Where Are All The Undescribed Fungi?: David L. Hawksworth and Amy Y. Rossman
Where Are All The Undescribed Fungi?: David L. Hawksworth and Amy Y. Rossman
Where Are All The Undescribed Fungi?: David L. Hawksworth and Amy Y. Rossman
First author: International Mycological Institute, Bakeham Lane, Egham, Surrey TW20 9TY, U.K.; second author: Systematic Botany and
Mycology Laboratory, USDA Agricultural Research Service, Beltsville, MD 20705.
Accepted for publication 29 May 1997.
ABSTRACT
Hawksworth, D. L., and Rossman, A. Y. 1997. Where are all the unde- In addition to undiscovered species, many have been collected but remain
scribed fungi? Phytopathology 87:888-891. lost or hidden as named species and ignored for lack of modern char-
acterization; others have been collected and recognized as new species
The hypothesis that there are 1.5 million fungal species on Earth, of but remain undescribed. Some fungal species are unrecognized within
which only about 70,000 are described, implies that 1.43 million remain erroneously circumscribed species, often based on presumed host speci-
undescribed. The recognition that many new species have yet to be found ficity, while others exist as biological species but remain buried within
is of fundamental importance to plant pathologists, agronomists, and those broadly defined species for lack of gross morphological charac-
plant regulatory officials, among others, who continue to encounter dis- terization. From these data, one must conclude that enormous numbers of
eases caused by previously unknown or understudied fungi. Unexplored unrecognized fungi can be found almost everywhere, including one’s own
habitats with their arsenal of unknown fungi are also of interest to those backyard.
searching for novel organisms for use in biological control or for their
pharmaceutical attributes. This paper presents data on the expected num- Additional keywords: biodiversity, biosystematics, diversity, emerging dis-
bers of fungi in some relatively unexplored habitats, such as tropical eases, inventory, lichenized fungi, plant pathogens.
forests, and those obligately associated with plants, lichens, and insects.
The generally accepted estimate of the number of species of have been undertaken that provide supportive evidence (8,19). For
fungi on Earth is a conservative 1.5 million (17,19,25). This estimate example, more than 500 fungi were identified in intensive studies
was derived by extrapolating both from data on known fungi from of litter from only five tree species in Panama (11). After 1 year of
well-studied regions, as well as data on well-studied fungi from intensive collecting in one forest in Kenya, 59 of 75 (79%) of the
plant hosts (17). Estimates of the species numbers in each major leaf-dwelling ascomycetes encountered were new species (40).
fungal group corroborate this conclusion (45). Although it is un- Recent investigations of fungi on palms yielded 1,580 species, of
certain exactly how many fungal species are already known, one which 75% of the species collected were new to science (27).
can be reasonably confident that it is in the range of 72,000 (21) to Data on the primarily tropical ascomycete family Phyllachoraceae,
100,000 (45). This implies that we know as little as 5%, i.e., only tar leaf spot fungi, suggest that although 1,150 species have been
1 in 20 of the species of fungi that exist. Clearly the knowledge described, the family may actually be support 169,000 species (7).
gap is immense. But where are the remaining 1.43 million species In exploring tropical regions for fungi, it is anticipated that the
to be found? The answer to this question is essential for mycol- most widespread and common species in a site will tend to be
ogists and plant pathologists to be able to anticipate and respond found first. Most likely, such species have been collected before
to problems resulting from emerging diseases caused by previ- and are described already. However, the longer the time spent in
ously unknown or understudied species and to prioritize and direct intensive exploration, the more species are discovered, as evi-
resources toward understanding the systematics of the most im- denced by the continuing accounts of new species, primarily of
portant and unknown groups of fungal plant pathogens. Addition- mitotic fungi, that have been discovered in Taiwan during the past
ally, the answer to this question will test the hypothesis itself and, 16 years (29–37). A 2-month visit to Papua New Guinea yielded 6
thereby, address the skepticism of some nonmycologists about the genera and 89 species of lichen-forming and lichenicolous fungi
number of undescribed species of fungi (16,39). In this paper, we new to science (2). Only through an intense examination of all
draw attention to results that indicate where at least some of this fungi in a defined area will the finite number of fungal species be
enormous treasure-trove of fungi is to be found. determined. The results of a recent workshop to plan an all-taxa
biodiversity inventory in the Área de Conservación Guanacaste, Costa
TROPICAL FORESTS Rica, estimated the number of fungal species remaining to be en-
countered in the 120,000-ha reserve at around 50,000 (6).
Many biodiversity specialists, particularly those with expertise An overall indication of whether the tropics are more species-
in macroorganisms, have determined that tropical forests are more rich in fungi than temperate regions might be expected based on
species-rich than temperate forests; thus, this is generally assumed an analysis of the origin of newly described fungi. The following
to be true for fungi as well. However, this hypothesis has not been data were extracted from the Index of Fungi database maintained
rigorously tested for fungi, although a few comprehensive studies at the International Mycological Institute (IMI), Egham, U.K.
Tropical countries were the source of 49% of the 16,013 fungal
species, including fossils, described as new during a 10-year per-
Corresponding author: D. Hawksworth; E-mail address: d.hawksworth@cabi.org iod, 1981 to 1990. However, the United States was the origin of
the largest number of new taxa, with 1,623 (10.1%) species, fol-
Publication no. P-1997-0716-01V
This article is in the public domain and not copyrightable. It may be freely re-
lowed closely by India, with 1,554 (9.7%) species. Of the remain-
printed with customary crediting of the source. The American Phytopathological ing countries with more than 1% of the total, 8 of 22 were tropi-
Society, 1997. cal. Rather than indicating whether tropical countries are the richest
888 PHYTOPATHOLOGY
source of new fungal species, these data suggest that all countries trees nearby. Well-designed studies are needed to provide reliable
are inadequately known mycologically. Those yielding the most data on this important issue.
species new to science are merely the ones that receive the most Data on fungi reported on Eucalyptus recently have been com-
intense scrutiny rather than those that are inherently the most piled (46). Of the known 450 species in Eucalyptus, 1,350 species
species-rich. This view is supported by the situation in the British of fungi are known from 150 host species. The number of fungi
Isles, the most comprehensively studied region for fungi in the from each host species ranges from 1 to 282. The highest number
world. Here critical or intensive studies invariably yield species of fungi were found on E. globulus, and 150 of the 282 fungi on
that have never been described: 460 species new to science were that host were not listed on any other species of Eucalyptus. Anal-
described from Great Britain and Ireland during the same 10-year yses of these and other data sets suggest that 5.3 unique fungi per
period. host plant species is a reasonable working number (20).