Blcok-5 MCO-7 Unit-1
Blcok-5 MCO-7 Unit-1
Blcok-5 MCO-7 Unit-1
MANAGEMENT
Structure
19.0 Objectives
19.1 Introduction
19.2 Nature and Goals of Credit Policy
19.3 Credit Policy Variables
19.4 Credit Evaluation of Individual Acco~~nts
19.4.1 Collecting Credit I~lfol-~ilation
19.4.2 Credit Investigation
19.4.3 Credit Granting Decision
19.5 Monitoring Receivables
19.6 Facloring
19.7 Securitisatio~l
19.8 Let Us S U I ~Up
I
19.9 Key Words
19.10 Terminal Questions/Exercises
+---I --+
Rigid Policy Credit Liberal policy
Policy
Figure 19.1: Credit Policy: Profitabilityand Liquidity
Management of Working ,A more liberal policy shows tliat liquidity decreases and profitability increases. In case of
Capital rigid and stringent policy, liquidity increases and profitability decreases. So a firm's credit
policy shou!d be such that can maintain balance between liquidity and profitability.
However, credit policy depends upon many factors. They are: (1) percentage of
credit sales to total sales, (2) the nature of business and conventions prevailing in tlie
trade, (3) tlie level of sales i.e., higher the sales high will be receivables and vice-versa,
(4) tlie collection policy, (5) tlie quality of customers; and (6) the ternls of sales.
On the basis of the above incremental contribution under the various alternative credit
policies over the present level, policy B slio~~ld
be adopted.
Illustratio~i2: A trader whose current sales are Rs.15 lakhs pcr annum and average
collection period is 30 days wants to pursue a lnore liberal credit policy to improve
sales. A study made by a consultant firm reveals the following information:
Credit Policy pcriocl Itzcreclse itz coll~cfiotzperiod Incrense itz sale
(Rs.)
A 15 days 60,000
B 30 days 90,000
C 45 days 1,50,000
D 60 days 1,80,000
E 90 days 2,00,000
Tlie selling price per uliit is Rs.5. Average cost per unit is Rs.4 and variable cosl per
unit is Rs.2.75 paise. The ~.equiredrate of return on additional investment is 20%.
Assume a 360 days in a year and also assume that there are no bad debts. Which of
the above policies would you recommend for adoption?
. :
I
Proposal D is accepted because it shows highest profits.
Selectioll of such alternative credit policies are based on certain assuniptio~~s
e.g.,
1
.prices are same and existing capacity is sufficient to cope with increased productioll
and sales.
Credit Period
Credit period is tlie lengtli of time allowed to c ~ ~ s t o ~ ntoe rpay
s for their purchases.
Sucb period directly affects the volume of investment in receivables. Longer credit
period may increase sales, but it also increases investment in receivables and lower the
quality of trade credit. The credit period differs from industry to industry and within
firms in tlie same industry. The firm usually talces into consideration tlie buyer's rate
of stoclc tulnovel; colnpetitors' approacli, natLire of commodity, margin of profit and
availability of f~i~ids.
The lengthe~lillgof credit period involves the costs. Such costs are involved in tying up
investment in receivables. The firm may also experience bad debts and increase in
collectiotl costs. The credit policy can be Iiberalised if the cost associated with
lengthening the credit period is less than increased earnings. In case the costs are
more, the credit period should not be extended. The finance manager has to find an
optimal credit period for tlie firm. The extension of credit period is useful and to.what
extent is also explained by incremental approacli, as show11 in above two examples,
i.e., 60 days in first and 90 days in second example.
Receivnbles Management
,4 creditor grants cash discount to a debtor if lie makes payment in or before credit
period. It is not a compensation but a premium on payment of clebts. The cash
discount temi indicates the rate ofdiscount and the period for which the discount has
been offered. Cash discount is beneficial lo both creditor and clebtor. It increases
the tLlr11over rate of working capital and the firm can do higher volume of business
with less illvestlnent in worlcing capital. Casli discount prevents clebtors from using
trade credit as a source of working capital.
Illustl-ation 3 : If the tracler of'fers a cash cliscount @ 2% if payment is made within
10 days ol'the date of invoice. If tlie collection period is reduced from 60 clays to 30
days, it is Iiopid 50% of customers will talie the discot.lnt benefit.
Assume Rs. 25,00,000 average investment in receivables and net profit in 30 days is
Rs. 54.000 ancl in GO days. Additional investment needed is Rs. 2,33,334 slid profit
rill be Rs. 80,500. Shoi~lclthe company givc this discoiunt'?
Cost of Casli discount -- Rs. 25,00,000 s 0.50 x 0.02
The amount of Rs. 1,16,667 is freed LIPand suppose trader wants 14% rate of return,
ildditional earnings will be Rs.l,16,667 s 0.14 = Rs.16,333. The cost of discount is
1iighe1Ilinn tlie additional earnings. So the cliscout~tshould not be ofkred.
Collectiot~Efforts
l d such that speeds up collection oTdiies. If the speed is
The collection policy s l i o ~ ~bc
slow, additional finance will be needed to sustain the production and sales. The
objective should be to collect dues and ]lot to offend tlie customer. The firm may take
eflorls like sending a reminder or personal request on phonc or (>el-sonalvisits to
custolner or tlirougll collection agelicics. 7'lie aging schedule of debtors sl~ouldbe
prcparecl. Sonie of the lirms i n big cities employ 'muscle' men to rccover payments,
wliicli is a wrong policy. Court casc of recovery shoultl be avoided as far as possible
becausc of court clelays a~iclmounting litigation expenses in India.
...............................................................................................................................
2) What are the objectives of credit policy?
1) Traditional Approach
2) Statistical Approach
-
Traditional approach relates to analysis of five "C"s of credit Capital, Character,
Collateral, Capacity and Condition, which have discussed earlier.
The traditional approach suffers from drawbacks like that it is not easy to judge these
five "CWs. There is no consistency in analysis or nolink to shareholders' wealth
maximisation.
Modern approach consists of (a) Heuristic approach, (b) discriminate analysis,
(c) Sequential decision an'alysis.
According to He~lristicor Rating Index approach, the factors to be considered are
credit requirements, pay habits, year of business, profit turnover, and qualitative
factor (i.e., discretion of the manager). Each factor is given n weight. Then
contribution of each factor to credit limits is expressed as percentage of net worth.
Discriminate analysis is computer based technique. It considers current ratio and
return on net worth ratio. These ratios are plotted on a grapli. A line is drawn
between the plotted poitits dividing them in equal parts, Seql~entialdecision
analysis follows three steps (a) consulting credit files,i.e. past payrnent rccord
(b) examining credit agency rating, i.e., internal analysis. (c) interchange of bank
report, i.e., external credit analysis,
f 9.4.3 Credit Granting Decision Receivables Management
C~lstomers
/ Low Refuse credit
It is necessary to compare cost of goods sold and revenue From sale. The present
value of 1.evenues from sale to customers who have been granted credit should be
compared with cost of goods sold plus cost of investigation. If there is a possibility of
repeat order from customer who pays in time, then the expected profits sl~ouldbe
considered after considering the probability of paynlerlt and repeat order. In sucb a
case time value of money be ignored.
Suppose a firm has an incremental cash flows of Rs. 300 as a result of change in
credit policy. Tile required rate of return is 5%. The cost of producing additional
units due to increase in credit sales of Rs. 35,000 is Rs.10,000. Then NPV will be =
P.V. of benefit - Cost.
The four weeltly receivables are Rs.800, Rs.720, Rs.640, Rs.620 and weekly sales are
Rs.300, Rs.3 12 alld Rs.3 16 respectively. The DOS for six weelcs.wil1 be as follows:
Rs.620
-= 20 days appraxlmately
(300+312+315)/30
Tile BOS slioirlcl be below 4 pre-determined period. A better methad is to shaw the
patter11of csllectio~~sassociated with credit sales by matrix method. If we divicle
credit sales by average debtors it will give us, average collection period. The average
collectioii period be shown as follows: 59
Mnnagenlent of Working Week of Sales I weel< 11 weel< Ill week IV week
Capital
Percentage of Receivables
Collected during I week 20% 15% 10% 35%
11 week 45% 25% 15% 10%
111 week 10% 25% 3 5% 5 0%
IV week 20% 50% 15% 10%
This method helps to remove the drawback of DOS payment behaviour. The matrix
neth hod helps to know when collection is improved, same ordeclining.
Aging Schedrrle
This method is also a traclitional method. It also suffers from the same defect as the
DOS. The qua1ity of receivables is determined by their age. It is compared with pre-
determiliecl credit period. For example, iftlie normal credit period is 30 days and their
age is as follows:
Age (n~aiiberof days) % of total outstanding receivables
[,ess than 30 days 80%
3 1 to 60 days 20%
G I to 90 days 10%
From the above, the aging shows that creclit policy is good.
Check Your Progress B
1) What do you mean by credit analysis?
...............................................................................................................................
2) List the five C's of credit.
19.6 FACTORING
Factoring is an increasingly utilized financial tool that speeds a firni's cash flow and
helps to avoid the proble~nsthat slow-paying custonlers can create. It involves an
outright sale of a co~l~pany'sreceivables to a financial ilistitution laown as a factor.
Wlien ~aeceivablesare factored, title passes on to the factor ancl tlie receivables no
longer appear on the company's balance sheet.
Factoring provides quick and convenient filndiiig to growing companies who need
capital t o expand their business. To do this, factors purchase credit-worthy accounts
receivable at a small discount and fund tlie colnpany with immediate cash. Nol.mally
it is witho~ltrecourse to tlie supplier who raised tlie bill. Hence, factoring turns your
receivables into cash today, instead ofwaiting to be paid at a future date.
The factor enters into an agreement with t l ~ ecompany for factoring receivables and
thb terms under wliich it is ready to advance funds. The firnis sends the customer
purchase order to the factor to do a credit verification and approval. Factor confirms
willingness to advance f~~ncls based on the credit risk evaluation. Based on this
confil-mation, the customer is inforlned that the receivables llave been sold and that the
payment must be made directly to the factor.
There is no debt rbpayme~~t, no compromise to the fii-111's balance sheet, no long-term
agreements or delays associated wit11 other metliods of raising capital. Factoring
allows the firm to u8e its own hard earned assets to create cash for the growth needs Receivables Management
of the business today.
-
19.7 SECUHgITPSATION -
Securitisation means the conversion of existing or fuiure cash inflows into tradable
security which tlien may be sold in the market. The cash inflow from financial assets
s~lclias mot-tgage loans, automobile loans, trade receivables, credit card receivables,
fare collections become the security against which borrowings are raised. In fact,
even individuals can take the help of sccuritisation instrutnents for bctter economic
efficiency. e.g, an individual having I-egularinflows by way orrent from property can
raise a loan by on'cring his rent receivables as security i.e. the rent receipts will first
be itsed to pay the loan a ~ i dtlien for other purposes. Since the lender is assured of
regular cash inflows, Lhere is a n enhanccd element of credit. Corporate securitisation
deals involving crores of rupees arc m ~ ~ cmore l i complicated. The importance of
securitisation lies in the fact that it helps to convert illiqi~iclassets or f ~ ~ l ureceivables
re
into current cash inflows and that too at a low cost. 'L'he company may sell the
receivahlcs in the marlcet and raise loans.
Securitisation therefore, is a process by which tlie f~lturccash inflo\vs of an entity
(originator) are converted ancl sold as debt instruments called "pay ihrough or pass
iX1rongl1"certificates with a lised rate ol'return Lo the Ilolders of'beneficial interest.
'I'lie originator of a typical sccuritisation tra11sfct.sa ~~ortfolioorliliancial asscts to a
Special Purpose Vehicle ( S13V ), commonly a ts~lst.The SI'V is basically ii~ncleclby
investo~*s, In return for the transfer, the originator gets cash up-front on the basis of n
~nutilallyagreed valuation of the receivables. The transl'er value of tlie receivables is
done in such a mauner so as to give tlie lenders a reasonable rate of return. In 'pass-
throi~gh'ancl 'pay-throitgh' securitisations, rcccivahles arc transrcrred to the SPV at
the inception of the securitisation, and no firrLIier transl'ers arc macle, All cash
collections arc paicl to tlic holclers ol'beneiicial interests in tlie SPV.
Special Purpose Velmicle ( SPV)
An SPV is an entity specially created for doing the securitisation cleal. It invites
investment from investors, uses .the invested fi111dsto acquire to receivables of the
originator and then uses the realizations Trom the receivnhlcs transferred to it to p;ty
[lie investors, therchy giving them a I-easonablerclurn An SI'V may be a trust,
corporation. 01. any ~tlict'legal entity. Its activities are :
e Holdingtitle to transl'erred financial assets
e Issuing beneficial interest (if the beneficial interests are in tlie form of debt securities
or equity securities, the transfer of assets is a securitisation)
e Collecting cash proceeds from assets held, reinvesting proceecls in financial
itlstruments pending distribution to the holders ofbencl'lcial interests and
otlierwise servicing the assets Ilcld
Distributing proceeds to the 11oldet.s of the beneficial interests.
Belleficial interests in the qualifying SPV are sold to investors and the proceeds are
used to pay the transferor for the assets transferred. Those beneficial intcrcsts tnay
co~npriseeither a single class liaving equity characteristics or tnultiple classes of
interests, somc having dcbt cliaractcristics and others having eqllity characteristics.
The cash collected from i11e pol-tfolio is clistributed to the investors and others as
specified by tlie legal documents that establishes the SPV. Normally, Iransl'er to the
SPV of receivables involves stamp dilty payments. However, tlicse costs t ~ ~ sbe ly
offset by benefits such as the PTCs being fairly tradable and liquid, higher credit
rating, etc. In India, the stamp ditty on secondary marlcet transactions is waivcd, if the
PTCs are issued in detnaterialized fortn. A Pass Through Certificate is a n il~strument
which signifies transfer of interest in the receivable in rtlvour of the holder ofthe Pass
Throitgh Celtificate. The investors in a pass throitgli transactiotl acquire the
o f Working
Rlanagcme~~t receivables subject to all their fluctuations, prepayment etc. The material risksand
Capital rewards in the asset portfolio, such as the risk of interest rate variations, risk of
I
prepayments, etc. are transferred to the investors.
Merits
Securitisation can help raise funds at a rating higher than what is the actual rating of
the originator. T1ie added advantage of a securitisation deal is that the securitised assets
(receivables) go off the balance sheet of the originator. This is especial ly helpful in the
banking industry which has to adhere to capital adequacy norms. Besides, the asset
portfolio (receivables) is liquidated releasing cash which in turn reduces the need for
demand and time liabilities that are subject to statutory reserves in case of banks.
Another advantage is that small investors can profit from such deals since they can
invest s~nallsums in the SPV and acquire beneficial interest. In fact there may be
issues whereby the SPV is filnded mainly by s~nallinvestors. Securitisation keeps the
other traditional lines ofcredit undisturbed. Hence, it increases the total financial
resoilrces available to the firm.
Demerits
Since securjtisation is off-balance sheet funding, the true picture of the, originators'
financial position is not clear merely from the balance sheet The best assets of the
company may be transferred to the SPV and the colnpany may be left with sub-
standard assets on its books. The greatest demerit of securitisation is its opagueness. A
colnpaliy may have taken huge liabilities but that may not be apparent from the balance
sheet or conventioilal financial statelnents ofthe company. This is especially true
where the securitisatio~lis with recoi~rsei.e. if the receivables wl~ichhave been
securitised to the SPV become bad the SPV will have the right to recover the dues
from the originator. The originator may have a lot of contingent liabilities without
anyone being aware of it.
The process of securitisatio~~ of receivables
A securitisation deal norn~allyhas the following stages : i) The originator determines
which assets he wants to securitise for raising funds. ii) The SPV is formed, iii) The
SPV is funded by investors and issues securities to the investors, iv) The SPV
acquires the receivables under an agreement at their discounted value, v) The servicer
for the transaction is appointed, normally the originator, bi) The debtors are fare not
notified depending on the legal requirements. vii) The servicer collects the receivables,
usually in an escrow mechanis~n,and pays off the collection to the SPV, viii) The SPV
either passes the collection to the investors, or reinvests the same to pay off to
investors at stated intervals, ix) In case of default, the servicer takes action against the
debtors as the SPV's agent, x) When only a s~nallamount ofoutstanding receivables
are left to be collected, the originator lnay clean up the transaction by buying back the
outstandiilg receivables, and xi) At the end ofthe transaction, the originator's profit, if
retained a r ~ dsubject to any losses to the extent agreed by the originatol; in the
transaction is paid off.
Check Your Progress C '
1) What is factoring?
...............................................................................................................................
2) How does SPV work?
Why factoring is not loan? Rcceivnbles hlnnagcment
3)
19.9 KEYWORDS - --
3) Discuss the role of credit terms and credit stalidards in a credit policy of a firm.