Qualities of A Good Critic: Blesses of My Father Lakshmangiri

Blesses of My Father
Lakshmangiri….
B. A English Semester - III
Qualities of a Good Critic

Course in Literary Criticism
Hitesh L. Goswami
7/29/2017
2
Qualities of a Good Critic
Literary criticism is the study, evaluation, and interpretation of literature.
 Introduction
Criticism or literary criticism is the term for studies concerned with classifying, analyzing,
interpreting and evaluating the works of literature. Dryden writes in his preface to The State of
Innocence as criticism was first instituted by Aristotle and which mean to standard of judging
well today. The term literary criticism aims at the study of works of literature with emphasis on
their evaluation.
Whether or not literary criticism should be considered a separate field of inquiry from
literary theory, or is a matter of some controversy. For example, the Johns Hopkins Guide to
Literary Theory and Criticism draws no distinction between literary theory and literary
criticism, and almost always uses the terms together to describe the same concept.
 Definition of Criticism
Criticism is the art of estimating the qualities and characters of literary or

artistic work.
 Webster Dictionary.
Criticism is the art of interpreting art. It serves as an intermediary between

the author and the reader by explaining the one to the other.
 Walter Pater.
Criticism is a disinterested endeavor to learn and propagate the best that is

known and thought in the world.
 Matthew Arnold.
3
 Origin of Criticism
The term “criticism” derives from the Greek word Kritikos. It means a judge of
literature. In the 2nd century, the word changed into criticus, which means the interpretation
of texts and words.
 Meaning of Criticism
Criticism is the art of judging the qualities and values of an aesthetic object in literature
or in fine arts. It is the art of interpreting art. Criticism is not concerned with the interpretation
of life. It is concerned with the interpretation of life as an essay. So, literature criticism is a
systematic development of intelligent and adequate reading.
Criticism is the practice of judging the merits and faults of something.
Literary criticism is the play of the mind on a work of literature. It consists in answering rational
questions about literature. Such inquiry leads to a better understanding of the nature and value
of literature.
 Qualities of a Good Critic

As the best critic of engineering should be an engineer, the best critic of poetry should
be a poet. This question has been answered by many great poets who have been critics like
Dryden, Goethe, Arnold etc. they have opened their minds to all the literatures with an
understanding. They have been able to tell us how the work begins, what its technique is and
what its end is.
A piece of literature implies not only a writer but also a reader. There is a voice at one
end and a listener to the other side. The critic is a listener who understands what is said to him.
A good critic should have the qualities in himself which described under:
4
[1] A well – read Man

A good critic should be a well – read man. He should have read the ancient and the most
modern works of the writers. If he judges an old work, he must think of all the allusions and
history, he should have the knowledge of morphological aspects of the language to judge that
work. If he judges a modern book, he should be aware of the modern trends in literary
criticism.
[2] Knowledge of Human Life

The critic should have good knowledge of the life from which the creative writer has comes out.
He must have understanding of what life call itself. If the work is a play or a novel, he must
know of human nature and raw materials upon which the theme is built. As Burk said –
If objects affect consciousness, they must be represented because they might

affect the artist.
The critics must be acquainted with the objects and he must have sensibility to ideas.
As Eliot says –
The conscious present is an awareness of the past.
In short, a critic should be well acquainted with the traditions.
[3] Command over the Language

A literary work of art is presented to the reader in the form of words or images or concepts. The
language of the artist should be fully intelligible to the reader or the critic. The critic must have
the sense for the meaning of the words whatever it is, a work well done or badly done. The
critic may guess what it might have been, what the writer wished to be, it should be much
better than it is etc.
5
[4] Biographical knowledge of the Writer

A good critic should have adequate knowledge of the author’s life. This knowledge helps him to
explore what is obscure in the author.
T. S. Eliot is misleading when he says –
Personality is not to express.
Impressions and experience which become important in poetry may play an important part in
man’s personality; but a critic cannot be indifferent to all these determining force. Sir Walter
Raleigh’s short biography of Shakespeare is a brilliant example of the manners in which a subtle
and imaginative critic may actually reconstruct the character of a man by studying his work.
[5] Sharp Memory

A good critic should have sharp memory. As Arnold said –
There should be lines and expressions of the great masters in our mind.
The characters of high quality of poetry are the touch stones, by which we can measure a work
and see if it has a mark and an accent of high beauty.
[6] Creative Experience

The aim of all fine arts is to please. A good critic should have an aesthetic sense to pass his
judgment of the work. He should have a creative experience which may help him to bring out
the best qualities in a piece of art. Ben Jonson rightly called that –
Judge of the poet is only the faculty of the poets; not of all the poets but of
the best.
It appears that the work of a critic is very near akin to the creative artist.
Sainte Beure remarks –

6
Poetry can only be touched by the poet.
The main difference is that the creative writer finds his subject in the same external life around
him or internal life experience. The critic finds his subject in other men’s book in the world of
literature.
 Conclusion
With all these qualification, a critic can judge the work of any writer of English literature.
A critic should examine the work’s treatment, its technique, the form and the author’s attitude
of life. A critic is the voice of the reader. He works like an artist.
The pen of a critic is more exact than the pencil of an artist.
X
HITESH L. GOSWAMI
Arts College Lavana

Qualities of A Good Critic: Blesses of My Father Lakshmangiri

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

Qualities of A Good Critic: Blesses of My Father Lakshmangiri

Uploaded by

Document Information

Original Title

Copyright

Available Formats

Share this document

Share or Embed Document

Sharing Options

Did you find this document useful?

Is this content inappropriate?

Copyright:

Available Formats

Qualities of A Good Critic: Blesses of My Father Lakshmangiri

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

Blesses of My Father

B. A English Semester - III

Qualities of a Good Critic

Qualities of a Good Critic

Literary criticism is the study, evaluation, and interpretation of literature.

Criticism is the art of estimating the qualities and characters of literary or

Criticism is the art of interpreting art. It serves as an intermediary between

Criticism is a disinterested endeavor to learn and propagate the best that is

Criticism is the practice of judging the merits and faults of something.

 Qualities of a Good Critic

[1] A well – read Man

[2] Knowledge of Human Life

If objects affect consciousness, they must be represented because they might

The conscious present is an awareness of the past.

In short, a critic should be well acquainted with the traditions.

[3] Command over the Language

[4] Biographical knowledge of the Writer

T. S. Eliot is misleading when he says –

Personality is not to express.

[5] Sharp Memory

[6] Creative Experience

Sainte Beure remarks –

Poetry can only be touched by the poet.

The pen of a critic is more exact than the pencil of an artist.

You might also like