Annex B Summary of Codes of Conduct in Ftas
Annex B Summary of Codes of Conduct in Ftas
Annex B Summary of Codes of Conduct in Ftas
Annex B provides excerpts from a variety of recent Codes of Conduct, and serves as background to the draft text proposed by the UNCITRAL & ICSID Secretariats on 1 May 2020.
PROVISION NAFTA EU- Singapore IPA Australia-Japan EPA CETA CPTPP EU-Vietnam FTA EU-Vietnam IPA Indonesia-Australia CEPA
(Only applicable to Chapter 19 (Annex 7 Code of Conduct for (Annex B Code of Conduct of (Annex 29-B (State-State)) (Chapter 9, Section B, Code for (Annex 15-B (State-State)) (Annex 11 Code of Conduct for (Annex 14-A Code of Conduct for
and 20) Members of The Tribunal, The Arbitrators, Rules of Procedure (In force provisionally Sept. 21, ISDS) (In force Dec. 30, 2018) (Draft) Members of The Tribunal, Arbitrators) (CEPA ratified by
Appeal Tribunal and Mediators) of Arbitral Tribunals) (EPA in 2017) Members of The Appeal Australia in Nov. 2019, and
(FTA in force Nov. 21, 2019/ IA force Jan. 15, 2015) (Code applicable to ISDS has not Tribunal and Mediators) (Draft) Indonesia in Feb. 2020)
will enter in force when ratified yet been published)
by all EU MS) (Full text available here)
(Full text available here) (Full text available here) (Full text available here) (Full text available here) (Full text available here) (Full text available here) (Full text available here)
Definitions A. In this Code of Conduct, 1. In this Code of Conduct: I. Scope Definitions Definitions Definitions ARTICLE 1
/Scope "Agreement" means the North "Member" means a Member of 1. This Code of Conduct shall 1. For this Chapter and under this 1. For the purposes of this Code 1. For the purposes of this Code Definitions
American Free Trade Agreement; the Tribunal or a Member of the apply to each person serving as Code of Conduct: of Conduct: arbitrator means a of Conduct: For the purposes of this Code of
"assistant" means a person who, Appeal Tribunal established an arbitrator, arbitrator’s assistant means a person who, member of a tribunal constituted (a) "arbitrator" means a member Conduct:
under the terms of appointment pursuant to Chapter Three assistant or administration under the terms of appointment pursuant to Article 9.22 of an arbitration panel (a) "Member" means a Member
of a member, conducts research (Dispute Settlement) Section A personnel involved in the of an arbitrator, conducts, (Selection established under Article 15.7 of the Tribunal or a Member of
or provides support for the (Resolution of Disputes between proceedings of an arbitral researches or provides assistance of Arbitrators); assistant means a (Establishment of the Arbitration the Appeal Tribunal established
member; Investors and Parties); tribunal (hereinafter referred to to the arbitrator; person who, under the terms of Panel); pursuant to Section B (Resolution
"candidate" means "mediator" means a person who as “covered person”) established candidate means an individual appointment of an arbitrator, (b) "assistant" means a person of Disputes between Investors
(a) an individual whose name conducts mediation in under Article 19.6 (Establishment whose name is on the list of conducts research or provides who, under the terms of and Parties);
appears on a roster or list accordance with Chapter Three and Composition of Arbitral arbitrators referred to in support for the arbitrator; appointment of an arbitrator, (b) "mediator" means a person
established under Article 1414, (Dispute Settlement) Section A Tribunals) of the Agreement. Article 29.8 and who is under candidate means an individual conducts research or provides who conducts the mediation
Annex 1901.2 or 1904.13 or (Resolution of Disputes between 2. Each arbitrator shall take all consideration for selection as an who is under consideration for assistance to that arbitrator; procedure in accordance with
Article 2009, Investors and Parties); reasonable measures to ensure arbitrator under Article 29.7; selection as an arbitrator (c) "candidate" means an Article
(b) an individual who is under "candidate" means an individual that his or her assistants or mediator means a person who pursuant to Article 9.22 individual whose name is on the 3.31 (Mediation) and Annex 10
consideration for appointment as who is under consideration for administration personnel comply conducts a mediation in (Selection of Arbitrators); expert list of arbitrators referred to in (Mediation Mechanism for
a member of a panel pursuant to selection as a Member; with Parts IV to VII of this Code accordance with Article 29.5; means a person appointed Article 15.23 (List of Arbitrators) Disputes between Investors and
Annex 1901.2 or Article 1903, "assistant" means a person who, of Conduct. The Parties may arbitrator means a member of an pursuant to Article 9.27 (Expert and who is under consideration Parties);
1904 or 2011, or under the terms of appointment agree to exempt any covered arbitration panel established Reports) or applicable arbitration for selection as a member of an (c) "candidate" means an
(c) an individual who is under of a Member, conducts person, other than an arbitrator, under Article 29.7; proceeding, rules; arbitration panel under Article individual who is under
consideration for appointment as research or provides assistance from application of a part or all unless otherwise specified, family member means the 15.7 (Establishment of the consideration for selection as a
a member of a committee to the Member; of this Code of Conduct. means an arbitration proceeding; spouse of an arbitrator or Arbitration Panel); Member of the Tribunal or a
pursuant to Annex 1904.13 or "staff", in respect of a Member, staff, in respect of an arbitrator, candidate; or a parent, child, (d) "mediator" means a person Member of the Appeal Tribunal;
Article 1905; means persons under the II. Governing Principle means persons under the grandparent, grandchild, sister, who conducts a mediation (d) "assistant" means a person
"member" means direction and control of the Each arbitrator shall be direction and control of the brother, aunt, uncle, niece or procedure in accordance with who, under the terms of
(a) a member of a panel Member, other than assistants. independent and impartial, and arbitrator, other than assistants. nephew of the arbitrator or Annex 15-C (Mediation appointment of a member,
constituted pursuant to Annex shall avoid direct or indirect candidate or spouse of the Mechanism); assists the member in his
1901.2 or Article 1414, 1903, conflicts of interest. arbitrator or candidate (including (e) "proceedings", unless research or supports him in his
1904, 2008 or 2011, Furthermore, each arbitrator and whole and half blood otherwise specified, means duties;
(b) a member of an extraordinary former arbitrator shall respect relatives and step relatives); or dispute settlement proceedings (e) "staff", in respect of a
challenge committee constituted the confidentiality of proceedings the spouse of such an individual. of an arbitration panel under member, means persons under
pursuant to Annex 1904.13, or of the arbitral tribunal. Through Family member also includes any Chapter 15 (Dispute Settlement); the direction and control of the
(c) a member of a special the observance of such standards resident of an arbitrator’s or and member, other than assistants.
committee constituted pursuant of conduct the integrity and candidate’s household whom the (f) "staff", in respect of an
to Article 1905; impartiality of dispute settlement arbitrator or candidate treats as arbitrator, means a person under
"participant" has the meaning proceedings conducted pursuant a member of his or her family; the direction and control of the
assigned in the Rules of to Chapter 19 (Dispute Rules means applicable rules arbitrator, other than assistants.
Procedure for Article 1904 Settlement) of the Agreement pursuant to Article 9.19.4
Binational Panel Reviews; are preserved. (Submission of a Claim to
PROVISION NAFTA EU- Singapore IPA Australia-Japan EPA CETA CPTPP EU-Vietnam FTA EU-Vietnam IPA Indonesia-Australia CEPA
(Only applicable to Chapter 19 (Annex 7 Code of Conduct for (Annex B Code of Conduct of (Annex 29-B (State-State)) (Chapter 9, Section B, Code for (Annex 15-B (State-State)) (Annex 11 Code of Conduct for (Annex 14-A Code of Conduct for
and 20) Members of The Tribunal, The Arbitrators, Rules of Procedure (In force provisionally Sept. 21, ISDS) (In force Dec. 30, 2018) (Draft) Members of The Tribunal, Arbitrators) (CEPA ratified by
Appeal Tribunal and Mediators) of Arbitral Tribunals) (EPA in 2017) Members of The Appeal Australia in Nov. 2019, and
(FTA in force Nov. 21, 2019/ IA force Jan. 15, 2015) (Code applicable to ISDS has not Tribunal and Mediators) (Draft) Indonesia in Feb. 2020)
will enter in force when ratified yet been published)
by all EU MS) (Full text available here)
(Full text available here) (Full text available here) (Full text available here) (Full text available here) (Full text available here) (Full text available here) (Full text available here)
2
PROVISION NAFTA EU- Singapore IPA Australia-Japan EPA CETA CPTPP EU-Vietnam FTA EU-Vietnam IPA Indonesia-Australia CEPA
(Only applicable to Chapter 19 (Annex 7 Code of Conduct for (Annex B Code of Conduct of (Annex 29-B (State-State)) (Chapter 9, Section B, Code for (Annex 15-B (State-State)) (Annex 11 Code of Conduct for (Annex 14-A Code of Conduct for
and 20) Members of The Tribunal, The Arbitrators, Rules of Procedure (In force provisionally Sept. 21, ISDS) (In force Dec. 30, 2018) (Draft) Members of The Tribunal, Arbitrators) (CEPA ratified by
Appeal Tribunal and Mediators) of Arbitral Tribunals) (EPA in 2017) Members of The Appeal Australia in Nov. 2019, and
(FTA in force Nov. 21, 2019/ IA force Jan. 15, 2015) (Code applicable to ISDS has not Tribunal and Mediators) (Draft) Indonesia in Feb. 2020)
will enter in force when ratified yet been published)
by all EU MS) (Full text available here)
(Full text available here) (Full text available here) (Full text available here) (Full text available here) (Full text available here) (Full text available here) (Full text available here)
3
PROVISION NAFTA EU- Singapore IPA Australia-Japan EPA CETA CPTPP EU-Vietnam FTA EU-Vietnam IPA Indonesia-Australia CEPA
(Only applicable to Chapter 19 (Annex 7 Code of Conduct for (Annex B Code of Conduct of (Annex 29-B (State-State)) (Chapter 9, Section B, Code for (Annex 15-B (State-State)) (Annex 11 Code of Conduct for (Annex 14-A Code of Conduct for
and 20) Members of The Tribunal, The Arbitrators, Rules of Procedure (In force provisionally Sept. 21, ISDS) (In force Dec. 30, 2018) (Draft) Members of The Tribunal, Arbitrators) (CEPA ratified by
Appeal Tribunal and Mediators) of Arbitral Tribunals) (EPA in 2017) Members of The Appeal Australia in Nov. 2019, and
(FTA in force Nov. 21, 2019/ IA force Jan. 15, 2015) (Code applicable to ISDS has not Tribunal and Mediators) (Draft) Indonesia in Feb. 2020)
will enter in force when ratified yet been published)
by all EU MS) (Full text available here)
(Full text available here) (Full text available here) (Full text available here) (Full text available here) (Full text available here) (Full text available here) (Full text available here)
interests, relationships and in question (e.g. the possibility of decided in the proceeding for regarding direct or indirect
matters that may bear on the any indirect advantage or any which the candidate is under conflicts of interest, such as the
integrity or impartiality of the likelihood of pressure which consideration; International Bar Association
dispute settlement process. could arise from their employer, (3) any past or existing financial, Guidelines on Conflicts of Interest
This Code of Conduct does not business associates or immediate business, professional, family or in International Arbitration.
determine whether or under family members). social relationship with the (f) In the event of an alleged
what circumstances the Parties 2. The obligation of self- interested parties in the breach of this Code of Conduct,
will disqualify a candidate or disclosure referred to in proceeding, or their counsel, or the Rules governing the
member from being appointed paragraph 1 shall also apply to such relationship involving a arbitration shall apply to any
to, or serving as a member of, a the arbitrator after the candidate's employer, partner, challenge, disqualification or
panel or committee on the basis confirmation of his or her business associate or family replacement of an arbitrator.
of disclosures made.] appointment and throughout the member; and
proceedings. During the course (4) public advocacy or legal or
A. A candidate shall disclose any of proceedings, the arbitrator other representation concerning 4. Disclosure Obligations
interest, relationship or matter shall disclose in writing to the an issue in dispute in the (a) Throughout the tribunal
that is likely to affect the Parties any information relevant proceeding or involving the same proceeding, candidates and
candidate's independence or to paragraph 1 when he or she matters. arbitrators have a
impartiality or that might becomes aware of it. 5. A candidate or arbitrator shall continuing obligation to disclose
reasonably create an appearance 3. In meeting these disclosure communicate matters interests, relationships and
of impropriety or an requirements, personal privacy concerning actual or potential matters that may bear on the
apprehension of bias in the shall be respected. The violations of this Code of Conduct integrity or impartiality of the
proceeding. To this end, a application of these disclosure to the CETA Joint Committee for dispute settlement process.
candidate shall make all requirements shall not be so consideration by the Parties. (b) The disputing parties or the
reasonable efforts to become administratively burdensome as 6. Once selected, an arbitrator Secretary-General, as the
aware of any such interests, to make it impracticable for shall continue to make all appointing authority for an
relationships and matters. otherwise qualified persons to reasonable efforts to become arbitration referred to in Article
The candidate shall disclose such serve as arbitrators. aware of interests, relationships 9.22.2 (Selection of Arbitrators),
interests, relationships and or matters referred to in will provide a candidate a copy
matters by completing an Initial paragraph 3 and shall disclose of this Code of Conduct and the
Disclosure Statement provided by them. The disclosure obligation is Initial Disclosure Statement set
the Secretariat and sending it to a continuing duty which requires out in the Appendix to this Code
the Secretariat. an arbitrator to disclose such of Conduct.
Without limiting the generality of interests, relationships or (c) A candidate shall submit the
the foregoing, candidates shall matters that may arise during all Initial Disclosure Statement set
disclose the following interests, stages of the proceeding. The out in the Appendix to this Code
relationships and matters: arbitrator shall disclose such of Conduct to the disputing
(1) any financial interest of the interests, relationships or parties or the Secretary-General,
candidate matters by informing the CETA as the appointing authority, no
(a) in the proceeding or in its Joint Committee promptly, in later than seven days after
outcome, and writing, for consideration by the receipt of that Statement.
(b) in an administrative Parties. [FN 1: This subparagraph does
proceeding, a domestic court not prevent the appointment of
proceeding or another panel or arbitrators by the disputing
committee proceeding that parties prior to the submission of
involves issues that may be the Initial Disclosure
decided in the proceeding for Statement.]
which the candidate is under [FN 2: For greater certainty, the
consideration; submission of the Initial
Disclosure Statement is without
4
PROVISION NAFTA EU- Singapore IPA Australia-Japan EPA CETA CPTPP EU-Vietnam FTA EU-Vietnam IPA Indonesia-Australia CEPA
(Only applicable to Chapter 19 (Annex 7 Code of Conduct for (Annex B Code of Conduct of (Annex 29-B (State-State)) (Chapter 9, Section B, Code for (Annex 15-B (State-State)) (Annex 11 Code of Conduct for (Annex 14-A Code of Conduct for
and 20) Members of The Tribunal, The Arbitrators, Rules of Procedure (In force provisionally Sept. 21, ISDS) (In force Dec. 30, 2018) (Draft) Members of The Tribunal, Arbitrators) (CEPA ratified by
Appeal Tribunal and Mediators) of Arbitral Tribunals) (EPA in 2017) Members of The Appeal Australia in Nov. 2019, and
(FTA in force Nov. 21, 2019/ IA force Jan. 15, 2015) (Code applicable to ISDS has not Tribunal and Mediators) (Draft) Indonesia in Feb. 2020)
will enter in force when ratified yet been published)
by all EU MS) (Full text available here)
(Full text available here) (Full text available here) (Full text available here) (Full text available here) (Full text available here) (Full text available here) (Full text available here)
5
PROVISION NAFTA EU- Singapore IPA Australia-Japan EPA CETA CPTPP EU-Vietnam FTA EU-Vietnam IPA Indonesia-Australia CEPA
(Only applicable to Chapter 19 (Annex 7 Code of Conduct for (Annex B Code of Conduct of (Annex 29-B (State-State)) (Chapter 9, Section B, Code for (Annex 15-B (State-State)) (Annex 11 Code of Conduct for (Annex 14-A Code of Conduct for
and 20) Members of The Tribunal, The Arbitrators, Rules of Procedure (In force provisionally Sept. 21, ISDS) (In force Dec. 30, 2018) (Draft) Members of The Tribunal, Arbitrators) (CEPA ratified by
Appeal Tribunal and Mediators) of Arbitral Tribunals) (EPA in 2017) Members of The Appeal Australia in Nov. 2019, and
(FTA in force Nov. 21, 2019/ IA force Jan. 15, 2015) (Code applicable to ISDS has not Tribunal and Mediators) (Draft) Indonesia in Feb. 2020)
will enter in force when ratified yet been published)
by all EU MS) (Full text available here)
(Full text available here) (Full text available here) (Full text available here) (Full text available here) (Full text available here) (Full text available here) (Full text available here)
6
PROVISION NAFTA EU- Singapore IPA Australia-Japan EPA CETA CPTPP EU-Vietnam FTA EU-Vietnam IPA Indonesia-Australia CEPA
(Only applicable to Chapter 19 (Annex 7 Code of Conduct for (Annex B Code of Conduct of (Annex 29-B (State-State)) (Chapter 9, Section B, Code for (Annex 15-B (State-State)) (Annex 11 Code of Conduct for (Annex 14-A Code of Conduct for
and 20) Members of The Tribunal, The Arbitrators, Rules of Procedure (In force provisionally Sept. 21, ISDS) (In force Dec. 30, 2018) (Draft) Members of The Tribunal, Arbitrators) (CEPA ratified by
Appeal Tribunal and Mediators) of Arbitral Tribunals) (EPA in 2017) Members of The Appeal Australia in Nov. 2019, and
(FTA in force Nov. 21, 2019/ IA force Jan. 15, 2015) (Code applicable to ISDS has not Tribunal and Mediators) (Draft) Indonesia in Feb. 2020)
will enter in force when ratified yet been published)
by all EU MS) (Full text available here)
(Full text available here) (Full text available here) (Full text available here) (Full text available here) (Full text available here) (Full text available here) (Full text available here)
7
PROVISION NAFTA EU- Singapore IPA Australia-Japan EPA CETA CPTPP EU-Vietnam FTA EU-Vietnam IPA Indonesia-Australia CEPA
(Only applicable to Chapter 19 (Annex 7 Code of Conduct for (Annex B Code of Conduct of (Annex 29-B (State-State)) (Chapter 9, Section B, Code for (Annex 15-B (State-State)) (Annex 11 Code of Conduct for (Annex 14-A Code of Conduct for
and 20) Members of The Tribunal, The Arbitrators, Rules of Procedure (In force provisionally Sept. 21, ISDS) (In force Dec. 30, 2018) (Draft) Members of The Tribunal, Arbitrators) (CEPA ratified by
Appeal Tribunal and Mediators) of Arbitral Tribunals) (EPA in 2017) Members of The Appeal Australia in Nov. 2019, and
(FTA in force Nov. 21, 2019/ IA force Jan. 15, 2015) (Code applicable to ISDS has not Tribunal and Mediators) (Draft) Indonesia in Feb. 2020)
will enter in force when ratified yet been published)
by all EU MS) (Full text available here)
(Full text available here) (Full text available here) (Full text available here) (Full text available here) (Full text available here) (Full text available here) (Full text available here)
person, except as provided in the (f) An arbitrator shall not both disputing parties or is
applicable rules. delegate the duty to make a necessary to ascertain whether
decision, order or award that arbitrator has violated or
G. A member shall take all to any other individual. may violate this Annex.
reasonable steps to ensure that (g) An arbitrator shall take all
the member's assistant and staff reasonable steps to ensure that
comply with Parts I, II and VI of his or her assistants and staff
this Code of Conduct. comply with paragraphs 2
(Responsibilities to the
H. A member shall not engage in Process), 4(a), 4(d), 4(e), 4(f) and
ex parte contacts concerning the 4(g) (Disclosure Obligations),
proceeding. 5(c), 5(h) and 5(i) (Performance
of Duties by Candidates and
I. A candidate or member shall Arbitrators), and 8 (Maintenance
not communicate matters of Confidentiality) of this Code of
concerning actual or potential Conduct.
violations of this Code of Conduct (h) An arbitrator shall not
unless the communication is to engage in any ex parte contact
the Secretariat or is necessary to concerning the tribunal
ascertain whether that candidate proceeding.
or member has violated or may (i) A candidate or arbitrator shall
violate the Code. only communicate matters
concerning actual or potential
violations of this Code of Conduct
to the Secretary-General,
disputing parties and arbitration
institution in charge of the
proceedings, or if necessary to
ascertain whether that candidate
or arbitrator has violated or may
violate this Code of Conduct, to
the Secretary-General, the
disputing parties, and arbitration
institution in charge of the
proceedings.
(j) Each arbitrator shall keep a
record and render a final account
of the time devoted to the
proceeding and of his or her
expenses, as well as the time
and expenses of his or her staff
and assistants.
Independ- Part IV: Independence and 10. A Member must be VI. Independence and Independence and impartiality of 6. Independence and Impartiality Independence and Impartiality of ARTICLE 5 Independence and Impartiality of
ence and Impartiality of Members independent and impartial and Impartiality of Arbitrators arbitrators of Arbitrators Arbitrators Independence and Impartiality of Arbitrators
Impartiality avoid creating an appearance of 1. An arbitrator shall be 11. An arbitrator shall avoid (a) An arbitrator shall be 10. An arbitrator shall avoid Members 11. An arbitrator shall be
A. A member shall be bias or independent and impartial. An creating an appearance of bias independent and impartial. An creating an appearance of bias 1. Members shall be independent independent and impartial. An
independent and impartial. A impropriety and shall not be arbitrator shall not allow past or and shall not be influenced by arbitrator shall act in a fair and shall not be influenced by and impartial and avoid creating arbitrator shall act in a fair
member shall act in a fair influenced by self-interest, existing financial, business, self-interest, outside pressure, manner and shall not create an self-interest, outside pressure, an appearance of bias or manner and shall avoid creating
manner and shall avoid creating outside pressure, political professional, family or social political considerations, public appearance of impropriety or an political considerations, public
8
PROVISION NAFTA EU- Singapore IPA Australia-Japan EPA CETA CPTPP EU-Vietnam FTA EU-Vietnam IPA Indonesia-Australia CEPA
(Only applicable to Chapter 19 (Annex 7 Code of Conduct for (Annex B Code of Conduct of (Annex 29-B (State-State)) (Chapter 9, Section B, Code for (Annex 15-B (State-State)) (Annex 11 Code of Conduct for (Annex 14-A Code of Conduct for
and 20) Members of The Tribunal, The Arbitrators, Rules of Procedure (In force provisionally Sept. 21, ISDS) (In force Dec. 30, 2018) (Draft) Members of The Tribunal, Arbitrators) (CEPA ratified by
Appeal Tribunal and Mediators) of Arbitral Tribunals) (EPA in 2017) Members of The Appeal Australia in Nov. 2019, and
(FTA in force Nov. 21, 2019/ IA force Jan. 15, 2015) (Code applicable to ISDS has not Tribunal and Mediators) (Draft) Indonesia in Feb. 2020)
will enter in force when ratified yet been published)
by all EU MS) (Full text available here)
(Full text available here) (Full text available here) (Full text available here) (Full text available here) (Full text available here) (Full text available here) (Full text available here)
an appearance of impropriety or considerations, public clamour, relationships or responsibilities clamour, loyalty to a Party, or apprehension of bias. clamour and loyalty to a Party or impropriety and shall not be an appearance of impropriety or
an apprehension of bias. loyalty to a disputing party or a to influence his or her conduct or fear of criticism. (b) An arbitrator shall not be fear of criticism. influenced by self-interest, bias.
non-disputing Party or fear of judgment, and shall not be 12. An arbitrator shall not, influenced by self-interest, 11. An arbitrator shall not, outside pressure, political 12. An arbitrator shall not be
B. A member shall not be criticism. influenced by self-interest, directly or indirectly, incur any outside pressure, political directly or indirectly, incur any considerations, public clamour, influenced by self-interest,
influenced by self-interest, 11. A Member shall not, directly outside pressure, political obligation or accept any benefit considerations, public clamour, obligation or accept any benefit loyalty to a Party or disputing outside pressure, political
outside pressure, political or indirectly, incur any obligation considerations and loyalty to a that would in any way interfere, loyalty to a disputing party or a that would in any way interfere, party or fear of criticism. considerations, public clamour,
considerations, public clamour, or accept any benefit that Party or fear of criticism. or appear to interfere, with the non-disputing Party or fear of or appear to interfere, with the 2. Members shall not, directly or loyalty to a Party or a disputing
loyalty to a Party or fear of would in any way interfere or 2. An arbitrator shall avoid proper performance of her or his criticism. proper performance of his duties. indirectly, incur any obligation or party or fear of criticism.
criticism. appear to interfere, with the entering into any relationship or duties. (c) An arbitrator shall not, 12. An arbitrator shall not use his accept any benefit that 13. An arbitrator shall not,
proper performance of his or her acquiring any financial interests 13. An arbitrator may not use her directly or indirectly, incur any position on the arbitration panel would in any way interfere or directly or indirectly, incur any
C. A member shall not, directly or duties. that are likely to affect the or his position on the arbitration obligation or accept any benefit to advance any personal or appear to interfere with the obligation or accept any benefit
indirectly, incur any obligation or 12. A Member may not use his or arbitrator’s impartiality or that panel to advance any personal or that would in any way interfere, private interests and shall avoid proper performance of their that would in any way interfere,
accept any benefit that would in her position on the Tribunal to might reasonably create an private interests and shall avoid or appear to interfere, with the actions that may create the duties. or appear to interfere, with the
any way interfere, or appear to advance any personal or private appearance of impropriety or an actions that may create the proper performance of his or her impression that others are in a 3. Members shall not use their proper performance of his or her
interfere, with the proper interests and shall avoid actions apprehension of bias. impression that others are in a duties. special position to influence him. position as a member to advance duties.
performance of the member's that may create the impression 3. An arbitrator shall not accept special position to influence her (d) An arbitrator shall not use his 13. An arbitrator shall not allow any personal or private interests 14. An arbitrator shall not use his
duties. that others are in a special any benefit that would in any or him. or her position on the tribunal to financial, business, professional, and shall avoid actions that may or her position on the arbitral
position to influence him or her. way affect, or appear to affect, 14. An arbitrator may not allow advance any personal or private personal or social relationships create the impression that others tribunal to advance any personal
D. A member shall not use the 13. A Member may not allow the arbitrator’s duties. financial, business, professional, interests. An arbitrator shall or responsibilities to influence his are in a special position to or private interests. An arbitrator
member's position on the panel financial, business, professional, 4. An arbitrator shall not use the family or social relationships or avoid actions that may create conduct or judgement. influence them. shall avoid actions that may
or committee to advance any family or social relationships or arbitrator’s position on the responsibilities to influence her the impression that others are in 14. An arbitrator shall avoid 4. Members shall not allow create the impression that others
personal or private interests. A responsibilities to influence his or arbitral tribunal to advance any or his conduct or judgement. a special position to influence the entering into any relationship or financial, business, professional, are in a special position to
member shall avoid actions that her conduct or judgement. personal or private interests. An 15. An arbitrator must avoid arbitrator. An arbitrator shall acquiring any financial interest family or social relationships or influence the arbitrator. An
may create the impression that 14. A Member must avoid arbitrator shall avoid actions entering into any relationship or make every effort to prevent or that is likely to affect his responsibilities to influence their arbitrator shall make every effort
others are in a special position to entering into any relationship or that may create the impression acquiring any financial interest discourage others from impartiality or that might conduct or judgment. to prevent or discourage others
influence the member. A member acquiring any financial interest that others are in a special that is likely to affect her or his representing themselves as being reasonably create an appearance 5. Members shall avoid entering from representing themselves as
shall make every effort to that is position to influence the impartiality or that might in such a position. of impropriety or bias. into any relationship or acquiring being in such a position.
prevent or discourage others likely to affect him or her arbitrator. An arbitrator shall reasonably create an appearance (e) An arbitrator shall not allow any financial interest that is 15. An arbitrator shall not allow
from representing themselves as impartiality or that might make every effort to prevent or of impropriety or bias. past or ongoing financial, likely to affect their impartiality past or existing financial,
being in such a position. reasonably create an appearance discourage others from business, professional, family or or that might reasonably create business, professional, family or
of representing themselves as being social relationships or an appearance of impropriety social relationships or
E. A member shall not allow past impropriety or bias. in such position. responsibilities to influence or bias. responsibilities to influence the
or existing financial, business, his or her conduct or judgment. arbitrator's conduct or judgment.
professional, family or social (f) An arbitrator shall avoid [FN n . 1 For greater certainty, 16. An arbitrator shall avoid
relationships or responsibilities entering into any relationship, or the fact that a Member receives entering into any relationship, or
to influence the member's acquiring any financial interest, an income from a government or acquiring any financial interest,
conduct or judgment. that is likely to affect his or her has a family relationship with a that is likely to affect his or her
impartiality or that might person who receives an income impartiality or that might
F. A member shall avoid entering reasonably create an appearance from the government shall not in reasonably create an appearance
into any relationship, or of impropriety or an itself be considered to be of impropriety or bias.
acquiring any financial interest, apprehension of bias. inconsistent with paragraph 2
that is likely to affect the (g) If an interest, relationship or and 5.]
member's impartiality or that matter of a candidate or
might reasonably create an arbitrator is inconsistent with
appearance of impropriety or an subparagraphs (a) through (f),
apprehension of bias. the candidate may accept
appointment to a tribunal and an
arbitrator may continue to serve
on a tribunal if the disputing
9
PROVISION NAFTA EU- Singapore IPA Australia-Japan EPA CETA CPTPP EU-Vietnam FTA EU-Vietnam IPA Indonesia-Australia CEPA
(Only applicable to Chapter 19 (Annex 7 Code of Conduct for (Annex B Code of Conduct of (Annex 29-B (State-State)) (Chapter 9, Section B, Code for (Annex 15-B (State-State)) (Annex 11 Code of Conduct for (Annex 14-A Code of Conduct for
and 20) Members of The Tribunal, The Arbitrators, Rules of Procedure (In force provisionally Sept. 21, ISDS) (In force Dec. 30, 2018) (Draft) Members of The Tribunal, Arbitrators) (CEPA ratified by
Appeal Tribunal and Mediators) of Arbitral Tribunals) (EPA in 2017) Members of The Appeal Australia in Nov. 2019, and
(FTA in force Nov. 21, 2019/ IA force Jan. 15, 2015) (Code applicable to ISDS has not Tribunal and Mediators) (Draft) Indonesia in Feb. 2020)
will enter in force when ratified yet been published)
by all EU MS) (Full text available here)
(Full text available here) (Full text available here) (Full text available here) (Full text available here) (Full text available here) (Full text available here) (Full text available here)
10
PROVISION NAFTA EU- Singapore IPA Australia-Japan EPA CETA CPTPP EU-Vietnam FTA EU-Vietnam IPA Indonesia-Australia CEPA
(Only applicable to Chapter 19 (Annex 7 Code of Conduct for (Annex B Code of Conduct of (Annex 29-B (State-State)) (Chapter 9, Section B, Code for (Annex 15-B (State-State)) (Annex 11 Code of Conduct for (Annex 14-A Code of Conduct for
and 20) Members of The Tribunal, The Arbitrators, Rules of Procedure (In force provisionally Sept. 21, ISDS) (In force Dec. 30, 2018) (Draft) Members of The Tribunal, Arbitrators) (CEPA ratified by
Appeal Tribunal and Mediators) of Arbitral Tribunals) (EPA in 2017) Members of The Appeal Australia in Nov. 2019, and
(FTA in force Nov. 21, 2019/ IA force Jan. 15, 2015) (Code applicable to ISDS has not Tribunal and Mediators) (Draft) Indonesia in Feb. 2020)
will enter in force when ratified yet been published)
by all EU MS) (Full text available here)
(Full text available here) (Full text available here) (Full text available here) (Full text available here) (Full text available here) (Full text available here) (Full text available here)
11
PROVISION NAFTA EU- Singapore IPA Australia-Japan EPA CETA CPTPP EU-Vietnam FTA EU-Vietnam IPA Indonesia-Australia CEPA
(Only applicable to Chapter 19 (Annex 7 Code of Conduct for (Annex B Code of Conduct of (Annex 29-B (State-State)) (Chapter 9, Section B, Code for (Annex 15-B (State-State)) (Annex 11 Code of Conduct for (Annex 14-A Code of Conduct for
and 20) Members of The Tribunal, The Arbitrators, Rules of Procedure (In force provisionally Sept. 21, ISDS) (In force Dec. 30, 2018) (Draft) Members of The Tribunal, Arbitrators) (CEPA ratified by
Appeal Tribunal and Mediators) of Arbitral Tribunals) (EPA in 2017) Members of The Appeal Australia in Nov. 2019, and
(FTA in force Nov. 21, 2019/ IA force Jan. 15, 2015) (Code applicable to ISDS has not Tribunal and Mediators) (Draft) Indonesia in Feb. 2020)
will enter in force when ratified yet been published)
by all EU MS) (Full text available here)
(Full text available here) (Full text available here) (Full text available here) (Full text available here) (Full text available here) (Full text available here) (Full text available here)
C. A member shall not disclose a in the award of the arbitral (c) An arbitrator or former any time the deliberations of the
special committee report or tribunal. arbitrator shall not at any time Tribunal
decision under Article 1905 prior disclose the deliberations of a or the Appeal Tribunal, or any
to its public release by the tribunal, or any arbitrator’s view. member's views, whatever they
Secretariat. A member or former [FN: For greater certainty, this may be.
member shall not at any time subparagraph (c) does not apply
disclose which members are to the arbitrator’s view in a
associated with majority or decision, order, award or
minority opinions in an Article opinion.]
1905 proceeding. (d) An arbitrator shall not make a
public statement regarding the
D. A member shall not disclose a merits of a
panel report issued under pending tribunal proceeding.
Chapter 20 prior to its
publication by the Commission. A
member or former member shall
not at any time disclose which
members are associated with
majority or minority opinions in a
proceeding under Chapter 20.
12
PROVISION NAFTA EU- Singapore IPA Australia-Japan EPA CETA CPTPP EU-Vietnam FTA EU-Vietnam IPA Indonesia-Australia CEPA
(Only applicable to Chapter 19 (Annex 7 Code of Conduct for (Annex B Code of Conduct of (Annex 29-B (State-State)) (Chapter 9, Section B, Code for (Annex 15-B (State-State)) (Annex 11 Code of Conduct for (Annex 14-A Code of Conduct for
and 20) Members of The Tribunal, The Arbitrators, Rules of Procedure (In force provisionally Sept. 21, ISDS) (In force Dec. 30, 2018) (Draft) Members of The Tribunal, Arbitrators) (CEPA ratified by
Appeal Tribunal and Mediators) of Arbitral Tribunals) (EPA in 2017) Members of The Appeal Australia in Nov. 2019, and
(FTA in force Nov. 21, 2019/ IA force Jan. 15, 2015) (Code applicable to ISDS has not Tribunal and Mediators) (Draft) Indonesia in Feb. 2020)
will enter in force when ratified yet been published)
by all EU MS) (Full text available here)
(Full text available here) (Full text available here) (Full text available here) (Full text available here) (Full text available here) (Full text available here) (Full text available here)
13
Other FTAs that provide for a Code of Conduct that has not been issued:
Commission has not issued Code of Conduct to this date Commission has not issued Code of Conduct to this date 6. The Parties shall, prior to the entry into force of this Agreement, provide
guidance on the application of the Code of Conduct for Dispute Settlement
Article 10.26: Arbitrators ARTICLE 29 Proceedings under Chapter 28 (Dispute Settlement) to arbitrators selected to serve
1. Except in respect of a Tribunal established under Article 10.29, and unless the Arbitrators on investor-State dispute settlement tribunals pursuant to this Article, including
disputing parties decide otherwise, the Tribunal shall consist of 3 arbitrators. Each 1. Except in respect of a Tribunal established under Article 32 (Consolidation), and any necessary modifications to the Code of Conduct to conform to the context of
disputing party shall appoint one arbitrator. The disputing parties shall jointly unless the disputing parties agree otherwise, the Tribunal shall comprise three investor-State dispute settlement. The Parties shall also provide guidance on the
appoint the third, who shall be the presiding arbitrator. arbitrators, one arbitrator appointed by each of the disputing parties and the third, application of other relevant rules or guidelines on conflicts of interest in
2. Arbitrators shall: who shall be the presiding arbitrator, appointed by agreement of the disputing international arbitration. Arbitrators shall comply with that guidance in addition
(a) have expertise or experience in public international law, international trade or parties. to the applicable arbitral rules regarding independence and impartiality of
international investment rules, or the settlement of disputes arising under 2. Arbitrators shall: arbitrators.
international trade or international investment agreements;
(b) be independent of, and not be affiliated with or take instructions from, either (a) have expertise or experience in public international law, international trade or
Party or the disputing investor; and international investment rules, or the resolution of disputes arising under
(c) comply with the Code of Conduct for Dispute Settlement established by the international trade or international investment agreements;
Commission. (b) be independent of, and not be affiliated with or take instructions from, either
3. If the disputing parties do not agree on the remuneration of the arbitrators Party or the disputing investor; and
before the Tribunal is constituted, the prevailing ICSID rate for arbitrators applies. (c) comply with any Code of Conduct for Dispute Settlement as agreed by the
4. The Commission may establish rules relating to the expenses incurred by the Commission.
Tribunal. 3. Where a disputing investor claims that a dispute involves measures adopted or
maintained by a Party relating to financial institutions of the other Party, or investors
of the other Party and investments of such investors, in financial institutions in a
Party's territory, then
(a) where the disputing parties are in agreement, the arbitrators shall, in addition
to the criteria set out in paragraph 2, have expertise or experience in financial
services law or practice, which may include the regulation of financial institutions; or
(b) where the disputing parties are not in agreement,
(i) each disputing party may select arbitrators who meet the qualifications set out
in subparagraph (a), and
(ii) if the Party complained against invokes Articles 14(6) or 17, the chair of the
panel shall meet the qualifications set out in subparagraph (a).
4. The disputing parties should agree upon the arbitrators' remuneration. If the
disputing parties do not agree on such remuneration before the constitution of the
Tribunal, the prevailing ICSID rate for arbitrators shall apply.
5. The Commission may establish rules relating to expenses incurred by the
Tribunal.
14