UHF RFID Reader Antenna with High Gain

I.Ismail, S.M.Norzeli

Abstract— An E-shaped microstrip single layer RFID system generally consists of a reader, a
patch antenna with high gain is designed and tag and a data processing system. In RFID system,
analyzed for RFID (Radio Frequency Identification) the role of antennas (for reader and tag) is very
reader applications. It has one port excited with important. The antenna allows the chip to transmit
microstrip line feed mechanism. To obtain an
the information that is used for identification.
optimum peak gain, the effects of adding parasitic
elements and slots are respectively investigated. The Commonly, the UHF tag antennas are linearly
physical parameters of the novel structure as well as polarized. Therefore, reader antenna should have
its partial ground plane are analyzed and optimized circular polarization (CP) characteristic since the
using commercial computer simulation technology tag antenna can be arbitrary positioned on the
(CST) simulation packages. Return loss (S11), voltage target. The size reduction and gain enhancement
standing wave ratio (VSWR), directivity and gain of UHF RFID reader antenna have been the key
are carried out. The results show that the proposed issues in the system developer [6, 7].
antenna has good impedance and radiation A reader (now more typically referred to as an
characteristics over the required bandwidth, 860-960
RFID interrogator) is basically a radio frequency
MHz (UHF RFID band). The return loss of the
optimized E-shaped microstrip patch antenna is
(RF) transmitter and receiver, controlled by a
below 10dB over the UHF frequency band. The microprocessor or digital signal processor. An
proposed antenna is very promising for various RFID reader emits electromagnetic signals where
modern communication applications. an RFID tag draws power from it. This power is
then used to energize the microchip’s circuits. The
Index Terms— E-shaped, microstrip patch antenna, chip then modulates the waves and sends back this
computer simulation technology (CST), return loss modulated wave to the reader. This process is
(S11), voltage standing wave ratio (VSWR). called backscattering where the reader sees the
tag. The reader antenna must have high gain and
directivity. Every additional 3 dB of reader
I. INTRODUCTION antenna gain increase the tag range approximately
by 40% [2, 8].
R ADIO frequency identification (RFID) is a
technology that provides wireless In telecommunications, microstrip patch
antenna is widely used because of their several
identification and tracking capability and is more
robust than a bar code. Now RFID system in the advantages such as light weight, low volume, low
ultra high-frequency (UHF) bands (860-960 MHz) fabrication cost and capability of dual or triple
finds many applications in various areas such as frequencies operations. However microstrip
electronic toll collection, asset identification in antenna suffers from numbers of disadvantages.
retail item management, access control, animal Narrow bandwidth is a serious limitation of these
tracking, and vehicle security [1-5]. This is microstrip patch antenna [9].
because the UHF band can provide high data In this paper, an E-shaped microstrip patch
transfer rate and broad readable range. antenna with high gain for RFID reader and
wireless communications is designed to resonate
on the Ultra High Frequency (UHF) RFID bands
Manuscript received April 3, 2013. of 860MHz-960Mhz. The effects of adding
This work was supported under Dana Kecemerlangan from parasitic elements and slots are respectively
UiTM. Grant No: 600-RMI/DANA 5/3/RIF (362/2012).
I.Ismail Ismarani Ismail is a Senior lecturer at the Faculty of
investigated. The theoretical simulations are
Electrical Engineering, Universiti Teknologi MARA (UiTM). performed using CST software.
S.M.Norzeli is a PhD student at Faculty of Electrical
Engineering, Universiti Teknologi Mara.
(email:syamimi.uitm@gmail.com)
 ISMARANI AND SYAMIMI: UHF RFID READER ANTENNA WITH HIGH GAIN 47

II. ANTENNA DESIGN CONFIGURATION Patch width,

ܿ ߝ‫ ݎ‬+ 1
ܹ= ඨ
2݂‫݋‬ 2
When two parallel slots are incorporated into
the rectangular microstrip patch antenna, it
becomes an E-shaped microstrip patch antenna. (1)
The E-shaped microstrip patch antenna is simpler where;
in construction. In this design, the center fo=operating frequency
frequency of antenna is chosen as fo = 915MHz. εr=dielectric constant
The front view of the design is shown in Fig.1 and c=speed of light (3x108)m/s
the side view of the design is shown in Fig.2.
Effective dielectric constant,
Lg

ߝ‫ ݎ‬+ 1 ߝ‫ ݎ‬− 1 ℎ
εreff = + ඨ1 + 12
2 2 ܹ
Lf (2)
Wg
Wf W Effective length,

ܿ
‫= ݂݂݁ܮ‬
2 ݂‫ ݋‬ඥߝ‫݂݂݁ݎ‬
L
(3)
Fig.1: Front view of the E-shaped microstrip patch antenna
Length extension,
Patch Substrate FR4

(ߝ‫ ݂݂݁ݎ‬+ 0.3)(W/h + 0.264)

ΔL = 0.412h
(ߝ‫ ݂݂݁ݎ‬+ 0.258)(W/h + 0.8)
Ground

Fig.2: Side view of the E-shaped microstrip patch antenna (4)

where;
The design of E-shaped microstrip patch h=substrate thickness
antenna consist of substrate width (Wg), substrate
length (Lg), antenna width (W), antenna length Actual patch length,
(L) and a feed line which have impedance of 50
ohm where its feed width (Wf) and feed length
(Lf) are introduced symmetrically with respect to L = Leff − 2ΔL
the probe position. Dielectric substrate materials (5)
are used for design E-shaped microstrip patch
antenna. A FR4 (loss-free) substrate was used Ground plane extension Lg≠Wg,
while designing the antenna. The substrate used
has thickness (h) of 1.6 mm, dielectric constant Lg = 6h + L
(εr) of 4.7 and loss tangent of 0.019. PEC material (6)
was used for patch and ground of the antenna with
the thickness of 0.035mm. Wg = 6h + W
There were equations used to calculate Lg, Wg, (7)
L, W, Wf and Lf. The calculations used are given where;
by equations (1)-(7) [10]:- h=substrate thickness

Microstrip feed line use for patch antenna

 INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF ELECTRICAL AND ELECTRONIC SYSTEMS RESEARCH, VOL.6 JUNE 2013

determine to be fed for 50 ohm for line impedance Return loss (S11) also described as power
(Zo). Length and width for microstrip feed line relations and involves the reflected power. The
calculated using Equations [10] (8) and (9):- return loss which can be recorded with a network
analyzer provides immediate access to the
Feed length, reflection coefficient magnitude and thus the

‫ܮ‬
degree of impedance mismatch between the
‫= ݂ܮ‬
transmission line and generator.
2ඥߝ‫݂݂݁ݎ‬ Voltage Standing Wave Ratio (VSWR) was
(8) measured to indicate the degree of mismatch
Feed width, between a transmission line and its load, or
evaluate the effectiveness of impedance matching
60 8ℎ ܹ݂
ܼ‫= ݋‬ ln [ + ]
efforts. The ideal value of VSWR is 1, but
ඥߝ‫݂݂݁ݎ‬ ܹ݂ 4ℎ
typically the value ranges from 1.5 to 2.5.

(9)
where; III. RESULTS AND DISCUSSIONS
h=substrate thickness
From the original design of E-shaped microstrip
Zo=line impedance
patch antenna, it has been altered to obtain the
required specification at center frequency
Table I shows the calculation result of E-
(915MHz). The parameters that have been
shaped microstrip patch antenna operating at
optimized were patch width, substrate length and
center frequency 915 MHz.
width. Table II below shows the result simulation
TABLE I
obtained from E-shaped microstrip patch antenna
Calculation for design of E-shaped microstrip patch antenna before being optimized.

Parameter Value (mm) TABLE II

Wg 108.3 Parameter values from design of E-shaped microstrip patch
Lg 86.3 antenna
W 98.7
Parameter Value
L 76.7 Zo 50.269 Ω
Wf 1.45
Gain 3.324 dB
Lf 28.9 S11 6.721 dB
VSWR 2.263
The substrate used for E-shaped microstrip
patch antenna is FR4 (loss free). FR4 was chosen A final result of E-shaped microstrip patch
because it is cheap, greater design flexibility, ease antenna has been optimized for S11, VSWR, gain,
of fabrication and reduce in weight [11]. A FR4 front-to-back ratio, beamwidth and bandwidth.
substrate was selected to obtain a compact Fig.3 showed an optimized E-shaped microstrip
radiation structure. patch antenna.
The Front-to-Back Ratio is a parameter used in
describing the directional radiation patterns for
antenna. If an antenna has a unique maximum
direction, the front-to-back ratio is the ratio of
the gain in the maximum direction to that in the
opposite direction (180 degrees from the specified
maximum direction). This parameter is usually
given in dB [10]. Having a high front to back ratio
also may help with forward gain (gain in the Fig.3: Optimized E-shaped microstrip patch antenna
direction that the front of the antenna points to) From Fig.4 and Fig.5, it can be observed that
because some of the signal that may otherwise S11 value has met the desired value (<10dB) which
escape out the back of the antenna and be wasted is 11.116 dB. As well for the VSWR value of
is now reflected and captured by the driven 1.77which is approaching to 1.
element(s).
 ISMARANI AND SYAMIMI: UHF RFID READER ANTENNA WITH HIGH GAIN 49

A. PARAMETRIC STUDIES OF EFFECT ON

GAIN

In this section, the proposed antenna is

redesigned to investigate the effect on gain.
Parametric studies of the proposed antenna are
presented to provide more detailed information
about the antenna design and optimization. The
parameters under study include adding parasitic
Fig.4: S11 (dB) elements and slot. To better understand the
influence of the parameters on the performance of
the antenna, only one parameter at a time will be
varied, while others are kept unchanged unless
especially indicated.

1) Adding Parasitic Elements

Fig. 8 below shows the proposed antenna
adding with parasitic elements. Two rectangular
Fig.5: VSWR are placed at the left and right of the patch. The
rectangular have a minor truncated at the top and
Fig.6 and Fig.7 gives the view of gain in far-field PEC material was used with the thickness of
and polar plot. It is observed from far-field view 0.035mm.
the value of gain is 5.799dB and approaching to
6dB. Beamwidth is the angle between the two
points (on the same plane) at which the radiation
falls to "half power" or 3dB below the point of
maximum radiation [10]. From Fig.7, the
beamwidth was carried out and the value was 89.4
degree when the main direction was at 0 degree.
Front-to-Back ratio of the antenna can be obtained
from gain polar plot view in Fig.7. It was observed
that the F/B ratio of the antenna is 5.8 dB.
Fig.8: Adding Parasitic Elements

From the simulations result, it was observed

that gain is increased to 5.966 dB. Fig.9 and
Fig.10 below show the gain in far-field and polar
plot. From Fig.10, the beamwidth was carried out
and the value was 90.3 degree when the main lobe
direction was at 0 degree.

Fig.6: Far-field view for Gain

Fig.9: Far-field view for parasitic elements Gain

Fig.7: Polar Plot for Gain
 INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF ELECTRICAL AND ELECTRONIC SYSTEMS RESEARCH, VOL.6 JUNE 2013

the variety of the width of both left and right

rectangular parasitic elements have a significant
effect on gain and S11of the antenna. As the Fig.
describes, decreasing w causes higher gain values
and when w= 10mm and 12mm, S11 value doesn’t
meet desired value (<10dB) which was 6.92 dB
and 8.35 dB. Results have revealed that the best
performance is obtained when w = 14 mm.
Fig.10: Polar plot for parasitic elements Gain
2) Height of Parasitic Elements (h)
From Fig.11, it can be observed that S11 value
has met the desired value (<10dB) which is 25.465 The effect of varying the height (h) of parasitic
dB. elements on gain and S11 of the antenna is shown
in Fig.13.

10

Gain (dB)
5
0 Gain (dB)

36.7
56.7
76.7
96.7
116.7
Fig.11: S11 (dB) Height (mm)

1) Width of Parasitic Elements (w) (a)

Fig. 12 shows the antenna performance curve 30

S11 (dB)

for different values of w: 10 mm, 12 mm, 14 mm, 20

16 mm, and 18 mm. It is clearly observed that 10
0
S11 (dB)
36.7
56.7
76.7
96.7
116.7

6.5
Gain (dB)

6 Height (mm)
5.5
Gain(dB)
5 (b)
10 12 14 16 18 Fig.13: Effect of height of parasitic elements (h) on the antenna
Width (mm) performance. (a) Gain. (b) S11

It is clearly known from the Fig.s that only h=

(a)
76.7mm has met the required specification of S11
30 (<10dB). Results have revealed that the best
performance is obtained when h = 76.7mm.
S11 (dB)

20
10 3) Adding Slots
S11 (dB) The design of adding parasitic elements were
0 improved by slot is cut on the patch. Fig. 14 below
10 12 14 16 18 shows the improved design. The rectangular
Width (mm) shaped slot in the middle of the patch and slot are
vacuum.
(b)

Fig.12: Effect of width of parasitic elements (w) on the antenna

performance. (a) Gain. (b) S11
 ISMARANI AND SYAMIMI: UHF RFID READER ANTENNA WITH HIGH GAIN 51

4) Width of Rectangular Slit (w1)

In this part of parametric study, we change w1
to show effects of variation in gain on the antenna
performance. Fig. 18 exhibits the simulation
results for various values when other parameters
are kept unchanged.

Fig.14: Improved design with slot 6.5

Gain (dB)
By improved the design by slots is cut on the 6
patch, consequently the gain has increased to 5.5
6.145dB. Fig.15 and Fig.16 below give the view Gain (dB)
of far-field and polar plot gain. From Fig.16 the 5
beamwidth was carried out and the value was 90.4 4 9 18 24 30
degree when the main lobe direction was at 0
degree. Width (mm)
(a)

13
12
S11 (dB)
11
10 S11 (dB)
9
4 9 18 24 30
Fig.15: Far-field view for slot Gain
Width (mm)
(b)

Fig.18: Effect of width of slot (w1) on the antenna

performance. (a) Gain. (b) S11

It is found that the effect of w1 on antenna

performance is, decreasing w1 causes lower gain
values and mounted shaped of S11. It can be
observed that the best S11 value is 12.63. Results
have revealed that the best performance is
Fig.16 Polar plot for slot Gain
obtained when w = 18mm.
From Fig.17 below, it can be observed that S11
value has met the desired value (<10dB) which B. SURFACE CURRENT DISTRIBUTION
was 12.63 dB.
The surface current distribution on the radiating
element is shown in Fig. 19 for a frequency
915MHz. The Fig. clearly shows the current of
three different antennas. The red arrows show the
strongest current distributed in patch of antenna.

Fig.17: S11 (dB)

 INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF ELECTRICAL AND ELECTRONIC SYSTEMS RESEARCH, VOL.6 JUNE 2013

(a) beam steering of RLSA antenna with RFID technology,"

Progress In Electromagnetics Research, Vol. 108, 65-80,
2010.
[4] Li, X. and J. Liao, “Eye-shaped segmented reader
antenna for near-¯ eld UHF RFID applications," Progress
In Electromagnetics Research, Vol. 114, 481-493, 2011.
[5] Amin, Y., Q. Chen, H. Tenhunen, and L.-R. Zheng,
“Performance- optimized quadrate bowtie RFID antennas
for cost-effective and eco-friendly industrial
applications," Progress In Electromagnetics Research,
(b) Vol. 126, 49-64, 2012.
[6] ShinChul, K., et al. A novel design of an UHF RFID
reader antenna for PDA. in Microwave Conference, 2006.
APMC 2006. Asia-Pacific. 2006.
[7] Nasimuddin, Zhi Ning Chen, Xianming Qing, “ A
compact circularly polarized slotted slit microstrip patch
antenna,” Proceedings of the Asia Pacific Microwave
Conference 2011.
[8] Hend A. Malhat, Saber H. Zainud-Deen and Kamal H.
(c) Awadalla, “Circular Polarized Dielectric Resonator
Antenna for Portable RFID Reader Using a Single Feed,”
Fig.19: Surface Current Distribution on the antenna International Journal of Radio Frequency Identification
performance. (a) Without change (b) Adding Parasitic Element and Wireless Sensor Networks 2011.
(c) Improved by Slot [9] G. Purnachandra Rao, Kshitiz Agarwal, M. V.
Kartikeyan, M. K. Thumm, “Wideband Single Patch E-
shaped Compact Microstrip Antenna for High Speed
IV. CONCLUSION Wireless Local Area Networks”.
[10] Constantine A. Balanis., “Antenna Theory: Analysis and
Microstrip antenna has become a rapidly growing Design”, 2nd edition, John Wiley & Sons, 1997 ISBN 0-
area of research. Their potential applications are 471-59268-4
limitless, because of their light weight, compact [11] Dr. Anubhuti Khare, Rajesh Nema, Rajeev Kumar
size and ease of manufacturing. In this paper, a Thakur and Puran Gour, “New Multiband E-Shape
Microstrip Patch Antenna on RT DUROID 5880
circularly polarized (CP) E-shaped microstrip Substrate and RO4003 Substrate for Pervasive Wireless
single layer patch antenna with high gain been Communication”, International Jounal of Computer
designed and adding parasitic elements and slot Applications (0975-8887), Vol.9, No.8, November 2010.
are investigated for UHF RFID reader. The return
loss was below 10dB for 915 MHz. By adding
slot, the value of gain becomes higher which was
6.681dB. The antenna is thin and compact with the Ismarani Ismail is a Senior lecturer at the Faculty of Electrical
use of low dielectric constant substrate material. Engineering, Universiti Teknologi MARA (UiTM). She holds
an Electronics Manufacturing Engineering from University of
These features are very useful for worldwide Salford, United Kingdom and Bachelor of Engineering degrees
portability of wireless communication equipment. in Electrical and Electronics Engineering from John Moores
University, Liverpool, UK. Her main research interest is in
Radio Frequency Identification system, electronics product
development, system development and electronic and electrical
ACKNOWLEDGMENT manufacturing processes. She has published in a number of
The work was completed with a grant from the national and international journals. In addition to teaching, she
supervises and advises Masters and Doctoral students.
Dana Kecemerlangan of UiTM. Grant No: 600-
RMI/DANA 5/3/RIF (362/2012).
Syamimi .Mohd Norzeli obtained her degree of B.Eng. (Hons)
Electrical Engineering from Universiti Teknologi Mara
(UiTM) Shah Alam. Currently she is pursuing her PhD in the
REFERENCES area of RFiD Technology. Her PhD work is focusing in
[1] Ankang, R., et al. A novel design for UHF near-field developing UHF RFiD reader antenna.
RFID reader antenna based on traveling wave. in
Communication Technology (ICCT), 2010 12th IEEE
International Conference on.
[2] Finkenzeller, K., RFID Handbook, 2nd Edition, Wiley,
New York, 2003.
[3] Jamlos, M. F., A. R. B. Tharek, M. R. B. Kamarudin, P.
Saad, O. Abdul Aziz, and M. A. Shamsudin, “Adaptive