A Vision Mashiach: The Rebbe and The Rambam
A Vision Mashiach: The Rebbe and The Rambam
A Vision Mashiach: The Rebbe and The Rambam
for MASHIACH
TH E R E B B E A N D TH E R A M BA M
L E SSON 2
The Road to Redemption
CHAIRMAN
Rabbi Moshe Kotlarsky
P R I N C I PA L B E N E F A C T O R
Mr. George Rohr
EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR
Rabbi Efraim Mintz
CURRICULUM TEAM
Rabbi Lazer Gurkow
Rabbi Ahrele Loschak
Rabbi Naftali Silberberg
C O O R D I N AT O R S
Mrs. Rivki Mockin
Rabbi Dubi Rabinowitz
© Copyrighted 2021
BY THE ROHR JEWISH LEARNING INSTITUTE
INTRODUCTION
The first proof is from the book of Devarim, where the Torah
foretells that Hashem will return the Jewish people to Erets Yisrael,
which will enable us to fulfill all the mitzvos that are related to living
in Erets Yisrael. The second proof is from the prophecy of Bilam in
the book of Bamidbar, where the Torah speaks of Mashiach’s role as
a successor to David Hamelech.
L esson 2 T h e R o a d t o R e d e m p t i o n | 1
unturned and no soul unmoved, we must delve into Bilam’s proph-
ecy in more detail.
TEXT 1
ׁשּורנּו וְ ֹלא ָקרֹוב ָד ַרְך ּכֹוכָ ב ִמיַ ֲֽעקֹב וְ ָקם ֵׁש ֶבט ֶ ֶא ְר ֶאנּו וְ ֹלא ַע ָּתה ֲא
וְ ָהיָ ה ֱאדֹום יְ ֵר ָׁשה וְ ָהיָ ה.י־ׁשת
ֵ ֵל־ּבנ
ְ ָמֹואב וְ ַק ְר ַקר ּכ
ָ ִמיִ ְׂש ָר ֵאל ָּומ ַחץ ַּפ ֲֽא ֵתי
.יְ ֵר ָׁשה ֵׂש ִעיר אֹיְ ָביו וְ יִ ְׂש ָר ֵאל ע ֶֹׂשה ָחיִ ל
I see it, but not now; I behold it, but not soon. A star has gone forth
from Yaakov, and a staff will arise from Israel, crushing Moav’s princes
and uprooting all of Sheis’s descendants. Edom will be possessed, and
Se’ir will be inherited by his enemies and Israel will triumph.
Bilam was discussing a future event. “I see it, but not now”—it will
happen, but not just yet. Which event was he discussing here?
Rambam delves into these words and explains that Bilam was
discussing two separate epochs. The epoch of David Hamelech
and the epoch of Mashiach. He broke down these epochs into four
statements:
TEXT 2
2 | A V I S ION F O R MA S HIA C H
.” זֶ ה ָדוִ ד, ָ“ד ַרְך ּכֹוכָ ב ִמיַ ֲעקֹב.2
”.” זֶ ה ֶמלֶ ְך ַה ָמ ִׁשיח,“וְ ָקם ֵׁש ֶבט ִמיִ ְׂש ָר ֵאל
מֹואב וַ יְ ַמ ְד ֵדם
ָ אֹומר “וַ יַ ְך ֶאת
ֵ וְ כֵ ן הּוא.” זֶ ה ָדוִ ד,מֹואב
ָ “ּומ ַחץ ַּפ ֲא ֵתי
ָ .3
.) ב, ח:ַּב ֶח ֶבל” (שמואל ב
“ּומ ְׁשלֹו ִמיָ ם ַעד
ָ , ֶׁשנֶ ֱא ַמר ּבֹו,” זֶ ה ַה ֶמלֶ ְך ַה ָמ ִׁש ַיח,“וְ ַק ְר ַקר ּכָ ל ְּבנֵ י ֵׁשת
.) י,יָ ם” (זכריה ט
” ֶׁשנֶ ֱא ַמר “וַ ְּת ִהי ֱאדֹום לְ ָדוִ ד לַ ֲע ָב ִדים,” זֶ ה ָדוִ ד, “וְ ָהיָ ה ֱאדֹום יְ ֵר ָׁשה.4
) יד, ח:וְ גו’ֹ (שמואל ב
”מֹוׁש ִעים ְּב ַהר ִציֹון
ִ “וְ ָעלּו, ֶׁשנֶ ֱא ַמר, זֶ ה ַה ֶמלֶ ְך ַה ָמ ִׁש ַיח,’“וְ ָהיָ ה יְ ֵר ָׁשה” וְ גֹו
.) כא,וְ גֹו’ (עובדיה א
L esson 2 T h e R o a d t o R e d e m p t i o n | 3
“Se’ir (Esav’s extended family) will become the inheritance” refers to
Mashiach, as the Torah states, “Saviors will ascend Mount Zion to
judge the mountain of Esav” (Ovadiah 1:21). The Entire Torah
SUMMARY
In the next section we will break down these four categories and dis-
cover that each represents a new stage in the journey to redemption.
4 | A V I S ION F O R MA S HIA C H
I I . F O U R M E S S I A N I C AC H I E V E M E N TS
A G R A D U A L T R A N S F O R M AT I O N
L esson 2 T h e R o a d t o R e d e m p t i o n | 5
“ּכִ י ָאז ֶא ְהּפְֹך ֶאל,וִ ַית ֵקן ֶאת ָהעֹולָ ם ּכֻ לֹו לַ ֲעבֹד ֶאת ה’ ְּביַ ַחד ֶׁשנֶ ֱא ַמר
.)רּורה לִ ְקרֹא כֻ לָ ם ְּב ֵׁשם ה’ ּולְ ָע ְבדֹו ְׁשכֶ ם ֶא ָחד” (צפני’ ג טָ ַע ִמים ָׂש ָפה ְב
If a king will arise from the House of David who, like David his ances-
tor, will diligently contemplate the Torah and observes its mitzvos as
prescribed by the written and oral Torah;
And who will compel all of Israel to walk in (the ways of the Torah)
and rectify any breaches in its observance;
He will then rectify the entire world by motivating all the nations
to serve Hashem together, as the Torah states: “I will transform the
peoples to a purer language that they all will call upon the name of
Hashem and serve Him with one purpose” (Tsephaniah 3:9).
6 | A V I S ION F O R MA S HIA C H
With these criteria, Rambam traces a path from Mashiach’s private
life to the world at large. Let’s break it down step by step:
5
This need not be through actual war, necessarily. It can also be achieved through the
power of his charisma and the profundity of his wisdom. In other words, it can be a battle
of wills and a war of words that is conducted with love and respect. See Yeshayahu 11:4,
“רּוח ְׂש ָפ ָתיו יָ ִמית ָר ָׁשע ֶ ָ”וְ ִהּכ- He will strike the earth with the staff of his mouth
ַ ה־א ֶרץ ְּב ֵׁש ֶבט ִּפיו ְּוב
and with the beat of his lips he will slay the wicked. See Toras Menachem 5752:1, p. 297.
L esson 2 T h e R o a d t o R e d e m p t i o n | 7
T R AC I N G T H E P R O P H E CY
These four criteria are logical, but how did Rambam know to set
them up precisely this way?
When considering these criteria, most people might not catch the
significance of the fact that they break down into four parts. But to
the Rebbe, this fact looms large. It is like a road sign that points back
to Bilam’s prophecy, which also included four stages.
When you look at these four prophecies, you see that they teach us
Mashiach’s four criteria. Together they tell us what we can expect of
Mashiach, and how we might learn to identify him when he comes.
1. When Bilam said, “I see it, but not now,” referring to David, and
“I behold it, but not soon,” referring to Mashiach, he was describ-
ing the person. He saw their virtue and scholarship. He beheld
their diligence and scruples. He could see them in the future.
2. When Bilam proclaimed, “A star has gone forth from Yaakov,”
referring to David, and “A staff will arise from Israel,” referring
to Mashiach, he was describing their influence on the Jews. The
people of Yaakov looked up to David Hamelech, as people look
up to a star, and were inspired to emulate him by seeking higher
and better spiritual achievements. As a staff that rules over Israel,
Mashiach will similarly lead and inspire the Jewish people.
3. When Bilam prophesied that they would, “crush Moav’s princes,”
referring to David, and “uproot all of Sheis’s descendants,”
referring to Mashiach, he was describing their influence over
the nations. David Hamelech fought many wars against Israel’s
neighboring tribes until peace settled over the Land. Mashiach
will use his compelling force to silence all opposition and ensure
universal compliance with his ideals.
4. When Bilam concluded, “Edom will be possessed,” referring to
David, and “Se’ir will be inherited by his enemies,” referring to
Mashiach, he was talking about the nations embracing G-d out of
goodwill. Saying that Edom will become the possession of David
Hamelech means that they will subscribe to the Jewish mindset
8 | A V I S ION F O R MA S HIA C H
and serve it willingly. Similarly, saying that Se’ir will be inherited
by Israel means that Se’ir will embrace the Jewish heritage.
SUMMARY
In the next section we will demonstrate that Mashiach will not only
restore what David Hamelech accomplished; he will improve on it.
L esson 2 T h e R o a d t o R e d e m p t i o n | 9
III. COSMIC LEAPS
I M PA C T O N J E W S
In the section describing their influence over the Jewish people, the
Rebbe found subtle differences in the text that highlights Mashiach’s
superiority over David Hamelech:7
TEXT 4
אויף דוד’ן ווערט געזאגט דער לשון א כוכב וואס ווייזט אויף אזא וואס
אבער בנוגע צו משיח’ן. . איז מרומם ומנושא פון אנדערע בני אדם
וואס, וואס פירושו כפשוטו איז מלך רודה ומושל,זאגט ער וקם שבט
. ויכוף כל ישראל לילך בה ולחזק בדקה,דאס איז בגלוי בא משיח’ן
1 0 | A V I S ION F O R MA S HIA C H
David is described as a star, which implies exaltedness over ordinary
people.8 . . . Mashiach is described as a ruler—a king who rules domi-
nantly.9 This is expressed through Mashiach’s ability to compel Israel to
walk in the Torah’s ways and rectify its breaches.
D O M I N A N C E O V E R N AT I O N S
With respect to their ability to bend the nations to their will, the Rebbe
found similar nuances that reveal the differences between them.
TEXT 5
און בא משיח’ן (א) וקרקר,בא דוד איז נאר (א) מחץ (ב) פאתי מואב
.(ב) כל בני שת די שליטה אויף אלע אומות
8
See Radak, Numbers 24:17, “Because of his power and exalted greatness, a king is
like a star.”
9
Rashi, ad loc.
10
Another nuanced difference is that in the section about David Hamelech, we are
described as Yaakov; in the section about Mashiach, we are described as Yisrael. Of the
two, Yaakov, which means a heel, describes Jews at their lowest level. Yisrael, which
means a G-dly minister, describes the Jews at their highest level.
L esson 2 T h e R o a d t o R e d e m p t i o n | 1 1
When the enemy is crushed, they can rebuild and mount a counter-
attack. Also, if only one enemy is crushed, they can seek assistance
from their allies. When all the enemies are not only crushed, but also
uprooted, there is no hope for further resistance.
The final benchmark that Mashiach will reach is rectifying the world
so that the nations will freely acknowledge G-d and serve Him,
shoulder to shoulder. David Hamelech achieved this to a degree,11
but Mashiach will outpace him:
TEXT 6
" וואס דאס דריקט זיך אויס, "והי' אדום ירשה,בנודע לדוד זאגט מען
'" און בנוגע משיח'ן—"והי. "ותהי אדום לדוד עבדים,אין דעם וואס
און ווי ער זאגט אין." ניט נאר די אנשי העיר,ירשה שעיר אויביו
," וואס סיומו איז, ועלו מושעים בהר ציון לשפט את הר עשו " ,פסוק
"."והיתה לה' המלוכה
As reflected by the many nations who streamed to the Beis Hamikdash during the
11
reign of King Solomon (his son and successor) to bring offerings and to acknowledge
the one G-d.
1 2 | A V I S ION F O R MA S HIA C H
Mashiach will do two things better than David Hamelech. (A) David
Hamelech swayed the nations to serve him. Surely, they had a rela-
tionship with G-d through David, but it was not direct. Mashiach
will establish G-d as the king of the world, and the nations will
submit directly to G-d.12 (B) As we delineated in the previous sec-
tion, David Hamelech only held sway over a small group of people
compared to Mashiach, who will hold sway over the entire world.13
CONCLUSION
12
There is a deeper element here. David Hamelech’s emphasis was on bringing the
nations to serve G-d. Mashiach’s emphasis will be on revealing that G-d is the true king
of the world. The focus won’t be on the people, it will be on G-d. The people’s servitude
will result from that.
13
The Rebbe also points out that by looking carefully at these pesukim we can see
the distinction between the third and fourth stages. The third stage speaks of fighting
a war and crushing the enemy, which implies that the enemy would have continued to
fight had they not been defeated. The fourth stage speaks of inheritance and rectifying
the world. When we inherit something, it belongs to us truly and fully. Similarly, when
Mashaich comes, the nations will embrace Hashem without reservation and will, there-
fore, make a lasting and irreversible commitment.
14
See Igros Melech 2, p. 84. See also Sefer Hasichos 5748:2, p. 389, where it is noted
that, ironically, Mashiach will only fulfill his mandate when the non-Jews embrace G-d.
Everything he will do for Jews won’t fulfill his messianic mandate because it won’t be
unique to him. Shlomo Hamelech and Chizkiyahu Hamelech both already achieved that.
L esson 2 T h e R o a d t o R e d e m p t i o n | 1 3
his efforts, the Torah will assume its natural and inherent role as a
universal spiritual guide.
May our learning about Mashiach, and our excitement over his
coming, hasten his arrival. Amen.
SUMMARY
KEY POINTS
1 4 | A V I S ION F O R MA S HIA C H