivity is required to carry out transient thermal stress
analysis of rocket propellant grains.
(2) Significance: Essential.
(3) Limitations:
(4) Properties: Density.
d. Typical Results:
CN-14
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
Canada/102.01.060
(1) Application: The CTE is required for thermal stress analysis of rocket propellant
grains and explosive charges. Tg, is used to assess the lowest operating
temperature limit of a propellant or explosive.
(2) Significance: Essential.
(3) Limitations: The measured Tg is often different from the one measured with TMA or
DMA.
(4) 4. Properties:
d. Typical Results:
(1) Tg = + 2% a = + 4.5%
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
(1) Bedford, F. and Ouellet, A., “A linear Dilatometer for use with polymeric
materials", DREV TN-1977/71, 1971.
CN-15
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
Canada/102.01.070
b. Description: The specimen must be small enough to fit into a 156 ml test cell (50 mm in
diameter). The specimen is placed in the test cell and the Pycnometer is purged with
helium gas. The volume of the test cell is then increased by a known volume and the
volume of the specimen is calculated from the pressure difference resulting from the
change in volume of the test cell. The density is obtained by dividing the weight of the
specimen by the volume measured with the Pycnometer.
(1) Application: Density measurement of any solid of any shape; very useful for
perforated gun propellant grains.
(2) Significance: Essential.
(3) Limitations: Not recommended for liquids.
(4) Properties: To be supplied
d. Typical Results:
CN-16
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
Canada/102.01.071
a. Type of Test: Physical Property - Mandatory for gun and rocket solid propellants and
Optional for high explosives.
d. Typical Results: Densities of gun propellants are about 1.6 g/cc and about 1.8 g/cc for
solid rocket propellants.
(1) Specific gravity/density values are very precise and reproducible if good
equipment and normal care are used.
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
(1) U.S. MIL-STD-2100 (OS), "Military Standard: Propellant, Solid, Characterization of,
30 March 1979, Method 5.4.21.
(2) U.S. MIL-STD-286B Methods 510.1.1 and 510.2.1,1 December 1967.
CN-17
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
Canada/102.01.340
1. TYPE OF EXPLOSIVE:
b. Description: To accomplish this test, the material of interest, punched into a 3.75 cm
diameter disc, is placed between two cylindrical aluminum anvils having a diameter of 6
cm. Then, the sample-to-anvils bond is achieved by pressing the assembly at 900 KPa
for 1 hour at 60°C. The test is carried out at a crosshead speed of 5 mm/min using an
Instron machine. The bond strength and the strain of the samples are measured at peak
load and rupture. Even though this test is designed for self- adhesive materials, it could
apply to other assemblies.
c. Information Requirements for Assessment: Results of this test allow the characterization
of the bond strength of components related to the insulation of rocket motors. The
resulting interfaces can be made up of insulants, liners, restrictors, and propellants.
CN-18
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
Canada/201.01.001
2. TEST TITLE: CERL Impact Test - (NOL Test with Modified Type 12 Tools)
a. Type of Test: Impact - Mandatory for primary, booster, and main charge high explosives,
solid rocket and gun propellants, and pyrotechnics.
d. Typical Results:
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
CN-19
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
Canada/201.01.002
a. Type of Test: Safety/Impact - Mandatory for primary explosives - Optional for sensitive
pyrotechnics.
c. Information Requirements for Assessment: This test is a better measure for impact
sensitivity of sensitive explosives and pyrotechnics than the CERL Impact Test
(Canada/High Explosives/Propellants/Pyrotechnics/201.01.001).
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
CN-20
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
Canada/201.01.003
b. Description: This test measures the initiation sensitivity of an explosive by using shock
waves of a given intensity and duration. An explosively driven metal flyer plate is caused
to impact simultaneously across the plane face of a receptor explosive. The strength of
the incident shock will be a function of the velocity of the flyer plate, its material and its
thickness. The energy transferred to the receptor explosive is calculated and a curve of
critical initiation pressure as a function of shock duration is obtained.
d. Typical Results:
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
CN-21
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
Canada/201.01.004
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
CN-22
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
Canada/201.01.005
a. Type of Test: Safety-Adiabatic Compression - Optional for main charge high explosives.
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
(1) Report of the Twelfth Annual Meeting of TTCP WTP-1 Quebec, Canada,
October 1983.
CN-23
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
Canada/201.03.001
d. Typical Results:
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
CN-24
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
Canada/201.04.001
a. Type of Test: Shock Initiation- Mandatory for booster and main charge high explosives.
d. Typical Results:
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
(1) Report of the Twelfth Annual Meeting of TTCP WTP-1, Quebec, Canada,
October 1984.
CN-25
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
Canada/201.04.003
T
TEST INFORMATION SHEET
a. Type of Test: Shock Initiation - Optional for solid rocket and gun propellants and
pyrotechnics.
c. Information Requirement for Assessment:This test provides data on the sensitivity of the
propellant or composite pyrotechnic to explosive induced shock.
CN-26
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
Canada/201.04.004
c. Information Requirements for Assessment: The test determines the ability of an explosive
material to be initiated from a small detonating source.
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
CN-27
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
Canada/202.01.007
a. Type of Test: Thermal - Ignition - Mandatory for main charge high explosives, solid
propellants and pyrotechnics.
d. Typical Results:
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
CN-28
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
Canada/202.01.008
c. Information Requirements for Assessment: The response of the explosive material. The
following information is reported:
d. Typical Results:
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
CN-29
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
Canada/202.01.009
a. Type of Test: Thermal - Mandatory test for all main charge high explosives containing
TNT.
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
(1) Voigt, H.W., "Exudation Test for TNT Explosives Under Confinement: Exudation
Control and Proposed Standards", ARRADCOM Technical Report
ARLCD-TR-83004, 3 February 1983.
CN-30
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
Canada/202.01.010
TEST INFORMATION SHEET
b. Description: This test is the same as US/High Explosives/ 202.01.012. The test
measures irreversible growth in main charge fillings caused by such factors as liquid
impurities or additive in the solid explosive.
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
CN-31
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
Canada/204.01.001
a. Type of Test: Toxicity - Mandatory for booster and main charge high explosives, and for
solid rocket propellants - Optional for pyrotechnics.
b. Description: No one test will cover all concerns with respect to toxicity of ingredients and
products during manufacture, storage and use. Decisions on tests to be done are made
in consultation with the Canadian Department of Health and Welfare.
CN-32
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
Canada/301.01.001
c. Information Requirements for Assessment: The data generated by this program are used
in the design and characterization of the propellants and rocket motors and for the
prediction of performance.
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
(1) NASA Computer Program SP-273 by Sanford Gordon and Bonnie J. McBride.
CN-33
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
Canada/301.01.002
b. Description: Theoretical performance calculations for solid gun propellants are made by
using one of the followings: BLAKE general thermodynamic code or BAGHEERA which is
a NATO standard.
c. Information Requirements for Assessment: To be supplied
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
CN-34
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
Canada/302.01.001
a. Type of Test: Performance - Mandatory for booster and main charge high explosives.
CN-35
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
Canada/302.02.002
c. Information Requirements for Assessment: Data are used to determine burning rate and
performance characteristics.
These are good at burning rates less than 7.5 cm (3 in) per second.
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
CN-36
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
Canada/302.02.003
b. Description: This test may be varied to suit different circumstances. It is used to observe
the burning behavior of loose pyrotechnic compositions in quantities and conditions
relevant to manufacturing conditions. The material is ignited by a suitable squib on
tables, trays or containers. When tested in the Trough Test (Canada/ High
Explosives/Propellants/Pyrotechnics/2O2.01.008) the explosive exhibited "Vigorous
Burning".
d. Typical Results: Pyrotechnics may undergo a wide range of behaviors, from very slow
burning to rapid burning with extensive flame to fast deflagration.
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
(1) McLain, Joseph H., Lectures on "Pyrotechnics and Solid State Chemistry",
Philadelphia, PA, 14-18 August 1978.
(2) McLain, Joseph H., Pyrotechnics, The Franklin Institute Press, Philadelphia, PA
(1980).
(3) Ellern, Herbert, "Military and Civilian Pyrotechnics", Chemical Publishing Co. Inc.,
New York, NY (1968).
NOTE: The Pyrotechnic Hazard Classification proposed by McLain in his above noted lectures is a useful
guide.
CN-37
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
Canada/302.02.004
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
CN-38
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
Canada/302.03.001
b. Description: Static testing of new rocket motor propellants in sub-scale motors is a step
in the development process. The conditions for individual tests will vary according to the
type of propellant, its proposed end use, etc. But in general, the motors are designed for
average pressures of 1000 to 4000 psi and firings are carried out with the motors
conditioned to selected temperatures between -55°C and +70°C.
c. Information Requirements for Assessment: Data on the burning rate with temperature
and pressure, burning uniformity, and thrust are essential for the development of
propellants for full-scale motors.
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
CN-39
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
CN-40
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
10.7.2 QUALIFICATION PROCEDURES OF THE CZECH REPUBLIC
PARAGRAPH PAGE
CZ-1
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
CZ-2
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
10.7.2.1 MILITARY DEPARTMENTS RESPONSIBLE FOR QUALIFICATION
Military Institute for Weapon and Ammunition Technology Slavicin (Vojensky technicky
ustav vyzbroje a munice Slavicin - VTUVM) has full responsibility for qualification of
explosives for military use.
10.7.2.2.1 Military Institute for Weapon and Ammunition Technology Slavicin (Vojensky technicky
ustav vyzbroje a munice Slavicin – VTUVM) is the appointed National Authority for the
Czech Republic and is responsible for the following functions in accordance with STANAG
4170:
h. Serve as a Point of Contact within the Czech Republic for inputs to AOP-7 and
AOP-26;
10.7.2.3.1 The basis for the Czech assessment for the qualification of an explosive composition is
laid down in the Czech Defence Standard 137601 ”Organization and Methods for the
Qualification of Explosives for Military Use“. This defence standard is in line with
requirements of STANAG 4170 and STANAGs for explosives testing quoted in STANAG
4170. This qualification procedure does not include the assessment of the explosive in a
particular ammunition system (final or type qualification) or legal provisions for storage
and transportation.
10.7.2.3.2 In the Czech Republic, research and development of new explosives intended for military
use are mainly carried out by private firms - e.g. Aliachem - division Explosia Pardubice-
CZ-3
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
Semtin (high explosives and propellants), Sellier Bellot Vlasim (primary explosives),
ZEVETA Bojkovice (pyrotechnics). Additionally, research may also be carried out in
certain state institutes sponsored by the Czech MOD (e.g. Military Institute for Weapon
and Ammunition Technology Slavicin, Military Technical Institute of Protection Brno).
10.7.2.3.3 In general, research and development of new military explosives are usually carried out
under contracts awarded by Czech Ministry of Defence or Czech Ministry of Industry and
Commerce. However, they may also result from a private firm’s initiative. Import of
explosives or munitions with explosives not qualified according to STANAG 4170 is also a
subject for the qualification procedure. In this context a new explosive is an explosive
which has not yet been qualified, whose composition, nature, manufacturing procedure,
manufacturer or manufacturing location has been changed, or which is intended for a role
for which it has not been qualified. Existing in-service explosives with unchanged material
specification may be regarded as being qualified by sufficient long experience
representative for its expected service life and intended use.
10.7.2.3.4 Written requests for qualification of a new explosive are to be submitted to the National
Authority. Requests may be submitted by the military services (Army, Air Force),
developers, manufacturers or importers or explosives and ammunition.
10.7.2.3.5 Before the start of the qualification procedure, an applicant requesting the assessment of
the new explosive must identify some basic characteristics of the explosive, according to
Table 1 to STANAG 4170 and must present results of tests obtained in the development
project. The information is evaluated by the National Authority and can be returned for
revision if unsatisfactory or incomplete. A producer of the new explosive also has to prove
that the explosive can be manufactured and processed in a full production scale and the
quality levels required can be met consistently. The National Authority can refuse further
qualification testing if it is clear from the preliminary results that the new explosive will not
satisfy general requirements for safety and suitability in the intended role.
10.7.2.3.6 In case of positive results of the preliminary assessment, the National Authority prepares
a list of tests for qualification of the explosive. The tests listed in STANAG 4170 are
always taken as mandatory for this purpose, the national tests listed in AOP-7 are usually
taken as optional (except those referred by STANAG 4170 to AOP-7, such as electric
spark test, detonation velocity and critical diameter test). Other tests not included in
STANAG 4170 or AOP-7, but which are suitable to obtain the required information, may
also be used in the qualification testing. Results of the optional tests can be taken from
the development project of a new explosive.
10.7.2.3.7 The National Authority is responsible for the conduct of the qualification tests in its testing
laboratories and the subsequent assessment of the new explosives regarding their safety
and basic suitability for military purposes. If any particular test cannot be conducted by the
facilities of the National Authority, the National Authority will delegate other testing
laboratory for conducting the test under supervision of a representative of the National
Authority.
10.7.2.3.8 Results of the qualification tests, together with other observations and recommendations
are considered by an expert committee of the National Authority, consisted of explosives
and ammunition specialists of VTUVM, other Czech military technical institutes, General
Staff and Ministry of Defence. The results are evaluated in relation to the results of the
CZ-4
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
same tests carried out on materials of a similar type and role that have proven history of
safety and satisfactory use in service. After completion of the investigation, the National
Authority prepares a qualification report in accordance with STANAG 4170 and the
qualification certificate with resulting qualification status: (a) qualified, (b) not qualified, (c)
qualified with certain restrictions.
10.7.2.3.9 If the National Authority determines that a new explosive is suitable for military use, an
organization developing, manufacturing or importing the explosive will prepare a technical
specification for this qualified explosive. The technical specification stipulates
characteristics of the explosives such as composition, nature, manufacturing process,
type and source of raw materials and use, as far as these ensure reproducible
manufacture and delivery. The quality requirements for the explosive, the testing methods,
provisions on quality assurance, packaging, storage and transportation conditions are also
reflected in this document. The final version of this document is ratified by organizations
participating on production, processing or use of the explosive (a developer, a
manufacturer, a processing company, military authority representatives to these
companies, the national authority, military standardization office, end user etc.).
10.7.2.3.10 In case of ammunition system developments requiring the new explosives, these
explosives must be qualified before the system design is finalized. The introduction of the
explosive for a particular role before conclusion of the qualification procedure and before
completion of the technical specification is prohibited in general.
10.7.2.4.2 List of Tests for Booster and Main Charge High Explosives:
CZ-5
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
CZ-6
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
m. Impact sensitivity test STANAG 4489 (C)
n. Friction sensitivity test STANAG 4487 (A)
o. Electric spark test 201.03.001
p. Large scale electrostatic discharge sensitivity test STANAG 4490 (B)
q. Shock sensitivity tests
(intermediate and super large scale gap test) STANAG 4488 (BD)
r. Large scale gap test 201.04.001
s. Critical diameter test 202.05.001
#
t. Uniaxial compressive test STANAG 4443
#
u. Stress relaxation test in tension STANAG 4507
#
v. Thermomechanical analysis STANAG 4525
#
x. Dynamic mechanical analysis STANAG 4540
CZ-7
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
t. Uniaxial compressive test STANAG 4443
u. Uniaxial tensile test STANAG 4506
v. Stress relaxation test in tension STANAG 4507
x. Thermomechanical analysis STANAG 4525
y. Dynamic mechanical analysis STANAG 4540
The tests required for liquid propellants are listed in Chapter 7 of this document.
10.7.2.4.7 Remarks :
* two compatibility tests are usually chosen from the lists
CZ-8
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
+
selection of a suitable chemical stability test depends on composition of
a propellant under test
#
applicability of the test depends on a resolution of the national authority
10.7.2.4.8.2 Determination of change in properties of a new explosive before and after the artificial
ageing is done by the following methods, in general:
CZ-9
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
10.7.2.5 LIST OF TEST INFORMATION SHEETS
CZ-10
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
10.7.2.6 CATALOGUE OF TEST INFORMATION SHEETS
NOTE: The Test Information Sheets are listed consecutively in accordance with the
Registry Number.
CZ-11
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
CZ-12
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
Czech Republic/102.02.001
b. Description: The density is calculated as a quotient of mass and volume of a sample. The
mass is measured with an analytical balance (resolution 0.0001 g) and the volume is
o
measured with a pycnometer by a liquid displacement method at 20 C. Liquid that does
not dissolve the sample is used as a medium for the pycnometric measurements (e.g.
water for high explosives, parafinic oil for propellants and pyrotechnics). A solid sample is
used in a form of small pieces that will pass through the pycnometer neck, with smooth
surfaces free from crevices and dust.
c. Information Requirements for Assessment: This test is used for material characterization
and quality control before some qualification tests.
d. Typical Results:
-3
Cast TNT loading density: 1.58 g.cm
-3
Good (± 0.005 g.cm )
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
CZ-13
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
Czech Republic/201.02.001
b. Description: The sensitivity of primary explosives and some sensitive pyrotechnics is tested by
means of the scale-down version of standard BAM friction test apparatus (described in Annex
A to STANAG 4487). The applied friction load ranges from 0.1 N to 18 N. Sensitivity of an
explosive is usually expressed as a down level (the maximum load giving 0 ignitions of 6
trials) and an upper level (the minimum load giving 6 ignitions of 6 trials).
c. Information Requirements for Assessment: This test is used to determine the sensitivity of
primary explosives and sensitive pyrotechnics at very low loads that can produce incorrect
results using the standard type of BAM friction test apparatus.
d. Typical Results: Results are quoted as minimum loads for obtaining 6 ignitions or explosions
of 6 trials (upper level)
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
(1) ON 66 8093
CZ-14
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
Czech Republic/201.03.001
c. Information Requirements for Assessment: To determine the electrostatic charge required for
ignition of an explosive material.
(1) RDX: 55 mJ
(2) PETN: 30 mJ
(3) Tetryl: 83 mJ (criterion for booster explosives)
(4) TNT: 116 mJ
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES
Czech Defence Standard 137601 “Organization and Methods for the Qualification of Explosives
for Military Use”, chapter 6.16
CZ-15
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
Czech Republic/201.04.001
b. Description: A flat shock wave from a conical donor charge of cast TNT (density
-3
1.58 g.cm , diameter at the bottom of the charge of 68 mm) with a coating layer of
PETN/TNT 50/50 and a small booster charge of PETN/wax 90/10 is attenuated by
layers of PMMA discs (diameter of 68 mm). The occurrence of detonation of the
acceptor charge in a steel tube (internal diameter of 60 mm, wall thickness of 5
mm, length of 200 mm) is assessed by the degree of damage to a 15 mm thick
steel witness plate under a 3 mm air gap. Thickness of the attenuator giving a 50%
probability of detonation is determined by a simplified Bruceton method.
d. Typical Results:
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES
Czech Defence Standard 137601 “Organization and Methods for the Qualification of Explosives
for Military Use”, chapter 6.18
CZ-16
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
Czech Republic/202.01.001
a. Type of Test: Stability/Thermal - Used for Gun Propellants and Nitrocellulose Based
Rocket Propellants
c. Information Requirements for Assessment: This test determines the stability level of
nitrocellulose based propellants.
d. Typical Results:
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES
CZ-17
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
Czech Republic/202.01.002
a. Type of Test: Stability/Thermal - Used for Nitrocellulose Based Gun and Rocket
Propellants.
c. Information Requirements for Assessment: This test determines a stability level of the
nitrocellulose based propellants.
d. Typical Results:
3 -1 o
(1) Nitroglycerine propellants: 6 - 16 cm .g .20hours (115 C)
3 -1 o
(2) Single based propellants: 10 - 25 cm .g .20hours (125 C)
3 -1
e. Repeatability and Reproducibility: Within 0.2 cm .ml.g .20hours.
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES
CZ-18
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
Czech Republic/202.01.003
b. Description: Commercially available DTA equipment with reinforced design is utilised. The
apparatus is capable to withstand explosion of up to 50 mg of primary explosives. Sample
weight of 50 - 500 mg of non-primary explosives can be used. In this apparatus,
endothermic and exothermic changes of the sample in a small glass test tube are
o -1
observed and recorded during heating at a constant rate (usually 5 - 20 C.min ) under air
atmosphere. The apparatus is very suitable for measurement of highly heterogeneous
samples (esp. pyrotechnics) that can produce unrepeatable results with low sample
weights. The equipment is also suitable for preliminary assessment of thermal reactivity of
an unknown explosive before measurement at more sensitive apparatuses.
c. Information Requirements for Assessment: This test determines the thermal stability of an
explosive - start, onset and peak of exothermal decomposition.
o -1
d. Typical Results (peaks of decomposition at 50 mg sample weight and 5 C.min heating
rate):
o
(1) TNT: 295 C
o
(2) RDX: 220 C
o
(3) PETN: 190 C
o
(4) Double Based Propellants: 165 - 170 C
o
(5) Black Powder: 320 C
o
e. Repeatability and Reproducibility: r 2 C of peak temperatures
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES
Czech Republic/202.05.001
CZ-19
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
a. Type of Test: Safety/Critical Diameter - Used for Booster and Main Charge High
Explosives, Propellants and Pyrotechnics
b. Description: The explosive under test contained in 100 cm long steel tube with a selected
internal diameter and wall thickness of 10 % of internal diameter, is subjected to an
explosive shock known to be sufficient to initiate detonation (using detonator or a plastic
explosive booster). The remains of the tube are examined to determine whether the
detonation has propagated through the whole length of the charge. If detonation
propagates, internal diameter of the next steel tube is reduced to its half. If detonation
fails, internal diameter of the next steel tube is doubled. Using this procedure, critical
diameter of the explosive at given loading density is determined as a minimum diameter
of the tube at which complete detonation occurs.
c. Information Requirements for Assessment: This test determines the critical diameter of an
explosive material for sustaining a detonation through a long confined explosive charge.
d. Typical Results:
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES
Czech Defence Standard 137601 “Organization and Methods for the Qualification of Explosives
for Military Use”, chapter 6.19
CZ-20
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
Czech Republic/202.05.002
b. Description: The explosive under test is contained in a steel tube (inside diameter of 32
mm, wall thickness of 3 mm, length of 500 mm), which is closed at one end with a welded
steel disc 3 mm thick. Initiation occurs by means of electric squib at the open end of the
tube. The lengths of deflagration and detonation zones are determined by means of a
mechanical sensor made of 3.15 mm thick steel wire wrapped with 0.6 mm thick copper
wire. The mechanical sensor is located inside the tube along all its length. After explosion,
the mechanical sensor is collected. The first cut of the copper wire into the steel wire
corresponds to the transition point from deflagration to detonation.
d. Typical Results:
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES
CZ-21
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
CZ/302.01.001
a. Type of Test: Performance/Experimental - Used for Booster and Main Charge High
Explosives.
b. Description: Two measurement probes (insulated copper foils or wires wrapped round or
pressed to each other) are inserted into the explosive charge of the selected diameter,
length and confinement. The explosive charge is initiated by means of a detonator or a
booster charge and the two probes are short-circuited by the passing detonation wave that
removes insulation from the probes. The time between the two generated pulses is
determined by an electronic counter. Knowing the distance between the two probes, the
average detonation velocity is calculated.
c. Information Requirements for Assessment: This test determines the detonation velocity of
an explosive charge - one of important performance parameters.
d. Typical Results:
-3 -1
(1) TNT (pressed 1.62 g.cm ): 6800 m.s
-3 -1
(2) RDX/wax 95/5 (pressed 1.62 g.cm ): 8150 m.s
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES
Czech Defence Standard 137601 “Organization and Methods for the Qualification of Explosives
for Military Use”, chapter 6.19
CZ-22
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
Czech Republic/302.02.001
c. Information Requirements for Assessment: The results of the test are used for a ballistic
assessment of the propellant.
d. Typical Results:
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES
U.S. MIL-STD-286C, „Military Standard: Propellant, Solid, Sampling, Examination and Testing“,
Method 801.1
CZ-23
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
CZ/302.03.001
a. Type of Test: Performance/Brisance - Used for Booster and Main Charge High Explosives
c. Information Requirements for Assessment: The value of the lead cylinder compression
corresponds to a brisance of the explosive.
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES
CZ-24
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
Czech Republic/302.03.002
a. Type of Test: Performance/Explosive power - Used for Booster and Main Charge High
Explosives
b. Description: 10 g explosive charge is detonated in a heavy (300 kg) steel mortar, damped
with a steel projectile (15 kg). The mortar is attached to a pendulum bar and suspended
on knife edges. After explosion of the charge, resulting degree of swing is compared to
that produced on detonation of a specific amount of TNT. The result is expressed as
percentage of TNT.
d. Typical Results:
(1) RDX/TNT 75/25: 144% TNT
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES
CZ-25
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
Czech Republic/302.03.003
a. Type of Test: Performance/Explosives - Used for Booster and Main Charge High
Explosives
b. Description: 10 g sample is placed into a tube with diameter of 25 mm made of tin sheet
and a standard detonator is inserted. The charge is then put into a hole in a lead block of
diameter and length of 200 mm. Volume produced by the explosion of the charge is
measured.
d. Typical Results:
3
(1) TNT (powder): 300 cm (100% TNT)
3
(2) RDX/Al/wax 76/20/4: 471 cm (157% TNT)
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES
CZ-26
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
Czech Republic/302.03.004
d. Typical Results:
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES
CZ-27
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Editiopn 2)
10.7.3 QUALIFICATION PROCEDURES OF DENMARK
PARAGRAPH PAGE
b. PROPELLANTS DN-5
c. PYROTECHNICS DN-5
1
10.7.3.5 LIST OF TESTS INFORMATION SHEETS NA
1
10.7.3.6 CATALOGUE OF TEST INFORMATION SHEETS NA
1
Not Applicable since Denmark does not perform tests.
DN-1
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
DN-2
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Editiopn 2)
10.7.3.1 MILITARY DEPARTMENTS RESPONSIBLE FOR QUALIFICATION
10.7.3.1.1 Denmark does not qualify new military explosives since no new explosives are developed
in this country.
10.7.3.1.2 Denmark procures explosives from foreign producers as part of a complete munition or
weapon system design or bulk explosives for production or rework of ammunition.
10.7.3.1.3 The approval of explosives, in Denmark, is done as part of the approval of the
specifications of the complete ammunition or weapon system as procured from either
Danish or foreign contractors.
10.7.3.1.1 The following authorities within the Danish Defense Organization are responsible for
approving the specifications for explosives contained in munitions:
10.7.3.2.2 The Danish National Authority does not approve explosives for military use. This is done
by the Materiel Commands. The Danish National Authority serves as point of contact for
STANAG 4170 and for specific explosive material STANAGs.
10.7.3.3.1 Approval of new explosives for military use is done by the above mentioned Materiel
Commands. If necessary the Materiel Commands may forward safety questions
concerning the introduction of new explosives to the Ministry of Defense Explosives
Safety Commission (the Danish National Authority) for further evaluation. The Danish
Defense authorities procure only ammunition and weapon systems containing explosives
approved by the military authorities in the country of origin. Normally, procurement takes
place from other NATO countries.
DN-3
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
10.7.3.4 QUALIFICATION METHODS AND TESTS
10.7.3.4.1 The basis for the approval of new explosives is the specifications with related
test-methods and requirements given in NATO-STANAGs used for approval in other
NATO countries. Specific Danish test methods for explosives do not exist. Consequently
Test Information Sheets are not relevant. The tests which the Danish authorities
consider mandatory for assessing the safety of an explosive material are listed below.
DN-4
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Editiopn 2)
10.7.3.4.3. Propellants
NOTE; The liquid propellants used by the Danish forces in naval torpedoes or other uses are generally
procured from other countries. The data required for these materials are as documented in Chapter 7 for
liquid propellants.
10.7.3.4.4 PYROTECHNICS
DN-5
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
DN-6
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
To be provided
FI-1
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
10.7.6 QUALIFICATION PROCEDURES OF FRANCE
PARAGRAPH PAGE
FR-1
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
FR-2
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
10.7.6.1 MILITARY DEPARTMENTS RESPONSIBLE FOR QUALIFICATION
(cf. STANAG 4170 Ed2 §3)
10.7.6.1.1 The procurement of all weapon systems for the armed forces is under the responsibility
of DGA (Délégation Générale pour l’Armement). According to DGA instruction 11500 -
which is the national STANAG 4170 implementation document - Qualification is
mandatory for all explosive material to be used in munitions intended for the 4 Services:
Army, Navy, Air Force and “Gendarmerie” (state police force). So DGA has the full
responsibility of qualifying all explosive materials to be used by the French forces.
10.7.6.2.1 Within DGA, the office appointed as National Authority for the Qualification of explosive
materials is the “bureau de la sécurité pyrotechnique” (explosive safety office) part of the
“Inspection de l’armement pour les poudres et explosifs” (Armament Inspectorate for
Propellants and Explosives):
INSP/IPE/SM
8 Boulevard Victor – Paris
00303 ARMEES
a. this well specified explosive material has the necessary properties to provide an
expectation of an adequate level of safety and suitability for service in military
use, for a given intended role,
b. the manufacture and quality of the explosive material are adequately controlled.
a. Generally, and especially for a new composition, the official request for qualifying
an explosive has to come from the designer of this explosive.
b. In some cases, the request could come from the manufacturer of the explosive,
or even from the munition or munition-component designer, which then acts as
the explosive designer by proxy. This request is sent directly to the National
Authority.
(2) the assessment data (from tests performed on material coming from industrial
production batches) on which the judgement of safety and suitability for
service use will be based, [type B information],
FR-3
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
(3) the information justifying that the manufacturing process and quality are
adequately controlled, [type C information].
b. According to STANAG 4170 (and DGA instruction 11500), all this information is
collated in the Qualification report upon which is based the Qualification decision.
a. The validity and quality of the information produced are ensured by involving two
“intervening parties” of DGA, DPM/SQ and DCE/ETBS:
(1) DPM/SQ - the quality assurance office for all armament programmes - mainly
involved in verifying that both the designer and the manufacturer of the
explosive have a good quality assurance system, and that the manufacturer
has the capability of producing it in conformity with the designer
specifications,
a. The following table provides the different steps of the qualification procedure and
the parties involved in them:
Step Participants
FR-4
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
10.7.6.3.6 The different types of Qualification decisions:
b. “In principle Qualification” (cf. STANAG 4170 Ed2 § 4(e)). A decision can be taken to
qualify an explosive material, even if there is no immediate application envisaged for it. In
that case, because, most of the time, there is not yet an industrial production of this
material, and so just type A and B (limited to a lab scale preparation of the necessary
samples) information is available, INSP/IPE/SM is just making an “In principle
Qualification” (Homologation de definition) decision of the explosive material which will
have to be completed with a confirmation of type B information (to be performed on
production batches of the material) and type C information prior to any military use in a
munition, this in order to verify that the manufacturer is producing it according to its
defined specifications.
c. “Qualification de facto” (cf. STANAG 4170 Ed2 § 3 & 6). Explosives already in service
for which there is a well-established history of safe and satisfactory use [type B’
information], providing the original material specifications remains the same, may be
qualified for use in the same role. Without further testing, or with a very limited testing
programme, and so just on the basis of type A, B’ (instead of type B) and C information,
INSP/IPE/SM is making a “Qualification de facto” (Homologation de fait) decision with
possible restrictions of the role.
FR-5
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
a. Mandatory Tests:
b. Optional Tests:
FR-6
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
10.7.6.4.2 List of Tests for Booster Explosives:
a. Mandatory Tests
b. Optional Tests:
c. For booster explosive, France uses the table I in chapter 7 but some criteria are
more severe or some additional tests can be conducted:
d. Tetryl from the reference lot M35 DNAG 82 meets the above criteria. If these
criteria are not met, supplementary tests are necessary. These are selected
based on the particular end item use and are addressed in the ammunition safety
report in accordance with AOP-15.
FR-7
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
a. Mandatory Tests:
b. Optional Tests:
FR-8
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
10.7.6.4.4 List of Tests for Solid Gun Propellants:
a. Mandatory Tests:
b. Optional Tests:
FR-9
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
a. Mandatory Tests:
b. Optional Tests:
FR-10
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
10.7.6.4.6 List of Tests for Liquid Propellants:
a. Mandatory Tests:
b. Optional Tests:
FR-11
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
101.02.001 Hygroscopicity
201.01.XXX Impact
FR-12
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
201.02.XXX Friction
201.04.XXX Shock
201.08.004 Friability
201.08.007 Hot wire sensitivity
FR-13
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
203.01.XXX Compatibility/Reactivity
FR-14
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
10.7.6.6 CATALOGUE OF TEST INFORMATION SHEETS
NOTE: The Test Information Sheets are listed consecutively in accordance with their
Registry Number.
FR-15
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
FR-16
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
France/101.01.002
b. Description: The method involves determination of the full composition of the powder
using appropriate techniques
(1) The organic components are identified and measured by the following
methods: gas chromatography, liquid chromatography etc
(4) The combustion ashes are analysed using X-rays to make sure that all the
minerals present have been noted. The composition is checked by
comparing the measured potential with the potential calculated from the
different levels of materials found.
d. Typical Results:
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
FR-17
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
France/101.01.003
d. Typical Results:
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
FP-105-D-1
FP-105-E-1
FP-105-G-1
FR-18
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
France/101.01.004
The method may be volumetric (direct or indirect), or coulometric with the generation of
iodine in situ by electrolysis.
d. Typical Results:
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
FP-103-D-1
FR-19
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
France/101.02.001
b. Description: The loss or gain in mass is measured as a function of the time spent in
hermetic enclosures in which there are relative humidities of 33, 52, 65, 76 and 93%. The
powder is first treated by holding it in an enclosure with 65% relative humidity.
The degree of humidity is measured before and after the test. The curve of equilibrium
humidity levels as a function of the relative humidity is deduced from these figures.
d. Typical Results:
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
FP-801-A-1
FR-20
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
France/102.01.011
b. Description: The test piece, which is a grain of powder machined at the ends (with a
length/diameter ratio close to 1), is compressed radially in a machine at a constant rate of
movement.
The curve which plots the force as a function of the movement allows deduction of:
(1) the point where rupture or cracking of the test piece begins;
(2) the radial stress;
(3) the deformation relative to the shattering force.
d. Typical Results:
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
Nil
FR-21
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
France/102.01.060
b. Description: A test piece whose length lies between 5 and 25 mm and whose
length/transverse dimension ratio is greater than 1 is subjected to a temperature increase
of 0.5 to 2°C/min under a very small constant load.
This method can also be used to estimate the glass transition temperature.
d. Typical Results:
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
NF T 70-313
FR-22
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
France/102.01.065
b. Description: The hardness of the material is estimated from the degree of indentation
caused by a penetrator under a constant force exerted by a calibrated spring for a
determined period.
The measurement is made using a test piece of minimum thickness 4 mm and a Shore
type A or D hardness tester.
d. Typical Results:
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
NF T 70-316
FR-23
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
France/102.02.001
d. Typical Results:
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
FA-600-A-1
FR-24
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
France/102.02.002
d. Typical Results:
± 2 cal/g
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
FP 807-A-1
FP 807-A-2
FP 807-A-3
FP 807-A-4
FC 705-A-1
FR-25
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
France/102.02.010
Two cylinders are connected by a differential-pressure gauge, and the container holding
the sample communicates with one of the cylinders. Each cylinder has a piston which
allows slow compression of the gas in it. The compression is stopped when the piston of
the reference cylinder reaches its end stop, and the other piston is moved until the
pressure is the same in both cylinders. The sample cylinder is graduated so that the
position indicates the volume of the sample. This trial is carried out under either air or
helium.
d. Typical Results:
3
(1) Double-base powder GB.Pa (0.075) = 1670 kg/m
3
(2) Ignition powder TB A1 = 3000 kg/m
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
FE 203-C-1
FP 803-C-1
FR-26
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
France/102.02.011
b. Description: The method is to measure the mass of a certain quantity of the material
which, loose in bulk, exactly fills a container of a given volume.
The bulk state is obtained by filling the container with the material flowing freely from the
orifice of a funnel located a specified distance above the said container, without
compaction.
The ratio of the mass to the volume represents the apparent density of the material (in
3
kg/m ).
d. Typical Results:
3
(1) Lead styphnate: 1300 kg/m
3
(2) Lead azide: 1600 kg/m
3
(3) Grain propellant B.19T (0.34)C: 950 kg/m
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
FA 303-A-1
FC 402-A-1
FP 819-A-1
FP 819-B-1
FP 819-B-2
FR-27
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
France/102.02.012
The piece of explosive is suspended below the pan of a set of scales weighing to within
1/10th mg, and is immersed in a suitable liquid (generally water plus a wetting agent).
If the material is porous, it should be very lightly coated with Vaseline oil.
3
The overall density is expressed in kg/m .
c. Information Requirements for Assessment: This trial is applicable to materials in the form
of blocks, grain or plates.
d. Typical Results:
3
(1) Hexabu: 1620 kg/m
3
(2) Compressed Hexal: 1850 kg/m
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
FE 203-A-1
FR-28
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
France/102.02.020
The laser diffractometer measures the angle of the diffraction caused by particles in
suspension which pass across a fine laser beam. Small fixed detectors (concentric
diodes) measure the diffracted luminous intensities.
Their positions correspond to particle sizes. A calculation programme transforms the
particle size into a volume corresponding to the sphere.
Particle counting gives us the differential and cumulative particle-size distribution curves.
From this we can deduce the mean diameter at 50% of the cumulative curve.
c. Information Requirements for Assessment: Counting of particles with sizes between 0.1
and 600 microns.
d. Typical Results:
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
FA-302-C-1
PPH-400
FR-29
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
France/102.02.021
The enlargement is adapted to the material under examination in order to determine the
shape and size of the crystals or particles
d. Typical Results:
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
Nil
FR-30
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
France/102.02.022
d. Typical Results:
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
NF T 70-332
NF T 70-333
FR-31
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
France/102.02.030
b Description: The method relies on the fixation of a layer of gas to the surface and within
each open pore of the sample by Van der Waals bonding. Krypton gas is used for
2 2
specific surfaces of less than 5 m /g and nitrogen for those of more than 5 m /g.
The method is to plot the gas adsorption curve at the temperature of liquid nitrogen for
different adsorbed gas pressures. Processing of the results by the B.E.T. method allows
calculation of the volume of gas adsorbed corresponding to a monolayer.
The specific surface obtained is divided by the apparent surface per unit mass calculated
for the material.
The result is a dimensionless figure indicating the ratio of the real surface to the apparent
surface of the propellant.
d. Typical Results:
2
(1) LB.Tu.72 (0.4): 4 m /g
2
(2) B.19T (0.36)C: 15 m /g
2
(3) GB.Se (0.3): 3 m /g
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
FR 901-B-1
FR-32
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
France/201.01.002
b. Description: The method of Bruceton is used to determine the energy bringing a 0.5
probability of a pyrotechnic event with an explosive placed in a capsule on which a
variable mass is dropped from an adjustable height.
The energies applied vary from 5 J to 200 J in discrete steps. A minimum of 50 tests are
carried out. The result is considered satisfactory if the mean energy converges towards
an asymptotic value.
d. Typical Results:
(1) Tetryl: 18 J
(2) Hexocire [RDX/wax]: 28 J
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
FMD 410-B-1
FR-33
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
France/201.01.004
The mass is dropped on one end of a test piece of thickness 8 mm placed in a tank of
mild steel 0.4 mm thick of dimensions 8 mm x 50 mm x 150 mm. Charging may be by
insertion of a machined plate, by direct casting, or by charging at gravimetric density
where powder materials are concerned.
The aim is to find the drop height at which 3 negative tests occur (that is tests where the
reaction is not a violent pyrotechnic event) provided that at the height which is one step of
0.25 m greater there is at least one positive test (violent decomposition with propagation).
d. Typical Results:
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
NF T 70-501
FR-34
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
France/201.01.005
The possible results of a test fall into one of the following categories:
d. Typical Results:
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
FA 503-A-2
FR-35
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
France/201.01.006
(1) the bottom of the recess deformed inwards by the impact of a striker with a sharp
end hit by a guided mass of 112.5 g falling from an adjustable height.
(2) an anvil of rounded form.
The possible results of a test fall into one of the following categories:
d. Typical Results:
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
FA 507-A-1
FR-36
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
France/201.01.007
The possible results of a test fall into one of the following categories:
d. Typical Results:
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
FA 507-B-1
FR-37
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
France/201.01.008
The mock-up comprises a body of steel 4 mm thick, and the explosive material takes the
form of a cylinder of diameter 40 mm and height 123 mm.
d. Typical Results:
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
SEN-209
FR-38
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
France/201.02.002
b. Description: The method is to determine the forces causing 0% and 100% functioning of
a pyrotechnic material deposited on a rough porcelain plate attached to a moving
assembly which makes a single to-and-fro movement of amplitude 10 mm relative to a
rough stylus resting on the explosive material.
(1) either the threshold of non-sensitivity as the force at which 10 successive negative
tests (with no functioning) are observed,
(2) or the threshold of sensitivity as the force at which 10 successive functioning events
are observed.
The possible results of a test fall into one of the following categories:
c. Information Requirements for Assessment: Any pyrotechnic material whose sensitivity (or
non-sensitivity) threshold lies between 0.1 N and 10 N.
d. Typical Results:
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
NF T 70-509
FR-39
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
France/201.04.002
FR-40
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
France/201.04.003
FR-41
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
France/201.05.002
b. Description: The explosive materials are placed in containers which are representative of
real objects in terms of volume and geometry, for example:
The mock-up, which is replaced for each firing, is held in a vertical position by its base
and attacked horizontally in its environment. The velocities of impact lie between 400 and
1000 m/s. A test is carried out for each velocity.
A table is drawn up to indicate, for each bullet velocity, the type of reaction observed
(type I to type V or non-reaction).
d. Typical Results:
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
VUL-102
FR-42
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
France/201.06.002
b. Description: The explosive materials are placed in containers which are representative of
real objects in terms of volume and geometry, for example:
The mock-up is held in a vertical position. It is attacked in its centre by the impact of a
steel ball (of diameter 39.5 mm and mass 252 g) travelling at a speed which may reach
2400 m/s.
The aim is to find the maximum velocity of the ball which does not cause the detonation
of the material.
d. Typical Results:
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
NF T 70-512
FR-43
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
France/201.06.003
b. Description: The explosive materials are placed in containers which are representative of
real objects in terms of volume and geometry, for example:
The mock-up is held in a vertical position. It is attacked in its centre by the impact of a 16
g steel fragment in the form of a cylinder of diameter 12.7 mm with a conical point
travelling at velocities lying between 500 and 2000 m/s. A test is carried out for each
velocity.
A table is drawn up to indicate, for each fragment velocity, the type of reaction observed
(type I to type V or non-reaction).
d. Typical Results:
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
VUL-101
FR-44
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
France/201.07.001
b Description: The explosive materials are placed in containers which are representative of
real objects in terms of volume and geometry, for example:
d. Typical Results:
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
NF T 70-511
FR-45
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
France/201.08.004
The friability is characterized by the value of (dP/dt)max obtained at 150 m/s or by the
limiting impact speed corresponding to a given value of (dP/dt)max (for example 15
MPa/ms for explosives and 18 MPa/ms for propellants).
d. Information Requirements for Assessment: This trial is applicable to all compact solid
explosive materials.
e. Typical Results:
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
SEN-216
FR-46
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
France/201.08.007
b. Description: The method is to determine the electric current in a resistance wire which causes
the initiation of a primary explosive in powder form.
3
The test device consists of a capsule of plastic material filled with 115 mm of
uncompacted explosive through which passes a 60 micron nickel-chrome 80/20
resistance wire.
The initiating current intensity (in mA) is obtained by taking the mean of 10 tests which
cause initiation of the primary explosive.
d. Typical Results:
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
FA 501-A-1
FR-47
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
France/202.01.009
After its return to ambient temperature, the material is examined visually and then
analysed to establish its physico-chemical, mechanical, ballistic, sensitivity and reactivity
characteristics etc.
The characteristics after ageing are compared with those of the unaged material.
d. Typical Results:
For a single-base grain propellant, the loss of stabilizer (diphenylamine) after ageing at
50°C for 42 days is generally less than 0.2%.
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
FP 406-C-1
FP 406-C-2
FR-48
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
France/202.01.012
The aim is to find the maximum temperature which does not lead to a pyrotechnic event
or, if there is always a pyrotechnic event, the temperatures leading to this event after 20
hours and 100 hours of exposure.
d. Typical Results:
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
SEN-307
FR-49
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
France/202.02.001
b. Description: The explosive materials are placed in containers which are representative of
real objects in terms of volume and geometry, for example:
The results noted are the time before the appearance of a pyrotechnic reaction and the
type of reaction observed (type I to type V or non-reaction).
d. Typical Results:
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
NF T 70-513
FR-50
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
France/202.02.002
The test is repeated 3 times; the least advantageous result is the one taken into
consideration.
c. Information Requirements for Assessment: This trial is applicable to all explosives and to
all propellants in block or grain form.
d. Typical Results:
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
SEN-104
FR-51
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
France/202.02.003
b. Description: The explosive materials are placed in containers which are representative of
real objects in terms of volume and geometry, for example:
c. Information Requirements for Assessment: This trial is applicable to all explosives and to
all propellants in block or grain form.
d. Typical Results:
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
NF T 70-515
FR-52
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
France/205.01.001
FR-53
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
France/205.02.001
b. Description: The trial is intended to determine the powder height threshold leading to an
explosion with or without detonation of a tube in a vertical position, open towards the top,
after a local ignition within the base of the tube. A 3 mm thick tube of diameter 82 mm
and height 1000 mm is used.
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
FMD-862-A-1
FR-54
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
France/302.01.001
c. Information Requirements for Assessment: This trial is applicable to all explosives whose
velocity of detonation is greater than 5000 m/s.
d. Typical Results:
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
NF T 70-700
FR-55
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
France/302.02.001
b. Description: The trial involves determination of the rate of flame propagation in a fine train
of pyrotechnic material laid out in free air in a semi-cylindrical channel with thick walls
and ignited at one end.
The material is poured into the horizontal channel with its normal gravimetric density, and
is then levelled off.
The flame heating device is placed under the channel, vertically beneath one end.
The rate of combustion is determined by measuring the time taken to travel between
marks placed a known distance apart, using a manual stop watch or a recording
chronograph.
The result taken as the velocity of propagation is the mean of at least two tests. Other
phenomena are also noted (time before reaction commences, failure to ignite,
interruption, explosion).
c. Information Requirements for Assessment: This trial is applicable to grain propellants and
pyrotechnic compositions in powder form.
d. Typical Results:
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
NF T 70-507
FR-56
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
France/302.02.002
The various ballistic parameters, such as maximum pressure, force, powder quickness
etc, are calculated by comparison with a reference powder or as absolute figures.
d. Typical Results:
3
(1) Artillery powders: quickness 1 to 2 m /s.kg
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
FB 665-A-1
FB 666-A-1
FR-57
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
France/302.02.003
After ignition, the intervals of time between the cutting off of the fuses are measured.
d. Typical Results:
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
FAP 100-A-1
FAP 102-A-1
FAP 102-B-1
FR-58
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
France/302.02.004
b. Description: Fuel blocks made of the propellant to be tested are fired in standard motors
in which the operating pressure and the temperature can be selected.
Such firing allows the main characteristics of the propellant to be deduced, in particular
its rate of combustion. The fuel blocks used are:
(1) for the “Épictète” and “Nitrargols” propellants (cast double-base): Panisse block
or Bates block,
d. Typical Results:
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
FAP 104-A-1
FR-59
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
France/302.03.001
b. Description: The Bruceton method is used to determine the thickness of a barrier which
gives a 0.5 probability of initiation of a booster explosive by a defined initiator-detonator.
The transmission of the detonation to the explosive under test is observed with the help
of a witness plate placed under the latter
The arrangement ensures confinement of the explosive. The thickness of the barrier
varies in discrete steps from 1 to 10 mm. A minimum of 50 tests are carried out. The
result is considered satisfactory if the mean thickness converges towards an asymptotic
value.
The trial is carried out on cylindrical test pieces of diameter 10 mm and height 18 mm,
obtained by casting, compression or machining.
c. Information Requirements for Assessment: This trial is applicable to all solid explosives
which can be put in the form defined above.
d. Typical Results:
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
FMD-210-A-1
FR-60
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
France/302.03.002
b. Description: The Bruceton method is used to determine the thickness of a barrier which
gives a 0.5 probability of initiation of an explosive charge by a defined PETN booster. The
transmission of the detonation to the explosive under test is observed with the help of a
witness plate placed under the latter
The trial is carried out on cylindrical test pieces of diameter 10 mm and height 18 mm,
obtained by casting, compression or machining.
c. Information Requirements for Assessment: This trial is applicable to all solid explosives
which can be put in the form defined above.
d. Typical Results:
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
FMD 210-A-2
FR-61
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
France/302.03.003
b. Description: The Bruceton method is used to determine the thickness of a barrier which
gives a 0.5 probability of initiation by a booster explosive, the acceptor explosive being a
PETN pellet. The transmission of the detonation to the explosive under test is observed
with the help of a witness plate placed under the latter
The arrangement ensures confinement of the explosives. The thickness of the barrier
varies in discrete steps. A minimum of 50 tests are carried out. The result is considered
satisfactory if the mean thickness converges towards an asymptotic value.
The trial is carried out on cylindrical test pieces of diameter 9 mm and height 10 mm,
obtained by casting, compression or machining.
c. Information Requirements for Assessment: This trial is applicable to all solid explosives
which can be put in the form defined above.
d. Typical Results:
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
FMD-211-A-2
FR-62
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
France/302.03.004
The inert barrier which attenuates the shock wave emitted by the primary explosive is
made of aluminium disks. The secondary explosive is considered to be initiated when it
pierces an aluminium witness perforation disk 3 mm thick.
The test quantities are 150 mg of primary explosive and 300 mg of secondary explosive.
The two explosives and the barriers between them undergo compression at 1000 bars.
d. Typical Results:
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
FA -603-A-1
FR-63
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
France/302.03.005
c. Information Requirements for Assessment: This trial is applicable to all solid explosives
whose critical diameter lies between 2 and 20 mm.
d. Typical Results:
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
NF T 70-701
FR-64
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Editon 2)
10.7.5 QUALIFICATION PROCEDURES FOR GERMANY
PARAGRAPH PAGE
GE-1
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
GE-2
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Editon 2)
10.7.5.1 MILITARY DEPARTMENTS RESPONSIBLE FOR QUALIFICATION
10.7.5.1.1 The Federal Office of Military Technology and Procurement (Bundesamt fur Wehrtechnik
and Beschaffung - BWB) has full responsibility for qualification of explosives. Within the
scope of qualification of a new explosive, the technical sections of BWB are responsible
for the following tasks:
10.7.5.1.2 Within the scope of qualification of a new explosive the WIWEB is responsible for the
following tasks:
b. Selections of the required tests in agreement with the technical sections of BWB;
10.7.5.2.1 The Defence Institute for Materials, Explosives, Fuels and Lubricants
(Wehrwissenschaftliches Institut für Werk-, Explosiv und Betriebsstoffe – WIWEB) is the
appointed National Authority for Germany and is responsible for the following functions in
accordance with STANAG 4170:
a. Establish and maintain a data bank of qualified explosives used by the military
services of the FRG;
d. Serve as Point of Contact to other NATO nations for the exchange of information.
GE-3
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
10.7.5.3.1 In Germany the term "explosives" comprises igniting and initiating substances and
mixtures of these, propellants, high explosives and pyrotechnic compositions. The
development of new explosives intended for military use is mainly carried out by private
firms. It is also the task of certain institutes sponsored by the GE MOD to carry out
research in the field of explosives.
10.7.5.3.2 A "new explosive" is defined as one which has not yet been used or qualified, whose
composition, nature, manufacturing procedure, manufacturer or manufacturing location
has subsequently been changed, or which is intended for a role for which it has not yet
been qualified.
10.7.5.3.3 In general, studies and developments are carried out under study or development
contracts awarded by the GE MOD or BWB. However, they may also result from a firm’s
initiative. Beside an application related development, a general development, i.e., without
relation to a particular equipment or weapon system, is also practiced.
10.7.5.3.4 The decision as to the suitability of an explosive in principle, which was developed within
the scope of one of the above mentioned contracts, is made by BWB after the completion
of the study or development contract. This decision is based on various factors, including
the fulfillment or nonfulfillment of basic safety requirements and of requirements set up in
a specification on which the contract was based.
10.7.5.3.5 After an investigation by WIWEB, the technical sections of BWB also decide on the use in
principle of such new explosives which are proposed by firms for a particular role.
10.7.5.3.7 The qualification procedure does not include the equipment/system integrated
assessment of the explosive. The qualification procedure is initiated by a written
application of the technical sections of BWB to WIWEB.
10.7.5.3.8 Before the start of the investigation, these sections and WIWEB must identify the
characteristics which are essential for the type, composition and nature of the explosive
and for its intended general use. This identification must not only take into consideration
the normal state in which the explosive is used, but also the state after stress caused by
expected storage and operational conditions, and must also include the effects of
environmental influences, in particular temperature, on the safety and performance
characteristics.
10.7.5.3.9 Based on these characteristics, WIWEB (in agreement with the section which applied for
the qualification) prepares the list of tests necessary to determine the characteristic data
of the explosive. The selection of the tests is influenced by the type, composition and
nature of the explosive, the intended role and application and the similarity with explosives
already qualified or used for similar purposes.
10.7.5.3.10 The investigation program must take into consideration the legal provisions for explosives
and transportation, and must permit an assessment of handling safety, stability,
compatibility and service life. In addition, it must provide for the determination of
chemical, physical, physicochemical and mechanical properties and performance data.
GE-4
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Editon 2)
10.7.5.3.11 The national tests listed in AOP-7 and the tests identified in STANAG 4170 are used for
this purpose. Other tests not included in AOP-7, but which are suitable to obtain the
required information, may also be used.
10.7.5.3.12 After completion of the investigations, WIWEB prepares an investigation report which not
only contains a substance characterization including the manufacturing process, and the
legal aspects with regard to explosives and transportation, but also the test procedures
applied and their results. The report also contains the assessment of the new explosive
in accordance with STANAG 4170 and the resulting qualification status: (a) qualified, (b)
not qualified., (c) qualified with certain restrictions. The assessment includes:
a. The evaluation of the new explosive on the basis of the legal provisions for
explosives and transportation; and
10.7.5.3.13 If IWEB determines that a new explosive is suitable in general for military use, it will
prepare a document which characterizes this qualified explosive (specification). This
specification stipulates the explosive characteristics such as composition, nature,
manufacturing process and use, as far as these ensure reproducible manufacture and
delivery. The technical requirements for the explosive, the testing instructions required for
their examination, and further, provisions on quality assurance and packaging, are also
reflected in this document.
10.7.5.3.14 After the substance specification has been written, the new explosive is approved for
immediate or later use. BWB is responsible for the decision to use it in ammunition.
10.7.5.3.16 The qualification of new explosives must be carried out independent of the equipment
tests and provings.
10.7.5.3.17 The introduction of the explosive for a particular role before conclusion of the qualification
procedure, before declaration of its basic suitability, and before completion of the
substance specification is prohibited in general.
GE-5
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
10.7.5.4QUALIFICATION METHODS AND TESTS
10.7.5.4.1 The qualification of high explosives, propellants and pyrotechnic compositions is based on
mandatory data obtained in tests listed herein.
GE-6
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Editon 2)
10.7.5.4.4 List of Germany’s Test Information Sheets
201.08.001 Deflagration-to-Detonation
Transition
201.08.002 Steel Tube Test (Koenen
GE-7
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
GE-8
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Editon 2)
10.7.5.5 CATALOGUE OF TEST INFORMATION SHEETS
NOTE: The Test Information Sheets are listed consecutively in accordance with their
Registry Number.
GE-9
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
GE-10
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Editon 2)
Germany/102.01.001
TEST INFORMATION SHEET
b. Description: Specimen: JANNAF type(B or C), gauge length 50 mm, width 10 mm, 6 mm
(DB) or 12 mm (Composite) thickness, transition radius 12,5 mm. Crosshead speed: 5
mm/min to 8 m/s. Test temperature: varies from 203 to 343ºK. Control measurements: 50
mm/min and 293ºK. After conditioning to test temperature (1 h), the specimen is pulled to
failure with constant crosshead speed. Force and elongation of the gauge section
(directly measured) are recorded. Main physical parameters affecting the results: strain
rate, temperature and relative humidity. Stress (force/initial cross sectional area)and
strain (elongation/initial gauge length) are calculated and plotted. Main results of the
stress-strain curve: initial tangent Modul Eo, maxLPXPVWUHVV BVWUHVVDWUXSWXUH r and
WKHFRUUHVSRQGLQJVWUDLQV BDQG r.
(1) Good
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
GE-11
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
Germany/102.01.002
TEST INFORMATION SHEET
1. TYPE OF EXPLOSIVE:
Main physical parameters affecting the results are: temperature, stress, and relative
humidity.
The creep compliance J(t) (strain(t)/stress) and the strain at failure are calculated. From
the results at different temperatures a shift factor aT can be determined.
d. Typical Results:
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
GE-12
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Editon 2)
Germany/102.01.003
TEST INFORMATION SHEET
1. TYPE OF EXPLOSIVE:
Main physical parameters affecting results: temperature, initial stress, initial strain and
initial strain rate. The relaxation modulus Er (t) (stress (t)/strain) is calculated and plotted.
From stress relaxation measurements at different temperatures the shift factor aT is
determined.
d. Typical Results:
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
GE-13
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
Germany/102.01.010
TEST INFORMATION SHEET
1. TYPE OF EXPLOSIVE:
b. Description: Specimen: Right circular cylinder with L/D <=2 (e.g. d = 20 mm, l = 40 mm)
or propellant grain (solid or perforated). Crosshead speed: 5 mm/min to 8 m/s; Test
o
temperature: 203 K to 343 K; Control measurements: 5 mm/min, 293 K. After
conditioning to the test temperature (1 h), the specimen is compressed to failure with
constant rate. Force and change of specimen length (displacement of the compression
bars) are measured and registered (not calculated from crosshead speed). Main physical
parameters affecting results: strain rate, temperature, relative humidity, specimen
geometry. Stress (force/initial cross sectional area) and strain (displacement/initial
length) are calculated and plotted. Main results: initial tangent Modulus Eo, stress and
strain at failure (onset of cracking).
d. Typical Results:
o -2 -1
(1) (293 . [ s )
(2) 5'; dB = 50 Mpa, G% = 2%, Eo = 1850 Mpa
(3) CompositHURFNHWSURSHOODQW dB 03D dB = 30%,
(4) Eo = 200 MPa.
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
GE-14
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Editon 2)
Germany/102.01.011
TEST INFORMATION SHEET
1. TYPE OF EXPLOSIVE:
b. Description: Specimen: Cylindrical shape, L/D >= 2 (e.g. d = 20 mm, L = 40 mm). The
test is done with a normal tensile tester. The fixture consists of two parts, a U-shape
outer compartment and a bar that fits in the center of the U. A central boring in the fixture
takes the specimen like a bolt. When the two parts of the fixture are pulled in opposite
directions, the specimen is sheared. Force and displacement are registered. Main
physical parameters affecting the results: crosshead speed, temperature and relative
humidity. Maximum shear stress (Force/two times the cross sectional area) and
displacement at maximum stress are the results of the test.
d. Typical Results:
(293 K, 5 mm/min)
2
(1) tetryl: = 2,5 N/mm , L = 0,12 mm
2
(2) HX 11 : = 0,25 N/mm , L = 2,57 mm
(1) Good
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
GE-15
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
Germany/102.01.022
TEST INFORMATION SHEET
1. TYPE OF EXPLOSIVE:
d. Typical Results:
(1) Good
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
GE-16
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Editon 2)
Germany/102.01.023
TEST INFORMATION SHEET
1. TYPE OF EXPLOSIVE:
d. Typical Results:
2
(1) H10s : HE: 20 to 40 N/mm
2
(2) DB Propellants: 4 to 8 N/mm
2
(3) Composite Propellants: 0,1 to 6 N/mm
(1) High
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
GE-17
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
Germany/102.01.042
TEST INFORMATION SHEET
1. TYPE OF EXPLOSIVE:
b. Description: Specimen: a) Rectangular bar, consists of two materials. The two materials
are partly separated and each part is mounted in one fixture of a tensile tester. b)
Disk-shaped specimen, the outer layer (second material) is partly separated and mounted
in a fixture of a normal tensile tester. The disk is fixed in the center by a bolt. The sample
is pulled and the force required to separate the two materials is measured. Main physical
parameters affecting the results are: Temperature, strain rate and peeling angle. The
result of the peel test is quoted as the mean force divided by the specimen width.
d. Typical Results:
(1) T = 2 N/mm
(1) Good
(1) DIN 53530 (Testing of organic materials; test for separating layers of laminated
woven fabrics).
GE-18
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Editon 2)
Germany/102.01.060
TEST INFORMATION SHEET
1. TYPE OF EXPLOSIVE:
d. Typical Results:
(1) Good
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
(1) DIN 53752 (Testing of plastics; determination of the coefficient of linear thermal
expansion).
GE-19
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
Germany/102.01.070
TEST INFORMATION SHEET
1. TYPE OF EXPLOSIVE:
b. Description: The density is calculated as quotient of mass and volume. The mass is
measured with a balance (resolution 0,0001 g) and the volume is measured with a gas
pycnometer (air or helium). The specimen must be small enough to fit into the test cell.
The main physical property that affects the result is the temperature.
3
The density is measured as g/cm .
d. Typical Results:
3
(1) PBX: 1,6 g/cm .
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
GE-20
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Editon 2)
Germany/201.01.001
TEST INFORMATION SHEET
b. Description: This test evaluates the sensitivity explosive materials to impact. The test
focusses on hazards associated with accidental impact during handling and transporting.
It determines, primarily, the lowest response level. The apparatus consists of a steel
block mounted on a concrete base. A steel anvil bearing the impact device is embedded
in the steel block. A column to support the guide rails of the free-falling drop weight is
attached to the rear of the steel block. Drop weights of 1 kg, 5 kg and 10 kg, each
assigned a given drop height test range, are used. The maximum height of the apparatus
3
is 1 m. The test substance of 40 mm rests between two coaxially arranged steel
cylinders fixed by a steel guide ring. An intermediate steel anvil and a steel centering ring
containing vent-holes complete this impact device. Powdered substances are dried and
sieved to a size of 0,5 to 1,0 mm before testing. Pressed or cast substances are crushed
and sieved to the afore- mentioned particle size. For liquids, a gap of l mm is left between
upper and lower cylinder. The upper cylinder is held in position by a rubber ring. The
sensitivity is the lowest height at which in a series of six tests at least one explosion is
registered. These values are quoted together with the resulting impact energy.
d. Typical Results:
Most solid rocket propellants have impact energies between 4 and 15 Joule (chips) and
15 to 35 Joule (pieces). Solid gun propellants lie between 3 and 10 Joule, whereas
pyrotechnic mixtures have impact energies over the entire range of the apparatus.
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
GE-21
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
Germany/201.02.001
TEST INFORMATION SHEET
b. Description: The test is used to evaluate the sensitivity of all types of explosive
substances to friction. Liquid and gelatinous substances are usually not tested due to
their lubricating tendencies and the resulting low heat development that is not sufficient to
cause a reaction. The explosive sample is held between a porcelain plate and a porcelain
peg under a given load. Frictional forces are applied by a horizontal movement of the
porcelain plate. An electric motor drives an eccentric disc and a connecting rod which is
fastened to the carriage of the plate. Movement of the plate relative to the peg is a
forward and backward motion of 10 mm each, with an average velocity of 5 cm/s. The
peg fixture also carries the load arm, which has six equally spaced notches for the
attachment of one of nine weights. By various combinations of weight and position on the
load arm one can apply loads from 5 to 360 Newton on the test substance. Before
testing, powdered substances are sieved through a 0.5 mm mesh screen. Pressed or
cast substances are crushed before sieving. The relative sensitivity to friction is indicated
by the lowest load expressed in Newton that leads to ignition, crackling or explosion at
least once in a series of six tests. The lowest load and the type of reaction observed are
registered on the data sheet.
c. Information Requirements for Assessment: The test determines the sensitivity to friction
of explosives. It is required by the German Explosives Law, Transportation Regulations
and is acceptable for the qualification testing of explosives, propellants and pyrotechnics.
d. Typical Results:
Load Reaction
Explosives: PETN 60 Newton crackling
Tetryl 360 Newton crackling
RDX 180 Newton crackling
HMX 160 Newton crackling
TNT >360 Newton
Comp B >360 Newton
Solid rocket propellants react with crackling between 40 and 360 Newton. Gun propellants show
crackling between 120 and 240 Newton. Pyrotechnics mixtures begin to react with
crackling at 20 Newton. The most insensitive lie above 360 Newton.
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
GE-22
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Editon 2)
Germany/201.03.001
TEST INFORMATION SHEET
c. Information Requirements for Assessment: The test is used to determine the lowest
discharge energy that will ignite an explosive or propellant sample under the given
conditions.
GE-23
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
Germany/201.04.001
TEST INFORMATION SHEET
b. Description: The shock sensitivity and the detonability of an explosive are determined as
a function of the height of a water column that is used to transmit and attenuate the shock
output of a standard donor explosive. Evidence of a detonation is provided by a
detonating cord placed on the acceptor charge and with its other end attached to a lead
witness plate. In the normal version, the donor charge of RDX/wax/graphite (94.5/4.5/1)
3
has a diameter of 2l mm and a length of 20 mm. Its density is 1.6 g/cm . Initiation is
conducted with a standard electric detonator. The acceptor charge has a diameter of 2l
mm and a length of 40 mm. Donor, water and acceptor are enclosed in a plexiglass tube
of 2l mm inner diameter and 25 mm outer diameter. Explosive materials with a critical
diameter greater than 20 mm are tested in a scaled-up version of the test where the
plexiglass tube has an inner diameter of 50 mm and an outer diameter of 60 mm. The
3
donor charge consists of 140 g of RDX/wax/graphite pressed to a density of 1.6. g/cm .
The dimensions are 50 mm diameter and 50 mm length. The acceptor has a diameter of
50 mm and a length of at least l00 mm. The limits of non-detonation (shock wave
sensitivity) and detonation (detonability) are determined by a type of up-and-down
procedure. Tests above the non-detonation limit will always give negative results and
tests below the detonation limit will always result in a detonation. Results are specified as
"mm water gap" and may also be supplemented by the corresponding shock pressure. A
substance is considered to be more sensitive to shock waves than others if its
non-detonation limit is greater than that of the other substance at a given density.
(1) The test is used to determine the shock wave sensitivity of explosives, and
occasionally of propellants. It is required by German military specifications (TL)
and is acceptable for qualification testing.
d. Typical Results:
GE-24
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Editon 2)
Germany/201.04.004
TEST INFORMATION SHEET
b. Description: In this test a propellant is confined in a 1" steel pipe and 300 mm long. A 0,6
g PETN detonator is used to initiate the propellant sample. The purpose of the test is to
determine whether a standard donor shock will initiate a detonation in the propellant and if
so, whether the detonation will propagate through the entire length of the propellant
column. Type and extent of reaction are determined by the examination of the remains of
the steel pipe. If there is no propagation under these conditions, the test is repeated
using a 2" pipe having a length of 500 mm. In this case a standard 50 g RDX/wax pellet
serves as a booster charge.
c. Information Requirements for Assessment: The test is used to determine the detonability
of propellants under confinement. Also in certain cases other explosive substances that
are not expected to sustain a detonation in their normal mode of application are tested.
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
(1) Koenen, H., Ide, K. H., Swart, K. H, Explosivstoffe 9 (1961) 4-13, 30-42
(2) Military Specification TL 1376-701, Teil III, Blatt 5.
GE-25
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
Germany/201.05.001
TEST INFORMATION SHEET
b. Description: The test is reproducible and the behavior of the test substance in its mode of
application is determined. The test can differentiate between the behavior of an explosive
in the powdered, pressed, or cast state. Normally, the explosive or propellant is tested in
its state of application, i.e., density, cast, pressed, extruded. It is confined in a seamless
steel cylinder with an inner diameter of 50 mm, an outer diameter of 55 mm, and a length
of 50 mm. Steel caps of 5 mm thick enclose the substance at both ends. The cylinder is
placed in a test stand and a 7.62 mm projectile is fired using a NATO G-3 rifle set up 15
m from the cylinder. It impacts the flat end of the cylinder with a velocity of approximately
800 m/s. In a series of ten tests, a detonation, explosion, burning, partial reaction or
non-reaction is determined. The damage to the steel cylinder is also noted.
d. Typical Results:
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
GE-26
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Editon 2)
Germany/201.08.001
TEST INFORMATION SHEET
GE-27
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
Germany 201.08.002
TEST INFORMATION SHEET
c. Information Requirements for Assessment: The test is used to determine the thermal
sensitivity of explosive substances. It is required by the German Explosives Law,
Transportation Regulations and is acceptable for the qualification testing of explosives,
propellants and pyrotechnics.
d. Typical Results:
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
GE-28
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Editon 2)
Germany/202.01.001
TEST INFORMATION SHEET
(1) The weight loss caused by the decomposition of the propellant is a measure of its
stability. The Holland-Test is required by German specifications TL 1376-600,
Blatt 27 (gun propellants) and TL 1376-701, Blatt 19 (rocket propellants).
d. Typical Results:
(1) Rocket propellants are required to have a loss in weight below 2%.
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
GE-29
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
Germany/202.01.002
TEST INFORMATION SHEET
(1) The Weight Loss Tests are used to assess the safe chemical life of propellants.
They are required by German specifications TL 1376-600, Blatt 29 (gun
propellants) and TL 1376-701, Blatt 20 (rocket propellants).
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
GE-30
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Editon 2)
Germany/202.01.003
TEST INFORMATION SHEET
b. Description: The stability of single and double-base gun propellants and double-base
rocket propellants is examined in this test. Propellant samples of 5 g are heated in
standardized tubes in an aluminum heating block. Single-base gun propellants are
o
heated for 5 hours at 132 C, double-base gun and rocket propellants are tested for 16
o
hours at 115 C.
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
GE-31
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
Germany/202.01.004
TEST INFORMATION SHEET
(1) The test is used to determine the ease of ignition of explosive substances.
d. Typical Results:
(1) Koenen, H., Ide, K. H., Swart, K.-H, Explosivstoffe 9 (1961) 4-13.
GE-32
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Editon 2)
Germany/202.01.005
TEST INFORMATION SHEET
d. Typical Results:
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
GE-33
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
Germany/202.01.006
TEST INFORMATION SHEET
b. Description: In this stability test, gun propellants are heated under standardized
conditions in a metal heating block. The test temperature for single base propellants is
o o o o
135 C (408 K) and 120 C (393 K) for double base propellants. The appearance of fumes
of nitrogen oxide is detected with the aid of methyl-violet indicator paper. The time
elapsed until the change of color sets in, is taken as the measure of stability for the
propellants. During a period of five hours, a deflagration must not occur.
(1) The test is used to verify the stability requirements specified for single and double
base propellants.
GE-34
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Editon 2)
Germany/202.01.007
TEST INFORMATION SHEET
d. Typical Results:
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
GE-35
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
Germany/202.01.008
TEST INFORMATION SHEET
b. Description: In this stability test a standard mass of solid rocket propellant is heated in
o
Bergmann-Junk tubes at 90 C in a metal heating block. The total acid produced by
oxidation of the decomposition products in the presence of a 3% H2O2 solution is
determined by titration with NaOH.
Results are expressed in days within which the amount of acid that can be neutralized by
12.5 ml n/100 NaOH has been produced. The result correlates with the 3% limit in the
o
90 C Weight Loss Test.
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
GE-36
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Editon 2)
Germany/202.01.009
TEST INFORMATION SHEET
(1) The test is used to determine the temperature at which an explosive ignites or
decomposes.
d. Typical Results:
o
(1) Tetryl: 202 C
o
(2) RDX/Wax/Graphite: 232 C
o
(3) Comp B: 205 C
o
(4) TATB: no visible sign of reaction up to 360 C
o
(5) Gun Propellants: 170-175 C
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
(1) Koenen, H., Ide, K.H., Swart, K.-H., Explosivstoffe 9 (1961) 4-13.
GE-37
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
Germany/202.01.010
TEST INFORMATION SHEET
(1) Used to determine all changes in enthalpy and the loss of weight as a result of
chemical or physical changes of the substance during heating at a constant rate.
Thus, information on stability and compatibility is obtained.
d. Typical Results:
o
(1) Silver Azide: crystal transformation 190 C
o
melting 289 C
o
explosion 307 C
o
(2) HMX: crystal transformation 180 C
o
beginning of exothermaldecomposition 262 C
o
explosion 271 C
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
GE-38
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Editon 2)
Germany/202.01.011
TEST INFORMATION SHEET
(1) The results are used to determine the critical diameter and the time to
self-ignition.
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
GE-39
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
Germany/302.02.001
TEST INFORMATION SHEET
b. Description: In this test the strand burning technique is employed to determine the linear
burning rate of solid rocket propellant under defined temperature and pressure conditions.
Before testing begins, the strands having lengths of 230 mm and diameters of 6 mm, are
coated with an inhibitor to prevent premature burning of the superficies. Also, holes are drilled
into the strands for attaching fuse wires and gauges necessary for ignition and determination
of the burning rate. After these wires have been introduced, the strand is fastened to a
holding device in the bomb head, which is then screwed into the bomb. The Crawford bomb
itself has a volume of 1 liter and may be pressurized to a maximum of 400 bar. Test
o o
temperatures may be adjusted between -40 C and +50 C. Constant pressure is maintained
throughout burning by means of an expansion tank connected to the bomb.The time of
burning between the gauges is recorded, converted to a burning rate, and plotted as a
function of pressure.
(1) The results from the test are used for quality assurance.
(1) The test has both good repeatability and reproducibility of + 1%.
GE-40
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Editon 2)
Germany/302.02.002
TEST INFORMATION SHEET
(1) The results of the test are used for a ballistic assessment of the test propellant.
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
GE-41
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
Germany/302.03.001
TEST INFORMATION SHEET
b. Description: The eprouvette is used for the determination of the performance of black
powder. It consists essentially of a cylindrical combustion chamber having a conical
opening at the upper end and a super-imposed cylindrical weight of 10 kg mass. Both are
mounted upright on a device similar to that of the impact test apparatus. In testing, a 10 g
sample of black powder is placed in the combustion chamber and ignited by means of an
electric fuze head. On ignition the weight is accelerated vertically upward between two
guide rails and arrested on reaching the maximum height. This height is determined as a
measure of the performance of the black powder.
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
GE-42
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
10.7.7 QUALIFICATION PROCEDURES OF ITALY
PARAGRAPH PAGE
IT-1
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
IT-2
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
10.7.7.1 MILITARY DEPARTMENTS RESPONSIBLE FOR QUALIFICATION
(cf. STANAG 4170 Ed2 §3)
10.7.7.1.1 The procurement of weapon systems for the Armed Forces is under the responsibility of the
three different bodies :
Body Procurement of
Direzione Generale degli Armamenti Terrestri (DGAT or TERRARM) Land Armament Systems
Direzione Generale degli Armamenti Navali (DGAN or NAVARM)- Navy Armament Systems
Direzione Generale degli Armamenti Aeronautici (DGAA or ARMAEREO) Air Force Armament Systems
These three General Directorates are subordinated to Defence General Secretariat and
National Armament Director (SGD/DNA), which is the national STANAG 4170 implementation
responsible.
Qualification is mandatory for all explosive material to be used in munitions intended for the 4
Services: Army, Navy, Air Force and “Carabinieri”.
10.7.7.2.1 Within SGD/DNA, the office appointed as National Authority for the Qualification of explosive
materials is the DGAT. So DGAT has the full responsibility of qualifying all explosive materials
to be used by the Italian forces.
a. this well specified explosive material has the necessary properties to provide an
expectation of an adequate level of safety and suitability for service in military use, for a
given intended role,
b. the manufacture and quality of the explosive material are adequately controlled.
a. Generally, and especially for a new composition, the official request for qualifying an
explosive has to come from the designer of this explosive.
b. In some cases, the request could come from the manufacturer of the explosive, or even
from the munition or munition-component designer. This request is sent directly to the
National Authority.
a. In order to make the Qualification decision, the following information has to be brought
to the DGAT:
IT-3
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
(2) the assessment data (from tests performed on material coming from industrial
production batches) on which the judgement of safety and suitability for service use
will be based,
(3) the information justifying that the manufacturing process and quality are adequately
controlled.
b. According to STANAG 4170, all these informations are collated in the Qualification
report upon which is based the Qualification decision.
10.7.7.3.4 The validity and quality of the informations produced are ensured by involving the DGAT offices
and the AQ Services (Army or Navy or Air Force), located on the manufacturers:
(1) DGAT - for technical expertise and testing – in participating in the design of the
Qualification programme as well as giving advice on the Qualification report.
(2) AQ Services – for the quality assurance for all armament programmes - mainly
involved in verifying that both the designer and the manufacturer of the explosive
have a good quality assurance system, and that the manufacturer has the
capability of producing it in conformity with the designer specifications. AQ
Services verifies that the tests are carried on according to the applicable
STANAGs.
a. The following table provides the different steps of the qualification procedure and the
parties involved in them:
Step Participants
IT-4
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
10.7.7.3.6 The term “Qualification” is applied in the following different cases :
a. When it is possible to completely follow the process as described under §5 of STANAG 4170
Ed2 and particularly as described under §10.7.7.3.3 “Approach” of this document, DGAT
makes the “Qualification” decision of the explosive material.
b. For the Explosives already in service for which there is a well-established history of safe and
satisfactory use, providing the original material specifications remains the same, may be
qualified for use in the same role. Without further testing, or with a very limited testing
programme, DGAT makes the “Qualification ” decision with possible restrictions of the role.
c. If an explosive material was already qualified according to STANAG 4170 by a foreign National
Authority, DGAT is just making a “recognition of the Qualification” - given by this foreign
National Authority - decision. This is done on the basis of the Qualification certificate produced
by this Authority and, if necessary, of the Qualification report (which should include all
informations on this explosive material). Most of the time, DGAT is also asking for additional
data according to the methods and tests described at §10.7.7.4.
d. A decision can be taken to satisfy a request from the designer or the manufacturer to qualify a
new explosive material, even if there is no immediate application envisaged for national military
use. In that case DGAT applies the criteria as described in previous point a.
IT-5
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
10.7.7.4 QUALIFICATION METHODS AND TESTS
a. Mandatory Tests:
b. Optional Tests:
IT-6
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
10.7.7.4.2 List of Tests for Booster Explosives:
a. Mandatory Tests
IT-7
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
10.7.7.4. 3 List of Tests for Main Charge High Explosives:
a. Mandatory Tests:
IT-8
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
10.7.7.4.4 List of Tests for Solid Gun Propellants:
a. Mandatory Tests:
IT-9
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
10.7.7.4. 5 List of Tests for Solid Rocket Propellants:
a. Mandatory Tests:
IT-10
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
10.7.7.4.6 List of Tests for Liquid Propellants:
a. Mandatory Tests:
IT-11
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
10.7.7.4.8 Other Tests
a. Chemical analysis
To determine the chemical characteristics of the different types of explosive materials, others
general tests can be conducted.
The tests, specific for each explosive material which have to be defined, will be conducted
according to the applicable STANAGs or national procedures.
In case of IM-MURAT (explosives and/or munitions) IT carries on the specific tests according
to STANAG 4439, in addition to the mandatory tests of the STANAG 4170.
IT-12
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
201.01.XXX Impact
201.02.XXX Friction
201.04.XXX Shock
IT-13
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
203.01.XXX Compatibility/Reactivity
IT-14
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
10.7.7.6 CATALOGUE OF TEST INFORMATION SHEETS
NOTE: The Test Information Sheets are listed consecutively in accordance with their Registry
Number.
IT-15
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
Italy/102.02.001
b. Description: The method is to measure the mass of a certain quantity of the material which,
loose in bulk, exactly fills a container of a given volume.
The bulk state is obtained by filling the container with the material flowing freely from the orifice
of a funnel located a specified distance above the said container, without compaction.
3
The ratio of the mass to the volume represents the apparent density of the material (in kg/m ).
d. Typical Results:
3
(1) Lead styphnate: 1300 kg/m
3
(2) Lead azide: 1600 kg/m
IT-16
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
Italy/102.02.002
The enlargement is adapted to the material under examination in order to determine the shape
and size of the crystals or particles
IT-17
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
Italy/202.01.001
2. TEST TITLE: Thermal Stability: behaviour under long period at 60°C or a lower temperature
After predetermined periods of heating (for example 42 days, 3 months, 6 months, 1 year, 2
years etc) a sample of the material under test is removed from the enclosure or building.
After its return to ambient temperature, the material is examined visually and then analysed to
establish its physico-chemical, mechanical, ballistic, sensitivity and reactivity characteristics etc.
The characteristics after ageing are compared with those of the unaged material.
c. Information Requirements for Assessment: This trial is applicable to all explosive materials.
d. Typical Results:
For a single-base grain propellant, the loss of stabilizer (diphenylamine) after ageing at 50°C for
42 days is generally less than 0.2%.
IT-18
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
Italy/202.01.002
The aim is to find the maximum temperature which does not lead to a pyrotechnic event or, if
there is always a pyrotechnic event, the temperatures leading to this event after 20 hours and
100 hours of exposure.
c. Information Requirements for Assessment: This trial is applicable to shaped solid materials.
IT-19
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
Italy /205.01.001
IT-20
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
Italy /302.01.001
c. Information Requirements for Assessment: This trial is applicable to all explosives whose
velocity of detonation is greater than 5000 m/s.
IT-21
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
Italy/302.02.001
The various ballistic parameters, such as maximum pressure, force, powder quickness etc, are
calculated by comparison with a reference powder or as absolute figures.
c. Information Requirements for Assessment: This trial is applicable to grain or stick powders.
d. Typical Results:
3
(1) Artillery powders: quickness 1 to 2 m /s kg
IT-22
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
Italy /302.03.001
c. Information Requirements for Assessment: This trial is applicable to all solid explosives whose
critical diameter lies between 2 and 20 mm.
IT-23
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
To be provided
NO-1
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
To be provided
PO-1
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
10.7.11 QUALIFICATION PROCEDURES OF ROMANIA
PARAGRAPH PAGE
RO-1
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
RO-2
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
10.7.11.1 MILITARY DEPARTMENTS RESPONSIBLE FOR QUALIFICATION
10.7.11.1.1 In Romania, the Procurement and Services Department (P.S.D.) and its Research -
Development Directorate (R.D.D), from the Ministry of National Defense, has full
responsibility for the qualification of explosives and ammunitions. The Chief of the
Testing - Evaluation Department and the Program Managers has the responsibility for the
implementation of R.D.D policy.
10.7.11.2.1 In Romania, the Research - Development Directorate (R.D.D) is the appointed National
Authority. This directorate has responsibility for qualification of military explosives and
ammunitions used by Romanian Armed Forces.
10.7.11.2.2 Within the process for qualification of explosive materials and ammunitions, the Research
- Development Directorate collaborate with:
During the process of establishing the tasks, and during the final qualification, R.D.D. co-
operates with representatives from the Army, Air Force and Navy Staffs, in order to
ensure safety of use, storage and transport of the explosives and ammunitions.
c. Receives from agencies within Romania, or from other nations the test data for
qualifying explosive materials, and assesses whether the material is safe and
suitable for consideration for use by the Services in a particular role or appli-
cation;
d. Publishes the test data and assessment which enables qualification, with or
without limitations;
f. Co-operates with the Standardisation Bureau for maintaining and enriching the
central collection of national and international standards relating to explosive
materials and explosive safety test data;
RO-3
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
g. Maintains and up-dates a data bank of qualified explosive materials used by the
Romanian Armed Forces;
10.7.1.2.3 The address for the Romanian National Authority is the following:
RO-4
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
10.7.11.3 QUALIFICATION PROCEDURES
10.7.11.3.1. Romania, as PfP nation, is determined to do its best to joint NATO. Regarding
ammunition and explosive safety and suitability for service, Romania is at the beginning
of STANAG 4170 implementation. Thus, the information contained in this section should
be considered as preliminary and can be a subject of change. All these things happen
because of the reorganization process of Romanian Ministry of National Defense and of
the institutions dealing with military materials research, development and production; it
also happens because of the process of lining up with the international standards.
10.7.11.3.2. Romania is able to produce and to load a wide range of explosive materials: Primary
Explosives, Solid Gun Propellants, Solid Rocket Propellants, Booster Explosives, Main
Charge High Explosives and Pyrotechnics. In the past, the process of Explosives
qualification proceeded according to the military standards of The Warsaw Treaty, and to
Romanian military standards. They were based upon the available international
regulations or the results of our national researches. The performing of the tests and
testing procedures were established by military standards, manuals of requirements and
internal norms. After 1990, Romania has dealt with the implementation of international
standards, especially NATO and MIL-STD. Thus, the Romanian technical military
standards were and will be modified so that the process of estimating – assessing and the
tests for qualification will be performed according to STANAG 4170 and AOP-7.
10.7.11.3.3. SMT 40362-2001 “The Principles and methodology for the qualification of military
explosives and ammunition” is the Romanian standard, which settles the qualification and
represents the implementation in Romania of STANAG 4170. The other NATO standards,
established to be compulsory for qualification of explosive materials will be adopted as
SMT and will be implemented in the near future, depending on the capability of the
Romanian institutions responsible for ammunition and explosive safety and suitability in
service.
10.7.11.3.4. In Romania most of the research in military explosives of all types is performed in the
following research, design and production units of the Procurement and Services
Department or of the State Owned Company ROMARM:
Part of the research, development and evaluation of military explosives and propellants is
done in private and public centers or civilian institutions such as National Center for
Mining Safety and Anti-explosives Protection “INSEMEX” Petrosani.
RO-5
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
10.7.11.3.5. Written requests for qualification of an explosive material are to be submitted to the
National Authority, which has to perform all legal actions for the beginning of the
qualification process.
10.7.11.3.6. In general, formal qualification testing of an explosive material is not done until it has
successfully passed all stages of research and development including laboratory model,
prototype lot and pilot - scale production. The explosive also must have been produced in
pre-production lots using full - scale production equipment, conditions and methods.
However, it is customary to use appropriate qualification tests during the research and
development phases to ensure that when an explosive finally reaches production it will be
unlikely to encounter unforeseen problems.
10.7.11.3.7. Before qualification, it is necessary for an explosive to have its transportation and storage
hazard classification determined in accordance with NATO STANAG 4123, "Methods to
Determine and Classify Hazards of Ammunition." This is the responsibility of the
Procurement and Services Department of Ministry of National Defense.
RO-6
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
10.7.11.4 QUALIFICATION METHODS AND TESTS
When the R.D.D. is satisfied that the explosive warrants qualification for safety and
suitability in service, the Program Manager prepares the appropriate papers and data
sheets for approval and issuance by the Chief of R.D.D and P.S.D.
RO-7
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
(4) Electric Spark Sensitivity STANAG 4490
(5) Temperature of Ignition STANAG 4491 (B1)/
201.03.001
(6) Vacuum Thermal Stability STANAG 4556
(7) Chemical Compatibility with Materials STANAG 4147
(8) Determination of Booster Explosives Components 101.02.001
(9) Detonation Velocity 302.01.001
(10) Melting Point 102.04.001
(11) Moisture Content 102.03.001
10.7.11.4.2 PROPELLANTS
RO-8
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
(6) Granulation 102.02.002
(7) Moisture and Volatile Contents 102.03.001/102.03.002
(8) Impact Sensitivity (BAM) STANAG 4489C
(9) Friction Sensitivity (BAM) STANAG 4487 (A)
(10) Temperature of Ignition STANAG 4491 (B1)/
201.03.001
(11) Electric Spark Sensitivity STANAG 4490
(12) Chemical Stability by Aging 202.01.001
(13 Vacuum Thermal Stability STANAG 4556
(14) Chemical Compatibility with Materials STANAG 4147
0
(15) Chemical Stability (Vieille Method at 106.5 C) 202.02.001
(16) Burning Rate Closed Vessel STANAG 4115
c. Solid Gun Propellants are tested for qualification in two stages, as formulation
and in specific charges in ammunitions.
RO-9
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
Test Registry / STANAG Number
c. Solid Rocket Propellants are tested for qualification in two stages: as formulation
and in specific motors:
(2) In specific rocket motors the following data are obtained and evaluated:
(a) Ballistic properties, such as: Thrust, Total Impulse, Specific Impulse;
(b) Temperature influence on performance characteristics.
10.7.11.4.3 PYROTECHNICS
RO-10
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
10.7.11.5 LIST OF TEST INFORMATION SHEETS
RO-11
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
RO-12
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
NOTE: The Test Information Sheets are listed consecutively in accordance with the
registry number.
RO-13
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
RO-14
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
RO/101.01.001
b. Description:
- The determination of individual components of Primary Explosives can be performed
with different analytical techniques.
- Is determined:
Primary Explosive (Mercury Fulminate, TNRPb, Tetracene, Lead Azide);
oxidants (e.g. Ba(NO3)2, KClO3);
reducing agents (e.g. metallic powder, Sb2S3);
binders;
moisture and volatile.
c. Information Requirements for Assessment: The test results are used to confirm that the
composition of the Primary Composition matches the declaration of the manufacturer, or
that the composition lies within the limits given in the product performance description.
The result represents a quality characteristic.
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
3.1 PTMI 20-2000 Testing Procedure.
3.2 SF – 17/32-1999. Technical quality requirements for TNRPb.
3.3 SF – 15/32-1999. Technical quality requirements for Tetracene.
3.4 NI – 5619-1974. Technical quality requirements for Barium Nitrate.
3.5 GOST 5593-1978. Technical quality requirements for metallic powders.
3.6 OST V 84-384-1971. Technical quality requirements for Antimony Sulfide.
RO-15
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
RO/101.02.001
a. Type of test: Chemical Property/ Analysis using different techniques of Main Charge
Explosives Components
b. Description:
c. Information Requirements for Assessment: The test results are used to confirm that the
composition of the Main Charge Explosives matches the declaration of the manufacturer,
or that the composition lies within the limits given in the product performance description.
The result represents a quality characteristic.
d. Typical results: The result depends on Main Charge Explosive Type. The methods work
for explosive compositions containing 0,01% to nearly 100 % of energetic material.
A IX-1 Main Charge Explosive Composition contents:
- RDX min. 94.5 %;
- Wax 5.0 – 6.5 %;
- Moisture and volatile max. 0.1 %;
- Insoluble particles in acetone max. 0.25 %;
- Ash max. 0.1 %;
- Acidity max. 0.05 %.
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
3.1 STP-M 40232-1998. Technical quality requirements for re-crystallized RDX.
3.2 SMT 40251-1999. Technical quality requirements and testing procedures for PETN.
(Corresponding to MIL-P-387 C).
3.3 SMT 40252-1999. Technical quality requirements and testing procedures for A IX-1.
RO-16
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
RO/101.03.001
b. Description:
The determination of Solid Propellants Components can be performed using
analytical techniques, by atomic absorption spectroscopy and gas chromatography.
For single base propellants is determine:
- NC content;
- Nitrogen content from NC;
- stabilizer content (DPA);
- inorganic substances content (KNO3, graphite);
- volatile content;
- moisture content.
For Double Base Propellants is determine:
- NC content;
- Nitrogen content from NC;
- other energetic material content (e.g. NG, NQ);
- stabilizer content (centralit I, II, III);
- volatile content.
Some title methods for establishing different contents are presented hereunder.
c. Information Requirements for Assessment: The test results are used to confirm that the
composition of Solid Propellants matches the declaration of the manufacturer, or that the
composition lies within the limits given in the product performance description. The result
represents a quality characteristic.
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
3.1 SMT 40133-1995. Solid Propellant. Preparing methods for physical and chemical
tests.
3.2 STP-M 40235-1997. Black powder. Technical requirements.
3.3 SMT 40375/1-1996. Solid Propellants. Technical requirements.
3.4 SMT 40397-1995. Solid Rocket Propellants. Technical requirements.
3.5 STP-M 40375/2-1996. Solid Gun Propellants. Physical and chemical requirements.
3.6 STP-M 40376/1-1998. Nitrocellulose. Technical requirements and methods.
3.7 STP-M 40375/2-1996. Solid Gun Propellants. Physical and chemical requirements.
3.8 STP-M 40376-1992. Solid Gun Propellants. Technical requirements.
3.9 SMT 40164/1-1996. Solid Gun Propellants. Technical quality requirements and
testing procedures for DPA, camphor, alcohol and ethyl - ether.
3.10 SMT 40164/4-1996. Solid Gun Propellants. Camphor content determination method.
3.11 SMT 40210-1996. Solid Gun Propellants. Potassium Nitrate content determination
methods.
3.12 SMT 40211-1996. Solid Gun Propellants. Potassium Sulphate content determination
method.
RO-17
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
3.13 SMT 40212-1996. Solid Gun Propellants. Ash content determination method.
3.14 SMT 40231-1996. Solid Gun Propellants. Ceresine content determination method.
3.15 SMT 40163-1994. Solid Propellants. Graphite determination method.
3.16 SMT 40385-1995. Solid Gun Propellants. PVC content determination method.
3.17 SMT 40386-1995 Solid Gun Propellants. Colophony content determination method.
3.18 SMT 40395-1995. Nitrocellulose. Nitrogen content determination method.
3.19 SMT 40382-1993. Solid Rocket Propellants. Nitric ester content determination
methods.
3.20 SMT 40383-1993. Solid Rocket Propellants. Butyl phthalate content determination
method.
3.21 SMT 40398-1993. Solid Rocket Propellants. Low nitrocellulose content determination
method.
3.22 SMT 40399-1994. Solid Rocket Propellants. Centralit content determination method.
3.23 SMT 40404-1996. Solid Rocket Propellants. Vaseline content determination method.
3.24 SMT 40414-1994. Solid Rocket Propellants. Lead dioxide, Calcium Carbonate and
Cobalt Trioxide content determination method.
3.25 SMT 40428-1995. Solid Rocket Propellants. Copper and Lead content by atomic
absorption spectroscopy.
3.26 SMT 40428-1996. Solid Propellants. Magnesium content by atomic absorption
spectroscopy.
3.27 SMT 40429-1995. Solid Propellants. Aluminium Oxide content by spectrophotometric
method UV-VIS.
3.28 SMT 40227-1998. Triple Base Propellants. NQ determination content.
3.29 SMT 40226-1998. Triple Base Propellants. Ethyl centralit determination content by
volumetric method.
3.30 SMT 40233-1997. Triple Base Propellants. Disc and cone method (similar to MIL-
STD-286C, method 103.1.3).
3.31 SMT 40246-1999. Triple Base Propellants. Cryolite determination method.
3.32 SMT 40303-2000. Triple Base Method. Graphite determination content by gravimetry.
RO-18
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
RO/101.04.001
c. Information Requirements for Assessment: The test results are used to confirm that the
composition of Pyrotechnic Compositions matches the declaration of the manufacturer, or
that the composition lies within the limits given in the product performance description.
The result represents a quality characteristic.
d. Typical results: The result depends on the pyrotechnic composition under investigation,
e.g. for V 11 Composition:
- PbO - 53,2 r 0,6 %;
- BaCrO4 - 24,6 r 0,6 %;
- KClO4 - 3,0 r 0,2 %;
- Zr - 16,8 r 0,5 %;
- S - 2,4 r 0,2 %;
- NC - 2,0 r 0,4 % (over 100%)
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
3.1 STP-M 40239-1998. Initiation and Delay Pyrotechnic Compositions. Technical
requirements. Analytical Methods.
RO-19
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
RO/102.01.001
a. Type of test: Physical Properties /Determination of Bulk Density by filling the explosive
material into a vessel of defined volume.
b. Description: The test is applicable to dry grain and pulverulent material. The dimensions
and the volume of the vessel have to be specified since the gravimetric density depends
3
on its. The volume of vessel depends on material type (e.g. a cylinder with 1000 cm
volume is used for Solid Gun Propellants). The sample is filled into a funnel which lower
opening in closed by a slide valve. After opening of the slide valve, the sample trickles
into the cylindrical vessel. The surplus of explosive material is removed by carefully
scarping off along the upper edge of the vessel. The explosive’s Bulk Density is calculated
as mass of explosive present in the vessel divided by the volume of the vessel.
d. Typical results: The results depend of explosive material and it manufacturing process.
3
- Granular single and double base propellant: 550 – 1200 g/dm ;
3
- P-45 gun propellant: min. 550 g/dm ;
3
- 4/7 Tgr gun propellant: min. 900 g/dm ;
3
- Black Powder DRP t 900 g/dm .
e. Repeatability and Reproducibility: The relative error of measurements must be less than 0.1%.
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
3.1 STP-M 40235-1997. Black Powders. Technical requirements.
3.2 SMT 40213-1996. Black Powders and solid gun propellants. Method to determine the
Bulk Density.
RO-20
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
RO/102.01.002
b. Description: The test is applicable to dry grain and pulverulent explosive material. The
apparatus, a metallic cylindrical vessel, is provided with two hand-operated valves at the
top and bottom of the vessel, a vacuum pump, a mercury manometer and connecting
tubes. Metallic sieves are disposed between the cylindrical vessel and valves. The
cylindrical vessel is full fill by mercury using the vacuum pomp. The mass m2 is than
determined. The vessel is full empty and 100 r 0.1g energetic material is placed into it.
Than the vessel is full fill with mercury and the mass m3 is measured. The Absolute
Density is calculated with:
m1 U Hg
U
m 2 m 3 m1
Where:
m1 - energetic material mass >g@;
m2 - the mass of cylindrical vessel filled with mercury >g@;
m3 - the mass of cylindrical vessel filled with explosive and mercury >g@;
3
UHg - the density of mercury at testing temperature >g/cm @.
c. Information Requirements for Assessment: The test results are a quality characteristic of
tested explosive. The Absolute Density affects the performance characteristics.
d. Typical results: Depend on the explosive type and its manufacture process.
3
- DRP 1R Black powder: 1.70 – 1.77 g/dm ;
3
- Single/double base solid propellant: 1.50 – 1.8 g/cm .
e. Repeatability and Reproducibility: Two parallel essays are performed and the median
3
value is calculated with 0.01 g/cm precision. The difference between the two results
3
must be less than 0.02 g/cm .
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
3.1 STP-M 40235-1997. Black Powders. Technical Requirements.
RO-21
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
RO/102.01.003
c. Information Requirements for Assessment: The test results are used to evaluate a quality
characteristic of tested explosives. The explosive density has many influences on the
performance and security characteristics. Variations in density mean changes in charge
manufacturing process. Reduced density may indicate defects and inclusions as voids
and fissures.
d. Typical results: The results depend on explosive type and the parameters of charge
manufacturing process.
e. Repeatability and Reproducibility: Two parallel essays are performed and the median
3
value is calculated with 0.01 g/cm precision. The difference between the two results
3
must be less than 0.02 g/cm .
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
3.1 SMT 40165-1993. Cylindrical hexatol charges. Technical requirements.
3.2 SMT 40182-1993. Cylindrical TNT charges. Technical requirements.
RO-22
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
RO/102.01.004
b. Description:
- The explosive sample is weighed in air with a high precision balance (r 0,0002 g). The
explosive mass must be within 0,5 y 1 g (for gun propellants with web d 0.8 mm) and
5y10 g (for gun propellants with web t 0.8 mm).
- A glass container is filled with a known density liquid and then the recipient is disposed
under the hydrostatic balance. On the balance arm is hanging a metallic case, which is
placed in immersion at 15 – 20 mm. The metallic case mass (m1) is determined.
- Than the case is filled with explosive samples. The total mass (m2) is determined with
0.0002g precision.
- The density d1 is calculated with:
d2 m
d1
m m 2 m1
Where:
- d2 - liquid density;
- m - explosive mass, weighted in air;
- m1 - metallic case mass, weighted in liquid;
- m2 - metallic case and explosive sample mass, weighted in liquid.
c. Information Requirements for Assessment: The test result is used to evaluate a quality
characteristic for Solid Gun Propellants.
d. Typical results:
3
- Single/double base propellants: 1,50 – 1,8 g/cm .
e. Repeatability and Reproducibility: The final result is the average value of two parallel
3
essays. The difference between the two results must be less than 0.015 g/cm .
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
3.1 STP M 40178-1996. Solid Gun Propellants. Methods to determine density.
RO-23
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
RO/102.02.001
b. Description: The test is applicable to Solid Gun Propellants with one or multi perforated
grains, tubular, annular, lamellar, and flake grains.
- For one or multi perforated grains, and for tubular grains web thickness, grain diameters,
perforation diameter, and grain height are measured.
- For lamellar and flake grains web thickness, length, width are determined.
- For annular grains web thickness, inner diameter, and external diameter are measured.
- Because of the inhomogeneity of extruded propellants, at least 20 – 30 different grains
have to be measured in order to achieve reliable results.
- For lamellar grains, the web thickness is measured at least in three places: at the ends
and on the middle.
c. Information Requirements for Assessment: The test results are used for quality
assurance. The interior ballistic behavior of a gun propellant depends strongly on its
dimensions.
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
3.1 SMT 40133-1995. Solid Propellant. Preparing methods for physical and chemical
tests.
3.2 STP-M 40377-1993. Solid Gun Propellant. Methods to determine the grain conformity
dimensions.
3.3 STP-M 40234-1997. Triple base propellants. Method to determine the grains
dimensions (similar to MIL-STD-286C, method 504.1.1).
RO-24
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
RO/102.02.002
a. Type of test: Physical Properties/Determining the dimensions for propellant grains which
has not a regularly shape.
b. Description: The method is used for determining the granulation of low sensitivity
explosives. The specimen shall consist of approximately 100 g of the explosive weighed
within 0.1g. The portions retained or passed by the various sieves shall be weighed and
the results calculated to a percentage basis.
- The sieves are of circular or square shapes, with 400 mm diameter/width.
- The mechanical shaker is set to produce 150 r 10 vibrations per minute, with 70 r 10
mm amplitude; the sieves, and the tested explosive must be covered and then shaken
for 3 minutes.
- The granulation fraction can be calculated with:
100 >%@
mi
xi
m
Where mi is the explosive mass retained by “i” sieve, and m is the explosive total
mass.
- The minimum and maximum size for the utilized sieves are:
For VU fl propellant: 0.40-0.56 mm ... 0.7-0.8 mm;
For VTK propellant: 0.56-0.70 mm …1.1-1.4 mm.
c. Information Requirements for Assessment: The test results are used to evaluating a
quality characteristic. The granulation can affect the bulk density.
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
3.1 STP-M 40310. Black Powders and Solid Gun Propellants. Method to determine the
granulation.
3.2 STP-M 40375/2-1992. Solid Gun Propellants. Technical requirements.
RO-25
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
RO/102.03.001
b. Description:
- The moisture content is determined by loss of weight, by water extraction with isopropyl
alcohol, by propellant decomposition with solvent mixture, and by Karl Ficher method
- Large propellants are ground or cut into pieces of maximum size 10x10x3mm.
- The loss of mass method is used for explosive which not contains volatile solvents. The
0
testing temperature is within 60-80 C, and the loss of mass is recorded after 150
minutes.
d. Typical results:
A IX-1 Main Charge Composition: max. 0.1 %;
PETN: max. 0.1 %;
ST –1 pyrotechnic composition: max. 0.2 %.
e. Repeatability and Reproducibility: Two parallel essays are performed and the median
value is calculated with 0.01% precision. The difference between the two results must be
less than 0.03 %.
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
3.1 SMT 40209-1996. Solid Gun Propellants. Methods to determine the moisture content.
3.2 SMT 40209/1-1993. Solid Rocket Propellants. Methods to determine the moisture
content.
3.3 SMT 40486-1996. High Explosives. Method to determine the moisture and volatile
content.
RO-26
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
RO/102.03.002
b. Description:
- For single base propellants, the volatile substances are moisture (eliminated volatile)
and residual volatile (e.g. ethanol, ethyl ether or mixture).
- The residual volatile content is represented by the difference between total volatile
content and eliminated volatile content.
- The propellant sample is dissolved into an organic solvent. After precipitation, the
0
solvent is eliminate by drying at 75-85 C, until a constant mass.
- Generally, the used solvent is acetone and the precipitation is performed with a mixture
ethanol/water (2/1).
c. Information Requirements for Assessment: The test result is used for quality insurance of
manufacturing process. The volatile contents may change the performance
characteristics of the ammunitions.
d. Typical results:
- P-45 single base propellant: max. 1.8 %;
- VTH-20 single base propellant: max. 3.7 %
- 22/1 TR single base propellant: max. 5.6 %.
e. Repeatability and Reproducibility: Two parallel essays are performed and the median
value is calculated with 0.1% precision. The difference between the two results must be
less than:
- 0.30 % - for web 0.7 mm;
- 0.40 % - for 0.7 d web d 1.0 mm;
- 0.50 % - web ! 1 mm.
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
3.1 SMT 40164/3-1996. Solid Gun Propellants. Method to determine the volatile content
by precipitation.
3.2 STP-M 40375/1-1996. Solid Gun Propellants. Technical requirements.
3.3 STP-M 40375/2-1996. Solid Gun Propellants. Physical and chemical requirements.
RO-27
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
RO/102.03.003
b. Description: Large propellants are cut into small pieces of maximum size 10x10x2mm.
0
Approximately 10 g explosive sample are heated and dry at 100 C for 30 minutes, until
the mass remain constant.
- After cooling into a desiccator, the explosive sample is weighed with 0.0002g precision.
- Than the sample is disposed into a desiccator which containing a KNO3/water solution
3
(1200g KNO3/1000 cm H2O).
0
- The testing temperature must be within 18 … 22 C, and the sample is maintained into
desiccator during 12 h.
- The hygroscopicity is calculated with:
'm
H >%@
m
c. Information Requirements for Assessment: Knowledge of the hygroscopicity is important
because the changes in moisture content can affect the performance characteristics or
lead to malfunction.
e. Repeatability and Reproducibility: Two parallel essays are performed and the median
value is calculated with 0.1% precision.
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
3.1 STP-M 40235-1997. Black Powders. Technical requirements.
RO-28
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
RO/102.04.001
b. Description:
- This method is used for determining the melting point of explosives to be used as a
criteria of purity;
- The specimen shall consist of a portion of a sample (not exceeding 5 g).
- The heating apparatus is equipped with an electrical heating controller device, which
0
supplies constant heating speed (e.g. 1y1.5 C / min.);
- The explosive sample is disposed into capillary tubes or between two glass plates. The
sample mass is according the used apparatus.
- The melting point is determined with accurately standardized centigrade thermometers.
c. Information Requirements for Assessment: The melting point is used to determinate the
purity of booster and main charge explosives. For an explosive composition, many
melting points can be determined.
d. Typical results:
0
- RDX: min. 200 C;
0
- TNT I and II: min. 80.2 C
e. Repeatability and Reproducibility: Two parallel essays are performed and the median
0
value is calculated with 0.1 C precision. The difference between the two results must be
0
less than 0.3 C.
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
3.1 STP-M 40232-1998. Hexogen. Technical requirements.
3.2 STP-M 40500-1996. Trinitrotoluen. Technical requirements.
RO-29
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
RO/103.01.001
b. Description: The testing compression equipment is provided with a mobile slab. The axial
motion may be selected with an appropriate constant rate. The strain indicator must
indicate the load with 1% precision, and the elongation with 0.01-mm precision. The
samples can have many regularly shapes: cylindrical, tubular etc. During the test, the
force and elongation are recorded. After the test, it is possible to obtain the maximal
strain, E-module, strain-deformation diagram. Parameters as temperature, dimension of
the sample and strain rate are influencing the results and have therefore to be specified.
At least two tests must be performed.
c. Information Requirements for Assessment: The test is used for characterizing the
mechanical behavior of the solid propellants. The data are required to assess the
mechanical properties, and the ability of the propellant to retain its integrity throughout
the range of operating conditions.
e. Repeatability and Reproducibility: The strain must be determined with r1 MPa precision.
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
3.1 STP-M 40450-1996. Solid Propellants. Method to determine the compressing
strength.
RO-30
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
RO/103.01.002
a. Type of test: Mechanical Properties /The test consist in the determination of the
deformation of solid gun grains at 157 MPa Strain.
b. Description: The test is conducted for single base gun propellants. 20 grains are
subjected to geometric measurements. The medium diameter and crossing area are
calculated. The samples are machined from a middle region of propellant grain, at length
equal with the diameter at .1 mm precision. Than the samples are subjected to a maximal
157 MPa strain, during 5 seconds, until the crack of the sample. The load is calculated as
the product between strain and medium crossing area.
d. Typical results: The deformation who not produce the samples crack must be:
- Min. 35 % - for 7/7 single base propellants (web t .7 mm);
- Min. 30 % - for 7/14 irregularly shaped grains.
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
3.1 STP-M 40378-1993. Single Base Gun Propellants. Method to determinate the
mechanical strength.
3.2 STP-M 40375/2-1992. Single Base Gun Propellants. Physical and Chemical
Requirements.
RO-31
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
RO/201.01.001
b. Description:
- The impact sensitivity test is used to determining the liquid, gelatinous and solid
energetic materials sensitivity.
- The KAST fallhammer apparatus consists in a solid plate, an anvil, and two guidance
bars from witch a striker is dropped down. Tetryl is used to verifying this device. The
explosive sample is placed in a confinement device, which consists of two coaxial
cylinders placed one on top of the other and guided by a steel ring.
- The weight hammers are 1, 2, 5 and 10 kg. For sensitive explosives such as primary
explosives, a small fallhammer is used.
- The usual fall heights are 0.1 – 1.5 m.
- The explosive samples (0.05 g for solid explosive) are sieved (0.9 mm sieve for granular
explosive) and pressed at 290 MPa between the steel cylinders.
- The inferior sensitivity (H0 – 4%), superior sensitivity (H96 – 100%), the impact sensitivity H50
and the frequency of explosions are determinate.
- 25 essays are conducted for every height.
d. Typical results:
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
3.1 The Kast method to determine the impact sensitivity of a small explosive samples.
A.T.M. Experimental Testing Proceeding.
RO-32
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
RO/201.01.002
a. Type of test: Safety/Impact. The test is used for Primary Explosive and Pyrotechnics -
Optional.
b. Description:
- A small sample of energetic granular material, 10 – 20 mg, is used for testing.
- The explosive sample is placed on a steel anvil and entirely covered by a metallic disc
(0.5 – 1 mm).
- It is then subjected to impact from a falling steel ball impacting on a striker with a
hemispherical end.
- The device (metallic disc, explosive sample, and the anvil) is placed under an
electromagnetic drop hammer.
- The method aims at establishing the sensitivity diagram, the height of 50 % explosions.
- 10 - 25 essays are conducted for every height.
c. Information Requirements for Assessment: The test is aims at determining the impact
sensitivity of Primary Explosives and represents the first step in assessment of the primer
compositions. The result is a safety characteristic.
d. Typical results:
- Primary Composition: 16 – 17 cm.
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
3.1 Method to determine the Ball and Disc Impact Sensitivity. A.T.M. Experimental
Testing Proceeding.
RO-33
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
RO/201.03.001
c. Information Requirements for Assessment: The test result is used to determining the
thermal behavior of energetic materials. The temperature of ignition is a safety and
quality characteristic. The test is also used to assessing the changes after an ageing
process.
d. Typical results:
0
- primary composition type F: 259 - 263 C;
0
- primary composition (based on Hg (ONC)2): 180 - 187 C;
- primary composition (based on Hg (ONC)2)
0 0
aged at 65 C for 8 days: 328 - 331 C
0
- double base ball powder type SB 511: 160 - 165 C;
0
e. Repeatability and Reproducibility: The temperature of ignition is determined with r 0.5 C
precision.
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
3.1 Method to determine the temperature of ignition. A.T.M. Experimental Testing
Proceeding.
3.2 STANAG 4491.
RO-34
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
RO/202.01.001
a. Type of test: Stability. The quantity of remaining stabilizer after ageing process is used as
a measure of chemical stability.
b. Description:
0
- The propellant samples are kept 60 or 120 days at 65.5 C temperature. Then the
quantity of remaining stabilizer is measured.
- 8 samples at 5 g are used for determinate the medium remaining stabilizer content.
- Each sample is placed in a hermetic glass tube (170 mm height and 27 mm diameter).
0
The tubes are placed in a heated device at 65.5 C.
- 4 tubes are taken out after 60 days and the rest after 120 days.
- When the brown gases appear, the test is stopped, and the propellant is considered
unstable.
- Spectrometry, chromatography or other analytical methods may measure the remaining
stabilizer contents.
c. Information Requirements for Assessment: The test is used for estimating the chemical
stability of the propellants.
d. Typical results:
- The propellant is considered stable, for 5 years, if the remaining stabilizer (after 60 days
aging) is 1 % at least or it represents more than 50 % from initial content. The minimum
value of stabilizer content must be 0.3 %.
- The propellant is considered stable, for 10 years:
- If the remaining stabilizer is 1 % at least or it represents more than 75 % from
initial content after 60 days; the minimum value of stabilizer content must be 0.7 %;
- If the remaining stabilizer is 1 % at least or it represents more than 50 % from
initial content after 120 days; the minimum value of stabilizer content must be 0.3%.
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
3.1 SMT-40584-2000. Triple base propellants. Method to determine the chemical stability
by aging.
3.2 STANAG 4117.
3.3 STP-M 40133-1995. Solid Propellants. Methods to prepare samples for physical and
chemical analysis.
RO-35
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
RO/202.02.001
b. Description:
0
- A standard mass of the propellant is heated in special apparatus at 106.5 r 0.5 C.
- The test has more methods: simple, repeated (10 x simple).
0
- The samples are prepared by cutting, sieving and drying at 95-100 C for 2 hours. The
propellant is not cut when its weight is under 1 g.
- Two 10 r0.1 g samples are placed into two hermetic glass tubes (23.5 mm inner
diameter and 79 mm height). In each tube is introduced a blue litmus indicator paper.
- The samples are maintained in the heating apparatus until the indicator paper changes
its color or brown gases appear.
c. Information Requirements for Assessment: The test is used for estimating the chemical
stability of the propellants.
d. Typical results: The test results are expressed in number of hours. For:
- simple method for single base propellant: Min 7 hours;
- repeated method:
- Min 50 hours for lamellar and porous propellant;
- Min 60 hours for other propellant.
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
3.1 STP-M 40294/1-1993. Solid propellants. Methods to determine the chemical stability
0
by blue litmus indicator paper at 106.5 C.
3.2 STP-M 40133-1995. Solid Propellants. Methods to prepare samples for physical and
chemical analysis.
RO-36
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
RO/202.02.002
b. Description:
0
- A standard mass of the propellant (2.5 r 0.002 g) is heated in special apparatus at 120 r 0.5 C
- 5 samples are putted into 5 glass tubes (15 mm inner diameter and 290 mm height). In
each tube are placed a methyl indicator paper (70x20mm).
- At each 5 minutes the sample are observed. When the indicator turns into pink, the test
is stopped and time is recorded.
c. Information Requirements for Assessment: The test is used for estimating the chemical
stability of the propellants. The test results are safety and quality characteristics.
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
3.1 STP-M 40238-1999. Triple base propellants. Method to determine the chemical
0
stability by heating at 393 r 0.5 K (120 C).
3.2 MIL-STD-286C, Method 404.1.2.
3.3 STP-M 40133-1995. Solid Propellants. Methods to prepare samples for physical and
chemical analysis.
RO-37
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
RO/202.02.003
b. Description:
- 10 r 0.0002 g are weighed and placed into spherical glass ball (49 mm inner diameter)
and than the ball is closed.
0
- The sample is heated in a special apparatus at 95 r 0.5 C.
- When 24 hours have passed, the ball with sample is weighed and the weight loss is
recorded.
- The weight loss is graphically represented as a function of time.
- The start of accelerate decomposition is represented by inflection point (the point where
0
the curve modifies its convexity). The sample is maintained 5 days more at 95 C after
the inflection point is reached.
- The constant of decomposition characterizes the velocity of uniform decomposition. The
loss of weight, in mg for 100 g propellant and 24 hours, is calculated with expression:
C a b
K100 1000
c d
Where: a - the loss of mass (%) till accelerate decomposition is reached;
b - the loss of mass (%) till uniform decomposition is reached;
c - the time (days) till accelerate decomposition is reached;
d - the time (days) until uniform decomposition is reached;
c. Information Requirements for Assessment: The test is used for estimating the chemical
stability of the propellants. The test results are safety and quality characteristics.
d. Typical results:
- For porous gun propellant: min. 8 days;
- For granular propellant: min 10 days.
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
3.1 STP-M 40294-1995. Single base propellants. Method to determine the chemical
stability by weight loss.
3.2 STP-M 40375/2-1992. Solid propellant. Physical and chemical requirements.
3.3 STP-M 40133-1995. Methods to prepare samples for physical and chemical analysis.
RO-38
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
RO/202.02.004
0
a. Type of test: Stability. Heating the sample, at 80 r 0.5 C, till iodine – starch indicator
paper change its color
b. Description:
- Four samples, 1.0 r 0.001 g each of them, are placed into an hermetic glass tube (15.5
inner diameter and 140 mm height) In each tube a iodine – starch indicator paper is
introduced too.
- The time passed until the indicator paper changes its color and is recorded.
- The test result is represented by the median value.
c. Information Requirements for Assessment: The test is used to estimating the chemical
stability of the propellants. The test results are safety and quality characteristics.
d. Typical results:
- TNT : min. 1 hour;
- PETN: min 1 hour;
- Nitroglycerin: min 0.5 hour.
.
e. Repeatability and Reproducibility: To be supplied.
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
3.1 Method to determinate the chemical stability of Explosives (Abel Method). A.T.M.
Experimental Testing Proceeding.
RO-39
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
RO/301.01.001
a. Type of test: Performance. The test determines the quantity of heat liberated in a closed
vessel.
b. Description:
- The energetic material is initiated in a vacuum stainless steel container. This container is
placed in an adiabatic water-bath calorimeter and heat of explosion of the sample is
determined from the temperature raise of the water-bath. Knowing the heat capacity of
the calorimeter the heat of explosion can be calculated.
- A standard mass is placed into the container.
- The test results represent the median value of two essays.
- The heat of explosion can be calculated with:
K 'T q am
Qv
Z
Where: K- heat capacity of apparatus;
'T - raise temperature;
qam - heat of initiation device;
Z- mass of the tested sample.
d. Typical results:
- primary composition type F: 460 kcal/kg;
- 4/7 T gr single base gun propellant: max. 875 kcal/kg;
- SB 511 double base gun propellant: 1290 kcal/kg;
- red flare pyrotechnic composition: min. 1600 kcal/kg.
e. Repeatability and Reproducibility: The difference between the individual results of the
heat of explosion must be lower than:
- 0.6 % for the explosive materials with Qvd1000 kcal/kg;
- 0.8 % for the explosive materials with metallic powder;
- 1.3 % for the rest of the Explosives, but not more than 47 kcal/kg.
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
3.1 STP-M 40319-1993. Solid propellants. Methods to determine the heat of explosion.
3.2 STP-M 40375/2-1992. Solid propellants. Physical and chemical requirements.
RO-40
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
RO/301.01.002
a. Type of test: Performance. The test determines the volume of gases products liberated
during the explosion.
b. Description:
- The gas products are introduced into a hermetic container and the raise of pressure is
measured. The specific volume can be calculated with:
W 0 'H 273.15
V 0sp
Z 760 273.15 t
Where: W0 - volume of the container;
'H - raise pressure;
Z - mass of tested sample;
t - ambient temperature.
d. Typical results:
- primary composition type F: 235 l/kg;
- SB 511 double base propellant: 812,5 l/kg;
- MS-2 pyrotechnics composition: 12 l/kg.
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
3.1 Method to determine the specific volume. A.T.M. Experimental Testing Proceeding.
RO-41
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
RO/302.01.001
a. Type of test: Performance. The test determines the detonation velocity within the
explosive.
b. Description:
- The time that has slipped away between two points at known distance is measured and
the velocity is calculated.
- At least two measurement sensors are placed on the explosive charge.
- The final value of the test represents a medium of two essays.
c. Information Requirements for Assessment: The test results are a quality characteristic.
d. Typical results:
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
3.1 Method to determine the detonation velocity. A.T.M. Experimental Testing
Proceeding.
RO-42
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
10.7.8 QUALIFICATION PROCEDURES OF THE NETHERLANDS
PARAGRAPH PAGE
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NL-1
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NL-2
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
10.7.8.1 MILITARY DEPARTMENTS RESPONSIBLE FOR QUALIFICATION
10.7.8.1.1 The Netherlands does not qualify new military explosives since no new military explosives
are developed in this country.
10.7.8.1.2 The Netherlands procures explosives from foreign producers as part of a complete
munition or weapon system design or bulk explosives for production or rework of
ammunition.
10.7.8.1.3 The approval of explosives, in the Netherlands, is done as part of the approval of the
specifications of the complete ammunition or weapon system as procured from either
Netherlands or foreign contractors by the involved Materiel Command after consulting the
1
Militaire Commissie Gevaarlijke Stoffen , MCGS.
10.7.8.2.1 The following authorities within the Netherlands Defense Organization are responsible for
approving the specifications for explosives contained in munitions:
10.7.8.3.1 It is required that the explosives are qualified before taken into service, the qualification is
part of the final classification. The properties of the explosive should be identified by TNO
Prins Maurits Laboratory (TNO-PML), either by assessing the data provided by the
manufacturer or by performing an (additional) experimental test program. This results in a
qualification report and draft specifications for the explosive substance.
1
Military Committee for Dangerous Substances.
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NL-3
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
10.7.8.4 QUALIFICATION METHODS AND TESTS
10.7.8.4.1 The basis for the approval of new explosives is the specifications with related
test-methods and requirements given in NATO STANAGs used for approval in other
NATO countries. Specific Netherlands test methods for explosives do not exist.
Consequently, Test Information Sheets are not relevant. The tests which the Netherlands
authorities consider mandatory for assessing the safety of an explosive material are listed
below.
10.7.8.4.2 The activities required for setting up and implementing a qualification program are:
The qualification of an explosive substance for military use is recorded by the chairman of
the MCGS in a qualification document.
a. Mandatory Data
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NL-4
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(2nd Edition)
10.7.12 QUALIFICATION PROCEDURES OF THE SLOVAK REPUBLIC
PARAGRAPH PAGE
SK-1
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(2nd Edition
SK-2
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(2nd Edition)
10.7.12.1 MILITARY DEPARTMENTS RESPONSIBLE FOR QUALIFICATION
10.12.1.1 Military Technical and Testing Institute Zahorie (Vojensky Technicky a Skusobny Ustav
Zahorie - VTSU) has full responsibility for qualification of military explosives.
Military Technical and Testing Institute Zahorie (Vojensky Technicky a Skusobny Ustav
Zahorie – VTSU) is the appointed National Authority for the Slovak Republic and is
responsible for the following functions in accordance with STANAG 4170:
h. Acting as a Point of Contact within the Slovak Republic for inputs to AOP-7
SK-3
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(2nd Edition
10.7.12.3 QUALIFICATION PROCEDURES
10.7.12.3.1 The Slovak Republic is in the beginning of the implementation process of STANAG 4170
into its testing practice. Thus, the information contained in this section should be
considered as preliminary and can be a subject of the change. The basis for the Slovak
assessment for the qualification of an explosive composition is laid down in the Slovak
Technical Standards. There are plenty of differences between Slovak Technical
Standards and STANAGs for military explosives. The Slovak National Standards will be
changed in the future and to this time the basis for the Slovak assessment for the
qualification of an explosive composition will be laid down in test methods and
procedures. These procedures are in preparation. They will be in line with requirements
of STANAG 4170 and the STANAGs for explosives testing quoted in STANAG 4170.
10.7.12.3.2 In the Slovak Republic, the research and the development of new military explosives
intended for military use are mainly carried out by private firms - e.g. Chemko a.s.,
Strazske (high explosives ), Konstrukta – Defence, a.s., Trencin (pyrotechnics), Zavody
Vseobecneho strojarenstva, a.s., Dubnica nad Vahom (high explosives, pyrotechnics) .
Additionally, research may also be carried out in certain state institutes sponsored by the
Slovak MOD (e.g. Military Technical and Testing Institute, Zahorie).
10.7.12.3.3 In general, the research and the development of new military explosives are carried out
under contracts awarded by Slovak Ministry of Defence, or Slovak Ministry of Economy.
However, they may also result from a private firm’s initiative. Import of military explosives
or munitions with military explosives not qualified according to STANAG 4170 can be
another source of new military explosives for qualification. In this context a new explosive
is an explosive which has not yet been qualified, whose composition, nature or
manufacturing procedure has been changed, or which is intended for a role for which it
has not been qualified. Existing military explosives may be regarded as being qualified by
sufficient long experience representative for its expected life cycle and intended use.
10.7.12.3.4 Written requests for qualification of a new explosive are to be submitted to the National
Authority. Requests may be submitted by the military services (Army, Air Force),
developers, manufacturers or importers.
10.7.12.3.5 Before the beginning of the qualification procedure, an applicant requesting the
assessment of the developed explosive must identify some basic characteristics of the
explosive, according to Table 1 to STANAG 4170 and must present results of tests
obtained in the development project. The information is evaluated by the National
Authority and can be returned for revision if they are unsatisfactory or incomplete. The
producer of the new military explosive has to prove the military explosive can be
manufactured and processed in a full production scale and the required quality levels can
be met consistently. The National Authority can refuse further qualification testing if it is
clear from the preliminary results that the new explosive will not satisfy general
requirements for safety and suitability in the intended role.
10.7.12.3.6 In case of positive results of the preliminary assessment, the National Authority prepares
a list of tests for qualification of the explosive. The tests listed in STANAG 4170 are
always taken as mandatory for this purpose, the national tests listed in AOP-7 are usually
taken as optional (except those referred by STANAG 4170 to AOP-7, such as electric
spark test, detonation velocity and critical diameter test). Other tests not included in
STANAG 4170 or AOP-7, but which are suitable to obtain the required information, may
also be used. The results of optional tests can be taken from the development project of a
new explosive.
10.7.12.3.7 The National Authority is responsible for conducting of the qualification tests and the
subsequent assessment of the new explosives regarding its safety and basic suitability for
SK-4
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(2nd Edition)
military purposes. If any particular test cannot be conducted by the facilities of the National
Authority, the National Authority will delegate other testing laboratory for conducting the
test. The qualification procedure does not include the assessment of the explosive in a
particular ammunition system (final or type qualification) or legal provisions for storage
and transportation.
10.7.12.3.8 The results of the qualification tests, together with other observations and
recommendations are considered by committee of specialists of the National Authority,
other Slovak military technical institutes, General Staff and Ministry of Defence. The
results are evaluated in relation to the results of the same tests carried out on materials of
a similar type and role which have proven history of safety and satisfactory use in service.
After completion of the investigation, the National Authority prepares a qualification report
in accordance with STANAG 4170 and the resulting qualification status: (a) qualified, (b)
not qualified, (c) qualified with certain restrictions.
10.7.12.3.9 If the National Authority determines that a new explosive is suitable for military use, an
organization developing, manufacturing or importing the explosive will prepare a technical
specification for this qualified explosive. The technical specification stipulate
characteristics of the explosives such as composition, nature, manufacturing process,
type and source of raw materials and use, as far as these ensure reproducible
manufacture and delivery. The technical requirements for the explosive, the testing
methods, provisions on quality assurance, packaging, storage and transportation
conditions are also reflected in this document.
10.7.12.3.10 After the technical specification for explosive has been written, it is to be sent for
comments by organizations participating on production, processing or use of the
explosive. The final version of this document is ratified by all the organizations (a
developer, a manufacturer, a processing company, military authority representatives to
these companies, the National Authority, end user etc.).
10.7.12.3.11 In case of ammunition system developments requiring the new explosives, these
explosives must be qualified before the system design is finalized. The introduction of the
explosive for a particular role before conclusion of the qualification procedure and before
completion of the technical specification is prohibited in general.
SK-5
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(2nd Edition
10.7.12.4 QUALIFICATION METHODS AND TESTS
a. Mandatory Tests
10.7.12.4.2 List of Tests for Booster and Main Charge High Explosives:
a. Mandatory Tests
SK-6
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(2nd Edition)
(21) Stress relaxation test in tension (only for PBX) STANAG 4507
(22) Thermomechanical analysis STANAG 4525
(23) Dynamic mechanical analysis (only for PBX) STANAG 4540
a. Mandatory Tests
SK-7
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(2nd Edition
b. Optional Tests for Solid gun propellants
a. Mandatory Tests
SK-8
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(2nd Edition)
b. Optional Tests for Solid rocket propellants:
a. The tests required for liquid propellants are listed in Chapter 7 of this document.
a. Mandatory Tests
10.7.12.4.7 Remarks :
* two compatibility tests are usually chosen from the lists
+
selection of a suitable chemical stability test depends on composition of
a propellant under test
#
applicability of the test depends on a resolution of the national authority
SK-9
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(2nd Edition
10.7.12.5 Aging Characterization
10.7.12.5.2 Determination of change in properties of a new explosive before and after the artificial
aging is done by the following methods, in general:
SK-10
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(2nd Edition)
10.7.12.6 LIST OF TEST INFORMATION SHEETS
201.02.XXX Friction
201.02.001 Small BAM Friction Sensitivity
Test
SK-11
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(2nd Edition
10.7.12.7 CATALOGUE OF TEST INFORMATION SHEETS
NOTE: The Test Information Sheets are listed consecutively in accordance with the
Registry Number.
SK-12
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(2nd Edition)
SK/102.01.071
b. Description: The density is calculated as a quotient of mass and volume of a sample. The
mass is measured with an analytical balance (resolution 0.0001 g) and the volume is
o
measured with a pycnometer by a liquid displacement method at 20 C. Liquid that does
not dissolve the sample is used as a medium for the pycnometric measurements (e.g.
water for high explosives, parafinic oil for propellants and pyrotechnics). A solid sample is
used in a form of small pieces that will pass through the pycnometer neck, with smooth
surfaces free from crevices and dust.
c. Information Requirements for Assessment: This test is used for material characterization
and quality control before some qualification tests.
d. Typical Results:
-3
Cast TNT loading density: 1.58 g.cm
-3
Good (± 0.005 g.cm )
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
SK-13
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(2nd Edition
SK/201.02.001
b. Description: The sensitivity of primary explosives and very sensitive pyrotechnics is tested
by means of the scale-down version of BAM friction test apparatus (according to Annex A
to STANAG 4487). The applied friction load ranges from 0.1 N to 18 N. Sensitivity of an
explosive is usually expressed as a down level (the maximum load giving 0 ignitions of 6
trials) and an up level (the minimum load giving 6 ignitions of 6 trials).
c. Information Requirements for Assessment: This test is used to determine the sensitivity of
primary explosives and sensitive pyrotechnics at very low loads that can produce errors in
results using the standard type BAM friction test apparatus.
d. Typical Results: Results are quoted as minimum loads for obtaining 6 ignitions or
explosions of 6 trials (up level)
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
(1) ON 66 8095
SK-14
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(2nd Edition)
SK/201.03.001
1. TYPE OF EXPLOSIVE: Primary, Booster, Main Charge High Explosives, Propellants, and
Pyrotechnics
d. Typical Results:
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES
(1) TP-VD-1080-(01)-00-ZH
SK-15
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(2nd Edition
SK /201.04.001
b. Description: A flat shock wave from a conical donor charge of cast TNT (density 1.58
-3
g.cm , diameter of the bottom of the charge 68 mm) with coating layer of PETN/TNT
50/50 and a small booster charge of PETN/wax 90/10 is attenuated by layers of PMMA
discs (diameter of 68 mm). The occurrence of detonation of the acceptor charge in a steel
tube (internal diameter of 60 mm, thickness of 5 mm, length of 200 mm) is assessed by
the degree of damage to a steel witness plate under a 3 mm air gap. Thickness of the
attenuator giving a 50% probability of detonation is determined by a simplified Bruceton
method.
c. Information Requirements for Assessment: This test determines the sensitivity to shock
initiation of explosives that will propagate detonation in confined charges with diameters of
60 mm
d. Typical Results:
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES
(1) TP-VD-1080-(02)-00-ZH
SK-16
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(2nd Edition)
SK/201.08.001
a. Type of Test: Safety/Critical Diameter - Used for Booster and Main Charge High
Explosives, Propellants and Pyrotechnics
b. Description: The explosive under test, contained in a 100 cm steel tube with a selected
internal diameter and wall thickness of 10 % of internal diameter, is subjected to an
explosive shock known to be sufficient to initiate detonation (using detonator or a plastic
explosive booster) and the remains of the tube are examined to determine whether the
detonation has propagated through the whole length of the charge. If detonation
propagates, internal diameter of the next steel tube is reduced to its half. If detonation
fails, internal diameter of the next steel tube is doubled. Using this procedure, critical
diameter of the explosive at given loading density is determined as a minimum diameter
of the tube at which complete detonation occurs.
c. Information Requirements for Assessment: This test determines the critical diameter of an
explosive for sustaining a detonation through a long confined explosive charge.
d. Typical Results:
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES
(1) TP-VD-1080-(03)-00-ZH
SK-17
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(2nd Edition
SK /201.08.002
b. Description: The explosive under test is contained in a steel tube (inside diameter of 32
mm, thickness of 3 mm, length of 500 mm), which is closed at one end by a welded steel
disc 3 mm thick. Initiation occurs by means of electric squib at the open end of the tube.
The lengths of deflagration and detonation zones are determined by means of a
mechanical sensor that is made of 3.15 mm thick steel wire wrapped with 0.6 mm thick
copper wire. The mechanical sensor is located inside the tube along all its length. After
explosion, the mechanical sensor is collected. The first cut of the copper wire into the
steel wire corresponds the transition point from deflagration to detonation.
d. Typical Results:
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES
(1) TP-VD-1080-(04)-00-ZH
SK-18
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(2nd Edition)
SK/ 202.01.001
a. Type of Test: Stability/Thermal - Used for Gun Propellants and Double Based Rocket
Propellants
b. Description: 10g samples of propellants, enclosed in standardised glass test tubes, are
o
heated at 100 C in a heating block. The number of days required to cause clearly visible
yellow or red fumes of nitrogen oxides is recorded.
c. Information Requirements for Assessment: This test determines the stability level of the
single and double based propellants
d. Typical Results:
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES
SK-19
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(2nd Edition
SKZ/202.01.002
a. Type of Test: Stability/Thermal - Used for Gun Propellants and Double Based Rocket
Propellants.
c. Information Requirements for Assessment: This test determines the stability level of the
propellants.
d. Typical Results:
3 -1 o
(1) Nitroglycerine propellants: 6-16 cm .g .20hours (115 C)
3 -1 o
(2) Single based propellants: 10-25 cm .g .20hours (125 C)
3 -1
e. Repeatability and Reproducibility: Within 0.2 cm ml.g .20hours for propellants.
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES
SK-20
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(2nd Edition)
SK/202.01.003
1. TYPE OF EXPLOSIVE: Primary, Booster, Main Charge High Explosives, Propellants, and
Pyrotechnics
b. Description: Commercially available DTA equipment with reinforced design is utilised. The
apparatus is capable to withstand explosion of up to 50 mg of primary explosives. Sample
weight of 50-500 mg of non-primary explosives can be used. In this apparatus,
endothermic and exothermic changes of the sample in a small glass test tube are
o -1
observed and recorded during heating at a constant rate (usually 5-20 C.min ) under air
atmosphere. The apparatus is very suitable for measurement of highly heterogeneous
samples (esp. pyrotechnics) that can produce unrepeatable results with low sample
weights. The equipment is also suitable for preliminary assessment of thermal reactivity of
an unknown explosive before measurement at more sensitive apparatuses.
c. Information Requirements for Assessment: This test determines the thermal stability of an
explosive - start, onset and peak of exothermal decomposition
o -1
d. Typical Results (peaks of decomposition at 50 mg sample weight and 5 C.min heating
rate):
o
(1) TNT: 295 C
o
(2) RDX: 220 C
o
(3) PETN: 190 C
o
(4) Double Based Propellants: 165-170 C
o
(5) Black Powder: 320 C
o
e. Repeatability and Reproducibility: r 2 C of peak temperatures
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES
(1) TP-VD-1080-(05)-00-ZH
SK-21
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(2nd Edition
SK/302.01.001
a. Type of Test: Performance/Experimental - Used for Booster and Main Charge High
Explosives.
b. Description: Two measurement probes (insulated copper foils or wires wrapped round or
pressed to each other) are inserted into the explosive charge of the selected diameter,
length and confinement. The explosive charge is initiated by means of a detonator or a
booster charge and the two probes are short-circuited by the passing detonation wave that
removes insulation from the probes. The time between the two generated pulses is
determined by an electronic counter. Knowing the distance between the two probes, the
average detonation velocity is determined.
c. Information Requirements for Assessment: This test determines the detonation velocity of
an explosive charge - one of important performance parameters
d. Typical Results:
-3 -1
(1) TNT (pressed 1.62 g.cm ): 6800 m.s
-3 -1
(2) RDX/wax 95/5 (Pressed 1.62 g.cm ): 8150 m.s
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES
SK-22
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(2nd Edition)
SK/302.02.001
b. Description: The basic ballistic properties of a propellant are determined in a closed high-
3
pressure combustion chamber of constant volume (5-200 cm ). The propellant charge is
ignited by a small black powder charge. Loading density of a propellant in the bomb
-3
should be 0.19-0.22 g.cm . The pressure rise is measured by a piezoelectric pressure
transducer, with computer evaluation of the pressure-time curve. The force, covolume,
quickness, vivacity, form and other ballistic parameters of the propellant are calculated
from the curve.
c. Information Requirements for Assessment: The results of the test are used for a ballistic
assessment of the test propellant
d. Typical Results:
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES
(1) TP-VD-1080-(06)-00-ZH
SK-23
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(2nd Edition
SK/302.03.001
a. Type of Test: Performance/Brisance - Used for Booster and Main Charge High Explosives
c. Information Requirements for Assessment: The value of the lead cylinder compression
corresponds to a brisance of the explosive.
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES
SK-24
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(2nd Edition)
SK/302.03.002
a. Type of Test: Performance/Explosive power - Used for Booster and Main Charge High
Explosives
b. Description: 10 g explosive charge is detonated in a heavy (300 kg) steel mortar, damped
with a steel projectile (15 kg). The mortar is attached to a pendulum bar and suspended
on knife edges. After explosion of the charge, resulting degree of swing is compared to
that produced on detonation of a specific amount of TNT. The result is expressed as
percentage of TNT.
d. Typical Results:
(1) RDX/TNT 75/25: 144% TNT
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES
SK-25
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(2nd Edition
SK/302.03.003
a. Type of Test: Performance/Explosives - Used for Booster and Main Charge High
Explosives
b. Description: 10 g sample is placed into a tube of diameter 25 mm made of tin sheet and a
standard detonator is inserted. The charge is then put into a hole in a lead block of
diameter and length 200 mm. Volume produced by the explosion of the charge is
measured.
d. Typical Results:
3
(1) TNT (powder): 300 cm (100% TNT)
3
(2) RDX/Al/wax 76/20/4: 471 cm (157% TNT)
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES
SK-26
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(2nd Edition)
SK/302.03.004
d. Typical Results:
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES
(1) TP-VD-1080-(07)-00-ZH
SK-27
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(2nd Edition
SK-28
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
To be provided
SW-1
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP/ UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
PARAGRAPH PAGE
b. PROPELLANTS CH-7
c. PYROTECHNICS CH-8
CH-1
NATO/ PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
CH-2
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP/ UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
10.7.14.1.1 Switzerland, as a Partnership for Peace, PfP, nation has taken the decision to make an
input in the national part of AOP-7 in view to declare its qualification tests and procedures
for explosives intended to be used in military applications. In case of STANAG
incompatible generation of data for qualification of explosives, a harmonisation between
Swiss tests and procedures and corresponding STANAG test requirements shall be
established as a long term objective.
10.7.14.1.2 As Switzerland does not join NATO’s MAP (Member Action Plan), a ratification of
STANAGs is not foreseen in near future. So a reference to a STANAG within the Swiss
national part of AOP-7 does not imply the acceptance of this STANAG without any
restrictions. Thus, such references are made in sense of pure literature references.
10.7.14.1.3 In view of a further development of tests and procedures for qualification of explosives to
future needs and requirements, as also to harmonize tests and procedures in direction of
corresponding STANAGs, Swiss authorities keep the right to adapt those according to the
given situation.
10.7.14.2.1 Swiss Defence Procurement Agency (DPA), and therein the "Weapon Systems and
Ammunition Test Center" (FA26), hereafter called "Test Center FA26", has full respon-
sibility for qualification of explosives for military applications.
10.7.14.3.1 The Test Center FA26 is the appointed Swiss National Authority for the qualification of
explosives for military purposes and is responsible for the following functions:
a. Defining the tests necessary to obtain evidence for the assessment of explosive
materials used by Swiss Army and Airforce, and the requirements applied for the
qualification of these materials.
b. Receiving from agencies within Switzerland, or from other nations the test data
for qualifying explosive materials, and assessing whether the material is safe and
suitable for consideration for use by the Services in a particular role or appli-
cation.
c. Publishing the test data and assessment which enables qualification, with or
without limitations.
f. Providing a Swiss Point of Contact to other countries for the exchange of infor-
mation, as appropriate, on the safety of explosives.
CH-3
NATO/ PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
(NOTE: Transportation hazard classifications are the responsibility of the Federal
Inspectorate of Dangerous Goods (EGI) which is located at Überlandstrasse 129, CH-
8600 Dübendorf)
10.7.14.4.1 In Switzerland research into explosives (of all types) for Army and Air Force is carried out
in governmental test centers or full or partially government owned private companies,
such as
10.7.14.4.2 Additionally, research may also be carried out in private industry, universities and further
governmental agencies under contract by Defence Procurement Agency (DPA).
10.7.14.4.4 The Test Center FA26 is a professionally independent, advisory body. It is normally
tasked by, and its advice addressed to, the appropriate System Manager of Defence
Procurement Agency (DPA).
10.7.14.4.5 The primary purposes of the Test Center FA 26 in view of explosives qualification are:
a. To provide impartial appraisal of the Safety, and advice on the suitability for
service, of those parts of weapon systems and stores within its field of
operations in which explosives are used. In this context, the term "suitability for
service" means that the explosive and associated elements of a weapon system
or store are capable of functioning technically as designed, and that neither this
functioning, nor safety, will be unacceptably degraded by the service
environment through the agreed service life. It does not embrace operational
effectiveness or reliability.
10.7.14.4.6 During the evaluation phase of the munition procurement process the System Manager
has formally to inform the Test Center FA26 about the timetable in which the assessment
and qualification of explosive materials has to be considered (paragraph 10.7.14.4.7) and,
if appropriate, conducted.
10.7.14.4.7 In a first analysis, all energetic materials involved in a certain system are considered by
corresponding specialists to determine whether these are new to service, or known
materials being used in a novel role.
10.7.14.4.8 All energetic materials either being new to service or being used in a novel role become
subject of assessment and qualification, for their safety and suitability for consideration
for use in service. STANAG 4170 will be used as a guideline for this process.
CH-4
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP/ UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
10.7.14.4.9 In certain circumstances, the Test Center FA26 may accept tasks from governmental
organisations or even private companies as specified in paragraph 10.7.14.4.1 for the
assessment and qualification of a new explosive material before it has been selected for
use by an ammunition project.
10.7.14.5.1 The basis for the Swiss assessment for the qualification of an explosive are the
requirements of STANAG 4170, whereas restrictions and additional claims are in
responsibility of Test Center FA26. It sets out the information required for assessment,
with general guidance on the suitable tests for the various types of explosives.
10.7.14.5.2 Selection of Tests. The selection of the specific tests to obtain data is a matter of
agreement between all organisations involved in the procurement and munition
surveillance process. If a qualification process is initiated outside the procurement
process (paragraph 10.7.14.4.9) the selection of tests is made to cover as far as possible
the requirements of STANAG 4170. In both cases consideration is given to type of
material, to its intended role and to the need to carry out tests at extremes of temperature
and on aged material.
10.7.14.5.3 For all materials, information is required to provide answers to Questions 1 to 8 of Table 1
in STANAG 4170.
10.7.14.5.4 Conduct of Tests. Once the test requirements for assessment and qualification have been
fixed by the relevant organisations, they are carried out in one or more test laboratories
as declared in paragraph 10.7.14.4.1 and 10.7.14.4.2.
10.7.14.5.5 Assessment. The results are considered in relation to the results of the same tests carried
out on materials of a similar type and role which have a proven history of safety and
satisfactory use in service.
10.7.14.5.6 Qualification. The test results, together with the discussion of the assessment, are
presented in a report, in which in case of positive overall conclusions is recommend that
the material is safe and suitable for consideration for use, with limitations if necessary.
10.7.14.5.7 Use in Service. Based on the recommendations and restrictions of the explosives qua-
lification report and the final munition evaluation test report, the system manager is
responsible for the use of the corresponding explosive materials to be introduced into
service.
CH-5
NATO/ PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
10.7.14.5.8 High Explosives
CH-6
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP/ UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
10.7.14.5.9 PROPELLANTS
CH-7
NATO/ PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
(12) Electrostatic Discharge Test 201.03.001
(13) EIDS Bullet Impact Test 201.05.001
(14) High Velocity Fragment Impact Test 201.06.001
(15) 50mm Shaped Charge Impact Test 201.07.001
(16) Steel Tube Test (KOENEN) 202.01.001
(17) Temperature of Ignition Test 202.01.002
(18) Heat Flow Calorimetry Test (Stability) 202.01.005
(19) Vacuum Stability Test (Stability) 202.01.006
(20) DSC/TG 202.01.007
(21) HPLC for Stabiliser Depletion not Covered by
STANAG 4117, 4541 and 4542 202.01.008
(22) HPLC for Stabiliser Depletion Covered by
STANAG 4117, 4541 and 4542 202.01.009
(23) Tube Test (FCO & SCO) 202.01.010
(24) Heat Flow Calorimetry Test (Compatibility) 203.01.001
(25) Vacuum Stability Test (Compatibility) 203.01.002
(26) Plasticiser Migration Evaluation 203.02.001
(27) Heat of Combustion Test 302.03.001
10.7.14.5.10 PYROTECHNICS
CH-8
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP/ UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
101.01.XXX Chemical
201.01.XXX Sensitiveness/Sensitivity/
Explosiveness Tests
202.01.XXX Thermal
202.01.001 Steel Tube (KOENEN)
202.01.002 Temperature of Ignition
CH-9
NATO/ PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
202.01.003 Weight Loss at 90 °C
202.01.004 Bergmann-Junk-Siebert
202.01.005 Heat Flow Calorimetry
202.01.06 Vacuum Stabilityt
202.01.07 202.01.007 DSC/TG
202.01.008 HPLC for Stabiliser Depletion
not Covered by STANAG 4117,
4541 and 4542
202.01.009 HPLC for Stabiliser Depletion
Covered by STANAG 4117,
4541 and 4542
202.01.010 Tube Test (FCO & SCO)
CH-10
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP/ UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
NOTE: The Test Information Sheets are listed consecutively in accordance with the
Registry Number.
CH-11
NATO/ PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
CH/101.01.001
TEST INFORMATION SHEET
2. TEST TITLE: HPLC for Energetic Material used in High Explosives not Ruled in Corresponding
STANAGs
b. Description: A state of the art High Performance Liquid Chromatographic system, inclu-
ding a suitable UV detector and a gradient solvent system is needed. The explosive is
dissolved in acetone or in an other convenient solvent. The solution is then injected and
the sample components are separated with the aid of a reversed phase column. An
optimised liquid phase mixture which allows base line separation of the component peaks
has to be used. For a mixture containing RDX, HMX, TNT, Tetryl and PETN a C-18
reverse phase column as a stationary phase and an eluent mixture of about 65% acetoni-
trile and 35% water is recommended. All eluents need to have HPLC quality (Purity:
99.5% or better). A detector wave length of 220 nm is used. If a diode array detector is
available, an optimised wave length for each individual component can be used too. The
components of a sample are identified by their eluation time. The run time of the
mentioned explosives should be less than ten minutes. For the acquisition of quantitative
information the chromatographic peak areas have to be related to their corresponding
concentrations by following a sample concentration screening. Thereby the wave length
of detection has to be fixed for each component. Based on this calibration function and
the detected peak area for a certain component the corresponding concentration can be
calculated.
c. Information Requirements for Assessment: The test results are used for the
characterisation of energetic materials or as a verification of product specifications.
d. Typical Results: Depends on explosive under investigation. The method works for
explosive compositions containing 0.01% to nearly 100% of energetic material.
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
CH-12
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP/ UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
CH/101.01.002
TEST INFORMATION SHEET
b. Description:
c. Information Requirements for Assessment: The test results are used to confirm that the
composition of the propellant matches the declaration of the manufacturer, or that the
composition lies within the limits given in the product performance description.
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
CH-13
NATO/ PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
CH/101.01.003
TEST INFORMATION SHEET
c. Information Requirements for Assessment: The test results are used to confirm that the
pyrotechnic composition matches the declaration of the manufacturer, or that the
composition lies within the limits given in the product performance description.
d. Typical Results: Depends on the pyrotechnic composition under investigation, e.g.: 20%
(w/w) Boron, 79% (w/w) Potassium Nitrate, 1% (w/w) Nitrocellulose.
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
CH-14
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP/ UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
CH/102.01.001
TEST INFORMATION SHEET
1. TYPE OF EXPLOSIVE: Solid Rocket Propellants /Main Charge High Explosives (PBX)
b. Description: JANNAF (if geometry allows) or otherwise specified samples are cast or
machined from bulk. After conditioning, these samples are subjected to a defined load.
Force, elongation and time are recorded. Parameters as Temperature, dimension of the
sample and crosshead speed are influencing the results and have therefore to be
specified too.
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
CH-15
NATO/ PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
CH/102.01.002
TEST INFORMATION SHEET
b. Description: The test is limited to case bonded rocket motors only. In this test, tapped
solid specimen (12 mm x 25 mm x 25 mm) consisting of Propellant, Liner and Case are
put under mechanical load. Specimen are pulled in tension at low rate of strain until
failure. Bond Tensile Strength and Time to max. Stress are recorded. The Type of Failure
is described. Parameters such as specimen dimension, crosshead speed, temperature
and applied load will affect the results and have therefore to be specified.
c. Information Requirements for Assessment: Bond failure either between propellant and
liner or liner and case influences performance and functionality of a rocket motor. This
test is used to assess the state of the interfaces propellant/liner/case.
d. Typical Results: Cured polybutadiene propellant motors (HTPB/AP, HTPB, steel) show at
room temperature and a crosshead speed of 12.7 mm/min the following, typical values:
2
(1) - Bond Tensile Strength:0.85 N/mm
(2) - Time to max. Stress: 0.09 minutes
(3) - Failure Pattern: Propellant on Liner, clean Separation of Case
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
CH-16
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP/ UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
CH/102.01.010
TEST INFORMATION SHEET
c. Information Requirements for Assessment: The test is used to assess the mechanical
behaviour of explosive pellets when exposed to compression. These parameters show a
correlation to sensitivity data of corresponding charges.
d. Typical Results: A wide range of compression moduli and breaking pressures may be
measured for high explosives and propellants, depending on composition and
application.
Dimension: 21x15mm
Conditions: Deformation rate 0.005mm/s, ambient temperature
e. Repeatability and Reproducibility: Assuming that the test samples are homogeneous, the
breaking pressure should be within 1.0 MPa.
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
CH-17
NATO/ PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
CH/102.01.020
TEST INFORMATION SHEET
b. Description: Solid specimens are either machined from bulk or cast. A typical
specimen is a rectangular bar of 10 mm x 6mm x 50 mm. Conditioned specimens are
cooled down and then heated up continuously (5K/min). The changes in length and
temperature are recorded. Changing of heating rate, mechanical load frequency and
specimen dimensions will affect the results. These parameters have to be specified.
c. Information Requirements for Assessment: The test is used to determine the Glass
Transition Temperature (Tg) of polymer based propellants and main charge explosives
(PBX). The glass transition point defines the lower temperature limit for the application of
polymer based explosives and solid rocket propellants. If this temperature changes after
storage or artificial ageing, a change in the behaviour of the explosive has to be expec-
ted. Life time predictions can be made by monitoring the changes of Tg during artificial
ageing of the samples.
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
CH-18
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP/ UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
CH/102.01.021
TEST INFORMATION SHEET
b. Description: Specimen are cast or machined from bulk. Typical dimension of these solid
specimen are 10 mm in length and 10 mm in diameter. After conditioning the samples are
cooled down and then heated up continuously. A typical heating rate is 5K/min. A purging
gas, e.g. Helium, with a flow rate of 20ml/min is used. Specimen dimension and heating
rate are affecting the results. These parameters have to be specified.
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
CH-19
NATO/ PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
CH/102.01.050
TEST INFORMATION SHEET
1. TYPE OF EXPLOSIVE: Main Charge High Explosives (PBX)/Solid Gun Propellants/Solid Rocket
Propellants
c. Information Requirements for Assessment: The test is used to characterise the low
temperature behaviour of polymeric based propellants and main charge explosives
(PBX). Glass Transition Temperature (Tg) is measured. Also the heat capacity (cp) can be
extracted in a certain temperature range. The test allows further the assessment of
physical ageing and chemical degradation of polymers. The glass transition point defines
the lower temperature limit for the application of polymer based explosives.
4. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
CH-20
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP/ UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
CH/102.01.070
TEST INFORMATION SHEET
c. Information Requirements for Assessment: The test result is used for characterisation
and quality assurance. Reduced density values may indicate defects / inclusions such as
voids and fissures or insufficient gelatination of the nitrocellulose in the propellant.
d. Typical Results:
3
(1) 1.5 – 1.8 g/cm for single/double/triple base propellants.
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
CH-21
NATO/ PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
CH/102.01.071
TEST INFORMATION SHEET
c. Information Requirements for Assessment: The test result is used for characterisation of
explosives and quality assurance of charge manufacturing processes. Reduced density
values may indicate defects/inclusions such as voids and fissures.
c. Typical Results:
3
(1) Hextro 60/40 cast cylinder 1.709 g/cm
3
(2) LX-14 isopressed shaped charge 1.820 g/cm
3
(3) LX-19 isopressed shaped charge 1.926 g/cm
d. Repeatability and Reproducibility: Depends very much on the size of the sample and the
method used to determine the density. The accuracy of the density should be within
3
r0.003 g/cm
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
CH-22
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP/ UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
CH/102.01.072
TEST INFORMATION SHEET
b. Description: The test is only applicable to grain explosives. The dimensions of the
apparatus have to be specified since the result of the test may depend on vessel
dimension and filling height. In case of propellant testing, a cylindrical vessel having a
volume of 1 liter is used; adequate volumes for high explosives and pyrotechnics have to
be chosen.The sample is filled into a funnel which lower opening is closed by a slide
valve. After opening of the slide valve, the sample trickles into a cylindrical vessel. The
surplus explosive is removed by carefully scrapping off along the upper edge of the ves-
sel. The explosive’s gravimetric density is calculated as mass of explosive present in the
vessel divided by the volume of the vessel.
c. Information Requirements for Assessment:The test result is used for quality assurance.
Reduction in bulk density means that less explosive can be filled into the ammunition
cartridge or into a explosive pressing mould. Reduced bulk densities indicate changes in
the granulation process.
d. Typical Results:
3
(1) Single/double base granular propellants: 950 - 1100 g/dm
3
(2) LX-14: 880 g/dm
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
CH-23
NATO/ PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
CH/102.01.073
TEST INFORMATION SHEET
1. TYPE OF EXPLOSIVE: Main Charge High Explosives/Solid Gun Propellants/Solid Rocket Pro-
pellants
b. Description: Large propellants are ground or cut into pieces of maximum size 20 mm x
20 mm x 3 mm. Air of defined humidity can be produced (i) through moistening an air
stream by bubbling it through water, followed by dilution with dry air, or (ii) by putting a
bowl containing a saturated salt solution into a desiccator. Temperature has to be kept
constant as the humidity level obtained does strongly depend on temperature. Humidity
levels between 45% and 85% (Swiss method), and between 22% and 86% (German
method) should be chosen.
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
CH-24
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP/ UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
CH/102.01.080
TEST INFORMATION SHEET
For the determination of web-sizes of one- and multi perforated propellants, cutting of the
grains before measurements is sometimes necessary. Alternatively, a system consisting
of a video camera, combined with optical image analysis, can be used for the
assessment of grain geometry. Because of the inhomogeneity of extruded propellants, at
least 20 to 30 different grains have to be measured in order to achieve reliable results.
c. Information Requirements for Assessment: The test result is used for quality assurance.
The interior ballistic behaviour of a propellant depends strongly on its dimensions.
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
CH-25
NATO/ PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
CH/102.01.090
TEST INFORMATION SHEET
c .Information Requirements for Assessment: The test result is used in order to reduce the
risk of accidents when firing the propellant (in the designated ammunition) at low
temperatures.
d. Typical Results:
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
CH-26
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP/ UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
CH/201.01.001
TEST INFORMATION SHEET
d. Typical Results:
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
(1) Explosivstoffe (Sonderdruck Nr. 8, 9, 10/58); H. Koenen, K.H. Ide, W. Haupt, P. Langen,
BICT Report Az.:2.2-9/5867/82, Sensitivity to Impact: Test Description and Procedure.
(2) Julius Peters K.G., Berlin 21; Apparaturen zur Ermittlung der Sicherheitstechnischen
Kenndaten explosiver Stoffe.
CH-27
NATO/ PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
CH/201.02.001
TEST INFORMATION SHEET
c. Information Requirements for Assessment: The friction sensitivity is used for the
assessment of handling safety of energetic material. In ageing studies the change of
friction sensitivity gives an indication about shelf life of energetic material from point of
view of handling safety.
d. Typical Results:
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
CH-28
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP/ UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
CH/201.03.001
TEST INFORMATION SHEET
c. Information Requirements for Assessment: The spark test is used for the assessment of
handling safety of energetic material. In ageing studies the change of electrostatic
discharge sensitivity gives an indication about shelf life of energetic material from point
of view of handling safety.
d. Typical Results:
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
CH-29
NATO/ PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
CH/201.04.001
TEST INFORMATION SHEET
b. Description: In the BICT Gap Test, the shock wave sensitivity and the detonability of an
acceptor explosive are determined as a function of the height of a water column used to
transmit and attenuate the shock wave output of a standard donor explosive. Evidence of
a detonation is provided by a detonating cord placed on the acceptor charge and having
its other end attached to a lead witness plate. The donor charge is of RDX/wax/graphite
(94.5/4.5/1) and has a diameter of 21 mm and a length of 20 mm. Its density is 1.60 r
3
0.01 g/cm . Donor, water and acceptor are enclosed in a plexiglas tube of 21 mm inner
diameter and 25 mm outer diameter. The critical diameter of the tested explosives has to
be well less than 21 mm.
The limits of non-detonation (shock wave sensitivity) and detonation
(detonability) are determined by a step of up-and-down procedure. Tests above the non-
detonation limit will always end negatively and tests below the detonation limit will always
lead to detonation. Results are quoted as "mm water gap" and may also be supplemen-
ted by the corresponding shock pressure. A substance is considered to be more sensitive
to shock waves than another if its non-detonation limit is greater than that of the other
substance at a given density.
c. Information Requirements for Assessment: The test is used to determine the shock wave
sensitivity of booster and main charge explosives.
d. Typical Results:
Limit of
3
Explosive Density [g/cm ] Preparation detonation non-detonation
[mm] water gap [mm] water gap
TNT 1.6 cast 6 - 7 49.5 kbar
TNT 1.6 pressed 20 18.4 kbar 21 17.2 kbar
Oktastit VIII 1.82 pressed 20 18.4 kbar 22 16.2 kbar
PBXW-11 1.79 pressed 18 20.9 kbar 20 18.4 kbar
PBXN-110 1.63 cast-cured 16 24.1 kbar 18 20.9 kbar
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
CH-30
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP/ UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
CH/201.04.002
TEST INFORMATION SHEET
b. Description: In the Intermediate Scale Gap Test, the shock wave sensitivity and the
detonability of an acceptor explosive are determined as a function of the height of a
Cellulose Acetate Card barrier used to transmit and attenuate the shock output of a
standard donor explosive. The thickness of the Cellulose Acetate Cards is 0.19 mm.
Evidence of a detonation is proved by a witness charge on a 10 mm thick steel witness
plate. The donor and the witness charge are of RDX/wax/graphite (94.5/4.5/1) and have
3
a diameter of 40 mm and a length of 40 mm. Their density is 1.60+/-0.02 g/cm . The test
specimens are prepared by either casting the sample directly into a 200 mm long steel
tube (inner diameter 40 mm, wall thickness 4 mm) or by inserting a cylindrical sample (40
mm diameter by 200 mm length). The critical diameter of the tested explosives has to be
well below 40 mm. Donor, Cellulose Acetate Cards, the steel tube with the acceptor
charge and the witness charge are placed in three overlapping cardboard tubes.
The limits of non-detonation (shock wave sensitivity) and detonation
(detonability) are determined by a step of up-and-down procedure. Tests above the non-
detonation limit will always end negatively and tests below the detonation limit will always
lead to detonation. Results are quoted as "mm barrier thickness", and are also be supple-
mented by the corresponding shock pressure. A substance is considered to be more
sensitive to shock waves than another if its non-detonation limit is greater than that of the
other substance at a given density.
c. Information Requirements for Assessment: The test is used to determine the shock wave
sensitivity of main charge explosives.
d. Typical Results:
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
nd
(1) UN Recommendation on the Transport of Dangerous Goods, 2 edition (1995)
CH-31
NATO/ PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
CH/201.05.001
TEST INFORMATION SHEET
1. TYPE OF EXPLOSIVE: Main Charge High Explosives/Solid Gun Propellants/Solid Rocket Pro-
pellants
b. Description: For the EIDS Bullet Impact test a tube (steel 37) with an inner diameter
of 47mm, a wall thickness of 4mm and a length of 200mm is used. The end caps are
reinforced (outer diameter: 65mm). The explosive ist either cast directly into the tube or
pressed to dimensions which tightly fit. Gun propellant grains are filled loosely (gravity
feed) into the tube. The loading density has to be recorded.
The test item, which is fixed on a heavy steel table, is impacted by an armour
piercing 12.7mm bullet. The impact velocity is 840 r 40 m/s and the bullet mass is 42g.
The impact point is the centre of one of the end caps, whereas a precision of r1cm has
to be achieved. The trajectory of the bullet into the test sample has to be as long as pos-
sible. The reaction level of the test item (according STANAG 4241) is assessed by the
state the two witness plates (steel 37, thickness 3mm, one at each side) and the
fragmentation pattern of the tube. At least three tests have to be conducted per explosive
type under consideration, whereas the severest reaction counts for the assessment of the
reaction level.
c. Information Requirements for Assessment: This test is used to assess the reaction
behaviour of energetic material against 12.7mm armour piercing projectiles.
d. Typical Results:
3
(1) Hextro 60/40 1.709 g/cm Deflagration
3
(2) Oktastit VIII 1.815 g/cm Explosion
3
(3) PBXN-110 1.671 g/cm No Reaction
(4) PBXW-11 1.792 g/cm3 Burning
3
(5) LX-19 1.896 g/cm Detonation
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
CH-32
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP/ UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
CH/201.06.001
TEST INFORMATION SHEET
b. Description: For the fragment impact test a tube (steel 37) with an inner diameter of 47
mm, a wall thickness of 4mm and a length of 200 mm is used. The end caps are
reinforced (outer diameter: 65mm). The explosive ist either cast directly into the tube or
pressed to dimensions which tightly fit. The loading density has to be recorded.
With the aid of a sabot the fragment (14.94 g) is accelerated and launched with a
velocity of 1830 r 60 m/s to the target. The impact velocity is recorded as well as the
generated overpressure (corrected by the overpressure generated by the cannon), the
state of the witness plates (steel 37, thickness: 2mm) and the fragmentation pattern of
the tube. The reaction level is assessed according the definition given in MIL-STD 2105B.
15.80 mm
14.70 mm
12.70 mm
20°
c. Information Requirements for Assessment: This test is used to assess the reaction
behaviour of energetic material against light weight high velocity fragments.
d. Typical Results:
3
(1) Hextro 60/40 U = 1.709 g/cm v = 1816 m/s Detonation
3
(2) PBXN-9 U = 1.740 g/cm v = 1814 m/s Partial Detonation
3
(3) PBXN-110 U = 1.671 g/cm v = 1822 m/s Burning
3
(4) TATB U = 1.864 g/cm v = 1824 m/s No Reaction
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
CH-33
NATO/ PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
CH/201.07.001
TEST INFORMATION SHEET
c. Information Requirements for Assessment: This test is used to assess the reaction level
of a rocket motor energetic material stimulated by shaped charge impact under
conditions, which are consistent with a future application.
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
CH-34
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP/ UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
CH/202.01.001
TEST INFORMATION SHEET
b. Description: Solid, liquid and gelatinous substances are tested by filling them into
steel tubes of 24 mm inner diameter, 0.5 mm wall thickness and 75 mm length. The open
end of a tube is sealed with one of a number of available steel orifice plates having
orifices with diameters from 1 to 20 mm. The plates are firmly secured by a threaded
collar and nut. An additional diameter of 24 mm results when the test is conducted
without an orifice plate.
The tube is suspended between two rods placed through holes drilled in opposite
walls of a steel protective box. One side and the top of the box are open. The walls and
the base are fitted with four propane gas burners, each set up in such a manner, that the
tip of the inner blue flame just touches the tube with the material to be tested. The
propane gas flow is adjusted to a heating rate of about 3.3 °C/s between 50 °C and 250
°C using Dibutylphtalate.
The burners are ignited and the time (t1) between ignition and the first reaction of
the sample a well as the reaction time (t2) itself are noted. With the aid of a step up and
down procedure the orifice plate limiting diameter is determined. This limiting diameter
defines a confinement, which leads to at least one explosion in three experiments under
the described thermal impact. Explosion is defined as the event causing the steel tube to
fragment into three or more pieces.
c. Information Requirements for Assessment: This test is used to assess the thermal sen-
sitivity of explosive substances in solid or liquid form under a defined confinement. It is
also required by the Swiss Transportation Safety Board for Transport Classification.
d. Typical Results:
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
nd
(1) UN Recommendation on the Transport of Dangerous Goods, 2 edition (1995)
(2) Arbeitsanweisung: FA26 PSE-BSA-P-001.01
(3) STANAG 4491
CH-35
NATO/ PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
CH/202.01.002
TEST INFORMATION SHEET
b. Description: A standard mass of the explosive material under test is heated in a test tube
located in a metal oven at a standard rate until an event occurs. The lowest temperature
at which a visible sign of ignition or decomposition is observed is taken as the
temperature of ignition or decomposition.
Fine granular explosives are used in original form, whereas explosives of larger
size are ground and sieved. The fraction 0.7 - 2 mm is used. Typical sample mass is
0.2 g for propellants and main charge explosives or 0.1 g in case of nitrocellulose and
main charge explosives. For primary explosives and pyrotechnics, even smaller amounts
might be necessary (such as 0.005 to 0.010 g). A heating rate of 5°C/min is commonly
used.
The actual values of "Temperature of Ignition" obtained are only useful under the
particular conditions used, and changing the rate of heating or size of sample will lead to
different results.
d. Information Requirements for Assessment: The test result is used for quality assurance.
It determines the temperature at which an explosive ignites or decomposes.
d. Typical Results:
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
CH-36
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP/ UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
CH/202.01.003
TEST INFORMATION SHEET
a. Type of Test: Stability / Heating the Sample at 90°C for a Given Period of
Time; Determination of the Weight Loss.
b. Description: A standard mass of the propellant under test is heated in "90°C weight
loss tubes" in a metal heating block or equivalent heating device at 90°C for 18 days
(double/triple base propellants) or for 28 days (single base propellants). The weight loss
within the first 8 hours is regarded as "volatiles". The weight loss from "eight hours" to 18
or 28 days is determined.
Fine granular propellants with web sizes < 1.3 mm are used in original form.
Propellant of larger size are cut into smaller pieces or ground and sieved. The fraction 0.7
– 2 mm is used for the test.
a. Information Requirements for Assessment: The test result is used for estimating the
chemical stability of the propellant.
b. Typical Results:
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
CH-37
NATO/ PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
CH/202.01.004
TEST INFORMATION SHEET
Fine granular propellants with web sizes <1.3 mm are used in original form.
Propellant of larger size are cut into smaller pieces or ground and sieved. The fraction 0.7
mm to 2 mm is used for the test.
c. Information Requirements for Assessment: The test result is used for estimating the
chemical stability of the propellant.
d. Typical Results:
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
CH-38
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP/ UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
CH/202.01.005
TEST INFORMATION SHEET
b. Description: The heat flow calorimetry method determines the heat flow produced by
decomposing explosives at a constant temperature over a given period of time. The heat
release is a measure for the sum of ageing reactions taking place. Temperature and
duration of isothermal storage are chosen such that they simulate thermal ageing over a
long period at standard storage conditions (e.g. 10 years at 25°C). For propellants, the "8
days at 80°C" sequence has proven to be a convenient test condition. Other test
conditions (temperature and measurement period) can be chosen as well, depending on
the material and goal of investigation.
Propellants are used, when possible, in their original form. If this is not possible,
the propellants are cut into smaller pieces or ground and sieved. In the latter case, the
fraction 0.7-2 mm is used for the test. For propellants, reconditioning of the sample is
usually not performed. Should the storage conditions markedly differ from 65-70% RH at
21°C, precondition may become necessary. Particle size and moisture content may
influence the result of the test. For pyrotechnics, the investigation of the influence of
humidity on the stability is usually the main goal. In this cases, the sample is precon-
ditioned, or a special sample cell that controls the humidity in the sample vial is used.
The explosive is filled to the top of the measuring ampoules (up). The ampoules
are tightly closed and put into a heat flow calorimeter operating at a constant temperature
for a certain period of time (e.g. at 80°C for 8 days). The heat flow rate is recorded over
this period, and the total heat production is determined (by integrating the heat flow curve
over the entire period). Excellent reproducibility can be obtained. However, all deviations
from the test conditions, in particular the use of lower filling grades and leaking ampoules,
will markedly change the heat flow curve.
c. Information Requirements for Assessment: The result is used to estimate the chemical
stability of the propellant.
c. Typical Results:
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
CH-39
NATO/ PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
CH/202.01.006
TEST INFORMATION SHEET
b. Description: The vacuum stability test is used to assess the thermal stability of an
explosive by measuring the volume of gas evolved on heating the sample for 40 hours at
90°C (double base propellants), 100°C (single base propellants, composite propellants,
explosives and pyrotechnics), or 120°C (certain other explosives).
Fine granular explosives are used in original form, whereas explosives of larger
size are ground and sieved. The fraction 0.2 – 2 mm is used in the latter case. As the ex-
plosive's moisture level may play a significant role in gas evolution, drying of the sample
is inappropriate.
Five (5) g of the explosive is filled into the sample tube. The sample tube is
evacuated before being stored in a metal heating block or equivalent heating device for
40 hours at the desired test temperature. The gas evolved into the vacuum is measured
by manometer or pressure transducer.
c. Information Requirements for Assessment: The test result is used for estimating the
chemical stability of the propellant.
d. Typical Results:
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
CH-40
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP/ UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
CH/202.01.007
TEST INFORMATION SHEET
d. Typical Results:
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
CH-41
NATO/ PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
CH/202.01.008
TEST INFORMATION SHEET
2. TEST TITLE: HPLC for Stabiliser Depletion not Covered by STANAG 4117, 4541 and 4542
a. Type of Test: Stability/Heating the Sample at Different Temperatures for Given Periods
of Time; Determination of Stabiliser Depletion.
(1) The test conditions and requirements have been elaborated from experience.
They are described in the following STANAG's:
(a) STANAG 4117 for single base propellants stabilised with diphenylamine (DPA);
single base propellants stabilised with ethyl centralite (EC);
single base propellants stabilised with a mixture of DPA and EC;
double base propellants stabilised with EC.
(b) STANAG 4541 for nitrocellulose based propellants with d 15% nitroglycerine,
stabilised with DPA;
(c) STANAG 4542 for nitrocellulose based propellants with d 15% nitroglycerine,
stabilised with 2-nitrodiphenylamine (2-NO-DPA).
CH-42
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP/ UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
CH/202.01.008 (Continued)
(3) For the extrapolation from the range of test temperatures to standard storage con-
ditions, 3 different approaches are commonly used. These are:
(a) Reaction Kinetics / Arrhenius Extrapolation: The reaction order of the stabiliser
depletion is determined, which allows to calculate the reaction rate constants for
the different test temperatures. From these data, the rate constant at storage
temperature is calculated using the Arrhenius equation. The shelf life at storage
temperature can then be calculated from the extrapolated rate constant using the
reaction equation applicable for the particular reaction order. This procedure is
described in STANAG 4527.
(b) Model Free Evaluation / Arrhenius Extrapolation: The period of time tx until a
given degree of stabiliser consumption is attained is estimated for all test
temperatures by fitting suitable interpolation functions to the stabiliser concentra-
tion data. These tx–values can be regarded as "shelf life values at the respective
test temperature (for the "acceptable stabiliser depletion" suggested above, tx re-
presents the time until the concentration of original stabiliser drops to 0.5%). The
extrapolation to the shelf life at standard storage temperature (tx at 20°C or 25°C)
can be performed directly using the Arrhenius equation (see Equation 4 in
STANAG 4527).
(c) Model Free Evaluation / Berthelot Extrapolation: The procedure follows (ii) except
for using the Berthelot equation for the extrapolation to standard storage
temperatures. The Berthelot approach is known to be more conservative than the
Arrhenius equation. Instead of performing a "standard" Berthelot extrapolation,
the prognosis can also be done using Berthelot with a ageing factor of 3.0 per
10°C. It is known from experience that this is a very conservative estimation.
(4) The influence of the selected approach on the resulting shelf life extrapolation is
subject of still ongoing investigations. For the moment, it is recommended to use:
(a) The "standard" Berthelod approach (iii) in cases where stabiliser depletion data
are available from at least three different temperatures, the lowest temperature
not exceeding 50 °C.
(b) The Berthelod approach with ageing factor of 3.0 per 10 °C for all other cases.
(ageing temperatures from only one or two different temperatures, of from "too
high temperatures" above 50 °C).
c. Information Requirements for Assessment: The test result is used as a means for
estimating the chemical stability/chemical shelf life of the propellant. In Swiss surveillance
programs the Berthelod extrapolation is considered as a standard.
d Typical Results: Chemical shelf life values of <20 years for single and double base
propellants.
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
CH-43
NATO/ PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
CH/202.01.009
TEST INFORMATION SHEET
2. TEST TITLE: HPLC for Stabiliser Depletion Covered by STANAG 4117, 4541 and 4542
c. Information Requirements for Assessment: For propellants of these types shortened test
procedures can be applied as described in corresponding STANAG's or if appropriate a
complete shelf life assessment can be made as described in AOP-7 202.01.008.
d. Typical Results: Chemical shelf life values of <20 years ("shortened test"), and <20
years (complete shelf life assessment)
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
CH-44
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP/ UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
CH/202.01.010
TEST INFORMATION SHEET
b. Description: For fast or slow heating a tube (steel 37) with an inner diameter of 47
mm, a wall thickness of 4mm and a length of 200 mm is used. The end caps are
reinforced (outer diameter: 65mm). The explosive ist either cast directly into the tube or
pressed to dimensions which tightly fit. Gun Propellant grains are filled loosely (gravity
feed) into the tube. The loading density has to be recorded.
For Slow Cook-off (SCO) experiments the tube is placed into an oven, in which
the test item is first equilibrated during 6 hours at 40 °C. After that, it is heated up with a
rate of 3.3 r 0.3 °C/h upon ration takes place. The temperature at different places on the
surface of the tube is recorded during the experiment. The reaction temperature as well
as the reaction level are denoted. The reaction level, as defined e.g. in STANAG 4382, is
assessed according to the fragmentation pattern of the tube.
For Fast Cook-off (FCO) experiments the tube is placed on a holding device over
a wood fire. To achieve a well balanced fuel/air ratio a wooden lattice of air dried pieces,
each not more than 50mm thick and spaced at about 100mm intervals, has to be con-
structed. The ignition of the wood is accelerated by the additional use of liquid fuel
saturated saw dust. The time to the reaction and the reaction level are recorded. The
reaction level is assessed according the penetration pattern of aluminium witness plates
(200 x 200 x 2 mm).
c. Information Requirements for Assessment: This test is used to assess the reaction level
and reaction temperature of confined energetic material under the stimuli of slow and fast
heating. It is also required by the Swiss Transportation Board for classification into class
1.6.
d. Typical Results:
SCO: FCO:
(1) Hextro 60/40 171 °C Explosion 13 Min Part. Detonation
(2) Oktastit VIII 185 °C Part. Detonation 21 Min Part. Detonation
(3) PBXN-110 178 °C Burn 15 Min Burn
(4) Single Base 129 °C Burn
e. Repeatability and Reproducibility: SCO: r 5 °C, within the reaction level; FCO: r 3 Min,
within the reaction level
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
CH-45
NATO/ PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
CH/203.01.001
TEST INFORMATION SHEET
b. Description: The heat flow calorimetry method determines the heat flow produced by
decomposing explosives at a constant temperature over a given period of time. The heat
release during this isothermal storage is a measure for the sum of ageing reactions
taking place.
For compatibility measurements, the heat flow of a mixture of explosive and test
material (material which comes into contact with the explosives during intended use of
the ammunition) is compared to the heat flows of the explosive and the test material
when heated separately under otherwise identical conditions. Compatibility is judged by
means of the additional heat produced because of the contact between the two com-
ponents of the mixture.
Temperature and duration of isothermal storage have to be chosen in a way that
they simulate thermal ageing over a long period of time at standard storage conditions
(e.g. 10 years at 25°C).
For propellants, the "8 days at 80°C" sequence already proposed for stability
assessment has proven to be a convenient test condition for compatibility testing as well.
It must, however, be noted that this sequence differs from the sequence recommended in
STANAG 4147.
Explosive and test material are used, whenever possible, in their original form. If
this is not possible, they have to be cut into smaller pieces or ground and sieved. In the
latter case, the fraction 0.7 – 2 mm is used for the test.
The measuring ampoules are filled up to the top with either explosive, test
material, or a mixture of explosive and test material. Usually, a 1:1 mixture by weight is
used for the measurements. Depending on the possible contact in the weapon system,
other mixture ratios (e.g. 10:1) as well as other arrangements (e.g. varnish coating of the
inside of the ampoule) are possible. The ampoules have to be tightly closed.
Preconditioning of the sample is usually not performed. Should the storage con-
ditions, however, markedly differ from 65 – 70% RH at 21°C, precondition might become
necessary. Particle size and moisture content of the sample may influence the result of
the test.
The ampoules are put into a heat flow calorimeter operating at 80°C for 8 days.
The heat flow rates are recorded over this period, and the total heat production is deter-
mined for each sample (by integrating the heat flow curve over the 8 day period). From
these results, the incompatibility QR is calculated (as difference between the actual heat
release of the mixture and the heat loss as calculated for the mixture from the results of
the isolated compounds).
If all test conditions are carefully observed, good reproducibility can be obtained.
However, all deviations from the test conditions, in particular the use of lower filling
grades and leaking ampoules, will markedly change the heat flow curves.
CH-46
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP/ UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
CH/203.01.001(Continued)
c. Information Requirements for Assessment: The test result is used as a means for judging
whether explosive and test material are chemically compatible with each other; to make
sure that they cause no safety hazard during storage or use.
e. Repeatability and Reproducibility: Within 10% (abs.) under identical test conditions.
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
CH-47
NATO/ PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
CH/203.01.002
TEST INFORMATION SHEET
c. Information Requirements for Assessment: The test result is used as a means for judging
whether explosive and test material are chemically compatible with each other; to make
sure that they cause no safety hazard during storage or use.
d. Typical Results:
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
CH-48
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP/ UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
CH/203.02.001
TEST INFORMATION SHEET
b. Description: The test is applicable to plasticiser containing solid rocket propellants (SRP)
only. Specimens are selected at different locations of naturally or artificially aged SRP–
Motors. Small cubes of 3 x 3 mm are prepared. The plasticiser is extracted quantitatively
with an adequate solvent. The plasticiser content of the samples originating from different
locations of the rocket motor is measured either by infrared spectroscopy (integration of a
separated plasticiser peak) or other adequate methods as HPLC. Based on a uniform
plasticiser distribution in a new rocket motor, plasticiser migration can be evaluated by
correlating plasticiser content and origin of the sample in the rocket motor. For the
investigation of the whole plasticiser migration process equivalent rocket motors have to
be aged over different time periods, till a steady state occurs. Plasticiser contents at
different locations of the rocket motor have to be expressed as a function of time and
temperature.
Migration of plasticiser from propellant into the liner or vice-versa, results in changes of
the mechanical properties and can lead to malfunction of the rocket motor. This test is
applied to programs for assessing physical ageing and chemical degradation for storage,
stability studies and lifetime predictions
d. Typical Results:
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
CH-49
NATO/ PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
CH/302.01.001
TEST INFORMATION SHEET
c. Information Requirements for Assessment: This test measures the detonation velocity of
high explosives at a certain density.
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
CH-50
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP/ UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
CH/302.02.001
TEST INFORMATION SHEET
d. Typical Results:
(1) Ignition mixture: 40% Ti (Type E) / 59% KClO4 / 1% NC: 0.49 ± 0.02 m/s
(2) Ignition mixture: 30% B / 69% KNO3 / 1% NC: 0.44 ± 0.02 m/s
(3) Black Powder Nr. 2: 0.57 ± 0.03 m/s
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
CH-51
NATO/ PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
CH/302.02.002
b. Description: The propellant is tested in its original shape and size. Manometic bombs
3 3 3 3
(closed bombs) of 70 cm , 75 cm , 150 cm , and 700 cm internal volume are commonly
used. Other volumes are possible as well. The propellant is filed into the manometric
3
bomb. Filling grades of 0.10 – 0.20 g/cm are commonly applied. The propellant is ignited
by a black powder or nitrocellulose igniter. The increase of gas pressure in the
manometric bomb as a function of time is measured by means of a Piezo element and
recorded in a transient recorder. The vivacity (liveliness) L of the propellant is then
calculated from pressure p as a function of time t according to:
dp 1 1
L
dt p p m
This value (graph of L between p/pm = 0 and p/pm = 1; with pm representing the maximum
pressure) is used as a measure for the propellant's burning behaviour. The manometric
bomb test might also be applied to determine changes in the interior ballistic behaviour of
a propellant due to ageing. For such investigations, unaged as well as artificially aged
propellants have to be tested consecutively.
It determines the burning behaviour of a propellant in a closed vessel. There are limi-
tations in the correlation between ballistic bomb and original weapon system. The results
of this test, however, gives in most cases at least a good indication on the interior ballistic
behaviour of the propellant. In particular, differences between similar propellants (such as
initiated by small differences in shape or formulation) can easily be assessed. The
manometric bomb has, thereby, to be regarded as a "comparative test".
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
(1) Testing Procedures PW 986 048; P 8 700 049; P 8 700 055; P 8 048 601;
NITROCHEMIE WIMMIS AG
(2) Druckbomben-Fibel; H. Jahnk, CCG-Kurs Innenballistik von Rohrwaffen, 1984
CH-52
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP/ UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
CH/302.03.001
TEST INFORMATION SHEET
c. Information Requirements for Assessment: This test determines the heat of explosion of
energetic material, which is a measure for the energy content of the explosive (heat
which can be released in absence of oxygen).
d. Typical Results:
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
CH-53
NATO/ PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
CH-54
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
10.7.15 QUALIFICATION PROCEDURES OF THE UNITED KINGDOM
PARAGRAPH PAGE
UK-1
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
UK-2
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
10.7.15.1 MILITARY DEPARTMENTS RESPONSIBLE FOR QUALIFICATION
10.7.15.1.1 The Defence Ordnance Safety Group (DOSG), formerly the Ordnance Board, has full
responsibility for qualification of explosives.
10.7.15.2.1 The DOSG is the appointed UK National Authority and is responsible for the following
functions to fulfil the requirements of STANAG 4170:
a. Defining the tests necessary to obtain evidence for the assessment of explosive
materials used by all three services, and the requirements applied for the
Qualification of these materials.
b. Receiving from agencies within the UK, or from other nations in the case of
munitions purchased overseas, the test data for qualifying explosive materials,
and assessing whether the material is safe and suitable for consideration for use
by the Services in a particular role or application.
c. Publishing the test data and assessment, which enables Qualification, with or
without limitations.
h. Providing the UK Point of Contact to other NATO countries for the exchange of
information, as appropriate, on the safety of explosives.
i. Liaising with the appropriate security officers of UK agencies to ensure that the
security regulations and requirements for commercial-confidentiality governing
the release of information are complied with in respect of data to be provided in
response to requests from other nations.
10.7.15.3.1 In the United Kingdom, research into explosives (of all types) for all three services, can
be carried out in MOD facilities, in Government Agencies, in academic institutions or in
industry by Defence Contractors. Such establishments are:
e. QinetiQ
UK-3
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
10.7.15.3.2 When a munition containing explosive materials is to be designed within the UK, or
purchased from overseas, the appropriate Integrated Project Team Leader in either the
Defence Procurement Agency (DPA) or in Defence Logistics Organisation (DLO) should
task DOSG to advise on the safety and suitability for service of that munition.
a. To provide impartial appraisal of the safety, and advice on the suitability for
service, of those parts of weapon systems and stores within its field of operations
in which explosives are used. In this context, the term "suitability for service"
means that the explosive and associated elements of a weapon system or store
are capable of functioning technically as designed, and that neither this
functioning, nor safety, will be unacceptably degraded by the service
environment through the agreed service life. It does not embrace operational
effectiveness or reliability.
b. To give advice on safety matters affecting the use of weapons and other
hazardous stores during military training.
10.7.15.3.4 Having accepted the task, the relevant Technical Section of DOSG will identify all the
explosive materials used, or proposed for use, in the equipment. These will be
considered to determine whether they are new to service, or known materials being used
in a novel role. All materials in these two categories become the subject of assessment
and qualification, for their safety and suitability for consideration for use in service, not
necessarily restricted to a particular munition.
10.7.15.3.5 In certain circumstances, DOSG may accept tasks from Research and Development
organisations for the assessment and qualification of a new explosive material before it
has been selected for use by a munition project.
10.7.15.4.1 The basis for the UK assessment for the qualification of an explosive composition is
currently laid down in Ordnance Board Pillar Proceeding 42700 (Qualification of
explosives). This proceeding is in line with the requirements of STANAG 4170. It sets
out the information required for assessment, with general guidance on the suitable tests
for the various types of explosives. More specific guidance for particular explosive roles is
given in OB Pillar proceedings P 111 (pyrotechnics), P119 (secondary HE main charge
and boosters) and P127 (solid propellants).
10.7.15.4.2 Selection of Tests. The selection of the specific tests to obtain data is a matter of
agreement between the specialist officers of the DOSG and the Tasking Authority. The
selection of tests is influenced by the guidance given in Chapter VII "Assessment
Principles and Common Requirements" of this manual for each type of material, together
with other factors such as the nature of the material and its role. Consideration is given
to the need to carry out tests at extremes of temperature and on aged material.
10.7.15.4.3 For all materials, information is required to demonstrate compliance with STANAG 4170.
10.7.15.4.4 Conduct of Tests. The DOSG, although the UK National Authority, has no test facilities
of its own. Once the test requirements for assessment and qualification have been
agreed by the relevant authorities, the tests are carried out in an approved test house
UK-4
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
which may be at one or more of the establishments listed in paragraph 10.7.15.3.1. There
is an ongoing programme to accredit UK test houses for particular qualification tests.
10.7.15.4.5 Assessment. The results of the tests, together with observations and recommendations,
are formally reported by the test establishment to DOSG. The results are considered by
officers of DOSG, in relation to the results of the same tests carried out on materials of a
similar type and role which have a proven history of safety and satisfactory use in
service.
10.7.15.4.6 Qualification. The test results, together with the discussion of their assessment, are
presented as a draft Proceeding on the material per se, or as a section in a Proceeding
assessing the safety and suitability for service of a complete munition or sub-system, for
consideration by peer review by DOSG, representing all three services. If satisfied,
DOSG will then publish the Proceeding in which they recommend that the material is safe
and suitable for consideration for use, with limitations if necessary.
10.7.15.4.7 Approval for Service Use. The Safety Approving Authority of the relevant service has the
final responsibility to accept DOSG advice, or to modify or reject it. The latter seldom, if
ever, occurs.
10.7.15.4.8 Compatibility. Materials used in munitions, which may come into direct contact with
explosives or propellants, must be compatible as defined in STANAG 4147. This also
applies to materials, which although not in direct contact , evolve vapours that can come
into direct contact with the explosive or propellant in the munition.
10.7.15.4.9 Terminology Used in the UK. As the methodology for the assessment of safety and
suitability for service has developed within the UK, terms have been used which may
have somewhat different interpretation from that given by other nations. In order to assist
in the understanding of UK assessments, the following explanations of UK usage are
recorded. They are not intended as rigid definitions.
d. Power is the term used in the UK for high explosive, to indicate the level of
explosive response following initiation in the designed mode.
UK-5
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
10.7.15.4.10 HIGH EXPLOSIVES
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
(14) Tube Test – Electrically Heated STANAG 4491
(15) Critical Diameter 302.02.002
(16) Detonation Velocity 302.02.001
(17) Vacuum Stability STANAG 4556
(18) DMA (for PBX) STANAG 4540
(19) TMA (for PBX) STANAG 4525
(20) Uniaxial Tensile (for PBX) STANAG 4506
(21) Stress Relaxation (for PBX) STANAG 4507
(22) Uniaxial Compression (for PBX) STANAG 4443
(23) Thermal Characterization by DSC/DTA STANAG 4515
10.7.15.4.11 PROPELLANTS
UK-7
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
10.7.15.4.12 PYROTECHNICS
b. The UK tables in Chapter 8 list the properties which require re-testing after
accelerated ageing.
UK-8
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
10.7.15.5 LIST OF TEST INFORMATION SHEETS
201.0X.XXX Sensitiveness/Sensitivity/Explosiveness
UK-9
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
201.06.001 Model Scale Motor Test
201.06.002 Fragment Impact-Gun Propellant
201.06.003 Fragment Impact-High Explosive
201.07.XXX Jet Impact Tests
203.00.XXX Compatibility
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
10.7.15.6 CATALOGUE OF TEST INFORMATION SHEETS
NOTE: The Test Information Sheets are listed consecutively in accordance with the
Registry Number.
UK-11
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
UK-12
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
UK/102.01.001
b. Description:
(2) Applied Load. Load applied varies with the material, normally in the range 0.3 to
o
2.5Mpa for composite propellant at 23 C.
(3) Experimental Method. After conditioning at test temperature for one hour, the
sample is pulled axially by the dumb-bell ends using a stiff tensile testing machine. Load
is applied at a constant strain rate (crosshead speed). Preferably the strain is measured
directly using an extensometer or similar device.
(4) Main Physical Parameters. The main physical parameters affecting the results
are strain rate and test temperature.
(5) Results. Tensile strength, Vm, initial tangent modulus, Eo, and the strain at
maximum load Hm, and at failure, Hb, are calculated.
(1) Applications. Used for characterization and routine process control of plastic,
rubbery and colloidal propellants: polymer based high explosives.
(2) Significance. The data are required to assess the ability of the charge to retain
its integrity throughout the range of operating conditions envisaged for the material.
(3) Limitations. Can only be used for materials that can be cut or machined to the
shape required i.e. not suitable for very soft or brittle materials.
d. Typical Results:
Temp qC Hm% Hb% Vm KPa
Rubbery propellant +25 33.3 40.1 754
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
ASTM D412; BS903 part A2 and BS 2782 part 3; method 320A describe the method in
detail but use different dumb-bell shapes. The JANNAF dumb-bells are described in the
ICPRG Solid Propellant Mechanical Behaviour Manual, section 4.3.2
UK-13
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
UK/102.01.010
b. Description:
(1) Geometry of Specimen. A right circular cylinder with a length to diameter ratio of
2:1; 10 to 25 mm diameter and 20 to 50 mm long is typical.
(2) Applied Load. Load applied varies with the material, normally in the range 0.3 to
o
2.5Mpa for composite propellant at 23 C; up to 20 MPa for cast HE.
(3) Experimental Method. After conditioning at the test temperature for one hour,
the sample is compressed directly between two plane, parallel surfaces using a
stiff testing machine. Load is applied at a constant crosshead speed.
Compression cages should NOT be used.
(4) Main Physical Parameters. The main physical parameters affecting the results
are strain rate and test temperature.
(5) Results. Compressive strength, Vm, initial tangent modulus, Eo, and the strain at
maximum load Hm, and at failure, Hb, are calculated.
(2) Significance. The data are required to assess the ability of the charge to retain
its integrity throughout the range of operating conditions envisaged for the
material.
(3) Limitations. Can only be used for materials that can be cut or machined to the
shape required. The method is not suitable for either soft or pressed materials
that do not consolidate well.
d. Typical Results:
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
ASTM D695 and BS2782 part 3; method 345A describe the method in detail. The BS
calls for a l/d ratio of 1:1.
UK-14
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
UK/102.01.025
b. Description:
(2) Applied Load. Sufficient to result in a strain of about 1%. The applied load is
cyclic, normally at 3 frequencies generated at 0.1, 1.0 and 10 radians/sec.
(4) Main Physical Parameters. The main physical parameters affecting the results
are strain rate and test temperature.
(5) Results. Shear storage modulus, G’ and shear loss modulus, G" and the loss
tangent, tanG, are plotted through the temperature sweep. The glass transition
temperature, Tg, is obtained from a peak in the G" curve.
(2) Significance. Used to assess the stability of the charge properties over the range
of operating conditions.
3. Limitations. Can only be used for materials that can be cut or machined or
pressed to the required shape. This method is not suitable for either soft
materials or pressed materials that do not consolidate well.
d. Typical Results:
Rubbery propellant
G’MPa G’'MPa tan V
o
at 25 C 9.99 4.22 0.422
o
Tg peak in G" is at -72 C.
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
UK-15
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
UK/102.01.050
b. Description:
(1) Geometry of Specimen. Solid or liquid; solids may be in film, powder, granular or
crystalline form. Sample size is 5 to 10mg.
(3) Experimental Method. Commercial equipment is used. Scanning rate and range
are dependant on the material, the mass and the property being measured.
(4) Main Physical Parameters. The main physical parameters affecting the results
are scan rate, sample size, physical form, purge gas used.
(5) Results. Heat capacity, Cp, glass transition temperature, Tg, melt temperature ,
Tm, and associated latent heats, Hf. Other peak areas and start temperatures
may also be measured eg crystal transition enthalpy, 'ht.
(2) Significance. Initial screening of materials. Used to assess physical ageing and
chemical degradation for storage and stability studies.
(3) Limitations. Experiments are limited to the temperature range and heating rates
of the equipment available.
d. Typical Results:
e. Repeatability and Reproducibility. With non-volatile sample the results are repeatable to
within 0.2 millicalories.
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
UK-16
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
UK/102.01.070
b. Description:
(1) Geometry of Specimen. Small pieces of material that will pass through the
pyknometer neck, (4mm x 4mm x 6mm maximum), with smooth surfaces free
from crevices and dust. If a 50ml pyknometer is used, the total weight of the
pieces should be around 20g.
(2) Experimental Method. The pyknometer is accurately weighed in air and then re-
weighed three times, with the sample inside, topped up with a suitable liquid and
full of liquid. The density, U, is calculated from the four weighings.
(3) Main Physical Parameters. The main physical parameter affecting the results is
changes of temperature.
(4) Results. Density, U, and/or specific gravity, SG; the void fraction may be derived
from a knowledge of the theoretical maximum density.
(2) Significance. The data are used to calculate the stresses applied to the charge
and store throughout its storage and operating life.
(3) Limitations. This method can only be used when a liquid is available that does
not dissolve or swell the material during weighing. It cannot be used if the
materials floats or the particle size is less than a 20 mesh sieve (850 Pm).
d. Typical Results:
NATIONAL REFERENCES:
BS 2782 part 6, method 620B; BS 903 part A1 method B; ASTM D792 method B; ISO/R
1183-1970; DQA/TS method M18/89.
UK-17
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
UK/102.01.071 mode 1
b. Description:
(1) Geometry of Specimen. A right regular bar with a uniform cross section, the area
of which can be calculated from its dimensions e.g. a rectangle or circle.
(3) Main Physical Parameters. The main physical parameter affecting the results is
changes of temperature.
(4) Results. Density, U, the void fraction may be derived from acknowledge of the
theoretical maximum density.
(2) Significance. The data are used to calculate the stresses applied to the charge
and store throughout its storage and operating life.
(3) Limitations. This method can only be used when the specimen are available in a
suitably geometry. It is not a suitable method for rubbery materials.
3
d. Typical Results. Density, U, of pressed RDX/TNT is 1.67Mg/m .
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
UK-18
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
UK/102.01.071 mode 2
b. Description:
(1) Geometry of Specimen. Any piece of material, 2.5 to 25 grams weight, usually of
irregular shape, with smooth surfaces free from crevices and dust. If porous it
may be necessary to coat the sample with a wax or lacquer.
(2) Experimental Method. The specimen is accurately weighed in air and re-
weighed immersed in a suitable liquid of known density. The specimen density is
calculated from the two weighings. For materials of density below or near that of
the immersing liquid a heavy sinker is added and an extra weighing made.
(3) Main Physical Parameters. The main physical parameter affecting the results is
changes of temperature.
(4) Results. Density, U, and/or specific gravity, SG; the void fraction may be derived
from a knowledge of the theoretical maximum density.
(2) Significance. The data are used to calculate the stresses applied to the charge
and store throughout its storage and operating life.
(3) Limitations. This method can only be used when a liquid is available that does
not dissolve or swell the material, or its coating when used.
3
d. Typical Results. Density, U, of plastic explosive is 1.60 Mg/m .
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
BS 2782 part 6 methods 620A and C, BS 903 part A1 method A; ASTM D792 method A,
ISO/R 1183-1970. DQA/TS M216/74 method C.
UK-19
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
UK/102.01.071 mode 3
b. Description:
(1) Geometry of Specimen. Any small piece (less than 6mm cube) of material, of an
easily identifiable shape, with smooth surfaces free from crevices and dust.
Samples cut from film should not be less than 0.13 mm thick.
(2) Experimental Method. Three samples are put into a column containing a suitable
mixed liquid or solution together with standardized floats whose density brackets
that of the sample. When the sample and floats are at equilibrium (10 minutes
minimum) the vertical distances from the floats are measured and the density
calculated.
(3) Main Physical Parameters. The main physical parameter affecting the results is
changes of temperature.
(4) Density, U, the void fraction may be derived from a knowledge of the theoretical
maximum density.
(2) Significance. The data is used to calculate the stresses applied to the charge
and store throughout its storage and operating life.
(3) Limitations. This method can only be used for solid materials that do not absorb,
dissolve or swell in the column liquids.
d. Typical Results:
3 NATIONAL REFERENCES:
UK-20
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
UK/102.01.201
a. Type of Test: Uniaxial Mechanical Properties, Tensile - Used for melt cast explosives.
b. Description:
(2) Applied Load. Applied load varies with the material, normally in the range 0.3 to
10 MPa.
(3) Experimental Method. After conditioning at test temperature for one hour, the
sample is pulled axially by the dumb-bell ends using a stiff tensile testing
machine. Load is applied at a constant strain rate (crosshead speed). It is
preferred that strain is measured directly using an extensometer or similar device
and not crosshead movement.
(4) Main Physical Parameters. The main physical parameter affecting the results are
strain rate and temperature.
(5) Results. Tensile strength, Vm, initial tangent modulus, Eo, and the strain at
maximum load, Hm, and at failure, Hb, are calculated.
(1) Applications. Used for characterization and routine process control of melt cast
high explosives.
(2) Significance. The data are required to assess the ability of the charge to retain
its integrity throughout the range of operating conditions envisaged for the
material.
(3) Limitations. Can only be used on materials that can be machined without
shattering. Values obtained for modulus will be unrealistically low if direct
methods of strain measurement are not used.
d. Typical Results:
3. REFERENCES:
The method is essentially that described in ASTM D638 but the dumb-bell is more suitable for
explosive materials.
UK-21
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
UK/201.01.001
b Description: A small quantity of the material confined between a brass cap and an
anvil in a heavy housing is subjected to an indirect impact from a 5 kg weight dropped
onto intermediate components (drift and striker). The median height for ignition is
determined and compared to that for a standard RDX to produce a figure of
insensitiveness (F of I) for the material.
d. Typical Results:
Explosive F of I
PETN 50
HMX 60
RDX 80 (Standard)
TNT 150
COMP B 130
VU (EDB) 15
ATN D28/47 (CDB) 20
SR44 30
SR651 180
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
UK-22
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
UK/201.01.002
b. Description: A small sample of the explosive under test is placed on a steel anvil and
covered by a brass disc. It is then subjected to impact from a falling steel ball impacting
on a striker with a hemispherical end.
c. Information Requirements for Assessment: This test aims to determine the impact
sensitiveness of primary explosives with a degree of discrimination superior to that
achieved for such materials by the Rotter Test.
d. Typical Results: Results are given as the height of drop required to give ignitions in 50%
of the impacts.
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
UK-23
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
UK/201.01.003
a. Type of Test: Safety/Drop-weight Impact - Used for all except most pyrotechnics.
b. Description: The sensitiveness of the test material is firstly measured using test
UK/201.01.001 (Rotter). Using the same test equipment, data for the mean gas volume of
decomposition products for positive events (ignitions) is collected across a range of
stimulus levels (up to 2.5 times the median drop-height). These mean gas volumes are
compared with the calculated theoretical specific gas production for the test material,
expressed as a percentage and corrected with reference to the output from a high
explosiveness standard sample of lead azide. When explosiveness is plotted against
stimulus level a characteristic curve is obtained for the material. Both an explosiveness
figure and a hazard index can easily be derived from such curves. Although this is a
small scale test, it clearly demonstrates the effect of the physical properties of the test
material and is thus an effective early indicator of charge scale safety characteristics.
d. Typical Results:
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
UK-24
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
UK/201.01.004
a. Type of Test: Safety/Impact - Used for Main Charge High Explosives, Booster
Explosives and Propellants.
b. Description: The sensitiveness of the test material is firstly measured using test
UK/201.01.001 (Rotter). Using the same test equipment, two further Rotter tests are
performed on the test material with added grit. A standard alumina grit with a well
specified and characterised particle size is added at two concentrations, 0.1 and 1% by
weight. It is added in such a way that the sample is as homogeneous as possible. Data
from the grit-sensitised samples can be compared with that for the uncontaminated
sample in order to determine the degree of sensitisation by the grit. It is often convenient
to plot a curve to illustrate the results.
c. Information Requirements for Assessment: The test shows which samples are more
likely to be significantly sensitised by the presence of adventitious grit particles.
d. Typical Results
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
UK-25
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
UK/201.01.005
a. Type of Test: Safety/Impact - Used for Propellants, Boosters and Main Charge High
Explosives.
d. Typical Results: Results are given as the height of drop required to give ignitions in 50%
of the trials.
VU (EDB) 1.1 m
ATN (D28)/47 (CDB) 1.3 m
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
UK-26
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
UK/201.01.006
b. Description: The Rotter test apparatus is used in conjunction with a modified sample
housing. A rubber O-ring is inserted at the base of a cylindrical cavity in a robust steel
sample cup. A standard volume of the test liquid is dispensed from a micro-pipette into
the cavity so formed. The cavity is then approximately half full. It is sealed by placing a
stainless steel shim and a steel plunger on top of the O-ring. This assembly is placed in
the impact housing and a standard pre-compression is applied to the cavity by rotating
the threaded central upper part of the housing. The housing is then placed under the
drop-weight machine and a 2kg drop-weight is used to apply a compression stimulus to
the cavity via an intermediate drift, ball bearing and plunger. The median height for
positive events (ignitions) is determined using a 50 shot Bruceton Staircase technique.
d. Typical Results:
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
UK-27
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
UK/201.02.001
d. Typical Results:
Explosive F of F
PETN 1.3
HMX 1.5
RDX 3.0 (standard)
LU double base propellant 2.4
RD 2503 Composite propellant 1.6
SR 92 delay composition 0.17
RD 1303 lead styphnate 0.17
RD 1343 lead azide 0.07
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
UK-28
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
UK/201.02.002
b. Description: The material is smeared between two steel surfaces, which are covered
with emery paper to provide a rough surface. A load of 15 kg is applied to push the two
surfaces together and the impact from a pendulum is used to move the lower metal
surface relative to the upper surface. The friction caused by moving the two rough
surfaces can ignite the material.
d. Typical Results: The results can be expressed as the striking velocity of the pendulum
required to give ignitions in 50% of the strikes.
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
UK-29
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
UK/201.03.001
d. Typical Results:
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES
UK-30
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
UK/201.03.002
a. Type of Test: Safety/Electric Spark - Used for Primary Explosives and Pyrotechnics.
b. Description: In this test, compositions which are ignited by the 0.045J discharge of the
UK Electric Spark Test are assessed. Two types of discharge can be used:
(1). Between metallic electrodes, simulating a discharge from one metal object to
another;
d. Typical Results:
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
UK-31
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
UK/201.04.001
a. Type of Test: Safety/Detonative Shock - Used for energetic materials where the critical
diameter is less than about 15mm.
b. Description: This is the small scale gap test described in STANAG4488. The shock wave
from an RDX/wax donor is attenuated by a water barrier and the detonation or otherwise
of the acceptor assessed by the transmission or otherwise of detonation along a length of
detonating cord. The cord is laid against an aluminium alloy witness plate. The thickness
of attenuator giving a 50% probability of detonation is calculated from the results of
testing using a Bruceton staircase procedure.
c. Information Requirements for Assessment: This test determines the sensitivity to shock
initiation of explosives which will propagate detonation in unconfined charges with
diameters of less than about 15mm.
d. Typical Results:
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
To be supplied.
UK-32
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
UK/201.04.002
a. Type of Test: Safety/Detonative Shock - Used for Main Charge High Explosives,
Booster Explosives and Propellants.
b. Description: This test is based closely on the US NSWC Large-Scale Gap Test. The
material under test is subjected to a shock wave from a donor pellet (tetryl) that is
attenuated by a Perspex™ (polymethyl methacrylate) barrier placed between the donor
and acceptor charges. A witness plate is used to distinguish the detonation of the test
explosive from sub-detonative reactions.
c. Information Requirements for Assessment: This test may be used to compare the
detonation shock sensitivity of explosive materials having unconfined critical diameters
up to about 100 mm.
d. Typical Results:
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
UK-33
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
UK/201.06.001
2. TEST TITLE: Model Scale Motor Fragment Attack Test for Solid Rocket Propellants
d. Typical Results: (All using fast attack on star-centred charges in aluminium alloy tubes,
using nozzles appropriate to design burning pressure 10 MPa).
o
Propellant Temperature ( C) Tube Fragmentation
CDB 18 Nil
" -10 2
" -30 21
" -50 36
EMCDB 18 Nil
" -10 Nil
" -30 Nil
" -50 22
HTPB 18 Nil
" -10 24
" -50 30
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
UK-34
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
UK/201.06.002
c. Information Requirements for Assessment: This test assesses the explosiveness of gun
propellants under the test conditions and enables comparisons to be made of the
vulnerability of charges differing in composition, configuration and web thickness.
d. Typical Results:
maximum
overpressure
NQ/S web (mm) at 1m (KPa)
1.42 34, 36
2.05 31, 28
3.05 24, 26
e. Repeatability and Reproducibility: For qualification three attacks at each velocity are
carried out but if the results differ by more than 25% a fourth shot is carried out.
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES
UK-35
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
UK/201.06.003
a. Type of Test: Safety/Projectile Impact - Used for Booster and Main Charge High
Explosives
3
b. Description: Approximately 260 cm of material at its normal filled density is confined in a
standard steel cylinder of wall thickness 9.5 mm. A mild steel or aluminium alloy end cap
provides a 3.0 mm thick septum which is impacted by a 13.15 mm diameter flat ended
projectile weighing 13.5 g. The projectile impact velocity is varied in the range 400 to
-1
2500 ms and the explosive response assessed.
d. Typical Results:
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
UK-36
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
UK/201.07.001
b. Description: Gun propellants are tested by loading them into a 165mm length of
combustible charge case and fitting card closures to the ends. Rocket propellants are
normally tested bare. In either case, the charge mass can be as high as 2.1kg. It is usual
to fire duplicate trials. For gun propellants it is useful to compare the test results across a
range of web sizes. Charges are supported in a steel frame that also locates spaced jet
arrestor plates, a 25mm thick conditioning plate and the shaped charge. The latter is a
o
63.5mm diameter 45 included angle copper cone. An optional second part of the test
varies the thickness of the conditioning plate until the median thickness for high order
reaction of the propellant charge is determined. Output from the propellant charge is
recorded on an air blast over-pressure gauge and the resultant peak pressure and
positive impulse readings are expressed as mass ratios by comparison with air blast
over-pressure tables for Comp B.
d. Typical Results:
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
UK-37
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
UK/202.01.001
b. Description: A standard mass of the explosive material is subjected to the short burst of
flame and hot particles emitted from the end of a length of standard gunpowder fuze.
Observations are made as to whether the sample ignites and if so whether it burns or
explodes. If a material ignites under the conditions of light confinement used, it must be
assumed that any non-electric spark will ignite it.
d. Typical Results:
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
UK-38
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
UK/202.01.002
b. Description: A standard mass of the explosive material under test is heated in duplicate
test tubes at a standard rate until an event occurs. This can be regarded as an
accelerated stability test. The actual values of "Temperature of Ignition" obtained are
meaningful only under the particular conditions used, and changing the rate of heating or
size of sample will lead to different results.
d. Typical Results:
o
FNH (gun propellant) 174 C
o
VU (rocket propellant) 185 C
o
ATN(D28)/47 (rocket propellant) 167 C
o
NQ (gun propellant) 167 C
o
Service Lead Azide 330 C
o
Lead Styphnate RD1303 269 C
o
Tetryl 183 C
o
RDX 219 C
o
PETN 186 C
o
SR44 >400 C
o
SR651 275 C
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
UK-39
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
UK/202.01.003
b. Description: The explosive material is laid in a train in a metal trough and one end of the
train is exposed to a flame for one minute.
d. Typical Results:
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
UK-40
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
UK/202.01.004
d. Typical Results:
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
UK-41
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
UK/202.01.005
a. Type of Test: Safety/Ignition - Used for Main Charge High Explosives, Booster
Explosives and Propellants
3
b. Description: Approximately 184 cm of material at its normal filled density is confined in a
standard steel cylinder of wall thickness 6.0 mm. The material is ignited using a standard
igniter and the tube fragments produced are examined and counted. Ten trials are
performed. This test is used to assess the explosiveness of a material.
d. Typical Results:
Explosive Fragments
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
UK-42
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
UK/202.01.006
a. Type of Test: Safety/Ignition - Used for Main Charge High Explosives, Booster
Explosives and Propellants
3
b. Description: Approximately 184 cm of material at its normal filled density is confined in a
standard steel cylinder of wall thickness 6.0 mm. The material is heated over a small fuel
fire and the tube fragments produced are examined and counted. Ten trials are
performed. This test is used to assess the explosiveness of a heated material.
d. Typical Results:
Explosive Fragments
Debrix 33 4
LX14 20
RDX/TNT 22
Rowanex 1001 1
PE4 >50
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
UK-43
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
UK/202.01.007
a. Type of Test: Safety/Ignition - Used for Booster, Main Charge High Explosives and
Propellants
3
b. Description: Approximately 184 cm of material at its normal filled density is confined in a
standard steel cylinder of wall thickness 6.0 mm. The material is heated at a
predetermined rate using an electrical heating winding and the tube fragments produced
are examined and counted. Trials are performed over a range of heating rates between
o o
3.3 C/hr and 10 C/min. This test is used to assess the explosiveness of a material.
d. Typical Results:
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
UK-44
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
UK/202.02.001
a. Type of Test: Thermal stability - Used for Booster, Main Charge High Explosives and
Propellants
c. Information Requirements for Assessment: Volume of gas evolved (at STP) for a given
mass of sample, temperature and duration of test. Comparison of this value to specified
maxima for test explosives.
d. Typical Results:
Test Typical
Explosive or Mass of Test time
temperature values
Propellant sample (hours) 3
(qC) (cm at STP)
RDX 5 150 24 1.7
HMX 5 120 40 0.2
PETN 2.3 120 20 4.7
PE4 5 120 40 0.7
Tetryl 5 120 40 4.5
SX2 5 120 24 0.3
KU 5 80 168 0.6
VU 5 80 168 0.6
N type 5 80 168 0.7
DX 5 80 168 1.2
CCC 5 80 168 0.5
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
UK-45
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
UK/202.02.002
a. Type of Test: Chemical stability - Used for nitrocellulose based Gun and Rocket
Propellants
c. Information Requirements for Assessment: The safe life is assessed by calculation of the
time required for 50% depletion of the initial stabilizer content at a constant 25qC
d. Typical Results:
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
UK-46
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
UK/202.02.003
a. Type of Test: Chemical stability - Used for nitrate ester based gun and rocket propellants
d. Typical Results:
Time to fume
Propellant type Stabilizer level NG level
(hours)
Small arms single
DPA 1% nil 2500-3000
base
Extruded gun triple
EC 3.5-7% 20% 5000
base
Rocket extruded
2-NDPA 1-2% 35-45% 3000
double base
Rocket cast double 2-NDPA 0.6%
35-55% 2000-2500
base pNMA 0.3%
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
UK-47
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
UK/202.02.004
TEST INFORMATION SHEET
b. Description: The test involves controlled thermal degradation of the explosive by heating
a sample (< 2g) under closely specified conditions. Evolved oxides of nitrogen are
detected by a colour change on a specially prepared starch-iodide test paper, contained
in a specified test apparatus. The time to develop a line on the test paper to the same
intensity as that of a standard tint is taken as the heat test time. The time to detection is
indicative of the intrinsic stability of the explosive at the time of test. The test cannot be
used to determine long term stability or to estimate service life.
c. Information Requirements for Assessment: The Abel Heat Test is a UK legal requirement
for military and commercial explosives. For propellants, the time to detection must be less
than 10 minutes.
d. Typical Results:
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
UK/202.02.005
TEST INFORMATION SHEET
b. Description: The 50mm cube crack test is used primarily to assess the stability of cast
double base propellants (CDB) with respect to gas cracking. It provides a measure of the
gassing rate and internal strength of the propellant. Samples of propellant are machined
into 50mm cubes, inserted into a close fitting aluminium can and then heated at 80qC for
a number of days. The cubes, three per can, are subjected to regular X-ray examinations
to detect the presence of cracks. The crack life is reported as a range in days from initial
to final observed cracking of the cubes.
c. Information Requirements for Assessment: A crack life of >10 days (initial) is regarded as
satisfactory (>7 days for EMCDB).
d. Typical Results:
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
UK-49
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
UK/302.01.001
b. Description: The test uses cylindrical charges of known density, initiated at one end with
a booster of similar diameter. The progress of the shock front is monitored using a
suitable high-speed camera, with the mirror speed adjusted to optimise the time and
distance dimensions. The length of the booster should be at least twice the diameter of
the acceptor and the cylinders should have a length to diameter ratio of at least six, but
this may vary depending on experience. Analysis should be carried out on the last two or
three diameter lengths. Where a sample is not self-illuminating, additional illumination
such as an argon flash bomb may be used.
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
UK-50
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
UK/302.02.002
a. Type of Test: Safety/Performance - Used for Booster and Main Charge High Explosives
and Propellants
o
b. Description: The test uses either a 5 included angle truncated cone and selection of
cylindrical charges or just the cylindrical charges. If the cone is used, it is initiated at its
larger diameter end with a booster of similar diameter and the progress of the shock front
is monitored using a suitable high-speed camera. The diameter at which detonation
ceases gives a good approximation to critical diameter, but for a more accurate value,
cylinders should be machined in a range of diameters close to and just above the
indicated diameter value. The cylinders should have a length to diameter ratio of at least
six, preferably eight. These are tested in the same way as the truncated cone and
monitored either with a high-speed camera or a witness plate can be used to determine
whether or not detonation is maintained.
d. Typical Results:
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
UK-51
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
10.7.15 QUALIFICATION PROCEDURES FOR THE UNITED STATES
PARAGRAPH PAGE
US-1
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
US-2
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
10.7.15.1 MILITARY DEPARTMENTS RESPONSIBLE FOR QUALIFICATION IN THE UNITED
STATES
10.7.15.1.1 Each Service, the Army, the Navy (which includes the Marine Corps), and the Air Force, is
responsible for selecting and qualifying explosive materials for its own application. This
authority is delegated from the Secretary of Defense to, respectively, the Secretary of the
Army, the Secretary of the Navy, and the Secretary of the Air Force. The Service
Secretaries delegate these responsibilities to organizations in their command. There is
no single National Qualification Authority identified for the United States. To comply with
STANAG 4170, however, the Department of Defense (DoD) has identified a Coordinating
National Authority to work with the NATO CNAD-sponsored organizations. He is the
responsible agent, in the United States for all matters relating to the implementation of
STANAG 4170; however this Coordinating National Authority does not Qualify explosive
materials or issue qualification documents.
10.7.15.1.2 To support the DoD Coordinating National Authority, each military Service has identified
an authority responsible for the qualification of explosive materials for its own needs and
to assist the Coordinating National Authority in the implementation of STANAG 4170.
These Service Authorities or their delegated representatives are responsible for staffing
all NATO correspondence and action items dealing with explosive materials qualification,
safety, and suitability for service to the proper organizations within their respective
Commands.
10.7.15.2.1 The U.S. Department of Defense National Authority for Explosives responsible for the
implementation of STANAG 4170 is as follows:
a. The DoD National Authority for Explosives performs the following functions:
(2) Coordinates the preparation, publication, and maintenance of the U.S. portion of
this manual and of AOP-26 Edition 1 – “NATO Catalogue of NATO Explosives”.
(4) Provides a DoD point of contact to NATO countries for the exchange of
information on safety and suitability for service of explosives and munitions.
(5) Oversees and sponsors, in coordination with the three U.S. Services, all DoD
activities related to the NATO AC/310 and its four subgroups.
US-3
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
a. U.S. Army:
(1) For explosive materials developed by the U.S. Army Tank-Automotive and
Armaments command:
Commander
TACOM-ARDEC
ATTN: AMSTA-AR-WEE
Picatinny Arsenal, NJ 07806-5000
(2) For explosive materials developed by the U.S. Army Missile Command:
Commander
U.S. Army Aviation and Missile Command
Redstone Arsenal, AL 35898-5249
Commander
Naval Ordnance Safety and Security Activity
23 Strauss Avenue, Bldg. D-323
Indian Head, MD 20640-5035
Executive Secretary
USAF Nonnuclear Munitions Safety Board
Air Armaments Center
nd
1001 N. 2 Street, Suite 366
Eglin Air Force Base, FL 32542-6838
(1) Defining the tests required to determine the safety and performance
characteristics of the explosives used by that Service and the associated
requirements for qualification.
(2) Receiving and assessing data for qualification generated by the various technical
organizations involved in the development of explosive materials. Determining
whether an explosive should be qualified based on test results indicating whether
that material is safe and suitable for consideration in a particular role. Ensuring
that all explosives incorporated in fielded weapon systems are qualified.
(4) Maintaining records of all explosives qualified including the data on which
qualification was based and provide such information to the other Services for
their consideration in qualification.
US-4
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
(5) Determining whether explosives qualified by the other Services are suitable for
their own applications.
The test requirements for hazard classification are not repeated in this document.
c. The qualification procedure followed by the Services provides the mandatory data for
assessing an explosive’s safety and performance characteristics related to a specific
role or a potential military application. Certain tests are required as the data are
deemed essential to the assessment process. A test method may be waived by a
Service Qualification Authority if rational is provided indicating that the mandatory
data are not relavant or can be accurately derived by using an alternative procedure.
e. Since variations exist between facilities using similar equipment for obtaining
qualification data, the data on new explosives are compared to that obtained with two
“Reference Comparison Explosives” (as defined in Chapter 4 above). The new
explosive and the comparison explosives are evaluated under the same test
conditions and with the same test apparatus. If possible, the two reference explosives
are chosen such that they bracket the sensitivity of the new explosive.
f. In general, the Service Qualification Authority will require a statement on the
processability and producibility of the new explosive material and a material
specification.
1
MIL-STD-1751A, “Safety and Performance Tests for the Qualification of Explosives (High Explosives,
Propellants, and Pyrotechnics”, Issued 11 December 2001.
2
NATO STANAG 4123, "Methods to Determine and Classify Hazards of Ammunition", has been ratified
by the United States, and is implemented by the above Tri-Service/DLA document.
US-5
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
3
MIL-STD-2105B, “Hazard Assessment Tests for Non-Nuclear Munitions” dated 12 January 1994 or
latest revision.
US-6
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
10.7.15.4 QUALIFICATION METHODS AND TESTS
10.7.15.4.1 High Explosives: These materials are qualified independently of specific end-items. The
tests and data requirements listed below for each type of high explosive materials are
required by the Service Qualification Authorities. Advisory or required pass/fail criteria are
applied for most test performed. Failure to meet any or all of the advisory criteria shall
normally be cause for rejection of the explosive. In general, the data requirements given
in STANAG 4170 and in this section of AOP-7 are used. However, other tests may be
required by the Service Qualification Authority when more data are required. Even though
multiple tests are listed below for some stimuli, it is necessary to conduct only one test for
each unless otherwise directed by the Service Qualification Authority. A brief description
of tests used to obtain the data required by the National Authorities is provided in the Test
Information Sheets provided below in section 10.7.15.7. The following is a list of
mandatory data and appropriate tests for high explosives.
a. Requirements for Primary Explosives: The following is a list of data, tests, and
advisory acceptance criteria for primary explosives:
(1) Impact Sensitivity. The data are compared to normal lead styphnate conforming
to MIL-L-757 or dextrinated lead azide conforming to Type I of MIL-L-3055,
measured contemporaneously with the candidate explosive. Tests normally
used are: Ball Drop Impact (U.S. 201.01.002), Bureau of Mines Impact (U.S.
201.01.003, ERL/Bruceton Impact Sensitivity (U.S. 201.01.001), or NATO
STANAG 4489 tests. The Ball Drop Impact test (U.S. 201.01.002) is preferred.
(2) Friction Sensitivity. The data are compared to normal lead styphnate
conforming to MIL-L-757 or dextrinated lead azide conforming to Type I of MIL-
L-3055, measured contemporaneously with the candidate explosive. The tests
normally used are: Pendulum Friction (U.S. 201.02.001), ABL Sliding Friction,
(U.S. 201.02.005), Small BAM Friction apparatus (U.S. 201.02.006), Steel/Fiber
Shoe Friction (U.S. 201.02.008), and STANAG 4487 tests.
US-7
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
(3) Electrostatic Sensitivity. The data are compared to normal lead styphnate
conforming to MIL-L-757 or dextrinated lead azide conforming to Type 1 of MIL-
L-3055, measured contemporaneously with the candidate explosive. The tests
normally used are: Electrostatic Discharge (ESD), - ARDEC Method (U.S.
201.03.001), NAWC Method (U.S. 201.03.002), and NSWC Method (U.S.
201.03.003).
(4) Stability (Constant Temperature). The advisory criterion is that there is no more
than 2 ml gas evolved per gram of explosive per 48 hours at 100 °C. The tests
normally used are: Vacuum Thermal Stability (U.S. 202.01.001), Modified
Vacuum Thermal Stability (202.01.022), and STANAG 4556 tests.
(5) Self-Heating. Although primary explosive charge sizes are not large enough to
warrant a self-heating analysis (U.S. 202.01.012), the minimum temperature for
exotherm onset is determined for information purposes using Differential
Thermal Analysis, DTA, (U.S 202.01.007), Differential Scanning Calorimetry,
DSC, (U.S. 202.01.020), or STANAG 4515 tests.
(6) Compatibility. The interaction of the explosive with common materials (e.g.,
metals, adhesives, acids, bases) that it may come into contact during
production and use is assessed. This is done by comparing the results for the
explosive in a 1:1 mixture with the material being tested with the results for the
candidate explosive alone. The advisory criterion when using DTA or DSC is a
change of no more than 10 °C in the exotherm peak temperature, measured at
a heating rate of 10 °C/minute or less. See (U.S. 203-01-001) for details.
(7) The tests normally used are: VTS (U.S. 202.01.001, CRT (U.S. 204.01.001),
DTA (U.S 202.01.007), DSC (U.S. 202.01.020), TGA (U.S. 202.01.008) or
STANAG 4515.
(8) Ignition Sensitivity. No advisory criterion. The data are compared to normal lead
styphnate conforming to MIL-L-757 or dextrinated lead azide conforming to
Type I of MIL-L-3055 measured contemporaneously with the candidate
explosive. The Hot Wire Ignition Test (U.S. 202.01.006) is used.
b. Requirements for Booster High Explosives: These materials are used in fuze
components on the warhead side of the interrupter (shutter) of safety and arming
devices and in items such as, leads, relays, ignition devices, and detonating cords.
The pass-fail criteria in the table provided in section 7.5.3.1 complimented by those
listed below are used to determine the suitability for service of booster explosives.
Normally, failing to meet one or more of these criteria is cause for rejection.
However, the Service Qualification Authority may accept the material if additional
tests show that the material is safe to use in its intended role. The following is a list of
data required, tests, and acceptance criteria for booster explosives:
(1) Impact Sensitivity. The candidate explosive passes the Impact Sensitivity Test if
it is shown to be no more sensitive than a Type I or II, Class 5 RDX standard
conforming to MIL-DTL-398, measured contemporaneously with the candidate
explosive. The tests normally used are: ERL/Bruceton Impact (U.S.
201.01.001), Bureau of Mines Impact (U.S. 201.01.003), Los Alamos Impact
US-8
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
(U.S. 201.01.004), BAM Impact (U.S. 201.01.005), or NATO STANAG 4489
tests.
(2) Friction Sensitivity. The candidate explosive passes the friction sensitivity test if
it is shown to be no more sensitive than a Type I or II, Class 5 RDX standard
conforming to MIL-DTL-398, measured contemporaneously with the candidate
explosive. The tests normally used are: Rotary Friction (U.S. 201.02.004), ABL
Sliding Friction (U.S. 201.01.005), BAM Friction (U.S. 201.02.006), Steel/Fiber
Shoe Friction (U.S. 201.02.008), or STANAG 4487 tests.
(4) Stability (Constant Temperature). The passing criterion is that no more than 2
ml gas is evolved per gram of explosive per 48 hours at 100°C when using the
Vacuum Thermal Stability, VTS, test (U.S. 202.01.001), (U.S. 202.01.022) or
STANAG 4556. When using the Chemical Reactivity Test, CRT, test (U.S.
204.01.001) the passing criterion is 4 ml gas evolved per gram of explosive per
22 hours at 120°C.
US-9
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
(9) Shock Sensitivity. Tests are performed in accordance with the NOL Small-
Scale Gap Test, (U.S. 201.04.003) or the STANAG 4488 Small-Scale Gap
Test. Twenty samples are fired using 4.0-decibang attenuators which
corresponds to an input pressure of 12.1 kbar. The explosive passes if there
are no detonations in 20 consecutive trials. Any reaction causing a dent of
0.002 inch or more in the target plate is considered a detonation.
(10) Exudation and Growth: No advisory criterion but data from tests performed per
U.S. 202.01.010 (Exudation) and U.S. 202.01.011 (Growth) are required for
TNT based explosives. Tests performed per U.S. 202.01.010 are required for
explosives containing energetic plasticizers.
c. Requirements for Main Charge High Explosives: No mandatory pass or fail criteria
are assigned. Advisory criteria are presented for several measures of sensitivity.
Failure to meet any or all of the advisory criteria is normally cause for rejection of the
explosive by the Service Qualification Authority. An exception to this preference for
rejection is made for impact and friction sensitivity for explosives containing
ammonium perchlorate. Such materials have sensitivities, as determined in these
tests that could lead to rejection. A thorough appraisal of all relevant safety data must
be made before any explosive is rejected. If a preponderance of the tests listed below
indicates that the explosive is in the same sensitivity range as booster explosives, the
Service Qualification Authority may require that the booster tests and criteria shown
above apply. The following data are required:
(1) Impact Sensitivity: The new explosive is compared both to a Type I or II,
Class 5 RDX conforming to MIL-DTL-398, measured contemporaneously
with the candidate explosive, and to a qualified main charge explosive. The
advisory criterion is that the sensitivity should be no greater than that of
Comp B conforming to MIL-C-401, cast at a density of 1.65 g/cm³. The
impact tests normally used are: ERL/Bruceton (U.S. 201.01.001), Bureau of
Mines (U.S. 201.01.003, Los Alamos Impact (U.S. 201.01.004), BAM (U.S.
201.01.005) or NATO STANAG 4489 tests.
(4) Stability (Constant Temperature): The passing criterion is that no more than
2 ml gas are evolved per gram of explosive per 48 hours at 100°C when
US-10
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
the VTS tests (U.S. 202.01.001), (U.S. 202.01.022), or STANAG 4556 are
used. When using CRT test (U.S. 204.01.001) the passing criterion is 4 ml
gas evolved per gram of explosive per 22 hours at 120°C.
(9) Shock Sensitivity. The advisory passing criterion is that the sensitivity
should be no greater than that of Comp B conforming to MIL-C-401, cast at
a density of 1.65 g/cm³. Tests used are selected as appropriate for the
critical diameter of the candidate explosive. Tests normally used are: NOL
LSGT, (U.S. 201.04.002), Expanded LSGT (U.S. 201.04.001), IHE Gap
Test (U.S. 201.04.005), Super LSGT (201.04.004) and STANAG 4488
tests.
(10) Exudation and Growth: No advisory criterion but data from tests performed
per U.S. 202.01.010 (Exudation) and U.S. 202.01.011 (Growth) are
required for TNT based explosives. Tests performed per U.S. 202.01.010
are required for explosives containing energetic plasticizers.
d. Requirements for Fuel Air Explosives: Because of the nature of these materials,
qualification is generally concurrent with Final (Type) Qualification. Specific data
requirements for qualification are assigned on a case-by-case basis by the Service
Qualification Authority. No pass of fail criterion is assigned. However, qualification,
as described herein, is required for the conventional explosives used in the fuel-air
weapon.
US-11
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
10.7.4.15.2 Propellants: Propellants are generally qualified in accordance with a specific application.
The final formulations are established late in the development cycle of the end item and
requests for qualification may be concurrent with requests for Final (Type) Qualification.
Advisory pass or fail criteria are applied for most sensitivity tests performed. Failure to
meet any or all of the advisory criteria may be cause for rejection of the propellant. In
general, the data requirements given in STANAG 4170 and in this section of AOP-7 are
used. However, other tests may be required by the Service Qualification Authority. Even
though multiple tests are listed for some stimuli, it is necessary to conduct only one test
for each unless otherwise directed by the Service Qualification Authority. A brief
description of tests used to obtain the data required by the National Authorities is provided
in the Test Information Sheets provided below in section 10.7.15.7. The following is a list
of mandatory data and appropriate tests for propellants:
a. Solid Propellants: The following tests and acceptance criteria are recommended:
(1) Impact Sensitivity: The new propellant is compared to a Type I or II, Class 5
RDX conforming to MIL-DTL-398, measured contemporaneously with the
candidate material, and to a qualified propellant used in a similar application.
The advisory criterion is that it is no more sensitive than the reference
comparison propellant. The impact tests used are: Bureau of Mines (U.S.
201.01.003, ERL/Bruceton (U.S. 201.01.003), Los Alamos Impact (U.S.
201.01.004), BAM (U.S. 201.01.005) or NATO STANAG 4489 tests.
(4) Stability (Constant Temperature): The advisory criterion is that no more than
2 ml gas is evolved per gram of explosive per 48 hours at 100°C when using
the VTS (202.01.001), (U.S. 202.01.022) or STANAG 4556 tests. When using
CRT test (U.S. 204.01.001) the passing criterion is 4 ml gas evolved per
gram of explosive per 22 hours at 120°C.
US-13
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
(4) Shock Sensitivity: The shock sensitivity is assessed using the NOL LSGT
(U.S. 201.04.002), IHE Gap Test (U.S. 201.04.005) or STANAG 4488 tests.
(5) Flash Point: The test is performed and the results are reported for information
purposes. No advisory criterion is provided. The test normally used is (U.S.
201.08.002). TGA (U.S. 202.01.008) may be used for liquid propellants with
low volatility.
(6) Minimum Pressure for Vapor Phase Ignition: The test is performed and the
results are reported for information purposes. The minimum pressure for
vapor phase ignition is verified using (U.S. 201.08.001).
US-14
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
Mandatory Data / Test Pyrotechnics
Impact sensitivity x
Friction sensitivity x
Electrostatic sensitivity x
Stability (Constant Temperature) x
Self-heating x
Compatibility x
a. Mandatory Tests and Data Requirements: No passing criteria are assigned; however,
advisory criteria are provided for each stimulus. Even though multiple tests are listed
for some stimuli, it is necessary to conduct only one test for each unless otherwise
directed by the Service Qualification Authority. The following data are required for
qualification:
(1) Impact Sensitivity: The impact sensitivity is compared to that of a Type I or II,
Class 5 RDX standard conforming to MIL-DTL-398, measured
contemporaneously with the candidate pyrotechnic and to a qualified
pyrotechnic material used in a similar application. The advisory acceptance
criterion is that the candidate be no more sensitive than the reference
comparison pyrotechnic. The impact tests normally used are: ERL/Bruceton
(U.S. 201.01.001), Bureau of Mines (U.S. 201.01.003, Los Alamos Impact (U.S.
201.01.004), BAM (U.S. 201.01.005) or NATO STANAG 4489 tests.
(2) Friction Sensitivity: The friction sensitivity is compared to that of a Type I or II,
Class 5 RDX standard conforming to MIL-DTL-398, measured
contemporaneously with the candidate pyrotechnic and to a qualified
pyrotechnic material used in a similar application. The advisory acceptance
criterion is that the candidate be no more sensitive than the reference
comparison pyrotechnic. The friction tests normally used are: Sliding Friction
(U.S. 201.02.005), Rotary Friction (U.S. 201.02.004), BAM (U.S. 201.02.006),
Steel/Fiber Shoe (U.S. 201.02.008) or STANAG 4487 tests.
US-15
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
(5) Self Heating: Self heating is assessed by calculation. The data required for this
calculation is acquired by DTA (U.S. 202.01.007) or DSC (U.S. 202.01.020).
The critical temperature is estimated using (U.S. 201.02.012).
(6) Compatibility: The interaction of the new pyrotechnic with materials (e.g.,
metals, adhesives, acids, bases) with which it may come into contact in
production and use is assessed. The results for the candidate pyrotechnic in a
1:1 mixture with the material being tested for compatibility is compared with the
results for the candidate material alone. The advisory criterion when using DTA
or DSC is no change greater than 10°C in the exotherm peak temperature,
measured at a heating rate of 10°C/minute or less. The tests normally used
are: DTA (U.S 202.01.007), DSC (U.S. 202.01.020). TGA (U.S. 202.01.008) or
STANAG 4515.
US-16
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
10.7.15.5 TESTS PERFORMED TO OBTAIN MANDATORY DATA
a. In general, the tests acceptable to the U.S. Service Qualification authorities and used
to acquire the data necessary to satisfy the requirements of STANAG 4170 are
described in Standardization Agreements, STANAGS, prepared by the AC/310
Subgroup 1 (Explosive Materials) and in Test Information Sheets catalogued in this
document. The STANAGs that may be used from time to time by the Service
Qualification Authorities are listed below. The other tests used by the Qualification
authorities and not necessarily covered by STANAGS are described in the Test
Information Sheets section provided below.
Tests STANAG No
US-17
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
US-19
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
US-20
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
10.7.15.7 CATALOGUE OF TEST INFORMATION SHEET FOR THE UNITED STATES
NOTE: The Test Information Sheets are compiled consecutively in accordance with their
Registry Number.
US-21
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
US-22
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
US/102.01.001
b. Description: The test specimens are prepared by die cutting or milling. Configuration and
dimensions use the JANNAF specifications. The JANNAF Class C (dogbone) sample is
die cut. The JANNAF Class A specimen, a milled truncated Class C configuration
specimen with tabs (usually aluminum) bonded to the ends, is used to obtain more
accurate results. The specimens are measured and conditioned at the test temperature
for a minimum of one hour prior to testing. An Instron, or equivalent tester with
temperature conditioning chamber and appropriate fixtures, load cells, and readout
equipment is listed for applying extension to the specimen at a constant crosshead rate.
c. Information Requirements for Assessment: Data from these tests are used to
characterize propellant response and failure behavior.
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
(1) JANNAF Solid Propellant Mechanical Behavior Manual, CPIA Publication 21,
Sections 4.3, March 1971, and 4.3.2 October 1988.
US-23
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
US/102.01.071
c. Information Requirements for Assessment: The value of specific gravity (or density) is
necessary for calculations in the design of the motor, and/or the determination of output
characteristics.
d. Typical Results: Most propellants have density values about 1.8 g/cc.
e. Repeatability and Reproducibility: Since the density vs. temperature values of both water
and mercury are known and precise, the test is considered very repeatable and
reproducible. Accuracy depends on the equipment used.
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
US-24
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
US/102.01.251
b. Description: The Guarded Meter method used to determine the thermal conductivity of
insulating materials (Ref. 1) and the method for estimating the thermal conductivity of
leather with the Cenco-Fitch apparatus (Ref. 2) were modified to provide a method to
determine the thermal conductivity of explosive materials. This method provides a one-
dimensional transient heat conduction between two faces of a flat specimen 102 mm x
102 mm x 6.4 mm. One face of the specimen is heated by a copper plate held at a
constant temperature, while the opposite face of the specimen yields its heat to a known
mass of a thermally isolated copper disc. The temperature-time profile of the isolated
disc yields the required thermal conductivity of the specimen.
c. Information Requirements for Assessment: This test provides background information for
qualification of explosives.
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
US-25
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
US/102.01.275
b. Description: Care must be taken to assure that minimum clearances are maintained
between explosive charges and containers in the upper range of storage or operating
temperatures because of different expansion coefficients of explosives and container
materials. The coefficient of thermal expansion is measured with a bulk mercury
dilatometer or with a standard laboratory linear expansion test apparatus. If the material
is known to be isotropic, its cubic expansion coefficient is calculated by multiplying its
linear coefficient by three.
c. Information Requirements for Assessment: This test provides background information for
qualification of explosives.
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
US-26
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
US/201.01.001
c. Information Requirements for Assessment: Fifty percent impact height of the test material
determined by the Bruceton method is compared to two reference comparison explosives
tested on the same machine under the same test conditions. A minimum of 20 shots per
sample is used to determine a 50% point.
d. Typical Results:
Lead Azide 4
PETN, Class 4 13
RDX, Type I or II, Class 5 18
Tetryl 38
TNT, Type I or II 78
HMX, Grade B, Class 1 19
HMX, Grade B, Class 5 28
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
(1) Walker, G. R., Whitbread, E. G., and Hornig, D. C., ed. Manual of Sensitiveness
Tests, Balcartier, Quebec, Canada: Canadian Armament Research and
Development Establishment. Published for Tripartite Technical Cooperation
Program (TTCP), Panel O-2 (Explosives), Working Group on Sensitiveness,
February 1966.
(2) NATO STANAG 4489, Explosives, Impact Sensitivity Test(s).
(3) Dixon, W. J., and Massey, F. M. Jr., Introduction to Statistical Analysis. 2nd ed.
New York: McGraw-Hill Co., Inc., 1957.
(4) MIL-STD-1751A issued on 11 December 2001, Method 1012.
US-27
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
US/201.01.002
b. Description: The apparatus consists of a free falling steel ball, a movable platform on a
vertical stand, and a hardened steel anvil block to hold the explosive powder. The
steel ball, 1.3 cm (1/2-inch diameter), weighing 8.35 grams, is made from chrome alloy
steel and has a Rockwell C hardness of 64-66. By means of a platform (ball-track) on a
vertical stand, the steel ball is dropped from heights varying by 2.50 cm (1-inch)
increments onto the explosive powder spread in a 0.330 mm (0.013-inch) thick layer on a
hardened and polished steel block. The anvil is made of steel hardened to Rockwell C
60-62.
d. Typical Results:
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
US-28
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
US/201.01.003
e. Typical Results:
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
(2) Becker, K.R., Bureau of Mines Instrumented Impact Tester. U.S. Department of Interior,
Bureau of Mines, Report of Investigations 7670, 1972.
(3) Dixon, W.J., and Mood, A.M., “Method for Obtaining and Analyzing Sensitivity Data.”
Journal of the American Statistics Association. 43: 109-126, 1948.
(4) Dixon, W.J., and Massey, A.M. Jr. Introduction to Statistical Analysis. 2nd Ed. New York:
McGraw-Hill Co., Inc., 1957, pp. 318-327.
US-29
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
US/201.01.004
The original drop weight was a hollow, conical, truncated nose-tipped cylinder fabricated
of tool steel hardened to 60 HRC. The redesigned drop weight has the same general
external appearance and the same weight of 5.5 pounds (2.5 kg). It consists of a steel
core hardened to 55-58 HRC surrounded by a solid case of Dural (aluminum alloy). The
redesign concentrates more of the mass centrally, along the line of impact.
d. Typical Results:
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
US-30
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
US/201.01.005
b. Description: This test was developed to evaluate the sensitivity of solid and liquid
substances to a normal impact. The device consists of a cast steel block whose base is
bolted to a concrete block. Imbedded in the steel block is the main anvil on which an
intermediate anvil holding the impact device rests. Guide rails, which are attached to the
steel block, facilitate free vertical movement of the drop weight and release mechanism. A
toothed rack is incorporated into one of the guide rails to arrest the rebounding drop
weight. The drop weight is positioned at various heights by means of a motor driven
winch. Drop weights of 1, 2, 5, and 10 kg are available for testing.
Solid explosive substances are tested dry. Powders are sieved and the fraction with a
particle size ranging from 0.5 to 1.0 mm is used. Pressed, cast, and otherwise compacted
substances are crushed and then sieved. Liquid explosives are tested without
preparation.
A limited number of tests are performed to ensure that results group together fairly well. A
25-shot test is then performed using a Bruceton analysis to determine a 50% point. In
judging test results, reactions are classified as either "no reaction," decomposition, or
explosion.
c. Information Requirements for Assessment: The device is calibrated using Type I or II,
Class 5 RDX, conforming to MIL-R-398, as the standard reference material.
d. Typical Results:
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
US-31
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
US/201.01.006
b. Description: This test is conducted using either the Picatinny Arsenal (PA) apparatus or
the U.S. Bureau of Mines (BoM) apparatus. Each apparatus is used with two variations,
one for solid and one for liquid explosives. The PA apparatus consists of an anvil, two
guide bars equipped with an adjustable support for a weight, vented plugs, die cups, and
die cup covers. This machine is used with weights of 2 kg, 1 kg, or 1 pound. The lighter
weights are used for the more sensitive materials. A yoke equipped with a release pin is
attached to two bars, which serve as guides for the falling weight. The yoke can be
moved to the desired height and held in place by hand screws. The BoM apparatus
consists of an impact block, a plunger and one of three weights (500, 1000, 2000 gm),
which can be dropped from any height from 1 to 100 cm. The weight is raised by an
encased magnetic coil, held in place by sleeves, and attached to two guide bars. A
contact point on the yoke breaks the electromagnetic circuit and allows the weight to fall
when it is touched by the contact point on the top of the magnetic coil. The Picatinny
apparatus used for this test is based on an older BoM design and is not to be confused
with the apparatus used in AOP-7 Registry No. 201.01.003.
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
US-32
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
US/201.01.007
b. Description: This test is used to determine the impact sensitivity explosives in powder
and liquid form. Results are reported at the 50% point using a Bruceton analysis and are
Compared to a Type I or II, Class 5 RDX standard conforming to MIL-DTL-398. A 3.6 kg
(8-pound) weight suspended between two cylindrical guide rods is used. The maximum
drop height is 83.8 cm (33 inches). Both solids and liquids can be tested with this
machine. For solids, the weight is dropped on a plunger and plug assembly in contact
with the explosive. For liquids, one drop is placed in a copper cup fixed in a positioning
block. A sticker is placed over a cup positioning block partly into the cup but not touching
the explosive. The assembly is placed on the same mechanism as used for solids.
d. Typical Results:
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
US-33
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
US/201.01.008
b. Description: A hollow drop weight of 5 kg is usually used and a 2.5 kg weight is also
available. Half of the mass of the weight consists of loose lead shot. An electric hoist
positions an electromagnet, which suspends the drop weight at any desired height up to
177 cm. A pair of rollers attached to the weight guides the fall of the weight. The rollers
run in groves cut in the parallel vertical tracks. The test may be conducted with or without
flint paper. In its absence, the explosive sample is placed directly on the anvil. The
sample may or may not be pelletized before testing.
d. Typical Results:
50% Point for 5 kg (cm)
Explosive With Without
Flint Paper Flint Paper
PETN (powder) 11 20
Tetryl (powder) 24 30
RDX (pellet) 28 --
HMX (pellet) 29 39
TNT (pellet) 76 --
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
US-34
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
US/201.01.009
b. Description: Test samples are placed on the flat metal surface (typically 12.7 mm
diameter) of an anvil. A metal impact hammer, with flat contact surface equal in size and
shape to the anvil surface, is brought to rest on the propellant sample. A 2 kg weight is
dropped on the hammer, and initiation is detected visually, audibly, or by other sensory
means and by infrared analysis of decomposition products. The threshold initiation level
is defined as 20 consecutive trials in which no initiation occurs at a drop height of one
level below that level in which at least one initiation occurred in 20 trials. Strict calibration
and sample preparation techniques are used to increase result repeatability. All samples
are conditioned at fixed temperature and humidity prior to testing. Solid propellant
samples are tested at 0.84 mm thickness. Gun propellant samples are tested lying on
their long dimension, in a monolayer for smaller granules, and are also tested in ground
form in a monolayer to simulate dust. Impact force and duration are measured for
calibration purposes and the impact machine calibrated regularly to ensure consistent
results. Hammer and anvil materials are changed for special tests.
d. Typical Results: Standard finished propellants are initiated by drop heights of 100-130
mm, depending on formulation and granule size. Sensitivity decreases when testing
larger granules.
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
(1) "Chemical Rocket/Propellant Hazards", CPIA PUB No. 194, Vol. II, May 1970.
US-35
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
US/201.01.010
b. Description: This test is performed with a standard impact apparatus described for
Registry Nos. 201.01.001, 005 and 009. The liquid test sample (0.03 ml) is enclosed in a
cavity formed by a steel cup, an elastic ring, and a steel diaphragm. A piston rests on the
diaphragm and carries a vent hole that is blocked by the steel diaphragm. A 2 kg weight
is dropped onto the piston. A positive result is indicated by a puncture of the steel
diaphragm accompanied by a loud noise or severe deformation of the diaphragm and
evidence that the sample was completely consumed. Data are reported as the height at
which it yields a 50% probability of initiation.
d. Typical Results: Tests are performed up to 91.4 cm (36 inch) drops, at which point the
hydrostatic pressure developed by the impact is sufficient to burst the diaphragm even
with non-explosive materials (e.g., water).
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
US-36
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
US/201.02.001
b. Description: This test is performed with a weighted pendulum. The lower end is attached
to a shoe with an interchangeable face of steel or fiber. The shoe is permitted to fall from
a height of 1-1.5 meters and sweep back and forth, across a grooved steel friction anvil.
The pendulum is adjusted to pass across the anvil 18 + 1 times before coming to rest
when no explosive is present. A 7-gram sample of explosive is spread in and about the
grooved of the anvil and the shoe is allowed to sweep back and forth over the anvil until it
comes to rest. The number of sweeps, cracklings, ignitions, and/or explosions is noted.
d. Typical Results:
Composition B -- Passed
PETN Passed Failed
TNT -- Passed
Tetryl Passed Failed
RDX Passed --
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
US-37
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
US/201.02.002
b. Description: This test and apparatus is similar to AOP-7 Registry No. 201.02.001. It is
based on the design originated by the Bureau of Mines. The bob of a weighted
pendulum, a curved plate called a "shoe", is allowed to brush across the explosive sample
at a low angle of incidence to the horizontal. The observations made and recorded are
"explosion", "burning", "local crackling", and "no local crackling".
d. Typical Results:
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
US-38
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
US/201.02.003
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
NOTE: The NAWC has no longer use a pendulum friction machine. The NAWC uses, chiefly, an ABL
friction tester but for certain materials, a BAM tester is also used.
US-39
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
US/201.02.004
b. Description: For High Explosives and Propellants the friction sensitivity of an explosive
material is measured by applying a vertical force to a piston resting on the test specimen,
which is contained in a rotating cup. The normal load on the sample can be varied to
utilize an up and down test method for determining the 50 percent fire point. The
rotational speed is held constant at 2000 RPM. The maximum test duration is 10
seconds, and if no fire or explosion occurs within this time, the test is considered
negative.
Reaction levels reported for Fire are: “Fire”, “Spark”, or “Burn”. Reaction levels reported
for No-Fire are “Melt”, “Glaze”, or “No detectable change in the physical state”.
d. Typical Results: Pyrotechnic compositions samples yielding "FIRE" results below 100
foot-pounds are normally considered sensitive to friction. Typical examples of results are:
Explosive Result
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
(1) Armour, Carl and Smith, Lloyd A., The Invention of a New Type of Friction
Sensitivity Apparatus, ROTR No. 60, 11 June 1965, Naval Weapons Support
Center, Crane, Indiana. (AD 617382).
US-40
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
US/201.02.005
b. Description: This test simulates the conditions occurring when a material is subjected to
a frictional force between moving surfaces. A sample is placed on an anvil, a known
force is applied hydraulically through a stationary wheel, and a pendulum is used to propel
the sliding anvil to a known velocity perpendicular to the force vector. Normally, sample
initiation is detected audibly, visually, or by other sensory means. Sample size is
approximately 50 mg. A valid test is comprised of twenty consecutive negatives and at
least one initiation at the next highest test level. Force levels are usually decreased by
25% increments. Velocity levels are reduced 30.5 cm/sec (1 ft/sec) whenever an initiation
is obtained at 4.5 kg (10 lb force) and the standard test velocity of 244 cm/sec (8 ft/sec).
Reported values are the calibrated velocity and final force gauge reading.
d. Typical Results:
Explosive Result
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
US-41
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
US/201.02.006
b. Description: The BAM apparatus consists of a reciprocating sample table that holds a
porcelain sample plate and a lever arm to which is attached a porcelain pin. Weights of
varying mass are attached at different distances on the lever arm to adjust the force
applied on a sample placed between the porcelain pin and plate. The sample table is
driven by an eccentric arm attached to a geared-down electric motor that executes one
revolution of the eccentric arm (one full cycle of reciprocating motion in the horizontal
direction) when the motor is actuated. The 50% probability level of initiation is determined
by an "up and down" Bruceton method. This level is reported as a load in Newtons
d. Typical Results:
Initiation Level
Explosive
50% Point (Newtons)
PETN, Class 4 56
Lead azide, Type I or II 10
RDX, Type I or II, Class 1 96
5'; 128
HMX, Grade B, Class 1 80
TNT, Type I or II > 360
Composition B, Type I > 360
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
(1) Harris, J., "Friction Sensitivity of Primary Explosives", ARRADCOM Technical Report
ARLCD-TR-82012, September 1982.
(2) NATO STANAG 4487, Friction Sensitivity Tests for the Qualification of Explosives for
Military Use.
US-42
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
US/201.02.007
d. Typical Results: Most standard finished propellants are initiated in the 68 - 110 kg
(150-250 lb) force range at 240 cm/sec velocity.
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
(1) "Chemical Rocket/Propellant Hazards", CPIA Publication No. 194, Vol. II, May
1970.
US-43
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
US/201.02.008
b. Description: The pendulum friction device consists of a steel swinging shoe, which is the
bob of a pendulum. The frame supporting the pendulum is known as the "A-frame". The
two free-bases of the A-frames at the lower ends of the device can be raised or lowered
simultaneously, thus controlling the friction between the shoe and anvil. In testing, a steel
shoe or one faced with red-hard fiber (called the "hard-fiber-faced shoe") may be used.
This facing is fixed permanently to the face of the particular shoe to which it is attached.
Seven gram samples are normally used. Results reported as "explosion", "burning", "local
crackling", "no local crackling", "snaps", or "unaffected".
An automatic tripper is used to allow the shoe to be dropped upon the anvil from any
desired vertical height ranging from 50 to 200 cm. Height of drop normally used is 100
cm. This test should be conducted in a temperature controlled room so that the
temperature of the anvil and shoe is 70 ± 5°F.
c. Information Requirements for Assessment: Twenty trials are conducted using the steel
shoe or fiber shoe. To pass, the test material using the steel shoe should not react in any
of the twenty trials.
d. Typical Results:
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
(2) Munroe, Charles E. and Tiffany, J.E., Physical Testing of Explosives at the
Bureau of Mines Explosives Experiment Station, Bruceton, PA. U.S. Dept. of
Commerce, Bureau of Mines, Bulletin 346, 1931. pp.78-84.
US-44
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
US/201.03.001
The electrostatic sensitivity test is divided into two parts. Part I is a screening test devised
to distinguish between relatively insensitive and relatively sensitive materials to
electrostatic. Part II is a more intensive procedure used to rank or to determine the energy
required to ignite the sensitive materials.
c. Information Requirements for Assessment: For tests performed according reference (2)
no reaction in twenty out of twenty trials at 0.25 joules is a pass.
d. Typical Results:
Booster and main charge explosives are subjected to a 0.25 Joule test. If a sample is
initiated at that energy level, the material is evaluated like a primary explosive.
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
US-45
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
US/201.03.002
2. TEST TITLE: Electrostatic Discharge Sensitivity – Naval Air Warfare Center Method
c. Information Requirements for Assessment: The test is begun at the 0.25 joule (0.02 µF)
level. If results are negative, i.e., no reaction, the test is continued until 20 consecutive
failures are reported. If the test sample has a positive result, i.e., flash, spark, burn, odor,
or noise other than instrument noise, then testing is performed at the next lower level until
20 consecutive failures are reported. The test is normally conducted at 5 kVdc at an
ambient temperature of between +65 and +90°F, and a relative humidity not exceeding 40
percent. A reference standard, such as Class 5 RDX, is tested in conjunction with the test
sample. This test measures the relative ease with which powders or solids can be ignited
by electrostatic (DC) discharge. Testing is normally conducted in the range of 0.001 to
0.25 Joule (0.02 F, 100 - 5000 V). This test will indicate high sensitivity, but it is not
designed for precision testing of highly sensitive materials such as primary explosives.
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
US-46
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
US/201.03.003
2. TEST TITLE: Electrostatic Discharge Sensitivity Test - (Naval Surface Warfare Center Method)
TNT 1.72 NA
PETN 0.095 NA
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
US-47
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
US/201.03.004
b. Description: The setup consists of a high voltage power supply, a high efficiency capacitor
(34.7nF) with independent coupling, an explosive sample, negative and positive brass
electrodes, and high voltage cables. The positive electrode is a 10 mm diameter by 210
mm in length brass rod with the end in contact with the test charge tapered to a 60° conical
shape. The negative electrode is a brass disk 110 mm in diameter by 5 mm thick.
The explosive material is placed between a conical positive electrode and a negative plane
electrode. The bare explosive sample or the one contained in the PMMA holder is
subjected to a series of electrostatic discharges with a fixed intensity of 15.6 joules. This
energy level is obtained by charging the selected capacitor to 30kV. After each discharge,
the explosive material behavior is noted. Consecutive discharges are then repeated until
an explosive reaction is observed or up to 30 discharges, whichever comes first. The test
is then repeated in triplicate on two additional samples of the same energetic component.
c. Information Requirements for Assessment: Explosive samples are tested in one of two
ways: (1) As bare billets, 90 mm in diameter by 90 mm long, with one face painted with a
conductive silver lacquer and (2) as granular or powder samples placed in a
polymethylmethacrylate (PMMA) container with 90 mm I.D., 102 mm O.D., and a length of
125 mm with a polyvinylchloride cover plate with a center hole for the electrode glued on
top of the container.
d. Typical Results: Sample behavior is defined according to the following reaction levels:
(1) No reaction
(2) Rising of the cover with flash
(3) Fragmentation of the explosive billet
(4) Combustion/burning
(5) Detonation
The explosive sample is judged to have failed the test if the results of (3), (4), and (5)
above are noted on any one of the three samples after 30 ESD pulses are performed on
each.
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
(1) NATO STANAG 4490, Explosives, Electrostatic Discharge Sensitivity Test, Large
Scale.
US-48
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
US/201.03.006
b. Description: The test sample is placed on a grounded metal plate. A needle, which is
connected to a charged capacitor, is lowered toward the sample on the plate until
discharge occurs. Initiation of the sample is detected visually, audibly, or by other sensory
means and by infrared analysis of decomposition products. Threshold initiation level is
defined as the level of energy at which no initiation occurs in 20 consecutive trials, with at
least one initiation in 20 trials at the next higher energy level. The sample is distributed as
a monolayer of dust or granules of known size for gun propellants and 0.76 mm thick for
other solid propellant samples. Samples are conditioned before testing. Typical tests are
o
in the 4000 to 5000 Volt level. Tests are performed at 70 F, 50% relative humidity.
d. Typical Results: Most standard finished propellant granules are initiated by discharges of 1
to over 5 Joules depending on the composition and granule size of the propellant. Dusts
are initiated by discharges of 0.2 to 1.5 Joules, depending on the particle size and
composition.
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
(1) "Chemical Rocket/Propellant Hazards", CPIA Publication No. 194, Vol. II, May
1970.
US-49
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
US/201.03.007
d. Typical Results: Results are reported as "FIRE" or "NO FIRE". Typical examples of
results are:
Explosive Result
RDX FIRE
(at 0.019 Joules [50%])
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
(1) Test Procedure for Electrostatic Sensitivity, WQEC TP 3403-47, 22 March 1976, Naval
Weapons Support Center, Crane, Indiana.
US-50
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
US/201.04.001
b. Description: This is a scaled version of the NOL Large Scale Gap Test (201.04.002). It is
used for evaluating the shock sensitivity of explosives that can not be evaluated in the
LSGT because of critical diameter constraints. The dimensions of the acceptor system of
the ELSGT apparatus are twice the dimensions of the acceptor system of the LSGT
apparatus. The dimensions of the donor system of the ELSGT are 1.875 times larger than
the dimensions of the donor system of the LSGT system. The witness plate thickness is
scaled by a factor of two.
The gap components are made from a 3.75-inch diameter cast polymethylmethacrylate
3 3
(PMMA) rod stock having a density of 0.0078 lb/in (1.185 g/cm ). The gap size is prepared
by stacking various component thicknesses of standard PMMA blocks. Standard
thicknesses are 4.0, 2.0, 1.0, 0.5, 0.25, 0.2, 0.1, .050, .025, and .010 inches. As required,
circular layers of 0.010-inch thick cellulose acetate are used to adjust the gap to the
desired thickness.
Acceptors are cast directly into the charge body or machined to a diameter that is small
enough to enable them to slide into the cold-drawn, mild-steel tubes. If required, chilling
the acceptor to permit a slip fit into the tubes is permissible. The tubes are fabricated from
seamless tubing with the ends machined to ± 0.010 inch of the desired length. The tube
has an inner and outer diameter of 2.88 inches and 3.75 inches, respectively, while the
length is 11.00 inches.
c. Information Requirements for Assessment: Explosive density and Gap thickness for 50%
point.
d. Typical Results:
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
(1) Jaffe, I., Beauregard, R.L., and Amster, A.B., The Attenuation of Shock in Lucite,
NAVORD 6876, May 1960.
(2) Liddiard, T.P. and Price, D., The Expanded Large-Scale Gap Test, NSWC TR
86-32, March 1987.
(3) Tasker, D.G. and Baker, R.N., Experimental Calibration of the NSWC Expanded
Large Scale Gap Test, NSWC TR 92-54, January 1992.
(4) MIL-STD-1751A issued on 11 December 2001, Method 10134.
US-51
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
US/201.04.002
2. TEST TITLE: Shock Sensitivity - NOL Large-Scale Gap Test (LSGT) Method.
d. Typical Results:
3
Explosive % TMD Density (g/cm ) 50% point (mm)*
RDX - pressed 91.0 1.64 82.0 (3.23 in)
Tetryl - pressed 94.8 1.64 60.5 (2.38 in)
Comp B - cast 97.7 1.70 51.1 (2.01 in)
TNT - cast 98.2 1.61 33.8 (1.33 in)
Pentolite 95.9 1.64 71.1 (2.80 in)
(50/50) cast
* The test result is the gap in inches that corresponds to a 50% probability of detonation of
the test explosive.
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
(1) Price, D, Clairmont, A. R., Jr., and Erkman, J.O., “The NOL Large-Scale Gap Test.
III. Compilation of Unclassified Data and Supplementary Information for
Interpretation of Results”, NOLTR 74-40, March 1974.
(2) Erkman, J.O., Edwards, D.J., Clairmont, A.R., Jr., and Price, D., “Calibration of the
NOL Large-Scale Gap Test; Hugonoit Data for Polymethyl Methacrylate”, NOLTR
73-15, April 1973.
US-52
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
US/201.04.003
2. TEST TITLE: Explosive Shock Sensitivity Test - NOL Small-Scale Gap Method.
c. Information Requirements for Assessment: Density of the explosive, gap thickness, and
calibration curve.
d. Typical Results:
*Value of point representing 50% probability of a fire. The unit of initiation intensity is
called the gap decibang.
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
US-53
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
US/201.04.004
TEST INFORMATION SHEET
b. Description: This test is applicable to explosives with critical diameters ranging up to 7.0
inches. The donor is an 8-inch diameter by 8-inch long unconfined Composition B cylinder
initiated with an electric detonator boosted with a 1-inch diameter by 1 inch thick
Composition A-5 pellet. Polymethylmethacrylate (PMMA) disks stacked to various
thicknesses are used to attenuate the shock. The disks are 8 inches in diameter and
range from .063 to 2.00 inches thick. The acceptor charge is cast into a 0.50 inch thick
steel case with an O.D. of 8 inches and a length of 16 inches. Piezoelectric pins, used to
measure detonation velocity, are spaced every 2 inches along the acceptor charge with the
first pin being 1/2 inch from the forward explosive metal interface. A mild steel (e.g. SAE
1015 - 1026) witness plate is used to evaluate whether a detonation has occurred. The
evaluation is similar to that used in performing the LSGT and ELSGT tests.
c. Information Requirements for Assessment: The plate is inspected after each shot with a
positive result or "go" defined as a neat hole punched in the plate. An example of a
negative result or "no-go" is a broken plate or one with a poor quality hole. Twelve charges
are usually required to obtain the mean or 50% point.
d. Typical Results:
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
(2) Glenn, J. G. Aubert, S. A.; and Gunger, M. E., “Development and Calibration of a
Super Large Scale Gap Test,” WL-TR-96-7039, August 1996.
US-54
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
US/201.04.005
TEST INFORMATION SHEET
2. TEST TITLE: Shock Sensitivity - Insensitive High Explosive (IHE) Gap Test
The test samples are conditioned at 25 °C for 4 hours prior to test. “A detonator (E1A, No.
8 blasting cap, or equivalent EBW detonator) is used to initiate the pentolite donors. For
the first test, no attenuator is used in order to obtain an example of a “go”. A "go" is
defined as a dent exceeding half the depth of the result obtained without an attenuator.
d. Typical Results:
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
(1) Adolph, Horst, The Insensitive High Explosives Gap Test, NSWC TR 86-058,
January 15, 1987.
(2) Spivak, Timothy, et al., Insensitive High Explosives Gap Test Data, NSWC TR
88-282, September 30, 1988.
(3) Erkman, J.O., Edwards, D.J., Clairmont, A.R., Jr., and Price, D., Calibration of the
NOL Large-Scale Gap Test; Hugonoit Data for Polymethyl Methacrylate, NOLTR
73-15, April 1973.
(4) MIL-STD-1751A issued on 11 December 2001, Method 1045.
US-55
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
US/201.04.006
The wedges are prepared by casting the explosive into the Plexiglas mold . The wedges
are radiographed to check for defects and density variations. A plane wave generator
introduces a planar shock wave into the booster charge. The booster charge detonates,
introducing a shock wave into the attenuator plates and hence, into the explosive wedge
sample. Different booster/attenuator combinations can be used to vary the input pressure
into the sample.
A streak camera is used to record the event. The surface of the wedge is mirrored to
reflect light into the camera. A laser is used to align the test fixture and the light sources to
the streak camera axis. When either the shock wave or detonation wave reaches the
surface, the surface distorts so that light is no longer reflected into the camera. As the
detonation wave overtakes the shock wave, the slope of the reflected light trace on the film
changes. Thus, the run to detonation point can be determined from the film record.
c. Information Requirements for Assessment: The results of a series of wedge tests are
presented as plots of input pressure versus distance and time to detonation (Pop-plots).
These plots are used to determine the relative sensitivity of explosive materials.
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
(1) Davis, W. C. and Craig, B. G., “Smear Camera Technique for Free Surface
Velocity Measurement,” Review of Scientific Instruments, Vol. 32, No. 5, May
1961, p. 579.
(2) Craig, B. G., Personal Communication, May 1987.
(3) Gibbs, T. R. and Popolato, A., eds., LASL Explosive Property Data, University of
California Press, Berkeley, CA, 1980, pp. 295-296.
(4) Los Alamos Scientific Laboratory, Selected Hugoniots, by Group GMX-6, Report
LA-4167MS, Los Alamos, NM, May 1969.
(5) Lindfors, Allen J. and Sandstrom, Frederick W., Wedge Test Results for
PBXN-107 Type II, NWC TM 6792, Naval Weapons Center, China Lake, CA, July
1990.
(6) MIL-STD-1751A issued on 11 December 2001, Method 1046.
US-56
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
US/201.04.007
b. Description: The test elements consist of a donor explosive consisting of two tetryl pellets,
cast Aerowax spacers (gap), the test explosive, and a metal witness plate. The witness
plate is used to determine whether the test result was a "go" or "no-go".
d. Typical Results:
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
US-57
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
US/201.04.008
d. Typical Results:
e. Repeatability and Reproducibility: The thresholds for burning reactions are repeatable
and reproducible. To determine the threshold of the test sample in terms of pressure
requires knowledge of the unreacted Hugoniot of the test material.
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
(1) Frankel, M. J., Liddiard, T. P., and Forbes, J. W., "Low- Level Shock Reaction
Thresholds in High Explosives and Propellants", Combustion and Flame, Vol. 45,
No. 1, January 1982.
US-58
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
US/201.04.009
b. Description: This test determines whether or not a high explosive can be initiated by a
blasting cap. The sample, a 5-cm (2-inch) cube, is centered on top of a 4-cm (1.57 inch)
diameter solid lead cylinder, and a # 8 electric blasting cap (or equivalent) is centered
perpendicular to and in contact with the top flat surface of the sample, using a 5-cm
(2-inch) diameter wood or cork cylinder with a hole drilled in the center to position and
secure the blasting cap to the sample. The cap is detonated and evidence of sample
detonation is considered to be deformation (mushrooming) of the lead cylinder, which
rests on a steel plate.
c. Information Requirements for Assessment: This test determines the initiability of high
explosives and propellants.
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
US-59
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
US/201.05.001
b. Description: This test employs a 5.4 kg (12 lb) projectile which contains slightly less than
0.45 kg (1 lb) of test explosive. The projectiles are fired from a smooth bore converted
(3"/70) Naval gun. The gun muzzle is 3.6 m (12 ft) from the target plate. The projectile
velocities range from 100 to 1400 feet per second (fps), although velocities up to 3500 fps
are possible. If the explosive survives the initial impact in this test, other energy transfer
mechanisms become dominant. After impact there is a rapid viscous flow of the
explosive followed by friction associated with crushing, and eventually a "pinch" stage for
explosive caught between the rear section of the projectile and the steel target plate.
d. Typical Results: Refer to SUSAN sensitivity curves in the detailed Procedure and
Expression of Results segments of the detailed method description of this test.
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
US-60
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
US/201.08.001
b. Description: This test is used to determine the minimum pressure below which it is
impossible to ignite a monopropellant vapor or fuel vapor-air mixture by using a fixed
quantity of energy applied in a well-defined manner. The apparatus consists of a
thermostat equipped stainless-steel bomb into which vapor or vapor-air mixture is placed.
The temperature and pressure of the internal volume of the bomb can be varied.
Ignition is accomplished by the electrical fusion of 0.0025 inch diameter Nichrome V
wires. The wire-fusion time is determined by the voltage applied to the wire and the
characteristics of the fuse wire.
The bomb is heated and can be regulated from ambient temperature to 260°C. In this
temperature range, sufficiently high pressures can be obtained with most compounds to
determine the minimum pressures for vapor-phase ignition.
c. Information Requirements for Assessment: For monopropellants the fusion time and
ignition energy are held constant (approximately 5 milliseconds and 0.07 joules).
o
d. Typical Results: Acetylene at 100 C has minimum ignition pressure of 3.5 cm.
Ethylene N-Propyl
Characteristic Acetylene
Oxide Nitrate
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
(1) Chemical Propulsion Information Agency (CPIA), Liquid Propellant Test Methods, July
1969.
(2) MIL-STD-1751A issued on 11 December 2001, Method 1041.
US-61
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
US/201.08.002
b. Description: This test is designed to measure the temperature where the sample will emit
vapors that may be ignited by an open flame. The flash point is determined in an open
cup tester. A test cup is filled to a specific level with the sample. The temperature of the
sample is increased rapidly at first and then at a slow constant rate as the flash point is
approached. At specific intervals, a small test flame is passed across the cup. The lowest
temperature where the application of the test flame causes the vapors above the surface
of the liquid to ignite is recorded as the flash point. To determine the fire point the test is
continued until the application of the test flame causes the sample to ignite and burn for at
least 5 seconds.
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
(1) ASTM D92-90, Standard Test Method for Flash and Fire Points by Cleveland
Open Cup. Philadelphia: American Society for Testing and Materials, 1990.
(2) ASTM D93-90, Standard Test Methods for Flash Point by Pensky-Martens
Closed Tester. Philadelphia: American Society for Testing and Materials, 1990.
US-62
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
US/202.01.001
TEST INFORMATION SHEET
d. Description: This test determines thermal stability as a function of the volume of gas
liberated on heating an explosive under vacuum. Two types of pressure measuring
instruments are used, the mercury monometer and a pressure transducer. The
monometer apparatus consists of a constant temperature bath, a bent capillary tube, a
heating tube containing the sample that is connected to the capillary tube, and a cup for
mercury filling. The capillary and heating tubes are calibrated with known volumes of
mercury. The capillary is filled with mercury, and a ground specimen is placed in the
o
heating tube. The sample is heated at the specified temperature (not less than 100 C for
48 hours. For propellants the sample is heated for 40 hours. The volume of gas
liberated is recorded after a 20-minute surge and upon completion.
Because of the toxicity of Mercury, NATO STANAG 4556, reference (4), describes a
pressure transducer method that can be used as an alternative to the manometer
method. Different assemblies for the connection between the heating elements and the
pressure transducers are used. Examples are given in the STANAG.
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
US-63
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
US/202.01.002
b. Description: This test is used to study the explosiveness of solid explosive materials in
fast and slow cook-off condition. A sample of explosive, confined in an aluminum liner
within a steel tube, is heated by means of electrical windings.
The apparatus consists of an aluminum liner, one from a series of increasing wall
thickness steel tubes, heating bands, thermocouples, steel spacer washers, steel end
plates and retaining bolts. The thickness of the aluminum sleeve is 2.5 mm and the
thickness of the steel tube can be 0.375 to 3 mm in 0.375 mm increments. Two
thermocouples are fitted, one in each of two diametrically opposing grooves in the
aluminum sleeve. Either two mica-insulated band heaters or an insulated nichrome wire
winding are located on the steel tube, spacer washers are added to each end and the
assembly is located in recesses between steel witness plates. The retaining bolts are
evenly tightened to a torque of 40.7 +/- 4Nm.
d. Typical Results: Five levels of severity of reaction are observed in this test:
(1) Burning: The steel sleeve is recovered in one piece. The aluminum sleeve is usually
recovered in one or two pieces. Witness plates exhibit no deformation. Retaining
bolts usually remain intact, although in some cases they may be bowed.
(2) Deflagration: The steel sleeve is recovered in one or two pieces. The aluminum
sleeve usually fragments into large pieces. Witness plates exhibit slight deformation.
Retaining bolts fail in shear.
(3) Explosion: Both steel and aluminum sleeves fragment into several large pieces.
Witness plates exhibit some deformation.
(4) Partial detonation: Steel and aluminum sleeves fragment into both large and small
pieces. Witness plates exhibit severe deformation.
(5) Detonation: Steel and aluminum sleeves fragment into very small pieces. Witness
plates exhibit severe damage.
CH-6 repeatedly cooks-off with a partial detonation (Level 4). Tetryl repeatedly cooks-off
with high order (Level 5).
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
US-64
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
US/202.01.003
2. TEST TITLE: Thermal Detonability (Fast Cook-Off) - NAWC (China Lake) Method
b. Description: The test fixture, a super small-scale cook-off bomb (SSCB), consists of a
steel tube 2.8 cm 0D/2.3 cm ID X 7.6 cm long (~1.1" OD/O.9" ID X 3" long) spot welded
(4 pts) to a witness plate 6 cm diameter x 1 cm thick (3" diameter X 3/8" thick). A similar
top plate is used and bolted to the tube-witness plate for explosive confinement. An
internal aluminum sleeve 2.3 cm OD/2.0 cm ID X 7.6 cm long (~0.9" OD/O.8" ID X 3"
long) is used to spread input heat evenly and temperature measurement is made with a
thermocouple. The explosive material is cast, pressed, or cured in steel tubes 2 cm
OD/1.5 cm ID X 3.2 cm long (0.8" OD/O.6" ID X 1.25" long). Each tube contains about 10
grams of explosive and two steel tubes are used per test. This allows a 1.3 cm (0.5-inch)
void area for thermal expansion. The outer steel tube is heated with two, 125-watt band
o o
heaters. With 220 VAC applied, the heating rate is ~1 C/sec and is ~0.2 C/sec with 110
VAC. The higher heating rate is similar to a heavy steel wall 1.3 cm (~0.5 inch) munition
in a fuel fire, the lower heating rate is similar to an area that is not in a direct heat path
from the fuel fire, i.e., fuze cup, thermally protected case, etc.
c. Information Requirements for Assessment: This test is used to determine the cook-off
temperature and reaction of a confined explosive. The time-temperature plot is used to
determine the cook-off temperature at a given heating rate. The body fragments and
witness plate are used to assess the severity of the reaction.
d. Typical Results: The severity of the cook-off reaction is assessed in the following manner
and is listed below:
The severity of the cook-off reaction is dependent on the heating rate. CH-6 booster
explosive yields a detonation. PBXC-123 will yield a burning reaction, which is similar to
the cook-off reaction of this explosive in a warhead.
e. Repeatability and Reproducibility: The tests have been repeatable in regard to thermal
response and reaction.
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
(1) Pakulak, J. and Cragin, S., National Weapons Center TP-6414, July 1983.
US-65
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
US/202.01.004
b. Description: Heat causes the decomposition of an explosive at a rate that varies with
temperature. Almost all explosives are characterized by a critical temperature, below
which the rate of decomposition is so small that it is negligible. If a small mass of an
explosive is suddenly subjected to a high ambient temperature, an induction or incubation
period ensues during which the explosive absorbs heat. If the ambient temperature is
sufficiently high, decomposition of part of the explosive liberates heat and causes
acceleration of the increase in temperature of the remaining explosive. When the
temperature reaches a certain value characteristic of the explosive, the rate-of-
decomposition value becomes so great that explosion of the remaining material takes
place. The temperature of the products of explosion is much greater than that developed
during the period prior to slow decomposition. If the explosion is brought about at the end
of a column of explosive, self-propagating detonation of the column can ensue.
In this test, a blasting cap containing the explosive is immersed to a fixed depth in a bath
of molten Woods’ metal. The time of immersion required to cause flashing or explosion is
noted. The temperature of the bath is varied and a number of tests are made in order to
produce smoke, fume, flashes or explosions over a range of approximately two to ten
seconds. Visible signs of evolution of smoke, fumes, etc., are recorded. A pressure-time
curve is constructed in order to finalize the temperature required to cause flashing or
explosions in five seconds.
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
US-66
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
US/202.01.005
c. Information Requirements for Assessment: This test determines the thermal sensitivity of
primary explosives.
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
US-67
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
US/202.01.006
b. Description: This test employs a 0.0508 mm (2 mil) diameter tungsten or chrome wire
that is in contact with the charge. When sufficient electrical energy is supplied, the wire
becomes hot and ignites the explosive charge. The particle size of the test material must
be small compared to the diameter of the ignition wire. The sample is dried to constant
o
weight at 55 C and then pressed into a cup at 27.56 MPa (4000 psi) and 103.35 MPa
(15000 psi).
d. Typical Results: Tetryl generally passes this test while PETN generally fails.
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
US-68
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
US/202.01.007
TEST INFORMATION SHEET
b. Description: The temperature difference between an inert reference compound and the
material is measured as they are heated at a constant rate. Because the reference
material undergoes no thermal reactions over the temperature range used, any endo- or
exothermic changes of the test sample causes its temperature to be lower or higher than
that of the reference material. The differential temperatures are recorded as a function of
the sample or furnace temperature. The sample and a reference material are placed in
separate test tubes side by side in a heating element. The temperature is raised at a
o o
constant rate of 5 C-10 C/minute to destruction. The temperature difference is plotted as
a function of the reference temperature.
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
US-69
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
US/202.01.008
TEST INFORMATION SHEET
The heating rate (dynamic experiment) is determined by the objective of the experiment.
Some energetic materials are volatile and will volatilize from the sample pan during this
test, sometimes prior to reaching the melting temperature
Samples used are representative of the material in the final form anticipated for service
use. Cast-cured materials are to be fully cured. Powders are used as such or
consolidated to a density similar to that proposed for a final configuration.
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
US-70
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
US/202.01.009
c. Information Requirements for Assessment: This method is used for determining the
o
stability of high explosives by subjecting them to 100 C at atmospheric pressure.
d. Typical Results: Kinetic data from DTA or other tests for the calculation.
e. Repeatability and Reproducibility: Should be good for test performed under the same
conditions.
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
US-71
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
US/202.01.010
b. Description: As the confined explosive is heated, TNT expands and an internal pressure
is developed which squeezes the exudate from the pores to a region of lower pressure,
e.g., nose of the shell or booster cavity. The droplets coalesce and dissolve the TNT,
cutting channels through the TNT and the main charge becomes more porous and of
lower density. With increased gun setback forces, any cracks in the charge can increase
the probability of a premature explosion. The test simulates the confinement of a closed
shell and the length to diameter ratio of the cast explosive approximates that of typical
artillery shell fillers. The paper wrap, which absorbs the exudate, serves as an insulator
between the cast specimen and the heavy walled cylinder, which tends to keep the
temperature constant. The cast TNT charge is loaded into the upright sleeve of the test
o o
apparatus weighed and placed in a steam- heated chamber (157 to 160 F). The amount
of exudate is determined from the increase in weight of the paper wrap.
c. Information Requirements for Assessment: Visual observation and or chemical test of the
exudates.
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
(1) Voigt, H. W., "Exudation Test for TNT Explosives Under Confinement: Exudation Control
and Proposed Standards", ARRADCOM Technical Report ARLCD-TR-83004, February
1983.
US-72
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
US/202.01.011
TEST INFORMATION SHEET
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
(2) Gryting, H. J., Pennington, O. K., Falterman, C. U., and Seaman, H., "Additives
for Controlling Cracking of Explosives Made with TNT", NAVORD Report 5595,
NWC, China Lake, CA, 1 November 1957.
(3) Pakulak, J., Jr. and Kuletz, Edward, "Thermal Analyses Studies on Candidate
Solid JPL Propellants for Heat Sterilizable Motors", National Weapons Center TP
4258, China Lake, CA, July 1970.
US-73
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
US/202.01.012
b. This Method is used both to predict and to experimentally determine the critical
temperature and self-heating properties of an explosive material.
The experimental critical temperature for a given size and geometry can be determined by
carrying out a variety of tests with the explosive confined or unconfined. These tests
include the isothermal cook-off (ICO), slow cook-off (SCO), one-liter cook-off (1-LCO) and
isothermal Time-To-Explosion (Henkin TTE) tests. The ICO and SCO are large-scale and
confined, the 1-LCO is large-scale and unconfined and the Henkin TTE is small-scale and
moderately confined. The first three tests must incorporate the use of at least one
thermocouple placed at the geometrical center of the explosive and one to monitor the
temperature of the heat source.
c. Information Requirements for Assessment: Data obtained from DTA, DSC, or TGA
experiments are used to determine the various kinetics parameters required in this
method, i.e., Arrhenius activation energy and pre-exponential.
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
US-74
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
US/202.01.013
b. Description: This test must demonstrate that the candidate high explosive is thermally
o
stable at 75 c. A sample of up to 50g is placed transferred to a tared beaker, covered
with a watch glass and weighed. The covered beaker is then placed in a constant
o
temperature explosion-proof oven. The temperature of the oven is raised to 75 C and
maintained at that temperature for 48 hours unless an ignition or explosion of the sample
occurs. The temperature is recorded continuously. The beaker is then removed and
cooled in a desiccator and weighed. The weight loss as a percent of the sample weight is
calculated.
c. Information Requirements for Assessment: This test is be used to evaluate the thermal
stability of explosive materialsy.
d. Typical Results: The sample is considered to have failed the test if it explodes, burns, or
decomposes.
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
US-75
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
US/202.01.014
b. Description: This test is used to determine if a small quantity of the test material will
transition from deflagration to detonation when unconfined. A 125-gram sample is placed
in a plastic beaker and placed on a bed of kerosene-soaked sawdust. The sawdust is
ignited with an electric igniter. Three samples are tested. The material fails the test if an
explosion or detonation occurs.
c. Information Requirements for Assessment: The data are used to determine whether an
explosive is safe to handle, transport, and store.
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
US-76
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
US/202.01.015
b. Description: The explosive material is contained in a steel pipe that is capped at both
ends. A black powder igniter is located at the center of the explosive sample and is used
to ignite the explosive. Three tests are performed. The test is considered positive if
either the pipe or one of the end caps is fragmented into at least two distinct pieces
separated from the pipe.
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
US-77
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
US/202.01.016
b. Description:
(1) Apparatus - A molten Wood’s metal bath and sample tubes (copper or brass) are
used.
(2). Procedure - A 1 gm sample is loaded into a copper or brass tube (usually a No. 6
blasting-cap shell). The tube is immersed the Wood’s metal bath heated to a temperature
(T), and the time interval (t) before ignition is recorded. The bath temperature is then
varied and additional samples are tested to obtain five or six points through which a
temperature-time curve can be drawn. The ignition temperature is the one for which
ignition occurs at five seconds.
d. Typical Results: Temperatures that are always higher than the ignition temperatures as
determined by differential thermal analysis (DTA) are reported.
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
(1) McLain, Joseph H., Pyrotechnics, The Franklin Institute Press, Philadelphia, PA
(1980).
US-78
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
US/202.01.017
d. Typical Results: Stable compounds have slopes of less than 1.0-mm Hg/min.
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
US-79
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
US/202.01.018
b. Description: A 224 gm (8-oz) glass bottle having a wide-mouth with a velvet ground
mushroom stopper is used for this test. It is placed in a chamber at 65 + 1oC. Daily
observations are made; samples may be withdrawn for mechanical and/or closed bomb
testing. The number of days required to cause the liberation of visible reddish fumes is
recorded. If mechanical properties and/or closed bomb tests are conducted, the results
are also reported.
c. Information Requirements for Assessment: This test is used to predict the safe storage
life of a propellant.
d. Typical Results: Single-base propellant should last several hundred days before fuming.
Double-base propellant should last at least 100 days before fuming. The test is not
reliable for triple-base propellants.
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
US-80
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
US/202.01.019
b. Description: The sample is placed in a metal cup and immersed in a molten Wood’s
metal bath. Samples are ignited at various bath temperatures and the time to ignition is
recorded. A graph of results is prepared and the temperature at which a minimum ignition
temperature would be observed at t = infinity is determined.
c. Information Requirements for Assessment: Data required for safe drying of composition
life.
d. Typical Results: The minimum ignition temperature is usually the same as that
determined by DTA.
o
e. Repeatability and Reproducibility: Repeatable to + 1 C.
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
(1) Johnson, Duane M., Ignition Theory: Application to the Design of New Ignition
Systems, NWSC/CR/RDTR No. 56, Naval Weapons Support Center, Crane, IN
24 November 1965.
(2) McLain, Joseph H., Pyrotechnics, The Franklin Institute Press, Philadelphia, PA
(1980).
(3) Ellern, Herbert, Military and Civilian Pyrotechnics, Chemical Publishing Co., Inc.,
New York, NY (1968).
US-81
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
US/202.01.020
b. Description: This test is used to evaluate the behavior of an energetic material when it is
subjected to a temperature rise. Characteristics displayed on the thermograms can be
used to monitor samples in comparison to controls and examine if changes have
occurred in a sample that may affect stability. Results provide onset temperature and
peak maxima of any endothermic or exothermic events.
Sample crucibles must be manufactured from material that is chemically inert to the
material under test and have high thermal conductivity. Typical materials of construction
are aluminum and platinum. Purge gas supply (usually nitrogen, argon or helium) and an
associated flow controller.
c. Information Requirements for Assessment: The weight loss (or gain) of is determined.
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
US-82
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
US/202.01.021
The apparatus consists of a 1-liter, Pyrex, round-bottom flask and a disposable oven.
The flask equipped with a thermocouple bundle inserted into the center of the sample and
extending to the bottom of the flask. The neck of the flask protrudes through a fitted
circular opening in the top of the oven. The sample either is cast directly into the flask or
may be loaded in chunk or powder form. The sample is heated rapidly (minimum 10
°C/min) to a temperature that is 10 to 20 °C above its melting point and held for
approximately 5 hours.
d. Typical Results:
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
(1) McKenney, R.L., Jr. and Krawietz, T.R., One-Liter Test: A Mid-Scale Safety
Characterization Test for Melt-Castable Explosives, AFRL-MN-EG-TR-1999-
7049, Air Force Research Laboratory, Eglin AFB, FL, July 1999.
US-83
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
US/202.01.022
b. Description: The standard vacuum thermal stability (VTS) test, developed in the early
1900s, measures the chemical stability of an explosive at an elevated temperature under
an initial vacuum for a specific time. Generally, a weighed sample of explosive (5.00 ±
0.05 g) is sealed in an all-glass apparatus designed to measure gas pressure by the
mercury manometer method. The system is evacuated and that portion containing the
sample is heated at 100°C for 48 hours. The pressure generated by the decomposition
gases is measured after the entire system has equilibrated to ambient temperature. The
problem with this system include (1) the toxic characteristics of mercury and the fragility of
the all-glass system, (2) condensation of water due to the experimental setup, (3)
potential inaccuracies associated with corrections and (4) time/labor requirements
associated with the test.
In the Modified Vacuum Thermal Stability (MVTS) Test, the energetic material is
contained in a glass tube that is inserted in a calibrated, stainless steel reaction vessel
assembly that is connected to a pressure sensor. The entire system is heated in an oven
and the real-time pressure/time data are recorded by a computerized data acquisition
system. This provides a continuous pressure/time record for the specific time period of
the test. From this the total volume of gas generated at STP can be calculated. Gas
chromatographic analysis provides the identity of the components and their individual
volumes. This allows one to distinguish between those gases associated with thermal
decomposition and those resulting from the evolution of adsorbed water/solvent.
c. Information Requirements for Assessment: Data required for processing and testing.
d. Typical Results: Results are presented in psig or as a pressure ratio (Pi/Pa) where Pi is
the driving pressure and Pa is the local ambient pressure. Ethyl or propylnitrate are
utilized as calibration standards.
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
(1) AFRPL-TR-66-294.
US-84
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
US/202.02.001
b. Description: The U-tube adiabatic compression tester consists of a U-shaped tube closed
at one end and containing a slug of test liquid in the curvature of the tube. The test is
conducted by suddenly pressurizing the open end of the tube, which forces the liquid slug
violently into the closed end. Peak pressures many times greater than the driving
pressure are attained in the closed end of the tube. The rate of pressurization is fast
enough to provide adiabatic compression.
c. Information Requirements for Assessment: Data required for processing and testing
d. Typical Results: Results are presented in psig or as a pressure ratio (Pi/Pa) where Pi is
the driving pressure and Pa is the local ambient pressure. Ethyl or propyl nitrate are
utilized as calibration standards.
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
(1) AFRPL-TR-66-294.
US-85
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
US/203.01.001
b. Description: Used for determine the reactivity of explosives in contact with materials used
in production and in munition designs.
(1) High Explosives: The Vacuum thermal stability test AOP-7 Registry No:
o
US/202.01.001 is used. Normally, the explosive and the materials are subjected to 100 C
for 48 hours. For a 5 gm sample of explosive, no more than 2.0 ml/gm/48 hours is
allowed. For materials like HNS, the test is performed at higher temperatures.
(2) Propellants: Most frequently the Taliani, Vacuum Stability, or Differential Thermal
Analysis (DTA) is used. Generally the AOP-7 Registry No: US/202.01.001 test is used.
(3) Pyrotechnic Compositions: Compatibility tests are designed around the materials
and potential contaminants. In general, the vacuum thermal stability tests AOP-7 Registry
No: US/202.01.001 is used.
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
US-86
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
US/204.01.001
TEST INFORMATION SHEET
The test is normally run on a powder unless thee test material is a paste or cast/cure
PBX. The sample size for the material being tested is 0.250 g. For compatibility tests,
both ingredients are weighed to 0.250 g and then blended together. In general, duplicate
samples are prepared and run for all materials being tested.
Samples are placed in the loop assembly and the loop is evacuated with vacuum until all
outgassing stops. The gas chromatograph is calibrated with a calibration gas containing a
small percentage of each of the gases being analyzed. In addition, PBX-9404 is routinely
run as the standard explosive composition.
d. Typical Results:
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
(1) Prokosch, David W., et al., Chemical Reactivity Test for Thermal Stability, UCRL-
JC-117941, July 1994.
US-87
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
US/204.02.001
c. Information Requirements for Assessment: This test determines the impact on the
environment of firing the propellant.
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
US-88
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
US/301.01.001
The data are used to characterize the propellant or pyrotechnic system and in the
prediction of the performance.
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
US-89
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
US/302.01.001
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
US-90
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
US/302.01.002
b. Description: The procedure for measuring the detonation velocity of liquids and vapor-air
mixtures is similar to that described for solid high explosives described in AOP-7 Registry
Nos. US/302.01.001. A detonation tube is used for vapor-air mixtures as described in
US/302.03.001.
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
US-91
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
US/302.01.003
TEST INFORMATION SHEET
b. Description: There is no well-defined test for critical diameter that is applicable to all
explosives at all diameters, dc; however, there are three main techniques used for
measuring the dc.
(1) A conical charge is initiated at the large end and the detonation is followed
optically or electronically until it fails. For the Electronic method, an embedded copper
wire is placed in parallel to a Nichrome wire in the center of the explosive. A constant
current source of about 200 mA is connected between the copper and the Nichrome
wires. The detonation front, which has a low resistance, completes the circuit. An
oscilloscope reads the potential difference between the copper and the nichrome wire.
Since the resistance per unit length of the nichrome wire is known, from Ohm’s law the
resistance of the nichrome wire remaining will tell where the detonation failed.
(2) A stepped cylindrical charge is initiated at the large end and progress of the
detonation front is followed through the various sections. The length of each step or
diameter must be about 4d or greater to allow over-boostering to fade out and sufficient
length of steady state propagation to measure detonation velocity. The camera cannot
view an extremely long charge and still give a record that can yield an accurate value.
Hence, the step cylinder, like the cone is best suited for obtaining an approximate value of
the critical diameter. Both of these methods should be followed by more precise
measurements on cylindrical charges.
(3) A series of cylindrical charges of different diameters and the smear camera
records are used to map the detonation velocity versus the diameter relationship. By
keeping the differences between the diameters small, the average of the smallest
diameter charge that gives a steady-state detonation and the largest charge that does
not, will give a reasonably accurate value of the failure diameter. The first two methods
will tend to give estimates of the critical diameter that are smaller than the true value.
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
US-92
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
US/302.01.004
TEST INFORMATION SHEET
c. Description: This test defines the threshold dc for the propagation of a steady state
detonation. The procedure is used for injection-loaded explosives with a dc in the order of
0.010 inch (0.025 cm) or less. The apparatus consists of a base with a variable diameter
groove and a cover plate. The groove is filled with the test explosive making sure that
there are no gaps, voids, or inclusions. If the explosive is curable, the uncured explosive
is loaded in the test hardware and fully cured before testing. The cover plate is mounted
on the base plate containing the test sample with an adhesive. A mild detonating fuze
(MDF) and shock absorbing tubing is installed in the cover plate making sure that the
MDF is in contact with the test explosive. After firing, the distance from the reference end
of the aluminum cover plate to the end of the detonation imprint is measured to obtain the
critical diameter.
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
US-93
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
US/302.02.001
b. Description: Strands 15-20 cm long and 0.3-1 cm in diameter are coated with an inhibitor
compound to assure vertical burning. Each strand is placed in a jig equipped with fuse
o o o o o o
wires. Strands are conditioned at -54 C (65 F), 25 C (77 F), and 74 C (165 F) before
testing. Test pressures are 500, 1000, 2000, 3000, 4000, 5000 psi. A Crawford type
stainless steel Strand Burning Rate Bomb with a volume of about one liter is used. It must
have an 0-ring closure and a working pressure of at least 5000 psi. Each unit is
hydrostatically tested for 30 minutes at 10,000 psi, is equipped with electrical wiring
contacts for ignition and timing, and has an opening for pressurizing and exhausting
o o o
gases. Temperature conditioning chambers with ranges from -65 C (-85 F) to +99 C
o o o
(210 F), controllable to +0.5 C (+ 1 F) must be available.
e. Repeatability and Reproducibility: Good repeatability and reproducibility over the most of
its range. The test is difficult to use when the burning rate exceeds 7.5 cm (3") per
second.
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
US-94
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
US/302.02.002
b. Description: The closed bomb is a constant- volume, high pressure combustion chamber
used to determine the linear regression rate of burning propellant. The bomb volume is
usually 100-300 cm. The propellant is loaded in the bomb. The igniter is placed in a
small bag with the propellant. An electric match is used to initiate combustion. A
piezoelectric pressure transducer measures the pressure rise.
c. Information Requirements for Assessment: This test determines the quickness and force
of a propellant.
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
(2). Round Robin Results of the Closed Bomb and Strand Burner, CPIA Publication
361, July, 1982.
US-95
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
US/302.02.003
b. Description: The test apparatus, procedure, results and criteria all vary according to the
end-item requirements of the pyrotechnic system. Specific criteria are established in
terms of end-item performance requirements. These criteria are normally examined in
prototype hardware similar to that envisioned in the final design. To this degree, some
performance characteristics are examined and pyrotechnic compositions are either
modified, accepted, or rejected.
d. Typical Results: Typical results could be reported in burning times, burning rates,
electromagnetic radiation intensity versus burning time, spectral outputs, visual color,
obscuration or screening times, or other results that would be specifically related to the
pyrotechnic end-item’s characteristics required.
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
(1) McLain, Joseph H., Pyrotechnics, The Franklin Institute Press, Philadelphia, PA
(1980).
(2) Ellern, Herbert, Military and Civilian Pyrotechnics, Chemical Publishing Co., Inc.,
New York, NY (1968).
US-96
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
US/302.02.004
TEST INFORMATION SHEET
d. Typical Results: Depending on the composition, it may (1) deflagrate, (2) burn as virtually
a solid state reaction leaving a solid residue, (3) ignite and eject out of a container as a
flaming mass or (4) flame in place.
e. Repeatability and Reproducibility: Normally repeatable if ignited the same way each time.
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
(1) McLain, Joseph H., Pyrotechnics, The Franklin Institute Press, Philadelphia, PA
(1980).
US-97
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
US/302.03.001
b. Description: A tube opened at both ends is used. It is fitted with hoops at each end for
sealing the tube with plastic a film. The tube is 60 cm in diameter and 180 cm long. For
liquid, a spray manifold is installed along the top. For particulates, cups are placed along
the bottom of the tube. The cups are connected to an air supply that ejects the fuel from
the cups. The thin plastic (Mylar) film is placed over both ends and an explosive charge is
placed at one end. Pressure transducers and foil switches are located along the sides of
the tube to measure the pressure and velocity of the detonation wave. Detonability is
determined by varying the fuel-air ratio by changing the amount of fuel dispersed in the
tube, or by changing the explosive initiator size. The fuel-air ratio is changed both up and
down until detonation failures are obtained. If a detonation is not obtained with a
stoichiometric mixture, the size of the initiating charge is increased until a detonation
occurs or the blast from the initiating charge would mask the pressure pulse from the
fuel-air detonation. The typical starting initiator charge size is 3 gm.
c. Information Requirements for Assessment: The data recorded for each test are generally
as follows: fuel type; fuel quantity; concentration; spray or mix time; ambient temperature,
pressure, and humidity; temperature drop caused by evaporation of fuel (optional); type
and size of initiator; data records showing closure time for detonation velocity gauges; and
data records of the pressure transducer outputs. The data records are assessed to
determine the detonation velocity and detonation pressure.
d. Typical Results: If a detonation is not obtained, the fuel is not considered a practical fuel
for FAE applications. If a detonation is obtained, the testing is continued with decreased
initiator size and/or off-stoichiometric concentrations until the detonability limits are
established as a function of both fuel-air ratio and initiator energy.
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
US-98
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
US/302.03.002
b. Description: Subscale motors are fitted with nozzles sized to operate at designated
average pressures (usually 1000, 2000, and 4000 psi), conditioned at the temperatures of
o o o o o o o o
either -54 C, 25 C, and +74 C (-65 F, 77 F, and 165 F, respectively), or -40 C, 25 C, and
o o o o
60 C (-40 F, 77 F, and 140 F, respectively). They are examined radiographically for
cracks, voids, etc., and only those without defects are statically fired.
c. Information Requirements for Assessment: These tests are used to obtain more precise
values for the burning rate of the propellant than can be obtained from slab motor or
strand burning tests, and for the determination of the dependence of the burning rate on
temperature.
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
US-99
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
US/302.03.003
b. Description: The design configuration is used. The pyrotechnic units are brought to the
desired temperatures. The ignition and burning characteristics are noted.
c. Information Requirements for Assessment: The unit functions safely and within the
performance specifications for the design.
d. Typical Results: Under colder conditions pyrotechnics generally are more difficult to ignite
and typically burn slower. Under hotter conditions pyrotechnics will generally ignite more
readily and burn faster. In some extremes cases, there are ignition failures under cold
conditions and deflagrations under hot conditions.
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
(1) McLain, Joseph H., Pyrotechnics, The Franklin Institute Press, Philadelphia, PA
(1980).
(2) Ellern, Herbert, Military and Civilian Pyrotechnics, Chemical Publishing Co., Inc.,
New York, NY (1968).
US-100
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
US/302.03.004
b. Description: The moisture content of the composition will be determined using analytical
techniques accurate for the chemicals involved. The effect of the moisture on the
performance characteristics of the composition in the test vehicle will be determined. The
allowable range of moisture content can then be extrapolated from the maximum and/or
minimum permissible for end-item performance requirements.
3. NATIONAL REFERENCES:
(1). McLain, Joseph H., Pyrotechnics, The Franklin Institute Press, Philadelphia, PA
(1980).
(2) Ellern, Herbert, Military and Civilian Pyrotechnics, Chemical Publishing Co., Inc.,
New York, NY (1968).
US-101
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
AOP-7
(Edition 2)
To be provided
SW-1
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED