Good Practices in SWM - A Collection of LGU Experiences
Good Practices in SWM - A Collection of LGU Experiences
Good Practices in SWM - A Collection of LGU Experiences
Suggested Citation: EcoGov Project. 2011. Good Practices in SWM — A Collection of LGU Experiences. Philippine
Environmental Governance (EcoGov) Project, Pasig City, Philippines
Published with assistance from the American people through the U.S. Agency for International Development’s
(USAID) Philippine Environmental Governance 2 (EcoGov 2) Project. Month and year of publication: June
2011.
The views expressed here do not necessarily reflect the views of the USAID or the United States Government.
Contributing Writers: Evelyn Sagun, Maria Theresa Espino-Yap, Diego Tautho, Mary Rose Rontal, Kent
Omictin, Apple Kristine Amor, Gil Viloria, Revelina Bayona, Stella Maris Salas
The Philippine Environmental Governance Project (EcoGov) is an initiative of the Government of the Philippines
implemented in partnership with the Department of Environment and Natural Resources, Department of the
Interior and Local Government, local government units and other stakeholders, funded by the United States
Agency for International Development and managed by Development Alternatives, Inc. and its Philippine-based
subcontractors:
ACRONYMS ........................................................................................................................................ ii
INTRODUCTION ............................................................................................................................... 1
1
Philippine Environmental Governance 2 Project. 2008. Study Report on Greenhouse Gas Emission Estimates from Burning or
Composting Cane Trash and Biodegradable/Residual Solid Wastes in Negros Island and Bayawan City and Their Implications
yard compost-
for cooling
Fermentation Area
leachate collector and will still
to do so have to Rubber Rubber Rubber
pay additional allow for a
Bins Bins Bins
fees for the possible 0.5-ton
leachate collector
collection of their Rubber Rubber Rubber increase on this
composting bins
Bins volume.
night crawlers
Bins Bins
biodegradable
Concrete
leachate collector
African
waste.
with
Benefits
The composting facility diverts about 18% of the total waste within the collection area.
The use of vermi-composting technology shortens the processing period by almost a month. It is also less labor-
intensive but produces high quality compost products.
Initiatives of the LGU to keep operating costs low through semi-mechanization, efficient processes, vermi-composting,
use of local materials and re-use of leachate enhances the sustainability of the facility.
LGU recovers 32% of total operating costs and plans to increase this.
The composting facility produces 35 sacks of high quality compost per month, selling around 85% or 30 sacks of
compost produced to local farmers and gardeners. The remaining compost products are used by the LGU in a
vegetable garden.
Sieving
Sievingand
andbagging
bagging
Storage
Storageand
andmarketing
marketing
Benefits
With this rate of diversion, the SLF’s useful life is increased while leachates are reduced.
The LGU has reduced the annual cost of its SWM operations and saved on the cost of daily transport to the
site.
For QSC, the compost facility is a potential income source as there is demand for compost from rice and
vegetable farmers. The QSC recovered the cost of its operations from the initial income generated from the
facility in the past two years. This income enabled QSC to invest in the construction of two additional windrows.
The facility provides support to the promotion of organic farming in Diffun and in Quirino through the sale of
compost.
The QSC has now become one of Quirino’s and Region II’s SWM learning sites frequented by visitors from
nearby towns and provinces.
Maddela’s central composting facility is jointly wastes to MIT’s composting site. MIT, in turn, will
managed by the Maddela Institute of Techno-logy be responsible for the processing of biodegradable
(MIT), a technical-vocational school under the wastes and in the marketing of soil compost
supervision of the Technical Education and Skills produced. The partners will then share the profits
Development Authority (TESDA), and the local on a 75%-25% basis, in favor of MIT.
government of Maddela, Quirino Province, by
virtue of an agreement forged in 2004. The joint Before the agreement, MIT used as raw materials
undertaking was borne out of intertwined concerns agricultural wastes generated from its farms and
of the two institutions: MIT needed an additional adopted the heap-type natural decomposition
and steady source of raw materials for a method. With the agreement, about 1,894
composting venture which it started in 2000 while kilograms/week of biodegradable wastes from the
the LGU was concerned about fulfilling its mandate public market, central business district and two
to divert solid wastes from the disposal facility. town barangays are brought to the disposal facility.
MIT thus decided to improve its composting
According to the agreement, the LGU will enforce method and increase the capacity of its facility. It
waste segregation in the public market and central availed of a small grant from the USAID-funded
business district and deliver the biodegradable EcoGov Project for the construction of cemented
windrows and drying shed. The facility currently
utilizes 12 cemented windrows, each one
accommodating up to 7,350 to 8,000 kilos of organic
waste. On the average, the facility can process
92,100 kilos of wastes per composting season which
takes about four months.
Benefits
Wastes taken to dumpsite have been reduced; the composting activity in MIT comprises about 18 percent of total
diverted wastes.
Decrease in annual SWM operating cost and savings in the daily cost of transporting and managing biodegradables
brought to the dumpsite.
MIT’s income from this business venture has grown with the increasing demand for organic fertilizer in the area. By
making the composting product available to farmers, local awareness on the importance of using organic fertilizer
also increased. The facility also serves as training ground for local farmers in organic farming.
Like QSC, the MIT is now considered one of Quirino’s and the region’s SWM learning sites. In addition to the
composting facility, MIT also has a successful SWM program in its campus.
Benefits
Davao Gulf
Active participation of barangay LGUs
make a difference in SWM implementation
Barangay Bagumbayan, Malalag, Davao del Sur
Mobilizing waste genera-tors for waste
segregation and diversion at source
Barangay San Jose, with a population of 4,000 and learning site where residents could see how
waste generation of about 1.2 tons daily, showcases composting and segregation are done, a Materials
the key roles of barangays in winning the war Recovery Facility (MRF) has been set-up in the
against waste. barangay hall compound along with a small vermi-
bed. A 500-sq.m. “Gulayan sa Barangay” has also
Composting coordinators per purok have later been been established where compost could be used.
appointed and provided some training. To have a Intensive information activities followed, targeting
Top photo: Students at Ablayan Elementary School learn to segregate their waste.
Above left: Principal Espino and Barangay Captain Ortiz at the school composting
bin. Above right: CENRO and barangay officials visit the school’s herbal garden
which uses compost.
After reconstituting its BESWMC, Barangay In support of all these efforts, Barangay Bandera
Bandera conducted an information drive covering also installed collection points at five (out of seven)
two schools, a subdivision and a beach resort. At purok where residents put their residual waste to
the schools, teachers discuss with students about be collected by the city.
various ways to manage their waste, such as
reducing their waste, recycling and composting
biodegradables. A composting bed was established
in each of the schools to give students hands-on
experience. In Lawig Subdivision, an SWM team
was organized and clean-up drives were
conducted. Waste segregation at the subdivision is
ongoing. The Paradise Island Resort, where an
SWM orientation for the staff was held, also
practices waste segregation at source. Composting
of bio-waste is also done in the resort.
One of the five “transfer stations” (collection points) in Vermi-bed of Matanos National High School – Bandera
Barangay Bandera Campus
Last May, the Barangay Sto. Nino Council, together with the
CENRO, had an opportunity to assess its SWM program and Recyclable items, mostly coming from malls,
are arranged at the Barangay Sto. Niño MRF
The Islamic City of Marawi is the capital of the waste problems threatening the said water
Province of Lanao del Sur. 96% of its population is resource. Years of unchecked human and industrial
Maranao. Being the center of the commercial, activities within the area have resulted in poor
political, educational and religious activities in water quality, diminished aquatic resources and
Lanao del Sur, rising solid waste generation has increased health risks The lake supplies 70% of the
been a critical concern within the City. About 68.4 electricity in Mindanao (with Agus River), serves
tons/day of solid wastes are generated within the as an important fishery ground and is home to
City, of which 70% are biodegradable wastes. many species of fish and invertebrates which are
endemic to the lake.
Situated along Lake Lanao, the largest lake in
Mindanao and the second largest in the Philippines, In 2002, the city government of Marawi started
Marawi City’s socio-economic activities have implementing its Solid Waste Management (SWM)
significantly contributed to the alarming solid program. Its initial efforts focused on two point
sources — the Public Market and the City Hall. To
note, 10 of the 100 mosques within the City are
located within the Public Market compound. These
mosques are being managed by the Muslim
Religious Leaders, the Imams, the Khatibs and the
Bilals. SWM initiatives within the Public Market
involved implementation of two-type waste
segregation — segregation into biodegradable and
residual wastes – in the 72 stalls of vegetable and
fruit sections. In response to the call of the city
government, stall owners provided their own waste
receptacles for biodegradable and recyclable
wastes. Within the City Hall, two-type waste
segregation was also carried-out. Most of the offices
within the City Hall provided their own
receptacles. These efforts, however, were not
sustained. Specifically, the Public Market stall
owners went back to the old way of managing
Marawi City situated along Lanao Lake wastes upon learning that the LGU still collected
The community-
based solid waste
management
Recyclable materials on the other hand are also
program was
recovered. These include assorted clear bottles,
formally launched in June 16, 2009 with a whole
cartons, papers, soft plastics, metal and
day seminar on the salient points of the Ecological
aluminum. Part of the responsibilities of the
Solid Waste Management Act of 2003 (commonly
1 st Sergeant is to monitor the recovery of
known as RA 9003). The primary goal of the
recyclable materials. Collected materials are
program is not only to sustain the cleanliness
sold to the nearest junk shop. Proceeds from
within the four corners of the military camp but
the sales are used to sustain the operation of
also to provide a model to those living outside the
the composting facility and the vegetable
vicinity of the camp to support the SWM program
garden.
spearheaded by the local government of Guipos.
The guards on duty are responsible in monitoring
True to their commitment to support the SWM
program implementation daily, particularly the
program of the local government, two of the camp
compliance of segregation. Following military
personnel have been delegated to be members of
regulations, violators (those who are caught
the Municipal SWM-Technical Working Group
littering and/or not segregating their wastes) are
(TWG).
given sanctions ranging from stern warning (for the
1st offense) to submission of Delinquency Report
Program Implementation and rendering of community service (for the 2nd and
succeeding offense).
The Commanding Officer, Col. Erwin Alea is
personally overseeing the overall implementation
of the solid waste management program.
Based on practice, cost-effective segregated waste Increased participation of barangay LGUs and
collection and transport should have the following private sector. As a result of efforts of
features: municipal and city LGUs to encourage
barangay LGUs to assume more SWM
most efficient collection route (based on responsibilities, BLGUs have started to assume
existing and planned collection area); waste collection responsibilities within their
distribution of waste generators within jurisdictions, through strict enforcement and
collection area (based on geographical garbage fee collection. Coordination between
characteristics); and among municipal/city and barangay LGUs
waste collection schedule (for specific waste has played a critical role in this development.
generators and waste types); Signing of Memorandums of Agreement
collection system (curbside, collection point (MOAs) among these stakeholders has proven
or a combination of both), and; to be effective in ensuring commitment of both
appropriate crew size and vehicles. parties, in determining and dividing
responsibilities and in monitoring impacts.
Since waste collection and transport pose health Barangays have been starting to allocate money
hazards to collection crew, LGUs should be able to from Barangay Funds to support waste
provide trainings on proper handling of wastes. collection activities.
They also must be able to give appropriate uniforms
and protective tools as well as equipment to the Private sector support for services in waste
collection crew. collection and transport is also an emerging
practice. Private sector assistance is a big help
in reducing LGUs’ expenses.
BEST PRACTICES
Recovering costs incurred in waste collection
and transport. Municipal and barangay LGUs
Strict implementation of no segregation, no collect garbage fees as a means to make waste
collection policy. This supports the mandatory generators aware of their own accountability.
waste segregation at source and segregated More LGUs are now charging fees among the
waste collection. To ensure compliance among different groups of waste generators, not only
waste generators, LGUs have passed the commercial establishments which had been
ordinances providing for the enforcement of the traditional practice. Matching the fees
this policy. Segregated collection can be done collected with costs incurred while taking into
by collecting specific waste types on a consideration the capacity and willingness to
designated schedule or by constructing pay of waste generators are part of decision-
compartments within the collection vehicles. making. The fees ensure the sustainability of
the delivery of said service.
Minimizing costs incurred in waste collection.
To decrease the subsidy they provide, LGUs
Jagna, Bohol
Like a ‘well-oiled’ and maintained
machine
Waste collection and transport, like a machine, is a week, every Tuesday and Wednesday,
system that needs to be ‘well-oiled’ and maintained, respectively. No collection points have been
as it is an important cog in solid waste management. designated since wastes are directly collected
In Jagna, the waste collection system was from stalls and brought to the collection truck.
implemented a month after the municipal LGU All stalls are required to have receptacles for
passed its SWM Ordinance in August 2006. The biodegradable, recyclable, residual and special
SWM ordinance provides for strict enforcement of wastes. Prior to waste collection, sweepers
“no segregation, no collection.” This has so far clean the market and put the wastes in covered
worked for the Jagna LGU and the communities. receptacles to prevent dogs from scattering the
While the LGU has jurisdiction over 33 barangays, wastes. The LGU’s three regular enforcers
collection services cover only seven, namely conduct monitoring before and after waste
Canupao, Canjulao, Looc, Pagina, Poblacion, Tejero collection to check on possible violations.
and Pangdan. Within these service areas are the
Municipal Hall, public market, a port, five primary Households’ and offices’ waste collection.
schools, 17 elementary schools, three barangay high Households, commercial establishments and
schools and four private colleges, two hospitals, a other offices have their own collection
health center in each barangay, about 750 schedules: biodegradable wastes, every
commercial establishments (including sari-sari Monday and Thursday; residual waste, every
stores), and 1,872 households. Tuesday; recyclable wastes, every Saturday,
and; special wastes, every 4th Sunday of the
Best features month. Their wastes are collected at the
curbside rather than at designated common
Through implementation, the LGU can now collection points. Collection of biodegradable
identify some of the best features of its collection wastes is concentrated among commercial
and transport service. establishments, as composting is now
mandatory for households and institutions,
such as schools. Households and institutions,
Public market waste collection. With 287 stalls and
however, can still have their biodegradable
50 registered sidewalk vendors, the public
wastes collected if they are willing to pay an
market is the single highest generator of
additional fee of P5 per sack for the processing
biodegradable
of wastes in the LGU’s central composting
waste at 0.743
facility.
ton daily or 83%
of its total waste.
Regular Inspection. A “recorida” is undertaken
Collection of
by one SWM enforcer one hour before actual
biodegradable
waste collection. He goes around the collection
waste is done
area on a bike with a megaphone to inform
every 7 A.M.
waste sources to ensure that waste would be
daily. At this
taken out on time and in their proper
time of day, the
containers. Taking out of wastes earlier than
consumers in
the schedule is prohibited by local ordinance
the market are
and thus would be penalized.
not so many.
Recyclable and
residual wastes, Receptacles and stickers. Uniform waste
on the other receptacles in the form of sacks are labeled with
hand, are collec- the category the generator belongs to—
ted twice a household, establishment or institution—and
Bio wastes are collected for P5/sack
Bayombong has 25 barangays: eight urban, five disposal pits for residual wastes are being
considered urbanizing, and the rest are rural. Since promoted together with the practice of waste
the 1990’s, the town’s garbage collection focused segregation.
on the eight urban barangays. Two trucks made
their daily rounds in these barangays and the public More autonomy and authority to the
market. Volume of mixed wastes collected daily barangay
was approximately 3,000 to 3,700 kilograms. But
the waste assessment study, jointly conducted by
The municipal government of Bayombong in
the municipality and the EcoGov Project, indicated
Nueva Vizcaya used several strategies to ensure
that this volume was just half of the total wastes
that barangay LGUs participate in SWM
being generated in these barangays.
implementation.
To increase the amount of
MOAs. Barangay LGUs have
collected waste and
signed an agreement with
strengthen the collection
the municipal LGU,
system, Bayombong used
outlining the SWM
the devolution of key SWM
functions of the barangays
functions to urban barangay
and the support that would
LGUs as a main strategy.
be provided by the
These functions include
municipal LGU to help
collection of biodegradable
barangays carry-out their
and residual wastes from
functions. The barangays
households, institutions and
have been given the respon-
establishments within their
sibility to collect and
territorial jurisdiction;
transport segregated wastes
enforcement of waste
in accordance with the
segregation and other
schedule set by the munici-
provisions of the local
pal LGU. The agreement
ordinance; and the manage-
with the municipal LGU
ment of barangay MRFs.
also requires the barangays
Waste collection has since
to adhere to the municipal
expanded from the eight
LGU’s no-segregation-no-
urban barangays to the Waste collection truck and collection crew of
disposal policy, prohibiting
adjacent urbanizing baran- Bayombong
the entry of non-segregated
gays. The 13 barangays,
wastes entry to the Ecological Park. Through this
together with the public market and night market,
policy, barangays are able to strictly enforce waste
account for about 80 percent of the total daily waste
segregation within their respective service areas.
generated in the municipality. As of the first quarter
The municipal LGU, on the other hand, are tasked
of 2009, a total of 4,095 households, or about 30
to monitor their activities, initiate regular feedback
percent of total households in the 13 barangays,
to the barangays and provide other forms of
were regularly served, along with 1,264
support that may be needed by the barangays. It
establishments (68% of total establishments).
has opted to retain the task of garbage collection in
the old public market, the night market,
By decentralizing waste collection, the municipal
slaughterhouse and municipal offices.
LGU is now able to focus its efforts and resources
on building the capabilities of barangays, on
Efficiency in transport. To assist the barangays in
education and communication activities, and on
performing their waste collection function, the
monitoring the performance of the program. It is
municipal LGU acquired reconditioned four-cubic-
slowly expanding the scope of its information
meter or 2.4-ton Isuzu mini-dump trucks. These
dissemination campaign to cover the rural
dump trucks, each costing P490,000, have been
barangays. In the latter, backyard composting and
Waste collection vehicle used by Barangay Waste collection vehicle used by Barangay Magsaysay
Waste collection vehicle used by Barangay Poblacion Waste collection vehicle used by Polomolok LGUs
At present, all open and controlled dumpsites of SLF. Presently, dumping only of residual
should have been closed. By now, LGUs should wastes at SLFs has been mandatory. This is
have complied with RA 9003 prescriptions; but this expected to lengthen SLF’s useful life and
has been a struggle for most LGUs due to high reduce operating cost.
investment and operations costs required. Best
practices on disposal management, nevertheless, Establishment and operation of a common SLF by a
have emerged among several LGUs. cluster of LGUs. Section 44 of RA 9003 which
cites Section 33 of the Local Government Code,
Construction of Residual Containment Areas. requiring “LGUs to consolidate their efforts,
Several LGUs have started closing their open services and resources to address common
and controlled dumpsites, and constructed SWM problems and/or establish common
Residual Containment Areas (RCAs) to serve waste disposal facilities,” have made LGUs
as transition facilities while SLFs are being more conscious of the benefits of establishing
developed. RCAs are temporary storages for and operating a common SLF. Major factors
residual wastes. Collected residual wastes are that pushed several LGUs to consider and come
placed in sacks and piled within RCAs and into formal agreements for a common SLF are
these will be eventually taken to the SLF for the lack of suitable sites for SLF, relatively low
final disposal. residual waste generation of participating
LGUs and the lack of capacity to construct and
Establishment and operation of SLFs suited to maintain individual SLFs. LGUs have realized
potential volume of residual wastes. Pre- too that a common SLF will yield higher
determination of the amount of residual wastes economies of scale, with reduced over-all costs,
for disposal, based on waste assessment and both in construction and maintenance.
characterization study(WACS) results, enables
the LGU to design appropriate disposal Partnership with the Private Sector for SLF
facilities, anticipate costs and source funds for establishment and operation. Tapping the private
SLF establishment and operation as well as for sector to be involved in SLF projects will help
manpower resources. Projecting the volume of disperse cost of construction and operation.
residual wastes for disposal also allows the Private sector participation is still minimal but
LGUs to construct the SLF by phase, i.e., cell has yielded worth-noting positive results. By
by cell. This gives LGUs the opportunity to involving the private sector at the onset—
budget funds according to the phases of cell during the planning process—the chances of
construction, thus, lessening the burden of getting them to be part of SLF construction and
raising large amounts of money that would operation are higher.
have been required by one time construction
Liner system for groundwater protection; residual wastes to the disposal facility. The BLGU
Leachate collection system to prevent pays fees to the Municipal Treasurer’s Office for
wastewater flow from the site; the use of said facility. The municipal LGU plans
Surface water control to prevent run-off water to open its disposal facility to other waste sources,
from entering the site; barangays and municipalities.
Gas management and odor control system;
and The Management and operation of SLF is under
Daily soil covering and compaction. the responsibility of the SWM Section of the
MENRO. The current SLF staff has two
A total of P2 million was spent by the Wao LGU to maintenance persons, one monitoring clerk and
develop the quarter-hectare cell of the SLF. three security guards. These guards and a
Operating Costs amounted to P25,000 per month. monitoring clerk record residual wastes taken to
These were used for equipment maintenance, as the SLF. The host barangay, Barangay Katutungan,
well as for fuel and manpower resources. At is allowed to dump its wastes to the disposal facility
present, Barangay Eastern disposes its collected for free.
Benefits
The planned two-hectare SLF will serve the municipality for 15 years. With only residual wastes being disposed
at the facility, it can be expected that maximum capacity of the SLF can be reached within its projected productive
life.
Threats to public health and water sources in the municipality are expected to be minimized.
Since waste generators are assured that proper disposal facility is available, they are motivated to practice
proper waste segregation at source.
With Wao’s SLF hosting the central MRF, efficiency in transporting collected wastes to these facilities is achieved.
Also, the SLF’s lay-out enables easier delivery of biodegradable and recyclable wastes from secondary segregation
of residual wastes to the central MRF.
Wao, being the first municipality to have an RA 9003-compliant disposal facility in ARMM, has been turned into
an influential learning site that is now encouraging LGUs to follow.
1. The process started with the identification of the site for the SLF. Originally, Barangay Silway
8 was selected, but had to be given up after the communities therein protested against the said
project. Thus, the five-hectare site in Barangay Kinilis, after the conduct of study tours/ocular
visits and passing suitability (topographic mapping, soil permeability tests) required by the
DENR-EMB, was chosen as the site for the SLF. Initial Environmental Examination (IEE)
checklist and Detailed Engineering Design (DED) of the SLF were developed by the Municipal
Engineer with technical assistance from EcoGov 2.
2. Once the SLF is in operation, inspection, acceptance and recording of volume of solid wastes
are daily activities of the SLF foreman.
3. Waste compaction is done by making a waste bench that allows compaction of wastes during
passage of collection vehicles for daily disposal activities. Final compaction is done during
soil covering by heavy equipment.
4. Covering of compacted wastes is done at least once a month or as the need arises.
5. Leachate collection and storage are also regular activities. Recirculation will be done at a later
stage of SLF operation.
6. A body or office is assigned to manage the SLF. In the case of Polomolok, it is the municipal
Ecological SWM Office (ESWMO). An SLF Foreman is tasked to supervise operation of the
facility and to monitor the volume of wastes taken to the SLF. In terms of equipment, there are
two waste compactors, a dump truck, a road roller and a pay loader used in daily SLF operation.
A part-time heavy equipment operator also works part-time. These SLF personnel have been
trained to do management and operation.
compliant SLF in South Cotabato, it is also expense of the new facility is approximately
willing to receive residual wastes from other P133, 000, with personnel salaries and fuel
LGUs, provided that the LGUs enter an expenses being the major cost items. For the
agreement with Polomolok. A tipping fee of time being, no tipping fees are collected from
P900 per truckload with a maximum capacity industries and barangay LGUs that are
of 15 cubic meters will be charged. dumping wastes at the SLF. The cost of
operating the SLF is presently subsidized by
Transport of waste improved. Since the existing the LGU. On September 9, 2009, Tupi LGU
SLF of the municipal LGU also hosts its central signed a MOA with Polomolok LGU on shared
MRF, including the composting facility and use of the SLF. Collection of tipping fees for
septic vault for special wastes, transport of use of the said disposal facility will commence
collected biodegradable, recyclable and on January 2010.
residual wastes is made more efficient. This
lessened fuel use and saved time spent on waste
collection.
With limited sites available for SLF construction Philippines, Lapanday Food Corporation and
and with low residual waste generation by most Universal Banana Corporation (UBC). Increasing
LGUs, the Provincial Government of South demand for agricultural products of the province
Cotabato decided that SLF clustering would be the has led to rising solid waste generation. While
most appropriate strategy ensuring proper disposal households have been identified to be major waste
management in the province. In addition to this, generators in most municipalities/ cities, agri-based
construction and maintenance of own SLFs will be industries generated bulk of the solid wastes in the
financially challenging to most LGUs. Clustering province. Based on the waste assessment, it is
became the most viable way to address the growing estimated that the province’s 10 municipalities and
solid waste management problems in South one city will generate 116.7 tons a day. Of these,
Cotabato province, which has 10 municipalities 69% are biodegradable, 12% are recyclable, 17% are
(Banga, Lake Sebu, Norala, Polomolok, Sto. Niño, residual and 2% are special wastes.
Surallah, Tampakan, Tantangan, T’boli and Tupi)
and a component city (Koronadal City). With the To identify potential common SLF sites within the
province’s water resources draining to Liguasan province, a map analysis was done by the SWM-
Marsh, disposal management was imperative. Provincial Technical Working group (PTWG) with
Liguasan is the largest swamp and marsh area in technical assistance from EcoGov 2 and MGB.
Mindanao, an important wetland site for many Taking into consideration distance, waste volume
water bird species, and home to the endemic and and field verification, Koronadal City and Surallah
endangered Philippine crocodile and at least 33 were identified as common SLF sites. Results of the
species of freshwater fishes2. analysis also showed that a Koronadal SLF cluster
would be accommodating residual wastes from
South Cotabato is host to major agricultural Tampakan, Tantangan and Tupi. Surallah SLF
plantations and agri-based industries in the cluster, on the other hand, would be able to serve
SOCSKSARGEN Region; some of these are Dole Banga, Sto. Niño, T’boli, Lake Sebu and Norala.
2
http://whc.unesco.org/en/tentativelists/5025/
Faced by the difficulty of acquiring potential sites After the signing of the MOA among the six LGUs,
in Barangay Colongolo and by an urgent need to the Detailed Engineering Design for a category 2
fast track compliance with RA 9003, the San Vicente, SLF was developed. The Surallah SLF is envisioned
Centrala site was selected. After favorable results to hold the residual wastes of Surallah (SLF host),
of the topographic mapping and hydro-geological Sto.Niño, Norala, T’boli, Banga and Lake Sebu.
study conducted by MGB for the site located in Following the provision in DAO 10-2006 which
Barangay Centrala in June 2007, social preparation rationalizes SLF requirements according to
activities were held in the communities. A series of estimated total residual waste generation of LGUs,
Benefits ‘
The establishment and operation of the Surallah SLF Cluster, taking into account provisions of the signed MOA, are
expected to yield several benefits.
Having the SLF cluster is more cost-effective; the total cost of constructing individual SLFs is higher. Resources
saved by the cluster LGUs from not establishing individual SLFs can now be used to provide other social services
to constituents.
Commercial and industrial establishments within 6 cluster LGUs with own collection and transport systems will also
be allowed to dispose their residual wastes in the Surallah SLF.
Availability of the Surallah SLF for immediate use by cluster members will ensure proper management of
approximately 23.5 tons/day of residual wastes. With the SLF cluster regularly monitoring, pollution from emissions
and leachate from residual wastes can be reduced.
LGUs will be motivated to fully enforce proper waste segregation at source and effectively implement waste diversion
strategies, including composting at source and recovery of recyclable wastes.
With the planned collection of tipping fees from members of the cluster LGUs, financial resources for operations
and maintenance will be made available. Fines and penalties will also ensure continuous and proper patronage of
the cluster LGUs.
The Surallah SLF is expected to serve as learning site while other LGUs in the Mindanao Region explore the
benefits of sharing a common disposal facility.
Signing of MOA for the construction of Surallah cluster Ceremonial groundbreaking for the cluster sanitary landfill
SLF between South Cotabato PLGU and Surallah in Surallah last September 7, 2009
SUSTAINING a solid waste management program important, RA 7160 or the Local Government Code
is costly and can prove to be a burden on the LGUs, permits LGUs to provide SWM services as a basic
which are already trying to make ends meet with municipal service or facility with reasonable fees
their limited budgets. But this doesn’t present a and/or fines through ordinances enacted by local
dead-end, as experiences of a number of LGUs have Sanggunian.
shown measures can be developed to recover costs,
even if not fully then on a scale that can help sustain Cost-recovery is the process of passing on to waste
implementation. RA 9003, for one, allows LGUs to generators and/or service users the full or partial
impose appropriate fees for the preparation, cost of collecting wastes, composting, recycling and
adoption and implementation of SWM plans and disposal in the landfill. Through this, waste
programs. Using the “users’ pay” principle, LGUs generators are made accountable for the wastes they
are allowed to levy fees on all waste generators and generate. It ultimately aims to decrease LGU
users of SWM facilities. This is in addition to the subsidy for the SWM program and make it self-
charging of fines and penalties on violators. Equally sustaining.
BEST PRACTICES
Ring-fencing SWM account. There are several recyclable wastes has also translated into
LGUs that have moved on to ring-fencing income for LGUs. Charging of tipping fees for
SWM financial resources (collected garbage use of disposal facility by other LGUs has also
fees, sale from compost, fines and penalties, been a lucrative way of recovering cost.
and annual LGU budget allocation). They have
passed local ordinances and developed Active participation of barangays in cost-
guidelines that have facilitated the earmarking recovery. Ring-fencing SWM account has also
of SWM money for an SWM Fund or Account been adopted at the barangay level. Barangays
which will be solely used for SWM activities. started to collect garbage fees within their
Special Accounts for SWM have been created collection area. With more barangay LGUs
and bank accounts for SWM opened. being involved in SWM within their
jurisdictions and generating income from it as
Maximizing opportunities for SWM revenue- well, this will ensure the implementation of
generation. Initiatives started by LGUs include SWM program at the barangay level.
collection of garbage fees and the marketing of
compost products and recyclable wastes. Increasing cost-efficiency in the delivery of SWM
Promoting organic farming has become a services. Through identification of SWM costs,
window of opportunity for the LGUs to LGUs have determined those that can be
recover the cost of running a composting minimized to increase savings. Strategies have
facility. When handled properly, farmers and included manpower maximization,
owners of agricultural plantations proved to segregation at source and full capacity per
be steady buyers of compost. Networking with collection trip, among others.
junkshops, consolidators and processors of
SWM Special Accounts. Several LGUs created activities. Barangays Cannery Site, Magsaysay and
Special Account for SWM. In the case of the Poblacion have made a commitment to open
Bayawan LGU, the city does not maintain a separate separate SWM accounts within the year. Series of
bank account for SWM as the present system can discussions and coaching sessions will then be
ensure that SWM funds are used for the conducted with local finance teams (Barangay
implementation of the program and that revenues Treasurer and Barangay Record Keeper) to
generated from SWM activities will be used familiarize them on the proper way of accounting
exclusively for the program. Budget allocation for SWM transactions following the Barangay
the program is lodged under the Economic Accounting System. Guidelines on the
Development Fund for infrastructure projects, management of the Barangay SWM Fund have also
under the General Fund Proper for operating been developed and agreed upon by the municipal
expenses and the General Services Office. and barangay LGUs.
Jagna has a Cost-Recovery Plan, where one of the Different Kinds of Fees. Bayawan charges households
strategies identified is the creation of an SWM and establishments a flat fee of P2 per bag of waste
Special Account under the General Fund. A and requires the use of tickets as tags on each bag
separate bank account has been opened for the of wastes. The ticket costs P2 each. It also collects
SWM funds. This entailed establishment of SWM tipping fees from municipalities that dump wastes
books of accounts where SWM costs and revenues at the LGU’s SLF.
are being posted. Under the SWM Special Account,
different ledgers have been created for different Collections from October to December 2008
SWM components. All costs related to SWM have reached P40,000, while collections from January to
been charged to the separate bank account. SWM March 30, 2009 were more than P72,000. The
revenues and LGU subsidy through an annual amount includes penalties collected because of
budget allocation accrue to this account and can violations. The Cost-Recovery Plan of Bayawan
only be disbursed to SWM-related activities. targets a recovery of 75% of the total cost of waste
collection in the next three years by charging
Financial management guidelines have been households and businesses a flat fee of P2 per bag
formulated to ensure that processes and procedures of waste. The city intends to recover 100% of the
are written, uniformly understood by the collection service cost within five years.
implementers and easily accessed and monitored.
The SWM Special Account is administered by the
SWM Officer. The SWM Office maintains a logbook
to monitor utilization of SWM budget and revenues
from garbage fees, and fines and penalties
generated. The SWM Office reconciles on a
quarterly basis its records with the Municipal
Accounting and Budget Office.
Develop and implement Cost-Recovery Plans. Conduct of periodic assessment of costs and
While LGUs have looked into their current revenues. Assessing SWM-related costs and
SWM costs and revenues, drafting Cost- revenues from time to time will assist the LGUs
Recovery Plans will facilitate setting targets in tracking rising costs and decreasing
and developing more efficient strategies for revenues.
implementation.
Regular reporting of SWM costs and revenues
Improving SWM revenue-generation activities. to ESWMB and other SWM decision-makers.
LGUs have also come up with various special These should be done for purposes of
activities that have helped generate revenues, accountability and transparency, even among
such as: barangay LGUs.
Revisiting of garbage fees. While garbage fees Provision of technical assistance to barangay
are being collected and planned to be LGUs on adoption of cost-recovery
collected soon, revisiting present garbage mechanisms at the barangay level. Aiming for
fees is needed. Adoption of volume-based participation of barangay LGUs in SWM
user fees also needs to be explored. program implementation, appropriate cost-
Garbage fees have to be analyzed vis-à-vis recovery mechanisms should be introduced to
costs of providing waste collection them. This will ensure sustainability of SWM
services; program and long-term involvement of
barangay LGUs as major decision-makers.
Improving collection efficiency. Identifying
waste generators served by LGU’s waste Conduct of annual SWM budgeting and
collection services and fully enforcing no performance evaluation by municipal and
garbage fee, no collection policy have to barangay LGUs. This is to determine the
be strictly implemented not only by effectiveness of the cost-recovery program,
municipal LGUs but also by barangays including standards and benchmarks set vis-
providing the service; à-vis reductions in LGU subsidies for the
program.
Improving quality of compost. This will help
in setting compost price at par with the
rate in the market;
Strengthening the recycling sector. The private There are seven hospitals, five of them located at
sector has been largely involved in the recovery the commercial business district, which have been
of recyclable materials. Recyclable Waste Fairs operating in the city, within Barangays Poblacion,
have been venues for convergence of waste Sudapin and Lanao. Assessment of THW
generators and buyers of recyclable materials, management practices of health care facilities in
including junkshops, consolidators and 2005 exposed the absence of proper disposal facility
processors. for THWs, including septic vaults. Cases of sharp
objects, e.g., needles, syringes, scalpels, blades,
mixed with other solid wastes, caused injuries to
waste collectors. These were reported, confirmed
and discussed by the city LGU with concerned
hospital administrators and Pollution Control
Officers.
With required proper disposal of THWs, waste collectors and communities are saved from acquiring infectious
diseases from health care-related THWs.
Since only properly segregated sharps will be accepted in the vault, health care facilities will be motivated to
comply with mandatory waste segregation.
With construction of THW vault borne by four partner hospitals, the LGU will not be burdened to shoulder a large
amount on the said facility. User fees will be used for the operation and maintenance and the LGU will be able to
cover cost of constructing the THW vault.
Savings by the city LGU can be used in other SWM activities.
On July 2007, the City’s SWM-TWG held a dialogue the city LGU realized that the situation called for
with stakeholders to finalize plans for THW an institutional arrangement that would define
management. The consultation resulted in an roles and responsibilities related to THW
agreement to install THW vault for sharp objects management, including construction and
disposed by health care facilities. A vault with a management of septic vault, handling and transport
capacity of 70 cubic meters was acquired and costs of THWs, and user fee mechanisms.
shouldered by four hospitals in the city. The city
LGU, on the other hand, donated a 100 sq meter The four hospital partners of the City LGU and all
for the septic vault located at the old dumpsite in government hospitals will be charged P5 per kg of
Barangay Binoligan. The septic vault is expected sharp objects. Other users (hospitals, clinics,
to be used for five years. laboratories and medical schools) will be charged
P20 per kg of sharp objects. The fees collected will
The THW septic vault was completed in April 2008. be used to finance the operation and maintenance
The City LGU offered this to the hospitals but the of vault, salaries and protective gears for personnel,
hospitals have not taken any action. Due to this, and eventual closure and rehabilitation.
General Santos City (a.k.a. “GenSan”) held its first commerce and trade, finance, services and
Recyclable Waste Fair, in celebration of Earth Day, education. It is also home to large agri-based and
at the Gaisano Mall of fishery-related industries.
GenSan. The city is With these, the private
considered the economic sector substantially
hub in the SOCSK- contributes to GenSan’s
SARGEN Region, and waste generation. The
thus the event was waste assessment con-
successful in highlighting ducted for the City in
not only the benefits of 2007 has shown that total
practicing waste segrega- waste generation within
tion and re-using recycla- the entire City is approxi-
ble wastes but also the mately 292.6 tons per day.
positive impacts of Sixty-four percent (64%)
strengthening collabora- of these are biodegrad-
tion among public and able and sixteen percent
private sectors. (16%) are recyclable
wastes. This translates to
GenSan residents sell their old newspapers during the
GenSan is regarded as “1 GenSan Recyclable Waste Fair
st 80% potential waste
Region 12’s center of diversion within GenSan.
Benefits
The Fair succeeded in recovering recyclable materials and at the same time generated income for the participants,
several of whom are individual junk buyers without local market. More than 1,500 kilos of junk electronic equipment,
including used appliances and computer hardware, were sold during the Fair. Many did not how to dispose of
these items.
Schools, large industries and many private establishments based in GenSan were made aware of their roles in
material recovery.
Junkshop owners understood their roles better in material recovery. With them being the main actors or buyers of
recyclable materials brought by individuals and establishments, their contribution to waste diversion was emphasized.
The event also provided a venue for schools, commercial and industrial establishments to link with junk buyers
operating within the City.
The Fair served as a major IEC activity that raised awareness on the need to practice proper waste segregation at
source.
In Nueva Vizcaya, the intensification of waste they buy to reduce the volume of waste disposed
segregation and waste diversion initiatives in the in the dumpsites.
municipalities resulted in the proliferation of small
local junk shops. Recognizing their potential One junkshop that readily took up the challenge
contribution to the recovery of recyclables, the was 4S Scraps and Papers. In 2001, this Solano-
provincial government, in collaboration with based junkshop only had a small warehouse with
EcoGov sponsored the one helper and rented trucks.
conduct of a recycling Its business was confined to
summit which provided a the buying of cartons, bottles
venue for these local junk and scrapped metals within
shops and other stakeholders the province of Nueva
to explore opportunities for Vizcaya. The operator, Nelly
partnerships with their Valerio, saw the opportunity
LGUs. The province wanted to expand her business. She
to launch a massive recovery was persistent in the search
of recyclable wastes and for buyers and successfully
tried to convince local buyers penetrated the market of
to expand the waste items 4S Scraps and Papers recyclables that were not
Expected Benefits
With the passage and implementation of the no open burning local policy, the following impacts are expected to happen:
Reduced GHG emissions resulting from burning. It has been estimated that canes that are burned before cutting to
facilitate harvesting generates 13.78 tons of GHG per hectare. GHGs include carbon dioxide, nitrous oxide, and
methane;
Improved public health. With enforcement of the no burning policy, respiratory diseases are expected to decrease;
Increased waste diversion. It is estimated that Bais City generates 104,144 tons of cane trash per cropping season;
Support to organic farming. With burning prohibited, quality of sugar produced are likely to improve with loss of
organic matter and nutrient content of the soil caused by burning reduced;
Reduced costs for farmers. With soil enhancer to be produced by farmers themselves from processing of sugarcane
trash to compost, costs incurred by farmers for purchasing of fertilizer are projected to be reduced; and
Strengthened SWM collaboration with sugarcane plantation owners. With existing cooperation among City LGU
and sugarcane plantation owners, Bais City can serve as a learning site for the implementation of no open burning
policy not only within Negros Oriental Province but also within Central Visayas where sugarcane industry is considered
a major local economic sector.
CHALLENGES
Conduct of regular dialogues with the private incentive program should be designed by
sector. Sustaining relationships of LGUs with LGUs. Awarding good performers will
the private sector has to be sustained through encourage participation of private sector in
regular feedbacks. This is also a way of SWM program implementation.
monitoring results of partnerships and
identifying areas for improvement. Monitoring compliance of private sector.
Monitoring compliance of private sector still
Strengthen links with buyers. For the effective needs to be part of the LGUs’ activities to ensure
and efficient recovery of recyclable materials, that their SWM activities are in line with RA
LGUs have to strengthen linkages with buyers 9003 and municipal-wide SWM program.
of recyclable materials who have no regular Regular dialogues with the private sector will
markets within a city or municipality. be good venues to discuss areas for
Organizing those involved in the recovery of improvement and technical assistance that has
recyclable materials would help. to be provided to them.