Outcomes of Recurrent cSCCA
Outcomes of Recurrent cSCCA
Outcomes of Recurrent cSCCA
Clinical Study
Outcomes of Recurrent Head and Neck Cutaneous
Squamous Cell Carcinoma
Copyright © 2011 Nichole R. Dean et al. This is an open access article distributed under the Creative Commons Attribution
License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly
cited.
Recurrent, advanced stage cutaneous squamous cell carcinoma (cSCC) is uncommon with limited publications on patient
outcomes. A retrospective study including patients who underwent surgical resection for recurrent, advanced stage cSCC of the
head and neck was performed (n = 72). Data regarding tumor site, stage, treatment, parotid involvement, perineural invasion,
positive margins, metastasis, and disease-free survival was analyzed. The majority of patients were male (85%) and presented with
recurrent stage III (89%) cSCC. Two-year disease-free survival was 62% and decreased to 47% at 5 years. Parotid involvement,
positive margins, nodal metastasis, or the presence of perineural invasion did not correlate with decreased survival (P > .05).
Distant metastasis was a strong indicator of poor overall survival (P < .001). Adjuvant postoperative radiotherapy did not improve
overall survival (P = .42). Overall survival was poor for patients with advanced recurrent cSCC despite the combined treatment
with surgery and radiotherapy.
Cancer (AJCC) guidelines, and histology was confirmed by Table 1: Patient characteristics.
pathology. Tumors were divided into 5 different anatomic Characteristic n (%)
sites: face, neck, ear, periauricular area, and scalp. Lesions
Age-years
occurring on the face included forehead, periorbital, nose,
lip, and chin. Periauricular lesions were defined as lesions Mean (range) 71 (42–93)
occurring on the temple, cheek, or postauricular area. Gender
All patients underwent aggressive surgical resection. This Male 61 (85)
included parotidectomy for cases in which parotid involve- Female 11 (15)
ment was suspected on preoperative imaging or clinical Tumor subsite
exam. Parotidectomy ranged from superficial to radical Face 19 (27)
parotidectomy with sacrifice of the facial nerve. The major- Forehead 5
ity of patients required neck dissection and postoperative Periorbital 4
radiation. Selective, modified, or radical neck dissection was Nose 8
performed at the time of resection or in a staged procedure.
Chin 1
Neck dissection was indicated when nodal metastasis was
Lip 1
suspected on preoperative imaging or when the patient
presented with an advanced T classification of their lesion. Periauricular 34 (47)
Postoperative radiation was recommended for patients with Cheek 13
large cutaneous malignancies when more than one positive Temple 18
node was identified on neck dissection, when negative Postauricular 3
surgical margins could not be obtained, or in the presence of Ear 13 (18)
perineural or lymphovascular invasion. Histological margins Scalp 3 (4)
were defined as negative if the advancing tumor edge was Anterior 2
≥4 mm from the line of surgical excision and positive if less Posterior 1
than 4 mm. All cutaneous defects were repaired either by
Neck 3 (4)
primary closure, split thickness skin graft, local or regional
T classification
flap coverage, or free tissue transfer.
Demographic characteristics, including patient age, gen- T1 1 (1)
der, a history of immunosuppression, previous treatment, T2 5 (7)
and time to recurrence, were recorded. Prognostic indicators T3 4 (6)
including tumor site, size, perineural invasion, positive mar- T4 60 (83)
gins, or histologic grade were reviewed. Outcomes measured Tx 2 (3)
consisted of disease-free survival and cancer recurrence. TMN Stage
Descriptive variables are reported as means (±SD) and III 64 (89)
categorical variables as percentages. Descriptive statistics IV 8 (11)
were compared by general linear models for normally
distributed variables or the Kruskal-Wallis test for otherwise.
The relationship between patient clinical and treatment
factors and disease-specific survival was calculated using the of immune suppression due to lymphoma or leukemia
Kaplan-Meier method. Survival time was calculated as the (n = 6), rheumatoid arthritis (n = 1) or were currently
interval from date of surgery to date of death or date of maintained on immunosuppressive medications due to prior
last followup. Deaths due to other causes were censored for transplant (n = 3).
these analyses. A P-value of <.05 was considered statistically No difference in margin status was observed between the
significant. Statistical analysis was performed using SAS various tumor sites (P = .48). Perineural invasion, a known
Version 9.2 software (SAS Institute Inc., Cary, NC). risk factor for recurrence and metastasis, occurred in 36.9%
of patients. Patients with cSCC of the ear and periauricular
3. Results area were more likely to demonstrate perineural invasion on
surgical pathology in comparison to all other sites (P = .06).
Between 1998 and 2007, there were 72 patients identified Although perineural invasion did not significantly correlate
who underwent surgical resection for recurrent, advanced with tumor site or size, patients with this finding were more
stage cSCC. The majority of patients were male (84.7%), likely to have parotid involvement (P = .04). A total of
presented with stage III disease (88.8%), and had undergone 39 patients (54.1%) underwent superficial (n = 16), total
previous surgical resection (76.5%). Median time from pre- (n = 11) or radical (n = 12) parotidectomy. Four patients
vious skin cancer diagnosis to presentation with recurrence had undergone previous parotidectomy for positive nodal
was 5.7 months (range, 1–41 months). Mean tumor size was metastasis. Parotid involvement, either by direct extension
3.4 cm in largest dimension (±SD 2.07). The majority of or nodal metastasis, was confirmed by surgical pathology in
lesions occurred on the ear or periauricular area (65.2%) 92.3% of cases (n = 36).
and were classified as T4 lesions (83.3%) invading into deep The majority of patients with parotid involvement
extradermal structures (Table 1). Ten patients had a history underwent neck dissection (92.3%). Neck dissection was
Journal of Skin Cancer 3
performed in 66.7% of all patients. The majority (64.5%) Table 2: Free flaps used for cutaneous defect reconstruction.
underwent selective (n = 31) or modified radical (n =
Flap type n
14) neck dissection. One patient required a radical neck
dissection. Another patient with a posterior scalp lesion ALT 12
had previously undergone an extended posterior triangle Latissimus 3
dissection. Three patients had undergone previous neck Rectus 8
dissections. Positive nodal metastasis occurred in 43.7% RFFF 13
(n = 21/48) of patients, and nearly all cases occurred in Fibula 2
patients with advanced T classification (83.3%) and those OCRFFF 4
with parotid involvement (85.7%, n = 18/21). The majority ALT: anterolateral thigh; RFFF: radial forearm free flap; OCRFFF: osteocu-
of nodes were located in levels I–III (95%). No positive taneous radial forearm free flap.
nodes were identified in level IV, and one case of nodal
metastasis occurred in level V (Table 3). Nodal metastasis Table 3: Patterns of cervical lymph node metastasis.
did not correlate with tumor size, though a larger percentage
of patients with cSCC of the ear demonstrated neck disease Level n (%)
(66.7%) in comparison to other sites (P = .14). Eight I 6 (25)
patients had evidence of distant metastasis at the time of II 12 (50)
surgical resection. Distant metastasis did not correlate with III 5 (20)
perineural invasion, original tumor site, size, or parotid IV 0 (0)
involvement at the time of surgical resection (P > .05). The V 1 (5)
histologic grades of the tumors consisted of 19% (n = 14)
well differentiated, 56% (n = 40) moderately differentiated,
8% (n = 6) moderate-poorly differentiated, and 17% (P = .18). Margin status, a history of immunosuppression,
(n = 12) poorly differentiated. There was not a statistically and perineural invasion did not predict cancer recurrence.
significant relationship found between histologic grade and Two-year disease-free survival was 62.2% and was
survival (data not shown). reduced to 47.2% at 5 years (Figure 1). Age greater than
All defects were closed either by primary closure or split 65 (P = .34), male gender (P = .06), immunosup-
thickness skin graft (n = 23), local or regional flap (n = 7), pression (P = .22), and patients with a previous history
or free tissue transfer (n = 42). One patient underwent of radiation (P = .4) tended towards worse survival
pectoralis major myocutaneous flap reconstruction, and 6 outcomes. Surprisingly, tumor characteristics including site,
patients required local cervicofacial flap coverage. Patients size (greater than 3.4 cm), parotid involvement, perineural
with larger defects typically required free flap reconstruction. invasion, or positive margins following resection had no
The radial forearm free flap (n = 13) and anterolateral influence on disease-free survival. Two-year disease-free
thigh (n = 12) were most commonly utilized for soft tissue survival for patients with positive nodal metastasis was
coverage. In cases in which bony reconstruction was also 47.7% versus 72.9% for those without neck disease (P =
required, the osteocutaneous radial forearm free flap (n = 4) .14) (Figure 2). Although locoregional metastasis was not
and fibula (n = 2) were employed (Table 2). a significant predictor of survival, distant metastasis noted
The majority of patients underwent postoperative radi- within 30 days of surgical resection was associated with poor
ation (66.7%) as a result of advanced stage disease. Fifteen prognosis (P < .001). No patient with distant metastasis
patients had undergone previous radiotherapy, and 3 under- survived beyond 13 months. Most patients required free
went both pre- and postoperative radiation. The majority flap reconstruction and postoperative radiation for advanced
of patients with positive margins underwent postoperative disease. Patients who underwent free flap reconstruction
radiation. Three patients had prior radiation therapy and tended towards worse survival outcomes (P = .24). Despite
were unable to tolerate the cytotoxic effects of a second aggressive surgical resection, postoperative radiation was not
course of radiation, and two electively declined further ther- shown to affect long term disease-free survival (P = .42)
apy. Three patients with perineural invasion did not undergo or repeat cancer recurrence (P = .85) for this patient pop-
postoperative radiotherapy based on personal preference. ulation. Although not statistically significant, patients with
Mean time to follow up was 18.5 months. Forty percent cervical metastasis who underwent postoperative radiation
of patients (n = 28) developed local (67.8%, n = 19), had improved locoregional control (68% versus 25%, P =
regional (25%, n = 7) or distant metastasis (14.2%; n = 4) .14) when compared to those who underwent surgery alone.
during the followup period. Median time to cancer recur-
rence was less than 7 months (6.5, range 1–41 months). One
patient had local recurrence and developed lung metastasis 4. Discussion
while another patient developed both recurrent neck disease Nonmelanoma skin cancer is the most common malignancy
and lung metastasis. Although not statistically significant, worldwide with over 140,000 cases of cSCC diagnosed each
patients were more likely to recur if they presented with cSCC year in the United States alone [8]. The incidence of regional
of the ear or periauricular area (P = .06), demonstrated metastasis among patients with cSCC ranges from 0.5 to 16%
positive nodal metastasis at the time of neck dissection [4] and can result in potentially fatal consequences. Although
(P = .14), or did not undergo postoperative radiotherapy a number of factors have been identified as high risk
4 Journal of Skin Cancer
INFLAMMATION
BioMed
PPAR Research
Hindawi Publishing Corporation
Research International
Hindawi Publishing Corporation
http://www.hindawi.com Volume 2014 http://www.hindawi.com Volume 2014
Journal of
Obesity
Evidence-Based
Journal of Stem Cells Complementary and Journal of
Ophthalmology
Hindawi Publishing Corporation
International
Hindawi Publishing Corporation
Alternative Medicine
Hindawi Publishing Corporation Hindawi Publishing Corporation
Oncology
Hindawi Publishing Corporation
http://www.hindawi.com Volume 2014 http://www.hindawi.com Volume 2014 http://www.hindawi.com Volume 2014 http://www.hindawi.com Volume 2014 http://www.hindawi.com Volume 2014
Parkinson’s
Disease
Computational and
Mathematical Methods
in Medicine
Behavioural
Neurology
AIDS
Research and Treatment
Oxidative Medicine and
Cellular Longevity
Hindawi Publishing Corporation Hindawi Publishing Corporation Hindawi Publishing Corporation Hindawi Publishing Corporation Hindawi Publishing Corporation
http://www.hindawi.com Volume 2014 http://www.hindawi.com Volume 2014 http://www.hindawi.com Volume 2014 http://www.hindawi.com Volume 2014 http://www.hindawi.com Volume 2014