The Survey Results Action Guide
The Survey Results Action Guide
The Survey Results Action Guide
Action Guide
Purpose
The purpose of this guide is to offer suggestions for Federal agencies
for successfully using their employee survey results in planning and
implementing positive organizational change.
Provided by:
2
Keys to Success
Get the most from your survey results!
Act quickly
3
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Accept Employee Feedback as a Gift Page 6
4
Support Improvement Efforts Page 36
Bibliography Page 47
5
ACCEPT EMPLOYEE FEEDBACK AS A GIFT
The survey results are a valuable gift
Surveys create expectations of action
Reap multiple benefits by using survey data
Surveys are a tool The work begins, not ends, with survey results. A survey is a
tool for meaningful dialogue among the members of an
organization.
6
Accept Employee Feedback as a Gift (continued)
Why use your Using employee survey data sends a message to employees
survey data? that organizational leaders value their input and respect their
time. It builds employee confidence that leadership will take
action to respond to their concerns.
7
ACT QUICKLY
Communicate promptly
The value of a survey is in action
Value is in action Survey data is of little value in itself. Its value is derived
from its use in driving positive organizational change.
8
SELECT TARGET AREAS
Create a review team
Identify highs and lows
Select areas for focus
Begin with a quick In the meeting, first familiarize yourselves with the survey
scan by reviewing how it is organized into sections and
reading through all the questions. This review will
provide you with a good understanding of the survey
content.
Data aids thinking As you work through the survey, remember that data is
an aid for thought, not a substitute.
9
Select Target Areas (continued)
Identify highs and Review the results for each survey question and classify
lows it as an area in which your organization is strong, is
doing okay, or needs improvement. Agree on a
definition for each category such as:
Strong = we have at least 80% favorable ratings
(Note: You would first need to decide what
“favorable” means, e.g., does it mean the
combined responses of “Strongly Agree” and
“Agree” or “Very Satisfied and “Satisfied” or does
it mean only “Strongly Agree” or “Very Satisfied”?
Many organizations consider a favorable rating
as the combination of the top two positive
choices.)
10
Select Target Areas (continued)
Look for question Typically survey results will cluster so that organizations
clusters appear stronger in some areas and not so in others.
Review how you classified each question and look for
patterns. Are there clusters of closely related items in
which your organization is strong or clusters which seem
to need improvement? For example, there may be
several questions about management communication
with employees and your organization scored low on all
or most of them. Circle these clusters or list the questions
on a flip chart or whiteboard.
11
Select Target Areas (continued)
Compare to If you have the results for a previous survey with the
previous surveys same questions, compare the results from the current
and previous survey, question by question. It is
important to check that the survey results are directly
comparable. For example, if missing responses are
included in the response choice percentages in one
survey but not in another, the percentages will need to
be recalculated before the results of the two surveys
can be compared.
12
Select Target Areas (continued)
Decide what to How do you decide which areas to focus on? Consider
focus on the following options to determine where positive
change is most critical for your organization.
13
Select Target Areas (continued)
Importance Be sure for each area of focus selected you can answer
these two questions:
“Why is it important for us to work on this area?
Actionable Be sure the areas you select for focus are directly
actionable, i.e., within the power of your organization to
change. For example, although the survey results may
show that many employees are not satisfied with their
pay, there may be little to nothing you can do about it.
This would not be a good focus area. In contrast, if the
survey results show that many employees feel that they
are not receiving enough feedback from their
supervisors, the organization can take several different
actions to remedy the situation.
14
COMMUNICATE WIDELY AND OFTEN
Communicate to all employees
Use multiple communication media
Communicate frequently
15
Communicate Widely and Often (continued)
Begin with leaders The first step in communicating survey results is to share
the results with organizational leadership and obtain
their commitment to using the data to improve the
organization. Leaders need to understand the results
so they will be able to present the results to employees
and answer their questions. They also need to make a
firm commitment to allocate time and resources to
apply the results and ensure that they will hold people
accountable for taking action.
Share the survey After organizational leaders learn the survey results, the
results with all next step is to share the results with all employees. The
employees most effective approach is to have the leaders directly
communicate the results to all employees and explain
how the survey data will be used.
16
Communicate Widely and Often (continued)
17
Communicate Widely and Often (continued)
Use simple, clear When the survey results are presented by leaders or
formats for results managers, be sure they are presented in a clear, easily
understood format. A good structure is to group the
results into areas of strength, areas for improvement,
and areas that are satisfactory but not notable.
Describe focus Describe the focus areas chosen and explain why they
areas were selected as top priorities.
Explain next steps Describe the next steps for how and when the data will
be used to address the focus areas. For example, a
recommended sequence of steps include:
1. Form an employee team for each focus area
2. Collect additional information as needed to
identify the underlying issues
3. Develop specific objectives for each focus area
4. Develop an action plan for achieving each
objective
5. Implement the action plans
6. Evaluate the actions taken and revise them as
needed.
18
Communicate Widely and Often (continued)
Request volunteers Ask for volunteers for each team. Explain that not
everyone who volunteers may be asked to join a team
because the teams will be balanced to represent each
division and relevant employee characteristics.
Describe the characteristics deemed important for the
issue such as supervisory status, level, type of
occupation, etc.
19
MAKE IT A TEAM EFFORT
Involve all employees
Form teams
Select the best solution
Develop SMART objectives
Name the teams It’s helpful to give the teams a title or acronym that is
easy to say and remember, e.g., ESAT (Employee Survey
Action Team), Survey Warriors, PSI (Problem Solvers Inc.).
Focus the teams It’s usually most effective to form teams that focus on
just one of the areas that you have identified for
strengthening. Thus, if you have chosen two areas to
work on, you could form two teams; if you chose three
areas, you could form three teams.
20
Make It a Team Effort (continued)
Team composition When you select team members from among those
who volunteer, consider the employee characteristics
that are important for the team’s focus area. In many
cases, you will want to have representation from each
division and each job level or occupation with a mix of
employees, supervisors, and union representatives as
appropriate. For other issues, it will also be important to
ensure both genders and most racial/ethnic groups are
included. For some issues, age, years of work
experience or other employee characteristics should
also be considered.
You will also want to ensure that the people selected for
the team have good interpersonal skills and a record of
meeting their commitments.
21
Make It a Team Effort (continued)
22
Make It a Team Effort (continued)
23
Make It a Team Effort (continued)
24
Make It a Team Effort (continued)
Collect more data After discussing the possible reasons for employee
responses, often a team will decide that they need to
collect additional information to accurately interpret
employee responses and make the best use of the
survey data. There are several possible approaches to
expeditiously collecting this information. Here are some
suggestions:
Team members meet with their work units to
request their input. This can be done in 30
minutes or less by simply asking colleagues to
explain why they think employees may have
given the response and discussing the possibilities.
25
Make It a Team Effort (continued)
Identify solutions After the underlying causes for the problem or strength
are identified, the team brainstorms and then discusses
possible approaches to take. Often good ideas will be
contained in the additional information collected from
employees.
26
Make It a Team Effort (continued)
Compare the Discuss these questions to select the best solution for
solutions your organization:
Which approach is likely to be most effective?
Which approach promises the most benefits for
the least cost in resources of people, time, and
money?
What are our constraints for investing time,
money, or people in this approach?
Which approach are we best equipped to try?
Do we have the knowledge, skills, or abilities
needed for this approach? If not, can we quickly
develop or acquire them?
Are there ethical, legal, or organizational
constraints?
Can we support this with enthusiasm
What obstacles might we encounter? How much
effort would it take to surmount these obstacles?
What have we tried before? What worked? What
didn’t work?
27
Make It a Team Effort (continued)
“Can Do” Attitude If there seem to be serious obstacles to doing what the
team thinks needs to be done, ask what is stopping you.
If the team can’t do it, who can? Enlist their help.
28
Make It a Team Effort (continued)
Example of SMART For example, the team that selected trust and
objective confidence as a focus may develop several specific
objectives for promoting behaviors that they believe
over time will develop stronger working relationships
between employees and supervisors and build trust.
29
Make It a Team Effort (continued)
30
DEVELOP AND IMPLEMENT AN ACTION PLAN
Determine how to measure success
Develop a step-by-step plan
Implement the plan
Focus area Describe the focus area concisely and clearly in terms
of a positive outcome. A phrase or a sentence usually
suffices. For example, “Facilitate the development of
trust by helping supervisors and employees build
stronger working relationships.”
31
Develop and Implement an Action Plan (continued)
32
Develop and Implement an Action Plan (continued)
Action steps To create the action plan, divide the selected solutions
into discrete, concrete steps. The action steps should
include tasks that will surmount any identified potential
barriers to implementation. List the action steps in the
sequence in which they will occur.
33
Develop and Implement an Action Plan (continued)
Think small and When you develop the action steps, think in terms of
meaningful how you can create opportunities for small but
meaningful accomplishments that will add up to
important changes. If the team can immediately “fix”
small things, employees will feel that the time spent
responding to the survey was worthwhile and their
input is valued.
Due dates Set a due date for each action step. Make it realistic
but aggressive.
34
Develop and Implement an Action Plan (continued)
35
SUPPORT IMPROVEMENT EFFORTS
Visible commitment
Communication
Provide resources, coaching, and recognition
36
Support Improvement Efforts (continued)
37
Support Improvement Efforts (continued)
Monitor progress Each action team leader should report on the team’s
progress and any obstacles faced to the sponsoring
manager. Problems or potential problems can then be
promptly addressed by a change in the action plan,
revised work assignments and priorities of team
members, additional communication by management,
or other means.
38
Support Improvement Efforts (continued)
39
Support Improvement Efforts (continued)
40
HOLD PEOPLE ACCOUNTABLE
Publish action plans
Implement meaningful consequences
Publish action Post the action plans and keep them updated so that
plans target dates are widely known and accomplishments
can be noted by all employees.
41
Hold People Accountable (continued)
A note about line The survey results and the action plans belong to line
ownership employees and managers, not to Human Resources. It is
line management who must be held accountable for
the survey action plans.
42
EVALUATE AND ADJUST
Monitor progress
Make adjustments
Monitor your The survey team’s job is not over once the action plans
progress are developed. The team should still oversee progress
and make adjustments where necessary. During regular
team meetings, plan time to evaluate the progress you
have made on the improvement action plans. Have
each team member responsible for a task report on the
progress made thus far and the progress expected by
the next team meeting. Include this information in the
minutes of your meeting.
43
Evaluate and Adjust (continued)
If you did not If you did not achieve your objective, figure out why.
achieve your Discussing the questions below will help.
objective Did we select a valid, accurate measure of
achievement?
What factors interfered with our plans?
Were interfering factors beyond our control?
If not, what could we have done better?
Was the objective unrealistic?
Do we need to modify the objective?
Did team members fulfill their commitments?
What lessons did we learn?
44
MAKE IMPROVEMENTS VISIBLE
Highlight success
Highlight management responsiveness
Share accomplishments and lessons learned
45
Make Improvements Visible (continued)
Share the wealth Share both accomplishments and lessons learned with
other organizations in your agency, with other agencies,
and external professional colleagues. This can be done
at all levels. Managers and executives can discuss the
teams’ experiences with their peers. Supervisors and
team members can talk about their discoveries and
experiences with their colleagues. All can make
presentations or write articles for professional
associations. Doing so enhances the reputation of both
the agency and the Federal Government at large.
Build on success When the teams’ objectives have been achieved, build
on success by choosing another issue raised by the
survey and work it through the same discussion and
action planning steps. Each effort you make to improve
effectiveness will bring you closer to achieving your
potential as a high performance organization.
46
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Burke, W.W., Coruzzi, C.A., & Church, A. H. (1994). The organizational survey
as an intervention for change. In A.I. Kraut (Ed.), Organizational surveys: Tools
for assessment and change (pp. 41-66). San Francisco: Jossey-Bass.
Church, A.H. & Oliver, D. H. (2006). The importance of taking action, not just
sharing survey feedback. In A.I. Kraut (Ed.), Getting action from
organizational surveys: New concepts, technologies, and applications (pp.
102-130). San Francisco: Jossey-Bass.
Hagen, C. & Sivie, J. (2007). The strategic alignment survey: Giving the CEO
more levers to push to improve organization performance. Retrieved Oct. 1,
2007 from http://www.crishagen.com.
Hinrichs, J. R. (1994). Feedback, action planning, and follow through. In A.I. Kraut
(Ed.), Organizational surveys: Tools for assessment and change (pp. 255-258).
San Francisco: Jossey-Bass.
47
Johnson, S.R. (2006). Preparing and presenting survey results to influence
audiences. In A.I. Kraut (Ed.), Getting action from organizational surveys: New
concepts, technologies, and applications (pp. 377-400). San Francisco:
Jossey-Bass.
Kraut, A.I. (2006). Moving the needle: Getting action after a survey. In A.I.
Kraut (Ed.), Getting action from organizational surveys: New concepts,
technologies, and applications (pp. 1-30). San Francisco: Jossey-Bass.
Marrelli, A. F. (1996). The Profile handbook: A cmi tool for teams. Los Angeles:
Hughes Electronics.
Otlacan, O. (2007). Rules to setting business goals and objectives: Why and
how to be SMART. Retrieved Nov. 9, 2007 from
http://ezinearticles.com/?expert=Otilia_Otlacan.
48
TOOL KIT
Communication Plan Template
Sample Communication Plan
Survey Action Plan Template
Sample Survey Action Plan
49
COMMUNICATION PLAN
50
SAMPLE COMMUNICATION PLAN
Timeline Audience Objective Content Media
11/26/07 Managers Share survey results Review & discuss the Meeting
Obtain survey results
commitment to Identify review team
action members
12/4/07 All Executive shares Review survey All Hands
employees the survey results highlights meeting
Solicit volunteers Identify focus areas
Explain next steps Printed
Employees break summary of
into small groups to results
discuss
Q&A
Request volunteers
12/11/07 All Disseminate team Explain action teams Division
employees action plans Share each team meetings
plan
Explain role of each
employee
12/19/07 All Report team Describe the E-mail
employees progress progress made, any bulletins
1/3/08 changes to the
plans, and the
impact on
employees
1/7/08 All Announce Announce plan All Hands
employees implementation of implementation meeting
plans Explain how the plan
will be implemented
& what it means for
employees
Recognize team
members & others
Celebrate success
2/7/08 Supervisors & Executive reminds Emphasize value of Meeting
managers supervisors & the change
managers of their Review supervisors’
role in supporting & managers’ role
the change Discuss any
obstacles & how to
resolve them
2/7/08 All Executive reinforces Emphasize value of E-mail
employees value of the the change bulletin
change Encourage dialogue
Remind employees
of their role
Each All Progress report Inform employees of E-mail
quarter employees Encouragement continued progress bulletin
& encourage Posters
continued support
51
SURVEY ACTION PLAN
Date:
Focus:
Objective:
Resources Person(s)
Action Needed Due Date Accountable
52
SAMPLE SURVEY ACTION PLAN
Focus: Facilitate the development of trust by helping supervisors and employees build
stronger working relationships.
Objective: Beginning in February 2008, every supervisor will meet at least every two
weeks with each employee for an individual update meeting to discuss the employee’s
work and development progress and other work-related issues as needed. The supervisor
will document the meeting using the Update Meeting form provided.
(2) Each manager’s manager will talk with the manager during their own bi-weekly
update about the meetings the manager has conducted with supervising employees
over the past two weeks and review the Update Meeting forms completed by the
manager for those meetings. The manager’s manager will submit a record of the
meetings conducted by supervisors and managers to the executive the last week of
each quarter.
Resources Person(s)
Action Needed Due Date Accountable
Develop brief training programs to Staff support for 1/4/08 Keisha Brown –
help the supervisors learn how to preparing training supervisor
conduct update meetings and the materials & job training
employees to get the most out of aids
the updates Jon Lee–
Funds for materials employee
training
About 40 hours for
each program
The Division executive meets with all Meeting space & 1/7/08 Ron Bertoia
employees to inform them of the sound system coordinates
new practice meeting
One hour time for
each employee to Maria Diaz
attend presents
All employees
attend
53
Resources Person(s)
Action Needed Due Date Accountable
Supervisors and managers Training space 1/25/08 Keisha Brown
participate in the training delivers training
Flip charts &
markers All supervisors &
managers
LCD projector & attend
screen
The update meetings are held and Update forms Bi-weekly All supervisors,
the update forms are completed beginning managers &
About 30 minutes 2/4/08 employees
per meeting
Each supervisor’s manager talks Update forms Bi-weekly All managers
with the supervisor during their own beginning
bi-weekly update about the About 60 minutes 2/4/08
meetings the supervisor has per meeting
conducted with his or her
employees over the past two weeks
and reviews the completed Update
Meeting forms.
54