Paper
Paper
Paper
Output of a Seminar on
Energy Conservation
in Paper and Pulp Industry
Sponsored by
Hosted by
Organized by
1993
Thailand Philippines
PREFACE
The conservation of energy in an essential step we can all take towards overcoming the mounting
problems of the worldwide energy crisis and environmental degradation. In particular, developing
countries ate interested to increase their awareness on the inefficient power generation and energy
usage in their countries. However, usually only limited information sources on the rational use of
energy are available.
The know-how on modem energy saving and conservation technologies should, therefore, be
disseminated to governments and industrial managers, as well as to engineers and operators at the
plant level in developing countries. It is particularly important that they acquire practical knowledge
of the currently available energy conservation technologies and techniques.
In December 1983, UNIDO organized a Regional Meeting on Energy Consumption as well as
an Expert Group Meeting on Energy Conservation in small- and medium-scale industries for Asian
countries. During these meetings, it was brought out that, for some energy intensive industries,
savings up to 10% could be achieved through basic housekeeping improvements, such as auditing
and energy management.
All these experiences brought UNIDO to prepare a regional programme on the promotion and
application of energy saving technologies in selected subsectors, since the rational use of energy calls
for a broad application of energy conservation technologies in the various industrial sectors where
energy is wasted. One of these energy intensive industrial sectors to be considered to improve
efficiency through the introduction of modem energy conservation technologies is the pulp and paper
industry.
The pulp and paper industry consumes much energy and water. The pulp and paper industry is
also noted for great percentage of the energy cost in the total production cost.
In the pulp and paper industry, appreciable amounts of energy could be saved or conserved by
regulating and insulating the temperature in the steam pipes, modifying the equipment to recover heat
from the various units in the process of pulping and paper-making and effective use and reuse of paper
machine white water.
Currently, UNIDO is implementing this Programme with the financial support of the Japanese
Government, in selected Asian developing countries. This programme aims at adopting these
innovative energy conservation technologies, developed in Japan, to the conditions of developing
countries.
In this programme, we are considering that the transfer of these technologies could be achieved
through:
(i) Conducting surveys of energy usage and efficiency at the plant level;
(ii) Preparing handy manuals on energy management and energy conservation/saving tech-
nologies, based on the findings of the above survey;
(iii) Presenting and discussing the handy manuals at seminars held for government officials,
representatives of industries, plant managers and engineers;
(iv) Disseminating the handy manuals to other developing countries for their proper utilization
and application by the industrial sector.
The experience obtained through this programme will be applied to other programmes/projects
which involve other industrial sectors as well as other developing countries and regions.
UNIDO has started this programme with the project US/RAS/90/075 - Rational Use of Energy
Resources in Steel and Textile Industry in Malaysia and Indonesia. This was followed by project US/
RAS/92/035 - Rational Use of Energy Saving Technologies in Pulp/Paper and Glass Industry in
Philippines and Thailand.
The present Handy Manual on Pulp and Paper Industry was prepared by UNIDO, with the
cooperation of experts from the Energy Conservation Center (ECC) of Japan, on energy saving
technologies in the framework of the above-mentioned UNIDO project. It is based on the results of
the surveys carried out, the plant observations and the recommendations and suggestions emanating
from the Seminars on Energy Conservation in the Pulp and Paper Industry; held under the same
project in January and February 1993 in Bangkok, Thailand and Manila, Philippines respectively.
The handy manual will not only be interesting for government and representative from industry, but
it is, in particular, designed for plant-level engineers and operators in developing countries as a help
to improve energy efficiency in the production process.
Appreciation is expressed for the valuable contribution made by the following institutions to the
successful preparation and publication of the manual mentioned above:
The Department of Energy, Philippines
Ministry of Science, Technology and Environment, Thailand
Ministry of International Trade and Industry (MITI), Japan
The Energy Conservation Center (ECC), Japan
July 1993
CONTENTS
Preface
The pulp and paper industry has been consuming much energy and water ever since Cailun (an
inventor of paper in ancient China) invented paper in A.D. 105. He crushed the bark of the shrub with
a stone mill to extract fibers, and separated the single fibers by washing them in water. When they
were uniformly distributed underwater, they were dewatered and formed by a drain board Then the
wet paper web was dried in the sun for a long time, and final paper products were obtained.
The basic principle in the manufacturing process of the pulp and paper industry today has
undergone almost no change, but industry has developed into a process industry constituting the
continuous production processes. Figure 1 shows an example of the production process.
The pulp and paper industry consumes much energy and water. The pulp and paper industry is
also noted for a great percentage of the energy cost in the total production cost.
- l -
Chemical pulping process
-2-
2. Consumption in the pulp and paper production process
It is extremely difficult to grasp the energy consumption pattern in the entire pulp and paper
industry. Since the pulp process differs considerably depending on production items and composi-
tion of the material woods, it is difficult to define the representative pulping process. Table 1
represents the unit consumption of the consumption pattern of steam and electric power summarized
according to the recent data in Japan, using the model of the integrated fine paper mill for general
printing paper and writing paper.
The paper machine, which is the greatest consumer of steam, followed by the black water
concentration process, is also the greatest consumer of electric power.
-3-
3. Promotion of energy conservation technology
3.1 Waste-saving and effective use of energy
The paper and pulp production equipment as a process plant is operated by electric power and
thermal energy. Energy conservation is meant not to reduce the energy for operation, but to ensure
“was@-saving” and “effective” use of energy, thereby resulting in reduced energy for operation.
“Waste-saving” and “‘effective” use of energy is ensured by field technology.
“Waste-saving” use is provided by continuous operation from the start of operation to the day
of shutdown determined by the production schedule, without the paper and pulp production being
interrupted by the machine and steam system failure, electric failure due to accidents, or paper
breaking on the paper machine.
This continuous operation requires:
1) Quality control system which permits the constant production of stable good-quality
products, without products rejected in the inspection, and
2) Preventive maintenance (PM) system which eliminates the possibility of machine and
equipment troubles or electric failure due to electric equipment failure.
The so-called total control system must be implemented every day as part of the routine work.
“‘Effective” use is to prevent dissipation and waste of heat of the energy supplied to the system
or to recover it, and to provide uniform hydration in the cross direction on the wire part, press part
and dryer part by ensuring the following equipment functions:
1) Improving the rate of circulated use of white water to reduce the wasteful discharge, which
leads to the reduction of new water used
The electric power for the pump, agitator and refiner is converted into thermal energy to
raise the pulp slush temperature. Discharge of the white water means discharge of heat.
Maintenance of a high system temperature by effective circulation of the white water will
improve the dewatering rate and reduce the amount of steam used for drying. Effective
circulation of the white water will also improve the yield rate.
-4-
2) Uniform nip pressure of the pressure to be ensured in the cross direction
Effective energy reduction cannot be gained by mere pressure increase. Uniform dewatering
is ensured only by uniform pressure in the cross direction, which, in turn, will permit
uniform drying and minimize the possibility of paper breaking.
3) Three functions of showering, squeezing and dewatering to be used to wash the press felt
The felt cleaned and dewatered to have low-moisture content promotes suction of water in
the pressing process. The use of hot water for shower provides effective washing and
prevents the wet web temperature from lowering.
4) Dryer surface to be kept clean by effective use of the doctor thereby ensuring high heat
conductivity
6) Ventilation inside the dryer part to be uniform on the front and back, dryer pocket in
particular to be eliminated completely
The following describes the concept of “wastesaving” and “effective” energy conservation,
with particular reference to the chemical pulping kraft process.
Figure 2 shows the case of batch cooking.
-5-
Cooking Control Gas Heat Recovery Blow Gas Heat Recovery
-6-
Much energy is consumed in the chip pulping reaction.
Heat required for reaction must be given as effectively as possible, and the heat should be
removed upon termination of the reaction; otherwise, it may affect the quality and yield. The
following points should be noted for this series of reaction:
(4) Blowing
When the pulp in the digester is to be blown out by the internal pressure, the blow speed is
increased and the blow time is decreased by increasing the differential pressure of the
exhaust gas. Pulps are attached to the jet condenser which absorbs a great amount of gas
and the thermal accumulator. Pulps also enter the heated dirty water, so they are attached
to the heat exchanger for heat recovery. Since the pulps feature extremely small heat
conductivity, they must be removed periodically.
-7-
For energy conservation in the pulp division, effective supply of energy for pulping must
be ensured, and the extra energy required for pulping should be recovered as effectively as
possible, and should be put to reuse.
- 8 -
This effort means a great contribution not only to energy conservation, but also to a reduction
in the amount of solid waste generated in the community and reduction in the refuse processing costs,
thereby contributing to the global environment protection.
The progress of the technology for an effective use of waste paper in the pulp and paper
industry is quite remarkable. Figure4 illustrates the consumption rate in the world. It shows
that energy conservation of the pulp and paper industry in the world is making a steady
progress.
-9-
Source: PPI
-l0-
3.4 Energy conservation technology in the papermaking process
The pulp and paper industry as a process industry is required to ensure efficient operation,
depending on the control method which provides continuous operation. An improvement of the
operation efficiency will lead to the effective use of energy and lowering of the unit consumption.
From the viewpoint of operation efficiency, the energy conservation measures can be reduced
to the following points:
It is generally felt that there is no remedy for electric failure. A paper manufacturing company
which frequently suffers from power failure adopted a private power generation equipment. Since
then, it has ensured a stable supply of power completely free from electric failure. Operation
efficiency has been increased, while power cost has been reduced to half that of the purchased power.
As a result, sales volume and yield have been improved, enabling the company to achieve
depreciation in less than three years. This effort has also contributed to the improvement of power
situations in local communities and they appreciate it very much.
The process industry cannot enjoy continuous operation without an effective maintenance
division. Preventive maintenance (PM) is to prevent accidents in advance and to repair and improve
the equipment by a planned equipment maintenance based on the past experience with the equipment
failure and by checking the operation through a daily equipment inspection on patrol. It is intended
to eliminate the operation shutdown by the maintenance division.
-ll-
3.4.1 Paper breaking
Paper breaking in the paper machine will lead to a waste of energy and reduced yield, causing
costs to be increased. It also results in a considerable labor consumption. Paper breaking used to be
considered as a matter of course: However, after a detailed analysis of the paper breaking is carried
out, the problem will be greatly reduced as a result of improved operator skill, improved equipment
ranging from material treatment to paper making process, and introduction of the instrumentation
control.
The following points should be noted regarding technical problems involved in the
equipment:
a) Selection of the equipment with insufficient functions (selection error)
b) Equipment not operating in conformity to the specifications
c) Neglected maintenance, inspection, repair, or performance checking of the equipment
therefore, required performances not fully used
d) Claim against electric failure not submitted to the section in charge inside or outside the
company; technical improvement delayed
It is their duty to check if each function is working, to review the operation method and to
improve it if something is wrong.
-12-
Figure 5 Cause and effect diagram of paper breaking
Table 3 Causes for paper breaking and remedies
Places for
Classifications Causes Measures Equipment factors
paper breaking
1. Wet part
(1) Couch Fall from couch Excess Moisture Promotion of Dewater rectify on
Wet dewatering on wire Wire Part
Insufficient strength) Setup of Pick up roll
(2) Press Breaking by crushing promotion of
press Roughened surface dewatering
on plain roll Roll grinding Grinding
Mixing of slime Removing the slime Heat kneeding
Mixing of adhesive Separation, removal
substances and dispersion
Uneven Faulty formation Formation correction Flow rectify in Head
dewatering Dirty blanket Promotion of blanket Box & Wire Part
Uneven line pressure washing Washing, squeeze,
Crown correction dewater. grinding
(3) Wet end Fall in wet end Faulty drawing Drawing adjustment Setup of high pressure
Excessive moisture Promotion of Press
Mixing of shives dewatering (line Centr, Cleaner, Fine
Triming water pressure increase) Screen, High Pressure
cutting fault Promotion of screen- Water Jet
ing
2. Dryer part
(1) Yankee Breaking due to Paper powder Effective use of the Dryer cleaner
Dryer faulty separa- attached doctor
tion Damage on dryer Polishing the surface Bronze Doctor,
surface Dryer Grinding
Breaking due to Mixing of shives Promotion of Centricleaner
intrusion of and impurities screening
foreign sub-
stances
Breaking by Faulty drawing Drawing adjustment Flow rectify in Head
tension Faulty formation Correcting the Box & Wire Part
formation
(2) Multi Breaking by Faulty drawing Drawing adjustment
Dryer tension between groups
Edge breaking Edge too dry Improvement of Pocket Ventilation
Mixing of shives dryer pocket Centricleaner, Fine
and impurities Promotion of screen- Screen
Trimming water ing
cutting fault Water pressure
increas
3. Calender crushing Faulty formation Correcting the Flow rectify in Head
part Breaking by Incorrect roll crow- formation Box &Wire Part
foreign sub- ing Correct the roll Grinding
stances Mixing of shives crown
Breaking in and impurities Promotion of Centricleaner, Fine
machine Faulty formation screening Screen
directions and wrinkling Improvement of
Unevey drying and dryer ventilation
wrinkling Correcting the
formation
Removing the dryer
pressure
- 14 -
3.4.2 Impurities
Shives, sands, pitches, slimes and deposits are defined as impurities.
Each of the pulping process, material pre-treatment process and papermaking process is provided
with the device to remove the impurities. This is because too many troubles are caused by the
impurities, and these are very difficult to remove.
(b) Even if pressure is applied to impurities by the press, they contain much moisture and will
produce black spots (fish eyes). To remove them, they must be overheated inevitably.
(c) This may cause the reduction of printing efficiency and even damage of the plate cylinder
when the user is printing. This may be the cause for claims against product quality.
Paper breaking will reduce efficiency, yield and production volume, leading to a great
energy loss. Fish eyes are often accompanied by much energy consumption due to over-
drying; they cause much curling, a poor paper quality and lower yield.
-15-
Accept
-16-
(b) Multi-stage removing of impurity
The multi-stage equipment is used when the impurity cannot be removed completely by
the one-stage equipment. The impurity removal ratio is measured, and the equipment of
the subsequent stage is installed for the existing equipment to provide a multi-stage
configuration featuring sufficient capabilities. This will improve the pulp yield and
quality and prevent paper from breaking, ensuring an improved overall yield.
a) From the fan-pump (large volume and low head pump) to the piping leading to the
head box
This position should be provided with the flange connection to facility at cleaning.
b) From the inside of the head box to the lip
Use the wooden scraper so that inner faces will not be damaged. (It must be prepared
for this purpose).
c) Side wall of the forming board under the wire, table roll journal, hydro foil, back of
the deflector and inner and outer surfaces of save-all devices
The amount of slime will increase if the amount of the circulated white water is increased,
and the temperature within the system is raised. When the temperature has reached 45°C
or more, there is no growth of deposits.
Note that the slime control agent is not an inhibitor; it does not remove the slime. It should
be used for a long continuous operation.
-17-
3.4.3 Press dewatering
Dewatering in the papermaking machine is achieved by increasing the nip pressure and by
applying it uniformly in the cross direction. To ensure effective use of the equipment function, repair,
maintenance and adequate modifications must be provided at all times. Care should be taken in the
daily control to assure that the press blanket is elastic enough to have a sufficient sunction force.
where,
The average of values in the cross direction is used as moisture. The sample should be
collected by dividing the total width into several equal parts, and is used for adjustment of
moisture deviation and improvement of the press.
Table 4 shows the moisture evaporated from Pw% of wet paper in the production of 1 kg
of paper, when paper moisture at the dryer end (Dm) is 5% or 10%:
-18-
Table 4
When the wet web moisture is decreased from 57% to 56% at the press part, where paper
moisture is 5%,
1.21 - 1.16
x 100 (%) = 4%
1.21
1.21 - 1.09
x 100 (%) = 9.9%
1.21
This will save steam for drying by about 10%. Furthermore, the yield is also improved by
5%. Combined with the advantage of energy conservation, a substantial cost reduction is
achieved.
-19-
(2) Other effect of improving the dewatering rate
For the mechanical pressure of the press, the following advantages are obtained by
improving the density between the paper layers:
a) The strength of the wet web is increased, and the breaking of the wet web between press part
and dryer part is minimized.
b) The surface strength is improved, and the shives attached to the dryer surface are reduced
by the numbers, ensuring a higher paper quality.
c) Uniform dewatering removes sag from the open draw part, and dryer wrinkles are
minimized.
d) The tensile strength, bursting strength and smoothness of the paper are improved.
Nip
Pressure
Rubber
Controlled Roll
Factor of
Freeness
Press
Arrangement
b) Roll crown
A pair of top and bottom pressure rolls serve as beams to support both ends, and are bent
downward by their own weight. When load is applied to the journals on both ends of the
top roll, the roll will bend upward. This brings both ends of the rolls into close contact with
each other, but a clearance occurs at the center. As illustrated in Figure 8 (A), the locus of
nip width is formed. The roll crown for ensuring uniform dewatering should be determined
so that an accurately rectangular form, as shown in Figure 8 (B), will be obtained, having
such nip width as obtained from the product quality, papermaking machine, papermaking
speed and analysis of the current situations.
-21-
Figure 8 Roll crown and nip width locus
-22-
Figure 9 Suction roll
The most fundamental type is the straight-through press, which is available with many
features; reduced installation area, equipment cost and power cost, prevention of paper
breaking, and improved paper surface. Figure 10 shows the typical arrangement.
d) Felt
To minimize the water passing resistance and to ensure the elasticity of the press felt, it is
necessary to wash the felt to remove contamination and excessive moisture.
Using the recovered hot water for washing shower is effective not only to increase washing
efficiency but also to reduce the wet web temperature.
-23-
A) Straight Through Press
Dryer
The unit water consumption of this industry was about 200 tons/paper ton by around 1960, so
the value is reduced to a half at present 30 years after that.
Table 6 shows the transition of the unit water consumption in a typical integrated pulp and paper
plant where about 150,000 tons of the bleached kraft are produced every year from the wood free
paper:
-25-
Table 6 Transition of the unit water consumption and head box temperature
1960 1990
Unit water consumption (ton/paper ton) 175 87
Head box temperature (°C) 20 45
Paper machine unit steam consumption (ton/paper ton) 3.6 2.8
It should be noted, however, that the compositions of the product types and quality manufacture
requirements are considerably different, and the production volume is also doubled during this
period. The annual average water intake temperature is 15.5°C. The rise of the head box temperature
indicates the use of circulating white water, thereby reducing the use of new water.
It occupies 20 to 30% of the unit steam consumption of a papermaking machine.
-26-
Even the equipment which has been installed with consideration given does not always
produce the planned performance. It is necessary to make the most effective use of the
equipment by repeating the so-called P-D-C-A method (collection of the data and its
analysis), as well as improving the equipment. This is the technique. The effective use of
white water has the advantages of improved yield, reduction of drain, and reduced drain
disposal cost in addition to energy and water conservation.
Figure 11 shows the lifted type fiber recovery machine in the flow sheet, while Figures 13
and 14 illustrate the fine fiber recovery filter.
Figure 12 gives the material balance and water balance around the papermaking machine
in terms of model (wrapping paper of 55 g/m2, with the daily production of 100 tons, and
total efficiency of 100%).
When the shower in the head box and wire washing water (new water) are replaced by the
clean white water treated by the white water recovery machine and sand filter, the head box
temperature can be increased up to the value of the stock box.
-27-
Figure 11 White water recovery and water discharge
-28-
Head Box
-29-
Flocculent
Pressured Water
Treated White Water
Figure 14 Polydiskfilter
-30-
3.4.5 Drying
The dryer is the greatest heat consumer in the pulp and paper industry. It is necessary to evaporate
almost the same amount of water as the volume of the produced paper. The following introduces the
outline of the factors and measures for the effective transfer of supplied energy to the wet paper and
efficient evaporation:
-31-
(a) Ensuring uniform moisture
To obtain a uniform moisture profile in the cross direction in the drying process after the
papermaking process, it is necessary to meet the requirements of the following interme-
diate product quality;
-32-
(2) Effective use of BM meter
The BM meter is used to control the moisture profile in the cross direction. This is a device
to control the profile within the specified range by the combination of basic weight and
moisture percentage sensors with the computer, while scanning in the cross direction. Basic
weight control is made in the cross direction and machine direction simultaneously. For the
control in the cross direction, the calculation is made by the computer, and fan-pump speed
or the opening angle of stream flow valve is controlled. Control in the machine direction
is made by manual adjustment of the slice lip.
Moisture is controlled by steam pressure control of the dryer section header.
The profile in the cross direction is controlled by the crown control roll (CCR) so that the
press nip pressure is uniform. It should be noted that the complete advantages of the BM
meter can be used only when the pocket ventilation device is installed.
-33-
3.5 Energy conservation technology In the pulp refining process
A pulp beating process was made with a beater before 30 years. After that, a larger capacity and
labor saving requirement of a paper making machine follows a continuous beating machine, that is
a rifiner. The types of a refiner are a conical type, a drum type and a disc type as shown in Figure
16.
-34-
1) Conical type refiner
A conical type refiner consists of a conical fixed shell and a conical rotor with bars on the
surface of the rotor.
-35-
3.5.2 Effective refining energy
Refining process effects the strength and surface condition in the quality of paper. The beating
power is saved with operation control according to the equipment specifications. The effective
beating energy (We kWh/t) is as follows:
Where,
Effective beating power (kW) = Motor load power (kW) - No-load power (kW)
Pulp volume (B.D. ton/h) = Passing quantity bone dry pulp per hour
It is important for the effective use of beating energy to control the pulp density and the pressure
at the inlet and the outlet of a refiner as specified. The pulp density is around 4% in general. The
pressure at the inlet of a refiner is 1.0 to 1.5 kg/cm 2 and the pressure at the outlet of a refiner is
1.0 to 1.5 kg/cm2 higher than that at the inlet in general. To control these factor, a density controller
is installed in the inlet of a refiner. It is good to use a flowrate controller as a density controller, but
it is necessary to keep constant flowrate at a headbox. The characteristic figure of refining process is
freeness. The factors are the pressure at the inlet and the outlet and the beating power of a refiner.
It is necessary to install pressure gages at a refiner. The instrument related to the characteristic figures
must be installed and be kept in the normal condition.
-36-
4. Energy conservation in the pulp and paper industry
To meet the economic’ growth, market quality requirements are getting more severe and
diversified. These quality requirements often make it essential to use much energy. Figure 18 shows
the trend of the energy conservation under this situation.
For the solution of this problem, the papermaking process mainly depends on increased
efficiency, while the pulping process depends on equipment improvement.
-37-
4.1 Energy conservation in the papermaking process
Table 7 shows the energy conservation in the papermaking process regarding steam and electric
power unit consumption for the paper and paperboard, and this data is based on replies from the
questionnaire sent by the Japan Paper and Pulp Technology Association.
Table 7 Steam and electric power unit consumption rate for the paper
and cardboard manufacturing process in Japan
Printing paper and coated manila board are required to meet severe quality requirements on the
suitability for printing. Energy conservation is carried out smoothly, although it contains many
factors which are disadvantageous to the unit consumption rate. This is due to the efforts for efficiency
improvement based on the following management policy:
“Followed by sales people, the production program with major emphasis placed on operation
efficiency of the paper machine”
The production plan in the factory is worked out by studying how to reduce the manual
replacement time, while major emphasis is placed on the order of manufacturing processes. The sales
people facing users promote sales activities according to this plan, and this uniform concept also
promotes the field technology in results.
For the newspaper and printing paper, continuous operation for 25 to 40 days is normal. Paper
breaking occurs only 0.1 to 0.2 times a day, according to some reports. Further efforts for higher
efficiency and effective use of the white water will be made.
-38-
4.2 Energy conservration In the pulping process
Energy conservation in the pulping process has registered a remarkable record in the KP method
(kraft pulp). The transition of the unit consumption is as shown in Table 8.
In the pulping process, the introduction of new equipment leads to a reduction of the unit
consumption.
Steam Electricity
Unit: t/pulp t Unit: kWh/pulp t
Cooking FY 1980 1988 1980 1988
N 1.2 1.0 230 220
L 1.0 0.8 130 120
Evaporation N 1.5 2.0 100 90
L 1.9 1.4 100 90
Bleaching N 0.8 0.4 260 220
L 0.6 0.3 170 140
Steam Electricity
Unit: t/pulp t Unit: kWh/pulp t
Batch Digester FY 1980 1988 1980 1988
N 1.45 1.3 200 215
L 1.1 1.1 120 115
Continuous N 1.1 0.75 I 240 I 220
Digester
L 0.9 0.7 130 115
-39-
The continuous digester has a smaller steam consumption but a greater power consumption
than the batch digester.
The yearly reduction of unit consumption for steam and electric power is due to a gradual
improvement of the continuous digester and its operation technique.
-40-