Unit 1 What Is Popular Literature?: 1.0 Objectives
Unit 1 What Is Popular Literature?: 1.0 Objectives
Unit 1 What Is Popular Literature?: 1.0 Objectives
Structure
1.0 Objectives
1.1 Introduction
1.2 Culture, Civilisation and Ideology
1.3 Popular Culture
1.3.1 Popular Culture, Mass Culture, Commodity and the Marketplace
1.3.2 Popular Culture as Residual Category
1.3.3 Popular Culture and the Idea of Hegemony
1.3.4 Popular Culture and America
1.4 Popular Literature
1.4.1 The advent of Postmodernism
1.4. 2 Defining Popular Literature
1.4.3 Genres of Popular Literature
1.4.4 Inverse Relationship between Literary Merit and Popular Literature
1.4.5 Literature and Media
1.4.6 Popular Literature Today
1.5 Let Us Sum Up
1.6 Hints to Check Your Progress
1.7 Glossary
1.8 Suggested Readings & References
1.0 OBJECTIVES
This unit will introduce you to the overarching framework of culture and popular
culture that encases the concept of popular literature. It will then discuss some of
the salient points of the larger debate that surrounds the concept of the ‘popular’.
We shall define, ‘popular’, then, present you an overview of popular culture. In
this overview we shall be looking at the origins of popular culture, debates around
popular culture, and the various connotations of the term popular culture, mass
culture, commodity and the market place. Towards the end we shall introduce
you briefly to some genres of popular literature. We end with discussing the
relationship between literary merit and the marketplace, popular literature and
media and conclude with a short note on popular literature today. We shall begin
by looking at what Literature is and the relation between popular and literature
next.
1.1 INTRODUCTION
Literature is considered to be a reflection of the culture of its times. As you
know, it is also said that literature mirrors society. Literature is considered to be
written works that have some artistic merit in it and has lasting value. The two
most important words in the term ‘popular literature’ are ‘popular’ and ‘literature’.
Both the terms are expansive and wide in meaning. “Popular” comes from the
Greek word “Populus”, which means people. So popular culture/literature is
people’s culture/ literature, that is capable of affecting 90 % of the people, 90 %
5
Popular Literature: An of the time. Popular is one of the most widely circulated terms in today’s critical
Introduction
discourse: in literature, politics and social studies, it pertains to the ordinary, the
accessible, well liked, informal and to policies and artifacts benefiting people.
What is important is that to understand popular literature in all its dimensions,
it is essential to be aware of the genesis, background and milieu in which this
term has gained currency and meaning. “Popular Literature” includes both fiction
and non-fiction. To understand its varied dimensions, a close look at the
phenomenon of “mass-culture” and reading taste is required and that is what we
shall look at next.
In the 18th century, with the rise of industrialisation, the term ‘Civilisation’ was
limited to describing the development of economic, social and political
institutions, and the word ‘culture’ was regarded as a particular set of codes of
conduct or attitudes which were held to be best exemplified in works of art, of
the select few, who are the proclaimed guardians of good taste. Mathew Arnold
in Culture and Anarchy (1869), referred to real culture as, ‘the best that had been
thought and said in the world’. But soon in the 19th century ‘culture’ began to be
used in the plural. An interesting addition was the term ‘folk’ or ‘peasant’ culture.
This led to the use of the term ‘cultures’ referring to at least two kinds of culture,
one of the ‘select few’ and the other, of the people especially the peasantry. In
most academic quarters, it is usually argued that the term ‘culture’ stands for
those artistic pursuits that are considered to be of a certain value or standard i.e.
culture proper. Other forms of activity are looked at differently – as entertainment,
recreation or leisure or, pejoratively, as ‘mass culture’. It was not until the early
19th century that ‘popular’ was used as a term of recommendation – albeit in a
fairly casual way – in the sense that the thing or person(s) to which it was applied
were ‘well-liked by many people’ (Williams, 1976, 199) and, moreover, that this
was to be counted in their favor.
6
The traditional classical concept of ideology was considered close to ‘culture’, What is Popular Literature?
but it suggested those forms of intellectual and artistic activity, which were related
to economic and political practices. Thus, it may be suggested that culture should
be used as a general term to refer to ‘the complex unity of those practices that
produce sense’, reserving the term ideology for specific types of culture – for
political ideas. To sum up, the term culture is largely used as an umbrella term to
refer to all of those activities, or practices, which produce sense or meaning.
This includes the customs and rituals that govern or regulate our social
relationships on a day-to-day basis as well as those texts – literary, musical, and
audiovisual – through which the social and natural world is re-presented or
signified. Culture in modern times demands an encounter with newer terrains
and transitions. Culture helps people develop. There are claims that culture
consists of tacit knowledge, and is the domain of primary socialisation. Culture
is also a bunch of memory, history and the past.
In the 19th century, Mathew Arnold’s school of thought, worried that Popular
Culture represented a threat to cultural and social authority, but the Frankfurt
School, a group of German intellectuals noted with deep interest the displacement
and menace caused by the explosion of mass culture: from newspapers and cinema
to popular fiction and Jazz. They argued that it actually produces the opposite
effect; it maintains social authority. In 1944, the German intellectuals Max
Horkheimer and Theodor Adorno coined the term ‘Culture Industry’ to
designate the processes of mass culture, (Storey, 2001, 85). An attempt to plunder
Popular Culture as a sociological and anthropological study was also made. Turner
in his seminal study Structure and Anti-Structure opines that Popular Culture is
world turned upside down in a stratified society. Pierre Bourdieu argues that
the celebration of ‘the remarkable of the unremarkable’- the everyday, forms the
core of Popular Culture. Let us look at what is popular culture, mass culture, and
how popular culture may be marketed in the sub section that follows.
8
1.3.3 Popular Culture and the Idea of Hegemony What is Popular Literature?
Talking of American culture, Fiedler says that the culture of the United States
has always been “popular” beneath a “thin overlay of imported European elitism”
(1982, 64). He further says that “Our national mythos is a pop myth and our
revolution consequently a pop revolution, when Europeans or other non-American
cultures talk of the incursion in their culture of pop forms like rock, country, and
western music, comic books, soap operas and cop shows on television, they tend
to refer to it as a “creeping Americanization” (1982, 65) of their cultures and is
used as a synonym for “vulgarization”.
9
Popular Literature: An Check Your Progress 2
Introduction
1) In what ways is culture understood as ‘high’ and ‘low’?
......................................................................................................................
......................................................................................................................
......................................................................................................................
......................................................................................................................
......................................................................................................................
2) Define popular culture and elaborate on its multiple connotations.
......................................................................................................................
......................................................................................................................
......................................................................................................................
......................................................................................................................
......................................................................................................................
Part of the difficulty stems from the implied ‘otherness’, which is present / absent
when we use the term Popular Literature. Marc Angenot in Pawling’s Popular
Fiction and Social Change says, “Para literature occupies the space outside the
literary enclosure, as a forbidden taboo, a degraded product.” But this is also
true as said earlier that Literature has always mirrored the reality of the age it
belongs to. Thus, the 20th century witnessed the rise of the popular taste. It divests
“popular” outside the ambit of elite consciousness and links it with ordinary
people, the common masses.
Flash fiction has emerged as a significant form of literature that is being accepted
by the masses. Flash fiction as an idea – a story or poem written in minimal
words – has been present in literature for a long time, but its undeniable success
in the 21st century cannot be debated. When Ernest Hemmingway wrote “For
sale: baby shoes, never worn” it was applauded as a story with intense depth,
gravity and minimal expressions. Today, flash fiction has arrived. In the world of
long working hours and Kindle, flash fiction provides a unique reading experience.
Though this fiction does not promise the emotional depth of The Scarlett Letter
or the expansive thrill on the Mississippi of The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn,
this fiction creates a world where fiction became a means of entertainment more
than introspection. The themes that are touched upon in flash fiction were rooted
in the simple emotions that the readers could connect with without delving deep
into the complexities of the thematic emotion of the text.
The 21st century witnessed not just a celebration of Indian writing in English, but
the birth of a readership for racy, quick reads. In this neo-liberalised globalisation
in India, we witness the rise of a new kind of readers who have become an
increasingly emboldened social class. Commercial popular fiction was celebrated
with Chetan Bhagat’s Five Point Someone (2004), One Night at a Call Centre 13
Popular Literature: An (2008) and The 3 Mistakes of my Life (2008). Romance and Campus Fiction
Introduction
became the two genres that gave the Indian audience a literature that was
thoroughly Indian. Post 2000s, the new brigade of engineers or management
graduates-turned authors held the baton of commercial Indian fiction such as
Durjoy Datta who was not just a commercial author, but a social media person.
From attending literary fests, conferences, book signings, doing appearances
and book reading before and after the release of the book, the commercial author
is here to stay. An important role is therefore played by both, the publishing
houses and the authors who are increasingly involved in connecting to the masses
through various social media platforms. So in many ways, the popular in popular
fiction in the current age of technology mirrors the true image of the society and
the readers / the audience choose book covers, review books, post videos about
book signings and participate in the making of popular literature.
..............................................................................................................
..............................................................................................................
..............................................................................................................
..............................................................................................................
..............................................................................................................
1.7 GLOSSARY
Cultura : Latin word for ‘culture’ from the root colere, whichhas various
meanings: inhabit, cultivate, protect.
Populus : Greek word for ’people’
Mass Culture : The common people and their culture; popular culture that
appeals to the common man
Commodity : object or thing that can be bought or sold; commercial;
saleable.
Hegemony : authority, one-upmanship, power
Ghettoize : place in seclusion, reject
15
Popular Literature: An
Introduction 1.8 SUGGESTED READINGS & REFERENCES
Arnold, Matthew. Culture and Anarchy. Cambridge: Cambridge UP, 1960.
Bakhtin, Mikhail. The Dialogic Imagination. Trans. C. Emerson and Michael
Holquist. Ed. Michael Holquist. Austin: U of Texas P, 1981.
Bennett, Tony, 1981, Popular Culture: Themes and Issues (Part I), London, Open
University Press
Bennett, Tony, ed. Popular Fiction: Technology, Ideology, Production, Reading.
London: Routledge, 1990.
Bigsby, CWE Superculture: American Popular Culture and Europe. Bowling
Green, Ohio: Bowling Green University Popular Press, 1975
Bourdieu, Pierre. Distinction: A Social Critique of the Judgment of Taste. Trans.
Richard Nice. Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard UP, 1984.
Browne, Ray B, 1973, Popular Culture and the Expanding Consciousness. New
York, Wiley
Fiedler, Leslie A., Cross the Border – Close the Gap, New York, Stein & Day
1972
—, What Was Literature?: Class, Culture and Mass Society, New York, Simon
& Schuster, 1982
—, “Giving the Devil His Due”, Journal of Popular Culture, Fall, 1978,pp197-
207
—, “Towards a Definition of Popular Literature”, Superculture: American
Popular Culture and Europe, Ed. CWE Bigsby, Bowling Green Ohio, Bowling
Green University Popular Press, 1975, pp 29-38
Gramsci, Antonio. Selections from the Prison Notebooks. Trans. Quentin Hoare
and Geoffrey Nowell-Smith. New York: International Publishers, 1971.
Srivastava Prem K “The Postmodern Condition and the Politics of the Popular.”
Creative Forum, Journal of Literary and Critical Writings. Bahri Publications,
New Delhi. Vol 16, No 1-2. Jan-Jun, 2003: 119-130
Storey, John, Cultural Theory and Popular Culture, London, Prentice Hall (An
Imprint of Pearson Education) 2001
Williams, Raymond, Keywords: A Vocabulary of Culture and Society, Revised
ed, New York, Oxford University Press, 1985, pp 87-93
16