How Agile

Principles Drive
Successful HR
Transformations
By Jérôme Mackowiak and Mark Whittle
For HR leaders looking to apply agile principles in their HR
functions, the pathway to success begins with understanding
what agile is, how it applies to HR and what it means to their
organizations specifically.
Given the rapid changes brought on by guidelines for how to get it done in HR. This
external and internal pressures, CHROs and makes it intimidating: Where do you start? How
senior leaders alike realize the way HR delivers will you know when you get there? As one of
products, solutions and value to its stakeholders our clients put it: “We’re on the edge of the
must evolve to increase alignment and impact. known world, going into the unknown.” Without
Seventy-four percent of HR leaders believe agile defining what an agile transformation means for
management is a way to achieve that goal, and HR, it is extremely difficult — if not impossible —
adopting agile has become a key priority for to lead one.
many HR functions (see Figure 1). Over the past year, we’ve spoken with dozens
However, most of us don’t know exactly of HR leaders about their agile journeys
what agile is, nor how to interpret or start and have heard many different stories. A
implementing it for the HR function. In the majority of our clients believe agile HR is
words of one client: “The broader organization important to implement and will enable better
is undergoing a transformation, and we’re trying business outcomes:
to figure out how to live it in HR.” • Eighty-four percent believe it will
Answering that question starts with increase speed.
understanding what agile is and how it can • Seventy-five percent believe it will
be applied to HR. Agile is still a relatively new increase quality.
concept in HR, and we don’t have one simple • Forty-five percent believe it will
set of clearly defined or surefire implementation help reduce cost.

Figure 1: HR Leaders' Beliefs Regarding Agile Principles

“I believe it is important to implement “I believe agile will help my HR function
agile in my HR function.” achieve key business outcomes.”
Percentage of HR Leaders Percentage of HR Leaders

2% 2%
Disagree Disagree
24% 26%
Neutral Neutral

74% 72%
Agree Agree
n = 171
Source: 2020 Gartner Agile HR Function Survey

HR Leaders Monthly | July 2020

Even though they believe in agile, most HR Figure 2: HR Functions With an Agile
leaders don’t have a clear strategy for achieving Implementation Strategy and Defined
it or a clear vision of what they hope to achieve Business Outcomes
(see Figure 2). We have found, however, that agile
Percentage of HR Leaders
can be applied in many successful ways in HR.
Agile is not “all or nothing”: HR functions can
implement agile to varying degrees and still reap
the benefits. Yes

The concept of agile originated in software

development in 2001 with a manifesto that
argued for prioritizing: 9% 10%

Agile Implementation Strategy

• Individuals and interactions over Strategy Both Strategy
Only and Outcomes
processes and tools
• Working software over comprehensive 9%
documentation Strategy Only

• Customer collaboration over

contract negotiation
• Responding to change over following a plan
Many organizations have attempted to apply the 78% 3%
principles of software design’s agile movement Neither Strategy Outcomes
to other management processes, including HR. Nor Outcome Only
In our research, we have found successful agile
transformations tend to start by translating the
underlying values of this manifesto into a set
No
of guidelines to help their HR function quickly
provide relevant solutions and support for its No Defined Business Outcomes Yes
customers. HR leaders can think of agile as a n = 171
set of values embodied in project management Source: 2020 Gartner Agile HR Function Survey
methodologies, tools and principles that can be
translated into both HR projects and the overall
HR operating model.
This approach focuses on solving end-user
problems and divides work into short cycles
with frequent reassessment and adaptation
of plans among highly collaborative and self-
managed teams. There are many ways to apply
HR leaders can think of agile as a
it, none of which are necessarily right or wrong; set of values embodied in project
it all depends on the context and needs of the management methodologies,
organization. tools and principles that can be
This underscores one of our key teachings: translated into both HR projects
Agile is a set of values realized, not a set of and the overall HR operating model.
tools deployed. The fact that HR does not need
to implement agile values in one “right way”
has been reassuring and motivating to many of
our clients. A participant at one of our Annual
Executive Retreats earlier this year said, “It’s
validating to see we are not behind and that
there are different ways to implement agile.”

HR Leaders Monthly | July 2020

Having this framework for understanding Working with other parts of the organization to
agile has helped our clients reframe their agile better understand their needs and, therefore,
journeys in terms of what they are meant to how to best help them demands a fundamental
achieve, whom they are meant to serve and shift in the way HR operates. It means moving
what needs to change to get there. “Agile away from the traditional customer-client
fundamentally is about the customer,” an relationship that has existed and defined HR and
attendee pointed out at one of our meetings. its partners for many years (see Figure 3).
“For HR, that means, essentially, the employee Agile isn’t free. Shifting to agile management
experience.” involves costs and trade-offs as well as growing
A big realization for many clients, and something pains as HR and the broader organization adjust
they noted from their own experiences as well, to new ways of interacting.
is that agile HR means “prioritizing better” and For many of our clients, this has meant being
“needing to partner better with others in the willing to make some mistakes, “even failing with
organization,” such as IT. Nevertheless, many our employees on some of their most important
agreed that “it feels hard to co-create.” In the priorities,” as one noted. For others, it has meant
words of one client: “It’s about bringing people setting new boundaries: “HR has to say ‘no’
together to think outside the box, and it’s scary more,” one client said. “IT says ‘no’ all the time,
to bring the outside in.” and agile gave us a better way to say ‘no.’”

Figure 3: Key Success Factors for an Agile HR Operating Model

Agile Manifesto Values HR Projects HR Operating Model

Individuals and interactions over Select project teams

processes and tools based on insight into
the end user's problem
instead of subject matter Create space for
expertise. strategic thinkers to
solve customer problems.
Working software over Prioritize good solutions
comprehensive documentation over implementation
support.

Customer collaboration Co-create with end users Create a proactive

throughout, not at the customer-sensing
beginning and end. HR model.

Responding to change over Use short, iterative Manage HR’s work as

following a plan project cycles instead an evolving investment
of predetermined project portfolio rather than as
plans. a set agenda.

Source: "Manifesto for Agile Software Development," 2001, agilemanifesto.org

HR Leaders Monthly | July 2020

Thinking about HR’s work as an evolving cross-functional collaboration, the portfolio
investment portfolio rather than a set agenda approach and the concept of business leaders
requires adjusting employees’ and leaders’ as end users, they are able to present stronger
expectations of HR as a service provider. One cases in these prioritization conversations.
client summarized it well: “We need to say ‘no’ to One client said this approach helped them
the customer too, so that the loudest customer understand their CEO’s perspective and vision
isn’t the winner.” for applying agile management throughout the
In other words, HR can no longer make excuses organization.
for not evolving its role in the organization from Our research is helping our clients answer their
transactional to strategic. HR leaders who are most important questions about agile, from
making the shift to agile say it is worth these “does it make sense for us to implement agile?”
costs in part because the cost of inaction is far
to “what is it going to look like for us?” and
greater. “We are changing everything,” one client
“what tough decisions will we need to make?”
told us. “We used to talk about change fatigue,
Implementing agile in your HR function entails a
but it doesn’t even matter anymore because
fundamental shift in how you think about project
literally everything is changing.” For this HR
leader and many others, not adapting is simply management and organizational structure.
not an option. Accordingly, a successful agile HR transformation
begins with the fundamentals of what agile is,
One of the benefits HR leaders are seeing from what it can do for HR and what it would mean for
their agile initiatives is greater cross-functional your organization.
collaboration. It helps them have better
conversations with their stakeholders about Once they decide to go the agile route, HR
how to implement agile, if they so choose, and leaders who have internalized these key
what trade-offs will be necessary. Many of our lessons are better equipped to have the right
clients are using agile principles to align business conversations with their clients about the costs
leaders to critical HR priorities in quarterly and trade-offs necessary to make their journeys
conversations with their C-suite. By embracing successful.

HR Leaders Monthly | July 2020

About Gartner
Gartner is the world’s leading research and advisory company and a
member of the S&P 500. We equip business leaders with indispensable
insights, advice and tools to achieve their mission-critical priorities today
and build the successful organizations of tomorrow.
Our unmatched combination of expert-led, practitioner-sourced and data-
driven research steers clients toward the right decisions on the issues that
matter most. We are a trusted advisor and an objective resource for more
than 14,000 enterprises in more than 100 countries — across all major
functions, in every industry and enterprise size.

Contact Us
Phone: 1 866 913 8102
Email: hrleaders@gartner.com
Web: gartner.com/en/human-resources

© 2020 Gartner, Inc. and/or its affiliates. All rights reserved. CM_GBS_1019154